HomeMy WebLinkAboutM-081226 August 12, 2026
Page 1 of 7 1
Zoning Board of Appeals
MINUTES
Wednesday, August 12, 2026
7:00 PM
To all persons interested in or affected by the actions of the Zoning Board of Appeals, you are hereby notified, pursuant to Section
11 of Chapter 40A of the General Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and all amendments thereto, that a public hearing
on the following appeals will be held on Wednesday, August 12, 2026, at the time indicated:
Call to Order
Chair Dewey calls the meeting to order at 7:02 PM with an introduction of Board Members:
Also present is Jim Kupfer, Director – Planning & Development; Jan Kendrick, Assistant Town Attorney; Anna Brigham, Principal
Planner; and Genna Ziino, Administrative Assistant.
Notice of Recording
This meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals is being recorded and broadcast on the Town of Barnstable’s Government Access
Channel. In accordance with MGL Chapter 30A §20, I must inquire whether anyone is recording this meeting and if so, to please
make their presence known.
Minutes
None
Discussion
Assistant Town Attorney Jan Kendrick discusses the recent state zoning changes. She explains that effective July 8, the FY2027
budget bill contained substantial changes to Chapter 40A. Changes are summarized in the document entitled “FY2027 40A
Amendments.” The main issue is that it establishes a n ew standard for variances. Applicants are no longer required to establish
significant hardship arising from soil, shape, or topography. The new measure is whether strict enforcement would result in p ractical
difficulty. The Board must weigh the benefits to the applicant and public interest (including housing). Jim Kupfer says the n ew
considerations are more a balancing act than the 3-prong test used to be. Variances are also now valid for 2 years rather than 1 year.
Also, use variances for residential uses are now allowed by right.
Jim Kupfer explains that the language was not reviewed by the Planning Association or the MA Municipal Association, so they have
found many errors. Attorney Kendrick says much of it is going to have to be fleshed out by the courts. Jim Kupfer says staff will
arrange a workshop for the Board once one is available.
Old Business
None
New Business
7:00 PM Appeal No. 2026-016 Tonelli
Edith A. Tonelli has applied for a Special Permit pursuant to Section 240 -47.2 Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs). The Applicant seeks
to remodel the existing barn with attached workshop into a 2 -bedroom, 2 bath, 1,553 sq. ft. ADU using the existing footprint and
adding an 8’ x 20’ exterior entry deck that conforms to setback requirements. The subject property is located at 1595 Main St reet,
West Barnstable, MA, as shown on Assessor’s Map 197 as Parcel 044. It is located in the Residence F (RF) Zoning District.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves.
Member Present Absent
Dewey, Jacob – Chair X
Bodensiek, Herbert – Vice Chair X
Pinard, Paul – Clerk X
Alves, Manny X
Dworkis, Debra X
Hurwitz, Larry X
Webb, Aaron X
Page 2 of 7 2
Edith Tonelli is the owner and explains that they have a large barn and storage facility at the back of the property that they would
like to turn into a 2-bedroom ADU. They have been through Barnstable Historic and then learned from the Building Department that
the building is larger than the 900 allowed sq. ft. She is asking for a special permit to use the existing building. The main home is a
2,200 sq. ft. structure. The barn used to be storage for retail inventory and was built in the 1880s. It is two stories, and the attached
workshop would be a single-story part of it.
Aaron Webb asks if they could use only 900 sq. ft. of the existing structure, since it hasn’t been built out yet. Chair Dewey is
concerned that it is larger than half the principal structure.
Ms. Tonelli says she lives in the main house with her handicapped son, and her daughter plans to live in the barn and help with his
care. Her daughter is married and will be having children so needs the space. The Chairman thinks the intent of the bylaw is to build
accessory structures, and they are meant to be small. He wonders if it could go in as a family apartment. They discuss that they don’t
have an exact number for the existing house square footage. The Board needs to know gross floor area. Manny Alves suggests Ms.
Tonelli discuss her options with the Building Commissioner.
Aaron Webb moves to continue to September 23, 2026. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves
Nay: None
Appeal No. 2026-016 Tonelli is continued to September 23, 2026.
7:01 PM Appeal No. 2026-017 Castignetti
Gerald and Sonora Castignetti have petition for a Variance pursuant to Section 240 -14 E. Bulk Regulations. The Petitioner installed a
pool that mistakenly encroaches into a setback. The newly installed pool is setback 7 feet from the side yard lot line and th e
requirement side yard setback is 15 feet. The subject property is located at 91 Forest Hills Road, Cotuit, MA, as shown on As sessor’s
Map 025 as Parcel 007-010. It is located in the Residence F (RF) Zoning District.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves. Anna Brigham prefaces that this lot is
part of an open space subdivision from 1988 that was approved by the Planning Board, which gave this lot the setback of 7.5 feet,
not 15 feet. So it’s half a foot into the setback rather than 7 feet.
