HomeMy WebLinkAboutM-072226 July 22, 2026
Zoning Board of Appeals
MINUTES
Wednesday, July 22, 2026
7:00 PM
To all persons interested in or affected by the actfons of the Zoning Board of Appeals, you are hereby notffied, pursuant to Sectfon 11
of Chapter 40A of the General Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and all amendments thereto, that a public heari ng on
the following appeals will be held on Wednesday, July 22, 2026, at the tfme indicated:
Call to order
Chair Dewey calls the meetfng to order at 7:05 PM with an introductfon of Board Members:
Also present is Kyle Pedicini, Assistant Director – Planning & Development; Jan Kendrick, Assistant Town Attorney; Anna Brigham,
Principal Planner; and Genna Ziino, Administratfve Assistant.
Notice of Recording
This meetfng of the Zoning Board of Appeals is being recorded and broadcast on the Town of Barnstable's Government Access
Channel. In accordance with MGL Chapter 30A S20, I must inquire whether anyone is recording this meetfng and if so, to please make
their presence known.
Chair's Statement for the public
I wish to remind everyone that no member of the public may speak without first being recognized by the Zoning Board of Appeal s
Chair.
The public will have an opportunity to speak for up to 3 minutes during any public hearing on an agenda item.
Out of respect for everyone's tfme, please refrain from repeatfng the same comments others have already made. Each member wil l
get one chance to speak on a topic and there is no ceding tfme to others.
Comments must be directed to the Zoning Board of Appeals as a body, through the Board Chair. You should not make comments
directly to any individual Member. You also should not be addressing your comments to anyone else in this room — not to Town staff
and not to another member of the audience. Public comment is to be directed to the Zoning Board of Appeals.
We also ask that the members of the public refrain from making audible comments during the meetfng unless they have been
recognized to speak by the Board Chair. Please treat fellow members of the public speaking at the mic, and members of this bo ard,
with the respect you would wish to be treated with yourself.
I hope this evening we can have a thoughtiul, respectiul meetfng.
Minutes
June 10, 2026 – Aaron Webb moves to approve. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Debra Dworkis, Larry Hurwitz, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Member Present Absent
Dewey, Jacob – Chair X
Bodensiek, Herbert – Vice Chair X
Pinard, Paul – Clerk X
Alves, Manny X
Dworkis, Debra X
Hurwitz, Larry X
Webb, Aaron X
Old Business
7:00 PM Appeal No. 2026-010 Walsh/AscIepius Corporation
Maria R. Walsh, Trustee of Mias Family Trust, has appealed an Administratfve Official's decision. The Appellant is appealing the
Building Permit dated April 6, 2026 which permits an emergency overnight shelter as a nonconforming use pursuant to 40A, 3 at 460
West Main Street, Hyannis. The subject property is located at 460 West Main Street, Hyannis, MA as shown on Assessor's Map 26 9
as Parcel 030. It is located in the Residence B (RB) and the Highway Business (HB) Zoning Districts. This matter was contfnue d from
June 10, 2026.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves.
The Chairman welcomes Assistant Town Attorney Jan Kendrick to provide background. Attorney Kendrick explains that a shelter is
not a permitted use in the zoning district, however, the Building Commissioner, based on the submissions received, made a
determinatfon that the emergency overnight shelter use is an exempt use under 40A sectfon 3, the Dover Amendment. That
amendment restricts the ways a town can regulate certain uses—in this case, religious uses. Tonight, the sole issue before the Board
is if the Building Commissioner’s determinatfon is correct. That is, if the emergency overnight shelter that Catholic Charitfes
proposes to operate as lessee of Housing Assistance Corporatfon is a use for religious purposes on land leased by a religious sect.
