Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
0122 WHITE OAK TRAIL
all 1p �W 12 1, it. is s, 14, y� A., It it, sil . ............. ..mo.............4" 10 tsit't Iisiti.4 ,7,F. iitlittitsf.i A itiIIititittit, Fit sIifI�Aj IIsIr,f titItllIto t-4 sIitsitr77 titt 'i, ";, M , ft'.�-�ri/ I I fT ,j ` `� li�t,7-7,j4���.'�,,,��,,�;i�,,tri-l�l,i�,-i-I �4 0 �( 11- -1011',R"'�,'r-` �`1z"; , � �'i Mi Q�R`VAA,Wmim-I P-011",""'a ",V,��'. it, Mm"'i"N't pp,, OM I�1�� ,, . �,-70 15, !� v- �,��, . 4 1 M'01 iN,R I % ,�t;t ��, I T """'" �"i-I % u, ,i W 1, M -,7 Immi'am s--W,VWI� -1 , j , , f i'�,��,'Z`f,!t�tffl%u ,".W,MVTU� .1. � " 4 0�'p, ."', I ',':,; � - P, ; ,I V-4 � .y, TW14i , �, � ,� p � � V, VA UT, �,1P ., I - - a - - � lyill"I �U'A t . I-Y�l VIIA - V . , .11 -.Alf" R-1 'I ,I X--,'Y -%�vm- �v I ra il' t ;�,- I 11 � IM I" .11 4 ,,�i�� I��I I I!AV,,,!I%ijff� ". g � �F,f��I�Avl....- J�,' '411 , ?.� , U , ,!@I ,�If' � , 5� - � ,, ,I'liff.,1,iy,�, ,% ,� , u , w , I v�t�. I .r " , 411,i .-�,#,;-,,-r"l--- j,--.V.(V" �l �Iki .� ,, �s-,. , ", , ff,�,J�, W If"#(�j � , �, I , �vjyg,(! I. � I 11,�t"f� ,ftf"�q I f I i fj,;� - �v 1"'.161"I �', I (A Y �pT� kA -0 I I -�RY , -, .11,11, lg�-Wu',J'1�1' 1. I V, -J, I t, � .T tffl�,'��,f�TWO N . I . �' �� p'll'tj lt� �vl V jiv � . T a UIN� .1,2 q ul,Klj,i�AvVvk��Yhl rur'. fl, M111 -4 �1, y"I", ,UP , I,U.�N -V,(ORJAN�;�)"�,i, �.fj1--',';,5 1 it il 'i�,F F , ,I �i�, I , , .�v i -if,I III !�� , g I ; , i�l, �� [A��Vvv 4`101i I , 2q,ji,f",I-I'J"�...... .�fW,I-Wl i,�I . I.Q I , q, ZC, I vp� T I 11� kji,l I 1% -�,�l v �i,W,VY,V, i Oi 61 I , '. E MAMPIMI ,�,,,Jv ul " Mffqii1m'14,y � l , � . X 41; wi",4,!4 Mill 'N' ,I � , � , i.11PI, %;� ---11�, , , I�, ,,"I( - 4 1 j gm- , , , Z11j"ll -",om ,j,!.�, , tt� ',,,��l,,i,i��i�t,,,,'�'�'�,'��I , , PRYKIR!" I�Ti,,Jg,, ,,� � A��, �M,�, J.1 �,,,1*jj;fj"vf;.,1 III � 0 , - I I"Y "), , ��,t -8�1,�Tcij,�)Wi:�, , I, ,?',:I i ,-T) - il �i'4,�I" -, ,a vo� '. r-p' �',m�,�g-,rgig, ,-;�"-'��i �'!Ifil Is,"o � ,p�',� "t I,,i?jti� ,'s - � , F,gptvi�-��4,;�� I"i-KI, ,f�'i ,� I , jK I " 1" - R1 t,,, 11 R , v ! -rw, ,,ti , � I ,�, - ,f;j� 011"NO", - �Wvv �I A '.� 'T , i4�i r) ! �, , �I % 111 ymo ��:Zfit, 4,�";,j?,;;�, �� ,-Ity V l , I �j 111!I , & �, �'IVWIVYI- I ,It") �;i,NIT�:��� ". , � - --l-l- -g�l, -,"'g.1,,��lc ,- v-- I -�,WIi4P"tjfR--,' 11!z � , . k tp�'v I I I NOW , , 1 " � I fit ��A - ., J� " �P V�j 9 ,% I ,q "Wqttvip"1111,ON 1 4 -,�'Iq t, �yi J.j;-A ,, I I , � � iT, ,� . . , ". , , , AWAVIF, � , I J'v , �' ,',,J',� �' � I wijrf,�j � 'k-P�f,j,,'�,,_'�'�Vltl�ill,�,' --�- "�, -�,,,Y,f�',!,"',4�0,*�ij�' , .1 "CF.��- ! 'NI M I ,., , -�i �1 I4 Mot " � I Ov " � i , , " ,"!Jig, 1,�,,h I . P �jq"�i '�,J,j 1r, - " � " , --l. !I I , ), , 1� � 1;�, .. t-,"". �,, - ,I M', ,�- ,;;, 1,',I 'i, " , , i , I � � ,"WIT , �1-`I!.110 A, I i't 0 �i, "O ,4� � "ii I , ,��j,�",-,il ivii""."I.;k0�v, 11 ". , , ,�,�',.Vil f f.ly, , , ! i�� I In 1 � , � ;, " , if�i'j j'ql,�)��� RVITNAN?4- I I,i, ill _V.,f,"!I I I ," .m ,'�,�� ,4', ,,Plif '1�11 ,, �, ..i" �v t , �,�4 I V 'IO.,'Pi'l.""�fiii,N-1��;i,��!iq�7�lf�!,il,;1, 71 '411, , - i���!R,.',I�%V,'I,',,I.i��,"i�i;;��,q�l'Ifii.i�,�i��i'll�,!�4,�iro�;"�.- --�kj" , ill-��l v ,-17&j ! i.i!�"fq �t,�I ,�,,� �t" 14-p� ,Y.% , �,,-Og-�.T'J',,.�--!jylij�,q�'g," ),f-,�;If,'J",,r..�;" , " -;j, , k,; ir,o;p, %�'! I - , J��".","� ."f�,,, lt'1�1;11M,��,;�,%,,-`��;I�: , .�ggppj ,M)?ill OW'P,�,�,-�jV�,�;"j, � . , k '4�;;,19, . ,'.J� , 'fRit .1 , I,;,, j , , I �"I,�3 -11-�"1,�I 0 II�l , '!;� �, ��,�,'j , I j,�" W'; t! iff!'C119 , P, �'�4�;"",4�,:!!.'���';�'�'�,,,�,�,�l,�;":"f'. ��� Uff S- qg,t�g, � , -YVIV �V , -'Y1,7, ,- -J� . 11, f i lO , ,�)V�;�,�,�,�iki�l,iYl�i!f'!,�,,�"!"��,A,' �"ji,"-,"rff'"'"'I " ," �-- ,Ri , . , Il'i" 4, i,,-,�tj,�� �,"i�!�',"Iy,�',, , ,- 'i R YV-'i,��"��,`�,J�?i:,F"i" I I i� l(��'t�?'F'Vit�W�11,1�1,11�gF��OTO�,r-')I�-,Ji�",;, �F 'I -,,�-�,' �,,-p I"- �I , - Oli�113611,�V1 q' I -41, ,,�p v;I 4-`,� , .011a, . , ,k:�,�',' IfIll F . " 0 hl,�Jljjf--`flMl(,i 1i 111� - � 11,�, ,1,�N ,;,�,��,�",i�T','i;"- � J i ,V , J , , -, 'I m ,�,�, , _ itid , ,4 I 1ki4'N1-1'V , - , - ?'I 4MY11 , ,�ift�o�,:Jv r , - . -,� X- ,, �, ,�;, i . , P , A I I � . - -N� - , � I T , ,, ., , , 341 1 1�, ll� ; ,tvjj1�%jjg'-,.ffr" j"iXIIII " ---', , -V`j4,-,�`��f�l.:� i,��,;,P'� � w.f ,- ; M 2 141(11'141'�PO% ',"I�i'�,,'I�,�"'�'�,",,if,'�,'.-!,',',,�i,�,,�,,57V -, ,, , � , I I , , 4 v . i"It T"LlP?qppv;� I . -'--j?01�1 "";1 9,�n i .1 -!. ;fNN� ,q ,'p,iql"W,Y�TTIP', - - I , i , ;�i,,,'�')�,-,",�',�,�'4,1,�,,,���!"',�,"�,�ilt�',��- 'il� l, 'F111,401 I., , !I ,,�J��i,�I�;� . ""'1',T�x,�'T"","i'Y �t 11 �, , . I I�1i 1Y k`A�'I I llo�, M ,�s I��j�,I ,i" ,�",I,,�jig,�;"'I" "I I.I �Ii!�!'",�4'1r,"i,�,��,1��'-,?���'�,,�j',','�� I-1 'i;1�1`��I 1'��I�`-T '?f � , , , , , , ,x,� ,,. �i�Ml�,114V '3 i ,�,'V I I."1, � 1� tjjq�ojiq'l ,, 1.. i 1I.V-T , , I , , ��",�, '��, , ,� ,I �-,�i,�,t '��.�,I`-,,*;��'�4,'�-'�z',�":l,I,,"��'�, .:t%"'�!i,,��"!�� ,r"! I,I)h 4ki'I.,,,�, ,1� " ,!"I't'!'?',1vj'T� , -!, I ,:1 jl'�T�:� �., ',�', " .dl,�6�Tl � ,i-i'!14f,.�;j�,'s�,'j i,!,) ..".11,I I,..., .t I ,��, q�,r'#"1-',q ,� 'AD tj � ,f�;,'���,,,,�f';,-I�,"��,,'�"is,if"�,i��i�i.f, � I 1�zil�i,i�`,��,�J`4'1""',!`�',,�4, " i �i I il) -11i A 4"Yll�' All I :�: � 7'�1 iN , " -,! . , , im 11,11",J�aRlY,11 , Rl -;, l� . ,;Oi I 11% " Y"i ,1�.Z, q yfpjf�.�N ilp"41fi, 'A ; , 7`-,�"�'�� `i�"`O� ,�A , �;','���,tliff,`3jj'�-��,�,, ��kI�II.jl�'.'(��ljllj�:,,f J,,,,, -%- ,7 1 Ai� 191 Y.1,11, - �t �ji -�,,'.' ITI "I 1-1" i. � ,, . -� k-', -.il� �lp I%vl�o� ')�,i�, ,�,j'f l��;�,',� , , p. I ,2�i-,-iP�- , , ,,-� I -- 40i - i It"gfil 6 N , ; ", ,,_,,; , ,j li��4�i,�-.,'?,�,��;'�,F�,i'.�,,�I I,I�I,,;;,;�11, ,A,t3i�� 'I'' .t���i,��,l�y ,.,Pw�,�, 11-11 , I 1M �v`i,11�� '�' , I 11� I � � �� I �qgt t��Il � 14�t, 1, �1;"v"i"Pl�r i � . 1� H i , �11 . y1i , 4 q 4;,,�11�i"W3110 i'MC11- � �;, i q �, wio� ,�I I I-iit"-11-1-i iZ ,,'-, "';`-., ��l I �! )i, , L ��,j,l. l �111I--,, - ,� I ft"f�,,�,",�,,�"!Y�f'��,,��"i� - 1!�,1., ( I, , ,f , 'I "I i , �,� t �' IMI!�1"MD'Of7lYMN � , -'- �,�!ill�,����,7��.,,jj,',ii,'�-�,','l"�'If,�',�'�,;,.jI P,," �,�;'Y�,T��;""."i V -��, 'l " rlil,��11;L.;,,l!,,j'I'�;!;,�'!��i �, � .i4,i,,,Rl���,�,���i'mif"ll�i",!f,�,�'it, 't1V.-"1(,- , IMI,,,�',iI it , W,�"-,..," " M ��j VIN , , , �, , ", � , I , � .i m v ,. - - I � I"I",'t . ��11 lit il , I i, I ill IT � i", 't . ,;4 V'�q, ,,`�, IV 1� 4i �,, r, - , �Vli -Tlik�X ,,,,�71fl igiA��t-,�'T�%,,��'.,Ik"`e�i,X�j,,,-j���,",.'�,��,"�":;,�""",;",�. I I . .�', 1MNVT,1,,�i,S,- ,41 �.--�;K,,�? , � -,� - l'14" , ( -, 4 M 4� , , I I , I � ", , il ,-:,.-,-,jljp�,,��kp. �,I.� r F,4;,I k , t 1, 1, . � , I , Op " U - . ftl --I ��,, " �, , 1 #-4m, . I I I 1", Aq" , "T".1k- I , V1, ,� R -�i"W,f,stli!�,4,,,�,��i, ,4,�i(��i6i�,14,�-�,"i,�!�,,�y,, �" . �""�, 4"u"i"'C.", �, , � ,, �, M.,IM 1, �,, �. ,Ril�i ,14" ,if.".' , , , � , f � ,go� , ,, , , , "'I'--, I" 1,-T,W-,-'-I;,��,--�i�'J.�' ,,I;,',,;-i:'��, I , - , I", '1�1;11 . , , 0 & �I VIlLfill-I lm�44144VYI,y�j"qi,vf,.- n m � "-�.;M"Ot"'i"L."'Vp . ; - -�,-,;!'n, --f ;,1,-'.�,i , 'iI' , ,., , , , � , , , , , .1, �--,�:1 I,"''1----.1 V,-VVI1YTHi,.','",',I ,��,",,',Y,;f J,"I;,� - ':l'�,�z I " - _., ':P-"l,1, � 1 ftl;i,d4,q ii, ,",�,��i�����,�,��4."?�"I-�,� "'.- �� l,I atl , , '4,t,��!!""i,r,v.i����,!����4'�."',��,���'���;�i�'. -, " ' .J. '� I'��.',i,'�,;�,,�l,'�,.!�,�.�,���"!f..'�,,",'����,',',��,,,!!,'i'��i',i'��,,',"���,:,����i,�,�I�,�,�i,��tl-",?",� - ."',",,.-� I 11-;-, , � -I, , i� .,WA, ,�I�WAI� M I I-11-T.1 ik� 01".,�,U-WMI ;�;;Iilltl�p`af' - , - ,��;4!' 1�l I ,,,-if , , , 1� I .71 R I M,,q ,; , f5y ,t; Ql� �;t,!, ��'11;1 ,, ,, -6,�'i,'�,-6??,�'i'Aqi,�.,it J, � .�"i�i�,111% �1111%1 ��;,� �","i,�"�, i ICIAM NN, . I i,� ;I - , I,, .'TV - � , -t,, ,;,�,,tao�;�,�', T,�,,��,�'�'� � " �" W, I P� I�1, -� �. , , , -,j�w,:.,�,., ,"�l I I M,�,-V� ,,;ill 0�;fijq�.�-JNQ; ,,'�'j� ',`,i�(:"!' , " N,�I, � - " ,, wil 11 ,��f",,I,�"!�,�,t�'ve"!�"i���,�t*'.� ."fl?, 0, I f "",-.�,(,f�,��, -��,,�O� ',�,,�--,���. �1-1 i, �i V '1!4 ,j f If 4 , , j ,�, , " , 1, � 1 14 in 1I .i"IVA I�', �-IATIP,RAI i,I i � A;, I 1 1 11 OIIVVIRWN'�ip��e`i,4q-VR I lffkl�� WMIM11"L P"',..',"AI46;;, ,�l , i I " , , . , � C 1,- RIA 11 , I , W , a -if� , 11 , ,t P'il�'�,�---:if�-", , - � � � ,, , ,'Ii�,�,, 'j", ,'�'j"; ,,�,,J� " I , , , I 4 I'l gl I I I N V i ), I`,A-, I , " 1-W- --,,�I ll I , " � , ,�,jyiip;�,'� . jl i,,�';"�,,JI�,,�!- ,; I I , , � I � I , - I , ,� " , --, ,",',i'��i:��,�,,�i,�(��'�!�'.,,;��t��IVL'11'11.��'1'1�11��:Yfk,�� I-, �,A-Z!",- p i le , !�Jjl '� �! qgi,'W�,,��,;,,�o��,i�L�r'!",k.",Ti�l',�Vt'i,�,�y",�-�ffi,.r'�!,!"C�,',,',,�,��,�,.-'�I ii , ",l��v�,��--,�e',',".,�i"�'�";,v q v.,',,,,,,��,,�",,',,,,,'-�-'i,�"",�i,�"",�!i�',,�J�i '-'?;,Jl�,') , " I i 410.,��i ir,,,g , , ;T,jtjjlq�t';iff IWWjj!i?j'," I yipg1f, ,!,�,,l �-Yv,q,�'�'�' , i , - 't O, 'i 'J�ili ,R,i�, i , ,O��,,"�",�'�;,i�pv"",�,,�,�i,t,,, � ,'��,,�,��,, ( , .�AV��"�`��::,�,�, ,4 - 'I, �.I�,� I , I --,- ., ",04,qifflj�zlxtl�,,�Iivvr I, � Wj�,1,iVNR � -,,, ��l,, -�,,'Y.�:'�,F,�� .. , -� ,�i � W,,I �y h �. �,�� P"I" ,.I - b I ,,��Ikf�111��,,�'I'���i'�l,,"����f,,*l,,.�,I��',,�,,','��,,,!i���,;��,,�,.'��l,�',,'i,��,'," I -1- I I 1-" , )"�, ) I. I�i ;,,-- , V 1;1Q - , -It��� , ,.""���.,,',�,��.��i��,�,','�z)�,�,,�,,��,'��;',,�i�,,�'�,�',,,,,,,,,'�',.��,,i,�',,�l�?�,�,-,."� � �;I x -I�i ; , I ,tw Ij71-- f" �, �t�,�f".i�-',�,�'i"�4�l,"i'.�� - ��!i��i:-"",�I!,�,li�����i����,� ,,;.,,��"'W,i,1 '4�' ",I f-o-w-��x """ , ,;t",-, � - -, * � ,$�VIXII VV W111*;11"I��',-,i il,��,,,i .,1f,"I�i��;�"i�f",�I I"?�I,I,�,�I ,', .1%,Wl; "I ,� , ,�;�1�".I"�',1,;A J-J,t"M"," I, � i?W I I I I , , , ��'�:,:�O,Q'I��! - "�."1, I; - - - , .i.: 'l,, "f- , � , - I -I .1 , �- , " � ,,,,, .,-, - - 1- 1. - "I", ), -, I I W r t,� t, , , , - �17"A ( 411 - A�,I i'l , i �i i(-N'-*,Y�V�,)i,,";,%�k -,V, -i"�',,�1, - -,- I, "''VIT".it rl, j� � - W j,I, ,liI'lf-'ai�',IM,�?�,�ij�,'Itit��",R�,�t;o ;10-'1I"1;,�J�j - , " 1.1-�il ", 1,-- "I fill ,- 11 �Ii W ,1.y U�, , , , , "i-�,,,,-,�,-I`�,�,�`,��R�,"',,�',,R%,'�` -- . "i� i....I 1114,11 I 11�1 � yilg�V, ' J"" � ,t� ,411t 7, q V , j, K"7"I ,�,Y,)J .��'i T, �,�" I , ,- 4, . ,V1&',i,b-yTR,VI'll �0,f,�,,'!.I�i�T,��j,�t'il�;�'(i�4"�i�, � , , . ,,� ,`%`�,., x04l�,,` I " I, i U � ,J�Jffi Nt ,vm ml'�, , �.'-,--,�-- ,,6-`,:;,�� ,�.'I'q ,il ,� �f"!��t,��,,If "." � , , - ..(01 ,�,�,�I-',;�!�'i'-i�l 1;1,��, :,;,!�,`q,`,`,�:,'�,�,,,��,I,j��,I M W-,-� t M'I'?K N�4��,,,/""f,�,,"������,',�'�,'�$�";, ,,",;Jf,�,:"�"i, ;�.�,WV,I - , -, " , . , I.I�""I,. , ''�, 'I ..", ,, . I , , � ,� �'-f I - f , ,.,�, , I 1 , - �- ,�11,1,,�,"", ,,j�,"�,l�,,h?�jiq?'�1'i�- 11�,� ; , ;-"',��,,�,�!,�4 �, � 4,1t A , ,��1'. , I �y " � '�' I I"f,i"t"!r�l',,��tY,,,.""",!,�,;:.f�! '� - , ,; !41'.4111il"�-?,)'�, , � , X,�,,M�!��': �,T�l - -A ";�i�'-',"Y''�, , i , , ,� 1, 0�,�'j'�'�",t"`�;,,,,,lj"`�� . ;r-,%;",',:".,i1 t V " ,�� I if��,;"" , , �! " . i � ., ,10' f- , , �11� � . , 11 , I I I �r t, , l, , i � . II .I l I , I�l�.- .,j lit; � , � ,I , � I ,)f R�1141',�Iq""� iI, P"I iF4? .. ,1,�,V1,-j�'V�t',,1�t T ;�!�g';,,,,,!:�'���,i'��,,�:j'�!'���-�4, ,�I"'V I"" -�`i v", , , , , , ',IV,P I ,j - t W*� I �,I,*,�,�,:,,`�,,;�'�-',��T-�,�'V�OIVS�, '- , 1 -,"'I",`,"��";:,f"i�, , - I- 11 "' I- '. , '.1'.1 I I 111.11 I - , ��i������,,,*i�),�l,,,,���:��,il','�,i4!,��",",(i',"tli�,"Y��,�"f;,;,,�,6�'i',�,-,��;"",�,',,,',,,it,��;,�,��,.,'�,, � , - ;��, - - ,.. ,� ,�,lt,,R--V� I Nli 11"I�i',`�' �'Jj�j"Rvp, I ,� 1, �,?���',��'�'I'll.��'ll",��,��i����;.t"",����ri � If I " � �' , ,,C� t&, A , , I i . 1.,I--.-�W"11 � �yl , . �4 10� �� , 1. ;,f.'��-'ii � , - ��,,R'%PWW1V - "I!�I t�-- - " , I.F , 'i ��ill,r-. , k:'�,ql,�' if, llv'lfllft�l , , .1, -"',�1,r.1��.'',':�, ,3,�,,l,�ly,�i,,�j",l�I,�'j-"I 11.11 "Ii.. , l,��-,;� T��,,�,,,�, ,,,,"I I lf�i,,?,,,!��,;��i�, I I , - I I ��I, ��v -",- -11 ,-t-- �, , -- , � -'-� ,f, 'I, -,),*�;�,1',�ll�,,�3",�,,;���,.�i!���",t)�,',!;,i-;��'�- �.,��,'"" "",��,�,'-,,;�""���i,",,,v��,,��,,,, -!,,� ,�2;, - -� � i�4 1 - q --"'..,,''. � . I I .1 , 'Mt , �- � ;�,�I ' , " -�.4 - - 4 ,'!�,,, ,.,I .1'!.�, , `� M.'j 'Y' , , , �. . ':,k,Iv l�',,,,';,:�,,�,;;, ,ii"!'i��],,-� -,� ".O j ,,I� , -�; , i,t ,�,��;,,�,,,,,j��,,",,,,.,I.l�-."",-,z""�-�,-:,�,.�"!�,,� , w-'iV, f';!'"J',6�,,-,-,'4. ", ,z- 1 ��.,l ,�,, ,,, "l .,".5 � � �,,*,,,,"I i, , ,� . "O 4 1,11 "' �' " �, , ""l- 5 f,I , , ,:"i I � .,l Vji,j,li.,;j - , ��, q,-1, i. 4i 7, 1 I , 'l,".1,�1,'I,�,i;��Y��j!�_I,-.,-!4%, , �i�p �,�,�',i,-,.,�"f�;�i�,:�;��,;"�,���.;��,"�,�j�""�,,���',�,,�,I �,i I I t W�1,� �! , , "', i , 0 . v,:I�i�i I, ��,�� 1�;,�.1,1'1�,�.;, A,1 r�,�4`� I , �'t� . :",-,�,`%I��,,�'- ,;1,-1','.,-- - " " , jil,'�� - -- ,i ." ,05Y'i3 of t �,�,;,-,'-�o;,!� '.:,2,!�,'�� �, � � , I.-� , , �, ,� jigj6�� ,'��i�,,,Jjillpi,"f "i Tjij , ,jZ,;�i,,'�;�-1-,!Y�� N J h3 � , 0 ,Yol�i�,,V",v, .t , " y I ;,- !"�,'.�i_','�`,`, ,`�I !"%,'�"',u ,"�,!,Ol" ,�,�,' i,)"'o `f"i tl:N i i,��,i�","� , 6 I,�;!��,. ,4',�!'!,IMY:�,�Iil,�!7o, , , ,V-, �!',i�,, , (fjk�,,V�!ij�;�,'f,',,'O' ;�i* I I`,Ulk"", , ','T I'T;F .",i ","I, . i, � V I �I I'�',�:�-.*--,�f-�� ,- i T,V�,Wt�rN,WA "i �110 Ii ,Vi" �.. ......� - I - , I q'i ,,I?J� z�.',qf�oj I`,, , , ,�J,t�o 1" ,, �,"? ,I I! � i, , `� , � �, ,,�, I,I,,,%- -it, -,�',� : , � � R�;,l0g,I I -,_4 j:lI ,, ,, "��,,,� , ,,,,t,,,N�"1vj , 'A'A " - U "i� 'l I it i:I,.",'.,' _��, _,��l , h,XT",�1, F-�� `�,�,,, !",I "', ,- -"� ,��:e,j;p, -!"�,��,,:,�,,I�,,�' " ,�;�:,�',�,�� I , ,�, ,�qitLgt . , ,�I, t Iii I � i �14,,,,� ,�� I �' , 1�,',t�j%l,.!� f , , , .� O "?, ,�( .� 7""81;I, IV m+ � "I'l A I r i t�!6 ?,,��,,'��dii-,��,Ii,� ," ,,',;�.,q;,�",',�',�,-,',,;,,'";�i t� � , ;!�, . . I .,,� "�,t,",�""���,,,;,�"1;"�,�'�:�',�,gf,,�,-i�,�� I ,'V'M 'I ,�!!'I'qf i�i�.I`,-,��ti�ij,,`�t,�v;t,'jf�'q",-��;�,i I -21�IU v, . , �,,,, ,, . �.O,M!�',!, ,iaf,x'� ,jA,tj,M ,`�'.J��l ,r"i, � �i , , , . '"', - 1� . I 41 , -;!-i',��, �i I,�I:1 F !�l�!,,,, ...,�';,� ,-iI��I�il y ,4��,i!,�;��-*,,ei`-,',i.-Z" " � N- - . ,I �,,�,, � .1 I,�, � i,,, ,� iz,i-�*", ,����,,-�P�, , -- - 1. , ; -!.,,,,�;,,�,31-,,,� I , ,!,� A,fv �,� 'WTOW,I- :",," ,,,,,�- " "v " ,-jj ,f,,�',,�l��t"$;�;,!;�k,oi-�s,t,i,t-,I��,i,�,:I ,.,7 t`��,',.`,! ��- 1 ',Iil,�,,�� )i"""'.;-- "�l,,;,,�tt'��'��',�ll,!,!',*,iz',�ii;�,;,,�-�,�,".,�,'���,'ifATM, --1?A1Kii3O, " `1'4"�M',(!,k,�1b),',',"�!i��7,�"Zf-i;!i,�!�,-�,'��:�"k,j,��i"�i,��,, �,P,"PI'lili; , , W���-?`." , - , �,-��Izi��,,�,�."I��,,;�!;���,;��i,l��k"'111 '.�I, ?,�-""' 'g,"'t" ,, 'f,I *I "-1. , , " , ," 7 - -� - -,,,.,;�?--�`,`,%':V� ,',,,�,i, .�i� U�,��Ijt� -, , , , � , �4 I, �,"i'l 1 7,m,;7.'.�'��.;�,� " ,I,',-,yj .l.V 1 i,�j�,l.WI ,T�Wil�11 fl;Iiip'l.,, t,�;�:, � I "'I., t,v ,"i 4,�!'i i,i."1,("i� . , 4, , - " - , , �;NA�M;11�1;)-',v��t,i' q I , , ,W, � , , I, .. -h,,�,,i -I,P,�;WHI'-1,�A, ',�Vi -�,%t.,,,�,I;'-J_� -,.7-,�"',C�,:`.IiI�-N,, ,,��,,';�,,�-,,`;,--,,� 11� , !-"f 1,11,111, :",� I" ,, . f � � , f" �_,�,O�,�i,; �; ��,-�llf,p�l�,,,',"� l�1� e�I��,11�3?1'.I.1 I X�1,v��,',��4,!,:.,',e,��,";""�,,i'm" , I If, I I I. I I "i'4MVW"m , " ,, -;:O', '.r�:�`-,'I-"," " I �,�:"""'. ,,I.!q�,;P,�,�,��,`, , ;'" �lr , - i i�-sl 17 I� �-�"T�`�,�`rviil . ( ,b -; W , .i ""'-,�-';�,,�,�,r����i,,���'i""�*,�i.",�,i'�������," � , ?",� 11 �', ,;,�,�V,,�i , 1��'!`�l'%"-,�...i��,.i i i,z -;,�,, . i I,� * I -'�-j 9 1�1j�.V�',', , � t i-l"', , � , I -�,�,Nq" W'. , ,g+f,,,ff . . . �f'��",��;�!�:P� , 1, � , �, 'g. � ,�yi�!h�t?vc, tfj �,-- - , f-, . -'I�,��,. 'I, ., I- , I ,,, , I I , i�,�,i��,l i�""��". "�I y-,I"j�4p��j.I� '. 11"'i "', I -,,,,,�,,,, v. ,m,-" , - -,:J�"'l, �,,�'-�,��;�,,-�.:�,-,�P,.:" . � , - -,, - I - ,'I I i":�, , I :�, � , " - - , � � !,"'), �'��`?'-'t:�� - t ��7 1 �S�, ��, , v, " X, � ') , , , .r,�,,��- , -, , T , ,I. .'I I " - , , � -�';"��'��','j�,-'.',--,-,�� 11'-l-�y��-Iy,,��JVV I,�,��,,',14-To" , - .,,. -.,- i,;:,,-;f�,,,,�,!�."i;�;5,�-,,';,:l--,�� 11 Jgll �, I ;I �;l - �,,��,,���.."I���*�--�i���t��,�,i�i �� -V 'i;..T;";."il���;��",�,it',�'�,,�,�i�,�� � I , , hlil,�n;i,;,i 1;l�I, "l'�!." .1:'l ,��,�, �P, � ,!"'!,'g, ..�, , i� � P,Y�,�-n%�"',';�� I I O WI) � ,�,�?O�,4;j�, - , -,, � �'!�!M,�'�- -4�, � , ,�� , ;- , �-�i� � 1�4� �, v -,,- , P,hi, ;,1; 5.11 -, , , �, , I il,'-,I, ,� -�'; � j, , 7-- -" 7�?�,�j,',%',',�;f��,. bl;,V,�'P I-il ��. , ,�. �'-- ,�!�,�",,�;��ij�,.,.. ! ""'O,,,�fa,�7 I 11 I .., I - "; , 4:;- ,;ga,-,-"1,,`,,�i�;���,,��j"�z,,;;;�' , "01 , i� " , I �,� ,- �� 'I. , . I ,,� ,� - . T 1-1 "I I f W, �i I,;--�il�.-o , �,,,-1�,',��j,,ir" --- -,'�� �'�',� ""I", . p, I im-v 'U"', I it i I '0;0 itf36;i� �� ! ,;, '. i�,I I " ,-, U., 4,'k,J; I ,, M , " ,,, , �`�--7,:�f�' . 0 R", i J " , ,�, I,�q. ,%,3-,�,.4!,eIi',,I��o ,�,-,��"; ,ii�,,!T'13;,�"-�;� I - - - , j,�.It ";Wt,0" j�,- ".1VI;'ll"� - I �i 1- ,I� - ,�.g -,,ii�x'S�,*,',,�V"',T.i:,', -','-��;�,�,, 1�:I , . " f-,-'I, ""��, ,-�,p,,�11�1��,I,,,,V.sVt",�,!l,,!��l � .i I I. I.I ;,- �` I l)�,d'i,��,qr'-�,;'t-"l,�l,,,�,-�q,,:,- � " I, ,- ,',jjj,'jW1' 4`.,iyiA'71,11i"'�, � iii -�,�,-,'�ll,�,,��`I,"�'!'��-���f 6 j�,,�111;".fif�,I!, ',qj,�,`��,�',j';,�,,'j I , ,.",� -, , t,, - , I- _, - Mi�11,1�vfjjj-liy,l " "��,,,,�"��-�,�:".�"�,,�,'!,�i�;:��Ii';,-'j�,�,��;,i,�",l 't�-,'i,�,� .;q ";��,-,- ,�""�?�,'4,',`i�,,,'�i, I : Ui A W, I UM,�� i" ,,x'q ,;V j jwi ",r.Tr I ,�i��,",,,jl;4�,0;',�,,��',',i�,��IT)I',�i�,'.',T.I'�h�., y"V�r -J�)"NnQ�-i'�'F�,'�,� , , ,l.: , ,,I, 'I,i " �5, ,:rj,, ,fh��4 ,I;��,�,�fI , ,��;;i�i , � .�- , , , t,�ll"I,!�:%"'v'-��-,`O"�N,?�, �, , �� :,,l,j�,:"gf" "'c',%!-, -'�ij,�,`Y,,,,�',,`,,-� � �1'�5 i4ft 4 , f �,, , , ,,, " , , ",."- 1, -W; , 4, I . i '-,'�,�,tl---, , , �;i� ,� i Pfi v.RiRi,1,h&Ar,'T U�`,!-;;�,`4414 , . 1 .1. " 'Qwl, , �,'�,���,',,! , I v ,j�g � .�,,,,- �I � , i, . 1�0-�,".�, , , , I% �,-4-' �-p, I I I � , Po :l'il'j"I"I 4�;:ir 411 't'M�f .4 -1 I I I ,k""�!'qi,�',;�u, �,�,�,,-�-Iq,,!I� "";i",�,iN" I ,'1,1`.";?J� - , -1. , j1Tiy,v)t4j1if,`1li'X 4; 11; '.'�J�-��, ,, ,, , ��Vi`i`;`��"ti;iz,;,."�,,ti�:i,�;��"".,�'i,�.,','�i�,�",i��',�,,���;,:-""i -"', ,- � ,,W.i". "I,.,,.- Allyt1j'PI'aill ,i!;l . - �, ,lb� t�,,- 11I.-I M., 4 -UO��,,� pit, ---- ---,�f PA, ',,',`;��- , , pi.t��q,l�,� �'! � !,��f'Li",,,,:�:��-�-,,,,��,-�,i,,,����if�,,,,"'��'��,'�'c lo,� !;,")"-'-,��;"'.- , . I 1. , - I , , ,- ,'.1 �i.%"-"��!��,,��,,'O�l�'l,",'$�I ,� fl�,,,Pk.Tj"`�'Imfi, It, -1� ;','�",I''I P-P 7-�-,; ,,-,. ,"�,--, -�1�� - , ."� � ",, ,, , "'ill,'�,01�,�q,�,ffj �'I y 7W,-' I �� I I�- ," I � , - ,,�,'!',-�lf,i�,',�',',�'�.",P,�,5"�i�i, N --% I I 111i �,jif, -'I'Ai f "UM, 'I �,v , , lj�,'�"I'�I-f'ijw., -goi,""'111, , Y��!;h,�:%�,�,'o�',440� t,A",;i,t, "''' -, ; , "'i,if"rti�",,�� ", V, . I-11 I ,"!, , NO ii��, ,�i�',,10;1 �;4.,i�,��, �1 ,'141, P"NOA, i it 11 14, *1,�I 1; "j,Y, �"'�,j�,T"i��;,��;���..i�i;'�l, �;,!.J�4 ��'� J'�Wg J � W� I T I 14 .� ,� 'v�i , :I �,? 1, ,jj-I" ,1'� ,,i4i, IN, I V , - I �111'i Z!I f13--�51,1111111 111- 4viRATiiMM U, tl�IQI'J�I . ,,,'�,1,1,1,,,i,f,,,�;�.�,,��i,'�'�l,,���S,`O� I N ) , , " , - IT.,1-1, "" .1 I,� I I 11 ,Qx� �1-11 111-11-1-,,""; , I , ;i'lVA I � HV�',j YiAij'�Iqt�,`,,�,� "".,"iittf.�i,'�.'��,;i,�"",��,�,�,�K mti�� -fv�,4.�1'4:i; ,"��i�,',�;�,F",,'ii���,yre"�� ,)%�*y �, I 1,�?,,-',,Y�� :i,"itf;�'A','f' ,,N,. - - ,tw,lllv�iiP,i ;I " , ..�, � �PMejfil ,� � �;� , t',�lltjk.` _ i " -,"t, ,,,,, "' ,,f4 ,� R I IVN,Q, ,j','�� - , , '.,-,� 'O ,�"',"T I I m "%641 -,N, - , - 1�,�,, ,�.��',,-,�:�;:�i,,!"��j`4 , , , , 'i, ��i�'t, "', I t, , , W, � il � . I :;,j"',ll�� , ,�,4, 1� �, ,, �! ii ,��i",�,,',�,R IN, iN,N �i�')RV"�f�,11�of ., Will , ',,��,"�,I"r"A J"�I - ,!!t'I5;,W".,7 -,�!