Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout0027 YORK TERRACE � — , a �" � �. a � � o � . � � �� ,. } . �.....� �1+.....__..-�-- .. -_++....T, .' ..,rrw�'Tw+�•r'.S^_"1 w..'�.Y+'„^e�.�'�C;:.*�^^.'r. r�r'p. .T.'.^«..w- ..n. -- y �^�"[?{'.^�! '..'!FA�... f, �-� -gor -ram {4F_ - F 4 I �.I F r 4 { L 1 I �Y prF; �I 4, 1 -� rs L __ _ J W- eT\C 01-c- 4t, 2 9 � � ► ,. � _ r - b � Q car 2 � r�, c .. � � � � �� f � � t TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION I1ap / Parcel - / TOVIN ;,t(= 6ARHs TABLeermit# � �6 2 9 Health Division �y � �o�/b�oz l /VO «cS se� %.� k�✓ tDate Issued /� /� a 6s . «�„ TT AM Q: 2� C7 Conservation Division Fee Tax Collector Ord dal/���� Treasurer %v �/� /0� DiVISiOd�SEP'HE� MUSTS INSTALLED IN COMPLIANY/7.3,F0 Planning Dept. Y=TITLE 6III— ENVIROMMMAL CODE ANO 'ONS, 11113 Date Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board TOWN REGULAMIffy Historic-OKH Preservation/Hyannis Project Street Address o2 7 1 D�K TE/�ief�C'.0 Village OSi�Gz✓ _ Owner �/FG� /"e � ���=�- Address oZ3�1ETL� Q�'�/f ©6 r� Telephone ,Of _ 76A' - 011��/ Permit Request oiz E"1</5TiA1e'�A/oc,25E l'44-cff 4'/ --.t, Gr/iNi��u!S , �6'vlo v� ���rrr./ti /lpowt Gt/� k���) Cv L,di�.t�� �[�� f/st�✓�JR.<f�U lyc7p t 70 ��'�VT Zbl�6' '46E) w ti Square feet:. st floor: existingAO00 proposed 2nd floor: existing ItI9 0 proposed Total new Valuation 1��O00•o Zoning District Flood Plain Groundwater Overlay Construction Type /gFe � Lot Size Grandfathered: ❑Yes ❑ No If yes, attach supporting documentation. Dwelling Type: Single Family U Two Family ❑ Multi-Family(#units) Age of Existing Structure Historic House: ❑Yes 2<0 On Old King's Highway: ❑Yes GJ4o Basement Type: 5fFull a,/C'rawl ❑Walkout ❑Other Basement Finished Area(sq.ft.) Basement Unfinished Area(sq.ft) 0 Number of Baths: Full: existing new Half: existing new Number of Bedrooms: existing new Total Room Count(not including baths): existing /Y new First Floor Room Count Heat Type and Fuel: O cbas ❑Oil ❑ Electric ❑Other Central Air: C7Yes ❑ No Fireplaces: Existing / New Existing wood/coal stove: ❑Yes ❑No Detached garage:Ua/existing ❑new size Pool:❑existing ❑new size Barn:❑existing ❑new size Attached garage:❑existing ❑new size Shed:❑existing ❑new size Other: Zoning Board of Appeals Authorization ❑ Appeal# Recorded❑ Commercial ❑Yes ❑No If yes, site plan review# Current Use Proposed Use BUILDER INFORMATION NamerCr rD�E i •,a /�ZE•c«% /d S ✓c Telephone Number %1- 4ZAe-�4A�!� Address k o�{05�o License# ©�� 7 Home Improvement Contractor# Worker's Compensations#; ��'3��(0�j10 00 ALL CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS RESULTING FROM THIS PROJECT WILL BE TAKEN TO C.�2t1��/�✓ � SIGNATURE DATE /_'0,11/`_1Oa FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PERMIT NO. DATE ISSUED MAP/PARCEL NO. - ADDRESS VILLAGE OWNER - ti DATE OF INSPECTION: FOUNDATION FRAME Stc U as oh (�ei v - f , INSULATION FIREPLACE ELECTRICAL: ROUGH .m , FINAL ' co PLUMBING: ROUGI ' . FINAL GAS: ROUG ; FINAL- , FINAL BUILDING 0 ad s N Q cs DATE CLOSED OUT t 'er ASSOCIATION PLAN NO. z s . t The Commonwealth of Massachusetts Inn Department of Industrial Accidents 600 Washington Street Boston,Mass. 02111 Workers' Com ensation Insurance Affidavit name: dvtl/65 TT/ location: X otty ❑ I am a homeowner performing all work myself. ❑ I am a sole pr ri Aor and have no one workiu in any capacity er rovidin workers'co ensation for my employees working on this job. Iam an em to P g mP.....:.:. :::::..::::.::..:::.::::::::.::::::::::::...........:::.;.>::.:.:::::.:::.:.:::.::::::::::..:::::::::::::::.::::::::::.::::::::::..:::.::::::::::::::::::.;:. .......... ::::::::::::..... :::>:: r ✓1 ..;::::.: ..:::.::.:::....... .:::.::.::::::.::::.::::::.:::. . ..... ...... .........................................::: m an :name a�a ress x hn 1 .........:.::.....................: Cl• am X .�f . . insurance co;:;:::> ❑ I am a sole proprietor, general contractor, or homeowner(circle one and have hired the contractors listed below who have the following s compensation polices: : :::::::::::::....:: . : : ::::::)``Y::i:�1:�1'r:�:��:4iil�::�'}i:ii:;i:;:;:;i::i�i;:�:j�i:<;i::..<::::::::;`s::::::::j::j::::i:::�'?iii'is4:�i : :��:'::�'r::j:>�Yii:`:ii;:i�iii::;�)::'isis�i:�i::y;::�'ii:-:�:�:�>i:�ii::�?:v:•ii::•:i?::•:::::::::::::::::::•...........:,:.,.: ;ii:;::iii:�ii:•i:4i:'.:}i:^i:!;. .: ..... ... .. .}i: coin an name;>::;;:<::::<: >?:<:: »:::::>::::>..... ................ ne ..........:::::::::::::::::.::::::::::::::::::::............................ i� ........................::.................:::::.�::::::::::::::.�.: ...........................:... :. uR Ie�ncance / .. . • ;:names::::::;:::>::>:;:::::>::<:::::>:::::>»::::»>::::>:>:::::;>;:;::;>::?:>:::;:>:: .::._.: .. ........ ..........................:::::::::::::::::: :::::::::::::' 'hen ;#; ij i;iiii%i si%;i:`;:%; %as2 '::`?`ii> :::: :.:.11ev:: '`i�cance� :::::. 0 Fafiure to aecare coverage a,required under Section 25A of MGL ls2 can lead to the imposition of criminal penalties of a fine up to 51,M o0 and/or one years,imprisonment as well as civil penalties in the form of a STOP WORK ORDER and a fine of S100.00 a day against me. I understand that a i copy of this statement may be forwarded to the Office of Investigations of the DIA for coverage verification. I do hereby certify a pains an pe allies of perjury that the information provided above is true and correct signature Date /0 � Print name. Phone# official use only do not write in this area to be completed by city or town official permit/license# ❑fig Department city or town: QLicensing Board response l9 required ❑Selectmen's Office ❑checkif immediate q ❑Health Department contact person: phone#; ❑Other (revised 9/95 PJA) Information and Instructions Massachusetts General Laws chapter 152 section 25 requires all employers to provide workers' compensation for their employees. As quoted from the"law", an employee is defined as every person in the service of another under any contract of hire, express or implied, oral or written. An employer is defined as an individual, partnership, association, corporation or other legal entity, or any two or more of the foregoing engaged in a joint enterprise, and including the legal representatives of a deceased employer, or the receiver or trustee of an individual, partnership, association or other legal entity, employing employees. However the owner of a dwelling house having not more than three apartments and who resides therein, or the occupant of the dwelling house of another who employs persons to do maintenance, construction or repair work on such dwelling house or on the grounds or building appurtenant thereto shall not because of such employment be deemed to be an employer. MGL chapter 152 section 25 also states that every state or local licensing agency shall withhold the issuance or renewal of a license or permit to operate a business or to construct buildings in the commonwealth for any applicant who has not produced acceptable evidence of compliance with the insurance coverage required. Additionally,neither the commonwealth nor any of its political subdivisions shall enter into any contract for the performance of public work until acceptable evidence of compliance with the insurance requirements of this chapter have been presented to the contracting authority. Applicants Please fill in the workers' compensation affidavit completely,by checking the box that applies to your situation and supplying company names, address and phone numbers along with a certificate of insurance as all affidavits may be submitted to the Department of Industrial Accidents for confirmation of insurance coverage. Also be sure to sign and date the affidavit. The affidavit should be returned to the city or town that the application for the permit or license is being requested, not the Department of Industrial Accidents. Should you have any questions regarding the"law"or if you are required to obtain a workers' compensation policy,please call the Department at the number listed below. City or Towns Please be sure that the affidavit is complete and printed legibly. The Department has provided a space at the bottom of the affidavit for you to fill out in the event the Office of Investigations has to contact you regarding the applicant. Please be sure to fill in the permit/license number which will be used as a reference number. The affidavits may be retuned io the Department by mail or.FAX unless other arrangements have been made. The Office of Investigations would like to thank you in advance for you cooperation and should you have any questions. please do not hesitate to give us a call. VON The Department's address,telephone and fax number: The Commonwealth Of Massachusetts Department of Industrial Accidents Office of Imlesduadons 600 Washington Street Boston, Ma. 02111 fax#: (617) 727-7749 phone#: (617) 727-4900 ext. 406, 409 or 375 oFt►�r The Town of Barnstable . ., nexNsiAsi.e. g Regulatory Services `b i659' •`0 Thomas F. Geiler, Director QED MA'f Building Division Elbert Ulshoeffer, Building Commissioner 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 i Permit no. Date AFFIDAVIT HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR LAW SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT APPLICATION MGL c. 142A requires that the"reconstruction,alterations,renovation,repair,modernization,conversion, improvement,removal,demolition,or construction of an addition to any pre-existing owner-occupied building containing at least one but not more than four dwelling units or to structures which are adjacent to such residence or building be done by registered contractors,with certain exceptions,along with other requirements. e Estimated Cost / Type of Work: Address of Work: Owner's Name: Date of Application: , I hereby certify that: Registration is not required for the following reason(s): ❑Work excluded by law ❑Job Under$1,000 []Building not owner-occupied ❑Owner pulling own permit Notice is hereby given that: OWNERS PULLING THEIR OWN PERMIT OR DEALING WITH UNREGISTERED ACCESS CONTRACTORS ARBITRPLICABLE HOME IMPROVEMENT WORK DO NOT ATION PROGRAM R GUARANTY FUND UNDER MGL cc..142A. ACCESS TO SIGNED UNDER PENALTIES OF PERJURY I hereby apply for a permit as the agent of the owner: 02 /mac--rye %Ve777 Z).,�y� Date Contractor Name Registration No. OR Date Owner's Name g1orms:Affidav RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMIT FEES APPLICATION FEE New Buildings,Additions $50.00 Alterations/Renovations $25.00 Building Permit Amendment $25.00 FEE VALUE WORKSHEET NEW LIVING SPACE square feet x$96/sq.foot= x.0031= plus from below(if applicable) ALTERATIONS/RENOVATIONS OF EXISTING SPACE C� G square feet x$64/sq.foot= t9 D O x.0031= plus from below(if applicable) ACCESSORY STRUCTURE>120 sq.ft. >120 sf-500 sf $ 35.00 >500 sf-750 sf 50.00 >750 sf- 1000 sf 75.00 >1000 sf- 1500 sf 100.00 >1500 sf-Same as new building permit: square feet x$96/sq.foot= x .0031= STAND ALONE PERMITS Open Porch x$30.00= (number) Deck x$30.00= (number) Fireplace/Chimney x$25.00= (number) Inground Swimming Pool $60.00 Above Ground Swimming Pool $25.00 Relocation/Moving $150.00 (plus above if applicable) Permit Fee projcost amvazaru i�y�fu��r 4 CTI s'. BOARD OF BUILDING REGULATIONS ( ,License: CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR Number: CS 050457 Expires: 04/19/2004 Tr.no: 19942 Restricted: 00 PETER M POMETTI PO BOX 2056 � COTUIT, MA 02635 Administrator �lpp ze;CJomvrrtaruaea� a i u�aeCla . Board of Building Regulations and Siandards r HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR Registration: 109606 Expiration: 9/21/2004 Type: Private Corporation A I ENTERPRISES iNC. PETER POMETTI 140 RIVER RD COTUIT, MA 0.2635 .Admiq.;q�atnr ;A . M. . .��C�: M.�7,"'L'•f .r • «. s.• ..... -.... _y,.a.y.—:• .i...e1. ♦�",.3 +a ,�44 �Ir;» ..•+C.i".C7+."'•.rw-.'!;rn�.. —�. _ ... Y" d� ppF}HE'O"1' The Town of Barnstable 9ARNSrA9LE. Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services 9 _MASS. �'PrFO MPy� Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA'02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 PLAN REVIEW Owner: Tj¢C�� L�/�M/ L Map/Parcel: /4/a Project Address: 97 162K -7-Ka- `45Trz rc.. Builder: l T3z re /moo W z-- ? -r The following items were noted on reviewing: i r g Reviewed by: Rr Date: q:building:fonns:review fir.. ... Iva �F \ Daniel E. Braman. P.E. n ' 199 Harbor Point Rd Gumnwquid MA 02637-0361 +�c.. K%._-CEc7L.:. c�t�Spc1.lisCes �� t.. -DAL IS sR., (,L--z 4c) _ N N 2 � SS x t2.-t5 x I .cpl � OF _ .. V 4 uS7=- 44-cp 2 _o3 CD LQd ac��s'e�a� 2.• �.x tvti LPL. Q►��Z�c �_ 5 ah � tt . .. CL* x J� C'k C>r -. 413x4`i;. tS5� Sul �- ST��- a tA G i-k-Gnu de kc-L6, koa ds ' - �Zv�.q�ty�cer' 77/ 9 Ow rer- t S 40 ur �Onl� t�L • ..... Remember Lujean Printing for all your printing needs!. 428-8700 0 4507 Falmouth Road (Route 28),Cotuit JA (.4 3 — SS TUE 1 6 25 c0L- 0N I AL LAND BUR '.-* E: Y I NG R _ 0 1 v � � fw Cie b+�b gK,:.�,�•��43g�..na►��:.......N....._...Scal,�= t'=_4�'bay=...��� _�Ct,..�°.l.�.$.. ..._._....... 0 11bt rs IOC 1 14• 63'± _ No. 27 _ S 2 story dwellin06 g o PCCC garage h>r 24 55' f3 God' 12. � • .._.......,....._..._`...-.__'...._...__,............,.:ytt4_........�.a.:..............:..,.__..__c...._..__.rv_-�.o.,...=..a_�..�.._.___......_.cx.c,eicr.......,._.......___gin:_.... .-a. - ---' - -I I ;'1) ,Clrkyrj}&) 1 I 5�d.1i�.•�•*.'N�•1�r.�r�✓i 4'�•NI ir'A,A,JF.Iitl/ I�.������ '4.�1eY�ti�1 � i �m 1�1I.��. il'�+!' �y�f 1 I �. i;,194. �lG���y �iV�'•:.d'd �ei1., ��l �p{.�1i5 `A- d �J Y.hy.�• n7nnt'8�1�.� tl�u.��'•.Z�.• �j..0.t�1L• W/���p�'i� +) "'COX,.Ui'tii.rAX,'��� t,?'¢:' �u�'j�;'.f�:���;�1✓� M1 6.,Q':� � ��, (�iP��lll1. �� �' �' sr woe,47cAa ;w-r) or, rkwr T The Loca4 •(. wbe" can w1lm sp heal atvAj, btmenstorvAL mQuiRectletiCs. this pLan was rx)c rrobe pop, pzcopbu,)C PIAMVMS o12 #gyp use to Ppe aa►pUlq 6W6 . �� �paor wai���1 on Op Ppopewv COLOD 1&L um 6u '7 "Stony, mul buo; o -er, pyres oa cotwicoupArtor9 cmv » acccwmtsYeb 20 hN30V44Z OMV By do a MPArE tnSCW "XM SUgVe V p( or)e 6I162d-7Is6 {�►x 6l?8z6-4623 JAN — 3 — $ 3 TUE 1 1 215 Cn LOt•a I AL LAND SUR '•:' EY I NG P _ 1_l i a►pp�fca►hC:�zt�1�1. #2,:. . 14Y. .44142011e�,....... ....._......_.... 'l1.�r�o=.._. r °�.l ....._ beeb • o�.'t43�Q..rJa►Ci�.:......,N....._._.SCx4.a: 1`611 =_4.4�.bzsr�Z...L�Fc Q�..�al�. ..........._._._..... IDS 14,11"cl"11,10 I � log is 14. v --63"-`---- No. 27 ..� c� 2 story dwelling ' o garage 4 9 /5 = Ln 24 55 !At 13 Got 12 LOCUS ltes In Alood Zone " ; a t cCMtFV tbar thts fw �n pPeP ►�FOP,cT "LE, S ,i &-=rzlSh' the bcMLLIM 0xxv" hworn %es * f'aL to &Sp�cta► rle- �ML A00611AZAi26 a POP,016- +��azn a� Cw?Q r)try or-: os'::Gnv 1 Ltd +° PJWL with a»erromve bam op: 8. 19 .85 Tt ,. $r vtv 1pcActon 01?the &cMl lt-) boes e confol2w co Vx 10CAL zMIM svilAtos to Errcc when c0t,)5cMkxzb wtrh tespecew u hoauvvcAj, btmEnstotlaL IWCK l ig wet-,cs. tilts pLan WAS noc nvos pop- PAr:�copbu-)q puapo$es 012 M2 use ul) p 66ab 6P-scatpuons_ wairtcarlon OF Ppopet� co o Owe dtmenstons, auAbwV opp.ecs, fps lAnb SMwvM company,M, 012 LotcoMp"Partorn oily 1.7*- avcc007Mt lxb 269hM V4gzsc tviovem CMN-023" � c�nL� �Y d►n accupz� mstvaumEr�szt�Y pbon�big s26-z� �c 6�7 azS-,asz� e 1 � too c J 1 i Assessor's office(1st Floor): v �s Assessor's map and lot number /1 /S ° p Leo`SYMAI *THE t0``. Board of Health(3rd floor): a�� �(;Q Sewage Permit number % VQR® s1l�]e��,. Beaa9T Engineering Department(3rd floor)` 71®W aL.0 WAS& House number ' e Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO - ��,1�11( WtiWL(hI Gl.C1 Z _ TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION Is - 19 _ TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: Location 2-� ��2/< �E�P/L- C� S��L�/LG�" i` �'-� a T Proposed Use J m/ t"&Ze r (?L' Zoning District Fire District ��������L-� S Name of Owner W 41?L V—, Q Address Name of Builder 0 C(/. /f 09065 Address Name of Architect Address Number of Rooms Foundation Exterior Roofing Floors Interior Heating Plumbing Fireplace Approximate Cost z0 d o- O Area Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable re gar in the above construction. Name ,t'F�/•-jc C���. . Construction Supervisor's License GARDNER, WALTER , r•. - j No 33215 Permit For BUILD SWIMMING POOL Accessory to Dwelling M} Location 27 York Terrace Osterville r: Owner Walter Gardner Type of Construction`-- :Concrete' Plot Lot Permit Granted September 15, 19 8.9 Date of Inspection 19 Date Completed_ 19 a •e" Gay.r� � _ .,- r. Rco'�� ' Michael J. Gardner, 'Builder 37 Wintergreen Circle Osterville, MA 02655 (508) 428-4422 Walter Gardner 27 Tork Terrace Osterville, Ma . 02655 Convert existing garage into cabanna/playroom, with a bathroom and bar sink. All new interior petitions will be framed with 2x4" studs . Existing rafters 2x6" . Existing floor joists 2x8" . Install new collar ties in upper two thirds, using 2x6"ceiling joists . All ceilings will be strapped for sheetrock. Sheetrock will be 2" drywall which will be taped . Insulation will be kraft faced, and proper R values will be applied as to pass all building codes . All carpeted areas will have a new sub floor installed. Stairs will be finished for carpeting. Garage walls will not be insulated or sheetrocked. yi _ Assessor's office(1st Floor): /� ---_�C SYSTEM �°�US Assessor's map and lot number —13 6 L/ �;�� Board of Health(3rd floor): I OTH MILE 5 .� ��� ,� �� � �a.c®� ram, Sewage Permit number BAUSTAMLL I Engineering Department(3rd floor): _ TG*WN REGULATIONS +oo M c House number �0 Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 �o MAI b' APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR L p11 ' APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO Uf LP(7�fV S �'� fp f lu 7 �90ol � 4'll Wool TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION ( (3 19 ?O i TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the followiing/ information: Location 1 toX RVVu�( ocl' V(fl Proposed Use %0^ P1 I Vt A Zoning Districts Fire District Name of Owner ��' yr Address p ,,//��-- I e, // Name of Builder�` 6,11W Address 3� �V(cA�e65d�>°dl Cf(/. L/`� ��1VG`"�' Name of Architect Address Number of Rooms Foundation 10(x a Exterior C 1(4,p����J Roofing ¢�*1 C� u� _Floors C u�'•� 1 T �` Intrior T �� Heating 4, C/ht G Plumbing J � Fireplace N( Approximate Cost IF 6R I A C AW6 Area Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee ��'✓ 5 ,p A-(��C � p�oF pia OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable`regarding the1 bove construction. Name ©g1ZfI Construction Supervisor's License GARDNER, WALTER i 34092 Renovation/ Install Bathroom Permit For Single Family Dwelling Location 27 York Terrace Osterville Walter Gardner r Owner - _ - Type of Construction Frame Plot Lot Permit Granted December .3 ,- 19 90 Date of Inspection 8- 1 19 Date Completed 19 r" ., �• OrODIf.�'IAOt Rs,ita:_-T C IRECTION TO J09: �••�- •,—— _ / - _-- -Y-, -/�_ - -" Oo j� r f:-_.. /� i a X�(L 3L X I DEPTHS: TO: �_ V ( mil/ ,!^�- , �, �• i Ian:a+e:--40AiC: W l+r p r'.. Gkt TLwu Oi`CTTfttVILt; . + A N Y 20 fVP . NTA�fdS • I • CMACRY GALLON! 1• 0 (� {�. a FILTER TYPE 'D r rp R=Jd O ' 0'O S W IF• W T tG E�'LKI. �.� T. PAL& SWIM OUI:YeS�GR`& • " U T Z ST$ I ROE CAD•MASnPEE.MA,OMQ l'uNDENWATEi WNW -VOLTS:Il a WATTS Z°S - NASHUA N.H. PLANTCTL `IIT..TilcM1 DY o�.•�K., 595.77Ta '•L oESIGNHi RRFAM• - ^ ,G txurt: YrS 4oa � AtA o % _ ,, E�IIiP ENTDpNCE •I1.sgMMEI• R ' I&.MAIN ORAIW. • - / M NELSON OE®}1EI.T: NO,OF JETS:�- �.1 L.r +Ih�uO- �f. ONA•k . o VIi�A-Ii7ti �1~10 16 MARCIFE r .o •. t.�t lr / S•eaAr ' �- F,eef LLrTCAntt'�✓Ay 1a AOUA SVA�S:(A CLFAN60 fL ,tv7nlj� F (. QARSeD k S l NM �,o� `A o- r Me IT.uaowrurO$ w ew �XTCA eew l TlF .go4T TYIHC +tY raa. 19.ELECT e \, �,LA�e 20.TESi1aT: it.eRusH a PGLE \ MAIu DeA of . r 'R•i:tfo Q/�Ot tr a7oA_ aZ.UPe)6IWAlE1 VAC: �+ 1 2&NOW FOR VAC: ,t��{p�, 'DFM Ht+ t°' 9 L Dc[? r"t'c O rf L.I.•Ovr 01 Re RA A+ 7 GY"\' `F. �. 5"4 25,FENSPA E '51 OWN01 to omNG Rocil t S < II ry VANE 27. a xt� 9" A47iLe^ Dex 2&LANDSCAPING: •ty ATH•cf A 6Ao NOR t • 29..ADDITIO AL PROVISION& r. goo Y� we' \ > - ::.'' l.IMl so' X Ai '-: ADD17he..k 1 ly.. MCAT lil .. EC at. lOLe excdej. �. � la► L' �, k' SNDE>D!A•Dr A•T' t✓t•7 n -'- '— - GAR E j& it FDct Ter of, '$+Eyf oPTo.aL f e16T{C.eP V 4/ tky�F, Klnwtn ar. a L �.+- '�I"• OVT e a ;� �`Ov O 1t uN� YLIDe'.NoeK'Vp • fI,' f:•.'Sr t. y J7. ♦ 9i a wf •s AVro oat CleYf..ne A 77- >p AyvAeO �E -Or" O•-7fc sa 4, QtAD 'h ?i lrvm WITU twill, si. A[rr9S T• FXfct� .. .. Low BFRcA 4 e2 � oB )IrP puTTFTc. - 12 aC *:;+� WALTE11 .. 3a Ll •• T�►11N �� / k,' ' .. I •' 2.r . :^,`.. • L— t CAPE COO NASHUA N.H. TiAT F•t. . Tl 'r�.--- O OM A77•Tr70 RG7)595-rna 4-1 EviTt(;RFFN'• - i •t si •• Vfi .. • (b ® : ' . .. v" •t %/,y- TO OWNER APPROXIMATE EELEVATION'OF. I < POOL ON DAY OF EXCAVATION POOL AREA 70 BE FENCED BY 6VMFA PEA TES TO E QT . - 1; _ •• \ O P fTDNIIl ORDINANCE. NG AND SEELF LLAATaeiG ' DO NOT TURN ON POOL lgHf (� WHEN FOOL IS E)AFM '...,.a.....a Nome McIrt QME .• Ex17NC wa Drc '. IF "G �, -----..+-. ......�...• � V000 ck Mew THE EXECUTIVE rootMI wrtSULTAM&1 Yt19 EwERIEfcE•J ORIENTAL POL 1YRIwESIAN POOLS.MWATER FALOOL ARaL.00. R®oaNxDEM SPO,ALTt `A� FOR ' "y�Teo""`� NAME e e C ... xU. ..`-�5 .`--•� •w �\ TIT°°u°TI 7 ORK E y:o- StS`o ....:.2' y �'a., c G7 Led b the Tradition �R CcnSui 6 Tnp t r.-.-NR i•1 rw".i.;.i .�.=�`--� 'mot hftacl lends '!IOL4IIQ 0. LlBOn of r' Cm l A PHONEB. gbL-'m 3 •N�r•4 •is•.'.: �taign Assoc. ]GtD. LOT t3 silt L t Store aft 7J 9�P8 avuba 1 ♦ (a7GOP ;.VJAII SEGTKtu 1•. .......r.w. �r. �+' 1 BLIIdIRg SIfIC0 19, 1Tf� CUS'TCMER•SSIGNATURE . ,.. e S rc.. eeeTe •• ••� \ t WATERFALLS.BRIDGES WOOD D WORK ST E� E Ovv7l BY S UF�se� DATE S�2L :S9 GiK BY oi- fi t> Assessor p ...s ma and lot number � !.?:d..,h...�c�� '� ' ypi T M E TO` y- 3fl Sewage ;Permit number ..........�. .......... ...................... � C4YiA'(�`'R' �3�t�1 Z DAHd9TADLE, i sQ'`i�.J'U a House number .............. ..... �gw�li � �O S 9 O 3 • 0� ISOAROo�tu� �� � �6OR0'.� TOWN OF BARNS ��A" I L��E- BVILDINS INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO ..........KP:4V S � .. �J// TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION ..............lil1.:S?SLA'.. . .Flt! ..7..fn..:e................................................................... !.!. \..L............................19.. y TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: Location ... ...... ............... .. .�.`.�..c,J.:..�.!.e ............................................. ProposedUse ....... L..............!�'`�...!•...4.............. S ................................................................... Zoning District ............::\. . ...................................................Fire District ... .4F .►1..����...�w� (� .7:4K..1/..f�� )Oo . A3ox C) �oy ,� �- t a� �.z err .� its C �, Name of Owner ` Address ..........:11:............................. ........6�..... ..... ..................!�l t'1. �Z....$0................................�.E Name of Builder ....u!'r.v.- �_ G.`t z`7. L.`.(........Address ...74...�. 1...�� ��v 101�v-°t s'���� O�c►s� Name of Architect ... �.`....k1�. A.C—Address ...7 d..Y t!l.l..... 0 S?t e r Number of Rooms ....A. .A ..tStn,...... !M v................Foundotion ..... ...��°t ��................ �K.� !.�.......`................. ..... . ...... Exterior �' ?. Z 4h t... ..U.+:^..�-....................Roofing ..............v..... ........ .. �.... . .............................. ................ ........... Floors .......... .v... .............................................................Interior F:04 `v.: .� .1................ ..... ........................................... ? Heating ...!..... A' .......... .....4!!Ak..........................Plumbing ..........Adt......4b.^'.. .......6.!�-- Fireplace .......... ..... .............................Approximate. Cost ....... ...:l. � ........... .............. Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board -----------_ _______19_______.- Area0`!'..... ±.�..1......... Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Feed....... SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF BOARD OF HEALTH OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regarding the above construction. pp NameC.... 1................ Construction Supervisor's License U P..9116..E.7........ GREGORY, DAVID T. ` 26323 Mom ADDITION. .............::.. Permit for .................................... Single Family Dwelling Location' .. .................................................ot 15, 27 York Terrace . ........ Osterville Dwner ...David T. .Gregory Type of Construction ...Frame............................. P_ ........................ ....... ..: ......................... plot ........................ Lot ........................ `. ')ermit Granted ..,• ri,l 23 � ` ' 84 A; -ite of Inspection ..................:......19, ;Ire Completed .................�. ...,........`.19' z � r � \, /� '- ` � \V� � (� U..� �� ����� � 1( 1 �. 1 \ � 1 ' , Engineering Dept. (3rd floor) Map 14/0 Parcel /,j 6 66 / Permit# House# :2 7� 3 Date Issued I Board of Health(3rd floor)(8:15 -9:30/1:00-4:36) ?'� .��Fee Conservation Office(4th floor)(8:30-9:30/1:00-2:00) 5 Planning Dept. (1st floor/School Admin. Bldg.) SEPTIC SYS E ST BE Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 INSTALLED ANCE WIT ' ENVIRDNME • • E AND TOWN OF BARNSTABLE TOYIN RS 'S Building Permit Application Project Street Address �JL2 E Village Owner _ d �� Address Telephone Permit Request 6mel-e- ` d First Floor square feet Second Floor - square feet Construction Type [• /"-1*-1 F� Estimated Project Cost $ a 10 ro0- Zoning District Flood Plain Water Protection Lot Size Grandfathered ❑Yes ❑No Dwelling Type: Single Family &------Two Family ❑ Multi-Family(#units) Age of Existing Structure 4�9 t Historic House ❑Yes la< On Old King's Highway ❑Yes 5,TO---- �I Basement Type: CUOR ❑Crawl ❑Walkout ❑Other Basement Finished Area(sq.ft.) Basement Unfinished Area(sq.ft) Number of Baths: Full: Existing New Half: Existing New No. of Bedrooms: Existing New — Total Room Count(not including baths): Existing New First Floor Room Count Heat Type and Fuel: ❑Gas it ❑Electric ❑Other Central Air ❑Yes ❑No Fireplaces: Existing 2New Existing wood/coal stove ❑Yes ❑No Garage: ❑Detached(size) z Z k Z 2 Other Detached Structures: ❑Pool(size) *V ZoX Z o f ❑Attached(size) ❑Barn(size) ❑None ❑Shed(size) ❑Other(size) Zoning Board of Appeals Authorization ❑ Appeal# Recorded❑ Commercial ❑Yes 10 If yes, site plan review# Current Use Proposed Use Bu' der Information NameJCL4F� _ Telephone Number 0-Ods-- Addre_ss�-�//j,� , "1 - 711- License# /7 7 gm y Home Improvement Contractor# 6 0357p- Worker's Compensation# 7V F TrWIM NEW CONSTRUCTION OR ADDITIONS REQUIRE A SITE PLAN(AS BUILT)SHOWING EXISTING,AS WELL AS PROPOSED STRUCTURES ON THE LOT. ALL CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS RESULTING FROM THIS PROJECT WILL BETAKEN TO Q/Z SIGNATUR�jEMIT DATE BUILDING DENIED FOR TIOLLOWING REASON(S) i 1 UL- FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PERMIT NO. Q DATE ISSUED MAP/PARCEL NO. ADDRESS VILLAGE OWNER DATE OF INSPECTION: FOUNDATION FRAME INSULATION FIREPLACE ELECTRICAL: ROUGH FINAL k PLUMBING: RQUGH FINAL GAS: ` CQUGH FINAL FINAL BUILDIN , •� _ DATE CLOSED OVT•. ASSOCIATION PLAN NO: °*VE 1, The Town of Barnstable KAM 9qp 1 Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services 'Eo► ► Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-790-6227 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner For office use only Permit no. Date AFFIDAVIT HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR LAW SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT APPLICATION MGL c. 142A requires that the "reconstruction, alterations, renovation, repair, modernization, conversion, improvement, removal, demolition, or construction of an addition to any pre-existing owner occupied building containing at least one but not more than four dwelling units or to structures which are adjacent to such residence or building be done by registered contractors, with certain exceptions,along with other requirements. c qq b Type of Work: Est.Cost rf,S D Address of Work: a / k1k Owner's NamerJU1,,2a*-. /n,/;,� Date of Permit Application: •I hereby certify that: Registration is not required for the following reason(s): Work excluded by law Job under$1,000. Building not owner-occupied Owner pulling own permit Notice is hereby given that: OWNERS PULLING THEIR OWN PERMIT OR DEALING WITH UNREGISTERED CONTRACTORS FOR APPLICABLE HOME IMPROVEMENT WORK DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE ARBITRATION PROGRAM OR GUARANTY FUND UNDER MGL c. 142A SIGNED UNDER PENALTIES OF PERJURY I hereby apply for a perm' as the agent of the owner: Date Contractor Name Registration No. OR /7 Date Owner's Name The Commonwealth of Afassachusctts &,partntent of Industrial Accidents A if Office 0111yestigotloffs 600 If'ashinhtun Street Bastoit.Alaas. 02111 ' Workers' Compensation Insurance Atrdavit 'tse PRINT�Ie� 1� �"�'�~'—..._-�._-._--r•---��_ artiliER Plc information':' _•. b - rir�• ` _ ` nhone it I am a homeowner performing all work myself. I am a sole proprietor and have no one working, in any capacity [� I am an emplover providing workers* corn;3ensation for my employees working on this job. • 7� cnnttt•tns name: P�14 co C- ttlrlrccc � 1 1a />' A It) cit. ni S ! l/1 U A O�f���"' nhnnc f�• af? yD (:)Of aS: r, tnmmitce en AR_l_I )ID:;� Cj I am a sole proprietor. general contractor. or homeowner(circle otte) and have hired the contractors listed below who have the following workers' compensation polices: atlrlretc• .._ Cltt•• DI1nflC�' Rniict�>'• tncrrr:tnrr rn. _•• __ �_ _�r�.`:r�� iT"f!��w• '�.l'►•t•�• ••�•�•�• �� coninnn%, nntnc• _. arltf rc�c� rite phone 0- insurance 0- insur-ince co. oli •!t . Attach additional sheet if necessary; .%r,;,7-;: '''= :t: "'�' '�'•''�'" Failure to secure cttvcraCc:ts required under Section ZSA of 111GL 152 can lead to the imposition of criminal penalties of a fine up to SI•500.00 andiur une dears'imprisonment as well as cisil penalties in the form of a STOP WORK ORDER and a fine of S100.00 a dap against me. I understand that n copy of this statement may be funt•arded to the Office of Inscstirations of the DIA for coserare seriflea[ion. l do herchy cc r trader the pair and penalties ofJ'.;t Jun•that the information provided above is true and ccorreect 1. Print name Phone is � d� official use onh do not��rite in this area to be c,mfacted by tits or town 0MCi2l city or rotors permit/license 1t r•1tluilding Department CLicensint;Board check irimrnediatc response is required QSelcet s Orrice _ ired �ticalth Department t �. phone#: nUther. i . contact person: 1 J' 0,/ aooar/cuaPtla ; BOARD OF BUILDING REGULATJONS '{ License;`CONSTRUCTION-SVpgRVISOR Numbe S\ 043556 I� F- - Tr.no: ,,5485 d1To: 00 • .) -- SQTT;E CROS - y` ,rj %i �j•. 6 SBY CIR OSTERVILLE, MA 02 55 - Admtn4tra�gr: .: , 6SFii%s'Y n :,�'�++r^a•ti•a+a t r ,yz -. ,3 '' , �i "�oix�no�uc o�✓�a!aaaaa/e�raelA; S��� �•'��iis�.