Gerry Castignetti is the owner and explains they bought the home in 2022 with the purpose of installing a pool. They built a retaining
wall to grade the ground because the falloff is significant. Pool work started in July 2023. The topography is complex, with 20-30 foot
grade changes to the front and side. The pool company had to crane the pool over the house to set it in place because of the grade.
He believes this is why the pool company made the mistake of putting the pool too close to the setback. The lot is adjacent to one
home, and all the back property is owned by the association of the neighborhood, and behind that is conservation land. There is no
building capability or visual capability. They are attempting to sell their home, and the cost to move the pool 6 inches would be at
least $70,000, and that’s if they can even get the proper equipment back there. The neighbors and the President of the association
have submitted memos with no issues.
Back to the Board for questions. Chair Dewey asks for the site plan—he would like to see the elevation details. Mr. Tonelli only has
the as-built. Paul Pinard asks if the association is aware of the extent that he is encroaching on their property. Mr. Castignetti says
yes. Mr. Pinard would like to see written confirmation about the encroachment. Chair Dewey is concerned about impervious lot
coverage and the potential need for an easement. Manny Alves thinks some members are conflating their concerns—some of those
are not zoning issues. But he would like to see the grading on the site plan.
Manny Alves thinks under the new variance standards, this may qualify as a practical difficulty. They discuss whether seeing a site
plan would help. Paul Pinard reiterates concern that much of the project is not on the owner’s land. Herb Bodensiek would be in
favor of granting the variance for this. Manny Alves says the Board is not required to discuss topography under the new standards —
but that they “may.” Attorney Kendrick walks through the new variance test again. Paul Pinard says in this case, the detriment is the
inability to sell the house and the cost to meet the setback standard.
Chair Dewey opens public comment. The Chairman says Mandy Gately submitted public comment to say no issue. Gill Schipani said
he personally has no issue. Aaron Webb moves to close public comment. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Page 3 of 7 3
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves
Nay: None
The Board deliberates. Chair Dewey says he would not be able to vote in favor. Manny Alves says the first prong is if the Board finds
that strict enforcement of the ordinance would result in practical difficulty. The Chairman needs to see the site plan to verify that it
was difficult to put the pool in. Manny Alves would vote in favor of granting the variance. Paul Pinard agrees. Aaron Webb is not
sure. They discuss whether a site plan would help them tell the story of whether this was self -inflicted.
Chair Dewey moves to continue the item to September 23, 2026. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Aaron Webb
Nay: Paul Pinard, Manny Alves
The Board requests an engineered site plan from the applicant for the next meeting.
Appeal No. 2026-017 Castignetti is continued to September 23, 2026.
7:02 PM Appeal No. 2026-018 Lorusso
Joseph P. Lorusso and Carolyn H. Lorusso have applied for a Special Permit pursuant to Section 240 -47.2 Accessory Dwelling Units
(ADUs). The Applicants seek to establish an ADU in the detached carriage house, which was constructed in 2007 and contains a total
of 933 sq. ft. The subject property is located at 205 Little River Road, Cotuit, MA, as shown on Assessor’s Map 054 as Parcel 002-004.
It is located in the Residence F (RF) Zoning District.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves .
Attorney Michael Schulz is representing the applicant. He explains that this is a single-family dwelling built in 2007 and a carriage
house built in 2001. In 2000, a 5-BR septic system was installed. The carriage house was the principle dwelling until 2007, when the
main house was built. The kitchen of the carriage house was removed in 2007 and the structure was inspected. His clients purchased
in 2010 and at that time, it had a kitchen in it, so it is his belief that the prior owners put the kitchen back in after inspection. For the
last 16 years they have used it without issue until they went to sell the property , and it was determined not to be permitted. There
has been no change in the carriage house since it was constructed. It meets all setbacks. It is 864 square feet on the second floor,
and a common bathroom in the garage that puts it over by 33 sq. ft.. There is no detriment to the neighborhood and no impacts to
septic.
Back to the Board for questions. Paul Pinard asks to define common entry. Attorney Schulz says it’s not so easily defined. He went
through the process with Building Commissioner Brian Florence who approved, but later, a different inspector found the entry an
issue, so they need relief for the 33 sq. ft. The common bathroom is 69 sq. ft. Paul Pinard says if the common entry is more than 33
sq. ft., then this meets requirements as of right. Attorney Schulz says that is correct, but the determination of the Building Dept. was
that it was not a common entry. The group discusses whether it’s a common entry. There is no option to wall up the area either—
they spoke to a builder about that.
Chair Dewey opens for public comment. He says the Board received public comment from Fredburg in opposition and a letter from
Jones in opposition that was later withdrawn.
Marvin Fredberg of 204 Little River Road speaks in opposition with concerns about traffic density and public safety.
The Chairman moves to close public comment. Aaron Webb seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Back to the Board for discussion. The Chairman asks why not make it a family apartment. Attorney Schulz says because the
ordinance provides the option for a special permit. It is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood.
Page 4 of 7 4
Chair Dewey moves to close the public hearing. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
The Board deliberates. They discuss whether they need to condition to add a door. Attorney Schulz says it’s not allowed under
building code to put a door. They discuss that the Commissioner found the common space to be considered part of the ADU.
Paul Pinard makes findings:
1. The application falls within a category specifically excepted in the ordinance for a grant of a special permit. Section 240-
47.2 (4) Allows an ADU over 900 Square feet in an existing structure.
2. After an evaluation of all the evidence presented, the proposal fulfills the spirit and intent of the Zoning Ordinance and
would not represent a substantial detriment to the public good or the neighborhood affected. He notes that there might
be some increased traffic.
3. A Site Plan has been reviewed and found approvable with conditions. Site Plan Review was not required.
Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron We bb
Nay: None
Paul Pinard makes a motion to grant Special Permit No. 2026-018 with conditions 1-4 from the Staff Report dated July 23, 2026.
Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Chair Dewey moves to grant with conditions. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Special Permit No. 2026-018 Lorusso is granted with conditions.
7:03 PM Appeal No. 2026-019 Moore
Giles and Constance Moore have applied for a Special Permit pursuant to 240 -92 B. Nonconforming Buildings or Structures Used as
Single- and Two-Family Residences. The Applicants proposes an addition to the front of the dwelling that increases the preexisting
nonconformity. The existing dwelling has a front setback of 21.7 ft. and the proposed addition has a setback of 20.5 ft. The subject
property is located at 76 Nyes Neck Road, Centerville, MA as shown on Assessor’s Map 233 as Parcel 035. It is located in the
Residence D-1 (RD-1) Zoning District.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves .
Trevor Meyer of Meyer and Sons Builders is representing the applicants. He explains they are asking for 1.2 feet of relief. They are
constrained by a pond on the rear or property and wetlands across Nye’s Neck Road. The addition is a modest bedroom expansion,
dining room, kitchen, and entry. It is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood.
Back to the Board for questions. Paul Pinard asks if they got approval from the Conservation Commission. Mr. Meyer says they
received approval at the hearing with a conditional item to bring the revised site plan back to them. The revised site plan was
submitted to Ed Hoopes and via email was approved.
Chair Dewey opens public comment. There is none. The Chairman moves to close public comment. Aaron Webb seconds.
Page 5 of 7 5
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
The Board deliberates. The group discusses whether the new amendment to Section 6 gives the applicant the right to do this. The
applicant says they didn’t submit to the Building Department because it was nonconforming. Manny Alves does not think the
provision in question would apply. The group agrees.
Chair Dewey moves to close the public hearing. Manny Alves seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Manny Alves makes findings:
1. The application falls within a category specifically excepted in the ordinance for a grant of a special permit. Section 240-92
B. allows for a Special Permit.
2. After an evaluation of all the evidence presented, the proposal fulfills the spirit and intent of the Zoning Ordinance and
would not represent a substantial detriment to the public good or the neighborhood affected.
3. A site plan has been reviewed and found approvable in accordance with Article IX herein subject only to the issuance of a
special permit. Site Plan Review is not required for single family dwellings.
Further Section 240-92 B. requires the Board to find that:
4. The proposed alteration or expansion will not be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing
building or structure.
Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Manny Alves makes a motion to grant Special Permit No. 2026-019 with conditions 1-5 from the Staff Report dated July 24, 2026.
Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Chair Dewey moves to grant with conditions. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Special Permit No. 2026-019 Moore is granted with conditions.
7:04 PM Appeal No. 2026-020 Barnstable House, LLC
Barnstable House, LLC has applied for a Special Permit pursuant to 240-93 B. Nonconforming Buildings or Structures Not Used as
Single- or Two-Family Dwellings and MGL Chapter 40A Section 6. The Applicant seeks to modify Special Permit No. 1986 -041 to
convert an accessory structure to a single-family residential use where the principal structure is used for professional office space (to
remain unchanged). The subject property is located at 3010 Route 6A, Barnstable, MA as shown on Assessor’s Map 279 as Parcel
021. It is located in the Residence F-2 (RF-2) Zoning District.
Chair Dewey assigns himself, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, and Manny Alves.
Attorney Marian Rose is representing and is joined by the applicant, Carrie Leonard. It is operating as office space currently.