��',izl�,',' - " , "TV.�"'i��;�',4'�,�',��-t��',���,,�'.'.?'�i �-�," - , f- yr'� ,�i",�".��,,,,,�,�'�1.11,��t?!"k,io -;��i�'�rWO�,�� V � .,1�I- -U�'" ��""t""q 11'ItTyl-,tq,�p,�qx �.Ill '! , .�,"." , " �J'AI r�A,)M4,,��fii,j . i �iv �� , I (I !j'�� "��,,�7,�, ,?'i�q`�:ft,j i.11 1V I 1.1 . J'�`� -� ,!i�--'�j�Y ,�, � ,It, �'?,V , I I , , , -l',- 11 , , , *i,y�4�",r;t"i",n,���;iiii�71i�p�lI , W � �lfr 1-1-1j� -ti, 11 ,f - "� � , - ',I, "i(-�,,, "l;I'VAPay 4 i iflk,ifktl,t.'?V�l"'��'f-'�ii,�,,�"Ili�!!Ii�I *� �.y i "��t,"��i���l,ii�;,�f'i�t);,;!t,�i-,i��'?,�",���;,��4,��,;,,;,-,,.;,if�i�,,,��,`It� ,� �;�t , , ,,,,,�-,I-Q.wil'l 't I ,I- - 'I," , . ,..-- 11 . I 1- 11 - I I M -, �ill,VI , , t'%4�-Iij- - ,I W-, 4 1 1;V�,-!',"bY(j&0k"wYNO"I ,-i'III �'i,-,�,,Q, " �,�'!'w,�,�#td,14,�,!;"VOI',;�.v , . ,- � i ,"IM i`� 13"", , m .4 , , 49 , ".. gr , , I jv it"41W v, `i,�;i;,��'�� ,, � Q'I'I�`i � , ,lj�yfivj� , .,;"".,,?i"ii���i�,�,"�",t,�,,�'��"il,,�V, �.1,�l',�,,",I",,�i)i��,,,,,,i,l�"lih*,�'�,.",,,�t�,���'�,I 1 Ij. f If� l.,"'- - 1. Now"wowi'M�'C& i�*00% -1',,� 4 -,',��j *jji� j, flf' , 'i?�,0.,.",:"�-.""��l�,-'�4!4;ffi�l'i��til�(�4,�',��,'-�i�i,,tii�,,I),�,�!"i - I��, J�f, jlj��V, I 1 11,"I I-�.-, ,-" � - , ,"�,�,, It'lf,%fi�j",�s'-', , . ,4lj�6; , " 'I,I,k,t�, t t,��I�;jl; � , `�jjljfjv P,�',U'A � -�, ,pli i"z,WPV,k�, � " ai,l% , ,Op '?� '�*,� ��, , � kkl,F,w,?1R � , 'i , , " 11'",OR 1 4 It, �,�,�� ) lv,i j J� 1411i "'P � I "t V(TI Y Yj�Y`L,'k" � , � 1,t��,) , I 1 I ijs,�ft,j, I "; . , CAM ;V. �, , I , , 1�f-41�'W'�, ,"; �,� if�- �t"�irl,�,�% "" � � I��V-�i.:i yl,`�'�"ItiV t'l,`N! ffi� , % . � .� jvi�jy�,I ,�? , i� ,4;�, il,ff-Xv�iff,*"Wjq, A.;;V,�;411;(,�i,�!,(, �W.,1,4,A-� , , �, ", - , - ,� jj�'?I ta"fill M19T1v1`17,bViVjjs"7 , i�j F 9 4WX U ij,j!,%,',,i9%%,j "Y�"i".k,�1�!)1111"1.1,It'Y"�'-"�';�'W�"�I�''`1 I T-I;-l ' 1, O'i'Ally" Ii ,�11 04N,V,e t"IRN W l I -11, --���-I,' . "-�Mlt4�, �",.,.",,h,"���4it"i,,i,),t",",,Oi-,-y",41 - ,",s"�-,'iZ`-,-,!?`4 i� i�,,1 i�,,i J,��,� .�,,,�',f,v ?t fit , I , I I,- �,A,,�',, - -b�y,I 11 w I Ill,1-1 11 . L INU411:41,0!�,,Z l?I,Jilto�ff,�I'V),� ,!V4 "',V,"g,I,',,�, ,�Jlj�,�,"I I -,t I;!v-i 4iv tj,��'Pjl� " -,-,I, � , , , , � ,Tyml"k-11 i�!��W �464 41�y �'',!,,4�,j ff;116N,,-,,�,�fi�i,�-I ,it,I ,$'�'! � , , , � ,�,Ij ,411&q :'?' ?t , ,z ., VAY'b','qV,1?Y1-1VV� � � W 1�'i 4 i 1 fi 1"I" �4fivIyPivV!,)l"-W-I f���,t,�,6,�.�'T',I��,f eI ,"I,i,;1l�Pjj1*, �VPPP,�,N,�,v ,�i ! ,7 �T flyll. Ill I ` ,-��,�'Itt�-,Voi�j,fjf4CMtr"�,F�ff,i$,'��A�k,..?,T w �11�i I 0 v W)11,;Wl�t ii i��i�,,-t, , - " .., _,,,.",," , , , , , T �-,A, - , wo,, , , ,,. � - ;01 �n� �l'�'M'i;Itli�'y ,�%J�,jlr;j I',' , m 4 X, ,% ,,?.,i � � .,.� "! , ,,, I,,-" . 4 "���""���,'��'�,�,'i."���.�'���i,�';',� I - �, , """ " , � , -�ii�"` ,!;� i :,�V*J"i;�I�!,- ��'f,,,,'-',','�-�7��,�zIl-��.?J-�-�Y',��':;:,i, V'Iml. 'ilf i�� A�t,1,, ff��11 11 i,i;, 1W4 oj,l�,g ,j� , �� -1`11",,�,1,R )4 �?� ki '. " I I I�XYP-Amp " 11 �, -�,!,,,�1p f? N�I "I , �-r jl"f�O,�I!y �! i, , I 11V,io ,,V,,�-'�'li,it,,Ii��t�.�l,,�,,�,� . " I w Y'AW�1 -i � � gyg�,-�.;! , i k 'I ; a ;� I� �)�%% � MR 511I,v Ni L � !�i'ii�;,%`IiIVR�4 WA qP .� ," �)�i � 'I ,f:4"'1Z,v',',1.,,:. , . '0� M'qU,�,At , . $,�'I,, , V�f , �, � ,IV WON'"��N-1,10 �1 � ' �'111 "I, ot, 1"" 1', i; ,��, ,� I 1, �,, I ,v 'a ��-1 , I , "' " . �� !.Iii , wi:, , ly , 11 ,�I I , ,��'J) �, �? i�Jffljj 4, I 4,1"GilifijV�,IT(iij �'f�l,-�'i,l�t�,",Vi",�,iii,�r�,,.���,',�p!�!�,,,�i.".,.!:"q�i,'��lif,�,, �i,�,*�,�,,�';,�,'i;�'i,�',,,,',�,!!i"l��ii',,'�!i�"t.�'� - , il, . 'i'mr, , , Aq yt,I ,� '', jx� , - W', .V1 *,� oft - - '�izi,yf��,j�!�""r�,�",I,I,J".)� jli �-�,,�,��t,,,-41 ��,., ,.v -W I I I II if ';',f'��,YVI,,Ijl�j4!i` ,1-'f,1'liT---,i � -,'I-I I 1111L-I-"I '� �l - - . --1",I, �;c�j , -- I�V�.,-�f 111�O,M, , '. , -Y xilf INO,fl,�� � I- ,.�, �,�;��";�'..�'I,J,i��i�'�,,�f"�,i.,I�,!.�;Ip �'�,,j"`6t'j`,,1-�", fqvi'lu, 'i�'i�"'��1,1��tl;ii�,,�,�,�,�,�,I,INM'Y-�` �i�'#-ty,,-zv-p- �'I.5 ...... ..'t.,., �, ';� ii�,,��,A'i�4 �,�i?!*V��" I ,,, k ,Mfj,ttj��,,,�t!,�), �)jt,�, -1, H "' i I I I Vi!`7 i� � I i � ff . 0'M,I ii. I I, - � ,,I 11,11- � -N,;T- ,, i-, 1�q.,.��,',I, , MI I IN 1,) , - ,--"%,#1"' I i I ij�l -!& -;.,---I1j11',�,"1 11110-�OVI.Ijfq Tf'1f`iji,1(-, ......I -fl " , , �""'�,.���?ri�;'��,'�,.,.i�;,il�,;t;i,i�'��'-',. 5�� ,- I , I I M14A;11 I .�v M MA, ,ti, . ,,I�" i�4. -`i"M _'j�i',�� I i, 11.1,-.,v�,;�, "", W U.� I ii f I , � . I M "i i , , , , t, �i��.I, I �� TVT lv-�- i I ��V,1,fit Mlf;wo I � t�`N lf�,"M 1� �� , �� ,� � , I , if A, 4 .� , --a , ,11,0,S t�i m j� .I . L , - � NJ �I W . OgivuMv.1.4 ij�� I , ,� ,�T i PO I l'i I I,,�jl�-I,.- o- I 1�,k)'�'!J��Ajj�j,',I i� , , f , i�,�I w%. ,'ji(�'�Jj�i�'V,,,!,Vl-jr�VU,��,�f',i;,,i` I t W,0 ,�,l �� .� ,I q , I il , j v it L IMA,, 40�11,�:I,;"� , "il I,i�IVAK�"Wi"WO1�1i m" 't'JA�y, ill!"""���f?t�.�'.�,",'I,,"k�/,,.."',,",�",91.Nil"N�Iii'll'"I fv�Jfky'j-q-Y,"&'T�'ij'iY�'l�'�,l�l,�'i."'����,!,,�O���'ji,i�,,, ,�0,�-Vl-'NVQ,Pwf, i,��U.j'*K,1�"AJ -,IT�",;`4��'-4 &,,V,��.. -JU.J,V�jj - � ,;Yl�,1,,,�'V'l�jt��'iV.Y',14',�,�,-L vt'!UIOVOO , -1 1�� I,,-I';i,� ,,� '11"W""',;%" , 4iY�,jRt'o4j4ffl ,,.,) "i;�'. ,"I ,�,, I, ,14�i! , -� ", I'T t., Ul i . .11V�,�R� ,Wl,,�J,,,f III�1`" -1 v ",, I'll , � -��u'.,�','po,f pL��!;p 5�" I I ,",r�,,I 111�wo Illy VI lC 11 t 'I �. , ,, , ; ! I ,I "Prb,dei I �, -, 71- I" y"i't �, .4 � fl I, , , 'AK � �,4 AIRA�,.3, I %"--(,i IViti,i!h1p4I KY',',-,1N-A-,t,, '---�, -;,� � ,VIVM�f�`,'V?,j� ,,�15� ,, ip � - I i Aii4lo r�l��V . ,�j;',',J,�'ji'V, Va i��,,,',N,, . '! ""�; 'i!f�FI'Y�lf"�,;,k�'4,4i�,i'ill�'if,�, ,Vj)I i�,j," 11)7,� 111fil, , ;��,4��Df YA�� 2 tflji I I 10T,"Y",- ,jg �t,"� , 1;tw igy,-� , MW,,O�Iiyjfqj,,Jlfi�,�; ,� .,Z!1,11� .1 i.-A , , yvit'liv," P,5U� 02"i"t, -'� I'��,�4'.,'e,��;!,�',,!�fq�i;,�"Oi�l;?�� 7"J,��,�j k� , � ,I -,q;,g�,��l ,1"I--,,,,,yrKuy"') I I 114' 11 I ,�i � ,�,�l'y'?"i��i�,,--,,�.1,��,�i,f;i���,';,���%, , R, P �,;imwm , q-4,�,gg .I 'L.V,vo'Itv , . -q " _g, jXf'fy,ji,lg,j�,).,i",�""�i��,,�ll,�ll,�t.1,fi't,71t,f,tie,�'�", " , . . .I ,,,.,��J,�,�,;,.;Y" ,'-,'-j-"C %'g,' lz�;bvfn......O'lft"I"JI ,1#�,��- , , �INAFI M "I.,?I" -.J0j;AA1,�,l,f ,; "I�'i��;,;f,�l',�,kf��-1;1,4.��f,f., r, ,f q,jjv gLwI,xj;qq-,4,," � L-qq ---m "t #1 01 kjr�,j I -,,,,,, ,11., MT; , t . , 1� ,!� , � 'A � � �-,j�af.'W,114��,;'It.V,�,i;� � ." , I I V, .1�,t��.; I I�,,,4,4 I' ,,,vX"v,V �7,1�,��)�'�,!V�t'k'),�l�,�(i,�l', 0��,�,ij�, , , qf;� *"!;;",I' '.'�"" h�,i'ill,ph",lArf, �,� ,ye ,., �; 011'1"K'�ilimi�� �,:Y��!, �,�'ll'i't'�,�vtfi�,,�Oftl,f"fqlpil"i-�,��.���l,fii�.,!��?0"4,ti ,2 , , , , :: --h 3 gm- , �` �O,R g if � ,I - q, , a r,,F6T"7V1,j'Aj-*ffiji j�i I,'g--q,?.%i' , I 0111'r I ,A'Klgglv,,�!,L.,(,�.,p�,�g � � i � , �� �,I 11, #,VN , �i�'-',A'�����'ji-�fl�iiyt�i,�1�(., . , -i! 11 fg,,,,, ly,'�b I � AXY1141 fle"11M, , - �'�T'Uf IIFVIIIRV,,�,,,`� A�M-q ,;�l , , -'III, "' I I 1�-- I -,',NIIJ�IM9 ,�q'�r,q,,?z3y�.!p,ly .�� , '-'v TiV V 1,414 f , y�I Y',,I T, ,4 p,k,`iO,1�'��J�m -wl , f1i 9"Y."111" N" V `?'i loi�����,t-.�,z;, � I "" 11,,. - A I I I I�,�e� "t,I I � t I i�, - ,m . , �, 't��J,#gp � " ,n - " ,'k, �'41111`It; &"i-'-%11TqgYo�.,k,g-- , ; , ,I,,, .. ,1mV,jAJq, � 'I i'� 1-11,�I,2�1 olom!����*'".',,5� :4 1 MINE' i i , Ki.�, , (ij ;,''�C:5�.,l o 11 m A�,�4 , i , ,i", t I IMY � fig, ,'i � �,j q ik� " , I I , , !fi �A Im"'I I FvMW,'e4q ,'-, j�?',W514"�� ii, , 'I o,,� - I � ".f '-,�t'i,,� , .� ,�, I I M - 1� , It ,-I 4"� i t " ��` Illf, � ;p- ", .� �� � " , ,I t!, it,�ig?4, - i , , ,T �`, k ,'.-F i -W ,.�Oil�,ih,,,.q'tua- �;, '�W ,, I"M. , "w - 'y"', 1j"It NNI -;e-,�� I , Uillwum 11�.",�,f "'.., j ov i " , 11� - �,�Ilv?-�5�lpt 31-Y. � - -4 i'� ,,�t�,,,,Jlt,ivj�v,i I, li�'p," Iil liv ,�I 1�;i,41'i-",4 to,4�40,10`11, , 11 I!, RIIAM4114 liV 11 AI?W "A 1,11, ( . F . `11 - . � zq�� "�'j zqw - ;?�,�'*-N�-',,',, mit, i� � ff ,�V �- 1'4� , -f�g�� * 1, f P . ,14mg1j, , ", � il�- ,-,lii,lY,tf,-fiti;f,'�vf�j7%,�t---f,-- �15�fl,�tyll�)�J,71j�`,31 � ,,, I "' -Ki� Py"r,"l-, lj'I4� ktl�,�', -p �f 't-�I"- , " , 1, , " R" 111 ,- ---fi . I ;,i i i,! Iri l?f,FV:"-iU m 1f �i,�;"'v��,';�I.ft,j %` IIN O 4; f,1,,,Piwh-VT t 11-11. -4 ,P�;. I'1�i, , M ,, llhl MP��lN�,��1;1� � ,� �� - ,'i�,,i ""Y'N'l �J,Nfv,:, I �. � ,� , i;i"M. . ��Ik I-i� , ,jil", ,q w 9,11m, ;",: �,, `4 1: f. . W, 6,I� , -,W ` '�'I Q, ,,i- I ,- - - 1, ii iL?!i'NjAjq,�ii%pP NBOWt'i;W!T" ,f f-j* jV'7 0,-�. ," ,� I J'�yt,l, - - --I ," t ,, . ,1 ,i 'I,, � I , -, � 1 NY V., , "ViTWA ,p - , 11 �, -1 -�WA� , "A � � , Ni," , - " - '-'-'-"-pk-j,,� fit' %.'Z1fAAM i�;I"g�!%,Y.��" 1"o 011, '" .r, I; .-, ,,,!,,,,-�,�,�,�,,j���,�,���i',,�ii",,�*,,�,7��,"�,� �', , t-Tf, . L.T I , �I, _� Y,iT,k�!I�fj�` "k",��-. I ',I�,I:F-11,pl%j,yp�,", - -� i�!�f- F,K 141 fli i V77 - ., , 11111"," L 1, mi,I �, �,,,�! , , w 'Filfri I � � , - I X"", ,,.!.'S`,�;�i�lj , 6%V� �;I 1 V�1,I g,�jv m----, "I, ---�-4,,,1,"-,,,.,g,���;�,� . ,i-,;�1,,-;�- 'u-- V0,wr --ix --ty, sl�;:'-7-1z?�N�U;"�',; . 'L",--,--, , , , v ,, I B14 "ii'I , -"i,- � 1141 4-"' - I p ?� �, ., , .�,, 1`11 I 11 -,13 ni "t, �ts,j I,f�I,�;!�f��V i4 l,i��,�y j l'i,i I �VmWft,�',$VIR t i . 'ji . A MNiil M s to �j , , I � �j , N j�7,l" 11I ,g, 'sl � ,, , , , �,�,,��. ri�,,?:At� go �! � 11�T,4, !�, ik�,gt,�kgj at &i i I � I ;,!�I,r p�I&pq g��m , , i .1 I , "i,-,��,� 0-11 Ir �� - , ,,',�i� �-Ij��J�,I V'j l'1� - , -v ,,-I.., ��,j, ;,, �;�,;I*W, - , -i ,.i�` 5. 'VIRD., , 11 v�j- -g-i'v ;Q , 1,16, , I, �,-3 . a � _j- A ?, ,, ,I , ") 1, " fly 14"W"i'Al , 1�%,'k " �'o � .�,,�,'A��,,,,�,-,'4�,�,�,,,,.�,,,,� ,� , ," , i 11 I g , IY�. � .. � ,fr r , w I, � , MiN , -0 , fil" '11-aij 12", 11 , I 0 M IV ,R I 6, 1 1 , I r RON 1�fi,j t�'-W,yo,gy X17"M7 111MM134`4 vail? �t;C'11"��P,VMOTI, ,gy ,11 ,v .i I h i ,I ,� , , " I ",�, " ; I I , 'I,'--1 4 , ,! , , 8 L,� I I x , , UY If 1� � IVIA VIO - 1'#�,�f',� , - ,Jrjlft,"�111%,��-�i � N , ,W ,AP� ,�Nt �;�,,�4� j �; , ju.,f��l i�,,j f�� IV,? tl �',IR,!di��-.� ,,Mi4iir'4ffl-VIR;� j, "N,V Rbl,i4, "', " -1"',""f4 ; ON I 1-111- , ,V�� ,k I wmm I�j;p il.MZvIal; , w � ,� J . � .1, 'i, I AM , I �4, 4m��4-1f--ij- o7jw ,RV.,�,�',VIWV -P , I] �gvg,K ,�j 1-'M,:-)'1 I r I FU �, , I , 1- , W 717i�-,��:I�--"1 �AIVIITMIAIPS,- -i Iit � 14011%, I , RZ50l - � ''I , 1. . '! ,�,,�,� zt,!"O", t�l %i!� I .�f,, " ri I I P, , , 'M , � �, ,J,,,�r I ` .4 7 � -4)� L, ,ij I 1-1 v � , w "t, c 1 1 I LIV Im, I ( I f,�i ".."'Al , vw�� � R�11-1�24 A 91' f 1 0.7�o,vl 1 MIA )l . �k�V,�Y16�,.,.,"���,�'""'�ZrI,�,,.,�', ,01 p'A -i I 'I , �7,, , , , .�, l � Q 't i` ,#' �'J',,I, Ml ? 'faz -111 � - tf N11.11"MU-S'.I- _ 'VORM NR`A1W;JMp%A-V �1, �),tl,� 14,14I,"J .. ,'� ; . . - ""t�,�,,,i�,!i,!;I�!�,,'i��l�",t:',�"l�,�,����"".-,,�,. A,I-1 I R ief" -gW2, - * �--- I 4 , fflWiitr�wil`A-At �11Y'111111--O-Tq 11 I-I,-,- -%- 1 4 '� ��v , , MAV! '�V, 4, - 1�11!�;f I I lV'r"y"', A I r "N", if , '. , ,� ; m fIR! l pyj ,� " 1 - , , - 'I, I Nvl-1 'I � Ir , ;iF,��v,l��fj��,��;�$�l�q�!�',�. l, fi;?". I � ........ � ,li, , ." 9� t .11, - ` ,j,i ZPW I I ,�I-va, , . M ttidfill ild .�-; I � wip 1, P, I , I !1�" ,,,r " - ; - Ii�i, lo'��",;,; jVIY,�-,ijI?jv"o-"�I`, ,-,'� 'Rj,,1��P,4- , MAN,�,i i,1--1 I . ., � I -l , L !I 'Al , �7i-,14 III-,It t 94."I I " - ,R, I w. - .:, p -1 I I vql,� 'I U-1- I ! 1, I, I ; , .1 I'll .? "I X�- 1-11.1 . IMW INAMmamm 11 T " .. l. �.I,- - - - I - � ,'', � - ��ti��`� /9/oi �Y"- ��-e� �— C�cl sly �- �' was Gy/ � ��9�"w "`oG� L, ZO �ZC.r/L . , - ° v , n �' , ° ., a •t °. ° �}� ryq . n l,e G�i., a '° , .tl ''ec b °y,•.r.e a o "" -�' v p T' r ° , ZZ r f .9; ,.. ...y.' °� .'� ." �'•' 'n'.' .�a a¢ ,° ar'_ .�a •A ,µ. '•paw b > a 10 Im qP 7 ° a ° � .�v..° 'fit°� 'r,rk.. r �, @. :v and a ., r � _ 0 7-.4 r � � - � � � � 4�.. a'.. ' � ''a q• �r� w �a r S H �f r r. -a-- elY ..'Yr. ��°! '� .: c9 (� o i v t ?` �'E ,.a•. °� ,. - 0 s e A Al •n- o,.. Q F v _ r ., ir�t •a y ,g a, ,. ' �, ' :°�v ' '1 ry• ra. �i, � ;� �� :.r a, o Ita B .. " •3 � a - 9" �' � a r , ° ..pn' [ ° n ' a v J a if ,, , ..a. ', (i @ .,,rt,. �� v •+ ,ry riF✓, q. ,.r_ d� a 'J4a � •„hr r,, ,a P m ARM"r, j',..y 4 P°. ,. dQx.9� . @ m it v r61 r-. ., r y. •-'n., '' •. @ :� ,y , nr`: d° ° � � � kr'v x' +. a � 'v' -' , f t o v o, ibe aJ. ur.. +� '�i y� i,, - .. J" �' p cr•° .,9 a may• t y rdr� a� A r 0 4 P Jb`'+re, r � ' ".'° , ra rIt r ER r , p.,a7. ,�'. Mc'Cr", •G '.� 11 rr ay*,.o .r ,r'. rN } ,�. ❑ ."v 44, ,a q r. fJ. gar . c i -d' `. aa° �, p 5f y a a.t'. a `� o . ® `�.1.:d< to-t..9 �. '.n� 'aH.'a h� 6. ' a � r o a" 'i � ��" d ,"r.• .u p, "`9 r v �I •;, '.o' q a ,• y-', °' w fy ^' ..'}. kr B;�G.' ❑"Y�i� �_w .. o , • a, ' .•.� + a w n �', :Yv ,,� a,.. .err a .. Fi r. .• v .if op A Nh� a" ' 4'; .. . _ 4 „ 1' r7e i rFaY •, a �N m o G ,i m„' rr a " v .: 0 ' � O r a 6 u t.r ,: r ._ � p >•. n n�' m. i °. - �li@ a tea., a'� �T. �', �.,. .. y �i °�v t, $' �,,. .. .. � .. r.. '.� :: ';m.' n" v @ fir. s' v"r r. r+o..° n�. ,•+' B a.w i - ° ^eb:.gF+..``��J'�°L d ,1 ;+r � '.�. nJl':, A G n fi .. • i '@ a'b.FT w� J � ,� !, •ee ,a� � a 6 � , . r-SY _'.o � =r n `° �..,� i J 4,. '' r � ..�, it if r. ,..,Jr, :r:' .,; a ,.' .r v ,, � ° ,. -.�. .F ,k �:h a� � a B "A i• ;a,- f, ti� �" .�d, `� �,, v. w r« ;� .a ,.., 'r< P.J'"-o 'n. '�' Q '� ,v n:,- +. .'p , •:° '�- r,,. '� • ,9r, " iNih.-'@ ,G�F a�` '4.' �`a�"- a` r9 rrlr � u'K "n `.t 6•.. �,__�. ��� •v ;�'_ ,. ,' � � y:: ���.'r� J.� a;. 4 � � �a 1 •,�, !J r"` r':, :,k i' ;.n ,n: " .tl c� �`a � a, � re,a , q° " r� ° :, 0 r ..,.{ -r 'r♦. ,,. P r . `a N ) �/'' `,tA. Ax 9 r y ° ?'. r',i° 'J4 2 . j v )q „, S' ,. 4 .r,., /J- tl. �. � l�4i .P. � :s° •;. rrV,' ,� + � � .. c ' r y a r a_d "3. eE ., n ° �;_ �; h r a. ° y " .'w.. 'F r-0i'r`f} 1'�ra a 1' -c� },1a� a •Q ,®' 1@p ._a 'g 'o,s po �;,.=5 n � ,. ,: " .'h/ 4 v rl a-. a 3,r�"„ y ,.r. - i• a:,. ,4r. ^� v 'r r, a.` ':'r tt,n " r ,. , ;a ,, err r 4.¢.`. �',',. ..� ':�;, t i �•u,y r'6 ..1, p°.. .rS " �r a. 'E,° a l' i ,,. 'i' cL "l,. 4.. _ a, .N. Aar ,i. � ,® 5�,,� F rn4:. r 'r74', •43f� ,,�vi 1'..: r r' N :.rs vi., .AL,� ,yr.�o u: �� r�s 'y a ./�••.F'.y ',?4r''x, 'r �.� a�d` r! :��b r� 1a i` r n,. ,.,[e,,,:, � �,>p: - '��.„�, ,r,p'&; C 'r ,. ,:�•i'.� „ -': {I, ,• ,3�.!a,r.:..:, "t•3, :,`'r h ,',¢:. e a o„r.'':;a. s-: eTau.- „ , ....i':. .�..,.r :.♦.. ..+'_ ,° oc..�°..p,l,.a, a,,.'k a+'d.r`rc`amti r@,fi" r— wau r..d: ` ,# t... r'tbd.�. nr�, r�..r"90.rI' :P:,C ,1%,. v "q, a .,t a .r tt. da. h<y... �.,:;.'rw;:..r �t'S y�: 'r`',rt,/7.w.�.4'�Wr •,rt@o,,rnr.rfXJd,"re'r'E e; •n A It� 5 av 'r' i m'� 0 5. p:' .}, a, 51.,, >r `Y i4, a w }� 'r '`e�"., .{F °•<a y r �B r Aw , 4 u ^ „ 4 r r qy ,'2fr ^' '�'r f• ®" •'�':�,.., s .,r r•,a n. q ,.' -. r'.�: :. ,: °- 'rr'�'Rryy a �.. ,�.. �:, ,. :,'.. J, r r..at:.".: ;. q�♦ ,^ '+ a 1¢� n�=� 'A:, � k. a`✓rr da o a o yp ,�3 'k',,, Y a m. ;�0 n�; ¢. .. 'n ., r v .,r T w�./ g f�tl' ,qa R Y �wd F✓� 'H !" �' a/,j� °' 9t. 6 , ,.. " '�_. _..° w' .-.-r.y' � + B .:.. '� ° ,. .,: � ° v "4,�� :fir Y s •.h, v,( �.• �r, v �r �s-J) f`q i° -$�� } .rr,v�F. t ruv a'.. '-A" � � 8;, a }$"4' '� +�' _ ?t• � .r „H: c a. w ° ` a y rd" ,. s.d r "E ,. ,r 7r. "rrr- .p'r ,g a �, .e?p', r, ., t.,' ° _ M,t :'e� a .$ nr, �,_• °y,.. ,, .." ,,. •� . �.1.Yr ,, ,", �r �,r::,' .a n r, a e o v.a a° a `.R .. q v+i �'' •q,�s d,'. a . om°' 'a�R d � � ., 'f,. .a �, .. s � q a q�I,` �•° �°,. . . !; r en �a ., :,ra .r+ '" ,- >-_ - v, 'rP,,. °v• 'i: .., •;d® .,�1 ....a <� �,k. ".° �r..r,,1 .. _J -.d'�La a @. °tar sd� fir. v .. •t:�Yl,. o ;9fy ,�r:, a' . .. Jry' ���� 9 r'q°.,�{"w° a p M• �p .�•.¢° h^ "� ° a. [, .. t Y F39 r`m ar,,,'v,' •r"'y. if' "t�°y d'� - .©' a' %` �.y: 9II ;. iY - ^'N' '.f.r+lrr r. :y.; _ I' �,Y ai�"6 rA'. Pr. ; ..•,a q o _N19"T "e 9 P• fs °r. r rya.. r r .,J,,.� *" ;''Q _� ;'H' '". ,.' 'v °.° 9,v •f}.' �r ;a4, .,,d - - b, f1:�e a., •sr �' ,.rA. ! @ ,4r 6 P'w IG + °' " F, `i:•n � n o-, � ., r°. if Yls@„ � >m h a� a c='• el ° J' ,.. .x t •, ,� 'e a ,,. i q a � q,,�' ' ,p °'g:a �t' �,. ,• o r N a. ':ti J ',T' ' u,. � 'f°°� ,it ae.��. .� ' v i r� . � ` W P,# n ��• i, O . .. :;y.�a '"aY' °.,n r� v` °"o �1 • : uRwsres A MA88. 9.1 • S 2: Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals Decision and Notice Appeal2001-105 - Sanborn Appeal of the Building Commissioner Summary: Upheld Building Commissioner Petitioner: James M. Sanborn Property Address: 122 White Oak Trail,Centerville MA Assessor's Map/Parcel: Map 192,Parcel 198 Zoning: Residential C and Resource Protection Overlay District Relief Requested&Background The applicant is appealing the Building Commissioner's issuance of a June 01,2001,order to cease and desist. The order alleges that the applicant,James M. Sanborn is carrying on business activity within a residential zoning district. According to the Building Division files,the question of the business use of the property dates back to March of • 1998. At that time,complaints were made to both the Building Division and Health Division claiming a number of commercial type barbeques and cookers were parked in and around the garages. The complaints were investigated,and the applicant.responded noting that he would reduce the number to one—his personal cooker. Complaints continued and during the year 2000,three separate complaints were received and investigated by the Building Division. Three commercial cookers were noted as being on the property. On May 21,2001,another Complaint Inquiry by the Building Division ruled that it was a"business operating in a residential zone". Pictures were taken showing at least three,perhaps as many as five commercial cookers in the garage area of the home. On May 31,2001,the Building Division wrote to Mr. Sanborn citing the violation of zoning and included the June 01,2001 order to cease and desist. Procedural&Hearing Summary: This appeal was filed at the Town Clerk's Office and at the Office of the'Zoning Board of Appeals on June 22, 2001. An extension of time for holding the hearing and for filing of the decision was executed between the applicant and the Board. A public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals was duly advertised and notice sent to all abutters in accordance with MGL Chapter 40A. The hearing was opened September 19,2001,at which time the Board found to uphold and reaffirm the Building Commissioners decision. Board Members deciding this appeal were Gail Nightingale,Richard L.Boy,Ralph Copeland,Jeremy Gilmore, and Chairman,Ron S.Jansson. Attorney Mark H.Boudreau represented Mr.James Sanborn who was also present during the hearing. Mr. Boudreau stated that Mr. Sanborn is not running a business and that the two large commercial cookers on the property were for his personal use..The Board noted that Mr. Sanborn has a truck with lettering advertising the • business. They discussed the number of cookers on the property. The Board stated that this was not a J•/f li • customary home out-door cooking equipment,but was being used for a business. The health dept staff inspection report was also cited. Mr.Boudreau submitted to the file two letters of support. They were from Skiff Greene and Dale Bishop, Norton,MA. The public was invited to comment and testify. Mike Murphy,a neighbor,supported the petitioner and stated that he did not think it was a business use. Helen Kenney stated Mr. Sanborn is employed with Southern Pride, as a salesman and distributor of the commercial cookers. He demonstrates the use of the equipment and it is moved many times a week for that purpose. Phil Haggerty stated that there are as many as seven units at any . time and that they are moved on average six or seven times a month. He submitted photos taken in February 2000. Mr.Vagts read a letter stating that the property was being used as a commercial property. Mr.Boudreau stated that he had made a site visit and that there were two pieces of equipment on the property today. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of September 19,2061,the Board unanimously found the following findings of fact: 1. James M. Sanborn has appealed the June 1, 2001 order of the Building Commissioner to cease and desist the storing,garaging and keeping of commercial business equipment as it is in violation of Section 3-1.3, Principal and Conditional Uses and Section 4-1.1 Accessory Uses of the Zoning Ordinance. The property is shown on Assessors Map 192 as Parcel 198. It is addressed 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville MA and is • located in a Residential C Zoning District. 2. The applicant has been storing large commercial barbeque equipment in his yard for several years. The equipment being stored on the property is not found in most homes. It is commercial equipment that is not customary found in single-family homes. The size of the equipment is not incidental nor is it accessory to the residential use. 3. "The equipment is in fact, accessory to the business activity that the applicant is carrying on in his home. The storage of that equipment on the property is not permitted under Section 4-1.4 of the Zoning Ordinance that regulates Home Occupations. 4. The predominate use in this Residential C Zoning District is single-family dwellings. It is the only principal use permitted as-of-right. 5. "New England Barbecue/Southern Pride"is listed in the Business Listings of the Hyannis Area July 2001 phone book.The listing did not give a street address but did note Centerville.The phone number given for that business was 508-775-1920. That phone number is the exact phone number listed on the Zoning Board Application submitted by the applicant on June 22,2001. The company is also listed under Restaurant Equipment and Supplies. Decision: Based on the findings of fact,a motion was duly made and seconded to affirm and uphold in full the decision of the Building Commissioner as stated in his June 1,2001 cease and desist order issued to Mr.James M. Sanborn. The vote was as follows: • 2 j • AYE: Gail Nightingale,Richard L.Boy,Ralph Copeland,Jeremy Gilmore,Ron S.Jans son NAY: None Ordered: In Appeal 2001-105 the Board has upheld the decision of the Building Commissioner. Appeals of this decision,if any,shall be made pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A,Section 17,within twenty(20) days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Id�oT� Ron S.Jansso , man Date Signed I,Linda Hutchenrider,Clerk of the Town of Barnstable,Barnstable County,Massachusetts,hereb-y certify that twenty(20) days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that rid ap jieal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Signed and sealed this(�O day of a& Ainder-Aw^pains an pena4ti�s of per),aq Linda Hutchenrider,Town Clerk • 3 `t LAW OFFICES OF PHILIP M. BOUDREAU 396 NORTH STREET HYANNIS,MASSAGHUSETTS 02601 (508)775-1085 TELEFAX(508)771-0722 PHILIP M. BOUDREAU PHILIP MICHAEL BOUDREAU October 22 , 2001 MARK H.BOUDREAU Peter F. Di Matteo Building Inspector' s Office 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 Re: James M. Sanborn - 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville Dear Mr. Di Matteo: As a 'follow-up to our recent meeting at your office, and in light of the hearing on September 18 , 2001, my client is agreeable to the following conditions relative to his residence at 122 White Oak Trail in Centerville: ( 1) He shall remove all commercial barbeque equipment/smokers, with the exception of the Southern Pride unit currently on a trailer. This unit shall be moved to the back yard and enclosed in a temporary garage-type structure not located within the rear or sideline setback appurtenant to the residential "C" District. (2 ) t This single unit shall be for his personal use so that no business activity is associated with it at the residential site. ( 3 ) Further, Mr. Sanborn agrees not to have barbeque "smokeouts" with his friends, whether or not they are entirely for private non-business purposes. (4 ) As he has done previously, Mr. Sanborn will not demonstrate his unit at his house or cook any food for eventual sale there. Peter F. Di Matteo - 2 - October 22 , 2001 I believe this constitutes our discussion and agreement relative to the October 2 , 2001 meeting at your office. If I have mis-stated anything, please contact me immediately so that this may be rectified. Sincerely, ; Mark H. Boudreau MHB:kb cc: James M. Sanborn �' �' i a �+ ;!� x� x �' �', �'" r r;I v� � i r*K �7 a' � ��." R � �� >rv� L � _ 4 I ` 1l�.2:ti`� � i >st -.�� ''�.. � .�;- �y',�. �� � f9 . (l l QdJ —�`` / � r L ' � � � � j "a�•*A� may. <t� s,'v ' +, r, `.s � -'- .:y , t .wk,4 Yj M /nI �}/� V✓� NAME ❑ BUY ❑ RENT ADDRESS DATE 0 1 HOME PHONE t Q BUS.ADDRESS. BUS.PHONE CASH DOWN PRICE RANGE MONTHLY PAYMENTS GI FHA COW TYPE OF HOUSE DESIRED ROOMS NEEDED BEDROOMS NEEDED Q SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS Q ► Q � PRESENT HOME INCOME OCCUPATION ' ❑OWN ❑RENT Q HEARD OF US FROM SALESPERSON PRODUCT 146 NEBS,INC.,ORDER TOLL FREE 1-800-225-6380 RECORD OF PROPERTIES SHOWN OR SUBMITTED TO THIS PROSPECT DATE ADDRESS BY - REMARKS NAME ❑ BUY ❑ RENT ADDRESS DATE 13 HOME PHONE BUS.ADDRESS BUS.PHONE CASH DOWN PRICE RANGE MONTHLY PAYMENTS GI FHA CONY. TYPE OF HOUSE DESIRED ROOMS NEEDED BEDROOMS NEEDED SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS O PRESENT HOME INCOME OCCUPATION t ❑OWN ❑RENT HEARD OF US FROM SALESPERSON PRODUCT 141 NEBS,INC.,ORDER TOLL FREE 1-800-225-6380 RECORD OF PROPERTIES SHOWN OR SUBMITTED TO THIS PROSPECT DATE ADDRESS BY REMARKS j y �* ht,itI� IFF�' f e g��)^gy,,,'�,"'��f?.��i�+f,7y�NM�f 1 �S k.q+ +� "•*�1�`� k ,�1$ 7! � � � •S�y.�' T4�'" � 4��i.%h '"4'o;�J�l py,�Yry 1'!b' �T�•: `` F '—�,� .. �a� , mot tt e VL42 4j g. v e� r" `. �e yY�'F•,r�.�. �«� .'� S " '4 � - � r✓ 'fix �3t � � '` �4 f r T .k r - � s { {``, '__ _�`{ { - -•.-__-�_ 'ems-�'!"-"_-_ -.+__ I •`._. �� - 2500-Pw y *M Amsterdam,NY 12010 oz`eworth Town of Barnstable oFT"E lA'+, Regulatory Services ti Thomas F.Geiler,Director " B" MASS.`�' ` Building Division 9 MASS. 0q .4i639 10 39 Tom Perry Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 COMPLAINUINQUIRY REPORT Date. f Rec'd by: Complaint Name d►�� Gl�'�,ov-v� Map/Parcel 2 - Location 1 I , Address:/-2Z C�)h� �� n� �Y'o,, Originator Name: L V Street. Village& L f State: Zip: Telephone: 1'19- P- 12 Complaint Description.�� Q Oc, =i 0 FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Inspector's Action/Comments Date: Co-24—03 Inspector: l� ,J RCS Additional Info.Attached ( Town of Barnstable ZHE Regulatory Services , Thomas F.Geiler,Director BARNSTABM MAW.MAW. Building Division �10tFp r�p�s Tom Perry Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 COMPLAINVINQUIRY REPORT Dater©-2.?—'0 'Z Rec'd by: Complaint Name: mc S Sa n to C),�-y J Map/Parcel 1 9 2. ) �PL Location (( _ f Address: / 2 2- (,2 )(l t - � 0 Q� Ty oL i C-TK, Originator Name: OVr, c4 ni bu S _ Street: Village: State: Zip: Telephone: Complaint Description: a ey 0 e Vvt�'�'( 0-V C'1 uJ GY en o FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Inspector's Action/Comments Date:�U.'2 / — G Z Inspector: 4A aP4-;Z4Ji2 S e v,y e C� 1, � (?V- !/Yl C)U-n�C a r i a C I.,, -P Q V(Zrl � Additional Info.Attached Q:forms:complaint °FINE r Town of Barnstable � ti Regulatory Services � r�IE� Thomas F.Geiler,Director i639. ♦0 p�EO r�a't A Building Division Tom Perry, Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 October 30,2002 Barnstable District Court Route 6A,Main St. Barnstable,MA 02630 Re:Town of Barnstable vs.Sanborn, 122 White Oak Tr.,Centerville,MA To Whom It May Concern: On Thursday,October 24,2002,the case of the Town of Barnstable vs.James Sanborn was heard before the clerk magistrate. We were informed,at the time,that we could appeal the decision. We would like to exercise this option and formally notify the court that we wish to appeal the court's decision. We look forward to hearing from you with a court date. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Thomas Perry Building Commissioner TP/AW ABLE Tom Perry ,k` Ss 10 S i Building Commissioner Town of Barnstable 200 Main Street 9i /15f0 Hyannis,MA 02601 / September 12,2002 Dear Commissioner Perry: As nearby neighbors to the residence of James Sanborn at 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville,we are again writing to register our protests regarding Mr. Sanborn's continuing violation of the Building Commissioner's ruling of June 01,2001 to cease and desist the storing, garaging, and keeping of commercial business equipment on his property. This decision was upheld by the Zoning Board of Appeals September 19,2001 in "" 0� findings of fact that clearly set forth Mr. Sanborn's use of his residence as a staging area for his business as a representative of Southern Pride, a manufacturer of industrial/commercial woodburning BBQ Pits and Smokers. It should be noted that the Appeal Board's,decision was made without restrictions, indicating that the decision of the Building Commissioner was fully affirmed and upheld as stated in his June 1,2001 cease and desist order. No appeal of the Board's decision was filed within the 20 days pursuant to MGL Ch 40A, Section 17. It is worth noting that complaints about commercial type barbeques and cookers parked in and around the Sanborn garages are long standing,dating back as far as March 1998. Now, more than a year later, we must act again in the face of Mr. Sanborn's continued violation of the zoning regulations in a Residential C Zoning district. Commercial equipment is apparently stored in a large structure that was put up without, as we understand it,a building permit. Mr. Sanborn is still in business with Southern Pride with a local telephone listing under New England Barbecue/Southern Pride. A large smoker unit appears periodically and for several days or weeks at a time parked in front of the Sanborn house. An extremely large carnival type mobile restaurant appears for several days at a time, is moved,and then reappears. For months a white commercial van was parked to the right of the house throughout the fall and the winter. At this writing the mobile restaurant has been there over the weekend. For the Appeal Board and the magistrate hearing this case,we want it to be clearly understood our position is (1)that the September 19,2001 ruling of the Appeals Board be fully upheld which states that no commercial equipment be stored on the Sanborn property(2) that we have not made and will not make any agreement with Mr. Sanborn for any modification of that decision, (3)that Mr. Sanborn's contention that a single smoker is maintained for his recreational use only is entirely without credibility. Clearly, he is conducting an individual business (not a franchise) as a representative of Southern Pride in Massachusetts and most of New England from his residence. His job as representative entails demonstrating models of these commercial cookers which are purchased through Southern Pride that handles billing and shipping. A representative's primary job is sales. Finally,we feel we have reached the limits of our frustration tolerance. Four years of living with this problem are more than enough. Thank you for communicating our concerns and positions to the Zoning Board of Appeals and the magistrate of the Barnstable District Court hearing this case. If we can be of further help in these proceedings, please get in touch with us. °FVKKUE ti Town of Barnstable ' 20Regulatory ServicesBMWSTABLE J g y 9 MAW. Thomas F.Geiler,Director �p �6g9. ♦� TE1639. A Building Division, Tom Perry, Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 -May 20,2002 Law Offices of Philip M.Boudreau Mark Boudreau 396 North St. Hyannis,MA 02601 Re:James M.Sanborn,122 White Oak Trail,Centerville,MA Dear Mark: Thanks for coming to discuss the on-going matter with Mr. Sanborn's BBQ cooking. As we discussed in the office I have to disagree with what Mr.DiMatteo allowed to take place after the Zoning Board turned this gentleman's appeal down. The Zoning Board denied to overturn the Building Commissioner's decision of June 01,2001 to cease and desist. This was done without restrictions and the decision of September 19, 2001 "was duly made to affirm and uphold in full the decision of the Building Commissioner as stated in his June 01,2001 cease and desist order.',' I must agree with the Zoning Board and hereby order that all items connected with the operation be removed from the premises by June 01,2002. Failure to comply with this order could result in daily fines. Again,thank you for coming in to discuss this with me. If we can be of further assistance feel free to contact this office Sincerely, P4Perry p Building Commissioner, m E TP/AW I LAW OFFICES Of - PHILIP M. BOUDREAUr 396.NORTH STREET HYANNIS;MASSACHUSETTS 02601 4 Telephone:(508)775-1085 ',Telefaz:(508).771=0722" Philip M.Boudreau, Philip Michael Boudreau _ - _ Mark H.Boudreau - _ - December 12; 2001 - - -. Peter F. Di Matteo _ Building Inspector's Office# :F 367 Main Street _ . E �. r _ e Hyannis, MA 02601 . r RE: James M. Sanborn 7122 White Oak Trail, Centerville Dear Mr. Di Matteo: As a follow-up to telephone inquiries from-you office,please be advised of the following: 1. My client has finally registered the large',.whitetrailer that was situated at his property located at 122 White Oak Trail,Centerville. I have attached a copy of the registration with the letter. - 2. He continues to-abide by the October,22, 2001 letter agreement by not having . barbeque smoke outs,at-his home, even if they are with his friends. 3. Further to that letter agreement;he has not demonstrated his unit at his borne or cooked any food for eventual sale there. ` ' 4.:As-per my statement to:your office:in the last week or two, Mr. Sanborn"§,garage type structure as arrived.. He,left a message with my office that the:garage structure-is complete and in the back yard., As per our,a reement ,his trailered Southern Pride,smoke unit is to be store&in _ this,garage structure,.which is to be located I it the back of his property and riot visiblefrom the street. He left a message that he will.be'away on business for several'days 1was not=able,to ask` him if he has in fact moved the unit into the garage,but will advice once I contact him or have the occasion to drive by his home.: , Peter F.Di Matteo - Building Inspector - a December 12, 2001 �. Page Two ; 5.-I believe the only remaining issue, therefore,-is the other smoker located to'the rear of his property to the.left side, which Mr. Sanborn has covered tightly with a tarp. -Re has advertised this unit for sale and to date has received an inquiry from a deer processing plant, = which would like'to purchase the unit in the Spring.,: I-understand that your office continues to receive regular complaints about the condition _ of Mr. Sanborn's property. I believe.that Mr. Sanborn has made the appropriate efforts to comply with the Town's wishes, albeit in a slowed and delayed manner: Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sincerely, Mark H. Boudreau} MHB/HCG_ M _ Enclosure a i1-2 SHE Tp� The Town of Barnstable r � r + SARNSTABLE, 9 MASS. Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services �p 1639. TEo Mn'�" Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-790-6227 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner March 20, 1998 Dear Councilor Elrich: Attached is a letter that will explain what happened on White Oak Trail. As you can see,he will be bringing the site into a more acceptable state soon. I'll keep YOU informed. Sincerely, Ralph Crossen Building Commissioner RC:Ib g980320c 1 , ���liorr�it✓yam 6ancein. .�arvtcl� life to-Go��ozeita���tsi.�.�t��cf�eu�t�aru�v�lo�ra� �G"aiu.���G'���ro'i��'��uG a►itA Oat—na o� �ev�mdsaywylz� m�y ay�,mdyar&W&4wy,&W V e!uv' rrL corutei�atior� �o taro.gee rru�y l ew�errb Gewa cif'tie,wa&al/3lwM•n min&v&someone awdd Aave,sad&vnedzy c&ec*to u&. Y eoer��a,cl6ece tali to-t/e ac�oe•�t .rtree��f onv u��� ,Tei��elserLJ Jlze carn�oue�-url�ile�a�urc��i�o��r�aru�a►a�a��me aGou.�� GarGe 15e Ywa&1w1Aa#,�ty to-yal al cliarwc&to-talk A&a►w de tiro& a+eOvA&w,del te��t/aa t!e arr�e arul,�lure�laere, �/fio�a�Ga�i��.,eaL �assiort-o�fm�c�aul��,z��tcu�to-ar�r�o�r.�a►lio-uiilGl�ste� Jl��� arl�en�.rl�/f aiul sai�s/e�f xuul it uu�n�e ,f��t or.�can.Free, �a,�or��lurve a./5,^c�e�wit/L aiu�� t/za,�,��.rr� altlux�ute leave aye Have laa�to-to%nt�a�art/terL j5��tie�tilLalGliou� �z,a�rtirt�urlre�/��o�/laau�wweate�i�tl�.�t�ee�a if trash arul so 6eer�Gortlee on,our-lwwj i ae d,& to-Vlwe,i,,-i&u .Guy��lob a►o�s� �c�carrce lae�e severnLa�ee�e� ���te�u�c�r�ors ct�rn�.rorL Gad rru�y Gac� �rol .�f o�rL u ,`fir u��� i2 9Ju liar lieeiL Gotl�` ,`�wilGlwall al Glue orL ct pro-rto-ore cam see��hour, arul ae�e ureatl��ete Getter; ,�a►ilL�/'icislG Itl so-rny.roiL cart lue Ga d �/aave�Grairc�raeur GarG'�ecue�ai�. ,/��/�erul����t!e old ort� Gu.�lze carp�take cb . al wole,oolm w� Yam az,tleAroce OlMaAV,W1 room 41&' �to aiul ae %Plww tkz(, �a►ilL lucre the once outs�o�� cvilGato-.ro-a,��roo� ��o�riGl� �a��j� �y woe laad the lw&three eealwl woe l��irae�ay�,�`���iyu�`, ✓�,ler��.ce� atlaere.r�e uror�e a�Jtw • ���� Jlelaaelze�-lo�rre sa/ea�tle�ealto� Ge ywff f lter lurrl tune a. ' lte.�not` ei "tstea °f*u,wl tlia the m&/e'rc& k,,qA �•n s!e'lGcalG�roorL f aru�y tlirrt�elre.� cart do-griuoaa MVIIe dIZ7,/a#b"to co �e�at� o�'nee./ll. Jaraliorn 122 VA6(e OA 9i-ad 6'eretuurlle I % Y o [EgEWR JUN 22 2001 / t m TOWN OF BARNSTABL ZONING BOARD OF APPEAL TOWN OF,BARNSTADLE Zoning Board of Appeals Application for Other Powers Date Received roftke use only: Town Clerk's Office: Appeal a �-14 Hearing to Dedslon Due The undersigned hereby applies to the Zoning Board of Appeals for the reasons Indicated: r ' Applicant Name: JAMES ,M. SANBORN 508-775-1920 Phone: . Applicant Address: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL CENTERVILLE Property Location: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL, CENTERVILLE Property Owner. JAMES M. SANBORN Phone: 508-775-1920 Address of Owner: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL CENTERVILLE Assessor's Map/Pan:ei Number:, 19 2/19 8 Zoning District: RC Groundwater Overlay District: This Is a request for. [ ] Enforcement Action (X] Appeal of Administrative Official's Decision l Other General Powers -Please Specify: Which Section(s)of the Zoning Ordinance and/or MGL Chapter 40A are you appealing to the Zoning Board of Appeals? SECTION 4-1 . 1 OF THE TOWN OF._-BARNSTABLE ZONING ORDINANCE & SECTION 3-1 . 