�'�4nt'�r�.b r ..0�y,'x�.a7 ,,F'f4l���hj "-HON IMPROVEMENT44CONTRACTOR��'x { ,�'� � �Registratlonl�Zf03582��' � ra �TypeDBAs EtX ration�� 07/09/00 + _ ��k�it�^t�G i ���R t� � a,. -rr b ?' P KvIA, 63CROSBYaBUILDERS cot E. CrosbY 151%, ,IMAIN�ST"UNIT r —ADMINISTRATOR> �qxtt''` r 4�;A!" ',dry tr, Of$t@'V�I�t1�BrMA;p0�2655* +•f,,'+ �,y,�' s 1 - f The Town of Barnstable Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner May 27, 1998 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: Our records reflect that the pool and apron at 27=York Terrace,_Osterv_ille-were constructed in conjunction with a valid building permit on September 15, 1989. It is the opinion of this office that the pool and deck, which were shown as located now,should have been ten feet from the property line. The State Zoning Act 40a allows grandfathered status to construction built in conjunction with a valid building permit but possibly in error if six years have passed. The result is that this structure,as built, is in compliance with zoning. Sincerely, Ralph M. Crossen Building Commissioner RMC/km OS/2t3/98 16:.35 $978 3415 9488. S'••;G -WSJCLAW OFFICE' } .; 123012 iKe �ool� �tiaiGDf�l�s ,i 27, Ib �1/��"C".'1��I� �Q - Ir< f t f•�-' 1- a fl � ({({ i i t' .r r. i� ::ii A`. 3. , Aft itv 9 �y r r fE ° f AST it ° ,h OF • . 'fir i, fV[— ` 9�i �� �� t }a i¢..b.r •i :• e, r° f, t r r y SALTER w I hereby certify that this plan has been prepared for Attlr Charles'A Ge➢ingis The dwelling shown hereon doe"s not f�ll,tnz �,fit, ,' ' a special F.E.MA Ilood h d s; a pe . . szar ':area th,an { ' effective Batt:of'7-2-92 and the Iocatlfln'of dwelling does confi)rm to the local-z®eaeaa�At y ��+e��s. �T1�/EO O11>T p,L�gi in effect at the time of construction,)With respec3 horizontal dimensianal.requirerhents 'The pool deck cneronches in the 10 R sideyard req a# aneni t� Plan wa notmade Ibt retord)ngipuc ®Res of fog lade , in recotainb decd &scriptions Vern Gatton building locations, property hneidtmensions.afen!ces, a` or lot configuration may be accomplished only b�r,ant .- accurate instrument survey which may reflect;. f r Low:; ' L 4 �c,t.`/ /S9G different information than what-is sho p hereon ,?. `f ' f �<r+ }, BA�C�� I-orTnolt l;a�;r pt,,r1wses'only r ,i � #• .�.�6�.�'i��.2� .•G�t*✓O Sue% a� CA, h MAy n',{`��. h Co c% '14 - 7 �J��.�G. a ss 90BRU1dkR P>,r•nnis Fomily Reyt ty Trust ' �+ + ` T e r- i� �f f r• ifrla: Wtq � i 4 1.I.EQ. i e-� • �• J�bola c�y�it? ! t o- 1 HAt to A� GartJrler arul '. e a ISa�Z-k - YewROUtfr t6Y: RieirerJ E T'.}BrooPi�,rFSr �'r(oitctee� � t of l-� � f �• / Mar ir ;cJA ' (� L!!1 r ------------------- Syd�,gd �• c i,,fff} 3 � �.1 wit.•.1. .y}..:a,,. } 71.' HUD-1 (3-86) RESPA, N8 cr i!Fa if f 1 4 I�. :Jis K }F•J F / ss .i r, M s ?rw. r Y 1 _L 05/26/98 16:34 V978 ,345 94F88 1'� �• '{G &R:LA�P OFFICE, � f�010 42. The Buyer acknowledges that he has t.had the •house > poo1�• and Premises inspected,',and :thatr he,: is ;folly. satisfied with the condition of. the,same: a .. ' .y "{' ... ,,. •r i� :„t ,�'.. ( ail P f 4 y'rT t 05/26/98 lei:35 %V9 i 6 345 9488 G.W&W LAW OFF'I'CE' Q 011 t u�vF�tJVr/J•IJ t_eV—tJJ�I .:10 rJ<EL13 CTF#-14f_i394 ' quit. WALTRII.A'0A1111NhR and ►fARY U4:( Aftt►1dltR, htisbnnd.And stile,ne'fenalttn by the nitrlrety, loch of 27 Ymk'Yerr/1eo. 11�11rtn1+to((asiervtefel {I{aigi'vetnble County,ale"adweeu■ 02fi'+S .9lt a 81ant to ItIC"�IARn lS 7 ;IIRC1(]KS% hiudiRR o'Fl.-I IIP 11RA6KR nA►1ILY WEN TY TRUST. utulrr a tleelwratlon.o/ rrtuet dated * 1!eing 130►' i4ent io. +' , ul .1P Mauntatn Rnad. Prtfuceron.'W2►rcectw_r Cnuc7t'11, wim 9ailrini►n rourtuuds ►las.tncltusetts 01541 •• . the Ivn>l Mirtogether bvUtlr Any hulldislas theferia.,situated' In Barnstable klsteivlllel. OAr.tgrshle County, Mwsoaohwsects, more 686r0culatly deserlbed as rollatvat LOT 20 an ahowa an Land,Coute.Plan''I9967-(;•rnnd'LOT 23 as'sh"n'on Court Plan 15967.11. together with Eh6;.r1�bY tpD ugo Vorti rorrace as described G►°IiaCun►ane nor grantors,title,`men Catfl/te:nte e P'f.Ukle No.'.1165O1i Y. - ta:1.'v r d .t:;w J 1•.l , t;J�,i�l.,; :►<• •t. .ark . .. . , . .. .•F •ter <,,'.. . . .. tic 1;,r r� u Fax"' rJl:i 1 °'•'s ti�, a , i c ' ,.� l°,i• rt. a',"i ) Fa.t r .ti; 4! as+,• it Y.:a rt a •;Si1r IS i,4..hr 1E f � -f + t a . 11,.IEJ"i 's•;� -i 7Fr,. { 4r•ll'!r ,t '1 V.r- , •!7 Frr.!,,'�S�t ^� i:'.a ..s,_ J it:�1. ..ni rix i:.Adf lr:{"..7r-) ��.{fs } :��f f P•7.. t a • � ..t i. e', e t i`,_,n� -('ft Fri:!.,.•i c,' ie■a'•ttnl us a■c'lIcd jt►ttrun+ani Niel■ ` ` r, day a( Jaae 1996 . rY ...d - rti� 'r•. 4y} Ml'.,: SFI 's f.J ;',2 1'e.r !.. -"�Ife-r-R; ar. n� - --- . i -' yiDllr Qlaannatth�enllbl F! Nils' Barlttitwl le°/ . r :'{ r . 1:F }}! � ,,:rS�$ f'8 (r . f"•i, d Jiina .a ; h 0996 "Ihm;per nalhr ■plMrre 1.l^Iw whew■'urn�sJ�,;Waifer,l/► Il'Ardner mail.Mary 12. t.ardnet rl and nchnawlcJacd gw'Iorey.ina;Incirua�e++C w Ye: ,their +'J+eb•ul.rsnd tlecrk • } . _ �lo�e7t.l.�OflaflYa N.,.mr YuA6..— ,i', `'/ - .�t.F,,, v •r.;{,,', ° •i a .'" /+ty''satan+i.elwi ■■pirer,' �/30/O1� Mix ?fl►. 91iliUleud 1011lrrrltt" '° the•saI(1 s •, WALTBR A. GAIiDNBR and NARY 1). CARDN1311 .IUllr_I111(u [i,elr� ,'�UIII(�S; dTl(lltlead jthig" 74p F,e�. �I, " r J - :. 1 11uy of + ' t"kn the War gone tbulusflnll';nine h"1"' J'nnd liiilety-six sr+'+i�t .� s•..l✓ .t.. r � .t61t{,,,,` IJr� �' 5,.;( 'tt• J '' Ifttealand•.aelile(1 urenresencooft ' t ,; ,6,. . .. .. r .:r� a cer ar net ---••-'---'-•--. ... ,'�F •!/ 6a t; / h'+ / L .fib_x 3L_=1&— oarNe:_gym:�1. m r4J 1� /. ♦. - ' ►" t0 to Swwc TLv u w C)mrnli , OEM": A s' (�rK tTIIN t; 4T0 Y� IhAA;.dS a a CA►AC1IN am OHa 2 Or• o DvT E,uee AL raoes.rsq, • RTENTYre �= wri le0 1e►- $wla ¢eo eox Aye. T. RAAa =ww•t our. yes .on•- 7 2 T.TS CAPE COD MASNIPEE 4AOIeW a'IINOBIWAt131 1f'1_vole:Jul_WATIA,1ES NASNUA N.N. •V) um� ti �• � ➢FSIG�rycX $ � �en'� F4Ti6o67TJa ``ANTItI ° � .• � f 1n uAHNr eo nPE 11ywA,�tf Tom Eli -A41 t.t I N 14.NQ=OHI O�JIFAT:iLNO.OF JET7: Ji- . A10 I •' I • ^ �`sa[aR yfwpu p. �. Oulyt� . k�A. 10•'' 1a NARGIL. r 1sxV & EA.sel7�lSl Ntt .� ��„► ' FHLryeNTCAnea'�,/AY n To�AQUA SWEEP&N arANeo t'NTtA f:ew t -51-F "ff''�. 1am+et lSr vv.a. p •L to EfCTRIQ Y w i1.enuN a Fore ,t� Mau tAenN oz• . a.Fwo QewPt hrbt a UNIX"ATE1VAC t i.'•; w DFM HFA W- q b Daw eAn o. n WSE FOR VAe: ?. �DES: q O o =t SPA OESCPoPTION O`7 pv' -6r'' ]'6 *L FENCE OwNr2 _ CA,nanV4 Dreg y 'P. St T PSAcL �� '• G*'a`• b WATER FAIL& IM Ovi OW 10 • FT >n.WATER FAIl� •. ..:. 496 MOH '�" 9•R �A uIANDSCAPNA: 'lY ATN7..C! '` vy„ ►'i Y54oer JOG WA'11 , Sp q'.PIteN�'i ADD17f�wM 1 In+ - �ICIIT I' r •: ... Ft-REoI ,��. . "'•�� .1! St • a Lr CdfJ. 1a% 1. 32. tIA•DfiIA•l1r A.T' INJc•! R >S r ce Ol• fePf OPry+il GA E TF FDC Ti ts,1e` . .�����•,---- •O KIHnw St. ♦ e e OPT . . y Lt vla 4CrDv .FIoeK'vP ., • ,, _ I ..• �. 'b � f LAC B.vT.e i•wAuf• n•. Y U{. . w .. tL1fit✓ . . _ �• • live . oat CLeMA,c1a N+iA' 1 i A 7Z IP ff^waco tPE 'f-Lr.-t 1>-7Sc y 3fTMvTN x�CeAOF� ri .gi lfwr t..ry txtfY• • _ i r ' : LWF BsTca 'Auer T. Cow 'ArrrSS 11 FlFcvn: RLS$hs ,. .• 4 g wwc Se8 71TF pIA,TNR. '• .p tr�•�• 77 lZ t.,va Fl w N ` - '• ' �`'4� - ' PT Hal 4L y ,.. IIFN aK.sr�, •Np�t'aRN � • �H .� . , '• �. •, •. . .�� �. tRa Box S!e CAPE OW NASHUA NA .. - bwNTt .:. .. • — ,F•`w • L OM 4n-"t PO5WTT7t -�.• //��E C1UhP Fviit f*-1 i IS-P 't �c • •' �' f' �'� OWNER . , A . �' 1 1 •; • �• APPROIAMATE ELEVATION OF • (� ` p.._ _ POOL ON DAY OF EXCAVATION - POOL AREA TO BE FENCED By OWMER PER• 1 •• CIT OP(7Wgt .. ORDINANCE OATTES TO BE SEJ . i .•\ \ CLOSING AND SELF LATCHING. 0k"Co- 7 DO NOT TURN ON POOL UGHI _ Now EAIT4C w re ' J WHEN POOLOE7IPiX ....-... SA— .�...r. NTi s� D r•`�•'+ •�•.�:°.+•+..v.�`•.�..`w.+• mow. �•��( 1•1�t \ W ooD CA Mae" IDOL CONQ&TMR a,YRS EXPBROOL4 THE EXECUTIVE 1 ` / ORIBRAL POLYNFSAN POOLa WATM FAL vyALTM GAL W 0 THE. ARaIIEe+WIRIDG CUMUo«om -r ^• FOR noon NmaFs eusrAr s►AS �... n .••� w..'�..•�.+.:....w.. .•.r0 .°rA,}' NAME 27 ;,t "�••�` - `c� s a ed the Tmdldon OR E y:o= SSS`a Y�w� `•'j L-.:'-M " w`:�"�'r"- .'\'� �lpcnnJ land or lk nWP 8. gbt-2l3 :w...�r •t +�.`. y•w:��M� �arru 8. Nelson CfTY PHONE :mot; Etstgn Assoc. i'ita. x 3 t t 9toiA'�'t 7J 9�PP "� - +�•`••"�•••" t7n1 11Ft&Ou'.1Da LOT 8lK i 1 • fosGoP % .: M04-L s ue,^:,' "'^" .'""�.. � \ BI,Ddinp Since 1B58 r/ C,USTOMEASSKMTURE ' `•� 'w.i�w+....�.. ..: WATERFALLS.EWIDOES.WOOOWORK STC 4E [� IT..c�. ee•cno.. _ - H ' OYJFI BY P S Ufcfe� DATE 712 `if 17At BY ��- v Sseszor's office(1st Floor): Assessors map and lot number / �5 Q�oF THE>o`+ Board of Health(3rd floor): Sewage Permit number USTULL i 91619 Engineering Department(3rd floor): 33Mr.sa House number oo i639• Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO 2 U/1 1, M I n16 L TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION �b Jy C. 12 i'7?!7 ( YW S' . 19 �— TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: Location - ��f� l� ��a��.• S��711. �//L L C= ''�r'.S, "] Proposed Use 44 Zoning District C Fire District Ce Tc° . fife e.t 0 s, 7,:-x o i 4-e ._Name of Owner k"411 zi. 7" Q.y4 Address Name of Builder t�rt'f'C L %i �E' Q 0 C.5 Address Name of Architect Address Number of Rooms Foundation Exterior Roofing Floors Interior Heating Plumbing 00 Fireplace Approximate Cost a Area Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee i i OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS 1 hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regarP,inq the above construction. Name �' Construction Supervisor's License 00 �16 Z Z -- S �' 1'� .�. .. C• i I I I/j��� j//YAl� ',\ V . -L / � / :�°�6 _.. ._ i i aa 0 0 o MCDA.NIEL .RESIDENCE 0 27 York Terrace 0 Ostervi I le, MA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bathrooms- Main House o Plans, Elevations, Electrical Etc. o provided by 0 Falmouth Kitchen Korner, Inc 0 205 Worcester Court. N Suite 67 � Falmouth, MA 02540 0 508=540-6484 ph. 0 508-540-4535 fax 0 R 0 U .• ,o (3�a w4f.. 1Ovz J N?Jo oP�yv c `(oo 0 0 �4. The Kitchen Korner C�l� of Falmouth, Inc. Heritage Place 205 Worcester Court Falmouth, MA 02540 Phone: (508) 540-6484 March 31, 1999 Re: McDaniel Main House Baths Considerations / Items Pending 1 . NOTE: ALL DIMDENSIONS ON ALL PLANS ATTACHED ARE FINISHED, UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED 2. See Gwen and Jack for all switch locations in master bath 3. See them for door hinging to master bath 4. Please provide blocking for towel rings and bars as indicated on plans. Paper holder to left of water closet. 5. Color of Whirlpool and all its trim peices to be white. Spec provided by Kitchen Korner is for general information only. Please obtain definitive installation specifications and acces panel requirements from manufacturer via your plumber (he is supplying the unit). 6. The McDaniel's have not yet chosen water closet, sinks, and faucets (4). these are to be supplied and installed by your plumber. 7. At this time Kitchen Korner is responsible for supplying and installing vanity cabinets, vertical front panel and false doors to clad side and front of whirlpool platform. Supply and install medicine cabinets. Supply and install Limestone counters on vanities and top of whirlpool platform. 8. All choices/discussions/for floors and shower tiles should be between customer and Cape Tileworks. Coordination should be done by contractor. i.e. schedule installtion of floor and shower tiles. 9. Kitchen Korner is still awaiting specs and style choices of glass shower panels and door and threshold requirements for shower. I hope to have definitive plan for this by mid April. n cc;1: n� ; ti �L •'s7a has r,ot beta d;sc.�sse�, w'.th 66--4t�,mor +o 411 �he� 1 ShfinS 5Ce .P1ar� . (Aod-Vo& FINE CUSTOM CABINETRY r 10. Kitchen Korner is still awaiting specs and style choices of glass shower panels and door and threshold requirements for master bath shower. I hope to have definitive plan/pricing for this by mid April. 11. Any questions related to atteched plans please call Marianne 540-6484 "7o w Z ulm� �- �ol2C�rm 2�4 O ,'~`wM 12t_Psot` (BY oTYtCf6j� 2 �/ BrJL_ Mo-ro.c A �PAG • I i ' 17I 41 I ' ' -_ l i(/�I - - - Tom•'__ _— .__ _ �� I t , 1 .i - —;-- ; I - i �; , ') ;.2`Z► 'PLgTTocr.. ' f' I` I ! j I I i. I, I � _..�_ � •�, _ Sc�i�w�;l-al { I /i I � 1 �A�' :i - - � I --- - ---�� ;57,-.,l•EL' soYrt' a i ; _ � _ '���'o�(,b) Fen M� .� b I �--.'---• ' Y - I� .I P �. � %� ,,,:►j row �K � � ! I i . z � � ,;. ; w cwercouit E ',A(L� i lu i , 02s1 1 IL I i I i i : : I I i i I 75 1/2 ---� 39 ' CL EAic 42 3/4f/^ Y K o 1�1 k►JtF vJ�Lt_/ — 38 1 ATc ld `�CQ f.. fe 6 M, —. 25�4 _ _ _ _ _ 1 -- CSEE W,'IIRL'PODL tJPEGS 41 18-I I Ro�H I i I I -rbf-;o or 661/4 40 3/4 I i (--- 43 5/8 39 1/2 74 Wit I K.Ly-obL- 157 '/8"-r IX}tthc�t xgrrttr of fafinouth,Inc. 205'Wmater Court jalnmouth,MA 02540 2 JrtrAen 9g7Mer of fafmoutfy Inc. j \ 205 Worcester Court fa(nnout(t,AN 02540 �E C) CAC6 ryE► V1l/tL L 5 L E:F7- 1N LL- I wa LL i � SrRtii OAENIN� , GC1r ouT.4112�� W11 LL 34A - FAN c N TO 50F FiT� 'F3��K8e1.D To Top oV -i C`F�ntilV:s FE�K ?C�YT=o2M- 20 ll ►Tease, �� bloclu�9 . under rned, Cir.A, Co.1o;40- 1--be-. C H,T 1NA-L.L -tcfwn xprnar of jaGaoutfii,Inc. 205 Womester Court r-- jalrnoutk,Mq 02540 'c L // II 1 T i i II i 1 I 1 M119 2 orZ i cT2. i 4 I �8`f:mee ! ioPoO, cr�� i cre z�r, � ��Z 1,011 �i "I 1 42 3/4 41 r• .- 661/4 LEY 40 3/4 22" �;J C V4,e de V 1/2 -- i latclun KMff of falmoutk Inc. A—.— __----------._---------- —_—{ 205 Wm=tcrCourt �—__ ----- --- _ _------------ falmoutk MA 02540 till r',� �, :�. �.. Sw�1=c� I`/�CT✓�I��� � �1CsFt i lv�Cr . all_ 1 , i K-852-H TEA-FOR-TWO"'5'BATH WHIRLPOOL While $2.273.00 31.4 440.0 j 60"x 32"x 18 1/4'cast iron bath with Safeguard'finish. \ Featuring Kohler Whirlpool SYSTEM If.with 4 Flexjets (order trim kit separately).1 hp 2-speed pump,solid state Full 2,500.30 electronic switch,Integral heater,PVC harness,UL \o \ Listed,LESS ALL TRIM.ADA compliant when installed Fashion 2.625.25 ' with seat at head end. 0 K-9694 ,Trim kit includes 4 Flexiets,suction cover(metal finish White 168.45 0.1 1.7 kits only),available in a selection of metal finishes or / color-matched plastic.Color-matched suction cover Full 168.45 shipped with whiripool. Fashion 168.45 K-852•H CP 196.65 ` TEA-FOR-TWO 5'BATH WHIRLPOOL 'a G.PB 259.75 Y.; I DHM CAT 1M SN 288.20 qxe For A Lifetime 'L ADA BN 357.90 X1:4- AU 463.00 U.r• K-7169-AF Clearflo contoured bath drain. CP 258.65 0.5 7.2 G.PB 270.70 E SN 287.35 BN 317.65 i • AU 336.25 y_ Bath and shower faucet of your dwice-refer to Faucet *' Price Book. K-586 Undemtounf installation kit for installation of Tea-tor-Two 5' h• cast Iron bath beneath stone,tile,wood,solid surface,or NA 27.05 0.5 4.0 other deck material.Includes cutout template and Instal- lation instructions. K-1491 Bath/whirlpool pillow,removable. White 74.95 0.2 1.2 7,47,96 82.65 .• K-1172 Adjustable feet for above-the floor roughing-in. NA 45.60 1.0 5.4 K-1179 Vinyl filing-in bead. NA 49.75 0.5 4.0 Handshowers and diverters-see page 111. Full Una Colors High Fashion Colors Finishes 6 .Skylight 56 Tender-Grey 7 Black Black- CP Polished Chrome :.-12,.Jersey Cream^-♦ 71 Seafoam Green '17 'Teats G'Brushed Chrome 'Mexican Sand"` 89 Desen Blcoml 52 Navy PB Polished Brass •c AS Wild Rose- 95 Ice"-Grey 53 Raspberry Puree'* SN 'Polished Nickel 47 -Almond 96 Biscuit 58 Thunder"Greys BN Brushed Nickel '55 Innocent Blush- 98 chamois-* 97 Timberline"- AU .Polished Gold 11V1 1 � =e' I KOHLER� '' • Product available made-to-order.Additional upcharge FIXTURES of 30%above Full Line Color. 77 I'Jleq�e (=vt outlet £ Eeh (Pc i on 't��<, vJgLl i i Jr Q9 1/2 i 25I 33 5/18-------A WCM1530 R 21 �1 - BF033 o E XIbTw& 193 4 ( c ogEl' J L 1 1 53 BV0483218R I CM1530 L 88 ----------- 1 59 1/2 LICTNT2 WT6305409 (` 35 — � 111 I S Beth's Bath Rev. 4 2/17199 Brookhaven Somerset xtchcre 9-,M r of Falmouth,Inc. 205 Worc4cster Court Falmouth,MAo2540 76U pIccAY� coo.-ram. SJFFI� iYi a1 �Jcn c.k. L.i J'nfi5 • I o be, 1r.5-I0.IItCL l'� She�� Ove(- meet; c.;.1 e- c.ab7 �lti--rI c.tco r` G C '�or �Cirvl. Color �' locic��G ;or I owel Kin' TQwe1 eqr a I-; t.r. �j o r r c.� ( �To ,FC' ieve- cV-- Uc,ti ---- — 3/4" m m � --_ T- 79" m m T mm m 32 Y4- ZP—I 99tchcn`Jpmcr Of Falmouth,Inc. 205 Wercestcr Court q Falmouth,9lfA 02540 0 0 9Utchen xpjw ofFafmout&Inc. 205 Worcester Court Falmouth,MA 02540 . C�L�:r �>Y 1,ram• 'I�d l t�l:. 1� iVtdwn xprnar of Falmouth,Inc. 205 Wormatcr Court Falmouth,MA 02540 f'". Y .� r..... .. :a..-. .... ..w ...w:-rv.�..ii.— •r S.r•r...ir/'K`�y -J'•�f''1'+r�T~ �.+h "•-,a w••'��`y... •Mr'r\,•1;ty.:-y-�.�:tfs�i":..r`'e... e _ 'M �, • •F.fi • 1.. Assessors office st Floor): /�/� _ Di �D/ T►+e e� Assessor's map and lot number Board of Health(3rd floor): Sewage Permit number Engineering-Department(3rd floor): Z Beaa9TsniL,. rasa House number ��° Definitive Plan Approved by Planning.Board 19 APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only Cr krl TOWN OF BARNSTABLE 21JILD,ING . INSPECTOR � -" �� [�, - , p 1 APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO ���IV f4A. f'-pC,�U f v y`�� f 1 I� y ��0 y� l lI � `GrO� l TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION -( I3 ..1 1s 90 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: [s i ,- Uq Z 2 The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: (C1 •�/0 014 tA Location 1 '6 ( V/Uv�LL�/ Proposed Use �U��t/d0 fJl -jW VI C�( / 1- i rl�� �`-Zoning District �- Fire District " Name of Owner '� l7u y Address 21 -/o/r `rdd�� ��/yl I �f � Name of Builder " '( r� `�U Address �� (41(uC ef5d dl IV. l/`i61 (0" Name of Architect Address 1 Number of Rooms Foundation �bc V c� lU � pp Exteric l / l I�e"k04 J Roofing ¢ � c (' I f ',Ykh Floors � ( (0/ P� ' ` ���,r. t i Interior ' V ,ram, Heating 4 N C Plumbing l Fireplace N( Approximate Cost (�f 000 Area Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee plot plug • r i � V OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS e , I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regarding the above construction. Name OtO Z 91 Construction Supervisor's License GARDNER, WALTER A=140-150-001 ;- - } /Ilo -/s- ,vo ! No 34092 Permit-For Renovation/ "install Bathroom Single Family Dwelling Location 27 York Terrace Osterville it Owner Walter Gardner Type of Construction Frame i Plot Lot . Permit Granted December 3 , 19 90 Date of Inspection 19 Date Completed 19 t 1 Y. r �a�.-R�-Pv�I�td� 7%=Yang a."._ J�f••F� •• � '�-RMIT COMPLETED 1/11 . Assessors map and lot number ...................................... F THE t Sewage Permit number .2'. !. � /t .r^g gs.......... ......................... Z BAMSTAXLE. i b House number .........t..,....4 �..................................... r IL . � '00 39• � E YPY d' TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO ..... rn C 7— .............................. TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION v dB ........................7...L.�..........19..93 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for. a permit according to the following information: Location ... a..7- / 5' � A/ AJ a1 d v g ....... ....................................................................:.......................................... ......................................................... ProposedUse ...... .. A..`..t..............`..&$/ .N C:................................................................................... ZoningDistrict .........................................................................Fire District .............................................................................. Name of Owner ff �j I . C/2.... ....' ........ ".� ..................Address ... ...vi .... ...!................................................... �� ✓--•l.G.l �/C/SC .%.�/.7 Py G ^ ` J1 . ..r.. . . ..`".` ''................................................Name o5Builde��1 Nameof Architect ..................................................................Address .................................................................................... Number of Rooms ....................................................Foundation l U U/ P Cf `- O v+ G r� ............. .............................................................................. L Exterior ...Cf r� 11....G�....'¢ ?.4-fL(�...................Roofing ....."-J o�o r ` l:� Ce,oA(z_ .......................................................................... Floors �G — S �7 Interior ..... ...................................................... i40 � �/� r-�_� Heating ................................... ....... ...............................Plumbing .................................................................................. Fireplace ✓ z= Approximate. Cost........................................................... ,.<.........c............................................. q Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board -----------__________________19 Area — .S S.... ........... Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee ....................................9T........ .J. SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF BOARD OF HEALTH 4D I � OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Townlof Barnstable regarding the above construction. Name . .........................../"f /JJf/°].......... .�.................... Construction Supervisor's License ..................... ........ -- SHIELDS, 8OBERT A=140-I54-1 i , \L4 ri - / N6 35446.- Permit for ...................................l� Stoz�' _ __�Single. Family_Dvve.11iug____.. - ' Location ..Lo.t...l.5......39.D_VViao�c,,Au/eoue uuc� ' -.--`�----���!.��.��------------ . ' C)moner .���b.ert.-SIlieIds............................ Type of Construction - -_------. . . . --.--..-.------.-.-....--,-.^.--.. . ' Plot -'----'r--' Lot ----------' ' ' ' ' `� I9 , J\o�o� ' � 83 Permit �ronte6 --..--------_-]V ~ ' Date of Inspection ,,--.--------..lA ` Dote Completed ........................................l9 . ' ' . / - . . . � . / . ~ ^ � Assessors map and lot number Sewage Permit number .:......:. y 3� EAEdSTAELE �� r :�O House number rhea 1639 TOWN Of BARNSTABLE m BUILDING INSPECTOR /e APPLICATION FOR. PERMIT TO, ...........0 c? l...S.' '?. :............^..........A L( ................................... TYPE OF'CONSTRUCTION ...............(U�Av A......... .-.................................................................. A(. .,..1..............................19... .y TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the .following information: Location ...�P. ..f. ............. V..C.?.R..k........1..<... 1!�C............... ^�e ............................................................ ProposedUse ......s..1.. �...S.�,z......... .!'!'`� .�.�. ........ . ................................................................ Zoning District :.......... t c,1 �� .. ...c................................................:Fire District:.........................�!. C.... .. .. v. � j�o i3 U x i F y c�'a s-� Name of.Owner ..... *!!!.M.. �....T..........`...... U!c .��.........Address ..... a." ....5!!..!�? !�. 1�{....5.:�..../1 A c S C Name of Builder ..... ''�.v..`. ....T.'....��.`t �. Uz.`.1.......Address, ...�.�..Y....A...'..!. ?'.......................................hl...,.r s r� t� oo?u 3� Name of Architect ��� r (��,. /� eC..Address .......!L 1;,,�!.. !....S. :..................... ..........0....: .................g. c�....... � Q... Number of Rooms .... ..! ..l.S?!`...... ..`.?...............Foundation ......[..�.�.K.f-. �or'—..�.ff �. ....:_ . Exterior ........W.U'?..`...... �.�t �!... .4 ¢.'L. - . ...............Roofing ....... `.'...................�.....:`w... .�.C... . Floors ..........!!`A....� ......................................................... .Interior P .Y., ....................:. Heating : .6.:......../ 0. .....k!k.........................Plumbing r 4.......b......C.............:....... .__ ..._.._ Fireplace ...........y ...f?!/.�.. a..�. ..........................Approximate. Cost .........1T..Aq....................................._.... Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board _________—____—___________19_______:• Area ....(. ...O.�... . ....:...Diq ram of Lot and Buildin with Dimensions 56.j �...........g 9 Fee ...... ........., ............... SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF BOARD OF HEALTH I g, A ti OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regarding the above f; construction. y �" Name ...�` !.�`. ...... .... �/...... �v �6 � -. Construction Supervisor's License .................................... GREGORY, DAVID T. A=140-150 No .26328:... Permit for ..Addition Single Family..Dwelling......................... Location .IAt... ......Z7..XrQk..T.exxda.......... .................. ...................................... Owner ............................ Type of Construction .F.zaM............................. Plot .......................... Lot ................................ K_ Permit Granted ..APri.l...2 ....................19, 84 Date of-Inspection ....................................19 Date Completed ......................................19 7z� s JLL. 6.1999 3:00PM TA SCHILLING PC 5067750792 NO.494 P.2 LAW OFFICES OF TELEPHONE:508 775 0700 THEODORE A. SCHILLING, P.C. FACSWILE: 508 775 0792 1550 Falmouth Road-Suite 10 Centerville,MA 02632 EMAIL: law@cape.com I SENT BY FAX: 790 6230 June 29, 1999 Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Town of Barn-stable 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 RE: 27York Terrace, Osferville Lot 20 on L.C. flan 15967-G &Lot 23 on L.C. Plan 15967-H Owners:John C. and Gwen C. McDaniel Dear Ralph; You may recall that earlier this Spring my clients,John and Gwen McDaniel were having some renovation work done to the outer building/garage at the above captioned property. The work was being done by Peacock and Crosby. The work started out as replacement of doors and windows and the project then developed into a much more extensive renovation including the removal of the existing kitchen,wiring and plumbing. At that time the work was stopped. My clients have since hired a new contractor who will file for a complete and proper, building permit. However, we now seek to replace the kitchen that was located in the garage building adjacent to the swimming pool. This is not to be an apartment and is only to be used in connection with the residence and as part of the pool area. My clients,as you may recall,purchased this property about 2 years ago with the kitchen installed, and represented to them at that time, as proper under the provisions of the Town By-Laws. They now seek to re-install the kitchen .JUL. 6.1999 3:00PM TA SCHILLING PC 5097750792 NO.494 P.3 I Mr. Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Page Two June 29, 1999 associated with the swimming pool and hereby request thatyou determine whether or not you will allow the same so that they can re-apply for a building permit and continue their work. I would greatly appreciate your forwarding a copy of this letter by FAX to me, indicating whether or not you would allow us to apply for a building permit to re-install the kitchen. Th you for your attention to this matter and your quick response. Very ?"y O SCHI ING /gs ACKNOWLEDGMENT/RESPONSE: By: Ralph Crossen A:\CtOSSEN.LTR.-pd .JUL. 5.1999 2:59PM TA SfiHILLING PC 5087750792 NO.494 P.1 LAW OFFICES OF 'THEODORE A. SCHILLING, P • C s i 1550 Falmouth Road - Suite 10, Centerville, MA 02632 TEL: 508 775 0700 FAX: 508 775 0792 DATE: July 6, 1999 TO: Ralph Crosson, Building Commissioner FAX NO: 790 6230 FROM: TED SCHZLLING SENT BY: GEOR01 NO. OF PAGES: 3 (including this cover sheet) SUBJECT: 27 YORK TERRACE, OSTERVILLS/MCDANILLS CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The documents accompanying this FAX transmission cover leaer contain Information from The Law Offices of Theodore A. Schilling,P.C.which Is confidentlal and prtvliege. The Information Is Intended to be for the use of the Individual or entity named on this transmittal sheet. If you are not the intended recipient,be aware that any dlsdosure,copying,dlstrlbutlen or use of the contents of this FAX transmission is prohibited. IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS FAX TRANSMISSION IN ERROR,PLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY BY TELEPHONE,AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL TRANSMITTAL TO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS VIA THE U.S.POSTAL SERVICE.Thank you. .K � •r `- �4-) +` ._ , -) • ♦r • - a ��. ••� � • - ; •• '' a -'' • , •1 _ - - -- -- 3 Zz ( ►Z v(l, TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION Map Parcel SD Permit# 3 Health Division I?W Date Issued Conservation Division Z Fee Tax Collector 3�a��gy QC__ T30SEPTIC SYS MUST taETreasurer INSTALLED IN COMPLIANCE Planning Dept. WITH TITLE 5 Date Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board ENVIRONMENTAL CODE AND TOWN REGULATIONS Historic-OKH Preservation/Hyannis Project Street Address 4 Village Owner Address Telephone q-6q0�- Permit Request rtr c cAAM Square feet: 1st floor: existing ?�,Y proposed O 2nd floor:existing A- proposed © Total new O Estimated Project Cost 000 Zoning District Flood Plain Groundwater Overlay Construction Type list P44.11a Lot Size Grandfathered: ❑Yes O No If yes, attach supporting documentation. Dwelling Type: Single Family a-- Two Family 0 Multi-Family(#units) Age of Existing Structure �D F— Historic House: ❑Yes 0-Pd6"- On Old King's Highway: ❑Yes &-Ne- Basement Type: tl'Fu l ❑Crawl ❑Walkout ❑Other Basement Finished Area(sq.ft.) At-A- Basement Unfinished Area(sq.ft) ky-P- Number of Baths: Full:existing 3 new Half:existing C) new 0 Number of Bedrooms: existing '4 new 4 Total Room Count(not including baths):existing / .b new O First Floor Room Count 6 Heat Type and Fuel: as ❑Oil O Electric 0 Other Central Air: 0 Yes Cro Fireplaces: Existing 1 �New O Existing wood/coal stove: 0 Yes M-1Vo Detached garage: e®' isting El new size Pool: exit sting 0 new size Barn:anisfing ❑new size Attached garage:0 existing O new size �_ Shed:O existing ❑new size Other: Zoning Board of Appeals Authorization 0 Appeal# Recorded 0 Commercial ❑Yes o If yes, site plan review# cc Current Use Proposed Use y _ BUILDER INFORMATION Cf Name Telephone Number . Q_ a Address d License# ���? o 2 Home Improvement Contractor# it la7 3J� Worker's Compensation# 00 ALL CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS RESULTING FROM THIS PROJECT WILL BE TAKEN TO SIGNATURE DATE 3 y ` `T ��Z'2t FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PERMIT NO. DATE ISSUED _ MAP/PARCEL NO. e. ADDRESS VILLAGE OWNER DATE OF INSPECTI0 ' i FOUNDATION FRAME 5 �7/9 9' INSULATION /9cl FIREPLACE ELECTRICAL: ROUGH FINAL PLUMBING: ROUG11 ; �` = FINAL ' GAS: ROUGH'- H 1P FINAL FINAL BUILDING ; DATE CLOSED OUT ASSOCIATION PLAN NO. a. . y April. 1.4 , 10-99 Fred Fisher Kitchen, Ka.rnar Tr'iC . f - ''.05 s;orcesre"r Court- Falmouth, MA 02540 Fax =-=.> S08,1540-4535 nea, Mr. Fws;ler This will confirm that we are retaining you to serve as our General Contractor Leo the remodeling at our homy at 27 York TPirate, Ost---rvil ie, Mass. We haye terminated our contract with Peacock '&, Crosby Builders . - I understand they did file for a permit for this work w;.th the Town of Earnstable . We would like the town to transfer this permit _o your tiompany, and make any adjustments that are necessary. IL YOU or anyone r oli1 the Town, of Barnstable has any questions about this, please feel. free to call me at my home in t,orceste- (538/355-2290) , evenings; or at my office {503/835- 9QC�ix2C , 1 loon forward to ha-ving ch..is work, dune' or. a timmely basis . Sar.cerely� i Propo t'y' vv n'r 2.7 York Terrace OS t cz-vi 11 e t 41`_l nC..0T GGC_T„_+,T.._11.JW 4!0IQ ;��` . -_ The Commonwealth of Massachusetts fl, � ' Department of Industrial Accidents office oflnsesmoo ions .. _. .. 600 Washington Street Boston,Mass. 02111 Workers' Compensation Insurance Affidavit name: r —i ' =I ev 'j (�0 �/G 'T location: , ..