HomeMy WebLinkAbout0707 IYANNOUGH ROAD/RTE132 11107
,4yznn;s
-- --___ -- --�-- -- ----- -- _ Cape Ced Carom,
�� f,�
��
���
Town of Barnstable
oF1HE T Building Department Services
gyp` do Brian Florence, CBO
s
A fit
Building Commissioner BARNSTLE
BAMSrASLE,
Y MASS. "`was"r,M;i n 111m15u
200 Main Street, Hyannis, MA 02601 lfi]9.3014
1639. ��
pTfO MA'S A www.town.barnstable.ma.us �
Office: 508-862-4038` Fax: 508-790-6230
November 2, 2017
t�
c/o Mr. Matthew Eddy
Baxter-Nye Engineering& Surveying
78 North Street
Hyannis, MA 02601
RE: Site Plan Review#063-17 Marriot'Courtyard Addition—Post DRI Approval
707 Iyannough RoadT(Route`T32);Hyannis
Map 311, Parcel 010 ,
Proposal: Construction of an addition to the existing Marriot Courtyard Hotel. Proposed
addition includes 50 rooms with an increase in rooms of 49 as one existing room
will be lost due to the proposed addition connection. Site improvements for the
new addition will include new and reconfigured parking for 249 vehicles;
improvement of vehicular circulation around the site; closing of two of the existing
entrances onto Rte. 132; and creating one centered entrance onto Rte. 132; addition
of a median in Rte. 132; significant improvements to drainage and storm water
management; modification to existing utilities; additional lighting and landscaping.
Dear Matt:
The above proposal was found to be approvable by the Site Plan Review Committee at the formal
site plan review meeting held November 2, 2017, and is subject to the following:
• Approval is based upon, and must be-substantially constructed in accordance with plan
entitled"Hotel Renovation—Site Re-Development Plans—707 Route 132, Iyannough
Road, Hyannis, Mass" consisting of 19 Sheets dated February 15,'2017 with final revision
October 23, 2017; "Storm Water Management Report and Site Operation and Maintenance
Plan for Hyannis Marriott Courtyard" dated March 3, 2017 all prepared for Jiten Hotel
Management by Baxter Nye Engineering& Surveying,Hyannis. Also, elevation,and floor
plans entitled"Alterations &Additions- Courtyard by Marriot".4 Sheets, by Callahan
Construction Managers, Bridgewater, MA; and,landscape and lighting plans entitled,
"Courtyard by Marriott"2 Sheets, dated February 22, 2017, last revised September 19, .
2017 prepared by Hawk Design, Inc., Sagamore, MA.
• The granting of a conditional use special permit for a hotel use in the HB District will be
required from the Zoning Board of Appeals as well as special permit relief for.impervious
lot coverage and pre-existing noncgnforming conditions related to the parking
reconfiguration as required.
• Conditions of the CCC DRI Scoping-Decision CCC #LR17010 (attached), including but
not limited to the following:
o If new signage is proposed as apart of the project,the applicant shall submit a sign
plan consistent with MPS HPCC2.12 (Signage) for review and approval by
Commission staff.
o Prior to the issuance of a Building Permit the Applicant shall obtain a Preliminary
Certificate of Compliance from the Commission that evidences that all conditions
of the CCC DRI Decision have satisfied and that the project is in with
the decision.
o Prior to the issuance of the Certificate of Use and Occupancy by the Town for the
Project as modified,the Applicant shall obtain a Final Certificate of Compliance
from the Commission.
• Existing Health Department hotel permit will need to be updated to reflect the additional
rooms. Also, any changes to the pool or food service will require review and approval from
the Health Department. Contact: Health Dept. 508-862-4644'.
• Consultation and the approval of Hyannis FD for hydrant location; addition to existing fire
safety alarm system; FDCs; and approval of finalized landscape plan depicting same will
be required prior to the building permit stage.
• Consultation and approval of a fire response access plan and narrative identifying
challenges (if applicable) and a performance alternative to resolve while meeting all
building code, will need to be provided and approved by Hyannis FD prior to the building
permit stage. Contact: Deputy Dean Melanson, Hyannis FD 508-775-1300
• Existing hotel license will need to be modified to reflect additional rooms.
• The existing liquor license will need to be modified to include the addition to the hotel.
Contact: Licensing 508-362-4672.
• All HP spaces onsite are required to comply regarding location to entrances and.
accessibility.
• Consultation and approval of the DPW will be required for new sewer connection to'the '
vacuum system and must be designed to accommodate the additional wastewater flows.
Sewer connection will require a Mass DOT permit for work in Falmouth Road/Route 28
layout. Final approval of stonn water management will be required prior to the issuance of
a building permit. Contact: Amanda Ruggiero, Assistant Town Engineer, DPW 508-790-
6400.
• A road opening permit from DPW will be required for the work within Route 132 and
construction may not occur between Memorial Day and Labor Day.
• Implementation of the Storm water Operations and Maintenance Plan is"required. `
• Applicant must obtain all other applicable permits, licenses and approvals required.
Upon completion of all work, a registered engineer or land surveyor.shall submit a letter of
certification,made upon knowledge and belief in accordance with professional standards that all
work has been done in substantial compliance with the approved site plan(Zoning Section 240-
105 (G). This document shall be submitted prior to the issuance of the final certificate of _
occupancy.