3 OF, THE TOWN OF BARNSTABLE ZONING ORDINANCE Nature of Appeal & Description of Request: A PPEALING THE NOTI CE OF ORDINANCE VIOLATION AND ORDER TO CEASE, DESIST AND ABATE ISSUED AGAINST HIM ON JUNE 1 2001 ) A COPY OF WHICH IS ATTACHED Attach Additional Sh"I ifNecemly 9��6br;93C-03TF bT:TT T00�./3T/9A { Application for Other Powers•Pape 2 Existing Level of Development of the Property-Number of Buildings: Present Use(s): Gross Floor Area: sQ Is the property located in a designated Historic District?..................................................... Yes[ ] No It yes ( ] -Old King's Highway Regional Historic District Date Approved(If applicable) [ ]-Hyannis Main Street Waterfront Historic District Date Approved(if applicable) Is the building a designated Historic Landmark?....................................................... ....... Yes [ ) No[)q Have you applied fora building permit?.......... . .................................................................. Yes [ ) No W Have you been refused a building permit?................... ............._........... ....................yes[ ] No W The following information. as applicable,should be submitted with the application at the time of filing. Failure to do so may result In a denial of your request. • Three(3)copies of.the completed application form,each with original signatures. • Three(3)copies of a certified property survey(plot plan)and one(1)reduced copy(81/2'x 11"or 11"x 1 r)showing the dimensions of the land,all wetlands,water bodies,surrounding roadways and the location of the existing improvements on the land. Three(3)copies of a proposed site Improvement plan and one(1)reduced copy(8 1/2-x 11"or 11-x in • The applicant may submit any additional supporting documents to assist the Board In making its determination. signature. � � Date: June AppJkant's or Rese gative's Slgnstum 1A1�r I G O�t �V ai �7 !S Representative's i� S , Phone. Address: 7 Fax No.: /�D2 b0 �J�d 9G6PZ93Z03T6 tT:TT 1007/3T/90 Property Location: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL MAPID: 192/198/// Vision ID 13743 Other ID Bldg# 1 Card 1 of :08/15/2001 �•�����.�,.:t�r.�,.�C�ILItEN�TO.��Xt ., , ' �' M����..�f)_ ,��"._�Ia '.�.T;;S�_�,l„��1���,� vE �,...,� d' ,. ;:• r�' � ':, , `� PrantDate ANBORN,JAMES M&BONNIE J 1 evel Public Watea Paved Description \ Code Appraised Value Assessed Value_ 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL as ES LAND 1010 52,600 52,600 CENTERVILLE MA 02632 eptzc SIDNTL 1010 ' SIDNTL 1010 128,600 128,600 801 500 500 Barnstable 2001,MA ccount# 118161 Plan Ref. ax Dist. 300 Land Ct# er.Prop. #SR Life Estate DL 1 LOT34 Notes: VISION 2 GIS ID Rig Total 181,700 181,700 ANBORN,TAMES M&BONNIE J C115327 09/15/1988 Y BROWN,DAVID B&NANCY P C79281 08/15/1979 Q 180,000 Yr. Code Assessed Value Yr. Code Assessed Value Yr. Code Assessed Value Q 9,500 2000 1010 36,500 999 1010 36,500 998 1010 2000 1010 90,700 999 1010 90,700 998 1010 36,500 2000 1010 300 999 1010 300 998 1010 90,700 300 Total 127,500 Total. 127 50 Total 127 50 '' „" OT ` -"" � r This signature acknowledges a visit by a Data Collector or Assessor 0 Year T e/Descri tion Amount Code Description Number Amount Comm.Int. 155 Appraised Bldg.Value(Card) 120 700 Tonal Appraised XF Value Bldg) ;.� . _�f7TnS.��.,. Appraised A 7,900 *9/89 EST NO BLA Appraised Land Value(Bldg) 500 Special Land Value 52,600 Total Appraised Card Value '181,700 . Total Appraised Parcel Value Valuation Method: 181,700 Cost/Market Valuation et Total Appraised Parcel Value ,700 B30204 Amount Ins .Date /o Com . Date Com PermitlD Issue Date I• e� � ,:� -,�,,,, .,. r � .` °..i, " ' '°,.." Descri tion -�� �-�" r 11/14/1999 WD ood Deck � Comments RYA 11/1/1986 AD 2,300 1/l/2000 100 1/1/2000 Date ID Ca. Pur ose/Result 25,000 1/15/1988 100 CE GARAGE 1/24/2000 PT 00 eas/Listed 1/13/2000 MF 40 idg Permit N/C 9/15/1989 ME B# Use Code Descri iron Zone D ronta e Units F 1 1010 Ingle Fain RC 3 Unit Price 1 Factor S.I. C.Factor Nbad Ad'. Notes Ad/S eczal Priem ,Ad Unit Price 1 0.62 AC 131,000.00 1.00 5 Land Value 1.00 37AC 0.65 PC L(.62,U10)Notes:lO1BLD 84,919.25 52,600 Total Card Land Units U.021 Aul Parcel To Land Area: 0.62 AC Property Location: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL MAP ID: 192/198/ Vision ID:13743 Other ID: Bldg#: 1 Card 1 of 1 Print Date: 08/15/2001 Element Cd. Ch. Description Commercial Data Elements tyle/Type 8 aised Ranch Element Cd. Ch. Description odel 1 esidential eat&AC DK rade C verage Grade tame Type g.5 aths/Plumbing 24 2 44 tories 1 1 Story ccupancy 0 eiling/Wall BAS ooms/Prtns BMT 11 xterior Wall 1 14 ood Shingle !o Common Wall 2 5 inyl Siding' all Height 12 oof Structure 3 Gable/Hip FAT FOP 12 BAS oof Cover 3 sph/F GIs/Cmp 4 GAR 2 12 6 BMT 2 nterior Wall 1 5 rywall lement ode escription actor 2 nterior Floor 1 14 Carpet dj 2 lootoor Ad 24 nit Location 44 eating Fuel 3 Gas US 44 . eating Type 5 of Water umber of Units 2 C Type 1 one umber of Levels /o Ownership edrooms 4 Bedrooms athrooms Bathrooms �, CQ „ :-'' T .: W , 0 Full Unadj.Base Rate 0.00 Total Rooms b Rooms Size Adj.Factor 1.00919 Grade(Q)Index 1.01 Bath Type Nbhd Adjustment 61.16 Kitchen Style Adj.Base Rate 129,782 Bldg.Value New 1980 Year Built A)1988 ff.Year Built 12 rml Physcl Dep uncnl Obslnc fAri .M . IV1I,Y. lfrSEE con Obslnc da ppsrrintinn rce t w = pecl.Cond.Code 1010 Single Fam 100 pecl Cond% 93 Overall /o Cond. eprec.Bldg Value 120,700 o� B rrILvrluclt�n� Code Description LIB I Units Unit Price Yr. D.Rt %Cnd Apr. Value SHED Shed L 64 8.00 1990 0 100 500 BFA Bsrnt Fin-Aver B 600 15.00 1988 1 100 7,900 s DGCIB� 5 s1VtARY�S&EIF1{, Code Descri tion I Livinje Area Gross Area Ef fArea Unit Cost Unde rec:Value BAS First Floor 1,276 1,276 1,276 61.16 78,040 BMT Basement Area 0 1,276 255 12.22 15,596 FAT Attic,Finished 288 576 288 30.58 17,614 FOP Open Porch 0 48 10 12.74 612 FUS Upper Story 88 88 88 61.16 5,382 GAR Attached Garage 0 576 202 21.45 12,354 WDKWood Deck 0 30 3 6.12 183 11. Gross Livlfease Area 1 652 3 870 2 122 [ — 129,782 i203 AW 192 #79 MAP 192 - - - #253 + OF 192 195 W 192143 (` 109 t ? NAP192 ' W192 /? MAP #10 i j { #201 J03't2 �W / AWIR . AIAP 192 , 1 5 1 194 i t p #236 #1 41 IMP 192 / ----- I 1 - -- - 144229 t MAP 19215 / / A110 AWAIn MAP192 1 - - 0 1 I 200 MAP192 #© 1 #770 ' 919 19 #188 1 14 1 �AU1Pt ` , l #151 r #139 I - 153 f 1 —� -- #216 AW 1 1'~ 20 \ /1 MAP 192 j MAP 192 --., #867 199 146 ' Y #1T4 #209 MAP192 154 tq4= ; MAP 192 MAP 192 95 ) 4�� � �� �� $ — gp 1 r.fb6Pcl , � win INAP l92 #36 - ' 155 #ns i � � "� 147 #52 MOONFENNY LANE / I1� MAP C7 NAP191 14 $ 550 cke . #to #1, 7 57 191 MAr 19t �� -- - Z�m s 9z, 56 t 1`_` 147 MAP 191 (j MAPt91 / a #.167 11 5#,o W191 58 # 70 22 191 i#es / #90 '`— #21 MAP191 _ 0 6 191 W11 14657 —� #20 #84 #160 MAP 141 (l MAPt91 f \ — __ 23 52 t #31 III MAP 191 _F --` - Al 191 NAPl91 O 1 145 153 —�,.._ _ 1 MI5 #147 1 #15a r MAR191 24 NAP191 49 f. MAP 191 / #41 1 bi %+ MAP191 i #64 #7p 1 144 1 f 541 .., it Q41 i ; Appeal #2001-105 MAP- 192 -PARCE L 198 - SANBORN W to E ' Centerville SCALE: 1"=150' S *NOTE: Planimetdlx,topography,and **NOTE:The parcel lines are only graphic representations DATA SOUR(ES: Planimetrics(man-made features)were interpreted from 199S aerial photograph by The James vegetation were mapped to meet National of property boundaries They are not hue lomtions,and W.Sewall Company. Topography and vegetation were interpreted from 1989 aerial photographs by GEOD Map Acalmcy Standards of a scale of do not represent actual relationships to physical objects Corporation. Planimetrica,topography,and vegetation were mapped to meet National Map.Accuracy Standards P=`Iff. on the map. at a scale d V=I00'. Parcel lines were digitized from 2000 Town of Barnstable Assessor's tax mops p:\microbeth\zoning\192-198.dgn 08/15/2001 08:04:49 AM THE FOLLOWING IS/ARE THE BEST IMAGES FROM POOR QUALITY ORIGINAL (S) v I 'C�� I /r \('- L DATA Ha ao a .0 30. 33 »�N y m ....9 a Town of Barnstable �olao; d T 0� �T 26 m amm m m Regulatory Services Thomas F. Geiler,Director. Oo m C Building Division Elbert C Ulshoeffer,Jr.,Building Comm' p ifp 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 p Y�9 Office: 508-862-4038 r `c May 31,2001 James M Sanborn 122 White Oak Trail Centerville,MA 02632 RE: 122 White Oak Trail,Centerville Dear Mr.Sanborn: I have read the file relating to the complaints of operating a business from your.premises at 122 White Oak Trail. Your house is located in an RC residential zone,as such the storing,keeping,garaging of equipment for business purposes is not a permitted accessory use under the provisions of section 4-1.1 of the Town of Barnstable Zoning ordinance. In order to continue to store/garage commercial equipment i.e.smokers, you will need to obtain a variance from the above section granted by the Zoning Board of Appeals. Enclosed please find notice of violation and order to desist and abate. Sincerely, Elbert Ulshoeffe Building Commissioner ;; SENDER: wish to receive the also ■Complete items 1 and/or 2 for additional services. I lso H ■Complete items 3,4a,and 4b. g services(for an t) ■Print your name and address on the reverse of this form so that we can return this extra fee): EU/er card to you. i ■Attach this Corm to the front of the mailpiece,or on the back if space does not 1.❑ Addressee's Address y permit. ■Write"Return Receipt Requested'on the mailpiece below the article number. 2.❑ Restricted Delivery t ■The Return Receipt will show to whom the article was delivered and the date ' certification#7000 0520 0021 821 delivered. Consult postmaster for fee. o 3.Article Addressed to: 4a.Article Number E / Z Z WI � ©A-A- 7�Q�Y!L 4b.Service Type — °o , ❑ Registered elcl rtified r C�i/✓ iCilff II / /(/ �3 ❑ Express Mail ❑ Insured / ' ❑ Retum Receipt for K:lerchandise ❑ COD cc 7.Date of eli ery 5. Received By: (Print Name) 8.Addre see's Address(Only if requested and fee is paid) 6. Sign t e: (Addressee or Agent) F o T g010529a " PS 811, December 1994 102595-98-a-0229 Domestic Return Receipt i - Regulatory Services. Thomas F.Geiler,Director 0IKEok- ti Building Division L Elbert C Ulshoeffer,Jr. Building Commissioner wexsr�tE. � 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 ' t639• ♦0 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 Notice of Zoning Ordinances Violation(s) and Order to Cease; Desist and Abate: Mr.James M.Sanborn and all persons having notice of this order. As owner/occupant of.the premises/structure located at 122 White Oak Trail,Assessor's Map 192 Parcel 198,you are hereby notified that you are in violation of the Town of Barnstable Zoning Ordinances and are ORDERED this date,June 1,2001 to: DIATELY,all functions connected with this violation on or at the above CEASE AND DESIST IMME mentioned premises. SUMMARY OF VIOLATION: ' Storing,garaging/keeping commercial business equipment is a violation of section 3-1.3 and 4-1.1 of the zoning ordinance. COMMENCE within seven(7)days,action to abate this violation. SUMMARY OF ACTIOMTO.ABATE: Remove all.commercial equipment relative to business barbecue(smokers)within 30 days of receipt of this notice. And,if aggrieved by this notice and order,to show cause as to why you should not be required to do so,by filing qfi appeal with the Town Clerk of Barnstable,a blice_ofAppeal.(specifying the ground thereof) within'thinY(30)days of the receipt of this order(in accordance with Cpter 40A Section 15 of the Massachusetts General Laws). If,at the expiration of the time allowed,action to abate this violation has not commenced,further action as the law requires will be taken. By order, uilding Commissioner Certified Mail 7000 0520 0021 82813636 R.R.R. g010531b I 5 U W EDy September 9, 2001 � SEP 11 2001 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE To the Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals: '�')NING B01Rn OF APPEALS There are a-few things that are of concern to me regarding the commercial business conducted at 122 White Oak Trail: a residential C Zoning District. 1. The ovens in question are used for preparing food. If not properly cleaned immediately after use the ovens could be a source for rodents searching for food. " 2. This kind of commercial equipment requires industrial cleansing, that increases risk of chemical run off into street and nearby storm drain. It also becomes a hazard for neighboring children and animals. 3. The ovens sitting in the yard have signs on them advertising what they are and the phone number of the company or owner,this could be a threat to property values. In closing commercialized equipment such as these ovens should not be on residential properly. Please continue to enforce"with the cease and desist the storing, garaging and keeping of commercial business equipment". Sincerely, arol B okman September 12,2001 /\ 4 S ; SEP 12 2001 Notice to the Board of Appeals TOWN OF BARNSTAB►_E Re: Sanborn Property, 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville,Ma, 02632;r)!I.'fNG BOARD OF APPEALS In May of 20011 went to the town hall to complain about the business being conducted at 122 White Oak Trail. My complaint was that there were several large cooking units stored in the yard. The person with whom I spoke checked map with this location on it and advised me that this location is residential and not zoned for business and no business request had been made of the zoning board;therefore, I am requesting again that this business and its cookers be removed and not allowed to be stored on this property. Several pictures were presented to the office showing all these cookers that were stored at 122 White Oak Trail. Sin ely, Philip ag erty 73 White Oak Trail Centerville,MA 02632 I f - - - - — - -- -- - ti _LQILI N-Q.F BARNSTABLE �MING BOARD OF APPEALS �__� N. _2�l i►l — _---R,�,,------�-- ---�--z--- PkV RA Yi— --------- - -- �c�.<<.�.'�_�..._�� 3sz R�E ' ^ f _...cn ' =.::. . -- Q _ .-z SQ.N ...__._�. 5_ca, ,- .--------- ' .. i i W s it} .� SEA 1 12001 TOWN OF BARN-STABLE '�)1MING BOARD OF APPEAL,- Ron S.Jansson, Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals 367 Main St. Hyannis,MA 02601 Dear Mr. Jansson: We are writing to fully support the order of the Building Commissioner directing James M. Sanborn "to cease and desist the storing, garaging, and keeping of commercial business equipment" at his residence at 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville. For the past several years we have had to endure daily the sight of as many as four and five large( and very large) pieces of commercial barbecue/ smokers (see Attachments) parked directly in front of the Sanborn house as we come and go from our residence directly across the street. It goes almost without saying that such a display is not in keeping with a residential area that,for the past twenty years we have been here, has been an attractive and extremely well cared for living space.We would like to point out that in addition to the visual affront of the presence of this equipment,the property value of surrounding property, according to realtor estimates, is affected quite negatively. We urge that Sections 3- 1.3 and 4- 1.1 of the Zoning Ordinance continue to be enforced for the general welfare of the White Oak Trail community. Sincerely, I Helen nney 145 White Oak Trail Centerville,MA 02631 505-771-9374 r 6 SEP 12 2001 J L MIN OF BARNSTABLE. BOA,' aD Or Ron S. Jansson, Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals 367 Main Street Hyannis MA 02601 Dear Mr:Jansson: As the former home owner of 115 White Oak Trail, I am writing to fully support the order of the Building Commissioner directing James M Sanborn "to cease and desist the storing, garaging and keeping of commercial business equipment at his residence at 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville. During,the last five to six years of my ownership, I watched in dismay as their driveway become a holding area for a dismantled boat, a full size sleeping trailer and several large commercial barbecue smokers, which on occasion were fired up! Mind you, all of this I looked out on as well as passed when you came and went from my residence. In the twenty some odd years that I lived on White Oak Trail, I cannot recall anyone with such an array of equipment. As a residential area, the street has been an attractive and very well cared for place to live with the exception of the Sanborn property. Not only is the front yard an eyesore, but also has a negative affect on the surrounding properties and their real estate value. It is my hope that Sections 3-1.3 and 4-1.3 of the Zoning Ordinance continues to be enforced for the well of the residents of White Oak Trail. Thank you. Regards, Lys Terkelsen (Former owner of 115 White Oak Trail) 720 Pitchers Way 17B. Hyannis MA 02601 508-771-2063 SEP 12 2001 OF pARNSTABLE ; F APPEALS September 11, 2001 Nicholas Mancini 197 Gleneagle Drive Centerville, MA 02632 Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals 230 South Street Hyannis,MA 02601 RE: Appeal 2001-105 Gentlemen: Please be advised that I am against the storing of business equipment on property as shown on Assessors Map 192,Parcel 198, addressed 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville,. MA. Respectfully, Nicholas Mancini I w September 11, 2001 ;s VT IA . Zoning Board of Appeals, SEP 11 2001 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE This is a reply to your notice of appeal 2001-105. "°Hr'G BOARD of APPEALS We have lived on White Oak Trail.since 1976. This is a residential area and we have worked hard to.keep our property neat and orderly. Mr. Sandborn has kept large smoker trailers and a full size storage trailer on his property with large signs on top with a large phone number on it if you want to hire him and his trailer to do cooking. These trailers are as large as some u haul trucks. He keeps them in front and on the side of his house at times there have been four trailers on his lawn in front of his hous e. First of all the.trailers are unsightly, second this is a;area of homes and we should not be subject to his business equipment/signage and third we worry about rodents, all these trailers are used to smoke food in, that can attract rodents. A neighbor on our road has one of the largest landscaping companys' on the Cape; you would not know he is in the landscape business you never see any trucks or landscaping equipment in his yard or in front of his house. That's the difference between a good.neighbor and a neighbor who doesn't care what he's doing to our road. I am a realtor and have worked in real estate for 16 years and I can tell you that.houses like Mr. Sandborn's hurts our resale value and we lose money because his house with all this equipment takes our entire road's prices down. We ask you to uphold the local ordinance.-- Sincerely, Gene and Ronnie Mulligan �-2- `S, — F �,.y r 'f a f£ eOk .j sm � F A—�. u•� z �'" .. r� .e.. {: r :t1'� s e r:y'ara� "'i },' .:.a'" •—"r, t .,,CC�• t , tc--fir.. ;��� t`, I r S 'f f• T'S � �' ��y� -� \ f � // r[ s'�V b• 3 5"x �` 6 .�f l .�`° a� � R• _r3'�T•� v`'T.x��.,`Sa'� � i ew ., ems.-�,,, ` ^ y� d•r'�,.1 .� . y *� L x 3" _ fi ;^'�' ;4!•: -'s` _rams'I; > ,`,b�rk'£% �r SFr y' - r � _-t` .' gi .• � �'���, stS-��'�2''?�.asP"�}' f����.t�4s� �-��-rt� '$-�`'�� -��_y.