Attorney Rose explains that the property has a long history, and the main structure was built as a residence in 1716. Today they will
be focused on the carriage house, which is well over 75 years old and has been used as storage space. It was a failed restaurant
Page 6 of 7 6
when the permit at issue was granted. Then the use was changed to professional office use. It is preexisting nonconforming as to lot
size, and the carriage house is preexisting nonconforming to setbacks. It is in a flood zone. The work proposed is to convert the
carriage house to a residential structure. This would not be allowed if they didn’t have a prior special permit, but the Building
Commissioner said the Board has the authority to modify the existing special permit to allow residential use. The use allowed by
right is a residential use, but it is complicated because there is no primary residence but rather a commercial use, it is not allowed by
right.
Attorney Rose says they need to bring it up to FEMA flood height. They have gone through OKH. The entry will have stairs and an
added covered shed roof facing away from Route 6A. On the front will be another entry. The other issue is that the permit from
1986 has a condition that says there will be no apartment use whatsoever. There is a tall attic area that used to be lived in—this is
what she thinks the Board was concerned about.
Back to the Board for questions. Manny Alves says on the last page of the prior decision, paragraph D reads the “new addition.”
Attorney Rose says there was the historic house and a more recent addition. The group discusses whether they could restrict the
apartment. Attorney Rose reiterates that the Building Commissioner said the existing special permit gives the Board the discretion to
modify a special permit. Since the only use in the district is residential, converting the barn from commercial to residential would be
within the Board’s discretion. Manny Alves says if they were to grant it, it would create two principal permitted structures on one
lot. They discuss whether that is allowed or whether there is a contradiction in her request. Attorney Rose suggests the Board could
condition this such that apartment use may be allowed in the carriage house but not in the main house.
Chair Dewey opens public comment. Jerry Desalvatare of 1100 Route 134 in Dennis is here on behalf of Cindy Brackett, Ms.
Elizabeth Grade, and Mr. Davis, who own the property north and west of this property. They are opposed to this becoming
residential because it is in their backyard, the setbacks are very small, and it is on wetlands. He is also concerned about it affecting
Crocker Lane.
Attorney Rose says the abutters he mentioned are not here opposing this. Carrie Leonard reached out to abutters about if they had
concerns and she did not hear back. The structure will not be getting closer to either of the setbacks. There will be limited impact.
Carrie Leonard says she has been in the building as a tenant since 2004, and purchased in 2012. When the previous owners did the
addition in 1986, it created an attic space that connects the original building to the addition. This continues to be used as an attic,
not an apartment. She is surprised to hear the abutters are opposed because this gentleman was at ConCom and said he was not
opposed. She reached out to neighbors after that and received no response. Her understanding was that by removing the provision,
they would be allowed by right. Having residential properties available is important to she and her husband.
Board discussion. They discuss whether to remove the condition about the apartment. A suggestion is made to remove the
restriction of no residence from the 1986 special permit. Manny Alves suggests striking just the apartment language.
Chair Dewey moves to close public comment. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
The group discusses whether they have the authority to create a new special permit that would allow for two principal permitt ed
uses. Attorney Rose believes when an existing special permit is involved, the Board has the discretion to do this. They discuss the
best way to move this forward.
Attorney Rose requests to continue. She says eventually they will come back for the strange conditions for the Barnstable House.
Manny Alves asks them to reach out to neighbors for clarifications as well.
Aaron Webb moves to continue to September 23, 2026. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Manny Alves, Aaron Webb
Nay: None
Appeal No. 2026-020 Barnstable House, LLC is continued to September 23, 2026.
Page 7 of 7 7
Board Elections
Chair, Vice Chair, Clerk
Manny Alves moves to reelect the current slate of officers. Herb Bodensiek seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves, Debra Dworkis, Larry Hurwitz
Nay: None
Correspondence
Zoning Amendment Notification Transmittal from Planning Board - 3 Proposed Zoning Amendments
Chair Dewey says this was discussed at Monday’s meeting, and anyone interested can watch it online.
Matters Not Reasonably Anticipated by the Chair
Chair Dewey asks the Board to continue thinking about zoning issues for the subcommittee.
Upcoming Hearings
August 26, 2026 (online), September 9, 2026 (online), September 23, 2026 (online)
Adjournment
Chair Dewey moves to adjourn. Paul Pinard seconds.
Vote:
Aye: Jake Dewey, Herb Bodensiek, Paul Pinard, Aaron Webb, Manny Alves, Debra Dworkis, Larry Hurwitz
Nay: None
Documents Used at this Meeting
• Document entitled “FY2027 40A Amendments”
• Appeal No. 2026-016 Tonelli application materials
• Appeal No. 2026-017 Castignetti application materials
• Appeal No. 2026-018 Lorusso application materials
• Staff Report for 2026-018
• Appeal No. 2026-019 Moore application materials
• Staff Report for 2026-019
• Appeal No. 2026-020 Barnstable House, LLC application materials
Respectfully submitted,
Genna Ziino, Administrative Assistant
Further detail may be obtained by viewing the video via the Barnstable Government Access Channel on demand at barnstable.gov