�)i city 't-��{�j(�Q,f�_ d�t'S-� phone# �I�/ ", (0 ! U U ❑ I am a homeowner performing all work myself. ❑ I am a sole r rietor and have no one workingin ca achy O//%%%%%///////%�%/�% %%%%O%%%%%%/%%%%/%%%%%��%%%%///%/ %%//%%%%/%%%%%%%%%%/%%%%%%%%%%%/%%%%%%%�%�%%�%%%�/�%�%%%%%��%%% ❑ I am an employer providing workers' compensation for my employees working on this job. condanv>nam .. ...... ... ................................... . .. ... .: ... an: CIV :::...:.::::..::::.::::::::::44,::::::•.:::::...::...:............................. .... ...................::: iX,i 7IISLLt C6:C0:;::':::i::::i::,':y ::;r.;.:::>::;<;<,:':::..;a>::::5:;.::;5:;i5:;;`:; :i:::,,..Fr.: qq.........4:4.....::>::>:;.:y>::;::::>'':/ ..... I am a sole proprietor,general contractor,or homeowner(circle one)and have hired the contractors listed below who have . the following workers' compensation polices: coaA '. . q q -q-44— .,�4�---.....4................ maanv:name-»::: :.;< .::::::........... ..:. .......................::..:.............................................................. .... ..... . ::._ :.;.:::.;:.;... ... :::.:::.:::::::::.::.::::....::..:::::::::.:::::::..:: ::: .... .:::::::::::.::::.::.:::::::::::._::::::::::::::::::::::.::::::.::.::.._:::::::::::.::::::::::::.:.::.::::::::: . .:..:::::::::::::.:::::. :: <.::::.:.:::...::::.:::::. :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.............:.... :.:. ...:.:: ..: ::.::.::::.::::::::::::::..:.::::::::::::.::::::::::::::::::.::::::::::::.::::::..::::::. :..:::: :...:::::.::. :: :::::::.::::: :::•.._::::::::::::::::::::: :::::. :.. ..;:.;::::'::i:,:::::::::::.`;::;::;:>.:::;:::<:i:::;::::::;:::r::::::.1..i;. >::;' .::>::>::>::>:.-.,:i:::`"::i::::::;:;::i:;:::::%:::::::::;::;;:::::;:::;::::;:::5::»»:t::s;::.::::::.::: :::::::: shone# r/...... city /1.. ii: ....... ,. :;<:>;...m.>:<:>:>;:<:>::;::»:... :::..... .... :..:..:.::y.:......;;;;:::.::....::".:::::::. ......... ....... .........::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.�:::::::::::::.::..� ,. .............................................................................. ::.�......... 4 . . . .......... ......... .............................................................. ............. . :>: �::>':.:::::::::::::::::::::::•:::::::.�::: �::::::::::::::::.:::::::::::::::::•::::::._:::::::%::::......:.....:.................................. �,/. 4. :1f✓: 'r:......................... :::::::..::::::::::::.:�:::: �::::::::::::•::::::::::•::.... ::::::.�::::::::::::::.�.�::•::::::•::.�:::::::._.�.�::::::::.:.�::: :::::::::::::::::::::: :;:;;;;:::::::;:::<:;::::::::::::::;:::'::::::::::::i::;::::.:;:'fi;::::;::::;:%:::S::isi:::::::;:::<:<::::::i:::::::::::::::::::;:;:::i:i;:::-*.—::;:::::::::::;:::;:;::;f::;::`:::>:i':i`::::i:::::i::i::>::i:ii]..{� �nsnrance.co..... ... :..;..:..;....:...................... comaA :::name::::>::::s:<.>:::•:>:>::>:•:.:•::::>:•:•>:•:•:•:•:•::>:>•:::•>:•:•>:•:•:•:•:::«•><:«•::::>::>::::>::::...................................................................................................... v .........................................: 4. ;:.:;::;;:;::.;<:: address. ;: :::. : <::<:>><<: Gl p "........::.r••::.:. .............. ...................... ::::: �/ Failure to secure coverage as required under Section 25A of MGL 152 can lead to the imposition of criminal penalties of a fine up to$1,500.00 and/or one years'imprisonment as well as civil penalties in the form of a STOP WORK ORDER and a tine of$100.00 a day against me. I understand that a copy of this statement may be forwarded to the Office of Investigations of the DIA for coverage verification I do hereby certify under the pains and penalties of perjury that the information provided above is true and correct Signature j�— z � Date _ _ Print name Phone# S 1'4 '��� official use only do not write in this area to be completed by city or town official . city or town: permit/license# ❑Building Department ❑Licensing Board ❑check if immediate response is required ❑Selectmen's Office ❑Health Department contact person: phone#; ❑Other (revised 9/95 PJA) . Information and Instructions Massachusetts General Laws chapter 152 section 25 requires all employers to provide workers' compensation for their employees. As quoted from the"law", an employee is defined as every person in the service of another under any contract of hire, express or implied, oral or written. An employer is defined as an individual, partnership, association, corporation or other legal entity, or any two or more of the foregoing engaged in a joint enterprise, and including the legal representatives of a deceased employer, or the receiver or trustee of an individual,partnership, association or other legal entity, employing employees. However the owner of a . _ dwelling house having not more than three apartments and who resides therein, or the occupant of the dwelling house of another who employs persons to do maintenance, construction or repair work on such dwelling house or on the grounds or building appurtenant thereto shall not because of such employment be deemed to be an employer. MGL chapter 152 section 25 also states that every state or local licensing agency shall withhold the issuance or renewal of a license or permit to operate a business or to construct buildings in the commonwealth for any applicant who has not produced acceptable evidence of compliance with the insurance coverage required. Additionally,neither the commonwealth nor any of its political subdivisions shall enter into any contract for the performance of public work until acceptable evidence of compliance with the insurance requirements of this chapter have been presented to the contracting authority. Applicants Please fill in the workers' compensation affidavit completely,by checking the box that applies to your situation and supplying company names,address and phone numbers along with a certificate of insurance as all affidavits may be submitted to the Department of Industrial Accidents for confirmation of insurance coverage. Also be sure to sign and date the affidavit. The affidavit should be returned to the city or town that the application for the permit or license is being requested, not the Department of Industrial Accidents. Should you have any questions regarding the"law"or if you are required to obtain a workers'.compensatioa policy,please call the Department at the number listed below.. City or Towns Please be sure that the affidavit is complete and printed legibly. The Department has provided a space at the bottom of the affidavit for you to fill out in the event the Office of Investigations has to contact you regarding the applicant. Please be.sure to fill in the peimitllicense number .which will be used as a reference number. The affidavits may be reiur Mio the Department by mail or FAX unless other arrangements have been made. The Office of Investigations would like to thank you in advance for you cooperation and should you have any questions. please do not hesitate to give us a call. The Department's address,telephone and fax number: The Commonwealth Of Massachusetts .Department of Industrial Accidents Me of Imlestlgadons 600 Washington Street Boston,Ma. 02111 fax#: (617) 727-7749 phone#: (617) 727-4900 ext. 406, 409 or 375 The Town of Barnstable s�errar�, • '' Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner Permit no. Date AFFIDAVIT HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR LAW SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT APPLICATION MGL c. 142A requires that the"reconstruction,alterations,renovation,repair,modernization,conversion, improvement,removal,.demolition,or construction of an addition to any pre-existing owner-occupied building containing at least one but not more than four dwelling units or to structures which are adjacent to such residence or building be done by registered contractors,with certain exceptions,along with other requirements. —�- Type of Work: kQC4Adj(L- 2- ✓ (�cl(� � _Estimated Cost (/OCJ Address of Work: Z 7 ��vl ✓`�-Wc 0 LzV,/c� Owner's Name: J Gc CA a,�— LL VA--( Date of Application: I hereby certify that: Registration is not required for the following reason(s): Work excluded by law Job Under$1,000 Building not owner-occupied / q ❑Owner pulling own permit Hl 2�lq l Notice is hereby given that: OWNERS PULLING THEIR OWN PERMIT OR DEALING WITH UNREGISTERED CONTRACTORS FOR APPLICABLE HOME IMPROVEMENT WORK DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE ARBITRATION PROGRAM OR GUARANTY FUND UNDER MGL c. 142A. SIGNED UNDER PENALTIES OF PERJURY I hereby apply for a permit as the agent of the owner. ?� Date Contractor Name Registration No. OR Date Owner's Name q:fortns:Affidav ?)aE ✓ UC 007t//7tOOtU/CCLGLIL d�'!/GIJ.JJILC�II.iC� OEPARIHENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY CONS TRUCT_IOM''SUPERYISOR LICENSE 3 Nula—i�-Expires: - Rests fed:_To= 16 FREOVf.ISHER,, �+�►vt 205 YORCES'ER ST FALMOUTH, MA 02540 s ,�/ee�asiarno=ucea�c�./�aaaadFnaol:,�"� �� HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR Registration 107350 t,..type PRIVATE CORPORATION F � • Ekpiration 07/31/00 �- = KITCHEN KORNER OF FALMOUTH IN .. -.. :Frederick. J. Fisher s °4r Worcester Court . • ���� Faimoath VMlNlSTF AMR MA 02540 • _•_;... } 1, ' 891/2 WCM1530 R 21-� --- ---------- BF0334 1934 53 BVO483218R CM1530 ( 88 ----------- 591/2 i WTB305409 5 Beth's Bath Rev.4 2/17199 Brookhaven Somerset v • I I- i Ir 7d 17711 WRiNSGp-r� �2P Y, wrn i ; VI IV JAJ _ t -- I - - -- —�-. r ? i I• :� j 1- i I i � I �' I- -; 1[•�.� -� 1 I ;. .i -�—.I -i �I � ( ;�,-' 91 i .. — ---;_ 'I n- - t - '-- L-4 }- - - - � I I ir i � i ` �i I I , � � Ir I i 'UN �+ i �� i f i j � I l . � :TILL.15.1999 1:17PP1 TA 8CH I LL I NG PC SF-8 7750792 P40.622 P.1 LAW OFFICES OF THEODORE A. SCHILLING P.C. 1550.Falmouth Road, Suite 10, Centerville, MA 02632FAX TEL: 503-775-0700 FAX, 508-775-0792 � ®ATE: j 199 9 TO: �(A- PAA,_ FAX NO: 39Q — te '230 FROM: TED SCHILLING SENT BY: # OF PAGES: (including this cover sheet) SUBJECT: Wor V, .-Te-rira U Ds4eYy L rM T')ax ►-1s CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The documents accomoanying this FAX transmission cover letter contafn Information From The Law Offices of Theodore A,Schilling, P.C.which Is confidential and privileged. The Information is intended to be for the use of the individual or entlr/named on this transmittal sheet If you are not the Intended reclolent,be aware that any disclosure,copying,distribution or use of the contents of this FAX transmission is prohibited, IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS FAX TRANSMISSION IN ERROR,PLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY BY TELEPHONE,AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL TRANSMITTAL TO US AT THE ABOVEADDRESS VIA THE U.S.POSTAL SERVICE,Thank you. IJUL.15.1999 1:17PM TA SCHILLING PC 5087750792 N0.622 P.2 LAW OFFICES OF TELEPHONE:508 775 0700 THEODORE, A. SCHILLING, P.C. FACSIMILE: 508 775 0792 1550 Falmouth Road-Suite 10 Centerville,MA 02632 EMAIL: lawcape.com SENT BY FAA:7RO 6230 June 29,1999 Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Town of Barnstable 367 Main Street Hyannis,MA 02601 RE. 27 York Terrace, Osterville Lot 20 on L.C. Plan 15967-G & Lot.23 on L.C. .Plan 15967-H Owners: John C. and Gwen C. McDaniel Dear Ralph: You may recall that earlier this Spring my clients,John and Gwen McDaniel were having some renovation work done to the outer building/garage at the above captioned property. The work was being done by Peacock and Crosby. The work started out as replacement of doors and windows and the project then developed into a much more extensive renovation including the removal or the existing kitchen,wiring and plumbing. At that time the work was stopped. My clients have since lured a new contractor who will file for a complete and proper building permit. However., we now seek to replace the kitchen that was located in the garage building adjacent to the swimming pool. This is not to be an apartment and is only to be used in connection with the residence and as part of the pool area. My clients,as you may recall,purchased this property about 2 years ago with the kitchen installed, and represented to them at that time, as proper under the provisions of the Town By-Laws. They now seek to re-install the kitchen p 7LL.15.1999 1:18P11 TA SCHILLI1h: PC 5097750792 NO.622 P.S Mr. Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Page Two June 29, 1999 associated with the swirruxung pool and hereby request that you determine whether or not you will allow the same so that they can re-apply for a building permit and continue their work. I would greatly appreciate your forwarding a copy of this letter by FAX to me, indicating whether or not you would allow us to apply for a building permit to re-install the kitchen. Th you for your attention to this inatter and your quick response. Very Y'v .� O i E SCHI zNG �S r ACQNOWL.FDGMEN T 7/RESPONSE. By: A:\CR0SSEN_LTR.wpd a� - LAW OFFICES OF TELEPHONE:508 775 0700 THEODORE A. SCHILLING, P.C. FACSIMILE: 508 775 0792 1550 Falmouth Road-Suite 10 Centerville,MA 02632 EMAIL: law@cape.com SENT BY FAX: 790 6230 June 29, 1999 Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Town of Barnstable 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 RE: 27 York Terrace, Osterville Lot 20 on L.C. Plan 15967-G &Lot 23 on L.C. Plan 15967-H Owners:John.C. and Gwen C.,McDaniel Dear Ralph ,. . . You may recall that earlier this Spring my clients,John and Gwen McDaniel were having some renovation work done to the outer building/garage at the above captioned property. The work was being done by Peacock and Crosby. The work started out as replacement of doors and windows and the project then developed into a much more extensive renovation including the removal of the existing kitchen, wiring and plumbing. At that time the work was stopped. My clients have since hired a new contractor who will file for a complete and proper building permit. However, we now seek to replace the kitchen that was located in the garage building adjacent to the swimming pool. This is not to be an apartment and is only to be used in connection with the residence and as part of the pool area.. My clients,as you may recall,purchased this property about 2 years ago with the kitchen installed, and represented to them at that time, as proper under the provisions.of.the Town By-Laws. They now seek to re-install the kitchen T \.f'� .J: Mr. Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Page Two June 29, 1999 associated with the swimming pool and hereby request that you determine whether or not you will allow the same so that they can re-apply for a building permit and continue their work. I would greatly appreciate your forwarding a copy of this letter by FAX to me, indicating whether or not you would allow us to apply for a building permit to re-install the kitchen. j h you for your attention to this matter and your quick response. y , E HI ING ACKNOWLEDGMENT/RESPONSE: -By: Ralph Crossen A:\CROSSEN.LTR.wpd LAW OFFICES OF ���' rwq * * = THEODORE A. SCHILLING, P.C. First 0 8 _ 1550 Falmouth Road-Suite 10 os JUL � 20 ���- � d u Centerville,NIA 02632 /990, r 0 8 5 Mr. Ralph Crossen -- Building Commissioner TOWN OF BARNSTABLE 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 l i �� � . �� '� '� • � . t 1 1 � a f f �� { f `+ + /f" � ' • J ,' f �� ' V� rt fMl ... s . Town of Barnstable Planning Department Staff Report McDaniels Appeal Number 1999-118-Appeal of the Building Commissioner Appeal Number 1999-119-Variance to Section 3-1.3 RC Residential District Date: October 5, 1999 To: Zoning Bo of Appeals From: Approved By: Robe P. Schernig,AICP, Planning Director Reviewed By: Art Traczyk, Principal Planner Drafted By: Alan Twarog, AICP, Associate Planner Applicants: John C.&Gwen C. McDaniels Property Address: 27 York Terrace, Osterville Assessors Map/Parcel: Map 140, Parcel 150.001 Area: 0:58 acre _ Zoning: RC Residential C Zoning District Groundwater Overlay: AP Aquifer Protection District' Filed:July 27, 1999 Hearing:October 13, 1999 Decision Due:January 03,2000(includes a 60 day extension) Background: The property that is the subject of these appeals consists of a 0.58 acre lot commonly addressed as 27 York Terrace, Osterville. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a living area of approximately 3,876 sq. ft. The other building is a one and a half story, detached garage/apartment structure with a living area of approximately 745 sq. ft.' The assessor's field card lists this structure as a single-family dwelling. In the spring of 1999, the applicants were issued a building permit(#35965)for the replacement of windows and doors in the garage/apartment building. Evidently, the renovation work expanded to include 'v the removal of the existing kitchen, wiring and plumbing. In the process of this additional work, after the removal of the interior, a Stop Order was issued. In a letter dated June 29, 1999 from Attofney Theodore Schilling to Ralph Crossen, the applicants requested that a new building permit be issued to allow the replacement of the kitchen. In response to this letter, the Building Commissioner wrote"must get a variance-the apartment is illegal". According to the applicants, the kitchen was already installed when they purchased the property in 1998. They contend that the second kitchen in the garage building adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single- family dwelling use only and is not in violation of any zoning by-law or ordinance. The applicants are appealing the decision of the Building Commissioner not to issue a building permit to allow the re- installation of the previously existing kitchen. In the alternative, they have also applied for a Variance to Section 3-1.3 of the Zoning Ordinance. Requested Relief: Appeal Number 1999-118-request for enforcement action and an appeal of the Building Commissioner's refusal to allow the issuance of a building permit for the replacement of a previously existing kitchen that was removed during the renovation of the subject building. According to Assessor's records dated 10/05/99 r, T Town of Barnstable-Planning Department-Staff Report McDaniels Appeal Number 1999-118-Appeal of the Building Commissioner Appeal Number 1999-119-Variance to Section 3-1.3 Appeal Number 1999-119-Variance to Section 3-1.3 to allow a second kitchen in an accessory building to the primary residence. The second kitchen would be used in association with the use of the swimming pool and would be used only in connection with the main residence. This appeal is in the alternative to Appeal Number 1999-118.. Staff Review: The applicants contend that the second kitchen is used strictly for single-family dwelling use only and is not in violation of the Zoning Ordinance. Section 2-3.6(1) of the Zoning Ordinance only allows one principal permitted building on a residential lot. The Zoning Ordinance defines a single-family dwelling as "A detached residential building designed for and occupied by a single family." It has been the policy of the Town to consider a structure to be a separate dwelling unit if it contains a kitchen as well as a bath and living space. One of the reasons for this policy is help prevent people from installing a second kitchen for the purposes of renting an apartment unit in single-family residential districts. The Building Commissioner has concluded that the garage apartment is illegal. There are no building permit applications in the file that authorize the installation of the kitchen in the garage building. A building permit was issued in 1990 for the furnishing of the upstairs into a playroom and the installation of a bathroom only. Variance Findings: Inconsideration for the Variance, the petitioner must-substantiate those conditions.unique to this lot or. structure that justify the granting of the relief being sought., Ingranting of the Variance the Board must -find that: • unique conditions exist that affect the locus but not the zoning.district in which it is located, • a literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve substantial.hardship, financial or otherwise to the petitioner, and • the relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. Suggested Conditions: If the Board should find to grant the requested Variance, they may wish to impose the following conditions: 1. The garage apartment unit shall not be.rented to anyone. 2. At no time shall the garage/apartment building be put on a separate meter service. Attachments: Applications Copies: Petitioners/Applicants Assessor's Field Cards GIS Map Property Deed Floor Plans Plot Plan Building Permit Applications June 29, 1999 Letter from Attorney Schilling 2 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE Zoning Board of Appeals &�+'�'O���T�r'F•. R < Applca°tiori..,fb`r/w+Other Powers0. D R v {- - ,Q� s,,t� l t: ,; :•� `� For office use owl !` f� T cif/ 1 J!1 s_ L AppealC # - , Hearing Date 10 2 7lsefet Decision Due 13 " 1�9 ! T e u a plies to the Zoning Board of Appeals for the reasons indic80RR�DOABLE F�ApLS 6 Applicant Name: John C. & Gwen C. MCDANIEIS Phone 508 755 2290 Applicant Address: 23 Metcalf Street, Worcester, MA 01609 Property Location: 27 YORK TERRACE, OSTERVILLE, MA 02655 This is a request for: XW4 Enforcement Action [] Appeal of Administrative officials Decision [] ' Repetitive Petitions . [ ] Appeal from the Zoning Administrator ['] other General Powers - Please Specify: Please Provide the Following Information (as applicable): Property owner: John C. and Gwen C. MCDANIEI,S Phone 508 755 2290 Address of owner: 23 Metcalf St., Worcester, MA 01609 zf applicant differs from owner, state nature of interest: Assessors Map/Parcel Number 140 - 150 - 1 Zoning District RF Groundwater overlay District which section(s) of the Zoning ordinance and/or of MGL chapter 40A are you appealing to the Zoning Board of Appeals? applicant seeks to overturn Building Commissioner who has refused to allow the issuance of a building permit to replace removed i c en wrien upgraded. Existing Level of Development of the Property - Number of Buildings: two (2) Present use(s) : single family residential dwep4i*Uss Floor Area: 3,200 +/-sq. ft. Yt Application for Other Powers Nature & Description of Request: Petitioner seeks to overturn building otm ni.ssioner's Stop Order for renovations to garage use and upstairs sleeping area and first floor kitchen and living area used in connection with the residence and as part of the pool & deck area. Building cammi.ssioner alleges that the kitchen is not allowed under zoning by-law. Petitioner states that the 2nd kitchen in the garage adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single family dwelling use only and is not. in violation of any zoning or ordinance. Petitioner purchased said ached separate sheet if needed. `>A Is the property located in an Historic District? Yes [] No ) If yes ORH Use Only: Plan Review Number Date Approved Is the building a .designated Historic Landmark? Yes (] _ Now If yes Historic Preservation Department Use Only.: Date Approved Has a building permit been applied for? Yes ] No [] Has the Building Inspector refused a permit? Yes ] No [ ] . Has the property been before Site Plan Review? Yes (] No kk For Building Department Use only: Not Required - single Family [ ] site Plan Review Number Date Approved signature: The following information must be submitted with the application at the time of filing, failure to supply this may result in a denial of your request: Three (3) copies of the completed application form, each with original signatures. Three (3) copies. of all attachments as may be required for standing before the Board and for clear understanding of your appeal. The applicant may submi a y a ditional orting documents to assist the Board in m it Is a n. signature: Date: June 29, 1999 44piA p icant or A nt,s signat re: by: ore A. Schilling, At In Fact Agents Address: 1550 Falmouth Road, suit 10 phone: 508 775 0700 Centerville MA 02632 775 0792 Fax No. r ,f TOWN OF BARNSTABLE Zoning Board of Appeals Application for Other Powers - Continuance Sheet Applicant Name: John C. and Gwen C. McDaniels Property Location: 27 York Terrace, Osterville, MA 02655 Nature & Description of Request: dwelling with pool, garage containing kitchen and upstairs living area, and that was represented as valid and existing legal use. Petitioner attempted to replace windows;doors and upgrade quality of the construction of the existing kitchen and . living area of the garage and in the process of work;after.-removal of the interior,• Building' Commissioner issued a Stop Order preventing the Petitioner from.' completing and reinstalling the existing kitchen. Petitioner uses said kitchen in connection with the pool and the garage living'area is used as part of the single- family use of the property and has not and will not be used as an apartment for lease or otherwise. Wherefore Petitioner requests that. the Board of Appeals overrules the Building Commissioner and directs him to issue a building permit for completion of the kitchen and the remainder of the garage under construction. AAAPPL.POWERS.wpd j ,J LAW OFFICES OF TELEPHONE:508 775 0700 THEODORE A. SCHILLING, P.C. FACSIMILE: 508 775 0792 1550 Falmouth Road-Suite 10 Centerville,MA 02632 EMAIL: law@cape.com SENT BY FAX: 790 6230 June 29, 1999 Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner Town of Barnstable 367 Main Street Hyannis; MA 02601 RE 27 York Terrace, Osterville Lot 20 on L.C.-Plan 15967-G & Lot.23 on L.C. Plan 15967:H , Owners:John C. and Gwen C. McDaniel Dear Ralph: You may recall that earlier this Spring my clients,John and Gwen McDaniel were having some renovation work done to the outer building/garage at the above captioned property. The work was being done by Peacock and Crosby. The work started out as replacement of doors and windows and the project. then developed into a much more extensive renovation including the removal of the existing kitchen, wiring and plumbing. At that time the work was stopped. My clients have since hired a new contractor who will file for a complete and proper building permit. However, we now seek to replace the kitchen that was located in the garage building adjacent to the swimming pool. This is not to be an apartment and is only to be used in connection with the residence and as part of the pool area. My clients,as you may recall,purchased this property about 2 years ago with the kitchen installed, and represented to them at that time, as proper under the provisions of the Town By-Laws. They now seek to re-install the kitchen IN LLIN6 F;v. !VIr. Ralph Cros_en Building Cocwlissioner Page Two June 29, 1999 associated with the swunmir. o or not you will 4ow the sauce suothat hh 1equesttl-,at You deiezmine wlzetiler continue their work. aPPIY far a building Permit and j would greatly appreciate Your forward- whether a :. me, indicating Whether or not you would alloy, us to to a COPY of this letter b to tie-install the kitchen. Y FAX to pply fora ouilding Permit .. _� . . you for Your Y attetttfon'to this matter and 9n r ouick res o Very y Y P rtise. "` • . ,AVM f. .O E 5 l\TG /gs AC'ICNOti1'I,FDGMEIV /RESPONSE: By,4t i� -- 2 F . TOWN OF BARNSTABLE Zoning Hoard of Appeals 1N0 ^"•' ROE 8 �••++.. '" A nlication to petition"fora'a variancePpROp o D CS u'�STARI4 SIC 'Z C For office : C o `Date Recei � ClerJc,Ot a „_ APPeal # ' LJl1 L ( gearing Date 1011b SE Decision Due .113 Oo t t TOWN Of BARNSTgg� , ebx applies to the zoning Board of Appeals for a variance from M1the Zoning ordinance, in the manner and for the reasons hereinafter set forth: Petitioner Name: Jot',n C-. Mcnaniels & GAM C. VzDaniel s , .Phone-508 755 2220 Petitioner Address: 23 Metcalf Street, Worcester, MA 01609 Property Location: 27 YORK-TERRACE, MERV • MA 02655 Property owner: same as Petitioner Phone same Address of owner: If petitioner differs from owner, state nature of interest: Number of Years owned: two (20 As Map/Parcel Number: -1 Zoning District: RF Groundwater overlay District: variance Requested: Cite Section 6 ritle of. the Zoning Ordinance Description of variance Requested: Petit,i seeks yaria*+ro to allcm for a seCXMd kitchen in an accessary building to a primary residence associated with the use of the swmnnmg poo in connection wit4jthe residential dwelling and use. Description of the Reason and/or Need for the variance: Petitioner seeks variance du' to building cannissioner's refusal to allow 2 kitchens in a single family residential property. Petitioner assumes that this is under the zoning ordinance that only allows tor single y and no ralltiple apartment use. However. Petitioner is not seeking Discription of construction Activity (if applicable) : No exterior constructlon other than replacement of windows is requested. All con- interior as snown and defined an a McDenlP 's Residence" drawn by Kitchen Romer of Falmouth, Inc. Existing Level of Development of the Property - Number of Buildings: two (2) /swimming pool Present Use(s) : single family residence with , Gross Floor Area: 3,200 +/- sq.ft. Proposed Gross Floor Area to be Added: 0 Altered: 700 +/- sq. ft. is this property subject to any other relief (variance or special Permit) from the Zoning Board of Appeals? Yes [ ] No QC�{ If Yes, please list appeal numbers or aoplicant,s name �t Application to Petition for a variance is the property within a Historic District? Yes [] No.w is the property a Designated Landmark? Yes [] No IT9 For Historic Department Use only: Not Applicable . . .. . . . .. . . .. . . [] OKH Plan Review Number Date Approved . signature: Have you applied for a building permit? Yesxj} No [ ] Has the Building Inspector refused a permit? Yes Xkk No [] • F All applications for a variance which proposes a change in use, new construction, reconstruction; alterations or expansion, except for single or two-family dwellings, will require an approved site Plan (see section 4- 7.3 of the Zoning ordinance) . That process should be completed prior to submitting this application to the zoning Board of Appeals. ". For Buildinc Decartinent Use only: `Not Required .. ... . . . . . . . . . .. .