Attorney Dan Creedon is representfng the appellant Maria Walsh, a direct abutter to 460 West Main Street. He is appealing the
Commissioner’s determinatfon that Catholic Charitfes’ use of a portfon of an office building as a shelter is exempt from zoning. He
wants to address the merits of the case and standing. To determine what is a protected use, the Board needs to apply the
framework that MA courts have applied in these cases. He requests to confine the analysis to MA law, not other states. For a
religious sponsor to establish that its use is exempt from zoning, it must satfsfy two required elements: that its use is religiously
significant, and that its use is primarily and dominantly religious. The reported cases in MA have found two ways to satfsfy the
second requirement: the use can artfculate religious doctrine, or can be accessory to a religious use on the property that artfculates
religious doctrine. He doesn’t think Catholic Charitfes meets the second use, and believes the determinatfon should be overturned.
Attorney Creedon would like to reference two existfng cases: Needham Pastoral Counseling Center, Inc. vs. Board of Appeals of
Needham and Becker vs. Somerville. Catholic Charitfes have asserted that their operatfon of an emergency overnight shelter is
inspired by faith and consistent with their religious mission, and is a form of ministry consistent with scripture. That’s not disputed.
But it does not speak to the second required element that the use must be primarily and dominantly religious.
He provides an analysis of the Needham case, wherein the court found that the pastoral counseling was inspired by faith and was a
form of ministry, but because it neither artfculated religious doctrine itself, nor was it accessory to an existfng use of th e land that
did as such. The court found that it was deemed secular and thus not exempt from zoning. This is also true in this case.
He provides an analysis of the Somerville case, wherein the operatfon of shelter in basement of existfng church was deemed exempt
from zoning because it was grounded in the landlord church’s religious beliefs and was an integral part to the church’s religious
mission located in the same building. He asserts that locatfon matters in these cases. There is no protected use co-located at 460
West Main. The use does not satfsfy the second requirement.
Regarding standing, he says there is no longer a rebuttal of presumptfon, and requests to withdraw that memo. He says the
appellants must demonstrate partfcularized aggrievement. A certffied appraiser submitted an affidavit that due to the stfgma of
shelters, market partfcipants suffer diminishing market values, and his client will suffer such injury if this use is established.
Barnstable under 242 has a purpose clause that states value is defined as a protected use.
Attorney Eliza Cox is representfng Catholic Charitfes of the Diocese of Fall River, Asclepius owner, and HAC which is the managing and
operatfonal representatfve of the property owner. She is joined by Attorney Valerie Moore who is co-counsel. She says they are not
challenging the appellant’s standing at this stage but reserve the right to do so should this end up in court.
Attorney Cox says many letters in oppositfon focus on concerns of locatfon and perceived public safety associated with a shelter. Her
clients have always prioritfzed safety, that of the community and of the shelter guests. However, shelter operatfons, proposed
locatfon, and use are not within the scope and are not relevant to tonight’s hearing. The issue before the Board is narrow. They are
not being asked to determine if this is a desirable use for this locatfon—they are being asked to determine whether the Building
Commissioner correctly applied state law in his determinatfon that the proposed use qualifies for protectfon under the Dover
Amendment.
Attorney Cox says the appellant argues that the proposed shelter is not an accessory use. She agrees with that, because it is the
primary use—the primary purpose for which the land and structure will be used. The only questfon before this Board is whether it’s
a religious use within the Dover Amendment. She applies the two-prong test: first, is the goal of the shelter religiously significant
and second, is it the dominant or primary purpose for which the land will be used. She says housing is the only use, and aids a
system of faith or worship.
Regarding the argument that the shelter does not espouse religious content to guests, that would violate the First Amendment and
has been rejected by courts. The sole purpose of the operatfon of this shelter is to aid the church in its system of faith and worship
by serving the most vulnerable members of the community by the gospel. The act of providing the emergency shelter to the
homeless is the direct instftutfonal expression of the Catholic Church and is itself a form of worship and so is clearly prot ected under
the Dover Amendment.