�- 3��`.z�E,�"'`� - r - tx , x •::+^ - � b �+. � .k` � ;\ Sys.. T. .. tM� Wet ` a ri f � ,�•.,�,�, sty �; � ✓t a�u-� F ro fix, ,z PRO •S 3p Southern Pride barbecue Uvens & 13BQ Pits Page 1 of 1 1 Select An Oven "Rusilless opportunities Our business is on fire and we are smoking the competition! !t To become a distributor or representative in your area please submit resume creditials including the products you now represent to Southern- Pride.com attention Steve Walker. Or contact us at 1-800-851-8180. We look forward to talking to you. Home/History/Testimonials/Pits J Recipes Catalog/Links/Business Opportunities/Contact Us Southem Pride Cu o/BBQ Traditions/How Southern Pride Works/ i Why Choose Southern Pride rem Created by Evolution Mu.ttiirnedia This site created and maintained by Evolution Multimedia Corn http://www.southern-pride.com/Pages/employment.php3 9/10/01 Southern Pride Commercial Woodbuming barbecue rats Ana amoKers ror 1cestauraUL5 M .. rage 1 vi 1 k S Commercial Woodburning BBQ Pits And Smokers For The Barbeque Food Service Industry Southern Pride is the largest manufacturer of industrial/commercial woodburning BBQ pits and smokers in the world. Our barbecue equipment is used by cooking professionals for items such as barbecue ribs, poultry, beef, brisket, seafood, and game in restaurants and catering businesses worldwide. Enter our site for information, pictures, and specifications on our wide range of woodburning barbecue pits as well as BBQ recipes, customer testimonials, and more. 02001 Southern outhem Pride Woodbuming Barbecue Pits And Smokers RESTAU RA-wr HOTEL-Mo`rEL Snow . http://Www.southem-pride.com/ 9/10/01 p Y , F SEP 18 2001 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS - - TOWN OF BARNSTABLE f Appeal No. 2001-105 PETITIONERS: James M. Sanborn OWNER: James M. Sanborn HEARING DATE: September 19, 2001 RELIEF REQUESTED This is an appeal of the Building Inspectors of The Town of Barnstable for a determination that James M Sanborn has violated Section 3-1.3 and Section 4-1.1 of the Zoning Ordinances of the, Town of Barnstable by the storing, garaging, or keeping of commercial business equipment. It is alleged that Mr. Sanborn is in the Barbeque business and, in keeping with that business is keeping two commercial Barbeque smokers at his residence in Centerville. Petitioner seeks the determination of this Board that no business is being operated out of his home and that the equipment stored at the said home is for his personal use. LOCUS The property in question is a single-family residence known and numbered at 122 White Oak Trail in Centerville. The property is further shown on the Town of Barnstable Assessor's Map 192, Parcel 198. FACTS James M. Sanborn is a regional sales person for Southern Pride Equipment. As such, he travels to six or seven states as a door-to-door salesman for that purpose. Mr. Sanborn sees no customers at his residence and has never received a delivery of even one piece of equipment at his home for further delivery to-his customer. Mr. Sanborn has maintained his residence at 122 White Oak Trail for the past twelve years. He does have a passion for barbeque and his a long-standing member of the National Barbeque Association. He has purchased over the years a number of large commercial smokers for his private use, and even trailers them to the homes of other National Barbeque Association members for Association "Group Smokeouts". I Y ARGUMENT The intension behind Section 3-1.3 and Section 4-1.0 of the zoning ordinance is to limit and control business activities in residential districts. While Mr. Sanborn does on occasion receive and make telephone calls relative to his employment with Souther Pride,this is the only business activity taking place at his home. Contrasting Mr. Sanborn's activities with those of any number of other businesses, such as those of a landscaper,plumber,painter, mason, etc., where business equipment is commonly stored in single family residences located in residential districts. I cannot imagine that most painting contractors, for example, do not keep ladders, brushes,paint, turpentine,,etc. at their homes. Plumbers often keep a supply of copper pipes at their homes and in their work:related trucks, etc. Mason keep trailers, cement mixes on trailers and take them to and from work sites. Section 3-1.3 of the zoning ordinances of the Town of Barnstable provides for single-family residential dwellings as a principle permitted use. Accessory to that use is the ability to barbeque meals for family and friends. It is conceded that Mr. Sanborn uses equipment that has greater capacity than most used at residential homes. Section 4-1.1 of the zoning ordinance addresses specifically accessory uses of a residential property where such use is customarily incidental to and subordinate to the principal use that is served. Mr. Sanborn and his family comprise the five occupants of this home. The occasional group barbeque or smokeout is accessory to and subordinate to the use of the property as a single family residence. FINDINGS AND DECISIONS For the reasons set forth above the applicant respectfully requests that his Board find that Mr. Sanborn's.maintenance of a commercial cooker at his home is not part of a commercial activity; and, further, that said maintenance of equipment does not constitute the keeping and storing of business equipment in violation of Sections 301.1 and 4-1.1 of the zoning ordinance of the T own of Barnstable. Respectfully submitted James M. Samborn By his attorney Mark H. Boudreau, Esq. 396 North Street Hyannis, MA 02601 (508) 775-1085 Date: F1 W FDOCMELEMMMSanbom—ingappul.wpd 3' 1 _• 1 Town of Barnstable Planning Division - Staff Report Appeal2001-105 - Sanborn p Appeal of the Building Commissioner Date: September 13, 2001 To: Zoning Board of Appeals From: ' A Tracz k, Principal Planner Petitioner: James M. Sandorn Property Address: 122 White Oak Trail,Centerville MA Assessor's Map/Parcel: Map 192,Parcel 198 Zoning: Residential C Zoning District RPOD-Resource Protection Overlay District AP-Aquifer Protection Overlay District Filed:June 22,2001 Hearing:September 19,2001 Copy of Notice: James M. Sandorn has appealed the June 1, 2001 order of the Building Commissioner to cease and desist the storing, garaging and keeping of commercial business equipment as it is in violation of Section 3-1.3, Principal and Conditional Uses and Section 4-1.1 Accessory Uses of the Zoning Ordinance. The property is shown on Assessors Map 192 Parcel 198, addressed 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville MA in a Residential C Zoning District. Background and Review: The applicant is appealing the Building Commissioner's issuance of a June 01, 2001, order to cease and desist. The order alleges that the applicant,James M. Sandorn is carrying on business activity within a residential zoning district. According to the Building Division files, the question of the business use of the property dates back to March of 1998. At that time, complaints were made to both the Building Division and Health Division claming a number of commercial type barbeques and cookers were parked in and around the garages. The complaints were investigated and the applicant responded noting that he would reduce the number to one — his personal cooker (see March 20, 1998 letter). Complaints continued after that initial contact. During the year 2000, three separate complaints were received and investigated by the Building Division. From those complaints it appears the applicant was operating "Cape Cod Clambake" from his home. Three commercial cookers were noted as being on the property (see attached Complaint/Inquiry Reports). Planning Division-Staff Report On May 21, 2001, another Complaint Inquiry by the Building Division ruled that it was a "business operating in a residential zone". Pictures were taken showing at least three,perhaps as many as five commercial cookers in the garage area of the home (see attached repost 5/21/01 and photos). On May 31, 2001 the Building Division wrote to Mr. Sanborn citing the violation of zoning and including the June 01, 2001 order to cease and desist. The Building division files noted that on June 04, 2001, a phone call to the residence was answered with a business name "New England Barbeque". Planning staff did search the Business Listings of the Hyannis Area July 2001 phone book and found a business listed for "New England Barbecue/Southern Pride". The listening did not give a street address but did note Centerville. The phone number given for that business was 508-775-1920. That phone number-is the exact phone number listed on the Zoning Board Application submitted by the applicant on June 22, 2001. The company is also listed under Restaurant Equipment and Supplies. The uses that are occurring on the property can not satisfy the requirements of Section 4-1.4 Home Occupation as-of-right, specifically conditions E and K which are: E. There are no external alterations,to the dwelling, which are not customary in residential buildings, and there is no outside evidence of such use. K. There is no exterior storage or display of materials or equipment. Staff Conclusion & Suggestion: It appears that the Building Division has no choose but to issue the citation. The above requirements also apply to Home Occupations by.special permit. Staff would suggest that the applicant should seel.garage storage unit to relocate the business that is properly zoned for the activity. 2 Planning Division-Staff Report Copy of Section 4-1.4-Home Occupation 4-1.4-Home Occupation INTENT: It is the intent of this section to allow the residents of the Town of Barnstable to operate a home occupation within single family dwellings,subject to the provisions of Section 4- 1.4 herein,provided that the activity shall not be discernible from outside the dwelling: there shall be no increase in noise or odor visible alteration to the premises which would suggest anything other than a residential use; no increase in traffic above normal residential volumes; and no increase in air or groundwater pollution. 1) After registration with the Building Inspector,a customary home occupation shall be permitted as of right subject to the following conditions. A. The activity is carried on by the permanent resident of a single-family residential dwelling unit, located within that dwelling unit. B. The activity is a type customarily carried on within a dwelling unit. C. Such use is clearlyincidental to and subordinate to the use of h the premises for residential purposes. D. Such use occupies no more than 400 square feet of space. E. There are no external alterations to the dwelling,which are not•customary in residential buildings,and there is no outside evidence of such use. F. The use is not object or detrimental to the neighborhood and its residential character. G. No traffic will be generated in excess of normal residential volumes. H. The use does not involve the production of offensive noise,vibration, smoke,dust or. other particulate matter, odors,electrical disturbance, heat,glare, humidity or other objectionable effects. I. There is no storage or use of toxic or hazardous materials, or flammable or explosive materials, in excess of normal.household quantities. J. Any need for parking generated by such use shall be met on the same lot containing the Customary Home Occupation,and not within the required front yard. K. There is no exterior storage or display of materials or equipment. L. ,There are no commercial vehicles related to the Customary Home Occupation, other than one van or one pick-up truck not to exceed one ton capacity, and one trailer not to exceed 20 feet in length and not to exceed 4 tires,parked on the same lot containing the Customary Home Occupation. M. No sign shall be displayed indicating the Customary Home Occupation. 3 Ilk Planning Division-Staff Report N. If the Customary Home Occupation is listed or advertised as a business,the street address shall not be included. O. No person shall be employed in the Customary Home Occupation who is not a permanent resident of the dwelling unit. P. Customary Home Occupations shall not include such uses similar to, and including the following: • Barber and beauty shops x Commercial stables or kennels • Real estate or insurance office • The sale of retail or wholesale merchandise from the premises. The sale of antique or second hand goods Service or repair of vehicles, and gasoline or diesel powered machinery. Contractor's storage yards Veterinary services The manufacture of goods using heavy machinery • Medical or Dental practice * Fortune telling or palm reading. 2. Home OccupationY P b Special Permit A Home Occupation may be permitted in the RC-1 and RF Single Family Zoning Distric ts provided that Special Permit is first obtained from the Zoning Board of Appeals subject to the provisions of Section 5-3.3 herein and subject to the specific standards for such conditional p � ) p uses as required in this Section: A. All of the requirements of Section 4-1.4(1), Customary Home Occupation,paragraphs (A) through (L) above. B. There is no more than one non-illuminated wall sign not exceeding two square feet in area, listing only the occupants'name and occupation. C. Not more than one non-resident of the household is employed. D. Home Occupations shall not include the uses listed in Section 4-1.4(1)(P) above. E. The Zoning Board of Appeals may permit the Home Occupation to be located within an accessory structure located on the same lot as the single-family residential dwelling unit. F. Approval of Site Plan Review is obtained. G. The Special Permit shall be issued to the applicant only at his or her residence, and shall not be transferable to another person, or to another location. (4-1.4 Added by Town Council vote on August 17, 1995 by an 8 IES 2 ABSTAIN roll call vote-item 95-195). 4 oanE RAMMBM MASK. i639. � Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals Decision and Notice Appeal2001-105 - Sanborn - Appeal of the Building Commissioner Summary: Upheld-Building-Commissioner Petitioner: JarnmM. Sanborn Property Address:C-122�White Oak Trail,Centerville MA + Assessor's Map/Parcel: Map 192,Parcel 198 Zoning: Residential C and Resource Protection Overlay District Relief Requested&Background The applicant is appealing the Building Commissioner's issuance of a June 01, 2001, order to cease and desist. The order alleges that the applicant,James M. Sanborn is carrying on business activity within a residential zoning district. According to the Building Division files,the question of the business use of the property dates back to March of 1998. At that time, complaints were made to both the Building Division and Health Division claiming a number of commercial type barbeques and cookers were parked in and around the garages. The complaints were investigated, and the applicant responded noting that he would reduce the number to one- his personal cooker. Complaints continued and during the year 2000,three separate complaints were received and investigated by the Building Division. Three commercial cookers were noted as being on the property. On May 21, 2001, another Complaint Inquiry by the Building Division ruled that it was a"business operating in a residential zone". Pictures were taken showing at least three,perhaps as many as five commercial cookers in the garage area of the home. On May 31, 2001,the Building Division wrote to Mr. Sanborn citing the violation of zoning and included the June 01, 2001 order to cease and desist. Procedural &Hearing Summary: This appeal was filed at the Town Clerk's Office and at the Office of the Zoning Board of Appeals on June 22, 2001. An extension of time for holding the hearing and for filing of the decision was executed between the applicant and the Board. A public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals was duly advertised and notice sent to all abutters in accordance with MGL Chapter 40A. The hearing was opened September 19, 2001, at which time the Board found to uphold and reaffirm the Building Commissioners decision. i Board Members deciding this appeal were Gail Nightingale,Richard L. Boy, Ralph Copeland,Jeremy Gilmore, and Chairman,Ron S.Jansson. r v Attorney Mark H. Boudreau represented Mr.James Sanborn who was also present during the hearing. Mr. Boudreau stated that Mr. Sanborn is not running a business and that the two large commercial cookers on the property were for his personal use. The Board noted that Mr. Sanborn has a truck with lettering advertising the business. They discussed the number of cookers on the property. The Board stated that this was not a customary home out-door cooking equipment, but was being used for a business. The health dept staff inspection report was also cited. . Mr. Boudreau submitted to the file two letters of support. They were from Skiff Greene and Dale Bishop, Norton,MA. The public was invited to comment and testify. Mike Murphy, a neighbor, supported the petitioner and stated that he did not think it was a business use. Helen Kenney stated Mr. Sanborn is employed with Southern Pride, as a salesman.and distributor of the commercial cookers. He demonstrates the use of the equipment and it is moved many times a week for that purpose. Phil Haggerty stated that there are as many as seven units at any time and that they are moved on average six or seven times a month. He submitted photos taken in February 2000. Mr. Vagts read a letter stating that the property was being used as a commercial property. Mr. Boudreau stated that he had made a site visit and that there were two pieces of equipment on the property today. Findings of Fact: At the hearing of September 19, 2001,the Board unanimously found the following findings of fact: 1. James M. Sanborn has appealed the June 1, 2001 order of the Building Commissioner to cease and desist the storing, garaging and keeping of commercial business equipment as it is in violation of Section 3-1.3,Principal and Conditional Uses and Section 4-1.1 Accessory Uses of the Zoning Ordinance. The property is shown on Assessors Map 192 as Parcel 198. It is addressed 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville MA and is located in a Residential C Zoning District. 2. The applicant has been storing large commercial barbeque equipment in his yard for several years. The equipment being stored on the property is not found in most homes. It is commercial equipment that is not customary found in single-family homes. The size of the equipment is not incidental nor is it accessory to the residential use. 3. The equipment is in fact, accessory to the business activity that the applicant is carrying on in his home. The storage of that equipment on the property is not permitted under Section 4-1.4 of the Zoning Ordinance that regulates Home Occupations. 4: The predominate use in this Residential C Zoning District is single-family dwellings. It is the only principal use,permitted as-of-right. 5. "New England Barbecue/Southern Pride is listed in the Business Listings of the Hyannis Area July 2001 phone book. The listing did not give a street address but did note Centerville. The phone number given for that business was 508-775-1920. That phone number is the exact phone number 2 listed on the Zoning Board Application submitted by the applicant on June 22, 2001. The company is also listed under Restaurant Equipment and Supplies. Decision: Based on the findings of fact, a motion was duly made and seconded to affirm and uphold in full the decision of the Building Commissioner as stated in his June 1, 2001 cease and desist order issued to Mr. James M. Sanborn. The vote was as follows: AYE: Gail Nightingale, Richard L. Boy,Ralph Copeland,Jeremy Gilmore,Ron S.Jansson NAY: None Ordered: In.Appeal 2001-105 the Board has upheld the decision of the Building Commissioner. Appeals of this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A, Section 17, within twenty (20) days after the date of the filing of this decision. A copy of which must be filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Ron S.Jansson, Chairman Date Signed I,Linda Hutchenrider, Clerk of the Town of Barnstable,Barnstable County,Massachusetts,hereby certify that twenty (20) days have elapsed since the Zoning Board of Appeals filed this decision and that no appeal of the decision has been filed in the office of the Town Clerk. Signed and sealed this day of under the pains and penalties of perjury. Linda Hutchenrider, Town Clerk 3 1 THE ram, Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services * BAMSTABLE, 9 MASS. Thomas F. Geiler,Director 1639. 