A copy of the approved site plan will be retained on file:
Sincerely, r
Ellen M. Swiniarski
Site Plan Review Coordinator: ,
CC: (BiiwFlorence, Building Commissioner,-SPR Chairman
Elizabeth Jenkins,Director Planning&Development
Amanda Ruggiero,,Assistant Town'Engineef-DPW
Deputy Chief Dean Melanson Hyannis FU
Tom McKean;Director.Health Department
Licensing Authority
Zoning Board of Appeals
Attachment: CCC DRI Scoping Decision#LR17010
3225 MAIN STREET • . P.O. BOX 226
BARNSTABLE, MASSACHUSETTS 02630
CAPE COD
(508) 362-3828 • Fax (508) 362=3136 • www.capecodcommission.org . COMMISSION
DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL IMPACT SCOPINGDECISION
DATE: OCTOBER 12, 2017
TO: ATTY. ELIZA COX, NUTTER MCCLENNEN AND FISH `
1471 IYANNOUGH ROAD, PO BOX.1630, HYANNIS, MA 02601
PROJECT APPLICANT/ JULIA HOTEL LLC C/O 3ITEN HOTEL MANAGEMENT INC
PROPERTY OWNER: 495 WESTGATE DRIVE, BROCKTON, MA 02301
PROJECT: HYANNIS COURTYARD MARRIOTT EXPANSION (CCC#LR17010)
PROJECT SITE/LOCATION: 707 IYANNOUGH ROAD, HYANNIS, MA
TITLE INFORMATION: BOOK 13428 PAGE 150
PLAN BOOK 561 PAGE 69 (PARCEL A)
ASSESSOR'S ID: MAP 311 PARCEL 010
SUMMARY
The Cape Cod Commission(Commission)hereby determines that the Project,involving `.
construction of a proposed 31,470-square-foot(SF) expansion of the existing hotel located at
707 Iyannough Road,Hyannis,Massachusetts(Project),does not involve substantial deviation
from the minimum performance standards of the Regional Policy Plan.(RPP)and does not have
significant impact upon the purposes and values identified by Section One of the Cape Cod
Commission Act(Act),as conditioned herein,and that Julia Hotel, LLC(Applicant)may
proceed with local permitting without further DRI review,subject to the conditions herein.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The Applicant is proposing an approximately 31,470-SF,two-story addition to the existing hotel.
The addition is proposed in the northeast corner of the 6.45-acre Project Site.The addition will
accommodate 5o new hotel guest rooms,though overall the Project will result in a net increase
Of 49 guest rooms as one existing room will be eliminated to connect the proposed addition to
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 1 of 14
the existing building.The proposal also involves the reconfiguration of the access/egress on the
project site's Iyannough Road frontage; changes to the front parldng area; construction of new
rows of paridng to the rear(south) of the Project Site;and new landscaping,stormwater
improvements,new pedestrian amenities,and other site improvements. (Project)
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The Applicant filed a DRI Scoping application with the Commission on May 19,2017.The
Applicant submitted additional materials in June,July,August and September of 2017.The DRI
Scoping application was deemed_complete on September 8,2017.
At its public meeting on September 28,2017,the Committee on Planning and Regulation(CPR)
reviewed a draft DRI Scoping decision,in which the Executive Director of the Commission
recommended that no further DRI review be required for the Project.The CPR recommended
the draft decision to the full Commission for its consideration and a determination that no
further DRI review is required for the Project.At its meeting on October 12,2017,the full
Commission held a hearing on the Project, and voted to adopt the draft DRI Scoping decision
and find that the Project does not involve substantial deviation from the minimum performance
standards of the RPP,does not have significant impact upon the purposes and values identified
by Section One of the Act,and that the Applicant may proceed with local permitting for the
Project without further DRI review.
JURISDICTION
The Project qualifies as a Development of Regional Impact(DRI)pursuant to Section 3(e)of the
Commission's Enabling Regulations(revised November 2014)as 'New construction of any
building or buildings...with a Gross Floor Area greater than zo,000 square feet."
In accordance with Section 5(a)of the Enabling Regulations, "f f]or any Project that is a
DRL .the proponent may apply to the Commission to limit the scope of the.DRI review."
Pursuant to Section 5(e)(v)of the Enabling Regulations,upon submission and after review of
such application, "In the event of a finding that no DRI review is required,the Executive
Director shall make the recommendation to the full Cape Cod Commission which shall render a
final decision whether to allow a development to proceed without further DRI review..."
FINDINGS
GENERAL FINDINGS
The Commission hereby finds as follows:
GF1.The Applicant submitted an application to scope DRI review on May 19,2017;the Scoping
application was deemed complete on September 8,2017.
GF2.The DRI Scoping application for the Project was reviewed subject to the 2009 Regional
Policy Plan,as amended in August 2012(RPP).
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 2 of 14
y.
GF3.The Project constitutes redevelopment,and the Executive Director considered the Limited
DRI Scoping Checklist for Redevelopment/Change of Use(Scoping Checklist)in its review and
deliberations on the DRI Scoping application.