Susan Mazarella, CEO of Catholic Charitfes and St. Joseph’s Shelter addresses the Board. She tells the parable of the good Samaritan
as a metaphor for the work they do. Catholic Charitfes is a nonprofit governed by a board of directors. Their purpose is to provide
social services through the gospel. They would offer day programs and resources. She discusses their core beliefs. She explains that
they need to relocate for safety, accessibility, and dignity. The current locatfon has steep, dangerous stairs, and cramped sleeping
areas. Chair Dewey calls for a point of order: he would like to keep testfmony to what is under the Dover Amendment and what is
before them and not the existfng shelter or the moving of the shelter. Attorney Cox argues that they are describing Catholic
Charitfes. This is a public hearing , and additfonal informatfon can be presented. Ms. Mazarella contfnues describing their mission.
Father Thomas Washburn explains that from a Catholic perspectfve, the operatfon of a homeless shelter is unequivocably a religious
use. It is at the core of their faith. He shares examples from scripture. Chair Dewey interrupts to say this is too much, and all the
Board needs is the signed affidavit that was already submitted. Attorney Cox says this is a faith leader describing how this is a
dominant use, because it’s been questfoned whether this is the dominant use. Chair Dewey doesn’t think Father Washburn is
speaking specific to this space. Attorney Cox disagrees. Chair Dewey wants to keep testfmony focused on legal standards.
Attorney Moore says Attorney Creedon mentfoned “inspiratfon” repeatedly. Neither of their religious leaders used the word
“inspired”—they used “command” and “mandate” of their faith, and that is central to how this case is different from Needham
Pastoral and is more aligned with the Somerville case. It is a mandate of their faith to shelter the unhoused. It is not optfonal, not
inspired by. The Supreme Court case from 2025 is important because it addressed similar first amendment concerns. Dover
enshrines the first amendment into MA law. Does it matter whether shelter guests are preached to—the Supreme Court said the
government can’t ask that questfon, because you would be creatfng a preference for faiths that require proselytfzing. The questfon
before the Board is what is the motfvatfon behind the actfon. The motfvatfon is religious service—the mandate to fulfil their faith.
Paul Pinard asks if there is guidance from the Attorney General on the legal test about the regulatfon. He reads language from the
AG’s website, and asks for an explanatfon of what a “Bonafide religiously significant goal” means. Attorney Moore says case law has
been consistent that it is about looking at religious intent of the provider. A Bonafide religious objectfve is anything that aids a
system of faith or worship. Attorney Kendrick says the opinion of the Town Attorney’s office is that motfvatfon is not the issue, but
rather zoning. It is looking at a principle use on a property and an accessory use on a property, and both have to be present.
Attorney Cox says there is a memo dated March 11, 2026 from AG relatfng to this request: page 6 says “it seems obvious that the
proposed shelter use qualifies as a religious purpose.” Attorney Kendrick says the memo referenced is not one issued as an official
opinion. What happened was a HAC legal officer contacted two assistant AGs asking they intervene. The letter was written in
response to town counsel and is an advocacy piece.
Manny Alves says the Building Commissioner issued a permit for an emergency shelter. Attorney Cox says the Commissioner
concluded that Catholic Charitfes’ proposed use is exempt as a religious use. Mr. Alves asks what is the use. Attorney Cox says it is
the expression of their faith that requires them to provide and care with the unsheltered, and they are doing this in accorda nce with
advancing their faith. The use is not inherently religious and so if it were not being done by a religious organizatfon, it would not
qualify under the Dover Amendment. Manny Alves asks for an explanatfon of the mentfon that the operatfon of the shelter is done
pursuant to a contract with the Executfve Office of Housing through the state. Attorney Moore says the court found in Somerville
that Dover doesn’t look at the means to how a religious organizatfon accomplishes its goals—it looks at the motfvatfon. Attorney
Creedon agrees that it looks at the motfvatfon to determine whether it’s religiously significant, but it looks at the use and whether
the use artfculates religious doctrine or is accessory to a use collocated on the same property, which is the second requirement. He
believes it needs to be both: religiously significant, and primarily and dominantly religious. He believes the arrangement in this case
between tenant and landlord is a financial arrangement to rent space.