1►. " Building Division Tom Perry, Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis, MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 RE: James Sanborn New England Barbeque 122 White Oak Trail Centerville, MA 02632 Map: 192 Parcel: 198 • 03/09/98 Complaint (construction), no permit, pictures • 03/16/98 Complaint: running business, no permit. R. Stevens went out to investigate and owner said he would remove cookers. • 03/20/98 Letter from Mr. Sanborn • 10/02/98 Spoke with Mr. Sanborn: will remove truck • 10/08/98 Complaint re: cookers • 09/01/99 Complaint, illegal business, pictures on site • 08/25/00 Complaint re: cooking, running illegal business • 09/07/0 Complaint, business in residential zone • 05/21/01 Complaint, running business in residential zone • 05/31/01 Letter to Sanborn from Commissioner Ulshoeffer • 06/01/01 Cease &Desist order • 06/04/01 Answers phone with "New England Barbeque.." Will stop. • 06/11/01 Mr. Sanborn will appeal decision • 06/22/01 Appeal to Zoning Board of Appeals re: Cease &Desist • 07/09/01 Have not heard from Mr. Sanborn. Left word on machine to call. • 09/13/01 Hearing on Zoning Board of Appeals re: Appeal of Commissioner. Building Commissioner's decision upheld. • 09/19/01 Letters from neighbors • 10/22/01 Letter to Commissioner from Atty. Boudreau • 02/02/02 Ms. Kenney(neighbor) had meeting with Atty. Smith and he told her he would address the problem • 05/20/02 Letter to Atty. Boudreau from Commissioner Perry Q:Gloria:NEBARBQ 1 I F�- q _ z ;xrt • FINAL DISPOSITION: Ticket#52901 $300.00 One for each vehicle s ALL PICTURES IN SEPARATE FOLDER 09/25/98 12/11/01 09/400 05/20/02 ,Y 10/31/01 06/14/02 F rc✓. � " 12/10/01 w t3" k E"t� `f ..fir lhk : t jµ. Ma b - '84 Q:Gloria:NEBARBQ 2 -0/9 If r o, hr� �7/, Ap A v o - . Ile �- y �� 0000 ;, � _ I' � � ;; . {` f' �• :, R � , • fi � .. i., ' . i 0 ROO Ir , s `l .t sf y 4,ZZZl/T .a. ,. is� �•. :a � �.... ..y - 'R Y -�_ M' ' W. _ �v _ .� 4 y _ _. t ;! is Engineering Dept.(3rd floor) Map Parcel 1:VJ Permit# �, �j 8 House# Date Issued t,o , G ' Board of Health(3rd floor)-(8:15 -9:30/1:00-4:30) ,$'' r e 00 Conservation Office(4th floor)(8:30-9:30/1:00-2:00) Planning Dept.(1st floor/School Admin. Bldg.) �'� Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 mm8STALLEo .! CE TOWN OF BARNSTABLET'Ow9����ULATILi it4D Building Permit Application Project Street Address /as w j ie Oak 7-�d i l ��L„ t6r-�3��_ - / —C Village 0 214`�k"t& P Owner C�0Y1 yof M�D k In Address a gi e Telephone ;77-57— /Z-2 Permit Request -P 1;� 2� � -- �+ P First Floor square feet Second Floor 9' square feet Construction Type &.2E24 Estimated Project Cost $ 1 30 0. �) Zoning,District Flood Plain Water Protection Lot Size Grandfathered ❑Yes ❑No Dwelling Type: Single Family Two Family ❑ Multi-Family(#units) Age of Existing Structure Historic House ❑Yes &I No On Old King's Highway ❑Yes %�No Basement Type: Full ❑Crawl ❑Walkout ❑Other Basement Finished Area(sq.ft.) /V�� Basement Unfinished Area(sq.ft) Number of Baths: Full: Existing New Half: Existing New , No. of Bedrooms: Existing New Total Room Count(not including baths): Existing New First Floor Room Count Heat Type and Fuel: ❑Gas ❑Oil ❑Electric ❑Other Central Air ❑Yes ❑No Fireplaces: Existing New Existing wood/coal stove ❑Yes ❑No Garage: ❑Detached(size) Other Detached Structures: ❑Pool(size) ❑Attached(size) ❑Barn(size) ❑None ❑Shed(size) . ❑Other(size) Zoning Board of Appeals Authorization ❑ Appeal# Recorded❑ Commercial ❑Yes ❑No If yes, site plan review# - Current Use Proposed Use Builder Information Name aeD �- P Il a 1 Telephone Number g7l (O Address k f 2 -e lA License# . P l� `]�►- 1[��' /,�t D' (o Z Home Improvement Contractor# /0 0 ! ® 5 Worker's Compensation# ,; 9� )� ?3 0 NEW CONSTRUCTION OR ADDITIONS REQUIRE A SITE PLAN(AS BUILT)SHOWING EXISTING,AS WELL AS PROPOSED STRUCTURES ON THE LOT. ALL CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS RESULTING FROM THIS PROJECT WILL BE TAKEN TO @4k,5-JA61p SIGNATURE DATE BUILDING PERMIT DENIE _ OR THE FOLLOWING REASON(S) x + FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PERMIT NO. DATE ISSUED MAP/PARCEL NO. ADDRESS r !r r- VILLAGE OWNER _ ^+ gL r �•�,4 +`ter �-i DATE OF INSPECTION: FOUNDATION FRAME n y INSULATION" FIREPLACE ELECTRICAL: ROUGH FINAL,., PLUMBING: ROUGH FINAL - GAS: ROOOH . " FINAL FINAL BUILDING =� DATE CLOSED OUT ASSOCIATION PLAN NO. ( A o r r a �e�llis� Al Of l t l�pµ0 1 fiu b° w I OLD !� !ce V�omvnzanuiea�!! `i�aooac�cuartla BOARD OF BUILDING REGULATIONS License:,CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR Numbem ZS 028899 �M f , Ezprres.OS/16/2001 Tr.no: 3278 - Restricted'To: 00 GEORGE J ALLAIN 116 SHEAFFER RD "� CENTERVILLE, MA 02632 Administrator `�/te�oa�nma�w*!�ld o�./uaoaac%uael�i i HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR Registration 100105 Type - INDIVIDUAL EXPiration 06/04/00 GEORGE ALLAIN i �b11�6 SHEAFFER Rd. ( Cw,co teTville MA 02632 , ADMINISTRATOR i y � r The Town of Barns table * Ba NHABm '� Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services ArEn '�" Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner Permit no. Date 9 9 AFFIDAVIT HOME IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTOR LAW SUPPLEMENT TO PERMIT APPLICATION MGL c. 142A requires that the"reconstruction alterations renovation repair,q p modernization,conversion, improvement,removal,demolition,or construction of an addition to any pre-existing owner-occupied building containing at least one but not more than four dwelling units or to structures which are adjacent to such residence or building be done by registered contractors,with certain exceptions,along with other requirements. Type of Work: 2c Estimated Cost ' Address of Work: /2 2„ (,e) Owner's Name: Tal YYt F Date of Application: I hereby certify that: Registration is not required for the following reason(s): ❑Work excluded by law ❑Job Under$1,000 ❑Building not owner-occupied ❑Owner pulling own permit Notice is hereby given that: OWNERS PULLING THEIR OWN PERMIT OR DEALING WITH UNREGISTERED CONTRACTORS FOR APPLICABLE HOME IMPROVEMENT WORK DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE ARBITRATION PROGRAM OR GUARANTY FUND UNDER MGL c. 142A. SIGNED UNDER PENALTIES OF PERJURY. I hereby apply for a permit as the agent of the owner: Date Contractor Name Registration No. OR Date Owner's Name q:forms:Affidav MAP 192 =Y MAP�'T92 i I j _... MAP 192 - 10) 7 1 # 108 MAP W) g:\basemaps\base192.dgn Oct. 14, 1999 08:48:32 MAP 192 SCALE 1"= ------ The Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Industrial Accidents Office offaresdooffoQs _ - y 600 Washington Street - - Boston,Mass. 02111 Workers' Com ensation Insurance Affidavit 11 name: � •� "� p location• ea P i, city � fz �� �� hone# Q I am a homeowner performing all work myself f am a sole •etor and have no one worldn in anv I am as employer providing workers compensation for my eloyees:worldng:on this job.::::::::::::::::::::?;>}:.}}>:;.}}}:.;:>:< ...... ......... ........::::::: .cam an <:name�:::':.:,....;:. • .. ........... Z. r.... f. :::. ....:.::.:....... ..... r..:.. ....:..........::::::..:• ...,.., w{.},::..K}.• sir{i::..:�.. ............... ..{.: » �., lnsurat<ce•ca::::. .:...t�,.�i.r•,. 7 .... '�,� ...�.�.� .......... ......... ;�'<� :� >�',:: Q I am a sole proprietor,general contractor,or homeowner(circle one)and have Hired the conaactors listed below who have the following workers' compensation polices: :::::.:..................................................,............................................. `« {.; ................::..........:::..:.:............ ................ .......... .... ..........................:.............:.................:..:�:•:::v:::v:::.�::::•.::w::v.}•}3}:^:::v.::::.v::w:::r•:::m::.:.....................}}::}:v:•ii•}i}}:i{-}}}::•:?;:r::? :;fi..ji;:ji}::i:tyi:Cj?i{.{i?}:::.:.}:.;�::. coma .. .....................;;.............. ..... .x ....:•{{...5.....YN.hNt{Va J.-:'.y::'J3:•}.':{ .................... ................ ...................>:yJ}w;.::::::.:,..•vvr.,v..........v., J^h. ......v •,:. +!b:G.:,,•.,;:::n}•:::{•}}}:J}:•}:•}:{•xv,.{v:}}:•.:•.;•.<N.•:.,}vn ....................... .:...n.............+:...:•.�::::::•n,... ............ ::.......k........r...n?Cxk'A.r.K`•$.v.v%`................. r.........::.-..^b'}4:Sv+..,�- :r,v:::...v.....n:`::�:::n:::•............... .. ::::.::r.:::::. ........ ........... ... ........r. ...,.......r...rv$r.:r: 'v}:•}:::4}'•}:J::�v::::{:.,;:::.i}:,•i:w::{•w:••:::::..,.•:::xL•}:•:: :•:•:•nv::4%t??•i::'::'�: .... ............... ......,,.......... .:. .r......... ..i......5..... .........n..... .v :•• .. +}{}.F::.-;.;.:v{i:{?:tJ':w::::::•::::??v}:•}S:v:•}::::v:y:?.,:•. ...... ................,.........,..........................................................r.,.• ,e.,. ...J.:.a'3F•?b:r. r. {K;b •.v:}^::::?:i:: .... ...... ................. .....a.v n.........................................................;.:v....4x:„3t'+a• .may( ..J:. ,.v�L..:.x,..v .kfCv.i�...r., ..r. :... . .....::•:::::;:•:::::....•vvv:v:::.}::::::v:::::::::}::.v:::::v::.vvv::::::.,................r... ...:.,�3`:..{,. .. +:^..;.....,........y:vrn,.....,v,,?.......v::r}.�:v:?•}•}:J}:':::v:::•:r}::v:r.,:•:::{;.:,:..:.:a::.:::;::::::: 'vfvvn•}:•i}:•f•:k�}:':.}:1+:i:'v}':{: .:Jkv:.J}}O:•: rig .J.. .:{rf.,YJ'•:J::{ix{• ?----Jss�i•:�:4')kE?:YTra?h:%0(:i:!:'_:-:: ryx:.;:'av::••. J.. ":S: - +rii0r' rv.•wAv.•:xwvv.•:}.wrr: .....r:v:rk......xA.•};••J:}{Lw::}}:..,nw,....,,.n.;.......r.::n..;..::::::-}n{'.};Y.-. .. :.. x. ::::..n...............•::n......... .........,:•: r..,v.,:w::•w:. ,....a.:. ...:•::•.ti x•}+:a:' .. .�L-Y'�. :}'• �Ov:..:'•'... ......................... .......:.,......Ja...na:............,<....5}:}::::::.........:�S.K•t......... b. ..�tJ �...... `r., +�:, ' :..r{ ........ ............................................:................ .3 ...r. .. .:r....•::::.......r a•::.::.�... r::::...r.•>3;?}:.n:••w::;. .....:.........,................... r3 J•:::r{a,r ;.{..,a ..{.:..... ................. ........ ..........................,..r.................. :.,v•..f...,... ..............+.a;•::::::.�}:.:•.,:•::.�::::,•.,.,.:•..•:.:::.,va•}k,•::}}:.�::..::;?•xo-::::2:ii:>;>:i::;::�;: #f ................. ....... .............................v................ �/(y•� k, .r suss.,} .... .....v............ ,{ ..................v......::.......a......::.:...v,....n......................n.....n................r.. f. .... v„avi :{+n Sr }pr. a ,Y:r:•x{?}:�:> :::::nvnv::n�::::x:• •.,Jk•.w., .axvx.... ..........�{•:x•:X,.....::r.• .-.{}- .. .:::v : a\Y.. }}� .................................... .}}....kv............k..J...x,.k..}o-....,•..CAh.x!..{}......... ?'+�{�AL ... }}v.A°<}:t.Xr:Yific... .. ............................................ ......:... .... ..............................................v............:.f. ...... ...:.........YY 3.....:. .v{ {.v}•'w::•::v.J:•}:v}}:.x:: .. r... ...:............... ................. ...{...........................a...........,............,..... 3*.'....}F2b. .F .... ... .�4. ..:.y.{:w:.v::. .. .... ....... v'ttfi:xv}'tx•}:•}:•}3:4:;{.. .;... ........... :::::::::::.w:::::•::.::•:::::..•::.avnvv.:::n..:.....:?:.}}:ti:i•}:AC•SnY.•. .q•:�:t{{\}L{}C:+.M•�1$:4f,.?tG,Yn^�: '�,•k'vrLC_u�.v::•}f.IX.myv.}}}:#::v:. •..}}}:?tiv:•}}Y.'ti[??^i?>: .dikes s: k•.v::. w.J.•k.:•:•:::v:::::::::x::::n}}}}:::4i}:J:J}}i}}}}:?;•}}}}}}:;4:???4}:i}•:�::�:::i:iiji'rii>}`,:i::::v�:}: .r.... :....::::::::...... ..............:•................................................................:....v. ... vow: ...:::::.. .. n:•w...v: :::::j$};{:;:i; :k _ �•�i:�Fi%':''::.:;i:�:;,v.;:}:i:{.'.y4::'.:;.;�:$:.}:?:4?:;i:: ` :;:y{i;.;}ii::::;:�:� j}.{}j,:.;`: v: ......: ...... av::::v.:::::::v ::v:.::::.:::::::::w:::::::::::-.;:•wn.v::w:::::::::>Svk..'r..f f:••}:xxw:::.r•: {, u r T } ........... .,.............................................:................ ... .,.....v::k:•::.r ises•:•,v.•}x•}:•:{H•iS•'•}3.....•-::::.v::.};i.....;.,:: ' .v. ...}} ....:.... ...., {w...............................�•.•::�•::::::::................... ..: .....,. .a.,.....r... ..t ....�.•ti•. :•::{r•:;;�:}:•x::i::;f::>:•.:•::'rr:ii•::a}fir::�r::;:��::::r:::::::i::i� ..::.. . ... ........... ..::•:.�:::-::{{,r:.,::•:•....{..........r:........................r•>}}:{•ik....xv....Jl..i�2.o...,sc:.:.... a}... 5.,: {• s»cxYL{J,{r>r>::{.;.: Feflm e,to seems eoveesge as req�red ceder Seetton 25A of MGL 152 e lnd to the imposwon oteelminai pPenaltiesof a Sae up to 51,500.00 md/or m sate yeah'imprbonmmt as weII as dvII peadties in the form of a STOP WORK ORDER and a foe of S100.00 a day against me. I understand that a Copy of this statement may be forwarded to the Office of tavestlgatiesls of the Di for corsage vesimtlon. I do hereby certify the pains mid olPffjwy A&the information provided above it trw.and corral Signatupe �--\ Date / © l Y/ lff r f Ptint nNIMP C V,01 Zb I Illice# oincial use only do not write in this area to be completed by city or town ofldal city or town: peemii/license# ❑Building Department ❑Licensing Board checkuhnmedlate response is required ❑Selectmen's Office ❑Health Department eontad person: phone#;- � ❑Others_ Uram 9l95 P1A) 1 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 I t .111 • • • • �• • •11 1 1 I / / • •11 i• :/ •a •II 11 1 • 1•11�/ 11 r:r r Y•111• I J / / :1 • ' • 1�• 1 1 • • • •1 ' 1 • •M .1• •1 • •• .1• •1 • • 1.l • .tl • • 1 ' • • 1/ • • I - • • • 1 • BI !Y• ` • / • 11 :111 • 1• 1 •Ii 1_ 1 - �% - • .�.1IIY. • • • <• .111 • • • 11 .1 • • / 1 • is jov.. ail 1.1 - 1 1• • • • 1 • • 1 - - •G Gt 11.1 :.111/ • 11 • ..IIU • - • • � / • ' 1:1 • 1 • w 1 • 1 • 1 11 • 1 • 11 • •1 1 1 � • •11.t 11 1• 1 • .w •i. 11:1 .tl/ •I 11 • 1• 11 • 1 • • 1_ 1• • 1 • 1.1 1 • :11111 • •jw4 •II • •fog II R Is II :+r 1 •11 I 1 raq• •II • e• • 0:490 116.11 1 111• 1! 1 • • •1l /I -S •blots • 1 • 1 ` I • .tl /1 11 .t • / I 1441guAll 1 • I'mI . 1 :.1111 • q 1 / a • •11 • .1 .� •/ .1 1 1 1kj I1 wl •1 1 II tl 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 till, 1 1 : 1 1 • 1 1 11 1 1 1 11 1 1 1 ' 1 1 • 1 1 • •II 1.tlll a Ir •11ltll •11 "�'% ( 1 / • JI • 11. •• 1• ••: 1 /• Y •11 1 1 ..111:1 111 • 1 r•I11• • I/ •.1 • 11 1 • • 1 / • •. IU• • ✓• / /.11 • •11111 1too ' •1 11 It 11 .11 �• 11 :./1.Illl • Ir 1 .Ir /" 1 I...1 • .�.111 �• • 11 •I11• ••• .111 • 1 jjjjjjjjjjjjj/jjjj/��j�j�j�jjj�jj�����jj�j��jjj�j ' 1 I 1 •• :�. 7I 1 11 '• •. :/ •I111•:./ .1• •II •• • 1 •1111• :l l' / ` 1. .•11 ' 11 1•1' 11 .1 .1/ / :.. • • 1 vlll .1• •1/ .11 • Its 1 It • Y•11111 .11 1 .111 .� r •1 w. ./1 r • 1 •11 111111 •.i •11 ' III .. •1• M:11' • 11 11 .11 I •• I 1� 11 1 1 oil I 1 1 • .1 111 -•11 •I 1 /11 • « • :.111. •I Y1111.1.11 .1• •11 • 11 11 .11 • .t _ 1 1 ( 1 �1 1 1 1 1' 11 �1 1 1 •• / 1 1 • ( 1 1 .i11 •1; • • 11 «1 ` •I • •' 1 11 .t 11 .Ir 1 «:1• •II • 11 4 1.1.1111 •I .•1 V 1 .11 1 1 :� • •11 •Y. / 1 ' 11 11 • 1 will ` :• 1 .: Ii1 1 1 /1 1 . /11.111 •J 1 111 .• « • :../1/. 11 • 1 • `. I I • _ �• 11 LI • • r Y. 11 '•11.�:1 Y•I111•.•/ W.1/ •II 1 • 1 ✓• 1 II - 1 • 111�.11 .1 11 IIIt11 1:) �• I 1 1 1 / II 11 .1 11y •• • 1 Y•1111/ �/- / 1 • 111 �1 ..`I 1 1 1 • . /1/•11 1 . • • / �• /. 1 11 • • 1 •111 •000 1 •• • •1 • I• :11 • 11 11 11 - :.11 11 1 •1 • 1 .� 1 �Y•1• •II - 1 • Y•111Y. • 1 1 :.•Y. I 11 ` II .1. 1 K111 1 •% -� �• ../ 111111 1:.1 1 •• 1 11- 11 1 111.1�• 1 - 11 / 71 11 11 / .'.•1111 Y..r 111111 •.t " 11 r I 1 11 1 • 111 ..11 I 11 •I 11 • 11.+ • •11 ' ..11 :.111. I 1�..1 11 r 1 i• • 1 7. • .7 1• •1/ • I / • 11 1 • 11 1 • .11 •1 • V•-• I.t .11 •II 1 • 1 • 1 • 1 1 • 1.� • •1 MEN���jj����j����jj/ 1 1 • •11:.11 / •1 .•. • 1 •11 - isle Y• 11 11 •.t 1 1 11 11 1 1 1 1 1 •'' 1 1 111 1 1 I I • M I 1 1 1 1 ( . 1 IL1 1 1• ' Il II 1 ' 1 ,- .��'��-T��'b '�]J�••��,t�. -. �'-x.+.-'�'.'Cs t'y r. T 3 a:.:,� >rr t }•r >.r > > •'" rf�j7^ X'7�.•r �'7 '��yh .. ..- THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS REGISTRY OF MOTOR VEHICLES P.O. BOX 199100 BOSTON, MA 02119 www.massrmv.com . ; PLEASE KEEP THIS DOCUMENT SIN YOUR VEHICLE AT ALL TIMES PLATETMPE REGL4TRATgNNUMSER CERTIFICATE OF REGISTRATION , TRN 880994 EXPIRES MONnN YEAR TRAILER 11 02 FEES: NAMES)OF OWNERS)AND MAILING ADDRESS REGISTRATION 72 . 00 SANBORN, JAMES M SR, EFFECTIVE DATE 12 06 01 a TITLE 50 . 00 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL NUMeR L sPEcuLPUTEs 0. 00 CENTERVILLE, MA 02632-1642 suESTAx 01134054090101 g 30. 00 TOTAL 152 . 00 RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS(IF DIFFERENT) -- — -- "REaS TRAR PASSENGERS FOR HIRE TRANSPORTING GOODS, 2001 HOMEM MAXIMUM NUMBER OF WARES OR MERCHANDISE: MFRS MODELGT4 0 0 0 TRA I L WHITE PASSENGERS B Eo T TOTAL�MS EKED WEIGHT YEAR )DELMAKE MODEL NAME BODYSTYLErtYPE COLOR N4A31.257 ARBELLA MUTUAL INS 006000 NOT VALID UNTIL STAMPED WITH OFFICIAL SIGNATURE STAMP OR SIGNATURE OF THE REGISTRAR • I s cw i ' < 2$vN�2ti54ti i t? ti < t r ti. Z ti� : ti ji,� ,�v- .R,KTiw £�. a � 4 tt,��}{{� ��N2.}�, �7py}{ �+,.�$y2`��r ' � ;i��t,, NJg1- •i�,.pf�"-�tµ�� h Z t•�.H ; .•r �,t •C�i`. 3"M 4` N. t �t S } t t> K > ,t y ± ,y, �r>r>,13}3u�^tu 4,,... :.'�2 ....,._, .r``....�..>...ry.�>tch3'`+<�..,.. >>�`r.?•. ,...: i�..:..,k :.>;.>.` ........ '" .,. ;,`'. THE FOLLOWING' IS/ARE THE BEST IMAGES FROM POOR QUALITY ORIGINAL (S) m ^ � DATA ING N0.112. P.:.1 Z2 110 UN W[E 4 =- 16 01 4 OF BARNSTA18 y BOARD OF APPEA TOWN OF BARNWABLE Zonino Board of Appoh iAPPflosHon for ouw Powers Town Cis Ome: 1 FV�o1Ncs_ u`_s�of : APB f Now"Owte t3adaton Due Ths undersigned hereby applies to the Z0*Q Board of Appeals for tt'tvi reasons indicated: AppficnntName: JAMES M. SANBORN pie. 508-775-1920 ApptieantAdGresa: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL CENTERVILLE proporty t.ocion: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL, CENTERVILLE PropwgOwner- JAMES M. SANBORN PhoNs; 508-775-1920 Address of Owner. 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL CENTERVILLE Aseessoe+s Majopmal Nord,w; 192/19 8 zonbo D1strict RC GroMdwom Owrtay Dishict This is a roquost for [ l Er&rcwrwnt Action (K] APPeat ofAdmlcthtntN#OmciWrs Dotdsion [ 7 other General Powom -passe Sperty: Which 8e00n(S)of the Zoning Ordinsnoa and/or MGM.ChOPIW 40A are YOU SPD*Onp to the Z.oNno Board of Appeals? SECTION 4-1.1 OF THE TOWN OF:'BARNSTABLE ZONING ORDINANCE & SECTION 3-1.3 OF THE TOWN OF BARNSTABLE ZONING ORDINANCE Ivet~,ra otAppe1et a 0es1don of Roquost AppLTC NT IS APPEALING THE NOTICE OF ORDINANCE VIOLATION AND ORDER TO CEASE, DESIST AND ABATE IZMD A AT ST HIM ON rriNE OF WHICH IS ATTACHED eu 390d 9G6vZ98�paT8 bT=TT TO®Z/8T/98 Regulatory Services 1HWE r ti Thomas F.Geiler,Director °.. Building Division MMSTeai:e. Elbert C Ulshoeffer,Jr. Building Commissioner&639. _ e� 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 Notice of Zoning Ordinances Violation(s) and Order to Cease. Desist and Abate: Mr.James M.Sanborn and all persons having notice of this order. As owner/occupant of the premiseststructure located at 122 White Oak Trail,Assessor's Map 192 Parcel 198,you are hereby notified that you are in violation of the Town of Barnstable Zoning Ordinances and are ORDERED this date,June 1,2001 to: CEASE AND DESIST IMMEDIATELY,all functions connected with this violation on or at the above • mentioned premises. SUMMARY OF VIOLATION: Storing,garaging/keeping commercial business equipment is a violation of section 3-1.3 and 4-1.1 of the zoning ordinance COMMENCE within seven(7)days,action to abate this violation. SUMMARY OF ACTION-TO ABATE: Remove alfcommercial equipment relative to business barbecue(smokers)within 30 days of receipt of this notice. And,if aggrieved by this notice and order,to show cause as to why you should not be required to do so,by filing ati appeal with the Town Clerk of Barnstable,a—Nb i .of Appeal.