GF4.The Applicant is proposing an approximately 31,470-SF,two-story addition to the existing
hotel.The addition is proposed in the northeast corner of the 6.45-acre Project Site.The
addition will accommodate 50 new hotel guest rooms,though overall the Project will result in a
net increase of 49 guest rooms as one existing room will be eliminated to connect the proposed
addition to the existing building.The proposal also involves the reconfiguration of the
access/egress on the project site's Iyannough Road frontage;changes to the front parking area;
construction of new rows of parking to the rear(south)of the project site;and new landscaping,
stormwater improvements,new pedestrian amenities,and other site improvements. (Project)
GF5.The Project is proposed to be implemented and constructed in accordance with the
following plan sets and other information and documents referenced herein:
Hotel Renovation Site Re-Development Plans,7o7lyannough Road,Hyannis,
Massachusetts,prepared by Baxter Nye Engineering&Surveying,dated 2/15/2017,
revised 7/27/2017'
Sheet Co.o: Cover Sheet
Sheet C1.o:Legend and General Notes
Sheet C2.0:Existing Conditions Plan
Sheet C2.1:Existing Conditions Plan
Sheet C3.0:Master Layout Plan
Sheet C3.1:Layout and Dimensions Plan '
Sheet C3.2:Layout and Dimensions Plan
Sheet C3.3:Sight Distance Plan .
Sheet C4.o:Master Grading and Drainage Plan
Sheet C4.1: Grading and Drainage Plan
Sheet C4.2: Grading and Drainage Plan
Sheet C4.3:Stormwater Management Facilities Enlargement Plan
Sheet C4.4:Stormwater Details Plan
Sheet C5.0: Utility Plan
Sheet C6.o:Detail Sheet
Sheet C6.1:Detail Sheet
Sheet C6.2:Detail Sheet
Sheet C6.3: Cultec Details
Courtyard by Marriott,7071yannough Road,Hyannis,Massachusetts,prepared by
Hawk Design Inc.,dated 2/22/20171 revised 9/1-9/2017
Sheet Li:Planting Plan
Sheet L2:Lighting Plan
Sheet Di:Planting Details
Sheet D2:Planting Notes
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 3 of 14
Alterations&Additions,Courtyard by Marriott,707lyannough Rd,Hyannis,MA,
prepared by HDS Architecture,dated 3/3/2017
Sheet Ai.o:Floor Plans
Sheet Ala:Roof Plans,revised 6/15/2017 ,
SheetA2.o:Elevations
Sheet A2.1:Elevations,revised 6/15/2017
Transportation ImpactAssessment,Development of Regional Impact,Hyannis
Marriott Courtyard Hotel Expansion,7o7lyannough Road,Hyannis,Massachusetts,
prepared by Vanasse&Associates Inc.,dated 4/28/2017(including Transportation
Demand Management Plan),as supplemented by email communication from Jeffrey
Dirk of Vanasse&Associates Inc.,dated 8/25/2017,updating the transportation
mitigation proposal,including the updated Master Layout Plan(Sheet C3.o)and Layout
and Dimension Plan(Sheet C3.2)referenced above
Proposed Addition to Courtyard by Marriot Hotel—Hyannis,Energy Narrative for
Cape Cod Commission Limited DRI Application;prepared by HDS Architecture,dated
3/3/2017(including LEED checklist)
Site Operation and Maintenance Plan for Hyannis Marriot Courtyard,707lyannough
Road,Hyannis,Massachusetts,prepared by Baxter Nye Engineering&Surveying,dated
3/3/2017
Stormwater Management Report for Hyannis Marriot Courtyard,707lyannough
Road,Hyannis,Massachusetts,prepared by Baxter Nye Engineering&Surveying,dated
3/3/2017
Landscape Maintenance Contract, Courtyard Marriott,Hyannis,draft,dated
9/19/2017
RPP FINDINGS
LAND USE
LUF1.The Project Site is located within a mapped Economic Center on the Commission- i
approved Land Use Vision Map(LUVM)for the Town of Barnstable,thus the Project meets
Minimum Performance Standard(MPS)LU1.1(Development Location).
LUF2.The Project involves multi-story development and is proposed within a previously
developed site.Thus,the Project does not involve substantial deviation from MPS LU1.2
(Compact Development).
LUF3.As the Project does not propose any capital facilities or infrastructure and is not on or
adjacent to agricultural lands,the standards under Goals LU2(Capital Facilities and
Infrastructure)and LU3(Rural Lands)do not apply.
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 4 of 14
y
LUF4.The Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant
impacts upon the Land Use Goals of the RPP and standards thereunder, and thus does not
require substantive.DRI review for the RPP issue area of Land Use,which is hereby scoped out
of DRI review. .
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
EDF1.The Project Site is located within a mapped Economic Center,thus the Project meets MPS
ED1.1(Location in Economic Centers).
EDF2.The Project is not located on agricultural,waterfront or recreational lands.Therefore,
MPS ED1.4(Resource-based Economic Areas)does not apply.
EDF3.The Project does not involve gaming.Therefore,MPS ED2.1(Gaming)does not apply.
EDF4.As the Project does not propose any capital facilities or infrastructure,.the standards
under Goal ED4(Infrastructure Capacity)do not apply to the Project.
EDF5.The Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant
impacts upon the Economic Development Goals of the RPP and standards thereunder,and thus
does not require substantive DRI review for the RPP issue area of Economic Development,
which is hereby scoped out of DRI review.