Commissioner Florence addresses the Board to say he found that Catholic Charitfes is a nonprofit and has in their purpose sheltering
the homeless. The building ’s primary purpose is sheltering the homeless. The documentatfon he received states that, and that’s how
he came to that conclusion. Chair Dewey asks about the tfmeline. Commissioner Florence says town counsel gave an opinion. He
doesn’t have the luxury of opinion—he has to make a determinatfon based on facts. He listened to the town attorney’s opinion and
all opinions and in his 7-page findings and determinatfon, he came to the conclusion that it was a Dover Amendment qualified use.
He adds that it’s been said tonight that a homeless shelter is not an allowed use. But a shelter is a residentfal use, and residentfal use
is allowed in the HB district, including congregatfonal housing. MGL 40A protects congregate living and building code protects
congregate living. If the applicant had come to him with an as of right permit, he may have issued that as of right. The Board
discusses concern that it was never discussed with the applicant that it could be done by right.
Chair Dewey opens public comment. He says what is before the Board is the Dover Amendment and asks the public to keep their
comments focused on what is within the Board’s purview.
Thomas Ryan speaks in support of the Commissioner.
Father Fred Edmond speaks in support of the Commissioner.
Rick Brigham of Hyannis speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
Mary Doolin of Osterville speaks in support of the Commissioner.
Sandy Jones speaks in oppositfon, with concerns about HAC describing the project in secular terms, without mentfon of religious
use, for most applicatfons other than Building.
Joseph Doolin of Osterville speaks in support.
Sharon Diggs Harrison of Osterville speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
Lori Crowley of Hyannis speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
Carol Melcher of Cotuit speaks in oppositfon. She used to work for HAC and doesn’t think they do any worship or bible study.
June Bertucci of Hyannis speaks in support.
Christfna Carrington speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
Cheryl Powell is a mental health practftfoner and speaks with concerns over public safety.
Taryn Thomas of Marstons Mills speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the businesses being affected.
Stephanie Wroten, CEO of Duffy Health Center, speaks in support and addresses misinformatfon about homelessness.
Alex Bonfiglio of Sea Street in Hyannis speaks in support.
Mike Ferrill of Cotuit speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
Kelly Tatrault of Hyannis speaks in oppositfon with concerns over it not being religious, and public safety.
Katfe Minehart of Marstons Mills speaks in support.
Maryann Barbosa speaks in support.
Sheila Lord speaks in support. She has been a resident of the shelter since 2021 and knows it is well run.
Roberta Mauch of Greenwood Ave speaks with concerns over the locatfon.
Brooke Sargent of Marstons Mills speaks in support.
Meagan Ashley speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
Jessica Cisternelli of Leonard Road speaks in support.
Kathleen Defeo of Centerville wants to know where to discuss concerns over the locatfon.
Elain Tung of Centerville speaks in support.
Nina Tupper of Hyannisport speaks in support.
Laura Russo of Centerville is a director at St. Joseph’s and speaks in support.
Larry Morrin of Cotuit speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the locatfon.
Jill Holland of Centerville speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the locatfon.
Katfa DaCunha speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the need for more community engagement.
Janice Godrow of Hyannis works at St. Joseph’s and speaks in support.
Karen Kim McGuire of Hyannis speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the need for more community engagement .
Michael Edwards of Centerville speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the locatfon.
Ocean McDonald of Marstons Mills speaks in support.
Mia Walsh of Hyannis speaks in oppositfon with concerns over it not being a religious use.
Chris Olsen of Centerville speaks with concerns over the locatfon.
Deacon Dick Murphy of Centerville speaks in support.
