HomeMy WebLinkAbout1. DH Zoning Community Meeting #1 August 2 2021utiledesign.com 1Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Hyannis Zoning Update
utiledesign.com 2Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Agenda
Introduction
I. Why Update Zoning?
II. Zoning Primer
III. Downtown Hyannis Zoning
IV. Document Overview
utiledesign.com 3Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Introduction
utiledesign.com 4Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Why Update Zoning?
Background and Context
1. Address housing goals including increasing
housing density, equity, and diversity
2. Improve urban fabric of downtown Hyannis in a
manner consistent with historic character and
development patterns
3. Streamline zoning requirements and procedures
and improve ease of use for
businesses/developers, public, and staff
4. Encourage housing production and mixed use
development at human-scale density, and create
predictable outcomes in urban form
utiledesign.com 5Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Housing Production Plan (2016)
Background and Context
1. Address local housing needs
2. Create year-round rental units for residents
3. Provide diverse housing options in Villages
4. Encourage village-scale mixed-use and
5. multi-unit development and re-development in
village centers
6. Allow increased density for mixed-use, multi-unit
development in Hyannis GIZ
7. Amend zoning to achieve housing goals
utiledesign.com 6Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Community Resilience by Design (2018)
Background and Context
utiledesign.com 7Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Community Resilience by Design (2018)
Background and Context
utiledesign.com 8Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Challenges to
Housing Production
Auto-dominant uses and underutilized parcels
produce undesirable streetscapes with large
setbacks and large surface parking lots
Background and Context
utiledesign.com 9Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Challenges to
Housing Production
Background and Context
Outdated zoning standards create unintended
outcomes and do not align with housing goals.
Hyannis’ Growth Incentive Zone has a diversity of lot
sizes that range from small residential lots around
4,000 SF to large commercial lots upwards of 70,000
SF
Ratio-based zoning metrics problematic:
• DU/Acre
• BR/Acre
• Floor Area Ratio Barnstab
le
Rd
.
Main
St.
R
o
u
t
e
1
2
8
utiledesign.com 10Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Challenges to
Housing Production
Background and Context
Overlapping jurisdictions create complex permitting
environment
Harbor (HD)
Single Family (SF)
Hyannis Gateway (HG)
Hyannis Village Business (HVB)
Medical Services (MS)
Office/Multifamily Residential (OM)
Gateway Medical (GM)
Transportation Hub (TD)
Growth Incentive Zone
Historic District Barnstab
le
Rd
.
Main
St.
R
o
u
t
e
1
2
8
utiledesign.com 11Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Zoning Primer
utiledesign.com 12Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Zoning Techniques: Use-Based
“Land Use” primary organizing principle
Similar uses sorted into distinct areas (zones)
● Single-family (Single-family)
● Multi-family (Office/Multifamily Residential)
● Retail/Commercial (Gateway, Medical Services)
● Industrial (Transportation Hub, Harbor)
Typically one set of dimensional standards per district
● Setbacks
● Building Height
● Floor Area Ratio
● Dwelling Units/Acre (Bedrooms/Acre)
utiledesign.com 13Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Zoning Technique: Performance-Based
Regulates the effects or impact of land uses on
surrounding properties
Performance measures:
● Traffic Impact (Vehicle Trips)
● Noise Levels
● Shadows, solar reflectivity, wind redirection
● Most Building Codes are performance-based
utiledesign.com 14Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Zoning Technique: Negotiated
Allows landowners to vary uses and development
standards in a zoning ordinance through a
negotiated process.
Local Example: Development Agreements
When approved, this type of zoning becomes a
“mini-zoning ordinance” that regulates development
of the site.
utiledesign.com 15Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Zoning Technique: Form-Based
● Building “form” or “type” is the primary
organizing principle
● Emphasis on dimensional standards
● Can de-prioritize land use regulation
● Predictable built results can allow for by right
development
● Better at producing housing diversity (types,
size, tenure, etc.)
● Regulate building underlying form, not
architectural style
utiledesign.com 16Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Approach: Form-Based Code “Light”
Smart Code Model Ordinance
1. Simplified Districts & Revised Map
2. Improved Dimensional Standards
3. Streamlined Permitting Process
4. Graphics & Clear Language
utiledesign.com 17Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Downtown Hyannis Zoning
utiledesign.com 18Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning Districts
Test Fits
utiledesign.com 19Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
All New Zoning Districts
Test Fits
Form-Based Zoning Districts
● Downtown Main Street
● Downtown Village
(Hybrid) Zoning Districts
● Downtown Neighborhood
● Downtown Hospital
● Hyannis Harbor
● Transportation Center
● Highway Commercial
utiledesign.com 20Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Form-Based Zoning Districts
Test Fits
Downtown Main Street District extends the
character and mixed-use commercial corridor of
the current main street
Downtown Village District promotes mixed
land uses that support the downtown core and
preserves traditional neighborhood forms and
pedestrian orientation
utiledesign.com 21Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning Districts
Test Fits
utiledesign.com 22Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Hyannis Village Business
utiledesign.com 23Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Form-Based District
Test Fits
Downtown Main Street District extends the
character and mixed-use commercial corridor of
the current main street
utiledesign.com 24Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Office/Multifamily Residential
utiledesign.com 25Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Form-Based District
Test Fits
Downtown Village District promotes mixed
land uses that support the downtown core and
preserves traditional neighborhood forms and
pedestrian orientation
utiledesign.com 26Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Medical Services
utiledesign.com 27Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning District
Test Fits
Downtown Hospital to maintain an area of Hyannis
for a large-scale Health Care Services institution
and is characterized by moderate to large floor
plate, multi-story buildings arranged in a
campus-like setting, with clear pedestrian and
vehicular connections to downtown and the region.
utiledesign.com 28Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Form-Based Zoning Districts
Test Fits
Downtown Main Street District extends the
character and mixed-use commercial corridor of
the current main street
Downtown Village District promotes mixed
land uses that support the downtown core and
preserves traditional neighborhood forms and
pedestrian orientation
utiledesign.com 29Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Lot Standards
Test Fits
Min/Max. Primary Front Setback
Mix/Max. Secondary Front Setback
Side Setback
Rear Setback
A
B
C
D
Primary Front
Secondary Front
Frontage Area
Buildable Area
Buildable Area
utiledesign.com 30Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Building Standards
Test Fits
Facade Build-out (min.)
Number of Stories
Ground Story Height
Upper Story Height
E
F
G
H
utiledesign.com 31Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New FBC Dimensional Standard
Facade Build-Out
A parallel facade must be provided within
the min & max setbacks for a min
percentage of total lot width
utiledesign.com 32Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New FBC Dimensional Standard
Facade Build-Out
A parallel facade must be provided within
the min & max setbacks for a min
percentage of total lot width
utiledesign.com 33Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Frontage Types
Frontage Types
Storefront Dining Patio Gallery Common Lobby
utiledesign.com 34Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Frontage Types
Frontage Types
Entry Plaza Front Garden Front Porch Dooryard Stoop
utiledesign.com 35Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Condition
Test Fits
Parking in Front
Large Setbacks
utiledesign.com 36Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Downtown Main Street Base Condition
Test Fits
utiledesign.com 37Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Downtown Main Street - Setbacks
Test Fits
Max. Setback
“Build To Line”
A Front Setback (min./max.)
B Side Setback
C Rear Setback
utiledesign.com 38Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Downtown Village - Setbacks
Test Fits
A Front Setback (min./max.)
B Side Setback
C Rear Setback
Max. Setback
“Build To Line”
utiledesign.com 39Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Downtown Main Street - Building Massing
Test Fits
A Primary Frontage
B Secondary Frontage
C Ground Floor Height (min.)
D Upper Floor Height (min.)
E Roof Pitch (min.)
No. of Stories
% Facade Build Out
4th Fl. Setback
Pitched Roof
Parking at Rear
Minimal Curb Cuts
Zero Lot Line
utiledesign.com 40Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Downtown Village - Building Massing
Test Fits
A Primary Frontage
B Secondary Frontage
C Ground Floor Height (min.)
D Upper Floor Height (min.)
E Roof Pitch (min.)
No. of Stories
% Facade Build Out
Pitched Roof
Parking at Rear
Minimal Curb Cuts
utiledesign.com 41Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning Districts
Test Fits
utiledesign.com 42Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Hyannis Gateway
utiledesign.com 43Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Gateway Medical
utiledesign.com 44Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning District
Test Fits
Highway Commercial to maintain an area for
larger-scale commercial land uses, with private
parking appropriately screened, on a regional
roadway and promote in the long-term
transformation of the area into a cohesive
gateway corridor into Hyannis. The area is
characterized by detached low- and mid-rise
commercial structures.
utiledesign.com 45Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Transportation Hub
utiledesign.com 46Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning District
Test Fits
Transportation Center to accommodate
transportation related-uses serving the
downtown, harbor and the region and is
characterized by functional buildings and parking
areas screened and not highly visible from
surrounding roadways.
utiledesign.com 47Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning District
Test Fits
Harbor District
utiledesign.com 48Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning District
Test Fits
Hyannis Harbor to maintain an area in close
proximity to Hyannis Inner Harbor for maritime
activities and water-related uses, and is
characterized by a mix of commercial, maritime
industrial, and residential development and the
presence of the commercial ferry services
utiledesign.com 49Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Existing Zoning Districts
Test Fits
Single Family
utiledesign.com 50Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
New Zoning District
Test Fits
Downtown Neighborhood District promotes
traditional uses and form of neighborhoods
adjacent to downtown and is characterized by
19th and 20th cen. detached and semi-detached
residential buildings
utiledesign.com 51Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
All New Zoning Districts
Test Fits
Form-Based Districts
● Downtown Main Street
● Downtown Village
Zoning Districts
● Downtown Neighborhood
● Downtown Hospital
● Hyannis Harbor
● Transportation Center
● Highway Commercial
utiledesign.com 52Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Document Highlights
utiledesign.com 53Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Table of Contents
1. Title
2. General Provisions
3. Definitions
4. Standards for all Districts
a. Building Standards
b. Use Provisions
c. Site Standards
5. Standards for Specific Districts (7)
a. Lot Standards
b. Building Standards
c. Design Guidelines
d. Use Provisions
e. Site Standards
6. Tables
utiledesign.com 54Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Standards for All Districts
A. Building Standards
1. Frontage types
2. Facade build out
3. Front doors
4. Number of stories
5. Components
6. Fenestration
utiledesign.com 55Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Permitted Use Table
P Permitted by Right
SP Special Permit
N Not Permitted
L Permitted with Limitations
utiledesign.com 56Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Minimum Required Accessory Parking
Existing Parking Requirements
Commercial Services 1/ business + 5/ 1,000 sf
Cultural Services 1/ 3 person of capacity
Food & Beverage Services 1/ 3 seats + 1/ 2 employees +
5/take out counter
Lodging 0.5/ room + 1/ 2 employees
Office 1/ business + 3.33/1,000 sf
Residential 1.5/ DU + 1/ 10 DU
Retail Sales 1/ business + 5/ 1,000 sf
utiledesign.com 57Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Standards for Specific Districts
Dimensional Standards
utiledesign.com 58Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Summary Tables
1. All District Standards
utiledesign.com 59Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Summary Tables
1. All District Standards
2. Frontage Types
utiledesign.com 60Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Summary Tables
1. All District Standards
2. Frontage Types
3. Building Components
utiledesign.com 61Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman
Feedback
1. Comments?
2. Questions?
3. Concerns?
utiledesign.com 62Hyannis Zoning UpdateDan Bartman