WATER RESOURCES
WRF1.Although the Project Site is located within Commission-mapped Water Resources
Wellhead Protection Area and Water Quality Improvement Area,the Project is connected to
public sewer and is expected to result in a small reduction to site-wide nitrogen loading due to
improved stormwater treatment.Thus,the Project is consistent with the MPS under Water
Resources Goals WRi(General Aquifer Protection),WR2(Drinking Water Quality and
Quantity),WR3 (Marine Water Embayments and Estuaries),WR4(Freshwater Ponds and
Lakes),WR5(Water Quality Improvement Areas),and WR6(Public and Private Wastewater
Treatment Facilities
WRF2.The Project involves significant improvements to stormwater patterns and treatment
and minimizes the amount of additional impervious coverage on the Project Site by using
permeable pavement.The proposed upgrades will result in an overall improvement of
stormwater treatment using bioinfiltration and other Best Management Practices.Thus,the
Project is consistent with the MPS under Water Resources Goal WRY(Stormwater Quality).
WRF3.The Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant
impacts upon the Water Resources Goals of the RPP and standards thereunder.The Project does
not require substantive DRI review under the issue area of Water Resources,and this issue area
is hereby scoped out of DRI review.
Courtyard Marriott.Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 5 of 14
NATURAL RESOURCES'
NRF1.The Project Site is mapped both in an Economic Center and as Significant Natural
Resource Area(due to the presence of Commission-mapped Wellhead Protection Area),but the
Project is not anticipated to negatively affect the water resources protected by this mapping.
Additionally,the Project Site does not contain and is not proximate to wetlands or wetland
buffer zones,and is not located on the coast or offshore.Development and redevelopment is
encouraged to locate in mapped Economic Centers.There is some clearing proposed of existing
vegetated areas of the Site-however,these areas are isolated from other naturally vegetated
areas and do not contain significant wildlife habitat.The Project does not propose to disturb or
alter more than two acres of previously undisturbed land,and is located on a developed site
within a heavily developed surrounding area;thus the Project neither involves substantial
deviation from nor would have significant impacts upon the Open Space and Recreation,Coastal
Resources,Marine Resources,Wetlands,and Wildlife and Plant Habitat Goals of the RPP and
standards thereunder,and the Project does not require substantive DRI review under these RPP
issue or sub-issue areas,which are hereby scoped out of DRI review.
TRANSPORTATION
TRF1.A Transportation Impact Assessment(TIA),submitted as part of the application
materials,prepared by Vanasse&Associates,dated April 2017,provides transportation
information in support of the application.The Applicant's proposed mitigation actions were
revised in an email from Vanasse&Associates,dated August 25,2017,and in revised plans
incorporated herein under Finding GF5 and Condition C6.
TRF2.The trip generation estimates are based on trip generation data in Institute of
Transportation Engineers'(ITE)Trip Generation,9tn Edition,for Land Use Code(LUC)310,
Hotel,which is an accurate characterization of the site,and the calculations were performed in
accordance with Technical Bulletin 96-oo3.The estimated increase in traffic from the Project
during different time periods is as presented in Table 1.
Table is Estimated Project Trip Generation
Trip Generation(trips)
Time Period Existing Site Proposed Site Net New Trips
Traffic, Traffie
Saturday Daily Trips 850 1190 +340
Saturday Midday Peak Hour 86 108 +22
1 Based on ITE LUC 31o,Hotel,u9 Rooms
2 Based on ITE LUC 31o,Hotel,168 Rooms(with io%Travel Demand Management(TDM)plan reduction)
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 6 of 14
TRF3.The Scoping Checklist for limited Development of Regional Impact(DRI)contains the
following transportation related questions:
Table 2:Transportation Scoping Questions
Will the project generate Yes,the project will generate more than 250 new .
more than 25o new daily daily trips,but safety improvements will fully
trips? mitigate additional trips.
Will the project generate lvo,the project will not generate more than 25
more than 25 new peak hour new peak hour trips through a high crash
trips at a high crash location.
location?
Does the project have direct Yes,the project site abuts Iyannough Road(a
access on or does the project regional road),but site access safety and overall
abut a regional roadway? roadway safety will be significantly improved
from existing conditions by the Project.
TRF4.The TIA is detailed and provides a comprehensive assessment of the scale and nature of
potential project impacts.The Project will result in the reduction in the number of site
driveways,improved site drive design and construction of a length of raised median on
Iyannough Road to discourage left turns,the inclusion of a sidewalk along the site frontage,and
the commitment to implement a Transportation Demand Management(TDM)program tailored
to the hotel use.It is also noted that the Project Site has an interconnect to the easterly abutting
property,and the benefit of an easementto Route 28,.which reduces the potential for• .
concentrated traffic impacts from Site development along and.to Iyannough Road.
