HomeMy WebLinkAbout[S] Superior Court Barnstable, 2272CV00062 , Costa v Barnstable Zoning Board Appeals2272CV00062 Costa, Alberto et al vs. Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals
et al
• Case Type:
• Real Property
• Case Status:
• Open
• File Date
• 02/23/2022
• DCM Track:
• F - Fast Track
• Initiating Action:
• Zoning Appeal, G.L. c. 40A
• Status Date:
• 02/23/2022
• Case Judge:
•
• Next Event:
•
All Information Party Event Tickler Docket Disposition
Alias Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Sabatt, Esq., Charles Mark
• Bar Code
• 436740
• Address
• Attorney At Law
540 Main St
Suite 8
Hyannis,MA 02601
• Phone Number
• (508)775-5050
Alias Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Sabatt, Esq., Charles Mark
• Bar Code
• 436740
• Address
• Attorney At Law
540 Main St
Suite 8
Hyannis,MA 02601
• Phone Number
• (508)775-5050
Alias Party Attorney
• Attorney
Party Information
Costa, Alberto
- Plaintiff
More Party Information
Costa, Christine I
- Plaintiff
More Party Information
Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals
- Defendant
• Connolly, Esq., Kathleen E
• Bar Code
• 558706
• Address
• Murphy Hesse Toomey and Lehane LLP
50 Braintree Hill Off Park
Braintree,MA 02184
• Phone Number
• (617)479-5000
• Attorney
• McLaughlin, Jr., Esq., Charles S
• Bar Code
• 336880
• Address
• Charles S. McLaughlin, Jr.
PO Box 2203
Hyannis,MA 02601
• Phone Number
• (508)737-2987
Alias Party Attorney
• Attorney
• Connolly, Esq., Kathleen E
• Bar Code
• 558706
• Address
• Murphy Hesse Toomey and Lehane LLP
50 Braintree Hill Off Park
Braintree,MA 02184
• Phone Number
• (617)479-5000
• Attorney
• McLaughlin, Jr., Esq., Charles S
• Bar Code
• 336880
• Address
• Charles S. McLaughlin, Jr.
PO Box 2203
Hyannis,MA 02601
• Phone Number
• (508)737-2987
More Party Information
Florence, Brian as he is the Building Commissioner
- Defendant
More Party Information
Events
Date Session Location Type Event Judge Result
06/28/2024 09:30 AM Second Session Courtroom 2 Rule 16 Conference Hogan, Hon. Maureen Not Held
Ticklers
Tickler Start Date Due Date Days Due Completed Date
Service 02/23/2022 05/24/2022 90 03/11/2022
Answer 02/23/2022 06/23/2022 120 06/07/2022
Rule 12/19/20 Served By 02/23/2022 06/23/2022 120 06/27/2024
Rule 12/19/20 Filed By 02/23/2022 07/25/2022 152 06/27/2024
Rule 12/19/20 Heard By 02/23/2022 08/22/2022 180 06/27/2024
Rule 15 Served By 02/23/2022 06/23/2022 120 06/27/2024
Tickler Start Date Due Date Days Due Completed Date
Rule 15 Filed By 02/23/2022 07/25/2022 152 06/27/2024
Rule 15 Heard By 02/23/2022 08/22/2022 180 06/27/2024
Discovery 02/23/2022 12/20/2022 300 06/27/2024
Rule 56 Served By 02/23/2022 01/19/2023 330 06/27/2024
Rule 56 Filed By 02/23/2022 04/04/2023 405 06/27/2024
Final Pre-Trial Conference 02/23/2022 06/20/2023 482 06/27/2024
Judgment 02/23/2022 02/23/2024 730 06/27/2024
Docket Information
Docket
Date
Docket Text File
Ref
Nbr.
Image
Avail.
02/23/2022 Case assigned to:
DCM Track F - Fast Track was added on 02/23/2022 Image
02/23/2022 Original civil complaint filed.1
Image02/23/2022 Civil action cover sheet filed.2
Image03/11/2022 Attorney appearance electronically filed for Defendants 3
Image03/11/2022 Summons, returned SERVED
Affidavit of service returned on Defendant Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals and Defendant
Florence, Brian as he is the Building Commissioner : Service via certified mail within 14 days of
filing of complaint
Applies To: Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals (Defendant); Florence, Brian as he is the Building
Commissioner (Defendant)
4
Image
02/21/2023 Plaintiffs, Defendants Alberto Costa, Christine I Costa, Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals, Brian
as he is the Building Commissioner Florence's Joint Motion to extend tracking deadline(s) Filing of
Rule 56
5
Image
02/22/2023 Endorsement on Motion to extend tracking deadline(s) (#5.0): ALLOWED
Image04/04/2023 Rule 9A list of documents filed.6
Image04/04/2023 Plaintiffs Alberto Costa, Christine I Costa's Motion for summary judgment, MRCP 56
,Partial
6.1
Image
04/04/2023 Alberto Costa, Christine I Costa's Memorandum in support of
motion for partial summary judgement P#6.1
6.2
Image
04/04/2023 Plaintiff Alberto Costa, Christine I Costa's Statement of
facts
6.3
Image
04/04/2023 Request for hearing filed
Applies To: Sabatt, Esq., Charles Mark (Attorney) on behalf of Costa, Alberto, Costa, Christine I
(Plaintiff)
6.4
Image
04/04/2023 Affidavit of compliance with Superior Court Rule 9A, Superior Court Rule 9C
No opposition
Applies To: Sabatt, Esq., Charles Mark (Attorney) on behalf of Costa, Alberto, Costa, Christine I
(Plaintiff)
6.5
Image
04/20/2023 Endorsement on Motion for partial summary judgment (#6.1): Other action taken
Partial Summary Judgement to enter that enforcement action as to the finished basement is
improper because it was not commenced in a timely manner Image
06/27/2024 Party(s) file Agreement for Judgment
The Finished Basement may remain in place and is hereby deemed to be in compliance with the
Barnstable Zoning Ordinance and the Massachusetts State Building Code.
7
Image
Docket
Date
Docket Text File
Ref
Nbr.
Image
Avail.
The Costas shall relocate the electric generator to a location on their property at 71 Sunset Lane,
Barnstable, MA that is approved by the Commissioner and shall obtain from the Barnstable
Building Department all necessary permits required for electric generator.
Applies To: Connolly, Esq., Kathleen E (Attorney) on behalf of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals
(Defendant); Sabatt, Esq., Charles Mark (Attorney) on behalf of Costa, Alberto (Plaintiff)
06/27/2024 Event Result:: Rule 16 Conference scheduled on:
06/28/2024 09:30 AM: Not Held : Case Settled
Case Disposition
Disposition Date Case Judge
Disposed by Agreement / Settled 06/27/2024