[] site Plan Review Number Date Approved signature: The followings information must be submitted with the Petition at the time of filing, without such information the Board of Appeals may deny your request: Three (3) copies of the completed Application Norm, each with original signatures. Five (5) copies of a certified property survey (plot plan) showing the dimensions of the land, all wetlands, water bodies, surrounding roadways and the location -of the existing improvements on the land. All proposed development activities, except single and two-family housing development, will require five (5) copies of a proposed site improvements plan approved by the site Plan Review Committee. This plan must show the exact location of. all proposed improvements and alterations on the land and. to structures. see •Contents of Site Plan:" Section 4-7.5 of the Zoning ordinance, for detail requirements. The petitioner may sub y anal s orting documents to assist .the Board in m 'n in fact by: Theodc Date: June 29, 1999 signature: Pe '- oner o Agent's sigma ure 1550 Falmouth Rd., Site 0 Phone: 508 775 0700 Agent's Address: , 775 92 Centerville, MA02632 Fax No. TOWN OF BARNSTABLE Zoning Board of Appeals Application to Petition for a Variance -Continuance Sheet Applicant Name: John C. and Gwen C. McDaniels Property Location: 27 York Terrace, Osterville, MA 02655 Description of the Reason and/or Need for the Variance: to create a separate apartment, rather a single family/one family use having two (2) kitchens, one of which is used in connection.with the swimming pool. . Y A:\APPL.VARIANCE.wpd r 1 ` DOC-733,019 07-14-9E 02:24 CTF91149342 BAR14STABLE LAND COURT REGISTRY Return to: MASBACBUSETTB QUITCLAIM DEED I, Richard E. T. Brooks, Or., Trustee of the Brooks Family Realty Trust u/d/t dated March 18, 1996 and recorded with the Barnstable Registry of Deeds, Land Court Section, as Document No. 667350 with Land Court Certificate of Title No. 140894, with a mailing address of 30 Mountain Road, Princeton, MA 01541, for consideration paid, and in full consideration of Six hundred sixty thousand and 00/100 ($660,000.00) Dollars grants to sod, C. me Dar.,I of 23 (he rAq St Wovoes*n MA OK09 with QUITCLAIM COir&ANTS the land in Osterville, Massachusetts,..,,, " A more particularly bounded and described as follows: The land together with any buildings thereon-, .situated in • Barnstable' (Osterville), Barnstable:County, Massachusetts,: more'. _ particularly described as follows: p Lot 20 as shown on Land Court Plan 15967-G and Lot 23 as �. . shown on Land Court Plan 15967=H', together with the right to use York Terrace as described in Document No. 307152. For Grantor's title, see Certificate of Title No. 140894. O No title examination was performed by the preparer of this instrument. iH WITNESS my hand and seal this 7 day of May, 1998. Y r Richard E T. Brooks, Sr., Trustee of the Brooks Family Realty Trust COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Worcester, ss. Date: 11404 Then personally appeared the above named Richard E. T. Brooks, Sr., Trustee of the Brooks Family Realty Trust and W (h N Cd[V� N 0S a , tirn o o C9 Q 4li 4� G W N 04 NCV .+ a Ix2' CDNN[V a o Y z 1 o u S.l Cl CJ r O U acknowledged the foregoing instrument to be his free act and deed, before me, Notary Public My commission expires: O N A S,...,,. ' SN i� O j C•_1 �J.' CHAPTER 183 SEC. 6 AS AMENDED BY CHAPTER 497 OF 1969 Every Deed presented for record shall contain or have endorsed upon it the full name, residence and post office address of the grantee and a recital of the amount of the full consideration thereof in dollars or the nnture of the other consideration therefor, if not delivered for a specific monetary sum. The full consideration shall mean the total price for the conveyance without deduction for any liens or encumbrances assumed by the grantee or remaining thereon. All such endorsements and recitals shall be recorded as part of the dead. Failure to comply with this section shall not affect the validity of any deed. No register of deeds shall accept a deed for recording unless it is in compliance with the requirements of this section. DOC:748,595 12-08 5D Ol Q'o MASOACNU•aTTO QUITCLAIM 0990 411NOt1T FORM IINDIVIDUALI 681 CTFIit151169 I, John C. McDaniel, BRR14STABLE LAHD COURT REGISTRY of Worcester, Worcester County.Massachusetts, i" beingYNknarrfeef,for consideration paid,and in full consideration of less than one hundred 1($100.00) dollars. r grantto John C. McDaniel and Gwen C. McDaniel as husband and wife, tenants by the• entirety. of 23 Metcalf Street with gUtttldMtootaanta ` Worcester, MA 01609 thelandin Osterville, Massachusetts, more particularly bounded and described as follows: IDewripdon and eocumbranrn.it anyl sr.• The land together with any buildings thereon, situated in Barnstable (Osterville), Barnstable County,Massachusetts,more particularly described as follows: r' Lot 20 as shown on Land Court Plan 15967-G and Lot 23 as shown on Land Court Plan 13967-K together with the right to use York Terrace as described in Document No.307152. For Grantor's title,see Certificate of Title No. 3'>} i No title examination was performed by the preparer of this instrument. The consideration being less than$100.00,there are no revenue stamps due. . N i O .M{1 !1laess my hand and seal this 7th day of December ,i9-21L John C. McDaniel 7!' i (obe leammaawtabb of>Aleaeat:busette x� Worcester, ss. December 7, 1998 ,.;. Then personally appeared the above named John C. McDaniel V.', and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to he his fr act eed before me 1 Return To: David L. Bennett, Esquire Da v L. ennett.Nour),PON I(2G30( Bennett 6 Forts. P.C. et 06/ My commission capl A I 1093 Main Street Holden. MA 01520 PQ�G�S`O ✓ - ^y ('Individual—joint Tenants—Tcants in Commit ChIAY11?g 1MjSE(:.6ASAMENDE.DNY(:IIAPTfRi97arIsX.N Every deed pressntcd for record shall contain or have endorsed upon It the full name,residence a nI Wit of the grantee and s recital of she amou I of the full consideration thereof In dollars or the nature of the other considerat then not delivered for a specific monetary sum.The full consideration shall mean the total price fur the conveyance without deduct for a lets of encumbrances . i' assumed by the grantee or remaining thereon.All such endorsements and recitals shall he rmlyded as pan Failure to comply i with this section shall not affect the validity of any deed.No regimer lddeeds shall accept a deed for recording unless it is in compliance with •• the requirements of this section. �,�ry _ �,•� 1��i i� ; G °� �3 /5 av - ►� BARNSTABLE REGISTRY OF DEEDS wig �XBI• ...•' 1 6 �} oa o t' WIN O rrip 16CIO w 10 16n� o wrla i ( rle 0 O I# ;. 14 7 n 1 '7t �1 1 2WIN.� :. wula 1 1 w114° 1Q # 161-1 WIN ttso 12 j s 29 �A z , wig ,..,., 15 t 1 2 ° I 494' I \ •. 1`" 129 i146 ' ti9f \ 0 1 2 1 \ 13 IN t9 o 300 FTA151 t�4 w 46 3� wr14a 1sm1 1 1t.,1�° t on 11 '•t to O 1 wrla `WIN 9m 1 > 1 4-1 MAP 140 PARCEL 150-1 N JOHN & GWEN McDANIELS w s SUILE: 1 n=150' ...\barn\dgn\mcdaniels140.dgn Sep.20,1999 14:07:27 • • / I I 1 1 -xr �;9'A" q'!'a'®• `e '¢•5. I tF r iY'�J�r! ,�T Ir B to I .. Y. .t � .} r r. p .n �. �3'oJ B>n,;}�9A�cjJ.r s�r;,xa:+�:�{n,,sa• �'! ��x � � >,�ts» ,{�r tar y:a a�v��, n, �y�a' r�,,{� �sy,�up�v �wa �'�' �'�>�ib'7�9i ��•¢•-.N �,?.SEE:;,'��"H�� nY� �l:+�aztD!71ii�i�'9;i:?&t}'Y14,o15,1k%:�fik'LL'7:6e�CiC«E ���w.s•.�>:ZiGd. :t:R11:a1:1...° .`�.e:-' s �3�v:i5:.I�{+:• 4t;:7,'� %5�'e•s;f7E3,isL,�i`x�l�l±ItIW°)'Srl1 "`�! 'S¢.",ra1<Ii.!�!r', ,33 METCALF1' � II I I 1 1 .sue"E' ai Y s•:, UB.r '/?r!9.11 1f6,N13'S�Mer(1��,'�p'Jr 'ENE '�'�;f/ '`.���.�tr>t•�,f`��t',���L�Fklf�1�.1v^7���'£vu�[i' [S�ril'.4v'Lv9GP.l19'LYt{C'Lt1:7Ii;. =f '• 300 I Life Estate ML I LOT , . • n N ,P 1' - •c\.,.9'!t'-':,yf, 7"�'. -r. 'h. B�'tpsO llI 1 r : P fwkar t:". a,d *+ 'f.t:r .,� ,drP �J,R:L.'LV its I. '`t`/A "•8s� .d) t ki tl` t �` ;� i,�(''yy,� ,•�...,. ..��. �'.'^v: .t {�sz^- ar � >l,��i�+ (✓ . r� 6�� <.rr df ti .,� ��:i'iv'� '. �4 ;f3 .>t I: 9i":Le lt� { -.Yob't^.� ,'dw'•>wv1,5�t�'�s�..,rrc:,'��7renY'}�:�,t!..:?aS�:�>kl�El',��,xrl" �7riy'1�r �j 8. 1"�r"I' +.1G''- `�1i✓ :::uJ3.z,.ii -Ir.K:a'M.' FLr.rv.."+GuE�fl4t.1..i:.c.'".Azt..F.r�%s'�?,�'.:.1 .>:3mk�3i a�':'d$,.61Pa.�i�;d ..�F1.7_� .ai:.?.+..1_.-.EL%.v.ay. .1: 1 � � J�nrrr�' r � rJ�nLOL.tp� rJ�n 1 I • ,I I • ..I III I I 1 I 1'I I 1 I I • I; 11 1 I; I, • 11 I I I I 1 1 11 ' 1 1 1; I 1 I II I I I 'l l I I 901 J' GREGORY,DAVID TR C90577 . 12/15/198� In GREGORY, 1 - I I T C95030 I I I I ��.•ILL f lil��1't114I111��171ti'i,l>.1 r v tC ;e' rw =m N 7 v 1N C F ltiL A di f6 a fT• I / Y tT� �4d Tr 1i1��', ��,,f.•r.����..w�.��:�z�au� ak.nc..s?�.�.r•'.J ,y�4��6�� �,���n� -��w s •�rBrA�aJ�,�4®���<�rr,l�{' at'�'t �� �x�n !riirSlY.�!. fst i ].f�rA`: L�i✓i�+$''I'�d-.�rtE.)'�-.f,�_w(:'S.��1.-�.'.t•,f!1'.�.$•t�� AppraisedAppraised g.Value(Card) 332,900 XrValue 1 • I � }. �34'� N5l' +..il'.l�"r}l Laud '157,8I 1 f;•Y' v',-ua 'Sa+'fin£ us Y.s`¢...'Yrr., �..4 as5e. .>'n: k! ]f k7..ir rt:, z.n � '" v,. I,._x. S.. n., e:?,`:. .R 5 .iu F t Appraised:Land Value Total 11 'r r Value 560,2 Total496,6111 Valuation Method. AefTenApp—mm"n - e I I I i.,. .m.:- - sr. - n>'... .•a✓' .sJ: e 1 •t'•r erti ..... .. r uc..Y _ ti .�aaa +.t.,^uc 1E;'tU r rrnd°r'' "� J I.�fr�r-I ;W'RT. ,rr, J.-f, �s.i:;'B J LGlgn .51n +�tf:., 'P71 s+9< r mac, c4•:rr ' Y'z �;'.. q...� (f. .,G « 1' ,,.° F'F. 2�''w,:' < �.�,u s;A �I,� -� r ""C'.�,a."zlf"i�.�e'_ .' .,,..;.. ',.�..•y�� y1 a. yg�9- y,{ , /. w,�rp I f�. .3s.�. 1: dn''.`i. ..'a �zl 0:,4� h;� q r ,G y� <s:,�t• .r�''.:725�d7J 'tiSaS��i4'.ta2•.'ds,' '.a,Yi �" t,tk,u;;.,:h�:k..As.t,.�.:d1�WAla.C_".?a'J�CxY,..:S.'E.^L.,Cr..:�:<L��"LL7.•�`tQSd' ,.u._,.�:.:..�:.il.L�til�t?�iiY.�:S°�4G.'i :....�.-J�.7.;:iii .:.[{.i�t'3i �' 2f1+�1.��AArr�1.ixUlP1."+In$t.:.: r"tl.�rui8��. I' I 1 III 11 1'RENOVI 1 II t 'I I I IS SW.POO IS 11 �- r••r I Jd+. ¢t:. F �q r' v. "f e, rt f ""=¢TMr' f'"': ,lKtn_F >r:. m.. YT Jr !. .r < fI f(tr a9 >E? €i.BY` tN TTjr.!n j Or`' Y s �k "im^ n�. A",= 1r„ �4.. �,� '�• �1J(�� q (y� y f (Qz`�� �am�'.�,,j�;/ ,.{ .Y �.��y-�{ ',.d�.� �-{•,f' x �J r� •`v .4. k.'aY 8 'i'tl K4 �j/y.":�d�-�'yp'j��'s�`,Y l�r+D'aillRle�11V11e1�9+-�Y:�i¢.�f,�.✓,[i1f'i-1eY:.n• 71 �Y;HRY�3r�a�.�,iliv4fo'i���S4..�N}luTa^�fVY��iv...¢.Y�NY._{11145d.�-4t�^.i{.. �Al�r�rritirr�n�:,rr,rar.�,�B�,r`��.' nrrr•.,_ I I I J � I � • I I'I I'I I I I I � ��� I'Il ' • I I f I I• I I'I I I :I'1 Property Lecadon: 27 YORK TERR OST MAP ID: 140/150/001// Vision M.8838 Otliw ID: Bldg#: 1 Card 1 of 2 Print Date:10/05/1999 gip en escrip on ommer Wren e ooven oElement eacrip on odet 1 idential e + + frame Type Eadisli'lumbing Front Saywindow 2x7es Storiescupancy 0 ling/Wall0 234 Exterior Wall 1 4 ood Shingle ommon Wall 2 ll Heigh 8M Roof Structure 3 GableMp us Roof Cover 3 pb/F Gls/Cmp 22 Interior Wall 1 8 rypical amen o e es peon ac or 2 Interior Floor 1 10 rypical r AX 1 2 o�it I. cati umbe on 0 Heating Fuel 1 one Heating Type 1 one r of Units C Type 1 one umber of Levels /o Ownership edrooms Bedrooms 10 3 athrooms Bathrooms g 1 0 Full .ijuse rim otal Rooms Rooms ize Adj.Factor .87385 3 e(Q)Index 67 9 ath Type dj.Base Rate 0.05 1W 7 tchen Style ldg.Value New 11,092 21 ear Built 900 Year Built 994 12 rml Physcl Dep 3 cnl Obslnc Obslnc pecl.Cond.Code a { e ese on ercen a e 1 Cond% 0 single am erall%Cond. 07 eprec.Bldg Value 332,900 e cnp on t Price r. ps Value 0o rFOP eserrp on Living ross Area rea n rec. a ue oor , reh,Open,Finished 64 13 14. 9;1per Story,Finished 1,83 1,83 1,83 70. 128,61 sement,Unfinished 1,83 36 14.0 25;70 WDK Wood Deck 68C 6 7.0 4,76 may; a r7' �d"IAAH a :vt" v,tT G �. 4ra," dl W i:,�•° G 1.:.e!; JK u�` t7y,irp 37� '�..anJ '�fl r Ft'w„`^U a'."i. METCALF 1 1 IRdNp��i7 .K::��ata- ....a;w<,.'�IE a...,t;a�:�•`s��.6rsm>t��s��as� ':rn,�s"`"k',_{�,,,r 7cti .�^�[��� r,Alccotmt 755YU P Life listate 1DI,I LOTI :• , .. 1 GUL Fes,- / r a n ;s r>ry 9_ �''llTftlll�]']Il141j1 q p r• 4.4 w. ^ �?. lcaf .d1Y 'G.ti9 9 B,AB' l .SST, ,Yr" t 31Lf1 tiB SI" m.Pt� S I, 1 •,, I 'alt���'e�^�e r-'��-� ..�� aG�^�' ,'�'t"�<,t'`'rr".r.:�?�..a'`;�0�1_vc.'� 1�'L� a. ���i�a:��,:�,"a 1 �aa 4"�,"�.,'"-s'• �y (�' .�yl '� -4.� ,�y'n .x 1 :1• ft�■L.L'� Q�LEiL ��l r-zrJ�nr���c:-rra� rs rr.�n.rrra I ' 1 I 1 :1 I ' 1 ..11 1 1 I I � • I I li I'1 1 I 1 1 I. • 1 1 C140894 1 587 ' 1 1 C116508 1 570 III I I 1 1 I 1 1 1 GREGORY,DAVID T C95030 11 II Z;REGORY,DAVID TR C90577 ': . 118511 I ¢a-. .sm� •' Ir:� b-g� s1".- • ''':. . •. P' is• biF:C T',��s �p �'Ig �L]111c11D���tQ11kllD "r I rl r6K' y 1`a I iCJf e *`'tn3 .,�"F 9'm.` 'i°k' acknowledges f r Go ti��� c�'��"'=:i'•i�$K?����A'�afD �7�8 ?�n�?7p>HS�✓��iS�I������'� } Appraised Bldg.-Value(Card) 63,6001 Appraised (Bldg) Appraised i ,'9g 5� ,.'S""'' r _,Ft ny� Hny ��qa A( y xn .. r-m < ��� [':.' ��• i �9 •Land. 11 1 't°�f ;. '3. � :'.....u�. ',=,'a,.tl'£�' a:. i."..F"`' " .YY2il+g�."ar M + ry •�' iw iWi fit. 'F f�" "1 f� t�. - y I� .�Y.����r�,l {�i,:.!f'`:T Value ..,t �� .:.:.:....... tk Special . Valuation Method: CosVM&r ket Total Appraised Parcel Value 221,401 re�"^�s }77;y .�.. �i•.r {'i's«i �:t'z:�• %1• :i q -':'7'r^i' R•'a* 1 4" tr< ss<r ^n -a.`;H`wl• ��"x- ^x,;�:� a= s- a:m;A �x5ITI' 1. :.'i?, .t,. `7' a, ,u ., ;m}T�11 kd3d .w. ,GiS :dl ,a.•,r'47'At?, .� r eZ'. °h.1,S`. .te. ti°.T '2 •P 4�y`i�E •G %�•.., .s:'�' t y,;.1. .. :s - �..�`X�T•J "' ':fkJY: -, n � 'Jh'4 � _.YY• aM y� ,� �,:! .� Fx; a;. �"�.t-.:;1?�(J .h..lr..,. a a5.71 ..c.u�.;r...:....`�. CI ..ws »b�lr�.v.:�•rirc.,..� �IlarE ".L'3"s�D.3i.S.^S,'u.�.'�'-"4P.'G.�i..�rG� .,S�w'S._��=x..! t�'i '�`'.^r: i.w:. _??„b..::��•+'�Y r3�`A�wv� ���E�C�.I,",�•d?�I 1 �w�,�n :��!.SA i� _..o., , .. .....,. �:,.. �u -:� � w,., n. mizF661"I, 1 ,x. .��., • t a...,� :Y> °.. v4. -, !�T- � r'gfsl.'t 3'7G ' !s 9' a. 77+' °�S''. G f ai". :_y. �r 'S'a'F'-,.`. ':> •^t' .,.r2' t•.' 5s �'�.L`sf „', , � ��-. Sh}; tr...'� v..a, '3.•r a•,1 n , � w�F sr .�� � '.�'-_,.v���ie3�as`�"t?� '� �•°. �?f�:r�.><?fit? �. -;3" A i�'(y�.w .t`�: sr ��K�! �1f�.`�,..•^'.�."la ,F. t-.'m�is,.��w�'>$sa' u��' .:�s�`� >�a3,.v "� ,�.<arc- kr�Fr.,>-a �, xu �.•(+�... .^a.,_ �fiY-`YFdStA1:�. t�Helt„(ctnd`wi� =5 '"?�tebt L�fiJ�' [:�3LJL � ' Sjir"Li-�L �d' L' L►L'7�4 s;`r rnn�.Tn�..9zA1LarRw•rr�n�r� I I I I I 1 1 I'I •. .�� I•Il •I I'I 1'1 I'I I n InT I r I I I r:�• ,n � ^,rrr: I Property Location: 27 YORK TERR OST MAP ID: 1401 150/001// r alon ID:8838 Other ID: Bldg#: 2.' Cord 2 of 2 Print Date:10/05/1999 vemni La. Imcnplion LOMMMIX Ma KIM= r, e 6 nven o escnp on Model l ldendal grade B tame Type ths/Plumbing Storm .5 1/2 Stories :UK 22 Hg Occupancy 0 ling/Wall Exterior Wall 1 1 3apboard i6 Gmmon Wall 2 all Height UOM Hoof Structure 7 brei BAS hoof Cover 0 Need Shingle Interior Wall 1 rywall ` 2 e on rr Interior Floor 4 arpetomp ex j 21 nor Ad nit Location Heating Fuel 4 lectrie 0 2 0 Heating Type 9 ical umber of Units AC Type 1 one umber of Levels Ownership Bedrooms 1 Bedroom Bathrooms Bathroom t 0 Full JIM=e total Rooms Rooms ize Adj.Factor .294SS Bath Type a(Q)Index .22 r':`. "'18 22 Kitchen S le dj.Base Rate 5.91 tY ]dg.Value New 6,568 - ear Built Year Built 990 Physcl Dep 7 uncrnl Obsinc Obslnc ecl.Cond.Code e escn n erce a pecl Cond°h Single am stall/°Cond. 93 eprec.Bldg Value 63,600 Lode DesAcriplion 12,111 unitsunit r. Up JU KLXd Apr.value e Description LtWngArea utwsAreaArea I Unitrec. ve TST rloor FGR hed Garage 0 SM 19 26.6 14,63 PHIS Story,Finished 381 S 38 53.0 29,18 UBM asement,Unfinished C 36 7 15.1 5,45 toss LwLease Area _ r , 9 1 < 1 toQ v No- N I s 4 � �► Q a, r p O� u1 Tr tun% ZA X I Zo ^ Q� �P I i V -H I ^ ` 1 0@p O� �•I � N � V .I ^ N V' �N v 40 • ;_ z tp z� Jt _ . o �• � ;gym ti yx jr r'^ �� •I o-� I O � S �' _ J oQil r, �• _ y� V s•. a„ v � _ m i Assessor's office(1st Floor): // / r - M SYSM7 LT-11C1 u rS, Assessor's map and lot number z tz `/ Di y :,.. . _ .LLED IN CO U L"R'.��O�pf TMf t0 7 Board of Health(3rd floor): p� Vam SEC Jc Sewage Permit number 70. m n,r Engineering Department(3rd floor): Tl�riiAfN"' REGULATIONS V ie"L oo House number 39 Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 �o APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR.PERMIT TO �{/(Nf (-?C,I(V S LN to Ilt 7 ✓tgo� l cic,I�'�l gQ TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION -1 13 19 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following �information: Location 27 Iz��((C�C D4UV( Proposed Use N1,00 Pyk 00 ply OW ' Zoning District Fire District (`I � �t1 1 4 Name of Owner YAl` ( Address 2� �O/� (91; Name of Builder o4to Address `ef d { Cl V Ile, Name of Architect Address J Number of Rooms Foundation 10(X u(I C Exterior C�p Roofing 1 -e-e �'`e u✓ Floors �/ hie a In rior 7 VVq�� 1 t Heating 4-(��lryrr Plumbing V� Fireplace A/ 7 Approximate Cost ( f 190,0 IF �.l�Q rA C /rlGt Area v Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions S,,Q ���uCk4 p�pf 01 i POOL r z f z . c c THE FOLLOWING IS/ARE THE BEST IMAGES FROM POOR QUALITY ORIGINALS) A , I DATA Engineering Dept.(3rd floor) Map Parcel_ /SD 66 / Permit# House# Q 7;D 6 Date Issued Board of Health(3rd floor)(8:15-9:30/1:00-4:30) Conservation Office.(4th floor)(8:30-9:30/1:00-2:00) Planning Dept.(1st floor/School Admin.Bldg.) SEPTIC SYS ST BE Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 INSTALLED ANCE WIT ENVIROK&I • AND TOWN OF BARNSTABLE T� �^rr..! n7-- .... `'.:''R Building Permit Application Project Street Address Lou r"4tca Village ato Owner ��O Address 5;� Telephone ,,pp 90 S Permit Request /[,P Me-;A_& 3 t dam V!tuk v S;MJ agga, First Floor square feet Second Floor square feet Construction Type Dy"Vl_ Fayrrt:¢ Estimated Project Cost $ oZ.S—&40- Zoning District Floc "V ' - _Water Protection Lot Size Gm Dwelling Type: Single Family 21__ IT vo Fi Age of Existing Structure_ & t B Highway p Yes 17�0 Basement lype: [W1 ❑Crawl p Wa? Basement Finished Area(sq.ft.) Number of Baths: Full: Existing 11 '1 New No.of Bedrooms: Existing New Total Room Count(not including baths):Eris �i � ^- fel ,*J nt y \ I Heat Type and Fuel: p Gas rl p l: Central Air ❑Yes Q No Fireplaces:I ve ❑Yes p No Garage: p Detached(size) Z k Z Z v�uo. _ _ _ 26,)(0,0 f Q Attached(size) ❑Barn(size) -- ❑None ❑Shed(size) —� ❑Other(size) Zoning Board of Appeals Authorization p Appeal# Recorded❑ Commercial ❑Yes &O If yes, site plan review# Current Use Proposed Use �� / Q B ' der Information 'C p Name _��:Cxr%!L (,i�/�%�".1, -'- - - Telephone Number 5 ` d, • � � f l r, •. - r �'� ,r �� , i .�• .� r y h,. r .. .�N} `...�uh'va✓r+�2.�G1 �."i,+ r.:-.'^.-"U``Nx.l�'4s��. ;r �. Y N' �i . .-�•-`'r..'.,.vi �. r✓ ::'J yr (y'�` • 1'f,.'-• :,t'-•M-.:,Vr•!•.•S'i#.fl�,<.•t }.,r.•V,vey' �r^:.f+•� i-`a• Assessor's office(1st-Floor): Assessor's map and lot number J o�oF YNE Tod♦. ! Board of Health(3rd floor): l Sewage Permit number / Z BAH357A E i Engineering Department(3rd floor);+• MAea House number Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 .+ �o MAI d APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO \ 1,V I W1'1n(N 6 .TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION ( 6 C 12[`7('" 9 15- 19 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: Location 1-7 K0 2. /C 1 E`-rrd?• c 1 S �n d/! G C=' Z 61 Proposed Use / ��! S' D 1A., e-z C JNe'- • SIR!' �l,�T�� ��- ; Zoning District C Fire District ���� Vlej e6— 4-* Marne of Owner d�ld 1�L 1► �11�`'{ Address Name of Builder`C(/ /l t/e fa U ee 'Address + Name of Architect Address Number of Rooms Foundation Exterior Roofing Floors Interior Heating Plumbing � 4 Fireplace Approximate Cost Area c� Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the•Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regar ing the above construction. Name /!r X � rf Construction Supervisor's License V . GARDNER, WALTER A=140-150 . 00.1 lye No 33215 Permit For Build Swimming Pool Accessory to Dwelling Location 27 York Terrace Osterville Owner Walter Gardner Type of Construction Concrete Plot Lot Permit Granted September 15, 19 89 Date of Inspectiori 19 Date Completed 19 ' 1i THIS DOCUMENT HAS Town of Barnstable NOT BEEN RECORDED, Zoning Board of Appeals FILE COPY ONLY! Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-118-McDaniels Appeal of the Building Commissioner Summary: Upheld Building Commissioner Applicants: John C.&Gwen C. McDaniels Property Address: 27 York Terrace,Osterville Assessor's Map/Parcel: Map 140, Parcel 150.001 Area: 0.58 acre Zoning: RC Residential C Zoning District Groundwater Overlay: AP Aquifer Protection District Background: The property that is the subject of this appeal consists of a 0.58 acre lot commonly addressed as-27 York " Terrace, Osterville. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated.pool. The main structure is . a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a living area of approximately 3,876 sq. ft. The other building is a one and a half story, detached garage/apartment structure,with a-living.area of approximately 745 sq. ft.' The assessor's field card lists this structure as a single-family dwelling. In the spring of 1999, the applicants were issued a building permit(#35965)for the replacement of windows and doors in the garage/apartment building. Evidently-,the renovation work expanded to include the removal of the existing kitchen, wiring and plumbing. In the process of this additional work, after the removal of the interior, a Stop Order was issued. In a letter dated June 29, 1999 from Attorney Theodore Schilling to Ralph Crossen, the applicants requested that a new building permit be issued to allow the replacement of the kitchen. Iry response to this letter, the Building Commissioner wrote"must get a variance-the apartment is illegal". According to the applicants, the kitchen was already installed when they purchased the property in 1998. They contend that the second kitchen in the garage building adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single- family dwelling use only and is not in violation of any zoning by-law or ordinance. The applicants are requesting enforcement action and are appealing the decision of the Building Commissioner not to issue a building permit to allow the re-installation of the previously existing kitchen. Procedural Summary: This appeal was filed at the Town Clerk's Office and at the Office of the Zoning Board of Appeals on July 27, 1999. A 60 day extension of time for holding the hearing and for filing of the decision was executed between the applicant and the Board Chairman. A public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals was duly advertised and notices sent to all abutters in accordance with MGL Chapter 40A. The hearing was opened October 13, 1999, at which time the Board upheld the decision of the Building Commissioner. Hearing Summary: Board Members hearing this appeal were Ron Jansson, Gail Nightingale, Richard Boy, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn. Attorney Theodore Schilling represented the applicant. Present was Kathy ' According to Assessor's records dated 10/05/99 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-118-McDaniels Appeal of the Building Commissioner Richardson, the broker who sold the property in issue to the applicants. Attorney Schilling requested, and the Board agreed,to hear Appeal Number 1999-118 and Appeal Number 1999-119 together. Attorney Schilling explained the petitioners are seeking to overrule the Building Commissioner to allow for the re-installation of a kitchen adjacent to the pool in an accessory building, or in the alternative, a Variance to allow a second kitchen. The petitioners purchased the property from the Brooks Family Trust. Attorney Schilling.submitted a letter from Pauline C. Peck, a member of the trust, stating the second kitchen was there when they bought the property and remained when they sold it to the McDaniels. Attorney Schilling stressed the applicants did not install this second kitchen-it was there when they bought the house. Attorney Schilling gave a brief history stating that sometime in late 1998-early 1999,the petitioners sought out a contractor for the purpose of fixing leaking windows and doors in the accessory building containing the second kitchen. A building permit was secured for that limited work. As the work progressed, it was determined that further work was warranted including an upgrade to the kitchen with newer cabinets and appliances, replacing what was already in place. The builder and general contractor apparently did not take out another building permit for the additional work which was not known to the owners. Only after the removal of the kitchen and the gutting of the interior was it determined that a new building permit would have to be issued. After several meetings between Attorney Schilling and the Building Commissioner, it was determined by the Building Commissioner that.the kitchen could not be,re-installed and the Building.Commissioner would not amend or issue anew building permit for that purpose. It is theletter.of.June.29, 1999 where the Building Commissioner has stated, "must get a variance-the apartment is illegal"that is being appealed. In Attorney-Schilling's opinion, the petitioner is a victim'-not having lived-in Barnstable, having used,an off- ,: ' . . cape attorney to purchase the property and purchasing an updated 80 year old dwelling that would lend most people to believe that the kitchen was an accessory use to the swimming pool and the property. The petitioners did not contribute to nor cause their own problem. Attorney Schilling referenced similar court cases, Boch v. Vincent et al., Singer v. DeMartino, and Commonwealth v. Jaffee where multiple kitchens have been allowed. As in those cases, the property in issue is a single family residence, designed for single family use only,it is just that there are two kitchens on the property. The Building Commissioner contends that having two kitchens on a piece of property automatically renders it a multi-family home rather than a single family home. In Attorney Schilling's opinion, having two kitchens is not a violation of the town's Zoning Ordinance. The property had two separate kitchens when the petitioners bought the property and they want to maintain both facilities on the property. The accessory building is used in conjunction with the swimming pool. Therefore, the Building Commissioner should be overruled and the petitioners issued a building permit that would include the replacement of the renovated kitchen for the purpose of use as a one-family house and not to be used as an apartment. Attorney Schilling reviewed the submitted photographs which show the main dwelling, the accessory building and pool area, and indicated these photographs demonstrate that the structures are constructed as a"unit'for single-family use. It is not designed as a separate apartment use. The property is intricately linked and does not lend itself to any kind of multi-family use. If the Board so desires, Attorney Schilling stated, the petitioners would assent to a condition that the issuance of the building permit would be recorded at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds which would state that the property has the use of two kitchens but is strictly limited to one family and shall not be used for lease or rent or any apartment use whatsoever. This would include the restriction that there will only be one electric service to the property. It would also state that the Town reserves all of their rights to enforce any violation if the premises are used for more than one-family use. 2 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-118-McDaniels Appeal of the Building Commissioner The Board and Attorney Schilling discussed the Boch Case. In the Boch Case, all the kitchens were in one unit and in this case there are two separate units. The Board was concerned with enforcement and monitoring the use. The Building Commissioner addressed the Board and reported the Town's records show in 1989-1990 the outbuilding was a garage. Then in November 1990, a building permit was issued for a"cabana"to include a playroom, a bathroom, and a bar sink-but not a kitchen. Over the years, it became a full kitchen. The Building Commissioner stated he has no problem with granting relief for the additional kitchen, but this should not be allowed as-of-right. The Building Commissioner agreed that the applicants are innocent-it was a previous owner who installed the kitchen. Public Comment: Kathy Richardson spoke in support. When she sold the property, she was told by the previous seller that the kitchen was allowed. It is the intent of the owner to use this property as a single family home. No one else spoke in favor or in opposition to this appeal. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of October 13, 1999, the Board voted on the following findings of fact as related to Appeal No. 1999-118: 1. The applicants, John C. &Gwen C. McDaniels;are appealing the decision of the.Building , Commissioner. They own the property in issue which is addressed as 27 York Terrace, Osterville, MA, as shown on Assessor's Map 140, Parcel 150.001 consisting of 0.58 acres. The site is located,in. the RC Residential C Zoning District. 2. The lot is developed with two buildings and.an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a gross living area of approximately 3,900 square feet. The other building is a one and a half story, detached garage/apartment structure.with a-living area of-:,,: - approximately 745 square feet. The smaller structure has a playroom,one bedroom, two bathrooms and a kitchen. 3. The petitioners contend that the use is legal under the Boch Case. 4. The Building Commissioner issued a Stop Order and then issued a Cease and Desist Order from using the premises with a kitchen in it. The petitioners are appealing that decision on the basis that the use that is there now is not an apartment use because it is not being used as an apartment and because it is not laid out as a separate apartment use. 5. The building itself-being separate-contains all of the amenities necessary to sustain individual living for a separate family. 6. It is the intention of the Town of Barnstable Zoning Ordinance in an RC Residential C Zoning District to allow for single family residential use. To allow this other building to exist, at this particular site, would constitute the allowance of a separate apartment-two separate family living dwellings- irrespective of whether they are currently occupied. 7. The proposed use of the dwelling is a guest house. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Gail Nightingale, Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: None Decision: Based on the findings of fact, a motion was duly made and seconded to uphold the decision of the Building Commissioner in Appeal Number 1999-118. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Gail Nightingale, Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Ralph Copeland i 3 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-118-McDaniels Appeal of the Building Commissioner Order: In Appeal Number 1999-118,the Building Commissioner has been Upheld. Appeals of this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A, Section 17,within twenty (20)days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed in the office of the Town Clerk. flp Emmett Glynn, Chairman Date Signed I Linda Hutchenrider, Clerk of the Town of Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts, hereby certify that twenty (20)days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that no appeal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Signed and sealed this day of under the pains and penalties of perjury. 2 US Linda Hutchenrider, Town Clerk 4 Pro of Publication LEGAL NOTICES LEGAL NOTICES Town'gf Sornsitablo Zpnina lWard pf Appoele N90co 91 Publiq Hoorinp Under The Zoning Orohmnos for 0919b4w 1p. 1"0 . To all persons interested in,or affected by the*Board of Appeals under Sec.11 of Chapter 40A of the General Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.and ail amendments thereto you are hereby notified that: 7:15 P.M. Rogers Appeal Number 1999-116 Mark Rogers has petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals fora Special R@rmit for a Family Apartment pursuant to Section 3-1.1(3)(D)of the Zoning Qrdinanpe.The property is shpwn on Assessors Map 120.Parcel 024 and is commonly addressed as 99 Red Oak Lane,West Sprnstable.MA in an RF Residential F Zoning District. 7:25 P.M. Bowes Appeal Number 1999117 John J.Bowes,Jr.has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals fora Variance to Section 3- 1.3(5)Bulk Regulations to legitimize on existing deck that encroaphes on the 10 foot sideline setback by 31 inches.The encroachment was not discovered until a plot plan was done for the sere of the property.The property is shown Qn Assessors Map 22fl.Parcel 091.A02 and ' is commonly addressed as 305 Riverview Lade, Centerville, MA in an RC Residential C Zoning District. 0:15 P.M. McDaniels Appeal Number 1999-110 John C.and Gwen C.McDaniels have appealed the Building Cpmmissionoes response and • his decision as stated in a letter dated June 99,:1999.The Building Crommle$Ioner will..not issue a building permit for the replacement of a kitchen which was fempved for upgrading. The Building.C9mmissionerhas stated the second WtShen/apartmentis illegal:and must get a Varience::T"'e property is shown on Assessor's Map 14A.Parce1150:001'and is rommonly. addressed as 27 York Terrace.Osterville.MA in an RC Residential:G.Zoning.District• J. 0 CM McDaniels Appeal Nurnbe[t;999,1.1 John C:and Gwen C.►Ncpeniels have applied to the Zoning t3gard of Appeals fara.Yarlance to Section 3 1.3.tq permjt a second'kitchen in en acpessory building to a Pfirnlary rgsidenca.• .. The second k►tchen would be used in association with the use of the swlmming pootand wopld be used in connection with the residential dwelling.The�roperty is shown on Assessor's map..: 140.Parcel 150:001 and is commonly addressed as 27 qe Ten►ace.Osterolle;MA in On RC , Residential C Zoning District: 0A5 P.M. Flaherty Appeal Number 1999-120 Teiiy Flaherty d/b/a Cape Auto(Midas)has applied to the Zoning Board,gf Appeals for a Variance to Section 4-3 Sign Regulations:The applicant proposes to remove the current signs and replace them with three (3) wall mounted signs. The property Is shown on Assessors Map 343,Parcel 013 and is commonly.addrQssed as 64lyonpugh Road.Hyannis, MA in an H13 Highway Business District. - 9:00 P.M. Meany Appeal Number 1999.121 Philip E. Meany. Jr. has petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Special Permit pursuant to Section 4-4.3(2)Nonconforming Buildings or$t uclures Used es Single and Two Family Residences.The applicant desires 19 iemodel the existing home by the addition of a one-car garage with one room over the garage area where the front yard setback will be less than 20 feat.The property is shown on Assessors Map 206.Parcels 056.002 and 057 and is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road.Centerville.MA in an RD-1 Residential D•1 Zoning District. 9:05 P.M. Meany Appeal Number 1999.122 Philip E.Meany,Jr.has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Variance to Section 3- 1.1(5)Bulk Regulations. The Petltipner seeks relief from the setback requirements- The Variance is requested because the proximity of the bite to the coastal bank limits the areas where the proposed garage can be added.The property is shown on Assessors Map 206, Parcels 056.002 and 057 and Is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road,Centerville,MA In on RD-1 Residential 0-1 Zoning District. These Public Hearings Will be held in the Hearing Room;Second Floor.New Town Hall.367 Main Street, Hyannis. Massachusetts on Wednesday. Qctober 13, 1999. All plans and applications may be reviewed at the Zoning Board of Appeals Offipe,Town of pamstablp, Planning Department.230 South Street,Hyannis,MA. Emmett Glynn,Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals The Barnstable Patriot September 23$September 30. 1999 The Town of Barnstable WWWABM Department of Health, Safety and Environmental Services Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner MEMORANDUM TO: Emmett Glynn, Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals FROM: Ralph M. Crossen Building Commissioner DATE: 8/25/99 RE: 27 York Terrace, Osterville Map 140, Parcel 150 001 Attached is the file you requested.' g990825a oFT"E r, ity,� Zoning Board of Appeals Town of Barnstable - Planning Department BAMSeABM : 230 South Street, Hyannis, MA 02601 v� MASS., (508) 8624685 Fax(508) 8624725 ArFD�.f A August 13, 1999 Ralph Crossen, Building Commissioner Town of Barnstable 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 Reference: McDaniels-Appeal of the Building Commissioner and Request for Enforcement Action Dear Mr. Crossen, John C. and Gwen C. McDaniels are requesting enforcement action and have appealed your decision not to issue a building permit for the replacement of a previously existing kitchen in the garage of this single- family home site. The property is located at 27 York Terrace, Osterville, as shown on Assessor's Map 140, Parcel 150-1. The above referenced appeal, filed under MGL, Section_8, was received at the Town Clerks Office and at the Zoning Board of Appeals Office on July 27, 1999. In accordance with Chapter 40A, Section 15, the Building Commissioner"shall forthwith transmit to the board of appeals all documents and papers constituting the record of the case in which the appeal [under Section 8] is taken." Please deliver said record to the Zoning Board of Appeals Office. Thank you in advance for your cooperation in this matter. The record will be returned to your office upon the Board rendering its decision. Aanu, Glynn, Chairman cc:. Thomas F.Geiler, Director„H.S.E.S. Robert Smith,Town Attorney Zoning Board of Appeals File ti TOWN OF BARNSTABLE B9�'20 r). Zoning Board of Appeals �' �j✓d'�1�� n s C�Aplf b&iica iWOther Powers 4A 9,4" `< .D R v � - h- , For office usecly { Appeal # Hearing Date IOLA Z Tog �; , Decision Due T e u a plies to the Zoning Board of Appeals for the reasons i dic�BOROF R PEALS e Applicant Name: John C. & Gwm C McDANME* , Phone 508 755 2290 Applicant Address: 23 Metcalf street Worcester MA 01609 Property Location: 27 YORK TERRAcE• OSTERVILLE• MA 02655 This is a request for: XXN Enforcement Action (] Appeal of Administrative officials Decision [] Repetitive Petitions [] Appeal from the zoning Administrator [ ] other General Powers - Please specify: Please Provide the Following information (as applicable): Property Owner: John C. and (fin C. McAANIIIS Phone 508 755 2290 Address of owner: 23 Metcalf st., Worcester. MA 01609 If applicant differs from owner, state nature of interest: I Assessor's Map/Parcel Number 140 - 150 - 1 Zoning District RF Groundwater Overlay District F f ' f which Section(s) of the Zoning ordinance and/or of MGL Chapter 40A are you appealing to the 'Zoning Board of Appeals? applicant seeks to overturn Building Corrmissioner who has refused to allow the issuance of a building permit to replace removed i c en when upgraded. Existing Level of Development of the Property - Number of Buildings: two (2) Present Use(s) : single family residential dwe414Wss Floor Area: 3,200 +/-sq. ft. f r Application for other Powers Nature & Description of Request: Petitioner seeks to overturn building cannissloner's Stop Order for renovations to garage use and 'upstairs sleeping area and first floor kitchen and living area used in connect3.on with the residence and as part of the pool & deck area. Building comdssioner alleges that the kitchen is not allowed under zoning by-law. Petitioner states that the 2nd kitchen in the garage adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single family dwelling use only and is not in violation of any zoning or ordinance. Petitioner Pied said Attached separate sheet if needed. Is the property located in an Historic District? Yes [] NoX Zf yea oRH Use only: Plan Review Number .Date Approved is the building a designated Historic Landmark? Yes [] Now If yes Historic Preservation Department Use only: Date Approved Has a building permit been applied for? . Yes ] No [ ] Has the Building Inspector refused a permit? Yes A] No [ ] Has the property been before site Plan Review? Yea [] No For Building Department Use only: Not. Required - single Family [ ] site Plan Review Number Date Approved signature: The following information must be submitted with the application at the time of filing, failure to supply this may result in a denial of your request: Three (3) copies of the completed application form, each with original signatures. Three (3) copies of all attachments as may be required for standing before the Board and for clear understanding of your appeal. The applicant may submi a y a itional orting documents to assist the Board in m it e a n. Date: June 29, 1999 Signature: A p Kant or A nt's signat re: by: re A. Schilling, At In Fact 1550 Falmouth Road, suit 10 Phone: 508 775 0700 Agent's Address: 775 0792 Centerville MA 02632 Fax No. G C.. Time BARMAW 99 A THIS DOCUMENT HAS Town of Barnstable NOT BEEN RECORDED Zoning Board of Appeals Decision and Notice FILE COPY ONLY Appeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 RC Residential District Summary: Granted with Conditions Applicants: John C.&Gwen C. McDaniels Property Address: 27 York Terrace,Osterville Assessor's Map/Parcel: Map 140, Parcel 150.001 Area: 0.58 acre Zoning: RC Residential C Zoning District Groundwater Overlay: AP Aquifer Protection District Background: The property that is the subject of this appeal consists of a 0.58 acre lot commonly addressed as 27 York Terrace;Osterville. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is . a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a living area of approximately 3,876 sq. ft. The other building is a one and a half story,.detached garage/apartment structure with a living area of approximately 745 sq. ft.' The assessor's field.card lists this structure as a single-family.dwelling. . In the spring of 1999, the applicants were issued a building permit(#35965)for the replacement of windows and doors in the garage/apartment building. Evidently, the renovation work expanded to include the removal of the existing kitchen, wiring and plumbing. In the process of this additional work, after the removal of the interior, a Stop Order was issued. In a letter dated June 29, 1999 from Attorney Theodore Schilling to Ralph Crossen, the applicants requested that a new building permit be issued to allow the replacement of the kitchen. In response to this letter, the Building Commissioner wrote"must get a variance-the apartment is illegal". According to the applicants, the kitchen was already installed when they purchased the property in 1998. They contend that the second kitchen in the garage building adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single- family dwelling use only and is not in violation of any zoning by-law or ordinance. They have applied for a Variance to Section 3-1.3 to allow a second kitchen in an accessory building to the primary residence. This appeal is in the alternative to Appeal Number 1999-118(appeal of the Building Commissioner). Procedural Summary: This appeal was filed at the Town Clerk's Office and at the Office of the Zoning Board of Appeals on July 27, 1999. A 60 day extension of time for holding the hearing and for filing of the decision was executed between the applicant and the Board Chairman. A public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals was duly advertised and notices sent to all abutters in accordance with MGL Chapter 40A. The hearing was opened October 13, 1999, at which time the Board granted the requested Variance with conditions after upholding the decision of the Building Commissioner in Appeal No. 1999-118. ' According to Assessor's records dated 10/05/99 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice ,,Appeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 Hearing Summary: Board Members hearing this appeal were Ron Jansson, Gail Nightingale, Richard Boy, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn. Attorney Theodore Schilling represented.the applicant. Present was Kathy Richardson, the broker who sold the property in issue to the applicants. Attomey Schilling requested, and the Board agreed, to hear Appeal.Number 1999-118 and Appeal Number 1999-119 together. Attorney Schilling explained the petitioners are seeking to overrule the Building Commissioner to allow for the re-installation of a kitchen adjacent to the pool in an accessory building, or in the alternative, a Variance to allow a second kitchen. The petitioners purchased the property from the Brooks Family Trust. Attorney Schilling submitted a letter from Pauline C. Peck, a member of the trust, stating the second kitchen was there when they bought the property and remained when they sold it to the McDaniels. Attorney Schilling stressed the applicants did not install this second kitchen-it was there when they bought the house. Attorney Schilling gave a brief history stating that sometime in late 1998-early 1999,the petitioners sought out a contractor for the purpose of fixing leaking windows and doors in the accessory building containing the second kitchen. A building permit was secured for that limited work. As the work progressed, it was determined that further work was warranted including an upgrade to the kitchen with newer cabinets and appliances, replacing what was already in place. The builder and general contractor apparently did not take out another building permit forthe additional work which was not known to the owners. Only after the removal of the kitchen and the gutting of the interior was it determined that a new: building permit would have to be issued. : . f After several meetings between Attorney Schilling and the Building Commissioner, it was determined by the.Building Commissioner that the kitchen could not.be-re-installed.and the Building Commissioner would not amend or issue a new building permit for that purpose. It.is the letter of June 29, 1999 where the Building Commissioner has stated, "must get a variance-the apartment is illegal"that is being appealed. In Attorney Schilling's opinion, the petitioner is a victim not having lived in Barnstable, having used an off- cape attorney to purchase the property and purchasing an updated 80 year old dwelling that would lend most people to believe that the kitchen was an accessory use to the swimming pool and the property. The petitioners did not contribute to nor cause their own problem. Attorney Schilling referenced similar court cases, Boch v. Vincent et al., Singer v. DeMartino, and Commonwealth v. Jaffee where multiple kitchens have been allowed. As in those cases, the property in issue is a single family residence, designed for single family use only, it is just that there are two kitchens on the property. The Building Commissioner contends that having two kitchens on a piece of property automatically renders it a multi-family home rather than a single family home. In Attorney Schilling's opinion, having two kitchens is not a violation of the town's Zoning Ordinance. The property had two separate kitchens when the petitioners bought the property and they want to maintain both facilities on the property. The accessory building is used in conjunction with the swimming pool. Therefore, the Building Commissioner should be overruled and the petitioners issued a building permit that would include the replacement of the renovated kitchen for the purpose of use as a one-family house and not to.be used as an apartment. Attorney Schilling reviewed the submitted photographs which show the main dwelling, the accessory building and pool area, and indicated these photographs demonstrate that the structures are constructed as a"unit"for single family use. It is not designed as a separate apartment use. The property is intricately linked and does not lend itself to any kind of multi-family use. If the Board so desires, Attorney Schilling stated, the petitioners would assent to a condition that the issuance of the building permit would be recorded at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds which would state that the property has the use of two kitchens but is strictly limited to one family and shall not be used for lease or rent or any apartment use whatsoever. This would include the restriction that there 2 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice -Appeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 will only be one electric service to the property. It would also state that the Town reserves all of their rights to enforce any violation if the premises are used for more than one-family use. In Appeal Number 1999-119, the petitioners are seeking a Variance to allow for the use and maintenance of a second kitchen as an associated use to the pool to be utilized by one single family in occupancy, restricting the property to one electric service. A literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve substantial hardship-financial or otherwise-especially since the Petitioner is an innocent victim upon purchasing the property with two kitchens without any notice or warning that the kitchen may violate zoning. The property is of irregular shape which is a unique condition affecting the focus but not the zoning district in which it is located. The relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the Zoning Ordinance because of the irregular shaped lot and location of the buildings and the improvements. The Board and Attomey Schilling discussed the Boch Case. In the Boch Case, all the kitchens were in one unit and in this case there are two separate units. The Board was concerned with enforcement and monitoring the use. The Building Commissioner addressed the Board and reported the Town's records show in 1989-1990 the outbuilding was a.garage. Then in November 1990, a building permit.was issued for a"cabana"to include. . a.playroom, a bathroom, and a bar sink-but not a kitchen., Over the,years, it became a full kitchen. The Building Commissioner.stated he has no problem with granting relief for the additional`kitchen, but this should not be allowed as-of-right. The Building Commissioner agreed thatthe applicants are.innocent_-Jt;- was a previous owner who installed the kitchen. Public Comment: Kathy Richardson spoke in support. When she sold the property,.she was told by;the previous seller that the kitchen was allowed. It is the intent of the owner to use this property as a single family home. No one else spoke in favor or in opposition to this appeal. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of October 13, 1999, the Board voted on the following findings of fact as related to Appeal No. 1999-119: 1. The applicants, John C. &Gwen C. McDaniels, own the property in issue which is addressed as 27 York Terrace, Osterville, MA, as shown on Assessor's Map 140, Parcel 150.001 consisting of 0.58 acres. The site is located in the RC Residential C Zoning District. 2. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a gross living area of approximately 3,900 square feet.The other building is a one and a half story, detached garage/apartment structure with a living area of approximately 745 square feet. The smaller structure has a playroom, one bedroom, two bathrooms and a kitchen. 3. The petitioners are seeking to vary the Zoning Ordinance by allowing the use of a kitchen in this existing garage structure. 4. The proposed use is a use intended to be accessory to the primary use and it is not intended for year- round occupation by anyone other than the primary owner of the property. 5. No findings are made under MGL Chapter 40A, Section 10 with the exception that the granting of this relief would not be in derogation of the spirit nor the intent of the Zoning Ordinance to allow the second kitchen in view of the fact that the second kitchen will be used in conjunction with the primary residence and not as a separate residence. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale 3 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice �'4ppeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 Decision: Based on the findings of fact, a motion was duly made and seconded to grant the relief being sought in Appeal No. 1999-119, subject to the following terms and conditions: 1. The garage apartment unit shall not be rented to anyone nor in anyway be used as anything other than occasional guest quarters. 2. At no time shall the garage/apartment building be put on a separate meter service. 3. The applicant shall at all times comply with any applicable Board of Health Rules and Regulations with reference to septic systems. 4. These restrictions shall be recorded with the Barnstable County Registry of the Deeds and become a . covenant that runs with the land. 5. The use of the building in issue shall be a use that is only accessory to the main structure and shall not be used independent of the structure. Even though rents may not be charged, no occupancy shall be used for families other than the primary-family occupying the property. 6. There shall be no further expansion of the living quarters themselves. The garage and storage areas within the building shall not be used for human occupancy. The Vote was as follows: AYE: - Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale Ms. Nightingale stated she voted in the negative because she did not feel'there were variance conditions. Order: Variance Number 1999-1.19 has been Granted with Conditions. This decision must be recorded at the Registry of'Deeds for it to be in effect. The relief authorized by this decision must be exercised in one year. Appeals of this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to MGL,Chapter-40A,'Section 17,within twenty (20)days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Emmett Glynn, Chairman Date Signed I Linda Hutchenrider, Clerk of the Town of Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts, hereby certify that twenty (20)days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that no appeal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Signed and sealed this d of a/ under the pains and penalties of perjury. Linda Hutchenrider, Town Clerk 4 RetNo mappar ownerl owner2 addr city state Zip 118+119 140 125 D'OLIMPIO, FELIX J ADELINE D'OLIMPIO 309 WIANNO AVE. OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 126 CAIN, ANDREA M 295•WAINNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 127 001 REARDON, MICHELE B 1313 HARLAND LN LAKE FOREST IL 60045 140 128 DENESHA, PHILIP A & DIANE M 602 MAIN ST OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 129 SHEA, RICHARD J & ELLEN M 246 HIGHLAND ST MILTON MA 02186 140 148 001 MURPHY, MARCIA M 232 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 148 002 MANGALO, MICHEL G & LYNNE TALA P 0 BOX 2128 HYANNIS a MA 02601 140 149 PATRICK, PAMELA H 12.SHATTUCK STREET NATICK MA 01760 140 150 001 BROOKS, RICHARD HT SR TRS '%MCDANIEL, JOHN C & GWEN C 23 METCALF ST WORCESTER MA 01609 140 150 002 TYRRELL, JOSEPH P & MARY A 241 BRISTOL RD WELLESLEY HILLS MA 02181 140 150 003 DEROSIER, J DAVID 278 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 157 CROCKER, JAMES H JR TR EAST BAY/OSTERVILLE TRUST. PO BOX'496 OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 159 BORG, NANCY J & BORG, LINDA A 125 ARNOLD ST E PROVIDENCE RI 02915 140 160 001 RYAN, JOHN G & MARY L 19322 OAK VIEW TERR HOUSTON TX 77094 140 160 002 MAZZEO, PAUL A & BRENDA A 145 EAST BAY ROAD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 161 MAHONEY, STEPHEN R & ANTONIA B P 0 BOX 5079 E HAMPTON, NY 11937 140. 161 001 CAIN, RICHARD TR P O BOX 454 HARWICHPORT MA 02646 140 205 OHARA, MARY ELLEN 1413 LANCEWOOD TERRACE PALM CITY FL 34990 140 206 FINNEGAN, M PATRICIA TR & FINNEGAN, JAMES J TR 14 :.YORK TERRACE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 207 ADAIR, GRACE S TR %CARROLL, POTTER HESSLER JR 268 FISKE ST HOLLISTON MA 01746 140 208 MCCAFFERTY, KEVIN M 2 TRODDEN PATH LEXINGTON MA 02173 140 209 KAVANAGH, HARRIET P& ROBERT HARRIET KAVANAGH REVOK TRST 38 YORK TERR OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 210 001 SUSIDKO, STEPHEN W & PAMELA 167 EAST BAY RD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 210 002 KESTEN, LEAH R 173 EAST BAY RD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 3 i Proof of Publication LEGAL NOTICES LEGAL NOTICES Town pf 111111ornsWAo Zoning 60a►d Pf Appeals Ngfto pf Aubliy Mooring Under The Zening Ordinonoe for 00911*err Tpt 1"0 To all persons interested in,or affected by the Board of Appeals under Sec.11 of Chpptgr 40A of the General Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts,and all amendments thereto you are hereby notified that: 7:15 P.M. Rogers Appeal Number 19W116 Mark Rogers has petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals fora Special Permit for a Family Apartment pursuant to Section 3 1.1(3)(D)of the Zoning Qrdinabce.The property is shown on Assessors Map 128,Parcel 024 and Is commonly addressed as 99 Red Oak t.ane,We 9t Barnstable.MA in an RF Residential F Zoning District. 7:25 P.M. Bowes Appeal Number 19991 t 7 John J.Bowes.Jr.has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals fpro Variance to Section 3 1.3(5)Bulk Regulations to legitimize an existing deck that encroaches on the 10foot sideline setback by 31 inches.The encroachment was not discovered until oplot plan was fone for the sale of the property.The property is shown on Assessors Map 220.Parcel 091.002 and is commonly addressed as 3q5 Riverview Lane, Centerville, MA in an RC Residential C Zoning District. 0:15 P.M. McPaniels Appeal Number 1999 110 John C.and Gwen C.McPaniels have appealed the Building Cpmmissioners response and • his decision as stated in a letter dated June 29, 1999.The Building Comrrllsslpner will not issue a building permit for the replacement of a kitch.pri which woo-re moved for upgrading. The Building Commissionerhas stated the second kitchenApartment Isillegal;and"must ! o Variance:The property is shown oh-Assessors Map 140,Parcel l a0.001 and is commonly addressed as 27 York Terrace,Ostervillet MA in on RC Residentiol.C.Zoning.Pistrict. 0:20 P.M McPaniels r Appeal Number l.SW-1a9 John C:and Gwen C.Mi:ppnlels have applied to the Zoning Board ofAppeals for a Variance to Section 34.3 to permit a second kitchen in an accessory building to a primary residence." The second kitchen would be used in association with the use of ftswimming pootand would be used in connection with the residential dwelling.Theg(ppertyis shown onAssessoes Map:: 140.Parcel 150:001 and is commonlyaddressed as 29 OaRTerrace.Qsterville;Main an RC Residential C Zoning District. 8:A5 P.M: • . Flaherty Appeal Number 1,095:120 Teiiy. Flaherty d/b/a Cape Auto(Midas)has applied to the Zoning Board.of Appeals for a Variance to Section 4-3 Sign Regulations:The applicant proposes to remove the current signs and replace them with three (3) wall mounted signs. The property is shown on Assessors Map 343,Parcel 013 and Is commonlyaddressed as 641yanpugh Road,Hyannis. MA in an HQ Highway Business District. - 9:00 R.M. Meany Appeal Number 1999.121 Philip E. Meany. Jr. has petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Special Permit pursuant to Section q 4.3(2)Nonconforming Buildings or Structures Used as Single and Two Family Residences.The applicant desires to remodel the existing home by the addition of a one-car garage with one room over the garage area where the front yard setback will be legs than 20 feet.The property is shown on Assessors Map 206.Parcels 056.9Q2 and 057 and is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road.Centerville.MA in an RDA Residential D•1 Zoning District. 9:05 P.M. Meany Appeal Number 1999122 Philip E.Meany,Jr.has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Variance to Section 3• I.1(b)Bulk Regulations. The Petitioner Seeks relief from the setback requirements.The Variance is requested because the proximity of the:aite to the coastal bank limits the areas where the proposed garage can be added.The property is shown on Assessors Map 206. Parcels 056.002 and 057 and is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road,Centerville,MA in an RD-1 Residential D-1 Zoning District. These Public Hearings will be held in the Hearing Room:Second Floor,New Town HAIL 307 Main Street, Hyannis. MassachvWta on Wednesday.Qctober 13. 1999. All plans and applications may be reviewed at the Zoning Board of Appeals office.Town of Bamstable, Planning Department.230 South Street,Hyannis,MA. Emmett Glynn,Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals The Barnstable Patriot September 23$September 30. 1999 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION Map Parcel 00 t Permit# 43W8 Health Division /�' �-��v Date Issued Z 2,0--29 Conservation Division Fee Tax Collector ,�j � _ I SEPTIC SYSTEM MAST BE Treasurer � ���� �U�`�01%o -'� INSTALLED IN COMPLIANCE t 'Planning Dept. WITH TITLE 5ENVIRONMENTAL CODE AND Date Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board TOWN REGULATION'S i Historic-OKH Preservation/Hyannis Project Street Address ` C� Qa/ CAL YtJ j' Village - OwnerQ�J/.4' Address CY e Telephone Permit Request cv� r� aL Square feet: 1 st floor: existing proposed 2nd floor: existing S�V proposed Total new Estimated Project Cost Zoning District Flood Plain Groundwater Overlay Construction Type Lot Size Qd Grandfathered: ❑Yes 0 No If yes, attach supporting documentation. Dwelling Type: Single Family 0/ Two Family ❑ Multi-Family(#units) Age of Existing Structure Historic House: ❑Yes O No On Old King's Highway: ❑Yes ❑No Basement Type: ❑Full ❑Crawl ❑Walkout O Other Basement Finished Area(sq.ft.) Basement Unfinished Area(sq.ft) Number of Baths: Full:existing new Half: existing new Number of Bedrooms: existing new Total Room Count(not including baths): existing new First Floor Room Count Heat Type and F el: Gas O Oil ❑Electric ❑Other Central Air: " Yes No Fireplaces: Existing New Existing wood/coal stove: O Yes O No P 9 9 Detached garage: existing O new size Pool:❑existing ❑new size Barn:❑existing O new size Attached garage:b existing ❑new size Shed:❑existing ❑new size Other: Zoning Board of Appeals Authorization ❑ Appeal# Recorded❑ Commercial ❑Yes ❑No If yes, site plan review# Current Use Proposed Use BUILDER INFORMATION Name G.,_ t�y Scg,-1 Telephone Number Address '� 0, (:2� License# (f ; 1�4 406 �► a 0Z Home Improvement Contractor# Worker's Compensation# ALL CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS RESULTING FROM THIS PROJECT WILL BE TAKEN TO 'r�/e SIGNATURE DATE DATE �T/�� FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PERMIT NO. (�� DATE ISSUED MAP/PARCEL NO. ADDRESS VILLAGE OWNER DATE OF INSPECTION: FOUNDATION FRAME INSULATION FIREPLACE ' ELECTRICAL: ROUG1-I-�) FINAL _ PLUMBING: ROUGIQ _ FINAL x, , GAS: ROUG'lff Fr FINAL FINAL BUILDING s 0 P ven El —�✓ . . •� r-' rnA €r DATE CLOSED OUT ASSOCIATION PLAN NO. BOARD V�nse: OF BUILDING REGULgTryONS CONSTRUC Number SON SUPERVISOR 057702 60rrlss: 12/002001 �. R Tr-no: 10383 FRED J FISHER eat"08d TO: 1G 205 WORCESTER ST FALM0(711. 02540 Administrator � 7k 1a4 y?.i u�aa' HOME .IMPROVE�MENT ;CONT,RACTOR Registration ``107, rt TY00- PRIVATE ORPdRATION f`. Expiration { 07/31%00. KITCHEN-KORNER 0f FALMOUTH IN Frederick J.:>Fishe`r 4 Worcester'CWt : ADMINISTRATOR Falmouth MA 02540 ,� __ w The Commonwealth of Massachusetts —j Department of Industrial Accidents ,� ==���- ; �'�• 01�ce otlaYest/gat�oas _ 600 Washington Street -_ Boston,Mass 02111 Workers' Compensation Insurance Affidavit name location city (' A A i1�J'�`"� V v(� f' �'`� phone# 45f U i�J ❑ I am a homeowner performing all work myself. ❑ I am a sole etor and have no one workin in a� act is ensauo n for 1 worlaa on this 'ob. worke � g J din �P em 1 mY I am an g � company name � .. � 2 �� •�'' � •,�"��ft� :}:: fit:> <:: _ .::.:.......................... ::..:;:...: ............:.. address ��'' .', a tw hone# ........ ..... ...... NY r�insurance�co:� .. > ..•���:::: };:;::;�}'::..... . . . . ::':. ;.;. :..:.:::• oiicv#..: ;,, •- ////// ❑ I am a sole proprietor,general contractor,or homeowner(circle one)and have hired the contractors listed below who have ' the followingworkers' compensation polices: mp........ .......... ..........................:........................................................................................................................,:.::::::.::.,,:.::.::.:::::.. "ev n -}: a m :. co aidre s . . :::::::::::........:............................. ........... .n... .......... .r...r....................................................................................................}}}Y}:•:{J}}}±:{.ri:nh•:::::mw::nw:: v;}::::v............................. 'yJ� �::: .................. }}}}:4}}iii ?}±±:•}}}:Ci:��±i}:}}}:?::•:�i}}}: one :1/Y'}:is!{:::is??!?•±:::±:{.±}iii}%±±±:?!.;r.}:-.� :. :::..::::•: ::•X. ::.... � h .................................................................................................................................... :.... ........................................................................................................................................................................ ............................................. ..:v:w::::::::...................... r....... ..:Y:r•}::{.;;r;:!S:•i}}:?!:?•::6: ................. ........... ....:...................... ..........-nL.-.{..r. .............. n'..x..{..:....vQw•n:rvnd:+1:3}":.�.}i}i ......................�:::............ ...-r:n•}:..............................::::......:rnv:r............-........n................................ v:w::-•.:..........w.�:.::{{•}::. r.... .......... ...............................................:..::::::::::::::::::::::.i}�.}ii±:?:U??<•:•: .#::.i'^}:i•}ii}i}::::.�:?•.;.:::::::._::!.;:n':.�::.;':.::{??::::.iii:::.::i:•is?•::::.}::::...?.i:?::Ji :?!::'�: :::.:.�::::.:::::..!.}:.�:.�...,.. ............. ... oGw RFR :. one: :.}. cl �.. tv' eur�ance oli cv Fai>nre to se�wre coverage as required mmder Section 25A of MGL 152 can lead to the impostlon of criminal peaaitin of•tine to S1,S00.00 and/or one yem,imprisonment as well as civil penalties in the form of a STOP WORK ORDER and a tine of SI00.00 a day agehut mG I�derstand that a copy of this statement may be forwarded to the Office of Investigations of the DIA for coverage veriScatiom I do hereby certify under the pains and penalties of perjury that the information provided above is trues and correct . Signature —� Date Print name _;cl� Phone#49t� c�`i` oindal use only do not write in this area to be completed by city or town official dty or town: perrnitilicense# ❑Building Department ❑Licensing Board ❑check if hnmediste response is required ❑sel�++�'s Office ❑Health Department contact person. phone#; ❑�u'�� i OrAnd 9l95 PIA) i r GF THE A The Town of Barnstable ,�� 9� : �0� Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services 1DtE0 r�a't A Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Ralph Crossen Fax: 50&790-6230 Building Commissioner Permit no. Date AFFIDAVIT HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR LAW SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT APPLICATION MGL c. 142A requires that the"reconstruction,alterations,renovation,repair,modernization,conversion, improvement,removal,demolition,or construction of an addition to any pre-existing owner-occupied building containing at least one but not more than four dwelling units or to structures which are adjacent to such residence or building be done by registered contractors,with certain exceptions,along with other requirements. Type of Work:T�Gt�Cl� �T/I��CT2lC��� Estimated Cost w Address of Work: ��� �'�zt/ t �� Owner's Name: (�G� Date of Application: I hereby certify that: Registration is not required for the following reason(s): ❑Work excluded by law ❑Job Under$1,000 []Building not owner-occupied []Owner pulling own permit Notice is hereby given that: OWNERS PULLING THEIR OWN PERMIT OR DEALING WITH UNREGISTERED CONTRACTORS FOR APPLICABLE HOME IMPROVEMENT WORK DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE ARBITRATION PROGRAM OR GUARANTY FUND UNDER MGL c.142A. SIGNED UNDER PENALTIES OF PERJURY I hereby apply for a permit as the agent of the owner: Date Contractor Name Registration No. OR Date Owner's Name q:forms:Affidav L—(5 (,ti�cJ �vrl � ov . T - - -- - - -- - - - ��� 0u„ e, -P3 t Z---2 -3 33 v �--- --. - --�--- -- - - -- - ----- �-------- -- - -.�___,._. .t. . � .. _ _ -- -- - - - -- - �, ,; y _._ . _--- _ _� - �-_ -- - - _ __ _ ..._ . . _ _. ._ _ r ' �- 1 h I 1 _ _. _ ..__-.\-T��.����...��.�� ._�_._ �.� _mil___�_.-... _�-.__.Y._... r .y _ � _ .. II �"' + � - � -=s--, � l(' � i - •.., �. - � ——— --µ------ —�--- -—— - --� -.--------- ._ e.�_ __ ._ _ _ _ _ ..._.... . .. 4, , r —'F �' ; r ,, � __.�� _+. ' � u . {� 4� � '" ---------�--f-�- — —-- -- — - --- -- —-..._._.--- - - - - - - - -- -- . .. _._-__ __.�_----µ-z----� --._ _ _.� _ _.� _ _...-- , ----. . _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ . ._ .__ � {J 1 t � r 0 0 r' I I MAScheck COMPLIANCE REPORT I 431, (AI Massachusetts Energy Code I Permit # I MAScheck Software Version 2.01 I I . I I Checked by/Date I I CITY: Barnstable STATE: Massachusetts HDD: 6137 CONSTRUCTION TYPE: 1 or 2 Family, Detached HEATING SYSTEM TYPE: Other (Non-Electric Resistance) DATE: 12-20-1999 COMPLIANCE: PASSES Required d UA = 115 Your Home = 115 Area or Cavity Cont. Glazing/Door Perimeter R-Value R-Value U-Value U ---------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------------ CEILINGS 400 30.0 0.0 f CEILINGS 300 30.0 0.0 - WALLS: Wood, Frame, `'16"`'O.C., 414 13.0 0.0 f WALLS: Wood' Frame, ' 16" O.C: ; 106 13.0 0.0 GLAZING: Windows or .Doors 70 0.330 -- 2 1rt.F: k GLAZING: Windows or Doors 35 0.330' 1 FLOORS: Over Unconditioned Space 384 30.0 0.0 - --1 --------------------------------------------------------- ------------------- COMPLIANCE STATEMENT: The proposed building design described here is consistent with the building plans, specifications, and other calculations submitted with the permit application. The proposed building has been designed to meet the requirements of the Massachusetts Energy Code. The heating load for this building, and the cooling load if appropriate, has been determined using the applicable Standard Design Conditions found in the 'ode. The HVAC equipment selected to heat or cool - the building shall be no greater than 125% of the design load as specified in Sections 780CMR 1310 and J4 .4. U Builder/Designer Date 1. t; 3 2 MAScheck INSPECTION CHECKLIST. J Massachusetts Energy Code MAScheck Software Version 2.01 - - DATEi' 12-20-1999 Bldg. Dept. 1 Use CEILINGS: [ ] 1. R-30 Comments/Location [ ] 2. R-30 Comments/Location WALLS: [ . ] 1. Wood Frame, 16" O.C. , R-13 Comments/Location [ ] 2. Wood Frame, 16" O.C. , R-13 I Comments/Location WINDOWS AND 'GLASS DOORS: [ ] 1. U-valuei 0.33' For windows without labeled U-values, describe features: # Panes Frame Type Thermal Break? [ ] Yes [ ] No Comments/Location [ ] 2 . U-value: 0.33 For windows without labeled U-values, describe features: # Panes Frame Type Thermal Break? [ ] Yes [ ] No Comments/Location FLOORS: [ ] 1. Over Unconditioned Space, R-30 Comments/Location AIR LEAKAGE: [ ] Joints, penetrations, and all other such openings in the building .-.. envelope that are sources of air leakage must be sealed. When installed in the building envelope, recessed lighting fixtures shall meet one of the following requirements: 1. , Type IC rated, manufactured with no penetrations between the inside of the recessed fixture and ceiling cavity and sealed or gasketed to prevent air leakage into the unconditioned space. 2 . Type IC rated, in accordance with Standard ASTM E 283, with no more than 2 .0 cfm (0.944 L/s) air movement from the the conditioned space to the ceiling cavity. The lighting fixture shall have been tested at 75 PA or 1.57 lbs/ft2 pressure difference and -shall be labeled. VAPOR RETARDER: [ ] Required -on the warm-in-winter side of all non-vented framed ceilings, walls, and floors. MATERIALS . IDENTIFICATION: [ ] Materials and equipment must be identified so that compliance can be determined. Manufacturer manuals for all installed heating and cooling equipment and service water heating equipment must be provided. Insulation R-values and glazing U-values must be clearly marked on the building plans or specifications. DUCT INSULATION: [ ] Ducts shall be insulated per Table J4.4 .7. 1. I DUCT CONSTRUCTION: [ ] All accessible joints, ' seams, and connections of supply and retuih ductwork located outside conditioned 'space, including stud bays or joist cavities/spaces used to transport air, shall be sealed using mastic and fibrous backing tape installed according to the manufacturer' s installation instructions. Mesh tape may be omitted where gaps are less than 1/8 inch. Duct tape is not permitted. The HVAC system must provide a means for balancing air and water systems. TEMPERATURE CONTROLS: T [ ] Thermostats are required for each separate HVAC system. A manual or automatic means to partially restrict or shut off the heating: and/or cooling input to each zone or floor shall be provided. ' � .` L'f HVAC EQUIPMENT SIZING: [ ] Rated output capacity of the heating/cooling system is. not greater than 125% of the design load as specified in Sections 780CMR 1310 and J4.4 . [ ] SWIMMING POOLS: . All heated swimming pools must have an on/off heater switch and require a cover unless over 20% of the heating energy is from non-depletable sources. Pool pumps require a time clock. [ ] HVAC PIPING INSULATION: HVAC piping conveying fluids above 120 F or chilled fluids below 55 F must be insulated to the following levels (in. ) : . _.,PIPE SIZES (in. ) HEATING SYSTEMS: TEMP (F) 2" RUNOUTS 0-1" 1.25-2". 2.5-4" Low pressure/temp. 201-250 1.0 1.5 1.5 2.0 Low temperature 120-200 0.5 1.0 1.0 1 .5 Steam condensate any 1.0 1.0 1.5 2.0 COOLING SYSTEMS: Chilled water or 40-55 0.5 0.5 0.75 1.0 refrigerant '. below 40 1.0 1.0 1.5 1.5 [ J CIRCULATING HOT WATER SYSTEMS: Insulate circulating hot water pipes to the following levels (in. ) : PIPE SIZES (in. ) NON-CIRCULATING I CIRCULATING MAINS & RUNOUTS HEATED WATER TEMP (F) : RUNOUTS 0-1" I 0-1.25" 1.5-2 .0" 2.0+" 170-180 0.5 1.0 1.5 2 .0 . c 140-160 0.5 0.5 1.0 1.5 - 100-130 L' " 0.5 '; A ` ' 0.5 0.5 1.0 ----NOTES TO FIELD (Building Department Use Only)-=------=---------------- , , li DEC-20-99 TUE 04 :00 PM KITCHENKORNER 5085404535 P- 03 w. TA SCHILUING PC 5�87?5079Z NV.993 TQwn oF9amstable-Zoning Board ofAppeel9-Dadsion end Notice Appeal Number 129IM19-MCDaniels Varlenca to Secticn 't Hearing Summary: Board Members hearing this appeal were Ron JOnSSOn,Gail Nightingale, Richard Boy, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn. Attorney Theodore Schilling represented the applicant, Present was Kathy Richardson,the broker who sold the property in Issue to the applicants. Attorney Schilling requested,and the Board agreed,to hear Appeal Number 1999-118 and Appeal Number'1999A 19 together, Attomey Schilling explained the petitioners are seeking to overrule►he Building Commissioner to allow for the re-installation of a kitchen,adjacent to the pool In on accessory building,or in the alternative,a Variance to allow a second kitchen. The petitioners purchased the property from the Brooks Family Trust, Attorney Schilling submitted a letter • from Pauline C. Peck,a member of the trust,stating the second kitchen was there when they bought the property and remained when they sold it to the McDanlels. Attorney Schilling stressed the applicants did not Install this second kltchen-It was there when they bought the house. Attorney Schilling gave a brief history stating that sometime in late 1998-early 1999,the petitioners sought out a contractor for the purpose of fixing leaking windows and doors in the accessory building containing the second kitchen. A building permit was secured for that limited work As the work progressed, it was determined that further work was warranted Including an upgrade to the kitohen with nower cabinets and appliances, replacing what was already in place. The builder and general contractor apparently did not take 61A another building permit for the additional work which was not known to the owners, Only after the removal of the kitchen and the gutting of the Interior was it determined that a new building permit would have to be issued. After several meetings between Attorney Schilling and the Building Commissioner, It was determined by the Building Commissioner that the kitchen could not be re-installed.and the Building Commissioner would not amend or issue a new building permit for that purpose. it is the letter of June 29, 1999 where the Building Commissioner has stated, 'must get a variance-the apartment Is Illegal'that is being aaaealed. In Attorney Schilling's opinion,the petitioner is a victim not having lived In Barnstable, having used an off- cape attomey to purchase the property and purchasing an updated 80 year old dwelling that would lend most people to believe that the kitchen was an accessory use to the swimming pool and the property. The petitioners did not contribute to nor cause their own problem. Attomey Schilling referenced similar court cases,Boch v.Vincent e4 aL,Singar v. DeMartino,and Commonwealth v.Jafles where multiple kitchens have been allowed. As in those cases,the property in Issue is a single family residence,designed for single family use only, it is Just that there tare two kitchens on the property, The Bulding Commissioner contends that having two kitohens on a piece of property automatically renders it a multi-family home rather than a single family home. In Attorney 8rhilling's Opinion,`laving two kitchens is not a violation of the town's Zoning Ordinance. The property had two separate kitchens when the petitioners bought the property and they went to maintain both facilities on the property. The accessory'building is used in conjunction with the swimming pool- Therefore,the Building Commissioner should be overruled and the petitioners issued a building permit that would Include the replacement of the renovated kitchen for the purpose of use as a one-family house and not to be used as an apartment, Attomey Schilling reviewed the submitted photographs which show the main dwelling,the accessory building and pool arep,and Indicated these photographs demonstrate that the structures are constructed as a"unit"for single family use, It is not designed as a separate apartment use. The property Is intricately linked and does not lend itself to any kind of MuM-family use, If the 60ard so desires.Attorney Schilling stated,the petitioners would assent to a condition that the issuance of the building permit would be recorded at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds which would State that the property has the use of two kitchens but 13 strictly limited to one family and shall not be used for lease or rent or any apartment use whafteVer. This would include the restriction that there 2 l i DEC-20-99 TUE 04 :01 PM KITCHENKORNER 5095404535 P. 04 o ti 7A SCHILLING2 PG NC.993 P.4 Town of Sarnstabie-UnN Board of Appals-D4C+sicn and Notice Appeal Nunl9er t&99-119-1,44Wniels Yarianm to Section 3-1.3 will only be one electric service to the property. It would also state that the Town reserves all of their rights to enforco any violation if the premises are used for more than one-Yamlly use. In Appeal Number 1999-119.the petitioners are seeking a Variance to allow for the use and maintenance of a second kitchen as an associated use to the pool to be utilized by one single family in occupancy, restricting th9 property to one electric service. A literal enforoement of the previsions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve substantial hardship-financial or otherwise-especially since the Petitioner i9 an innocent victim upon purchasing Tie propel' with two kitchens without any notice or warning that the kitchen may violate zoning. The property is of irregular shape which Is a unique condition effecting the locus but not tie zoning district in which it Is located. The relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the Zoning Ordinance because of the irregular shaped lot and location of the buildings and tho j improvements. The Board and Attorney Schilling discussed the Soch Case. In the Hoch Case, all the kitchens were in one unit and in this case there are two separate units, Thei Board was concerned with enforcement and monitoring the use. *(Tie Building Commissioner addressed the Board and reported.the Town's records show in 1989-1990 the outbuilding was a garage. Then in November 1990, a building permit was Issued for a"cabana"to include a playroom,a bathroom,and a bar sink-but not a kitchen. Over the years, it became a full kitchen. The Building Commissioner stated he has no problem with granting relief for the additional kitchen,but this should not be allowed as-of-right, The Building Commissioner agreed that the applicants are innocent-it was a previous owner who Installed the kitohen, Public Comment: Kathy Richardson spoke in support. When she sold the property, she was told by the previous seller that the kitchen was allowed. It is the intent of the owner to usa this property as a single family home. No one else spoke in favor or In apposition to this appeal. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of October 13, 1999, the Board voted on the following findings of fact as related to Appeal tdo.1999-119: 1. The applicants,.John C. &Gwen C. McDanlels,own the property in issue which is addressed as 27 York Terrace, Ostwlle, MA, as shown on Assessor's h1ap'140, Parcel 150.001 consisting of 0.68 acres. The site is located to the RC Residential C Zoning District. 2. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single tamiN, resldencs with a gross living area of approximately 3,900 square feet.The other building is a one and a half story, detached garagelapartmbnt structure with a living area of approximately 745 square feet The smaller structure has a playroom,one bedroom, two bathrooms and a kitchen. 3. The petitioners are seeking to vary the Zoning Ordinance by allowing the use of to kitchen_In this existing garage structure. 4. The proposed use Is a use Intended tc be accessory to the primary use and it Is not Intended for year- round occupation by anyone other than the primary owner of the property. 5. No findings are made under MGL Chapter 40A,Section 10 with the exception that the granting of this relief would not be in derogation of the spl,►It nor the intent of the Zoning Ordlnanca to allow the seoond kitchen In view of the fact that the second kitchen will be used in conjunction with the prima•yr residence and not as a separat0 residence_ The Vote wZs as follows: AYE:' Richard Boy,Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale r DEC-20-99 TIDE . 04 :02 Prl K I TCHENKORNER 5.P85404535 P. 05 DEC.[0.1553 1 Z 1OAt1 TA SCHIU_11`6 PC 5087750792 ti0.995 P.5 Town of eamstaple-zoning Board of Appeala-Decision and NelicC Appeal Plumber 1999-119-MQ0Q,1(®l6 Variance to Ssaon 3-1.3 . DeCISiOn: Based on the findings of fact, a motion was duly made and seconded to grant the rellcf being sought in Appeal No. 1999-119,subject to the following terms and conditions: 1. The garage apartment unit shall not be rented to anyone nor in anyway be used as anything other than occasional Quest pueeters. a. qt no time shall the panage/epertment building be put on a seperat®motor 6arvioe. a. The applicant shall at,all times comply with any applicable Board of Health Rules and Regulations with reference to septic systems. 4. These restrictions shall be recorded with the Bamstable County Registry of the Deeds and become a. covenant that runs with the land. S. The use of the building in issue shall be a use that is only accessory to the main structure and shall not be used independent of the structure. Bven though rents may not be cherged.no occupancy shall be used for families other than the primary-family occupylrg the property. 6. There shall be no further expansion of this iiving quarters themselves. The garage and storage areas within the building shall not be used for human occupancy. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland,&nd Chairman Cmmett Glynn NAY: tail nightingale Ms. Nightingale slated she voted In the negative because she did not feel there were variznee ov rM•r..�. Order: Variance Number 1999.119 has been Granted with Conditions. This decision must be recorded at the Registry of Deeds for it to be in effect. The relief authorized by this decision must be exercised In one year. Appeals of this decision, if Any.shall be mad®pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A,Section 17,within twenty (20)days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed In the office of the Town Clerk. l±mmett Glynn, Chairma Date Signed I Linda Hutchenriider,Clerk of the Town of Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts, hereby certify that twenty (20)days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that no appeal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Signed and sealed this ay of under the,pains aild penalties of perjury. i r � Linda HXchenrider, Town Cie* 4 1 DEC-20-99 TUE 04 :03 PM KITCHENKORNER ._5085404535 P. 07 DEC.�0.1999 11 19A°I TA SCHIL•L-ING PC 508775079Z ND•993 P.7 • ProQf of Pcatjgn Toom of 8ernatebfe Zoning Board%I Appeals Notice Pi Publ;c Hearing Linde#The Zoning®rdtivence fo►oFtober tar i999 To all parsons Mterered ire or effected by the Beard of Appepla under Sec.t 1 of Chapter 40A of**Generpl Laws of the Cotnmornvoalth of Masspehusetts,and all amendrnirnts thereto you are-hgreby notified that 7:15 P.M. Rogers Appeal Number 1 y99416 Meek Ftogers hss petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appq*W foraSpecial Pem ltfora Fam!ly Apartment pursuant to Section 4-1.t(VD}of the Zoning Ordinance.The property Is yhawn on Assessors Map 128.Pprcel 024 and le commonly addeeiiaedas 09 Red Oak lone:West Eaimatable:MA In an RF Resldentiel F Zonlnp DlstAet, 7;25 P.M. Bowen Appeal Number 1§99.117 John J.00way,Jr,hss tpp!(ed to the Zortinp.board of AMels for 6 Variance to Sectlon 3- 1.3U)Bulk Regulations tolegitImIze pg exi6ft deck that encroaches on the 10 foot ridellne 4etbeek b 91 inches.The encroachment Was riot discovered untn a plot plan wee done for 1114 Vale of the property.The propeRy!s Chown onAssogaves Mep R28.Ptiraat 091.002 and • Is Cr rnMonly addressed as 5p5 RlvgNow Lane, CertervtAe.MA In an RC Residential C 20n!n9 D15trtct. 1AS P.M. MrDanlals Appeet Number IM-11 e John C.and Owen C.MGDonlels have appealed the Building COmmlegionpra respon6e and • his decision as stated in q letter doted June 29. 1899.The®ulle$ne Commissioner will not focus r bulldxng permit for the(eplgcernent Of a Mltchen WhIGh was removed for upgmding. The 9411dIng Commissioner be;stated the%#send kltehen/ApInMent Is I1tegA1 and mu51 got a Vorianea.The property is shown on Asses4ces Map I,%Parcel 140.001 and is gpne Le addressed ae 27 vnrtcTerrmee,oatervil►a,Mp in an PIC Resteentiel Cloning 0i4tAet. ' 8.20 P->,A. Mepaniels App sal Number tpg9.t 18 John C.grid Gwen C.M;DmAels We applied to the Zoning 0 card of Appeets fors Vo+lance to Section 3•1.3 to permit o second kitchen in an 4ccessory building to a prtrnary rosidonco- "The si�Cond kitchen would be us ad n sa#ocie4onvAh ti o us4 of the swlrnming pot)ond would beusedim connection wilh She resldemial dwell;ng.The amp¢rtyla eho.Yn qn Asssssoea Meg 140.Parcel ib12,001 and iseerrmonlygddresseda99tOpit frroee.Ostd Mile;MAinonRC Residential C Zoning 010101, 8:48 P.M. . Flaherty Appeal Number I N9.120 Terry Flaherty d/b/o Cape Auto(Midas)has applied to the Zoning Roped of Appefle,fpr a VananC9 to ettton 4.3 Sign Reyuletione.The applicani prtposes to remove the currant , s9116 end replace them with three t3)wilt mounted eigns. The property is shown on Assessor#Map S43.ParceI013 and 19 Commonlyaddressed as 04lvancuph coed.Hygnniy. MA in an X$Highway Eualneas Dlatriet. • 9;00 F.M. Meany Appeal Number 1909-121 Philip la Meany. Jr.hsa petitlonod to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a spocial permit pursuant to Section 4A,3(2)Noneerlforming%3 Idngs or 51r4ctureS Uaed at.5inglg PAd7wo Family Resldenco.The Applicant desires to remodel the a iating home bythe addition of a one-ear garai a with one room overthe qsrage area Whore the frontyard setback will be lagq thon 20 teat,The property 15 shown oA Assessors Map 206.Pgrcals 034,902 and OB7 end Is eomrnanhredd essed ps 74 Ladd Road,CenterAlle,MA in an RD4 Residential D-1 Zoning • OiDtrict. s:os P.M. Meany Appeal Number 119p$-i22 9t•.;11p V.Meany,Jr.has applltd tothe Zoning poard ofAppeal$fora VariancetoSection$- L I M)Bulk Pagutations, The P8110pner attpka relief from the setback reQUiremenis.The` r VetUnce is requested becquse the proximity of the site to the coastal bank Irmits the erees where the proposed Gonage can be Added.The property is shoAm on Assessors Map 206, 'Pdreele 056.002 and 057 and is commonly addressed as 14 Ladd Road,Centerv0la.MA h an fiD-1 Aarrtdentiat D-1 Zoning Oistrlet. •,4 These Pubho HeAnngs will be held In the tIeennp Acorn;See"Floor,New Town Hall,3$7 { Moin Street, Hyanrsa.Mas$achusetta on Wodriasday.October 13. 1999- Al plans and SWICetions May be revi"eg at the Zonis f�osjd of App"!a Offlct.Tovm of Barnstable. Fimnino DepaKMent.230 South Street.HYN0013,MA. Emma((.Glyni Chpirmen Zoning Board of Appeals / • The Bamstable Palrioi September 23 d,September t o d rn m Wo mappar "nerl awneat2 addr state zip nj N ,140 125 1)O OLMPIO, FELTX J ADE. rwc 0 MTHPIO 309 "TA1I110 AVE OSTERVTLLE 14A 02655 � p 140 126• CAIti, ANDRZA H 295 6TAI17130 AVE OSTE"mLB MA 02655 D 140 127 002 REAMW01I, MICHELE B 2313 HARIAM LH LAKE FOREST IL 6004S N � 140 129 OUTESHA, PHILIP A & OIAllgM 602 MAIN ST OSPERVLLLE 11A t12655 m 140 129 SHPA, RICHARD J L MEW R 246. gr iLARD ST w'LT011 t4h 02186 m 3 m 140 140 001 IMPYHY, M4=A 14 . 232 NYAM10 AVE 03TERVILLE PM 02655 A 140 148 002 awkWAiA, mTCt1RL G & LYNHt;n" P 0 60X 21ZB HYAt7PIS 71A 02601 � 140 1.49 P&T'RICA, PAMEMA H 12 SNATTUCK SMET NA2IC8 M 9060 _t W 3) 140 150 001 BRO:)K3. RICOAR0 R? SR TRS 9HCDAITIRL, 30MI C & C14F-1 C 23 118WALT S1' WOR ESTER /4A 61609 N n 3 140 150 002 T'Y.RREEL, JCWgCM'P & liARr1 241 ORMPOL RD QELLESLEY HILLS ma 02181 X .., 7, L40 150 003 crROSIER, J DAVID 278 WSA7tNO AVE OSTEBVTF,LZ MA 02655 r- ...140 157 CROCKER, JAMES H JR TR EAST BATIOSTZRVILLE TRUST PO FOM 196 OS17EM US !IA 0Z655 � (1 140 15.4 BORG, NAUCY J 6 IIOFI:, LINDA A k2S AR1:0L0 Sr P, P'INIVIDROCE PIT 0"1.5 _ m 140 160 MI RYAN, JO rRM H17 G & MRY 1 19322 OAC VIEW T RMSTON TX 7'094 n Z 140 1G0 402 MA7.2F,0, PAID. A & DRE110.L A 145 EAST BAY ROAD OSTMVILLE. I1A 026S5 27 O 140 161 MAH01MY, STEPHEN R & AMTCaA b P 0 BaX 5079• C KPAPTM, IVY I1937 A Z I 140 161 001 CAIS, RICHARD TR P 0 BOX 454 KARMC-MUVRT XFL 02646 En m 140 Z05 ORAM, MARY ELLEN 1413 LAPM100D TE97MCF. PAL" CITY FL •JIM � A 140 206 FITal9FSGAN, Is PAlWC.rA TR s FIIATF.GTti, J IE.q J TR 14 YORK TERRACE 0S7"mRVILLC MA 02635 cn 140 207 AAAIR, 4CR1:CE S TR tCARROLL, POTTER RESSLER JP. 260 FrSRE ST HOLYSZ"' t!A Ol'746 -J 140 200 MXAFFMT)C, XEVIN H 2 TROODEt7 PATQ L°L%=VGTOt7 MA 02.173 rU 110 209 r.AVANAGB, HRRRIP,T P& RCOM HAIiRIAT KAVAIPACn REVOK TRSt 38 TOPJ< Tt P. OSTERVILLE tM •02655 t4U 210 001 S1iSIDICO. STEPRM S 6 Mini 167 EAST BAY RD OSTEItt*iT.LB Mel 02655 140 210 002 KBSTP7, LBAtr Ft 373 ZAST BAY RD OSTRRVILLE MA 02655 T m 01 A m Z A W tD N w - >T 3 m s QUERY PERMITS': QUERY END QU` RY PERMITS PENTAMATION----------------------------------------------------------- 04/27/99 PERMIT NUMBER 37409 PARCEL ID 140 150 001 27 YORK TERRAACE PERMIT TYPE BREMOD RESIDENTIAL ALT/CONV DESCRIPTION REMODEL 2 EXISTING BATHS CONTRACTOR PERMIT FEE 71 . 30 VARIANCE STATUS A ACTIVE CONSTRUCTION TYPE 434 GROUP TYPE 1 APPLICATION Q3/_29/1999 EXPIRATION VALUATION �23`0'OO . Oj0 DATE ISSUED 03/29/1999 COMPLETED DEPARTMENT-----STATUS---DATE-----DEPARTMENT-----STATUS---DATE---- (N) EXT/ (P) REVIOUS/ (C) ONTRACTORS/ PR (0) PERTY/ (I) NSPECTIONS/ (H) ISTORY/ (F) EES/ (A) RCHITECTS/ (V) IOLATION/ (E) XIT f I i' i PENTAMATION----------------------------------------------------------- 04/27/99 PERMIT NUMBER 37409 27 YORK TERRAACE PARCEL ID 140 150 PERMIT TYPE BREMOD CODE CONTRACTOR NAME 057702 FRED,EI PRESS ESC TO END VIEW i I I e cQ T-1 { i I 4 : . I ne i own of isarnstaoie Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services Building Division '367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 C& Office: 508-8624038- Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building'Commissioner Permit no. Date AFFIDAVIT HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR LAW SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT APPLICATION MGL c. 142A requires that the"reconstruction,alterations,renovation,repair,modernization,conversion, improvement,removal,demolition,or construction of an addition to any pre-existing owner-occupied building containing at least one but not more than four dwelling units or to structures which are adjacent to such residence or building be done by registered contractors,with certain exceptions,along with other requirements. Type of Work: &^M ZU u,W_ Estimated Cost Zd i CDC)- Address of Work: at) O y 1, C Owner's Name: Date of Application: I hereby certify that: ` Registration is not required for the following reason(s): Work excluded by law C]1ob Under S1,000 Building not owner-occupied Owner pulling own permit Notice is bereby given that: OWNERS PULLING THEIR OWN PERMIT OR DEALING WITH UNREGISTERED CONTRACTORS FOR APPLICABLE HOME IMPROVEMENT WORK DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE ARBITRATION PROGRAM OR GUARANTY FUND UNDER MGL c. 142A. SIGNED UNDER PENALTIES OF PERJURY I hereby apply for rmit as the agent of the owner. 1035S Date Co tractor Name Registration No. OR Date Owner's Name gIbmis:Affidav The C'omnrontrcalth of Aki.vachusctty _.�;�:il ;s •�---=j..= Apartmcnt njLrdustrial.4ccidcnts Office of10Y.=19,711 AS •:\.,�,� . _ 600 If ashin�turr Street Worl;ors' Compensation Insurance Afridavit Artilicant information: ^••--�•^'���plc�se 1'R(NT•legiil�^��—M�•��'� ___-+ - name: lncnrion• 01 1.,,�h- LA-� a ...... in,o 49,9 I am a homeowner performing all work myself. I am a sole proprietor and have no one wor:c;n_= in any capacity I am an employer providing workers'—compensation formy employees working on this job. tt•conttnv mime: P co GK ef C �7(-os U cit,• �i1S� U 1 (.1.�_,•r,�}�l A o� —� nhnnc R• Loo incmrancc cn /�Q J nn)� _ nolic� !i �G� 00 g Xz6 [� I am a sole proprietor. general contractor, or homeowner(circle otre) and have hired the contractors listed below who have the following workers' compensation po►i%,-s: Comm tnv n tine _ arirlresc• city• nhnnc�+• incur-incc rn com inv name atitf resc� rite nhon�R• incur•tnce co _ policytt -y-- -- Attach additional sheet if n Cie essary - ► "-:L' -- -_ .--� -_�;,;,._ ..,,,�,•� Failure to secure coveracc as required under Section 2SA of N I G L 152 can lead to the imposition of criminal penalties ol•a line up to S1.500.00 andiur unc ;cars'imprisonment:is-cil as civil penalties in the farm of a STOP NVORK ORDER and a fine of S100.00 a day against me. 1 understand that a copy of this statement may be furwnrded to the Olfcc of investigations of the DIA for coverage verification. !do herehr•cc ifr r rrlrr Nie reins ern penalties oJprrjun•that the information pmrvided above is true and correct. Sianature Datc _a l 19 Print name - �I Phone* Y�� d� ' official use unit' do not write in this area to be completed by gin or town ofl7eial city or town: permit/license 0 rlBuilding Department % Licensing hoard E check if immediate response is required 0Scleetmen s Office _ 011c2ith Department . contact percon — phone q• Miller i . J r µcagy:CO��'fl�I�1'lb�S.