TRF5.The TDM program,included in the TIA,involves the following actions and measures:,
• An on-site transportation coordinator will be assigned to coordinate the traffic reduction
program for the Project and work with the Town of Barnstable,MassRIDES(MassDOT's
rideshare coordinator),and the CCC to develop and refine the elements of the trip "
reduction program for the Project;
The hotel operator will become a MassRIDES employer partner to facilitate and
encourage healthy transposition options for employees and guests of the Project,and to
coordinate a carpool/vanpool matching program with other area commercial properties;
• . Information regarding public transportation services,,maps,schedules and fare
information will be posted ida central location and will be available through links
provided on the hotel website and social media accounts;
•. Employees will be provided with a"welcome packet"that will detail available public
transportation services,bicycle and Walking alterative,and commuter options available
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA -
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 7 of 14
r
through MassRIDES'and their NuRide program which rewards individuals that choose
to walk,bicycle,carpool,vanpool or that use public transportation to travel to and from
work;
• Employees will be made aware of the Emergency Ride Home(ERH)program available
through MassRIDES,which reimburses employees of a participating MassRIDES
employer partner worksite that is registered for ERH and that carpool,take transit,
bicycle,walk or vanpool to work;
• Direct deposit of employee payroll checks will be offered;
• Employees will be provided with access to kitchen facilities that include accommodations
for meal storage and preparation;
• To the extent feasible,employee schedules will be coordinated so as to be consistent with
public transportation schedules;
• Sidewalks will be provided within the Project site that will link the hotel building to the
sidewalk infrastructure along Route 132;
• Lighting will be provided within the Project site and around the building perimeter to
provide a safe and inviting pedestrian environment;
• -Full handicapped access will be provided within the Project site and along internal
circulating roadways where pedestrian accommodations are provided; and
• Secure bicycle parking will be provided that will be conveniently located proximate to the
hotel entrance.
TRF6.The raised median will greatly improve safety in the area and offsets any potential
transportation impacts of the Project.The raised median is proposed to extend past the eastern
edge of the site-drive.The design of the raised median and overall roadway cross-section will
need to be reviewed and approved by the appropriate permitting authorities of the Town of
Barnstable during local permitting,though Commission staff and the Applicant has already
discussed this proposed median with town officials.This median extension,along with the
sidewalk and TDM program,mitigate the transportation impacts of the Project as it relates to
the requirements of the RPP.
TRF7.The Applicant shall institute the above-referenced transportation improvements, and
thus, as so conditioned herein,the Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would
have significant impacts upon the Transportation Goals of the RPP and standards thereunder.
The Project does not require substantive DRI review under the RPP issue area of
Transportation,and this issue area is hereby scoped out of DRI review.
WASTE MANAGEMENT .
WMFi.The Project is located within a Wellhead Protection Area,but does not involve hazardous
materials or wastes as defined by the RPP.Further,the Project will not create significant
amounts of solid waste during the construction phase different from those wastes routinely
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 8 of 14
associated with new development,and thus does not require the preparation of a construction
and demolition waste plan.
WMF2.The Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant
impacts upon the Waste Management Goals of the RPP and standards thereunder.The Project
does not require substantive DRI review under the RPP issue area of Waste Management,and
this issue area is hereby scoped out of DRI review.
ENERGY
EF1.The Project proposes to be LEED-certifiable,complying with Goal El(Emissions and
Energy Use).
EF2.The Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant impacts
upon the Energy Goals of the.RPP and standards thereunder.The Project does not require
substantive DRI review under the RPP issue area of Energy, and this issue area is hereby scoped
out of DRI review.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING
AHFi.The Project is located within an Economic Center as mapped on the LUVM for the Town
of Barnstable.
AHF2. In accordance with MPS AH3.1(Mitigation Standard),the Project's community
contribution is calculated under the use of"Other"in accordance with Technical Bulletin io-
001.
AHF3.The Project falls under the NAICS code"Hotels(except Casino Hotels)and Motels"as
used by the Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Employment Statistics(OES).Roughly
93.5%of jobs within the sector nationally pay below average wages per the OES.The OES .
average wage.($23.86/hour nationally and$23.66/hour for Barnstable County)is similar to
income limits for affordable housing for those making 8o%of Area Median Income
($22.88/hour for Barnstable County).
AHF4.The Applicant has provided actual staffing numbers showing the number of workers per ,
square foot to be below that shown in the most recent CBECS, and using the Applicant's current
figure of 1 worker per 2366 square feet in the calculation of"Other"does not represent
substantial deviation from the MPS of the RPP as it is consistent with the logic of the calculation c
outlined in Technical Bulletin 10-oo1
AHF5.MPS AH3.1,as adjusted in accordance with Finding AFH4,currently requires a payment
Of$31,32o for the use of"Other"for the Project
AHF6.The Applicant shall make a payment in-the amount of$31,32o to be used'toward the
development of Affordable Housing in the Town of Barnstable,and thus, as so conditioned
herein,the Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant`
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 9 of 14 .
impacts upon the Affordable Housing Goals of the RPP and standards thereunder.The Project
does not require substantive DRI review under the issue area of Affordable Housing,and this
issue area is hereby scoped out of DRI review.
HERITAGE PRESERVATION/COMMUNITY CHARACTER
HPCCFI.The Applicant submitted a Project Notification Form(PNF)to the Massachusetts
Historical Commission(MHC)and MHC did not respond to the PNF within its 3o-day comment
period.Commission staff reviewed the Project and did not identify any archaeological sensitivity
in the highly-disturbed surrounding area.Thus,the Project meets MPS HPCCi.3
(Archaeological Sites).The Project complies with HPCC1.i(Historic Structures)and HPCC1.2
(Cultural Landscapes)because the Project will not impact any historic structures or cultural
landscapes.There are no historic properties or districts within vicinity to the Project Site.