Councilor Betty Ludtke speaks in oppositfon with concerns over the purpose of zoning.
Paul Phelan of Centerville speaks in oppositfon with concerns over public safety.
John Julius of Hyannis speaks in oppositfon with concern s over public safety.
Aaron Webb reads into the record the letters that were submitted to the Board: Public comment from Sandra Jones Fitzgerald to
MassDev regarding HAC’s legibility for UPP grant, from Amaral, President of Catholic Charitfes in support, from Bean in oppositfon,
from Bent & School Committee with concerns, from Bolliger in oppositfon, from Brenowitz in oppositfon, from C. Murphy in
oppositfon, from Carty in support, from Connolly in oppositfon, from Crawley with concerns, from DaCunha in oppositfon, from D.
Smith in support, from Dumouchel, Executfve Director of Attleboro Housing Authority in support, from Duran in oppositfon, fro m
Duran de la Torre in support, from Edwards in oppositfon, from Fedele in oppositfon, from Figueiredo in oppositfon, from Fitzgerald
Jones with concerns, from Brigham in oppositfon, 1 & 2 from Green in oppositfon, from Guenther in oppositfon, from Haynes in
support, from Herschler in support, from Hills in oppositfon, from Julius in oppositfon, from Kanaris in oppositfon, from Kimball (+
attachment) in oppositfon, from Kuhn in oppositfon, from Livramento in support, from Loumiotfs with concerns, from Ludtke in
oppositfon, from Moran in oppositfon, from Mort in support, from Nicholson in oppositfon, from Nommensen in oppositfon, from
Wroten, CEO of Duffy Health in support, from O’Connor in oppositfon, from Our Lady’s Guild in support, from Preston in support,
from Resident in support, from Ryan in support, from Sawyer in oppositfon, from Schulte in oppositfon, from Stephens in suppo rt,
from Thomas in oppositfon, from Torres in support, from Vasys in support, from Victoria C. with concerns, 1 & 2 from Welden in
support.
Chair Dewey thanks the public and reiterates that all that is before this Board is whether the use qualifies under the Dover
Amendment. All other issues need to be directed to Town Council.
Chair Dewey moves to close public comment. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves
Nay: None
The Board takes a break at 10:38 p.m. and the meetfng resumes at 10:47 p.m.
Manny Alves requests to discuss the artfculatfon of religious use that is required. The language from the Hume case talks about a
goal: “If we consider whether the religiously significant goal is the primary or dominant purpose for which the land or structures
have been used…” So if you accept that the goal of housing the unhoused is the goal, why isn’t housing primary and dominant?
Attorney Creedon says because there is no MA case that supports that positfon. Attorney Moore says once you’ve accepted that
housing the unsheltered is a religious use, it just comes down to whether the use is primary. There is nothing else happening at this
property—the entfre use is religious. There is no requirement in MA for colocatfon. The requirement is that the use be religious and
then that that religious purpose be the primary use. Manny Alves asks how an emergency shelter aids or assists in faith and worship.
Attorney Moore says the Catholic faith mandates that they fulfil this duty.
Manny Alves says they are also under contract with the state for an emergency overnight shelter. Paul Pinard think it comes down to
“religiously significant goal.” Chair Dewey asks for the ownership and the funding sources to be laid out. Attorney Cox says the
funding isn’t relevant to Dover. The property is owned by Asclepius and the proposed space is being leased to Catholic Charitfes.
HAC is involved but the operator is Catholic Charitfes. During the permitting process, Catholic Charitfes was identffied.
The Board deliberates. Herb Bodensiek believes it falls under Dover. Chair Dewey asks if “emergency overnight shelter” is
specifically religious. They discuss whether the use is dominant. Manny Alves says the way to comply with the second prong has
been decided by courts, but neither predicates this. Attorney Moore says there is a clear religious artfculatfon. The Supreme Court
answered this last year unanimously and held that you can’t require a religious actfvity to require proselytfzing. The Board expresses
concern that the use of “emergency overnight shelter ” doesn’t give enough room for religious actfvity, along with the fact that they
are constrained by a state contract. Aaron Webb reads the HB zoning district purpose and is concerned that this doesn’t meet the
purpose. They discuss again whether it ’s the primary use.