►JRuISc�, . . . E Num 043 0.;. V l a• 00 l,L•�,.MA► 0�6;5• `�Adm(ntsl; O.r;;; :. eW. mmm OR ta r f I HARRINGTON PLUMBING P.O.BOX 1635 MASHPEE, MA.02649 508-477-1749] April 21, 1999 KITCHEN KORNER RE: McDANEL RESIDENCE 27-YORK TERRACE OSERTVILLE ATT: Maryann BATHROOMS-MAIN HOUSE MASTER BATH- Install shower, tub, toilet and two lavatories as shown on drawings by Kitchen Korner. All fixtures and faucets will be supplied,by Kitchen Komer. We will supply all labor, shower pan, pipe and fittings, permits. For$5,200.00 BETH'S BATH-Install'tub,toilet and lavatory-in-the same-fashion as master bath. For$ 1,200:00 Sincerely David.Harrington i "M a,��ice,,.P- r ,,'b � .�`,ti +'.. ,{'•'r f�a�' ,; 1 i IA i F+C i' I Assessor's office d lot number lnum' ��� �� ®� SEPTIC SYSTEM E" Assessor's map and Board of Health(3rd:floor): 2n INSTALLED IN C w Sewage Permit number 30� 61, 23 WITH TIT Engineering Department(3rd floor): I r ENVIRONMENTA ' House number �/ TOl1911q �'r� �� `�' ' 6. Definitive Plan.Approved by Planning Board 19 rev APPLICATIONS PROCESSED 8:36-9:30 A.M.and 1:00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN-_ OF B.ARNSTABLE POP" ILI LDING INSPE TOR ATION FOR PERMI" y �( i1 i TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION (0 "[ 19 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit a9c?rding to the following information: /� Location !i� �& t'C, (Qtt i1t((/)10 W4 R. 01 � Proposed Use �,yo Ybom f 0 It k Zoning District V L Fire District �`�fy! �I7 Name of Owner WA( Address 27 10✓IL kVVVL1 U,k Name of Builder M<<( ✓� Address �� ���� ✓'��y Cl ✓� ��� Name of Architect Jt/L A- Address I tZIf So✓tl h,bP5 q , b."P Number of Rooms Foundation Exterior C "d (4(uPbowr� Roofing � ►' Floors -i fT u'�tlf-� `L Interior elnt tr Heating (C�� got s Plumbing JV` Fireplace Al Approximate Cost ?JD p nn S� Area Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regarding the ab a construction. Name �- Construction Supervisor's Licensee / v GARDNER, WALTER & MARY r t No 35104 Permit Fo •. N Single Famil e- 1 Location 27 York a Osterv ' 1 t, UU Owner` Walter & a ardner Type of Construction F e Plot Lot Permit Granted. June 8, 19 92 .'. .Date of Inspection ,�/�� 19 a �' Date Completed 19 14 N � r • P 'e :. La' ru � " 01013:785,012 11-17-99 03:06 BAIW"ML& `99 Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-119 -McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 RC Residential District Summary: Granted with Conditions Applicants: John C. &Gwen C. McDanielg Property Address: 27 York Terrace, Osterville Assessor's Map/Parcel: Map 140, Parcel 150.001 Area: 0.58 acre n Zoning: RC Residential C Zoning District �1 Groundwater Overlay: AP Aquifer Protection District XQ Background: The property that is the subject of this appeal consists of a 0.58 acre lot commonly addressed as 27 York Terrace, Osterville. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a living area of approximately 3,876 sq. ft. The other building is a one and a half story, detached garage/apartment structure with a living area of approximately 745 sq. ft.' The assessor's field card lists this structure as a single-family dwelling. I In the spring of 1999, the applicants were issued a building permit(#35965)for the replacement of windows and doors in the garage/apartment building. Evidently, the renovation work expanded to include the removal of the existing kitchen, wiring and plumbing. In the process of this additional work, after the removal of the interior, a Stop Order was issued. In a letter dated June 29, 1999 from Attorney Theodore I v Schilling to Ralph Crossen, the applicants requested that a new building permit be issued to allow the replacement of the kitchen. In response to this letter, the Building Commissioner wrote"must get a variance-the apartment is illegal". According to the applicants, the kitchen was already installed when they purchased the property in 1998. They contend that the second kitchen in the garage building adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single- family dwelling use only and is not in violation of any zoning by-law or ordinance. They have applied for a Variance to Section 3-1.3 to allow a second kitchen in an accessory building to the primary residence. This appeal is in the alternative to Appeal Number 1999-118 (appeal of the'Building Commissioner). Procedural Summary: This appeal was filed at the Town Clerk's Office and at the Office of the Zoning Board of Appeals on July 27, 1999. A 60 day extension of time for holding the hearing and for filing of the decision was executed between the applicant and the Board Chairman. A public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals was duly advertised and notices sent to all abutters in accordance with MGL Chapter 40A. The hearing was opened October 13, 1999, at which time the Board granted the requested Variance with conditions after upholding the decision of the Building Commissioner in Appeal No. 1999-118. ' According to Assessor's records dated 10/05/99 } Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 Hearing Summary: Board Members hearing this appeal were Ron Jansson, Gail Nightingale, Richard Boy, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn. Attorney Theodore Schilling represented the applicant. Present was Kathy Richardson, the broker who sold the property in issue to the applicants. Attorney Schilling requested, and the Board agreed, to hear Appeal Number 1999-118 and Appeal Number 1999-119 together. Attorney Schilling explained the petitioners are seeking to overrule the Building Commissioner to allow for the re-installation of a kitchen adjacent to the pool in an accessory building, or in the alternative, a Variance to allow a second kitchen. The petitioners purchased the property from the Brooks Family Trust. Attorney Schilling submitted a letter from Pauline C. Peck, a member of the trust, stating the second kitchen was there when they bought the property and remained when they sold it to the McDaniels. Attorney Schilling stressed the applicants did not install this second kitchen -it was there when they bought the house. Attorney Schilling gave a brief history stating that sometime in late 1998-early 1999, the petitioners sought out a contractor for the purpose of fixing leaking windows and doors in the accessory building containing the second kitchen. A building permit was secured for that limited work. As the work progressed, it was determined that further work was warranted including an upgrade to the kitchen with newer cabinets and appliances, replacing what was already in place. The builder and general contractor apparently did not take out another building permit for the additional work which was not known to the owners. Only after the removal of the kitchen and the gutting of the interior was it determined that a new building permit would have to be issued. After several meetings between Attorney Schilling and the Building Commissioner, it was determined by the Building Commissioner that the kitchen could not be re-installed and the Building Commissioner would not amend or issue a new building permit for that purpose. It is the letter of June 29, 1999 where the Building Commissioner has stated, "must get a variance-the apartment is illegal"that is being appealed. In Attorney Schilling's opinion, the petitioner is a victim not having lived in Barnstable, having used an off- cape attorney to purchase the property and purchasing an updated 80 year old dwelling that would lend most people to believe that the kitchen was an accessory use to the swimming pool and the property. The petitioners did not contribute to nor cause their own problem. Attorney Schilling referenced similar court cases, Boch v. Vincent et al., Singer v. DeMartino, and Commonwealth v. Jaffee where multiple kitchens have been allowed. As in those cases, the property in issue is a single family residence, designed for single family use only, it is just that there are two kitchens on the property. The Building Commissioner contends that having two kitchens on a piece of property automatically renders it a multi-family home rather than a single family home. In Attorney Schilling's opinion, having two kitchens is not a violation of the town's Zoning Ordinance. The property had two separate kitchens when the,petitioners bought the property and they want to maintain both facilities on the property. The accessory building is used in conjunction with the swimming pool. Therefore, the Building Commissioner should be overruled and the petitioners issued a building permit that would include the replacement of the renovated kitchen for the purpose of use as a one-family house and not to be used as an apartment. Attorney Schilling reviewed the submitted photographs which show the main dwelling, the accessory building and pool area, and indicated these photographs demonstrate that the structures are constructed as a"unit"for single family use. It is not designed as a separate apartment use. The property is intricately linked and does not lend itself to any kind of multi-family use. If the Board so desires, Attorney Schilling stated, the petitioners would assent to a condition that the issuance of the building permit would be recorded at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds which would state that the property has the use of two kitchens but is strictly limited to one family and shall not be used for lease or rent or any apartment use whatsoever. This would include the restriction that there 2 r Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 will only be one electric service to the property. It would also state that the Town reserves all of their rights to enforce any violation if the premises are used for more than one-family use. In Appeal Number 1999-119, the petitioners are seeking a Variance to allow for the use and maintenance of a second kitchen as an associated use to the pool to be utilized by one single family in occupancy, restricting the property to one electric service. A literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve substantial hardship-financial or otherwise-especially since the Petitioner is an innocent victim upon purchasing the property with two kitchens without any notice or warning that the kitchen may violate zoning. The property is of irregular shape which is a unique condition affecting the locus but not the zoning district in which it is located. The relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the Zoning Ordinance because of the irregular shaped lot and location of the buildings and the improvements. The Board and Attorney Schilling discussed the Boch Case. In the Loch Case, all the kitchens were in one unit and in this case there are two separate units. The Board was concerned with enforcement and monitoring the use. The Building Commissioner addressed the Board and reported the Town's records show in 1989-1990 the outbuilding was a garage. Then in November 1990, a building permit was issued for a"cabana"to include a playroom, a bathroom, and a bar sink-but not a kitchen. Over the years, it became a full kitchen. The Building Commissioner stated he has no problem with granting relief for the additional kitchen, but this should not be allowed as-of-right. The Building Commissioner agreed that the applicants are innocent-it was a previous owner who installed the kitchen: Public Comment: Kathy Richardson spoke in support. When she sold the property, she was told by the previous seller that the kitchen was allowed. It is the intent of the owner to use this property as a single family home. No one else spoke in favor or in opposition to this appeal. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of October 13, 1999, the Board voted on the following findings of fact as related to Appeal No. 1999-119: 1. The applicants, John C. & Gwen C. McDaniels, own the property in issue which is addressed as 27 York Terrace, Osterville, MA, as shown on Assessor's Map 140, Parcel 150.001 consisting of 0.58 acres. The site is located in the RC Residential C Zoning District. 2. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a gross living area of approximately 3,900 square feet. The other building is a one and a half story, detached garage/apartment structure with a living area of approximately 745 square feet. The smaller structure has a playroom, one bedroom, two bathrooms and a kitchen. 3. The petitioners are seeking to vary the Zoning Ordinance by allowing the use of a kitchen in this existing garage structure. 4. The proposed use is a use intended to be accessory to the primary use and it is not intended for year- round occupation by anyone other than the primary owner of the property. 5. No findings are made under MGL Chapter 40A, Section 10 with the exception that the granting of this relief would not be in derogation of the spirit nor the intent of the Zoning Ordinance to allow the second kitchen in view of the fact that the second kitchen will be used in conjunction with the primary residence and not as a separate residence. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale 3 Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999-119-McDaniels Variance to Section 3-1.3 Decision: Based on the findings of fact, a motion was duly made and seconded to grant the relief being sought in Appeal No. 1999-119, subject to the following terms and conditions: 1. The garage apartment unit shall not be rented to anyone nor in anyway be used as anything other than occasional guest quarters. 2. At no time shall the garage/apartment building be put on a separate meter service. 3. The applicant shall at all times comply with any applicable Board of Health Rules and Regulations with reference to septic systems. 4. These restrictions shall be recorded with the Barnstable County Registry of the Deeds and become a covenant that runs with the land.' 5. The use of the building in issue shall be a use that is only accessory to the main structure and shall not be used independent of the structure. Even though rents may not be charged, no occupancy shall be used for families other than the primary-family occupying the property. 6. There shall be no further expansion of the living quarters themselves. The garage and storage areas within the building shall not be used for human occupancy. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Richard Boy, Ron Jansson, Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale Ms. Nightingale stated she voted in the negative because she did not feel there were variance conditions. Order: Variance Number 1999-119 has been Granted with Conditions. This decision must be recorded at the Registry of Deeds for it to be in effect. The relief authorized by this decision must be exercised in one year. Appeals of this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A, Section 17, within twenty (20) days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Emmett Glynn, Chairma Date Signed I Linda Hutchenrider, Clerk of the Town of Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts, hereby certify that twenty (20) days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that no appeal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Signed and sealed this _ day of n under the pains and penalties of perjury. Linda Hutchenrider, Town Clerk 4 D RefNo mappar ownerl owner2 addr city state zip k` 118+119 140 125 D'OLIMPIO, FELIX J ADELINE D'OLIMPIO 309 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 126 CAIN, ANDREA M 295 WAINNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 127 001 REARDON, MICHELE B 1313 HARLAND LN LAKE FOREST IL 60045 '140 128 DENESHA, PHILIP A & DIANE M 602 MAIN ST OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 129 SHEA, RICHARD J & ELLEN M 246 HIGHLAND ST MILTON MA 02186 140 148 001 MURPHY, MARCIA M 232 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 148 002 MANGALO, MICHEL G & LYNNE TALA P 0 BOX 2128 HYANNIS MA 02601 140 149 PATRICK, PAMELA H 12 SHATTUCK STREET NATICK MA 01760 140 150 001 BROOKS, RICHARD HT SR TRS %MCDANIEL, JOHN C & GWEN C 23 METCALF ST WORCESTER MA 01609 j 140 150 002 TYRRELL, JOSEPH P & MARY A 241 BRISTOL RD WELLESLEY HILLS MA 02181 140 150 003 DEROSIER, J DAVID 278 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 157 CROCKER, JAMES H JR TR EAST BAY/OSTERVILLE TRUST PO BOX 496 OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 159 BORG, NANCY J & BORG, LINDA A 125 ARNOLD ST E PROVIDENCE RI 02915 140 160 001 RYAN, JOHN G & MARY L 19322 OAK VIEW TERR HOUSTON TX 77094 140 160 002 MAZZEO, PAUL A & BRENDA A 145 EAST BAY ROAD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 161 MAHONEY, STEPHEN R & ANTONIA B P 0 BOX 5079 E HAMPTON, NY 11937 140 161 001 CAIN, RICHARD TR P 0 BOX 454 HARWICHPORT MA 02646 140 205 OHARA, MARY ELLEN 1413 LANCEWOOD TERRACE PALM CITY FL 34990 140 206 FINNEGAN, M PATRICIA TR & FINNEGAN, JAMES J TR 14 YORK TERRACE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 207 ADAIR, GRACE S TR %CARROLL, POTTER HESSLER JR 268 FISKE ST HOLLISTON MA 01746 140 208 MCCAFFERTY, KEVIN M 2 TRODDEN PATH LEXINGTON MA 02173 140 209 KAVANAGH, HARRIET P& ROBERT HARRIET KAVANAGH REVOK TRST 38 YORK TERR OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 210 001 SUSIDKO, STEPHEN W & PAMELA 167 EAST BAY RD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 210 002 KESTEN, LEAH R 173 EAST BAY RD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 3 r Proof of Publication --LEGAL.NOTICES LEGAL NOTICES Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals Notice of Public Hearing Under The Zoning_ Ordinance for October 13, 1999 To all persons interested in,or affected by the Board of Appeals under Sec. 11 of Chapter 40A of the General Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts,and all amendments thereto you are hereby notified that: 7:15 P.M. Rogers Appeal Number 1999-116 Mark Rogers has petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Special Permit fora Family Apartment pursuant to Section 3-1.1(3)(D)of the Zoning Ordinance.The property is shown on Assessors Map 128.Parcel 024 and is commonly addressed as 99 Red Oak Lane,West Barnstable,MA in an RF Residential F Zoning District. 7:25 P.M. Bowes Appeal Number 1999-117 John J.Bowes.Jr.has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Variance to Section 3- 1.3(5)Bulk Regulations to legitimize an existing deck that encroaches on the 10 foot sideline setback by 31 inches.The encroachment was not discovered until a plot plan was done for the sale of the property.The property is shown on Assessors Mop 228,Parcel 091.002 and is commonly addressed as 305 Riverview Lane,Centerville, MA in an RC Residential C Zoning District. 8:15 P.M. McDaniels Appeal Number 1999-118 John C.and Gwen C.McDaniels have appealed the Building Commissioners response and his decision as stated in a letter dated June 29, 1999.The Building Commissioner will not issue a building permit for the replacement of a kitchen which was removed for upgrading. The Building Commissioner-has stated the second kitchen/apartment is illegal and must get a Variance:The property is shown on Assessors Map 140,Parcel 150.Q01 and is commonly addressed as 27 York Terrace,Osterville•MA in an RC Residential C Zoning.District. 8:20 P.M. - McDaniels , Appeal Number 1999.119 John C.and Gwen C.McDaniels have applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals fora Variance to Section 3-1.3 to permit a second kitchen in an accessory building to a primary residence. The second kitchen would be used in association with the use of the swimming pool and would be used in connection with the residential dwelling.The gropertyis shown on Assessors Map 140.Parcel 150.001 and is commonly addressed as 21 6AITerrace,Osterville;MA in an RC Residential C Zoning District. 8:45 P.M. . Flaherty Appeal Number 1999.120 Tent'Flaherty d/b/a Cape Auto(Midas)has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Variance to Section 4-3 Sign Regulations.The applicant proposes to remove the current signs and replace them with three (3) wall mounted signs. The property is shown on Assessors Map 343,Parcel 013 and is commonly addressed as 64 lyanough Road.Hyannis, MA in an HB Highway Business District. 9:00 P.M. Meany Appeal Number 1999.121 Philip E. Meany. Jr. has petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Special Permit pursuant to Section 4-4.3(2)Nonconforming Buildings or Structures Used as Single and Two Family Residences.The applicant desires to remodel the existing home by the addition of a one-car garage with one room over the garage area where the front yard setback will be less than 20 feet.The property is shown on Assessors Map 206.Parcels 056.002 and 057 and is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road.Centerville.MA in an 19D-1 Residential D-1 Zoning District. 9:05 P.M. Meany Appeal Number 1999-122 Philip E.Meany,Jr.has applied to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Variance to Section 3- 1.1(5) Bulk Flegulations.'The Petitioner seeks relief from the setback requirements. The, Variance is requested because the proximity of the site to the coastal bank limits the areas where the proposed garage can be added.The property is shown on Assessors Map 206, Parcels 056.002 and 057 and is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road,Centerville,MA in an RD-1 Residential D-1 Zoning District. These Public Hearings will be held in the bearing Room;Second Floor,New Town Hall,367 Main Street, Hyannis, Massachusetts on Wednesday, October 13, 1999. All plans and applications may be reviewed at the Zoning Board of Appeals Office.Town of Barnstable, Planning Department.230 South Street,Hyannis,MA. Emmett Glynn.Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals The Barnstable Patriot September 23&September 30. 1999 Pro_Publication Town of Sars st"2=hoard o/ Nolte of PubRe filoosh (lade►Tlsa 20::4AA not, for Oos k 10,19" Xll persons nterosted e cte a or offed by the Board olAppssls under Sec.11 of Chapter of the General Laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.and as wnwmdmante - thereto you orb hereby notified that: . 7:15 P.M. Ropers Appeal Number 198811E Mork Ropers hoe petitioned to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a Special Permit for a Fomly Apartment pursuant to Section 3.1.113)(D)of the Zoning Ordrmance.The property 1s shown on Assessols Map 126.Parcel 024 and to ctmmony sddressod as 99 Red Oak Lane.West Barnstable.MA in an RF Residential F Zoning Dialect. 7:26 P.M. Bowan Appeal Number 1988117 John J.Bowes.Jr.has aappppImad to the Zonkkpp Board d Appeals for•Variance to Section 3- 1.3(61 Bulk Regulations toleplirtiss on el'1elYV deck dial encroaches on time 10 fool sideline setback by 31 inches.The encroachment wee not docwered unit a plot plan wee done for the side of the property.The property to sil avoi on Asoessor's Map 228.Parcel OB 1.002 and is commonly addressed as 306"Maw Lane,Conterville.MA in on RC Residential C Zoning District. 8:I s P.M. MCDenials Appeal Number 188811S John C.and Gwen C.McDaniel&have appealed the Buildup C ormissionors response and • his decision ss stated In a letter dated.Are 29.1 ON.The Bulking Commissioner will not issue a building permit for the replacement of a kitchen which vat romovod for upgrading. The Building Commissioner has slated the second kilchan fsperinenl Is 000 and must pet a Variance.The proporty is shown on Assessors Map 140.Porcal I bO.001"is commomJy addressed as 27 York Terrace,OstarWlla,MA in an RC Residential C Zoning Dotnct. ' 6u20 P.M. McDonels . Appool Number 1BB8110 John C.and Gwen C.McOarlols hws spoked to the Zoning Bard of Appeals fail Variance to Section 3.1.3 to permit a second kilchhiinn In an accessory building to a primary residence. The second kitchen would be used In association with the use of the awimrring pool and would be used in connection wilh the residential dwelling.Thajrop&rty N shown on As sessors Map 140.Parcel 160.001 and is corrinonly addressed as 27 0ok�Tsnsce.OsleMls.MA In an RC Residenlef C Zoning District. 8:45 P.M. FloheAyy Appeal Number 18gg 120 . Terry Flaherty d/b/e Cope Auio 1Midas/hoe applied to the Zoning Board of Appetite for a Variance to Section 4-3 Sign Regulations.The applicant proposes to remove the current signs and replace them with three 43)wadi mounlad signs.The property Is shown on . Asssssorsi Map 343.Parcel 013 and le commonly,addressed so 64 yenough Road.Hyannis. MA in an HB Highway Business Dstdcl • 9r00 P.M. Manny Appeal Number 1998121 ' Philp E.Meary.Jr.has petitioned to the Zoning Board at Appeals for a Special permit Pursuant to Section 4.4,312)Nonconforming BuNdirps or Structures Used es 64VW"Two Family Residances.The applicant doalrso tg remodel the eaisllng home by the addition of a ono csr garage with one room over the garage area whore the front yard selbock will be loss than 20 fell.The property is shown an Assessors Map 206.Parcels 066.002 and 067 and iscommonyedddaesedss74 Ladd Road.ConterWle•MAinan RD.IRe ldentidD•1Zoning District. 9:05 P.M. Moony Appeal Number 1999,122 Philip E.Meany.Jr.has is ad to the Zoning Board of Appals for a Variance to Section 9• 1.1(5)Bulk Regulation.The Petitioner tasks relief from the setback requirements.The' Valence H re4us6led because IM pf"mipr of the ono to the coastal bank limits the aloes where the proposed garage can be added.The properly is shown on Assessoes Map 206. Parcels 056.002 and 067 and Is commonly addressed as 74 Ladd Road.CwnlorWie.MA in an RD I Residential D.1 Zoning 011I60. ' These Pubkc Hoanngs will be held In this Hsi"Ram;Second Floor.New Town Hall.367 Mein Street.Hyannis.Mouachuselto on Wednesday.October 13.19%. AN plans end apphcalmon6 may be roviewad at Iho Zonl�npp Board of Appe ble. de Office.Town of Bamsta Planning Deportment.230 South Street.alp a.MA Emmet)Glynn.Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals The Barnstable Patrol September 23 5 September 30.1NO BARNSTABLE COUNTY REGISTRY OF DEEDS A TRUE COPY,ATTEST JOHN F.MEADE,REGISTER a3�yu • OUCi7bS,012 11-17-99 03106 B44ST11BLE LRNO COURT REGISTRY It Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999419•McDanlels Variance to Section 3.1.3 RC Residential District. S` Summary: Granted with Conditions ,J1 h Applicants: John C.&Gwen C.McDaniel$ Property Address: 27 York Terrace,Osterville M Assessors MaplParcel: Map 140.Parcel 150.001 v 0 Area: 0.58 acre IV Zoning: RC Residential C Zoning District ( Y Groundwater Overlay: AP Aquifer Protection District G7` /,5//(� Background: ^� r The property that is the subject of this appeal consists of a 0.58 acre lot commonly addressed as 27 York Terrace,Osterville. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom,two-story single-family residence with a living area of approximately 3,876 sq.ft. The other building is a one and a half story,detached garage/apartment structure with a Irving area of approximately 745 sq.ft.' The assessor's field card lists this structure as a single-family dwelling. In the spring of 1999.the applicants were issued a building permit(#35965)for the replacement of windows and doors in the garage/apartment building. Evidently,the renovation work expanded to include the removal of the existing kitchen,wiring and plumbing. In the process of this additional work,after the removal of the Interior,a Stop Order was issued. In a letter dated June 29,1999 from Attorney Theodore Schilling to Ralph Crossen,the applicants requested that a new building permit be issued to allow the replacement of the kitchen. In response to this letter,the Building Commissioner wrote"must get a variance-the apartment is illegal". According to the applicants,the kitchen was already installed when they purchased the property in 1998. They contend that the second kitchen in the garage building adjacent to the pool is used strictly for single- family dwelling use only and is not in violation of any zoning by-law or ordinance. They have applied for a Variance to Section 3.1.3 to allow a second kitchen In an accessory building to the primary residence. This appeal is in the alternative to Appeal Number 1999-118(appeal of the Building Commissioner). Procedural Summary: This appeal was filed at the Town Clerk's Office and at the Office of the Zoning Board of Appeals on July 27,1999. A 60 day extension of time for holding the hearing and for filing of the decision was executed between the applicant and the Board Chairman. A public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals was duly advertised and notices sent to all abutters In accordance with MGL Chapter 40A. The hearing was opened October 13,1999,at which time the Board granted the requested Variance with conditions after upholding the decision of the Building Commissioner In Appeal No.1999-118. 