HPCCF2. The proposed addition will be located interior to the site and does not create or
extend strip development,as required by MPS HPCC2.i(Strip Development),and will eliminate
a curb cut along Iyannough Road.The Project also meets MPS HPCC2.2(Protection of Existing
Roadway Character)as the location and size of the building and the proposed landscaping for
the Project are consistent with surrounding development and will not significantly alter the
existing character of the roadway.
HPCCF3.The proposed building has a building footprint of approximately 15,10o square feet.It
is set well back from Iyannough Road and will be partially screened by other development,but
will still be visible due to its size and the presence of open parking lots between it and the
roadway.The Project incorporates variation to the building facades,to reduce the roof and eave
height in some areas,and uses exterior building materials that will appear similar to traditional
buildingmaterials.Thus,the Project meets MPS HPCC2.4(Consistency with Regional Context
or Surrounding Distinctive Character),HPCC2.5(Footprints over 15,000 Square Feet),and
HPCC2.6(Building Forms and Facades).
HPCCF4.Although the Project maintains an existing parking area in the front of the building,
new parking areas will be located to the rear of the building meeting MPS HPCC2.8(Parking to
the Side or Rear of.Buildings).The Project proposes to create vegetated islands within the front
parking lot,which will significantly improve the existing parking lot landscaping and will also
help to break the parking lot up into smaller areas,meeting MPS HPCC2.9(Landscape
Improvements for Redevelopment) and HPCC2.10(Landscape Plan Requirements).The Project
also proposes substantial additions and improvements to the buffer area between the parking lot
and Iyannough Road,as required by MPS HPCC2.9,by adding appropriate shrubs,trees,and
plant beds.The Applicant has supplied a draft Landscape Maintenance Contract consistent with
Commission requirements.
HPCCFS. Proposed exterior lighting is consistent with MPS HPCC2.11(Exterior Lighting).
HPCCF6.As conditioned herein,if new signage is proposed,the Applicant is required to submit
a sign plan to ensure that any new signage is consistent with MPS HPCC2.12(Signage).
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 10 of i4
I
HPCCF7.The Project neither involves substantial deviation from nor would have significant
impacts upon the Heritage Preservation/Community Character Goals of the RPP and standards
thereunder.The Project does not require substantive DRI review under the issue area of
Heritage Preservation/Community Character,and this issue area is hereby scoped out of DRI
review.
CONCLUSION
Based on the foregoing findings,the Commission hereby further finds and determines that the
Project as described in this decision does not involve substantial deviation from the minimum
performance standards of the RPP,does not have significant impact upon the purposes and
values identified by Section One of the Act,does not require further DRI review and that the
Applicant may proceed with local permitting for the Project without further DRI review,subject-
to the conditions below.
CONDITIONS
C1.The Applicant may undertake and obtain local permitting for the Project without further
DRI review,pursuant to and consistent with this terms and conditions of this decision,within
period of seven years from'the date of this decision,which time may be extended by the
Commission,upon good cause shown by the Applicant.
C2. This decision shall be appurtenant to and run with the property which is the subject Project
Site.The decision shall bind and be enforceable against,and inure to the benefit of,the "
Applicant,its heirs,successors,and assigns.
C3.Failure to comply,and remain in compliance;with all findings and conditions stated herein
shall be deemed cause to revoke or modify this decision.
C4.The Applicant shall obtain all necessary federal,state, and local permits for the Project
C5.This decision shall not be valid and effective until a copy of the same has been recorded with
the Barnstable Registry of Deeds.The Commission shall record a copy of this decision with the
Barnstable Registry of Deeds,with recording costs borne by the Applicant,after the decision's
appeal period pursuant to Section 17 of the Cape Cod Commission Act has elapsed,or if such an
appeal has been filed, after the appeal has been finally dismissed,settled or is adjudicated or
otherwise disposed of in favor of the Applicant.No local development permit that might be
issued for the proposed development approved herein shall be valid or effective until the
Commission has so recorded a copy of this decision.
C6.The Project shall be undertaken,constructed and maintained in accordance with the
Findings and Conditions set out herein,including the plan sets and other information and
documents referenced herein under Finding GF5. Changes to the approved Project and to the
approved project plans shall require modification to this decision,in accordance with the
Modification section of the Commission's Enabling Regulations then in effect when such
modification is sought.All plans and documents required to be submitted as conditions of this
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 11 of 14
decision shall hereby be incorporated into this decision as and when received,reviewed,and
approved by the Commission.
C7. Prior to and as a condition to issuance of a Building Permit or undertaking any development
as approved herein,including but not limited to site work and installation of foundations or
footings,the Applicant shall obtain a Preliminary Certificate of Compliance from the
Commission that evidences that all conditions in this decision required to have been satisfied
prior to the issuance of a Preliminary Certificate of Compliance have been satisfied,and that the
Project is in compliance with this decision.
C8.Prior to and as a condition to issuance of any Preliminary Certificate of Compliance by the
Commission for development as approved herein,the Applicant shall submit copies of final
project plans as approved,and permits,licenses and approvals issued,by state,federal,and
local authorities(except for a Building Permit)for review by Commission staff who shall
determine their consistency with this decision. If Commission staff determines that the final
plans are not consistent with those project plans approved,referenced and incorporated herein,
the Applicant shall be required to seek a modification to this decision for further review and
approval of the project plan changes by the Commission in accordance with the"Modification"
section of the Commission's Enabling Regulations in effect at the time the modification is
sought.