(specifying the ground thereof) within-thirty(30)days of the receipt of this order(in accordance with Capter 40A Section 15 of the Massachusetts General Laws). If,at the expiration of the time allowed,action to abate this violation has not commenced,further action as the law requires will be taken.. By order, uilding �o�,'inissioner/% Certified Mail 7000 0520 0021 82813636 R.R.R. g010531b f Asse'ssor's offioe (1st floor): p h F !..! ...... "+1 °` F THE T0� Assessor's map and lot number ................/. Board�af Health (3rd•floor): f`11 rALLED IN COMPLI � Sewa a Permit number �..0.......:.................. ... . g k , , . WITH TITLE 5 , : BAHMAB LE, 639. Engineering Department (3rd floor): �.. � , � �� E�1�/6RONA�Ei�1'�'AL CODE Housenumber. ... .............................................................:..... YPY d' ti TOWN REGUL�►TIONS APPLICATIONS PROCESSED. 8:30�-9:30 A.M. and 1:00'-2:00 P.M. only ; TOWN OF BAR•NSTABLE } . PUILDI-K. INSPECT-OR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO ....... ... /' .. TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION ..... .AVG ..........:............................................. ....................................... Y A( v.....•.........................19: TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: '• �` The uridersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the follow'n information: . Location ...... �. .(�!�. .. :(. �. D.2� .......................... Proposed Use ... ,e�t�6 �,.i... .......... ...................................... }. .k . �. Zoning District ....... ' .Fire District Er2 ✓a��y� - �? �, '� v�C. Name of Owner '...Address ,�C .�/aV/ .... .. .. Name of Builder l � 111✓� G Address � 41vX/- .. ' . .. . . . . . ...... ... . . . . : T t 7 Name of Architect .............,.. .......................:.'.............Address ................,...........:................................ r Number of Rooms ......`...... -2 c y....... .........................Fou'ndation ....... Exterior ........Roofing ..... .......... .... ................ .. ........ .. Floors .. .�.... i% ...........Interior .... .. . : ...^..................................... �... Heating /....�/�.� �......:...........:..........:................. ..Plumbing ......:l...... ...T. .. Fireplace .:.....:....... ...... .. .......................................................Approximate Cost .......... . .. �:,•''�?.. ....... r fp �hU 77 Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board -------------------__-.----- 9 Aea ..... r ..............2 ��• Diagram .of Lot andBuilding, with Dimensions ' ' Fee ... . SUBJECT TO APPROVAL ,OF BOARD OF HEALTH t _ -Cap' Ile OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIREb-FOR NEW DWELLINGS , [" hereby agree to conform: to all the Rules and Regulations of the.Town arnstoble'�egar i g the above construction. ' Name .. ......Y. ........ Construction Supervisor's {License .®.6.. .... .......... BROWN, DAVID . . . .Permit" for•BREEZE69A�C §�'•GARAGEt `i • Location 122 White Oak., Trail Centerville F Cent " 0t:. . .. . . .*. . . . . . . . i Sr Owner. David•Brown. . . . .`. . . . . . �` rTYPe, of Construction: Fr-ame ` r �p E Plot. . ... . . . . . Lot. : . '. . . .: . . . . I' Permit "Granted. 'Novembe•r 19 i-. , 9 86 ' Date of Inspection. 19 {' -Date' completed . ._. . . 19 . . ;-^ � - • _�� f •� r t y sr ^+y Y M F its N jr - - - ^� ..-r... ,., ' 1. r .t ,, - .F �f. �•}�« ! <_.�. ., � � .��•- r , ` r 12 2-6 Prohibited Uses 2-6 .1 Application and Scope: The following uses are prohibited in all zoning districts : ` 1) Any use which is injurious, noxious or offensive by reason of the emission of odor, fumes, dust, smoke, vibration, noise, lighting or other cause. 2) A tent maintained or occupied for living or business purposes, except as permitted in Section 2-5 . 1 (4) above . (Changed by Town Council vote on 2122196 as item #95-I94-by a 9 Yes 2 No roll call vote. ) 3) A trailer parked, stored or occupied for living or business purposes, except as specifically provided for in Section 2-5 erein. 4) Hotels and motels in precincts 1,. 2 , 4 , 6, and 7 as existing on November 9., 1983 , except in the IND LIMITED and IND Industrial Districts . ��st t RESIDENTIAL :PROPERTY MAP NO. LOT NO. _ FIRE DISTRICT SUMMARY STREET 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville 74 LAND 192 198 C-0 Ol BLDGS. OWNER TOTAL 9 RECORD OF TRANSFER DATE BK PG I.R.S. REMARKS: Lot �U LC 2 -F Sheet 1 P� LAND 125 Ol BLDGS. Grosboy! -v t-f -31561 TOTAL d 5Ci' • - LAND BLDGS. TOTAL Edward Bamforth; LAND - 47 138.=11 lots) m BLDGS: Wilber; Bernard-1--Elizabeth J W 1=14=76 °tf: 66373, 535/9 TOTAL LAND Brown, David B. & Nancy P. (tens ent) 8 30-79 Ctf. 9281 $9,500, rn BLDGS. ti/h,7-p- DA k 1'��i L '��.�T� / v ,/lam M TOTAL LAND /Hit Z25- k Co d1 / (1 BLDGS. TOTAL LAND a) BLDGS. TOTAL LAND INTERIOR INSPECTED: BLDGS. DATE: TOTAL LAND ACREAGE COMPUTATIONS Of BLDGS. LAND TYPE # OF ACRES PRICE TOTAL DEPR. VALUE TOTAL HOUSE LOT t LAND CLEARED FRONT v v BLDGS. REAR TOTAL WOODS&SPROUT FRONT LAND REAR BLDGS. WASTE FRONT TOTAL REAR LAND BLDGS. TOTAL LAND Of BLDGS. LOT COMPUTATIONS LAND FACTORS TOTAL FRONT DEPTH STREET PRICE DEPTH % FRONT FT.PRICE TOTAL DEPR. COR. INF. VALUE HILLY TOWN SEWER LAND ROUGH TOWN WATER BLDGS. HIGH GRAVEL RD. TOTAL LOW DIRT RD. LAND SWAMPY BLDGS. F sUNDATION BSMT. & ATTIC PLUMBING PRICING . Base Conc.Walls �✓ Fin. Bsmt.Area Bath Room LAND COST / �0 Conc. Blk.Walls Bsmt. Rec. Room St. COST t. Shower Bath Bsmt. Conc. Slab BUM.Garage St. Shower Ext. PORCH. DATE ,I Walls PORCH. PRICE. �/ ;"'�%;-•,�,.,.':.'''''~ Brick Walls Attic FL 8 Stairs Toilet Room Roof RENT �• Stone Walls Fin.Attic Two Fixt. Bath Floors Piero. INTERIOR FINISH Lavatory Extra Bsmt. 1 2 3 Sink /D s/a r/= yx Plaster Attic /? Water Clo. Extra 24, /1 EXTERIOR WALLS Knotty Pine Water Only Double Siding VjAj y Plywood No Plumbing Bsmt. Fin. ,y Single Siding Plasterboard Int. Fin. H --- W'U Shingles 3ly TILING Z/ ' Conc. Blk. G F P Bath Fl. Heat f Q'a 7 y v Face Brk.On Int.Layout All, Bath Fl.&Wains. Auto Ht.Unit 7` Veneer Int.Cond. /✓' Bath FI. &Walls i� Fireplace D 'y-�. (•-� Cam. Brk.On HEATING Toilet Rm. FI. Solid Cam.Brk. Hot Air Toilet Rm.FI. &Wains. Plumbing / Steam Toilet Rm.FI. &Walls Tiling /3� Blanket Ins. 010, Hot Water B13 CIAI St. Shower Roof Ins. Air Cond. Tub Area Total Floor Furn. ROOFING _ COMPUTATIONS Asph. Shingle Pipeless Furn. L-1 S. F. J (� Wood Shingle No Heat S.F. SD 0 Asbs. Shingle Oil Burner / / / 70 / 034,(O(� S. F. Slate Coal Stoker S. F. Tile Gas ✓ S.F. OUTBUILDINGS ROOF TYPE Electric Gable Flat S.F. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 MEASURED Hip Mansard FIREPLACES S. F. Pier Found. Floor Gambrel Fireplace Stack Wall Found. 0. H. Door LISTE FLOOR Fireplace -' Sgle.Sdg. Roll Roofing Conc. LIGHTING Dble.Sdg. Shingle Roof Earth No Elect. DATE Shingle Walls Plumbing Hardwood ROOMS Cement Blk. Electric Asph.Tile Bsmt. 1st TOTAL �, / Brick Int. Finish PRICED Single 2nd 3rd FACTORTt REPLACEMENT .•/ y �(� OCCUPANCY CONSTRUCTION SIZE AREA CLASS AGE REMOD. COND. REPL. VAL. Phy.Dep. PHYS. VALUE Funct.Dep. ACTUAL VAL. DVVLG. 7d 1 2 3 4 5 6 -7 it B 9 10 TOTAL PROPERTY ADDRESS ZONING I DISTRICT CODE SP DISTS.I DATE PRINTED I CSTATE LASS I PCS I NBHD KEY NO. 0122 WHITE OAK TRAIL 10 RC .300 loco 07/09/95 1011 JO 37AC R112 198. 1181O.LAND/OTHER FEATURES DESCRIPTION ADJUSTMENT FACTORS T 61 Lana ey/Dale Sae D�menswn y UNIT ADJ'D.UNIT ACRES/UNITS VALUE Dasc,,,,_ S A'48 O R N P J A M E S M 3 BONNIE J MAP-CD. FF-De m/gaes LOC./YR.SPEC.CLASS ADJ. COND. PE PRICE PRICE 4 L A N D 32,500 S CARD IN ACCOUNT L BLDG_STT 1 X` .6 =10 131 39999.9 52399.9 .62 32500 49LDG(S)-CARD-1 1 101,100 01 OF 01 A BATHS '1 .0 U X #0THER FEATURE 1 700 --�1 g4 * N C= 100 3500.0 3500.0 ' 1.00 3500 3 #PL 122 JHITE OAK TRAIL ARKET 89800 D FIREPLACE U X C 100 3100.0 3100.00 1.0U 3100 3 qDL LOT 34 INCOME SHED S 8 X 8 1984 C= 94 11.7 10.95 64 700 F #32 12J80 31 $00040000 I SE A #RR 1829 0135 APPRAISED VALUE D i YCL22 A 134P300 `A U 1TA9 175.00 PARCEL SUMMARY T S #FAB 175.U0 AND 32500 A T LDGS 101100 M 0-IMPS 700 OTAL 1.34300 E INE CNST E DEED REFERENCE Type DATE R-.,Cetl PRIOR YEAR VALUE A T soak Page Insl. MO. V.D S.1-Pricy AND 32500 T S C115327 1 9/38 180000 LDGS 101800 U C792-1 D8/79 9500 TOTAL 134300 R E BUILDING PERMIT 9/8 9 EST NO G L A S LAND LAND-ADJ ' INC ME I SE SP-BEDS FEATURES BLD-ADJS UNITS Number Data Type Amount 32.500 1 7001 6600 B30204 11J86 AD 25000 Class Consl. Total Base Rale AO.Rate B It. A Norm. Obsv. Units Units 1 A u f I qe Dep, Cona. CND Loc %R-G Rep, Cost New Aa, Repl Value Stories Reigbt Rooms Rms B.tns •Fix. I P.rtywnil F.o. o1C 000 110 110 58.10 63.91 80 80.14 87 100 87 116150 101100 1 .J 6 4 1.0 4.0 Descnplion Rate Square Feet Repl.Cost : 1 0 O IMP.By/DATE: ME 9/8 9 SCALE: 1/0 J.5 6 ELEMENTS CODE CONSTRUCTION DETAIL S BAS 100 63.91 1144 73113 MK7.INDEX c t I ; a T UFO 60 38.35 88 3375 * 14- -TYT_E Jl . AiSED RANCH 5.0 FWD 85 6.50 172 1462 ! FWD 12 DESrGN-ADJ;MT- _J1D SIG'N--ADJUST` .-0 R 1S8 IOC 63.91 132 8436 13 ! EXTcR=WA-UC3-- -TO t.L-9207-SHIN5-1E---Y7:0 U G14 60 35.35 576 22090 + *-1U-*------44----------* SEAT/AC TYPt JI�a�=HDT_WATF-R -iJ.O C FOP 3.5 22.37 48 1074 *-----24-----*--12*-= + T NT-_R: I�Ii3H- J4J�YWALL ------ ---J.0 ! G14 111 S3 . 11 ! Ir4 ER=LAY00T- -T2 +:lE, tv(iR U ! ! ! ! INTcR:7?IxCTY_ -J2:� ?TE-AS-EXTFR:-- =0 R ! BASE 26 FL L R-STKUCT- -U2 IT-J07ST18T-A-M----a=0 A w2"4 24FOP 4 + cFt ri7R-%JVER -U4 P T--- -------u=G' L D 220 1276 ! *--12--* + OOF.-TYY-E ---- -.01JXB-F_Ew-A-SPA-StT---Y .n E Total Areas Aux= B..a = BUILDING DIMENSIONS ! i ! ! E L c�:T R I?`tfiL iJ I AVE R Ar -7'0 T i3A-SW 4 UFO Si)2 E44 Not W44 .. ! + I + T i A BAS N26 FwID S01 15B W12 u14 W24 *----- UFO 01-4DAT�Jl9-'- -07 -UUR;t�--CONE-----v .-9 24-----* *-----------44----------X -------------- - ------------------------- I - S24. E24 N24 .. 1S8 Sll FOP SO4 *-----------44----------* -----NEIuKBJI' 0JG S7AC-TENTEl7VILL-F-- L E12 N04 . W12 1SB E12 N11 LAND TOTAL MARKET FWD W04. N13 E14 S12 W10 .. BAS PARCEL 32500 134300 E44 S26 .. AREA 965 VARIANCE +0 +13300 STANDARD 25 22 ' I . 3 RC, RD, RF-1 and RG Residential Districts 1) Principal Permitted Uses: The following uses are permitted in the RC, RD, RF-1 and RG Districts: i ntial dwelling (detached) . A) Single-family reside 2) Accessory Uses: The following uses are permitted as RD RF-1 and RG Districts : accessory uses in the RC, 1 i A) Keeping, stabling and maintenance of horses subject to the provisions of Section 3-1 . 1 (2) (B) herein. 3) Conditional Uses: The following uses are permitted as conditional uses in the RC, RD, RF-1 and RG Districts, provided a Special Permit is first obtained from the Zoning s subject to the provisions of Section 5-3 . 3 Board 0 pP f Appeals 7 herein and subject to the specific standards for such conditional uses as required in this section: A) Public or private regulation golf courses subject to the provisions of Section 3-1 . 1 (3) (B) herein. Kee in stabling and maintenance of horses in excess of l! B) p g the density provisions of Section 3-1 . 1 (2) (B) (b) herein, either on the same or adjacent lot as the principal j building to which such use is accessory. C) Family Apartment subject to the provisions of Section 3- 1 . 1 (3) (D) herein. D) Windmills and other devices for the conversion of wind echanical energy, but only as an energy to electrical or m accessory use. 4) Special Permit Uses: The following uses are permitted as special permit uses in the RC, RD, RF-1 and RG Districts, irst obtained from the Planning i provided a Special Permit is f Board: A) Open Space Residential Developments subject to the tion 3-1 . 7 herein. provisions- of Sec i 5.) Bulk Regulations : ZONING MIN .LOT MIN.LOT MIN.LOT MINIMUM IN FT. HEIGHT MINLDFT. DISTS . AREA FRONTAGE WIDTH SETBACKS SQ.FT. IN FT. IN FT . --------------- FRONT SIDE REAR 30 * �! RC 43560**. 20 100 20 # 10 10 30 * RD 43560** 20 125 30 # 15 15 30 * RF-1 43560** 20 125 30 # 15 15 200 30 # 15 15 30 * RG 65000 20 �t 1 ii I; Health Complaints 09-Mar-98 Time: 4:00:00 PM Date: 3/5/98 Complaint Number: 1227 Referred To: EDWARD BARRY Taken By: L.S. Complaint Type: NUISANCE CONTROL REG. 1 RUBBISH Article X Detail: OWNER JANES SANBORN Business Name: SOUTHERN PRIDE Number: 122 Street: WHITE OAK Village: CENTERVILLE Assessors Map_Parcel: 192- 198 Complainant's Name: ANONYMOUS Address: Telephone Number: Complaint Description: THERE ARE FOUR COMMERCIAL COOKING DEVICES ON THE FRONT LAWN OF THIS RESIDENCE AND COMPLAINANT WOULD LIKE IT CHECK OUT. Actions Taken/Results: ON SITE THERE ARE THREE COMMERCIAL WOOD BURNING SMOCKERS PARKED IN THE YARD. THESE ARE DEMOSTRATORS FOR HIS BUSINESS "SOUTHERN PRIDE' WHERE HE SELLS THESE SMOCKERS. EACH SMOCKER IS ON A TRAILER. IN ADDITION TO THESE HE HAS A PULL BEHIND CATERING TRAILER " LA PIZZERIA". THERE IS ALSO A CABIN CRUISER COVERED WITH A BLUE TARP BEHIND THE CATERING TRAILER. THERE IS A PILE OF METAL AND WOOD DEBRI ON THE GROUND TO THE LEFT OF THE GARAGE Investigation Date: 3/9/98 Investigation Time: 12:30:00 PM 1 • i s }£ F _ 1MEMa iz ire gp .+.�.- �- � a -, d IV f 3 i s fi isw a� VA �3s r �•' ' E S � Z � � ,y SEE E 49 € ,E t 1 i. Ntevens E `�� 203 E„• Old Sta e Road~ "F EN E V ,><, F EEE tt?4 gil ��' F• '�.x.�� 31.:r.i. �.4, h�, �K Anonymous O, �x � E h�l��••. '.dtlt,� �.� jE .�. 3». Interior and exterior construction taking place . during the past two years without a building permit. •q EEC ((�t ;E� `}�l 'E�u�@E�EtE �5 _� rE'{t ?"kku'' .2€ .: .xFt {"EE• Ftt.. � J it EET i E R SE � t ik€ •• E E 4 ,»_. �R F€E E!!`����(��t"�E} »���E'�'�* . €U; E i htt :ttttt}y 316981 iii>.192198 :<.}. .......... �F,.y> > :.BUILDING {: itti+^?iii �?4>i+ii•r't�ttt:it:iiiiiiti;:i`};:�i�:�`v`�`tiiti .};:}'.:.::i•}Xv;::.w.w:::•.vi^::w};}:•}:•}:G:G:G:G:•}:•:�:•: :iCiiiLi}}::•.ii•}:.w::;•}}:G.v:}::•}:?•:vv{•.v:}:{•;}i}:vii•}}:•}iv}.v::�•. ...:.nv.,::::.}yvvvvvvvvvv;::::.w::.�:::::.vxvv::. w::::n•:.v::::v.«w::::.xvvvv�:::nw.:vw:n:::vvv::•::vvv:•.:•v. .v.v.v:m:�::.,.:::.w:::::..:.v::.:::..v.vvvv.w:.vv:v •.�•:.•:. •:::::::::.::::..v ..:..::•. •:•. ••::.-. -::::...:. ::::::::::::::::::::::y:.�::::::.vvvvw::::.>.ti•.:d:.>.::it::.::.:.i:..i.::::i:vvvv:.iv.istiiiiv{;tttt}Yk}::,.vv:.v,:::..CLy}Y>vvi :::::.w.v:::.�.};:::::::.v..v:::::}:•.v:..:::: .vxvv.•.•.•�•.vvv.•�•.•.r.•.•�j•.•.-:::::::.:�.,v::..}xw:::.}yn}vvvy::n;.j•:ti,}}.; .4 ;: ' •••��7:•:1: iiiri.:<tiLLitv:`.>.iii{i�` <<Y'~.,}iM1tt•. {} iiitit>•:• vvvv • vvv '•..:.v:•.v•}:: :•:v4!c:•i:ti ii>.}::>.::t>.:i is .v:: ::i::..... ...,v,•:::::.;•::::::::::.:•::::;:::nw:.v::•.vw.v: .v.vxw:.:v. ,••}};:•::::+a:: :•:vx}.:}::::f•.v vvvv4:v:•.viS}•.}:i.:u.}:•:vvvtiivv +bb iivxii•.iiiii•.vv i••.:::.:'xixxvivvyir ANBURN >'WHITEAK TRAIL::M1 E V L - ;C?4"...:'>.-..-•.•.:•....;. •.}:������������}}}}tit:�:::%: :.}}.: ::i :•`:41 ::t: ''� :: :}: ::;`:•,`: :;%::M1�:: `:` ::,`:: :?::?` :�`:�� ;.;•.}},•.,}•.;•:.;;.;•.;::;::::.::.} ....:...::::.:::::. HB EI G ORS ...., Ma � i .v.;.:,•}:ti.:{iiL.:x•.vvvv::tiiiivi':i: �y .:}:. ::..v.•v xi::•:vvw:::.:w.vvvvvxvv v:iii::::tiG:tiL>. v}}v} •'.ttt::22222 iitti� R �. BUSINESS OM4.HOUS E—,,, THEY ARE GOING T G O TAKE P U PETIT ION.N. VE RY ERY UPSET.ET. S >x> .......:...... ......... ....... G.U.WILL GO ON SITE AND TAKE PI CTL7RES. i f G�/-d 1L.tL! L. zG- N Gz'� •/J C C . f :.,•::::::::...:::::::::::. :::.:::.:is,,...,:..:....::::::�>:: .}:.::::::.:::::.,..,..,,,,, .:::;>.iii.}:i.}:iiii.:i.:i<>...,,,,,•::::.,,• 7 u lu 7 � � 1 i � � � --- ---�- a a&w � � &,en yoel a,d&fice lwaz*to to de k* &wwl acm del&I-eeelmwi, to-aw Gl ia.�aico izocu andael t/w w, - �re�lieu, �ivi�G�fe'r�ie/L wn,can,ta4ee��A(�P,lAaAd 076Aadlol-6�-- yllm-alAaldfem do to-c001 d � sin 6�ente�vi/,� f L&AAAYYa6 i/vkgi Ya�vYY . ComplainVInqui y Report - �. Assessor's&L �f Date: Ree d br. ye Z 1 Complaint Name: Location Address: m1Pqz Originator Name: ( e �G Q_.2 c��Ct_� K :� GYl U(.IL,( 1 . Street Wage: State: Zip: -Telephone:D/E Complaint ascription 41 rr Inquiry Description: For Office Use Only Inspector's Action/Comments, Date• Inspector. Follow-up, Action Additional Info.Attached Copy Distribution: White-Depamnent File I'ello;v-Inspector pink-Inspector(Return to Office:lfanagrr) rTMA a ";�t4 y �'�" n 15- s. i b•d 't r n"b 61- fir F+'F- Y ♦g+y,� �y� -'+y'-3 j F'��t"��ry q ��}'•fA b 3 Y W�l IN A P— ii��rr-� �t s xr- (r !1 Of MIN'. �,i�-.�• p-" ''t,'i 3 r' Sssr3.+�y j .; 4'�Ea tZ' t ,+aG ? - .�f"P.c '�""'r C.�e •.3nT.� c�tt-` ;,1„Y, •,€ }.� sa S�• P 4 ; � 9Y? -tp 4 wn 14, - zc ;.� .«,t`i+`'�' 3w� - � Fes• J -A q ,F . i `.s,......-.�.-•-' i s fit'*--_ y'F'`�.- a a 3" 1'*i Y �a K.. „�. Pn12 Mix� �r � r#"�'4 �` �C�,y�:3,� � r< � �`�t'g�,• a �s'�?"'� #f ^3�.' � �� `L"pJ._�"-Y '8.�,�'4f '�^�,17"`� ���T t`•-te" � _ �ES� ,.����'•",A. � � i��a��• +�'' � �tF�� � _ r,t. £��•,/A��y� .�^+ , a h�_„zr �t�b ^i��sr � ^,.�{y�l '�+•�ag� �'-aY' lT r n�v 5 -Al Jr I r� i rolli. f FIFA Building Depart menc ort �] Complaint/Inquiry Re P I Rec'd by: Assessor's No.: Complaint Name: Location (.���iJ P „9I l SA j l!�L'✓Pl�'Y./ P Address: /�� M/P Originator Name• - Street: 2: WW41 � ��lC lw/l vale: Telephone: D/Tr 3 � 7 7 Z 'G 7i1L Complaint ❑ /r� �, Description: .,L_, iiiquIXY Description: For Office Use Only Inspector's Action/Comments Dace: Inspector. I Follow-up Action Additional Info.,Attached Cop},Distnbuaon: Mike-Department File Yello;v-Inspector Pink-Inspector(Retum to Office Manager) °FTHE °� The Town of Barnstable BAMSTABM 1e� Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services prFo r��" Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-790-6227 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner ago "^ emu a ti ovw- S ij JhL L- ✓ � l� Svc �` �. �i.� �(/L, (zD�"(Iq Prt")n W-&,)L,O �� Ck-- L uuu.aaa6 L...rda uu%.AAJ6 - y CompIainUkquiiy Report � � 4 Date: (7/7/ Rec'd r Assessor's No.: Complaint Name- . Location. Address: AUP Originator Name Street: Ytllage: State: Zip: Telephone:D/E Complaint Description: &Ljl& 4V4,4--�k J Oil lt/&, Inquiry Description: For Office Use Only Inspector's Action/Comments Date: Inspector. Follow-up Action Additional Info.Attached Copy Di=budon: White-Deparrmcnt File YeBow-Inspector Pink-Inspector(Retum to Olfce:lfanagrr) - V 1• t - �}p�- ,}gym A � `fr f -�i� tnn ./.CAI/' 1'_B..H' Y� " Lul " wm� ,Q a Building Department Complain nquiry Report Date: 5 o? Rec'd by: Assessor's No.:----- Complaint Narne: Location Address: ��a W��J P Q1,91-( r l!�/U✓PIeY� WP Originator Name: Street: vva�: state: zip:�L6 3 y Telephone:D/E Complaint F� Description: Ingwry Description: For Office Use Only Inspector's Inspector. Action/Comments Dace: rollow up Action Additional Info. Attached Cop}•Distribution: White-Depamnent File Yellow-Inspector Pik-Inspector(getum to OlFce Manager) MARK H. BOUDREAU ATTORNEYAT LAW Law Offices of PHILIP M.BOUDREAU Area Code 508 396 North Street Telephone-775-1085 Hyannis,Massachusetts 02601 Fax-771-0722 Iate m a Postage $ C. 49 rLi j cc Certified Fee r im Return Receipt Fee 11�1_ i H811 ru (Endorsement Required) JUI, O Restricted Delivery Fee O (Endorsement Required) O Total Postage&Feesru Ln Recipient's Name (Please Print early)(To be completed by mailer) G Street,Apt.No.; r PO Box No. C3-- �r --� ---T'��L ........ ------- M1 State,ZIP+4 , I Certified Mail Provides: o A mailing receipt ` o A unique identifier for your mailpiece o A signature upon delivery m A record of delivery kept by the Postal Service for two years Important Reminders: o Certified Mail may ONLY be combined with First-Class Mail or Priority Mail. ®Certified Mail is not available for any class of international mail. 0 NO INSURANCE COVERAGE IS PROVIDED with Certified Mail. For valuables,please consider Insured or Registered.Mail. r o For arladditional fee,a Return Receipt may be requested to provide proof of delivery.To obtain Return Receipt service,please complete and attach a Return Receipt(PS Form 3811)to the article and add applicable postage to cover the fee.Endorse mailpiece"Return Receipt Requested".To receive a fee waiver for a duplicate return receipt,a USPS postmark on your Certified Mail receipt is required. e For an additional fee, delivery may be restricted to the addressee or addressee's authorized agent.Advise the clerk or mark the mailpiece with the endorsement"Restricted Delivery". n If a postmark on the Certified Mail receipt is desired,please present the arti- cle at the post office for postmarking. If a postmark on the Certified Mail receipt is not needed,detach and affix label with postage and mail. IMPORTANT:Save this receipt and present it when making an inquiry. PS Farm 3800,February 2000(Reverse) 102595-00-M-1489 a SENDER: I also wish to receive the ■Complete items 1 and/or 2 for additional services. f011oW1n services for an rn ■Complete items 3,4a,and 4b. g d ■Print your name and address on the reverse of this form so that we can return this extra fee): .y. card to you. al d ■Attach this form to the front of the mailpiece,or on the back if space does not 1.❑ Addressee's Address u L permit. 2.❑ Restricted Delivery to � e Write"Return Receipt Requested"on the mailpiece below the article number. ■The Return Receipt will show to whom the article was delivered and the date Consult postmaster for fee. delivered. P O o 3.Article Addressed to: 4a.Article Number 0 v S¢/N8O�/✓ c� 5ao rr�3/ / CD d �3'�Yt S N l�o�/'�(v3y c CL 4b.Service Type :3E Z 2— bO _� ©A-e- Z ❑ Registered eCertified 0 n Cn Ile / ��3 El Express Mail [I insured re/ ' ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise ❑ COD 0 7.Date of eli ery o a L 6 i ' 0 ¢ 5.Received By: (Print Name) 8.Addre see'S Address(Only if requested Y and fee is paid) Ml 6.Sign t e:(Addressee or Agent) -T Ps 811,December 1994 102595-98-B-0229 Domestic Return Receipt t I l UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE M., O� F W PM sLA .=a-m O Print your n e,`adt# s and ZIP G Town of Barnstable � Building Division $67 Main St. Hyannis�,MA 02601 e �Is� etAez-, �'� r 1 J Cog �o Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services Thomas F.Geiler,Director Building Division Elbert C Ulshoeffer,Jr.,Building Commissioner 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 May 31,2001 James M Sanborn t 122 White Oak Trail Centerville,MA 02632 RE: 122 White Oak Trail,Centerville Dear Mr. Sanborn: I have read the file relating to the complaints of operating a business from your premises at 122 White Oak Trail. Your house is located in an RC residential zone,as such the storing,keeping,garaging of equipment for business purposes is not a permitted accessory use under the provisions of section 4-1.1 of the Town of Barnstable Zoning ordinance. In order to continue to store/garage commercial equipment i.e.smokers, you will need to obtain a variance from the above section granted by the Zoning Board of Appeals. Enclosed please find notice of violation and order to desist and abate. Sincerely, 7 Elbert Ulshoeffe , r, Building Commissioner EU/er certification#7000 0520 0021 8281 3636 h 4 g010529a r Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services �d °FTHE tpk� Thomas F.Geiler,Director °s Building Division BARNSTABL'E, Elbert C Ulshoeffer,Jr. Building Commissioner KAS§. g :° ATen 339. p,0 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-.6230 Notice of Zoning Ordinances Violation(s) and Order to Cease, Desist and Abate: Mr.James M. Sanborn and all persons having notice of this order. As owner/occupant of the S premises/structure located at 122 White Oak Trail,Assessor's Map 192 Parcel 198,you are hereby notified that you are in violation of the Town of Barnstable Zoning Ordinances and are ORDERED this date,June 1,2001 to.- CEASE AND DESIST IMMEDIATELY,all functions connected with this violation on or at the above mentioned premises. SUMMARY OF VIOLATION: Storing,garaging/keeping commercial business equipment is a violation of section 3-1.3 and 4-1.1 of the zoning ordinance COMMENCE within seven(7)days,action to abate this violation. y SUMMARY OF ACTION TO.ABATE: Remove all.commercial equipment relative to business barbecue(smokers)within 30 days of receipt of this notice. And,if aggrieved by this notice and order,to show cause as to why you should not be required to do so,by filing an appeal with the Town Clerk of Barnstable,a Notice of Appeal(specifying the ground thereof) within`thirty(30)days of the receipt of this order(in accordance with Chapter 40A Section 15 of the Massachusetts General Laws). If,at the expiration of the time allowed,action to abate this violation has not commenced,further action as the law requires will be taken. By order, j Building Commissioner• Certified Mail 7000 0520 0021 8281 3636 R.R.R. ti 1 g010531b r - LAW OFFICES OF PHILIP M. BOUDREAU 396 NORTH STREET HYANNIS,MASSACHUSETTS 02601 (508)775-1085 TELEFAX(508)771-0722 PHILIP M.BOUDREAU PHILIP MICHAEL BOUDREAU October 22 , 2001 MARK H.BOUDREAU Peter F. Di Matteo Building Inspector' s Office 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 Re: James M. Sanborn 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville Dear Mr. Di Matteo: As a follow-up to our recent meeting at your office, and in light of the hearing on September 18 , 2001, my client is agreeable to the following conditions relative -to his residence at 122 White Oak Trail in Centerville: ( 1) He shall remove all commercial barbeque equipment/smokers, - with the exception of the Southern Pride .unit currently on a trailer. This unit shall' be moved to the back yard and - enclosed in .a temporary _garage-type structure not located within the rear or sideline setback appurtenant to the residential "C" District. . , (2 ) This single unit shall be for his personal use so that no business activity is associated with it at the residential site. (3 ) Further, Mr: Sanborn agrees not to have barbeque "smokeouts" with his friends, whether or not they are entirely for . private non-business purposes. (4 ) As he has . done previously, Mr. Sanborn will not demonstrate his unit, at his house or cook any food for eventual sale there. I Peter F. Di. Matteo - 2 - October 22, 2001 I believe this constitutes our discussion and agreement relative to the October 2., 2001 meeting at your office. If I have mis-stated anything, please .contact me immediately so that. this may be rectified. ` Sincerely, Mark H. Boudreau MHB:kb cc: James M. Sanborn Law Offices of Philip M. Boudreau P M ��°� 396 North Street cs. c Hyannis; MA 02601 J zz OCT ' 0 0� Peter Di Matteo, Bldg. Com Building Inspector' s Office Town of Barnstable 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 !• ._.� "'!"_ ✓•..f f �i�!!!!llt�fi-�13l�lSl.!!!lj.1lil�liYelt�l?!!Ii!7�lS.TI.£�i)!!?�t3�S 711 Vsp� / P THIS ENVELOPE IS RECYCLABLE AND MADE WITH 100% . > > t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t t [ t t c It Hit t t 11 t t 11 .RECYCLED PAPER, 30% POST-CONSUMER CONTENT i LAW OFFICES OF PHILIP M. BOUDREAU 396 NORTH STREET HYANNIS,MASSAGHUSETTS 02601 3 (508)775-1085 TELEFAX (508)771-0722 PHILIP M. BOUDREAU PHILIP MICHAEL BOUDREAU October 22 , 2001 MARK H.BOUDREAU Peter F. Di Matteo Building Inspector' s Office 367 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 Re: James M. Sanborn 122 White Oak Trail, Centerville Dear Mr. Di Matteo: As a follow-up to our recent meeting at your office, and in light of the hearing on September 18 , 2001, my client is agreeable to the following conditions relative to his residence at 122 White Oak Trail in Centerville: ( 1) He shall remove all commercial barbeque equipment/smokers, with the exception of the Southern Pride unit currently on a trailer. This unit shall be moved to the back yard and enclosed in a temporary garage-type structure not located within the rear or sideline setback appurtenant to the residential "C" District. (2 ) This single unit shall be for his personal use so that no business activity is associated with it at the residential site. ( 3 ) Further, Mr. Sanborn agrees not to have barbeque "smokeouts" with his friends, whether or not they are entirely for private non=business purposes. (4 ) As he has done previously, Mr. Sanborn will not demonstrate his unit .at his house or cook any food for eventual sale there. Peter F. Di Matteo - 2 - October 22, 2001 I believe this constitutes our discussion and agreement relative to the October 2 , 2001 meeting at your office. If I have mis-stated anything, please contact me immediately so that this may be rectified. Sincerely, f f Mark H. Boudreau MHB:kb cc: James M. Sanborn SR,''k` t 4 0' ` `v 51 a F 3; rs, 4 z - r NAME OF OFFENDER __..._._ ..,..._.._...�...._.�._..__.....r....,_...,__._ _.._�...,.�.,.._._...._. .._ __.,._ —_..�,�..=.ter -_ TOWN OF • ADDRESS OF OFFENDER '' "J t� BAR :_ (� r ; BARNSTABLE �' � CITY.ST IP CODE •. 2 d jS w df tHE •� �Z�+ 3'..Z �.�•�,�., � � a ,.fr� MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER IMXNtiI'AXLF., OFFEN$ - } A 71ME AND DATE OF VIOLATION�� ��• : . � - O f � � 0 �''-' NOTICE OF .LOCATION F VIOLA710N =i (A.Mr/P.M.)ON „19 w ) W VIOLATION SIGNATU OF ENFORCING PERSON �p - / W - , XA li a c7 �/ ENFORCING D ,Jamey �~ OF TOWN BADGE NO. Q a w � �* H�REBY'ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X Cl) m �" ; & : r~" ; ORDINANCE Unable to obtain signature of offender. OR Date mailed THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS Q YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION 2 WILL J r N REGULATION DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w (1)You may elect to pa the above fine,e8her b a O L OPERATE AS A FINAL a y Y ppearing in person between 8:30 A. Uj M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday Through Friday,legal holidays exce ¢ F � i before:The Bamstable Clerk E Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,orb mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,RO.Box 24 Hyannis,MA 02Go1,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE y �i NTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. pted, W i a ;(2)If ou desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceedin , y BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 0263 � s ( citation for a hearing. 9 You ma do so by making written request to IS COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST €�> 0,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this 1 �� (3)It you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing o to pay any fine determined at the hearing � r `� to be due criminal com taint ma be issued a ainst ou. iI HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ ' Signature x i �• :Y'.'ae '^�r83 .,.ra r_y: ..— -e. r�" - a 'fn,vun..,' s .- _ - _ �mrtw s _ / •-! _ NAME OF OFFENSE J. BAR- =J A I ADDRESS OF OFFENDER •__,,,,»- ,,� --�I --� - - I -CITY ST TE,ZIP CODE ) REGISTRATION NUMBER i T.. - MV/MB RE I Lu Qlgt, �-- i ) � W _ OFFENSE - _30. j• r J to X TIME AND DATE OF VIOLA N"N CATION 0 VIOLATION Z F LOCATION F VIOLA 10 w E OF f, , A.M)/P.M.)ON ' r� 19 , " J 3O SIGNATURE OF ENFORCIN ERSON' _ ENFORCING DEPT BADGE N0. w i m JION ,�. 0 I m WN M I H�RE13Y-ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X LU j X IANCE fable to obtain Signature of offender. � THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS Date mailed w YOU.HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO.DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL I. i I m DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. I I z re ATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W ,I i W m before:The Barnstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,orb mailing a check,money ordecor postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, w t > Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. ': ! ((2)1 If yyou desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,yyou mayy do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARiJSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNS TABLE,MA 02630,Attn:'21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of'this, citation for a hearing. >_ r (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing �j i M to be due,criminal com Iaint may be issued aQainst you. - ❑ 1 HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess.to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature E. i �1 - �.w ' _ r s w -.; � y,�t�z'zr�s - _ a( -,.++ t> ''.teie>?t. t � 22i{�k���}� > >2 sr, ram( ♦r . 'y i'•i'Z..QM.L` LEr G CZ (.. # � s 5 . 3 — _ i-� Nw- y� .R Nt 4tFH,� .�`+"�'E5t � ire w•.F 4 i} y � ',� LAW OFFICES OF PHILIP M. BOUDREAU O p 396 NORTH STREET O HYANNIS MASSACHUSETTS 02 601 Telephone:(508)775-1085 Telefax:(508)771-0722 Philip M. Boudreau Philip Michael Boudreau Mark H. Boudreau June 19, 2002 Clerk - 21 D Noncriminal Hearings First District Court P.O. Box 427 Barnstable, MA 02630-0427 Re: Appeal of Zoning Violation Notice Dear Sir or Madam: Please be advised that I represent James Sanborn in connection with a zoning violation notice which he received recently from the town of Barnstable. Although the notice is illegible (copy enclosed), we believe we are aware of the gist of the alleged violation and wish to appeal the same. Please notify this office of the date and time of the hearing. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, A �41r H. Boudreau MHB/AMB Enclosure Jcc Gloria Urenas/Building Dept. Town of Barnstable - 3 T .a'r.� ,. 'f:7♦ LR�`1� � f^�:'fj' 4R ! .,Yi � J IA..�\.t:.) x - 1 �f V r�-fj'uf." 7 s"'_. l ?l'yc; f�, ;?�:3 -Alp�� .5fe �f ,` trs�. t + t �rt.,. N�,. f,i4.t.� •fY >- KegU1aLuJLy OUL Vl%.Ua IKE roh� Thomas F.Geiler,Director Building Division LUMSTnsLL Elbert C Ulshoeffer,Jr. Building Commissioner v 'UAa • 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 Notice of Zoning Ordinances Violation(s) and Order to Cease, Desist and Abate: s Mr.James M.Sanborn and all persons having notice of this order. As owner/occupant of the premises/structure located at 122 White Oak Trail,Assessor's Map 192 Parcel 198,you are hereby notified that you are in violation of the Town of Barnstable Zoning Ordinances and are ORDERED this date,June 1,2001 to: CEASE AND DESIST IMMEDIATELY,all functions connected with this violation on or at the above mentioned premises. SUMMARY OF VIOLATION: ' Storing,garaging/keeping commercial business equipment is a violation of section 3-1.3 and 4-1.1 of the zoning ordinance COMMENCE within seven(7)days,action to abate this violation. SUMMARY OF ACTION•TO.ABATE: Remove allIcommercial equipment relative to business barbecue(smokers)within 30 days of receipt of this notice. And,if aggrieved by this notice and order,to show cause as to why you should not be required to do so,by filing ati appeal with the Town Clerk of Barnstable,a jqQ& _of Appeal-(specifying the ground thereof) withirr;thirty(30)days of the receipt of this order(in accordance with ChIpter 40A Section 15 of the Massachusetts General Laws). If,at the expiration of the time allowed,action to abate this violation has not commenced,further action as the law requires will be taken. By order, uilding Commissioner Certified Mail 7000 0520 002182813636 R.R.R. g010531b THE FOLLOWING IS/ARE THE BEST IMAGES FROM POOR i QUALITY ORIGINAL (S) 11 M -Aw it DATA f IN, NO.112 P.Zr22 UN 2 2 2001 16 J OF BARNSTABL BOARD OF APPEA TOWN OF BARAWARLE j Zonlnp Board of Appeals Application!or Other Powers Town gaWS Cfta: �roft°-� use or&-: Apped* Nsart�p Oaa Deddon Due The undersigned hereby applies to tie Zoning Dowd of Appeals for Um reasons Indicated: ApprcentName: JAMES M. SANBORN Phone: 508-775-1920 ApplicantAddresa_ 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL CENTERVILLE property Location: 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL, CENTERVILLE Property Owner. .TAMES M. SANBORN Phohs; 508-775=1920 AddreasofOwner. 122 WHITE OAK TRAIL CENTERVI LE Assessors MapiParcel NymbR; 19 2/19 8 zon kv district RC Groundwstm Oveft Dbtrkt This Is a request for. ] EdWCament Adlon Ixl APDeat ofAdministrattve Otllaai's DgcLgon [ ) Other Genww Powers -Please sosay: Whidt S*d"(s)of the Z*nkV Ordinance and/or M%.Chapter40A are you appealing to the Zoning Boars of Appeals? SECTION 4-1.1 OF THE TOWN OF:'BARNSTABLE ZONING ORDINANCE & SECTION 3-1.3 OF THE TOWN OF BARNSTABLE ZONING ORDINANCE Netur®of Appeal 6 0esctlption of Request: APPL•T CANT IS ARRFALING THE NOTICE OF ORDINANCE VIOLATION AND ORDER TO CEASE, DESIST AND ABATE 0 E 1 . 2001, A COPY OF WHICH IS ATTACHED. Attrch AddMFo0W Sh6W pNece a#y E© MVd 9Z6�Z9t3Z09 G6 01 M 1QQZ/9t/90 - 1 r' �Y E' NAME OF OFFENDER' i TOWN OF AODREssOFOFFENOER SAR I BARNSTABLE Clrv,ST IP CogE01 G Z G 3' Z, MVI MB REGISTRATION NUMBER 1 i 11ANNSTANIF.. Lu OFFENS . O ra�D elf NOTICE OF TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION �^� y�j�i` { J (A.M:/P.M.)ON LOCATION F VIOLATION j m w OR VIOLATION SIGNAT OF ENFORCING PERSON 19j J � ENFOgCING D _ �L GG , JJ BADGE NO. Q OF TOWN �I_HFEBY"ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X c� ORDINANCE Unable to obtain signature of offender. 0 w + t � � a OR Date mailed THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS P YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD To DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERA q pq W REGULATION DISPOSITION WITH NO flESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. Uj LLJ be You may sled to pa the above fine,either b e L a y Y appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday Through Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q 4 before:The Barnstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 026Oi,or by mailing a check,money order or Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-0NE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. y #'$ postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, I `"� 2)Ill desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you ma do sob $ BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT CpMpOUND, y CL ) t citation for a hearing, MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630 Ahrc 2 e Noncriminal DISTRICT COURT encPART copy (3)If You if to andpay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 da or H you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing FLLy j , orn s to be due criminal c faint ma be is u again ed st ou. I rn i ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first Option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature y