HomeMy WebLinkAboutHallett Letter of OppositionDear Ms. Brown,
I am writing to strongly oppose the proposed relocation or alteration of 49 Putnam Avenue in
Cotuit, also known as the Ebenezer Crocker Jr. House.
This property is not just another building. According to my research, it was built in 1783, it is the
oldest surviving home in Cotuit and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places for its
architectural and cultural significance. It has served as a sea captain’s residence, a local court
seat, and Cotuit’s first summer home. Its Georgian design and documented history are integral
to our village’s identity. The careful restoration in 2003 ensured its preservation and reaffirmed
its value to the community.
Relocating or dismantling this landmark would strip it of its historical context and meaning.
Moving a National Register property for reasons of convenience, profit, or personal
preference—rather than true preservation or safety—is unacceptable. It disregards the purpose
of the Register and disrespects the community that has worked for generations to safeguard
Cotuit’s heritage.
This proposal show speculative ownership, and a lack of appreciation for context. Cotuit’s
historic homes are not interchangeable commodities. They are cornerstones of our community,
and undermining them undermines us all. The removal of original ells would further diminish the
integrity of the house and its place in history. One ell, according to my research, may be older
than the main block.
The protections of the National Register must be upheld in both letter and spirit. Cotuit’s
character is rooted in landmarks like 49 Putnam Avenue, and once that context is lost, it cannot
be regained. I urge you to deny any relocation or alterations that would compromise its integrity.
Sincerely,
Karen Hallett
4803 Falmouth Rd
Cotuit, MA 02635