C9. Prior to and as a condition to issuance of a Preliminary Certificate of Compliance,the
Applicant shall provide written proof to the Commission that a copy of this decision has been
received by the Project general contractor.This decision and a copy of approved plans for the
project shall be maintained on the Project Site throughout project construction.
Cio. Prior to and as a condition to issuance of a Certificate of Use/Occupancy for the Project by
the Town,the Applicant shall obtain a Final Certificate of Compliance from the Commission that
evidences that all conditions in this decision required to have been satisfied prior to issuance of
a Final Certificate of Compliance have been satisfied and that the Project is in compliance with
this decision.
Cif. Commission staff will undertake a review of the Project's compliance with this decision,
including the applicable conditions hereof,upon the Applicant's request to the'Commission for
issuance of a Preliminary or Final Certificate of Compliance.At the time the Applicant requests
such'a certificate,it shall provide Commission staff a list of key project contact(s),along with
their telephone numbers,mailing addresses,and email addresses,in the event questions arise
during the Commission's compliance review.As part of its compliance review,Commission staff
may make,and the Applicant hereby authorizes, a site inspection,as needed,at reasonable
times and upon reasonable notice to the Applicant.Upon review,the Commission shall either
prepare and issue the requested Certificate,or inform the Applicant in writing of any
compliance deficiencies and the remedial action required.for the issuance of the requested
Certificate.
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 12 of 14
i
C12.The Applicant shall implement and construct the transportation improvements listed under
Finding TRF4,including installation of a sidewalk along the Project Site's Iyannough Road
frontage,redesign of the site drives,construction of a raised median in Iyannough Road,and the
implementation of the`][DM plan.These improvements shall be constructed,implemented,and
maintained,as the case may be,in accordance with the plans and documents incorporated
herein under Finding GF5 and Condition C6.The Applicant shall implement and construct said
improvements prior to and as a condition to issuance of a Final Certificate of Compliance.
C13.The Applicant shall maintain the site drive such that no signs,vegetation,or other visual
/.� obstructions be placed in a manner that would create an obstruction to safe sight distance at the
drive.Commission staff shall conduct a site visit to confirm that no such obstructions exist prior
to and as a condition to issuance of a Final Certificate of Compliance.
C14.The Applicant shall offer to the Town of Barnstable a pedestrian right of way over and in
the proposed sidewalk,which the Applicant shall negotiate with and grant to the Town should
Q� the Town be interested in and accept such pedestrian right of way.Prior to and as a condition to
issuance of a Final Certificate of Compliance by the Commission,the Applicant shall provide the
Commission proof that it has offered the grant of such pedestrian right of way to the Town,and
that the Town has received such offer.
C15.Prior to and as a condition to issuance of a Final Certificate of Compliance,the Project shall
pay to the Barnstable County Treasurer in care of the Commission an affordable housing
mitigation payment of$31,320,which payment shall be held for and made available to the Town.
of Barnstable to support projects or strategies that increase the availability of affordable housing
in the Town.
C16.If new signage is proposed as part of the Project,.the Applicant shall submit a sign plan,
consistent with MPS HPCC2.12(Signage)for review and approval by Commission staff.Upon
approval, said plan shall be incorporated by reference into the approved plan sets for the project
included herein under Finding GF5 and Condition C6.
SEE NEXT PAGE FOR SIGNATURES
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 13 of 14
Y
SIGNATURES
Executed this /, � day of O'C'4 b ec 2017.
Si Mature
j r� YYl�cdut'� c�r2 ,
Print Name and Title
CONIIVION VFALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
Barnstable, ss •62E. 42 , 2017
Before me,the undersigned notary public,personally appeared aL�-'"eya o c 1t/ll z-L&'
1,r Cc r nU62 of the Cape Cod Commission,in his/her capacity as (
whose name is signed on the preceding document,and such person acknowledged to me that
he/she signed such document voluntarily for its stated purpose. The identity of such person was
proved to me through satisfactory evidence of identification,which was[ ]photographic
identification with signature issued by a,federal or state governmental agency, [ ]oath or
affirmation of a credible witness,or[� ersonal knowledge of the undersigned.
GAIL P.HAN LEY
(tj
Notary Public
COMMONWE'A rf W MASSM.NuatI I Notary Public
My Cortunission Expires
September 28.2D18
SEAL My Commission Expires: �S
Courtyard Marriott Expansion,Hyannis,MA
DRI Scoping Decision
Page 14 of 14
i
3225 MAIN STREET P.O. BOX 226'
BARNSTABLE, MASSACHUSETTS 02630 ,
CAPE COD
(508) 362-3828 Fax (508) 362-3136 • www.capecodcommission.org COMMISSION-t
Cape Cod Commissio.n Meeting Agenda
DATE: THURSDAY, OCTOBER 12, 2017
TIME: 3:00 P.M.
PLACE: FIRST DISTRICT COURTHOUSE ASSEMBLY OF DELEGATES CHAMBERS
3195 MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE,_MA 02630
• Roll Call _
• Public Comment
• Approval of Minutes:.Potential approval of Commission meeting minutes of August 3,2017 and August 31,20117.
• Executive Director's Report—Paul Niedzwiecki
The Cape Cod Commission Executive Director will report on any recent activities he and/or staff has had regarding the
Cape Cod Commission.