Aaron Webb moves to close the public hearing. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Manny Alves thinks it needs to be more than internal motfvatfon—they need to show a base of observable religious practfce that
would otherwise be discriminated against without the Dover Amendment. They discuss whether it’s a motfvatfon or if there needs
to be a more external, overt expression of religion.
Herb Bodensiek moves to vote to uphold the Building Commissioner’s decision. He does not receive a second.
Aaron Webb moves to overturn the Building Commissioner. Manny Alves seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves, Jake Dewey
Nay: Herb Bodensiek
In Appeal No. 2026-010 Walsh/AscIepius Corporatfon, the Building Commissioner’s decision is overturned.
New Business
7:01 PM Appeal No. 2026-014 Premier Capital Inc/210 North St LLC
Premier Capital, Inc. has appealed an Administratfve Official's decision. The Appellant is appealing the Building Commissioner's
Notfce of Denial for Zoning Enforcement dated April 29, 2026 under Sectfon 240-125 B. (l)(a). The subject property is located at 210
North Street, Hyannis, MA, as shown on Assessor's Map 309 as Parcel 259 -001. It is located in the Downtown Village (DV) Zoning
District.
Attorney Richard Reiling is representfng the appellant, the owner of 200 North Street. He says there were misrepresentatfons in the
defendant’s applicatfon. His client requested enforcement because the building was not being built within the footprint as it was
supposed to. The Building Commissioner denied the request for enforcement, and he is asking the Board to have the Commissioner
enforce the zoning regulatfons at issue in this case.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves.
Herb Bodensiek moves to contfnue. Commissioner Florence objects to a contfnuance. He says the matter is simple: it was not
appealed in a tfmely manner and there has been no misrepresentatfons of zoning—the appellant’s concerns are all building code,
not zoning. He asks the Board to hear this case and uphold his decision. Herb Bodensiek withdraws his motfon to contfnue.
Attorney Reiling says the appeal was asserted within 30 days of the Commissioner’s failure to act. The denial letter was dated April
29, 2026 and the appeal was filed May 28, 2026, so within 30 days. They discuss the zoning issues. Attorney Reiling claims the
building wasn’t built within the footprint as it should have been. If they are not building on the existfng footprint, it’s not permitted.
Commissioner Florence says the appeal of the building permit was not tfmely—it came months after the building permit. When he
denied that for lack of tfmeliness, the appellant decided to take a second bite of the apple with an enforcement demand. Attorney
Kendrick says the applicant is trying to get around the denial of enforcement for the building permit. The Board discusses whether
an abutter has the right to request enforcement if they see a building isn’t being built to plan.
Aaron Webb moves to contfnue to September 9, 2026. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves
Nay: None
Appeal No. 2026-014 Premier Capital Inc./210 North St. LLC is contfnued to September 9, 2026.
Correspondence
Matters Not Reasonably Anticipated by the Chair
Upcoming Hearings
August 12, 2026 (in person), August 26, 2026 (online), September 9, 2026 (online)
Adjournment
Aaron Webb moves to adjourn. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves, Debra Dworkis, Larry Hurwitz
Nay: None
Documents Used at this Meeting
• June 10, 2026 minutes
• Appeal No. 2026-010 Walsh/AscIepius Corporatfon applicatfon materials
• Appeal No. 2026-014 Premier Capital Inc/210 North St LLC applicatfon materials
Respectiully submitted,
Genna Ziino, Administratfve Assistant
Further detail may be obtained by viewing the video via the Barnstable Government Access Channel on demand at town.barnstable.ma.us