'According to Assessor's records dated IOM/99 F - r. Town of Barnstable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and NoIW Appeal Number 1999-119-McDanbh Variance to Section 3-1.3 Hearing Summary: Board Members hearing this appeal were Ron Jansson,Gail Nightingale,Richard Boy,Ralph Copeland, and Chairman Emmett Glynn. Attorney Theodore Schilling represented the applicant. Present was Kathy Richardson,the broker who sold the property in issue to the applicants. Attorney Schilling requested,and the Board agreed,to hear Appeal Number 1999-118 and Appeal Number 1999-119 together. Attorney Schilling explained the petitioners are seeking to overrule the Building Commissioner to allow for the re-installation of a kitchen adjacent to the pool in an accessory building,or in the alternative,a Variance to allow a second kitchen. The petitioners purchased the property from the Brooks Family Trust. Attorney Schilling submitted a letter from Pauline C.Peck,a member of the trust,stating the second kitchen was there when they bought the property and remained when they sold It to the McDaniels. Attorney Schilling stressed the applicants did not install this second kitchen-it was there when they bought the house. Attorney Schilling gave a brief history stating that sometime in late 1998-early 1999,the petitioners sought out a contractor for the purpose of fixing leaking windows and doors in the accessory building containing the second kitchen. A building permit was secured for that limited work. As the work progressed,it was determined that further work was warranted including an upgrade to the kitchen with newer cabinets and appliances,replacing what was already In place. The builder and general contractor apparently did not take out another building permit for the additional work which was not known to the owners. Only after the removal of the kitchen and the gutting of the interior was it determined that a new building permit would have to be issued. After several meetings between Attorney Schilling and the Building Commissioner,it was determined by the Building Commissioner that the kitchen could not be re-Installed and the Building Commissioner would not amend or Issue a new building permit for that purpose. It Is the letter of June 29,1999 where the Building Commissioner has stated, 'must get a variance-the apartment is illegal'that is being appealed. In Attorney Schilling's opinion,the petitioner is a victim not having lived in Barnstable,having used an off- cape attorney to purchase the property and purchasing an updated 80 year old dwelling that would lend most people to believe that the kitchen was an accessory use to the swimming pool and the property. The petitioners did not contribute to nor cause their own problem. Attorney Schilling referenced similar court cases,Boch v.Vincent at al.,Singer v.DeMartino,and Commonwealth v.Jaffee where multiple kitchens have been allowed. As in those cases,the property in issue is a single family residence,designed for single family use only,it is just that there are two kitchens on the property. The Building Commissioner contends that having two kitchens on a piece of property automatically renders it a multi-family home rather than a single family home. In Attorney Schilling's opinion,having two kitchens is not a violation of the town's Zoning Ordinance. The property had two separate kitchens when the petitioners bought the property and they want to maintain both facilities on the property. The accessory building is used in conjunction with the swimming pool. Therefore,the Building Commissioner should be overruled and the petitioners issued a building permit that would include the replacement of the renovated kitchen for the purpose of use as a one-family house and not to be used as an apartment. Attomey Schilling reviewed the submitted photographs which show the main dwelling,the accessory building and pool area,and indicated these photographs demonstrate that the structures are constructed as a"unit"for single family use. It is not designed as a separate apartment use. The property is intricately linked and does not lend itself to any kind of multi-family use. If the Board so desires,Attorney Schilling stated,the petitioners would assent to a condition that the issuance of the building permit would be recorded at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds which would state that the property has the use of two kitchens but Is strictly limited to one family and shall not be used for lease or rent or any apartment use whatsoever. This would include the restriction that there 2 I Town of Barnstable•Zoning Board of Appeals•Decision and Notice . Appeal Number 1999-119•MGDaMets Variance to Section 3-1.3 will only be one electric service to the property. It would also state that the Town reserves all of their rights to enforce any violation if the premises are used for more than one-famlly use. In Appeal Number 1999.119.the petitioners are seeking a Variance to allow for the use and maintenance of a second kitchen as an associated use to the pool to be utilized by one single family In occupancy, restricting the property to one electric service. A literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve substantial hardship-financial or otherwise-especially since the Petitioner is an innocent victim upon purchasing the property with two kitchens without any notice or warning that the kitchen may violate zoning. The property is of irregular shape which is a unique condition affecting the locus but not the zoning district in which it is located. The relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the Intent or purpose of the Zoning Ordinance because of the irregular shaped lot and location of the buildings and the improvements. The Board and Attorney Schilling discussed the Boch Case. In the BDch Case,all the kitchens were in one unit and in this case there are two separate units. The Board was concerned with enforcement and monitoring the use. The Building Commissioner addressed the Board and reported the Town's records show In 1989-1990 the outbuilding was a garage. Then In November 1990,a building permit was issued for a'cabana'to include a playroom,a bathroom,and a bar sink-but not a kitchen. Over the years,it became a full kitchen. The Building Commissioner stated he has no problem with granting relief for the additional kitchen,but this should not be allowed as-of-right. The Building Commissioner agreed that the applicants are innocent-it was a previous owner who Installed the kitchen. Public Comment: Kathy Richardson spoke in support. When she sold the property,she was told by the previous seller that the kitchen was allowed. It is the Intent of the owner to use this property as a single family home. No one else spoke in favor or in opposition to this appeal. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of October 13,1999,the Board voted on the following findings of fact as related to Appeal No.1999-119: 1. The applicants,John C.&Gwen C.McDaniels,own the property in issue which is addressed as 27 York Terrace,Osterville,MA,as shown on Assessor's Map 140,Parcel 160.001 consisting of 0.58 acres. The site is located in the RC Residential C Zoning District. 2. The lot is developed with two buildings and an associated pool. The main structure is a 3 bedroom, two-story single-family residence with a gross living area of approximately 3,900 square feet.The other building is a one and a half story,detached garage/apanment structure with a living area of approximately 745 square feet. The smaller structure has a playroom,one bedroom,two bathrooms and a kitchen. 3. The petitioners are seeking to vary the Zoning Ordinance by allowing the use of a kitchen in this existing garage structure. 4. The proposed use is a use intended to be accessory to the primary use and it is not intended for year- round occupation by anyone other than the primary owner of the property. 5. No findings are made under MGL Chapter 40A,Section 10 with the exception that the granting of this relief would not be in derogation of the spirit nor the intent of the Zoning Ordinance to allow the second kitchen in view of the fact that the second kitchen will be used in conjunction with the primary residence and not as a separate residence. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Richard Boy,Ron Jansson,Ralph Copeland,and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale 3 s , Town of Bamslable-Zoning Board of Appeals-Decision and Notice Appeal Number 1999.119-MCDanieb Variance to Section 1-1.9 Decision: Based on the findings of fact,a motion was duly made and seconded to grant the relief being sought in Appeal No.1999-119,subject to the following terms and conditions: 1. The garage apartment unit shall not be rented to anyone nor in anyway be used as anything other than occasional guest quarters. 2. At no time shall the garagetapartment building be put on a separate-meter service. 3. The applicant shall at all times comply with any applicable Board of Health Rules and Regulations with reference to septic systems. 4. These restrictions shall be recorded with the Barnstable County Registry of the Deeds and become a covenant that runs with the land. 5. The use of the building in issue shall be a use that is only accessory to the main structure and shall not be used Independent of the structure. Even though rents may not be charged,no occupancy shall be used for families other than the primary family occupying the property. 6. There shall be no further expansion of the living quarters themselves. The garage and storage areas within the building shall not be used for human occupancy. The Vote was as follows: AYE: Richard Boy,Ron Jansson,Ralph Copeland,and Chairman Emmett Glynn NAY: Gail Nightingale Ms.Nightingale stated she voted in the negative because she did not feel there were variance conditions. Order: Variance Number 1999-119 has been Granted with Conditions. This decision must be recorded at the Registry of Deeds for it to be in effect. The relief authorized by this decision must be exercised in one year. Appeals of this decision,if any,shall be made pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A,Section 17,within twenty (20)days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed in the office of the Town Clerk. �o •vS-99 Emmett Glynn,Chairmae Date Signed I Linda Hutchenrider,Clerk of the Town of Barnstable,Barnstable County,Massachusetts,hereby dbitify that twenty(20)days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that nd ' �•. appeal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. r 's ♦� A Signed and sealed this _ day of under the pains end n lJlesfl 0 perlury. Linda Hutchenrider,Town Clerk 4 4 I Re1No Dmppar ownerl owner2 addr city state rip 118+119 140 125 D'OLIMPIO, FELIX J ADELINE D'OLIMPIO 309 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 126 CAIN, ANDREA M 295 WAINNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 127 001 REARDON, MICHELE B 1313 HARLAND LN LAKE FOREST IL 60045 140 128 DENESHA, PHILIP A 6 DIANE M 602 MAIN ST OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 129 SHEA, RICHARD J 6 ELLEN M 246 HIGHLAND ST MILTON MA 02186 140 148 001 MURPHY, MARCIA M 232 WIANNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 148 002 MANGALO, MICHEL G 6 LYNNE TALA P O BOX 2128 HYANNIS MA 02601 140 149 PATRICK, PAMELA H 12 SHATTUCK STREET NATICK MA 01760 140 150 001 BROOKS, RICHARD HT SR TRS BMCDANIEL, JOHN C 6 GWEN C 23 METCALF ST WORCESTER MA 01609 140 150 002 TYRRELL, JOSEPH P 6 MARY A 241 BRISTOL RD WELLESLEY HILLS MA 02181 140 150 003 DEROSIER, J DAVID 278 WIARNO AVE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 157 CROCKER, JAMES H JR TR EAST BAY/OSTERVILLE TRUST PO BOX 496 OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 159 BORG, NANCY J 6 BORG, LINDA A 125 ARNOLD ST• E PROVIDENCE RT 02915 140 160 001 RYAN, JOHN G & MARY L 19322 OAK VIEW TERR HOUSTON TX 77094 140 160 002 MAZZEO, PAUL A a BRENDA A 145 EAST BAY ROAD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 v 140 161 MAHONEY, STEPHEN R 6 ANTONIA B P O BOX 5079 E HAMPTON, NY 11937 140 161 001 CAIN, RICHARD TR P O BOX 454 HARWICHPORT MA 02646 140 205 OHARA, MARY ELLEN 1413 LANCEWOOD TERRACE PALM CITY FL 34990 140 206 FINNEGAN, M PATRICIA TR a FINNEGAN, JAMES J TR 14 YORK TERRACE OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 201 ADAIR, GRACE S TR %CARROLL, POTTER HESSLER JR -268 FISKE ST HOLLISTON MA 01746 140 208 MCCAFFERTY, KEVIN M 2 TRODDEN PATH LEXINGTON MA 02173 . 140 209 KAVANAGH, HARRIET Pt ROBERT HARRIET KAVANAGH REVOK TRST 38 YORK TERR OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 210 O01 SUSIDKO, STEPHEN W 6 PAMELA 167 EAST BAY RD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 140 210 002 KESTEN, LEAK R 173 EAST SAY RD OSTERVILLE MA 02655 3 I I , g lil <� - - $ � I _ x L®r 1-7 It I ry _ I I L t— IQ r F rol TZ )Ni -1 -- -- - - I Z --�n� goo �a 1 iy F DATE' PROJJEICV.AI��1S , F_15QON6.110 L -'ra::— C REVISIONS- DRAWN BY 1 SCALE' V�1' :.I I.Oa I.y'E 219 Fax(5088)428r1295 SHEET' TITLE �j�p (fit ^, I ARCHTTECTUItAL INNOVATIONS AI - 2 rI� 1 L42:9� 1 IAI� _ AVIVMNOPNEMPFR=IHC 1. P.O.BOX 2056,COTUIT,MA 02635 . w n.1 }i� 1 •. .. 1 P.�.f fjpyff} � ,� � P 1� P- h � jl j I :r Kr� ,:.ter •_�� . a •w A Slo"r �r>IQ C s lo r , �c = Z. sE8 Y till pz, ifl 5S 5r L I IX , Ty • �. . � � ��� rat ® 6. sEff f o i /T L7GClD RE EM oz hr L I `- 7-4 �� ' L � L l m i m L D m R 4 ° Z T P s s r y s .V Y y y r '•.tea. 4 s I���, �Y: r >F' i ,,giF:pp y •�a, C+.SFtr;��#, �6 Jl t �u�s DATE: 10/10/02. PROJECT REVISIONS* DRAWN BY' . (508)428-4219 SCALE' Fax)SOB)4284 295 ,M p9! _: kC SHEET "'x TITLE A 2_ 2 Ti s ARCHMCTURAL INNOVATIONS A VfM0MOFAI MffMtFR=RAC P.O.BOX 2056,COTUrr,MA 02635 { ` 4 �A 1 ' i 3Z . - �E L LzL" 12° c -o 119 q°+ SZ p Zm T N � I J•a � S Q a #g N �I-I�— — r to r I•II%4' I 12° �� � 't z T � zLa C _ _ ar s �=z N p�a �• ��� � ���S �+ v _ (IDS I �� 6�1 � ,s , o° zm — �• i I II 'I° �- n 1- -1-- � ` 1 _ - — vp zmmm�_m: (o� I. � TZ r c n o \ z M G cn DATES I0II-Olo2 _ PRO-JJEECL:..AGP1TL,1.IS I.lavPrlohiS-'("O�:'{:,-1 C REVISIONS• DRAWN BY 1 19 SCALE' V¢•i; .II.OI' - I.,E MGD�Nh�L FaX(528<12- Fax(508)428-4295 SHEET' A 1 AI n TITHE — ARCMTECTURAL INNOVATIONS A OMSTON OFN DOFRFRSq WC P.O.BOX 2056,COTUff,MA 02635 o�7 .. w.-..a.`-.�..w ..... .`..,.-.a..na—�'--�,'w.sviwa.�-1 .. .. ++.._..ic..:�.L�i...�es�..rF-=?...i'�,�. �'9�w,W i.t�:. w�teit'«t.JUF�+}w(<.,.Aw,�..2..4, - �r'r a• '+aa- .-5.a ..ws.r e: :.e ,f •1 na f -- K1,411i M. • ,�y'jl ,,Lu i DATE - - - - A SCALE 1jll �, pu _ -- - --- TITLE DRAWING NO. �c�1� �Boa�- P�►�! h i .f g , yea'� Y G 7I b ' b�Qpl-1D 'Wlv)T{ oftsrr,_ ' I 'm v r L �'/• 1 I II/¢° Iti a R a � v I I I a� I _l C In. 13•q AU144 W/ W4"T. —� L 1 11%+1 12° t I . KI s pp Z�=ter �p _ FIT�c tt rl� I m, O I C ! Z Z --,TZ o I Z i'� TLC o o I m rn � O cn 0 71 ;�. DATE' IOIIO�OZ PROJECT::.AGprrIOLIS �Et.JOVPj'IOFdSo:':— REVISIONS• DRAWN BY T SCALE' M 4J� �.II.O� I"8 GDAKJ[F_ Fax(5 L ���ID 28.4219 ' Fax 08)4284295 SHEET' TITLE Al - 2 rI� �� PLAN — ARCHTfECTURAI.INNOVATIONS A DIVBfON OPAL dItRDRlSLT INC P.O.BOX 2056,COTUrr,MA 02635 r s Vrl r z it � 1 AIN Al c_ ® 6 L sr o i N _ so • - o r� a Uo r �6m >aQm i s A Ima u , ->r +N .. AT��oH.y .l- cNc ErSo}��°Y MID nz w m = S\i T p* v l\ ;�l A . v rm m J i L .. 7t'-fir` DATE. I0/I0/02. PROJECT- AporrWJ4'-'F-H1J ATIeU-, REVISIONS- DRAWN BY' I (508)4284219 SCALE' I/W_ ILo,,. _ �m MGDANI�LSID��IG� D Fax(508)428-4295 ,�•�,,;,� ,; SHEET ram.% 1 TITLE ARCHITECTURAL INNOVATIONS A T� s A DN=MOfAIQRUD=INC P.O.BOX 2056,00TUrr,MA 02635 4v ao 1ss. i Li I M. N :z 4, z r7 O Y k lie, V ti 1 j aflw W4WAm-,,,"pkaW „ a+ OOMW,,4rn+'*Fr Vft"" ,.',,,,,"z,,, w.:,., : ",d I I ,*alraAJr+ P«K. 0004006*##F,~ �ll'#,*Ill"t"#*Atl wl' n .. { - ,� 1 u. .ir:{FIMl,�m,.,:w ,,, . ..0."..,a.�K.�fwa111,Y:":,,A,*W+rl 4,Wry. :,J• .y• .n w'{+. ,i:rv;� Y ,1 �: . w ; , t �. a 4 4` .yl r,., !!�:, ".I. ) `.,.xy •". \',,,a.r'°I 7 I-:r,.,,,.4�`.,. s n I aa,P'.I L, r.. ,:'A. .atW R y, µ� LLL y h ��: ., „I:y.' r «•. ( 3 e'' ',,, is "I , „.,•. :., *, pb'nl�:o, a,+ A ,: s ., ,,..«:b .,,,I•,_... > t r.n. C�qt�;. .t'u. A-i;.` . . '.I„ 11 S 4 j A �i�'n � ql, I i. 4 ( .r '.e,m....t Y' •.4 '� y. !.{�P, m Y��Yyyn « 'I fylz 1. ' (S � 1, 'h ,;µ,ar-,.., � ! ('��#� ,gay �pA,d � ;q91 < ;� � .' r 1 k , '� ` � 1 W Ar E w� q�'C"( l�AtK �1f,Y�`�° ,j.� 't6"I�V,Pjii� #,, rnl, " �yL��,, �t 7 �1� 45i1 ��q 'A' I 4,, w _ter.,a, ,.1,..,.w... er. ��I �/tf�fJt r : _ 1 { 3 6 4"t'"'"'iw"r , .: L.., ,,:A!f ,n�.a14 , :G J111 x» *' .R ,.{ ., i.. y,y+.'s, } Y ;�f ;ar,:,:.»,,.r,mr+Jww4,A,., a, ,. a s�.« . _ 1 • 1 , �r��,„. �. ��y �t } a�1 ,, ., } '�+'r ` r i i 4 I M! 'a'"+ " `47 11 i wlP P"44I, „. ,: . t V"t r1 :A,_„lti.,'?I'., Mwr::1. t P! i.,i. .. 7, r d,:J a�i�p �, �ryy ,, nr ,. \ ° '. x.,w.:... .�A" : 1 ,0 � ��' `fa a '„�.;Fm«y.'>AWmr+r� , FF.r".. p4 ,; 4 i61 �,.,,. 4 1" } 7N .' 1°6 w1•iT P''�' ..1d1C. iPy F"R fnB RM tpr ',,_ t u a ! ", , �tVIrM ,.A fit.:,aJ.� °''N1rI, ff AV n f Y ' �} .,�"I 1 �G 1 - y I� I f 11 t , I', b m I s1+un1'1 o "f 8'x P J!b r,.: k f, f...f'.S p 4, ;i . 4, � �. T, ,nq:: ? 4»,. +' '�" >,. 7 , .,a1ABs �.'r6 v�.�^"�. ....,w... :,.1. .,..,Alt„.„.w.:„_. ,,..,,...... , - w.r 4&11a,.., f ,(- I 'r. d .rr �',• r„ .;..: ", !°'.:, ♦ ;d'� 7:. rx a t,,, 1•r^". •,,.,,.:..�•, "..�...+.... ...,�,. ,.. o.,,.,awxK ,: , I. <. <,y;•:,. ••..d• n....,.^.:, _...A, .'."`nr- -"+....+,dr+.,�►wn»+I,4*.,J,.,,...y,r .tia , .,At• 'I 1 F�' a 7, ';r; :,1 .�, J, s ;,. (� yy�. ti ...,,:,„wkn, �. I e:igj. .a., I 4, ., "� + �,'f ,.;` :. 4,— +' m y. I w f y ..,�'1 .I •, a,,µ64 l y r�l:. rJ,t,. ,•,. ."' •',•'': �.. r�r �M � , #., Ii ,. !. 1 .I A g I k r."a' r..,:. 1. ��(( ,: ': • " q, s WyS�I,. .. W..�i.M'-,.L,,}YA•AI Fa4 J3'xi M..,.• 1 yy ,�y�� • qq 1,...,'`xn L.r�.. .�,. ,,. , ..... "`„ . 7 ..._M,....,,w� `�.... .. e. llll' �'y'.� l="F,o•" e , OL J r. ,,.. { r ' a,. r, 7 : . ,., .., P�11', .."" AI4r .;i,�nr ♦,Fw�' . ., I 7 r g� ' „ III �I I-.,:�f A P �n r,. , ^a,�,„d 1 a it r "' s. ,.:,n. �[(Ye 'ii 4 r -'b! tt:.,t 7, Ir. TIik 4, ,1�,', 't w�twrd w-•.+fw.,»..w.. xN,*,: .. ...,A,�:. r.Ji,t. , r' i . ,.�. • k 1 4Y 4 ,, 1Y.a ;4 f .. z)7r;f Prl. n,... , t M; . ',. py. k V /'+' ' ,., �� LI.. :.�i„ 'H: ,a....,.°,,,.._.,1i.,,iw. -„ _: V; I._ IIJ"T lrsptrw ',H P'�1'fdN,o,'!. ,q,,y �a r+ { �,.: ,r; ., ,.. ..+ { r,ruil'aw '• F , - ,+ , .;b , i'•yw.;.,,, 1B0ir, w F"7 .'. fP.,"� 'wx c.• .,. X.y A 11�r: rll' ," " i i 3" n Y ':„ .", ,. AF. •^w,yro,,,, IJ"• q j` �3 , � 6 �t { "` 1. I. A. ,B a' :r .;J A ; N ,1 rod` 44 'w +' iR ,,1 ,,.. iaSy°'R : .r«Yaw�J,l11� r>.x "N{'. cil:Fk +'.':r z a _.. \y1 ... ` ..:1 I.r.-.. I. :'� .. • �"'...p� "n..M ^., � l at, t, ' iiji Ih! .��,t' t N ,��. 7 .R .'.�?�,;' ',.,t. .�• ) *�N +y,y'�'MY��{ " ir.,, � "; Jr .,'" •d y� r{p : 1.P t'Ptr#'+., .,,. 1 d:. .- , ., a k A a ,�m y ', ;,,: ,. Y't t. J:. r 'V' ''t A9�1 it". :� `B 14$': 11,;, '",W..� � ;.. ;.. u I : ,r',r- 1,,4tn:+IG��_/". �' N' i ,� t,:.i . ,�` it f;u r Y' . , ,� A - F .,.y ,,✓ r ..P°4 ,�4{Iw" ,1 aF .I$!q .A ��`°`'4'` ,.. ,uy ' ,. - y';a`f,:`'tFr:„�,.w,.•.t .. , .+° . I, Qf,04 I y,rIL Y11, w s r 'w:. ,. Ala 1 +�� t 4 I t t ) ' ,1. � I� r , 1, �'� 4 � 4 i:a.,,:� AI= ��;.."� oI q� � , ti v ,BYk�y }}k r Fr I ! Hn ,+e /r 1 ``• ± � •A..' i'. 1:iMy�yyv.{ 'B ,p>'^" ' .a� C -'�",r i�'�h,r',�y" W, Yx,. 1., U,' 1,,�{�.�y(�.,t ' , .'„)F rvh'5,+ + 5.C'' R. ,.f 11, IS d+l^MwF �.,HM'•r"nF4.1"'.Y :. 5 1 , i 'C .. i,' a.p„+4FUFrN*i +. ` 4w tl �' '`'fit 3.. At d, I I. a ) :. 'I'� cf1 ,. `I t .F..,... � �" .,,•'°,AID .} �,' „.a r � ',, t 6 '�:.,, `" x" «r d;:: r s nxn-.r aniw+ i» �+w' W, ,r •.. '.w,,.... r �j ,(+y i +" 1 it 'j ^� w a :! .w+ ,. ` ,& _r d - r. bt17.M, i., „ ,: " 'td" Y'Y 1, w , w >; .nl .7wS9Me"ky^l. w^Wit,+*!" ,,n . .J,«.,,.,.: 8 �,, i ,_. �0) , rj"'ni' _ * B:,, Nk',14 'U g FAA.4'`N1fi+i�Trc., ,..,. / ^ , f i'+ t F M 9 a w^ w Irt wwa Hvo:4ndrN uwM':,n„I„ .a ..x:,.w, p I f �111 d" }Q X'as> (. ,, , ; ;,i i. �' x .., 1. (/ , i , fu I � ' 't' ,,- ,1. ',1 $41, ; ', Ma' „dmtl•,,m..,+,�br,+„P!t 11,w;,K,-•Apia.., J.`"`°M^. tI„ 1,:^• , 1 ,.,.,,.,. _.'M: ,_.Iw. ,k t ',,� i '+s J t h,:;; ,r�•, ,,a••: fi 'T" 1, p }4: ,74a; '� ` '. 1aWr.id, ::J, �•,' '` a , vN,4:':,«a, ,, ,.10 , v rr r aJ I y M .,.. r .. - ",�� .n n,i, �,. ,. F fey ; . �f .0 tima w.. , 4 ',.y - "..,. ..+' ,. ,w ,*.,: ' '1� � °: . '..r, hp,i"" ;, 1, F k ,�' AM it t7 �,.� ti- �. ^., f , I. � 1� •r �+� y�` ee1�9,K,w w r�iA.wilt., Ja .. u, a J ,. •,. 11 �'':: .. i !' w . ,,I <'. R'l ,I'i .,.,. . � .P .. 7 'n d �'{ t:' r z 1rt. r y, . r 1 '.', " ! tl l 1, : I , ,Ir a &a w.. p �' nTMn d �`i k f r. r.M g`y, nw, y a f w.,m,.,,.. ..._,•. ,d.. ,.,;.,1 y >44 y1'�'1. �a>1,L..'..., )p N - 1'�. , sl i«�'j y,,.'•.1^ �,, r ',.. Q"' Y'I.��`:'k. ':"� ... ...,... ",.. , ( f r " ,'; fi,,.� 6 ±, f t 1 r. y i ,G "t L. jf ,h I+,, ���� I Z - a � n.. ` p. , : ..;»,,. r,.,q, 'r , ,,,. ,.Y,W W:ulet 1 �� F .w.. 1' 1 i ,. , J4q, % t5. ,. : I= n" 1.. 1 , i' ., .Y ,I 1 �..' .,.:...,_ .. r , .. .. n,+ . . m.,fry nP ,S}ta I,"• M •r- h "., ,; +' Ky. 11 1 A + , ,.:. d 3 +,�. , I I 4f t. ` V 1�1} IIUS ,11I y":. ,. „o- I* �rl; j B ,, + w, ":d„ - 3�1 F}=r. M f r.)I T _ !M1 I r « !a ^ J ', ii:,,', 1�'p 'F ,� 1 1� r "'.4 t, f i } T�& 4 r a ; . � ', .Jn '4��r1, } p w I d a idA 1�0 •, ti 0�1 ,': !fW �1 'I m,ry q` r td "•4 " %"; rr,�y Yu„+ 'Y" '�aipA ns "" ,a::n r�� t..Ba . ilk rtl ,�.c-'K � -- .... - k I „ e " y '4,Y ! j��{" II d't i ,ri,w rI r 1 '; •C ) , :;'''. �,`..1:, ' ; a f' . ` ,+ 1 I `Iy� k '';Lv Y,9,,Si ,, : : j;, i w I'. 1 Y �,„'.,, ' 'S r Y'.wl P 1W., ,t. � \v „. �� - :�:.a i I w' {w 4 �I S 1, 1 * w yagep� e w' �1t ltl11, �'�+y`I, f 4, �':f i y5. ,;a. rr' I 't� J: ,a'"» �f T �'., r i if a '�1' J4;&7£1"r' I q�' :r. ) ;a', 'cam I p ,a I i I :. 1..1 "N ' :n,'+- r dr' J ''a l a1,.1., S 111 n:' ,y i 1�,y .P�, J , , i':. ,t { d y p �; + pr,. .rro. a'.J I� 4 ,.,(�1:. t„ AI �!i. 13, ( f� LF �' � � ,. .e"'�A a,a; I�� ,1� , '!, �!' s, �w:.1 1 1 'i k 9+'r ,� t'". y �' :I , "..._ , ..,, .... , +' ty,j (. Jn^k. ,tw �.B - ",r• N4 A'I t 6,... B - Y4JJ 5, f 1 i ` ,:Y.F d .-:. _ .. ".". 'R {' y�A,, I '�,�41a rr' I rt• ';.. s' S PJ '`� "" J,L , It 71� C Xp` .,. .. :Y 1 . ,. a. r � r 1, `I,t xI p a t �� :�, I , 4 ,wr.'-,,,1 w r , i i�a as e vI j 7,a� ,� .'1 r,'f. 4 N a, F "t , ,a +`°'y,, « "os 1 " ,1 \� , r� _:, 11 ty r I 01 r .. .. :• , ' ,. J a, : I..1 1 .i:�.a .., :,..".."MwM ...:. .wA I wig t it 1 1 1 \�� r A W 1 i. 1 .I y' �1r ,, 'y I ,, J�1! I :I\. r 7 rJ•... l6 Y'"_}' ,i �, , ...iu 1 �l fa P1G Mt s" '` 1: 4 �r",.., I .n': wI, " r , f yit a ,+r J,, - i r d w 1 1 ..I I y'r, = I , 17. « �yyi�pp k ! � � in \ E fi II'. i ..a..,......, ,.a:,».IL'4-,.: �. I %11 � '- ,!1 ,I .,,+ �•� Si�Y ,l A,}, l:y, .`Kt :::_'`(' ,.,., ..A. ..n ,NJ 3 <Y k.t�'1, 'Slw"Lj" ,:1�. _ ,Lt•. 1 �..a.A r 4 <, '4 ., .t; Y s , pp �e - � nr '1. , .. ltl :'.' I 1 t., d « '�M; t V # ,: I*'A I, n'° \t,. Nr la . f•7.»h A,1.�q n I . F q�� } . .1,?¢ ,.ti:. ,, ,+4 S. , A ,i ,I '.1t +ai r14'' ! .;� a :,P, s,,}y��" ', "ai « ,IIP 1,, ., +t sa 'a,trM - ds '', '.I:'. '�`r..� •, � n� )� `' w'hb l i , u ' i fJ 0. I,. d�•I 7t, V , r(,r T� :,,,: ' t t:,- 4i Y 'r'nr*Bn �i 1 ,.: i',... 1 // .Y ii {.., .'� t J� r °i 1 y i , "p`3 a y �'� dnd,1.�Y1, 4 e` :: '��I :t. .,rPl 'l,:. }, <ky d "t i b dF ei , ,,9tnY,,yF" ,t;s ))F ,.,x* [tp '�y„ J, '% - i' ,p.1:. 1 1 ll.:r °+. 914 t.':Wr ' }' ,• 7". ' i q.e J;`SiRI !� ;. �!`� tr" •.l 4' t k•Y `!'u '�n, fFj 1 41 ,�,.,! ,C i..�" _�'� {v y �P ,:. LF.. �M' aiR 9' r ,0 - I , r,. 1 . 4 m d'If' i _ - -J.. !:1:, ,,,,.1, £� " j r ', xu M>'R, '::..,r u° q +.,,-r r� ,��' 'e 1 �� '9 1 I i',w, �, +-t^` 4_ ��II : :.,... y , ., k ray a I 14" ,,.,�,,A # 's 'A °"' �!B��. �' ,� 4„, raw .1 .;*,r •.,., venri«x .e,n,:,,,.,,n ,ra:;,.:a r- a•, B,m".+' ,:'�' �. '# ,Ij, "h ..J " c ':n&k' ',NI)MBIEai,c'Wr,aril@4J'uWiWWY6'1} P..tw,bAw"M$N a'io,i a,M,.*.,.k.m„ ,;1 lie ,k . ,d y^'r i, , ,o.i'liulealWMalwtlFB�w YAr'0.MWu,.a.t�.ma,.•r,xaJuw,,:�...,: ,r ,.«..,,,:,, r.ry /•: k,. - 'r`' rK . :.. 1'y V , 5 a 1 1 � , s.4 n.',:1+, +,. "'fit,' A�a'.' , '�',. �?'' a r r{Y h +" A ''wq t. d J °, , ; 11 , I f� , , ;, w fit, ,x roR�w `..� "1 r+ a.+ d1,:'jj,:: \ .wY w :. I ,; Mfk. ;,,.:3 'XIF Ma'W7•ICP.: 4.aa.AA=M «Yn........,1Ld:_,.,,,.,y,.J 1,"k. I., 1 ) .. w ,j! •, ,n,�' rs. `b;;l gg ' t}. ,, e ;-:... ..:, ., _ i ,�,1. 1..'. r..., ,:,1 r! .,, w ::h•,. .. ! ,. y.,.,"i. '."..,� a„'' ',9 't r, t;.. Y ! n4 `1 e'1 p! ,b t , 1 F •,.,...�.1 t. - 'r `y':. ,t r,, - , :l ;3 k:," + '�, M=wN. 7° ,,I AI tls,iy ,71 ,,: y ,.• " +. p ».. , �:+J1r 1.M'r4 r. A ,a, i +�!`,� 't ..0,y,n'�y:, a, .1 ,.{. `� ,t" 4 a F r i xJ % , y ,,, U 'n ',11n F I"4ff1e ..I i; I 1 d 1 e„-!. ,iWw,F .\... !kY 1 -.,,. ,..,,[., , , L, ^i., " yl P f 't +.,a' swn;Y� r+..a�.'; .1. t .� . IY , :.. ,, , 1W .11�, >t Y %L':t,P'.,, ,i Mh. 1 + I �q Re )'' ,Aa;''.r a .,, y.,,il.!`t,'.: 1'. P,.. ,..'tell L. F. t P f 1. i,. 'Ip, Y. A 1,' :.hP.I..J�,,,B kk3 nitvwtR^ai Ia y J , r� 1 ,i I 4. - ti. n,, I . f1', a..A.. {� r.,n,i' � j � '.n kc,ro,.n'1 d+aw^t •, a: ,I i ..v � r,T � +3 a ,i r � q. r, `\ ! yi ,: f A:.W+c'r±.w.+y `t 1 A:. ,;fa.14,..t` .^ti:t. .,` tr » � ': 1. Y _ `',"1 trl� " y .II'., .:. I !}I 1� ik An, :I,'d \. Y 1 Y 4 G,I'�� i r '" I�. + S 4_ 4f ••t.t'1 'i,. j 4Y 'F".. 'q> ,r.�,P. +.f,:h' rIY :r 1� 1 , i °! `7 •d 1 .:i'.. +' s . 1 ran .14;P,1 I«. , .. ,f 1F r ,N n•..t y;>t,r, «J A J ..•�..{ .:.JJw.,, t" a e� 4@, 1 Y. v , .I 4:.a ,W :IT. r.\.1'rt:.rt�•:F.1,.• .H„rr.. Y •I ;=1• ,. +Y '"� � � ..:, 1 P .Fallax,}cs f ,I;x , •,.. :. .: ,. r 1, ,.. '. ���vd�° , �',A}'�s �i'11 ra:}� �`I �)\ .Jrt w„- J ", I I i , d � x�¢,«. iph akNh m w ,.+ s Fh,.1. T.,.stt,Y h;.41FW,. d. x� {,, Y' •. ar• ,;. , Rv II'uV Ir. r n..t 1:,_' , ` 'Y' : 'Yi S .:t.' y a K ,a. , J a r �? ' r ,_ .,.i...d t„, a,•L:, i/d, { .I . r,1F r5 aAlfi e r 11" y i' , ,i6�'aM.4 *PfI'1�, �'�� 7^.: id Ivw'1t (4}n;l '� b'M7;,^: !f F, 1 '. \-t S"„ _. A; t +y,:, w.," r t +: `, e.r .' - °, , .x k t(!,IDS A } i :v kw.l, a:, ;, �. �: Y +I • "': ,:. Yu L•N..'A.L ,'IJ Al 1'P"..:' ,.,�� ,Yf R: I,.::IL.,. 3 '1, Z � id y ',. ,i ` It�� p 1,`it y1 : ., "•;„ '. i.., i ' t y„A;. "„'. „ .,..' w P I•= t. 'f:' r:„•, Ir•. '%+i_,f"1, 1:..".I « ,..",_ +.AEI, -I ,.1. '1 a,y I,y t. Hm.E#F,.;''rt7 ,.�, °' \ { i ,:.. w, 1 -,-IAA A N,4"ik r , .• �.: >.A. u,y, r.c+.tF 'a.,« -^rt,.a, r.:t1,N,»s.'! Y .:r , ,; :4 ,I„ ..�; v1 ,, :Yr p' ..:.: t,,,,Ae., , ti '4v I > Mt 4:.w I, , , �, if i f"'"' rn i1 T,�„�," ,8 r I , 1 i ..,i - .,,•pa:.'-: _C•,a: 1 ..,•AIF_L. , "vfW t. wFro '..1? �,,t - ;9 t �'a� ,, - ..,: . ' 4 L w.S. r"YM J. ;r.. .,r., a.pL. , , .. nq,I .., pit)u r+ 'J P ,, ,�:, 'teI fi I + G '' k` f :..:. L .:. 4 n :., ^+;a ,w a; L, ItI M...n.lftt ,r ?`� aI to A, k w... „ .I 1 Y r��yy,` �Fnfya, '. ... ...! .,.. P--,r.. tl ,I.„ �, - I . ,\ . 1 ' ..YIF7{. wFM ;j`(M++•�ilf ,',i' , ,:" i. , . „1� �yyl�r'JLy✓,..: It { w,. ` '�6j j r "" 1 i ! r C n .nrw1 )•,. 4 �. � � 0, �. ;.� y � „ , . `v. 4 NM C. .. flPkslU , 'rn K� a; y 11 +ice+ , ,1 y0 '' w ^*M.4'J Ap,ag,a.k:ut'w.:''W .M:t ��. ,r Wi x\ 1 " iai a r1,.F... :.r.,.F. _ Ir:='., ` .�`v, F a y�e i:,.:. JJF'J,'" t,aiin YllY"tFr, ha,.z / c1 a „r .w ,..,. I . , , .. .! Li' ) r„ Y A 4. '.' y,; I 1I' - I. '4.¢ 7 d r' , n. 1 ii � t ,.,a,,,„. » .t n.. h; i 1 i(„a, a ,a dB , a l k , • . .... . , .,..,'.- ,.1 h " <.. �jj y 1 ,, 154i'Y " t ',fi t Ell, i :..51....1a.�'w(I ,,.: , r 1 ati , ,. k1, .;,„ S 41 4 +�.3t ..yµt �"' I 4� 1; I1 +. •I@;' ;A. Fp r,.�, n ^ , I 4 n. ,'7 , eY§_' , `, 1 *I _ 1.:..p, Ia,9 `41 11' ,. ,,�`p p �! ,�,1 , W„+Ft" 1 rnr p;ewrr L.. 1 .I 1 , .,'. It a 'q.:F,0S?Iz°w"Y ',,7„ •�' e a;4(';kil. hrP l'. II ,�',..{fl, �„ r ,r t.: i t7f1F M w I r,. ;1. willWIM IY�Y�'1r1MNMMYJiIo"IIIIIdIl1d*� l,;.*,L"Q.iP'!wBrp-,'.. . .:.....:........ I M A ,niy{ « n , .5. .I F " ':J'. z )•:ilnNawwt}rYAaq,#f', IaIWFV+kYnW'7/a,ID.,N :,-. 1 ,. , A � Y1 Oft �0.5 ��'� 11� 1 )1 ,� J ((� 1 `L.1/ • 1 o baz sd ti �h6L vl .. 0 I A)-1 <7 --- --.------ - _._-- a end� • r 7tc . � ,_ __ ofr .-=:• yH���v=*-,. �-`—�;��-. � _ ... �_ ... _.:.�_ � _ _ -� ,, 1 Q JAI e-U � ! : � , ,,•a,�,�r�r L�'T:1bz i ` ' �._,. .__ +.. ..�-,�. _-�.-�•. .�.._..:_ _ -._ �:_,.,_ _ � -- _�. _ ___ ..._._r�..�. __ ��� ems_ - -"�'' _ ' -• '_ � ( ! _ '14 �i 44 LNJ : ! � r_ ��{ � c. _ 1 ! --- f tt }.� SAS • _ _ , 5���I t �1'°s 41 title N ; ; �` GEORGE C. HAGHT ASSOCIATES I L1_ .A ARCHITECT:.)Li Y ADZ :Main it ryarshfioid ma, !scale drawn hocked IRECTION TO JOB: ! /I REF. NO.: D f. t/ • ,� / tom -/ ., �, y ram" Y- __ 1. POOL SHAPE: �v L j� -- . I � � : } 2. SIZE: _�2�_ X X DEPTHS: _TO: 3. TILE: 6x6: MO IC: 1�1 tilt r r . , 4. DECKING: YARrIt i' 4 5. CAPACITY: GALLONS:_ c!I ` f1 i .., w / �IN►M OU-T ! I 6. FILTER TYPE: y E SQ. FT.: I Q '.9 Al v 7 `� __e ip P • a 7. RAILS: SWIM OUT:�_ GRAB: 1 <. Jc ! �►' •O BOX 33t3 ttdAS;-f. EE ir+1A. 0�64y CAPE COD �Y � OSEi 777$ NASHUA N.H. 8. UNDERWATER LIGH : r VOLTS (t WATTS: '- K DfS tG tom' t63) 5W7778 PL A t+.�TE2 9 DESIGNER BEAM: `0,t„- w' r i r cA lwr 10. LIGHT: c s C ! TYPE: x' Xl�i HV,�j y 11 SKIMMER: 2 ' 12. INLET FITTINGS: k. f 13. MAIN DRAIN: E 14. NELSON DEEP HEAT: F! > NO. OF JETS: 4-1 L , �q f 4��. • • , ' la's ` _ � ` l Q 15. MARCITE: d r� Varo--> �1./� t flt, � + E�J'CA rCt ✓A 16. AQUA SWEEPS: (AUj� CLEANER) A ti I IC��� ?tL ; . t�J' /�( 17. CHLORINATOR: e►�+kJ'j 6121esl G `r° ..XT fry A VQ�vj 1�g "T1 LF � ` _ - Y � Ii�r�tti( ; � l i� a't _ `! 18. TIMER: rY C3(I'')�r Y'� 19. ELECTRIC Uy w1itw- , 20 TEST KIT: 21 BRUSH & POLE: ( pQa4En ^x-p 22. UNDERWATER VAC. a J Cr 7 I f{ �t 23 HOSE FOR VAC _ I� F� 44 _ i,.► t � "'- 24 SPA DESCRIPTION: _ QtJT a ,y�tlU 25. FENCE: t( 04WrlLtve-v, D- f�k 7 �pwr� jt. ? K 26. DIVING ROCK: v 27. WATER FALLS: _ _v Ci 0 UT �311 yr _ q&-K .. Pd 28. LANDSCAPING _ _. r f (J I KEY S•-�,�N er ' n� 29. ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS: ` 14�i;,t' "r t�, �,•`� � _ Lt Cla T f l 30. _. 31 b 32. De N x�> , f r{ , 1 Po tb i (�, ,.,`,, y' If tt'1�'►tn+ r ` {_rA^' AdT L 33 )t E r i L t - t. °/ � �1 \+,' \/ �r r 34 4 t" E Gr s J t.r _. FUG c .y, ,i ✓ Y 35. ;4, g 36 {l - `4 °` ,��+ v {j: _ Y 37. �-7 L 0i `J V tT T $R 'J 38 °+ / Z 1V T oy;./}M1 .i F 12 39. Of-A,0 7 14 X' Sire 40. ` ( ,fir / J ow bt-Ac to 41. -_i�w 0_It' �{?Y� f t IJ� c e LA;TE7 L wr13 '+P P ..�1t �'i} py1 1 �/C {tF- � { tl 1(_ r j - ,� 4 2. t ~�''? 43. -r4* 04 s ` 44. -- --- - - 45. WAIFt N r 1 4 Src cT •. _- *P.O. 13ox 338 MASHPEc, CIA. �'.)rokq ,� __ .- - Y j 2T�-ou +{� ;: ---- CAPE C �rt/1c�+Tt i - -- - -- �� 4D NASHUA N.H. �� _ �- -.- 1s f50 ) 477 7�78 (6{)3) 595 7778 OWNER / TO DETERMINE _ ': ,, � ,.,• '•.� '4 e� APPROXIMATE ELEVATION OF POOL ON DAY OF EXCAVATION POOL AREA TO BE FENCED ♦ ! \ + ` BY OWNER PER COUNTY OR CITY ► _. _ (► flhi�1 ORDINANCE. GATES TO 8E SELF -__-- '' '� +. ,+ •1, \ \ l`, ( ..r , � ,, j� t�j CLOSING AND SELF LATCHING i r DO NOT TURN ON POOL LIGHT WHEN POOL IS EMPTY. rc *vrna 4, r-,�r.a@ GE-_t�E-2A ��t S Pow t_opM+4 �AVonn 0.TK �X2 -v_TeefitD 1_ YO• 1. PIP1..{6 t6 S,GwN SGNtM0.:IC Al:`( nuG ' .. ., � _ ,_.,ram,- - __^.-, SRMc.�. SCIMntQ Rw.T,.nt.,u L,vEa 1--'---"'L Ptt'U5T , ti -.1 .__ /�-coP,U4 OhAly !St r ,r..„ .�. 0 F' C .,a EG.r•` , ��/ 1 c r YY o1D Ir K + y :' �` at or -(--0 `t . �11 _ � �; THE EXECUTIVE -- (^ R,T-,v- ►� ;"^ cj ®nxS oR I r*ti2n tp nTt ¢r or g,L,.f � \ + lVf,E t0/t B E R POOL. CONSULTANT 33 YRS EXPERIENCE ` --t -'•�- ^ >' ^R.S s...a_t, LnP ^. MW. Bn2 e,.. �y�r � i! ', y \ .I , POOL ORIENTAL POLYNESIAN POOLS, WATER FALLS, o. , Ganuv�R "'• �� LTE 1Z �rAC i A �t= + yti � + ARCHITECTURAL LANDSCAPING, ROCK DESIGN, 4i c�` oftn,u.LG solL WIT~ LcaS T�>J 1 + WOOD BRIDGES. CUSTOM SPAS nww0 1 GRO.-K.,o u,nT*re Snn�:. txlaT wcrNlw, rk- T i t,Y I 1 Dlvl.x, f3onRD 1 y LInn IT`> OF T Mt= ExC0.v AT,01.i t ST 9�T ; `'. `•t �' I` iL�f F O R ( c.T,o+.inL) i [.ouC.lGT <n! �. ♦G a .- __ , �,,,+ i ,� + �,.. t •-1t4,rs y0.1 r Ro'�Tj6t1 4 NO SURLMh4Gt bum AOD.'T ..�•ry�" ._. \\\ 1 i-�ti MhK.H.G n_ nRpv,,,.p SHALL �%l1ST WITHIU T4.O Of' TNT SNhLLO,. rf A..,r.a✓'•" .. .r.....w?�""" , '✓'""• -` 1 \ \ t+ i - T* aj1 !']u4Y Fw111 nr:. 12' c G. oR G'-o• r-id.,. r«(� DCty Cvc ..,,r.-- + �+ Lo L THr. ccri +usT Ac ..�Pr t v�-eT,U�_ S -x1 OLrR,Uv � � •., a / ,""\ cr►r, zTtcL N I O N A L t ;o►s*►i 1 i a,-,HELD,., ttt+e2,uG wE0.TNtR t. 1 ti 'y i y 1 '+ Sr & POOL NAME I<E s tcs'a) �4 QIz o c. G *JALrs To ec c.�noon ,�ptxvlo�s .you- TITUTE P!F1h1 YtiPtcl� .: tD� �' eta �.c(>s o) iwr aov� n.uv rarrn rnt py k r - PRCt ADDRESS Ft,2p.TNL � PVvnnTCnLLY Consulting & Designing ° or. F CCxjrE-vT ,.icrl � ried In the Tradition, �a„ti,f ansh-r't3, '"Ix , asapingA _ oe a . 0 ipW,RT To FWR. liarrg RNelson CITY_ TLf Achitectural : J AC_ --'- _ PHONE --=y II Rnnw oU OY,v G{tS F+�F+�Q�-Y. Design S3(2 �♦��''�I (`�{ C9 9 V,,t4 � Y 8\ OW\t42S �+O St j�7 fesign boar. 1[tb. Z �� { '.. WA.y T .1` ♦ � _. ....� LOT .._- -�' ._ BLK. ._� �`-"�Q.�tf�B. e 3.,- ° � LEA 'i I ZairGfG'> Ev6 ou oC M1= i L'aVVIV Nt CG VfQ lNALI y+021 CRMQ CI,Zy>1.ipelk.P.,, nDTKcuT iTrW cC.JR.G� A'a RL`--Q 4'11C,�G. �.. -'_ -- ---._---- 111.IG FILL :.�.� � ��aS ,._o.• Q., .,.,.T, A_.. �l�sigtter & ,< ut(aer ._-�. --+ --- --- Building Since 1958 ' CUSTOMER'S SIGNATURE No Sc^LC �{I.THe RtX.P t� c,.w.lk� OF T_y5lHnitGKJ4 �.,._ WATERFALLS, BRIDGES, WOODWORK, STOLE , _-- TYICA� St=C'T'ip►� �rA �tx Cn+ •cY .rTHI. z4 tcaar. fitUo " r`''f DWN. BY DATE g CHK Y . v� . . Y f p V C �RA Ci�M UP�at1 � .� �L/ --- tah lz SINK 13 f i d � t i g f r i SCALE: t 4 1 r APPROVED BY DRAWN BY p •` c DATE: IZ4 QZ t7 ti!• A K..L w F R DRAWING NUMBER I - i .,,..,.:., e. . ... ...............i ..,..._.,.,..,..,. EXISTINIG POICA., AND DECK � c j ......_._._..d__..__,_._.._..........,..._....^. _.,...,..,.�.._...._............,., ............_r ,T.«.....,.a._..... ..,........_... ...... _ .....- �..«........,... ...�,..,.>....,..w.................. ..b»...._.,..._...,..4�..., .. ,,.....,, .- � ........., e..,.tie _..».. ..,.-.�...-_.»�..«. SCALE: N U _ I APPROVED BY DRAWN BY PLAN VIEW : SCALE 10 u ►� . _ � � A � � IQ t� �1 J 27 ' Lt SAS'h � � a � (K` I �' sr'.0 Gi=r . �rh./ t->71I7• I � � , \ jt 4 ZI / t i i i t l