Public Hearing: Hyannis Courtyard Marriott Expansion#LR17010 —Jeffrey Ribeiro
The Cape Cod Commission will hear presentations and take public testimony on the Development of Regional Impact
(DRI)Scoping application submitted by Julia Hotel,LLC that proposes_construction of an approximately 31,470 square
foot,two-story addition to the existing hotel located at 76 Iyannough Road(Route 132)in Hyannis,MA. The addition
is proposed in the northeast corner of the approximately 6.45-acre property and will accommodate 50 new hotel guest
rooms together with associated site improvements. The Commission will consider whether to adopt the draft written
DRI Scoping Decision and approve the project,as recommended by the Commission's Committee on Planning&
Regulation,which if adopted and approved by the Commission,would allow the applicant to proceed with local
permitting for the project,subject to.the DRI Scoping Decision,without the requirements for any further DRI review.
• Public Hearing: Proposed Eastham District of Critical Planning.Concern Designation —Sharon Rooney
(Continued from hearing held on October 3,2o17 in the Eastham Town Hall). The Cape Cod Commission will hear
presentations and take public testimony onthe Proposed Eastham District of Critical Planning Concern(DCPC) '
Nomination submitted by the Town of Eastham pursuant to Sections io and a of the Cape Cod Commission Act. The
Commission voted to accept the Eastham Board of Selectmen's nomination;for consideration at its meeting on August
31,2017. The area of the proposed designation and its boundaries encompass commercially zoned land in the Town of
Eastham,including District C Industrial,District D Retail Sales and Service,and District E Residential/Limited
Commercial,and all land within the North Eastham Overlay District. The proposed district consists of approximately
28o acres of land area and approximately 2.9 acres of open water. The Commission will consider and potentially vote
whether to adopt the draft written decision and propose designation of the Eastham DCPC and submit the proposed
Eastham DCPC designation to the Assembly of Delegates for adoptiori by County Ordinance..
• New Business: Topics not reasonably anticipated by the Chair more than 48 hours before the meeting.
• Adjourn
If you are deaf or hard of hearing or are a person with a disability who requires an accommodation,please contact
the Cape Cod Commission at(5o8)362-3828;for Telecommunications Relay Services(TRS)dial 711
Caso estas informag6es sejam necessarias em outro idioma,por favor,contate o Coordenador de Titulo VI da MPO
pelo telefone(5o8)362-3828 or Para servigos de retransmissao de telecomunicag6es,disque 711.
t
?Vi OF B A R 1`4STABLE, ,
3225 MAIN STREET P.O.-BOX 226Iti
BARNSTABLE, MASSACHUSETTS 02630
t
CAPE COD
(508) 362-3828 Fax (508) 362-3136 www capecodco.mmis.sion.org COMMISSION
t
;;HEARING NOTICE }
CAPE COD COMMISSION -
Hyannis Courtyard Marriott Expansion.#LR17010.
October 12, 2017
The Cape Cod Commission will conduct a public Bearing on Thursday, October 12, 2017 at 3:oo p.m.
in the First District Courthouse,Assembly of Delegates Chamber`s;3195 Main Street(Route <:
6A), Barnstable,MA. The following Development of Regional Impact(DRI) Scopmg application was
submitted to the Cape:Cod Commission under Sections 3 and 5 of the Cape Cod Commission's Enabling
Regulations Governing Review of Developments of Regional Impact .The Commission will consider and
potentially vote on a.draft written DRI Scoping Decision for the project which,i.f adopted by the
Commission,would allow the applicant to proceed with local permitting for the project,sib�ect to the.DRI
Scoping Decision,without the requirement for any further DRI review:. This notice is being published as
required by Section 5 of the Cape Cod Commission Act.
Project Name: Hyannis Courtyard Marriott Expansion
Project Applicant: Julia Hotel, LLC
Project Site/Location: 707,Iyannough Road(Route 1.32),Hyannis,MA
Project Description: Proposed construction of an approximately 3i,470.square foot,two-story
addition to the existing hotel. The addition is proposed in the northeast
corner of the approximately 6.45-acre property and will accommodate 50
new hotel guest rooms. The project also includes reconfiguring the
access/egress on the property's Route 132 frontage,changes to the front
parking area,and constructing two new rows of parking to the rear(south)of
the property. The project also includes new landscaping,stormwater
improvements,pedestrian amenities and other site improvements.
Anyone wishing'to testify orally will be welcome to do so. Written comments may also be submitted at the -
hearing,or delivered or mailed to the Cape Cod Commission,P.O. Box 226,3225 Main Street, Barnstable,
MA 02630 for receipt before the date of the hearing. The application,plans and relevant documents may be
viewed by calling the Cape Cod Commission office at(508)362-3828 to schedule an appointment between
the hours of 8:3o a.m. and 4:30 p.m. If you are deaf or hard of hearing or are a person with a disability who
requires an accommodation,contact the Cape Cod Commission at(508)362-3828;for Telecommunications
Relay Services(TRS)dial 711.
Caso estas informag6es sejam necessarias em outro idioma,por favor, contate o Coordenador
de Titulo VI da MPO pelo telefone (5o8)362-3828 or Para servicos de retransmissao
de telecomunicac6es, disque 711.
P s