Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
1903 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28
A : n .. � . �� _ _ �� � �� E �- � o ,. , , e 0 0 '�r � o �► i � � - �- � .. a ,. SCHULZ LAW OFFICES, LLC WILLIAM CHARLES PLACE 7 PARKER ROAD OSTERVILLE, MASSACHUSETTS 02655-2034 TELEPHONE(508)428-0950., FACSIMILE(508)420-1536 ALBEIT J. SCHULZ MICHAEL F. SCHULZ aschulz@schulzlawoffices.com mschulz@schulzlawoffices.com April 30, 2013 Thomas Perry, Building Commissioner Town of Barnstable q 200 Main Street Hyannis, Massachusetts 02601 Via Hand Delivery Re: 1903, 192 7 and 1941 Falmouth Road, Centerville, Massachusetts Our file: 22629 Dear Tom: C r I In connection with our recent conversation I am p g rovidin Y ou with material coljcernin g"l:;1�03 - 1927 and 1941 Falmouth Road, Centerville, MA(the "Property"). The Town gparnstakFp �n presently designates the "use" of this property as "motel.". However, based on the inforination that follows, I submit that the use designation of the property as "motel" is too narrow and-Alfa]2 "multi-family"more accurately describes how the property has been used since it was first developed. In 1948 Joseph Silvia("Silvia") and A. Roland Robert("Robert")purchased the property which was vacant woodland and depicted as Lot'12 in Plan Book 48, Page 49. See Exhibits 1 and 2. Between 1948 and 1949 and prior to the enactment of zoning, Silvia and Robert developed the property. See Exhibits 3 and 4 (notin$t the deeds in Exhibits 3 and 4 state "with the buildings thereon" while Exhibit 1 states "woodland"). Under the deeds, Silvia owned the westerly portion(presently known as 1927 Falmouth Road)_and Robert owned the easterly portion(presently known as 1903 and 1941 Falmouth Road). See Exhibit 5.• The development of the property by 1949 is also supported by the Town of Barnstable Assessing Division Field Cards which dates the structures at the property to that-time. See Exhibits 6A-6C.1 By 1949 the property was improved with the four(4) structures that exist today. See Exhibits 1-6. In 1952 Robert conveyed the easterly portion of the property to Silvia. See Exhibit 7. Additional support for the development and use of the property comes from 2002 Affidavit of Floyd J. Silvia which states that his parents purchased the property in 1948 and that during the 1950's it not only served as their residence but it was utilized as a motel and apartments (Ranch Rail 1 It appears that the Town of Barnstable Assessing Division Field Card for 1903 Falmouth Road dates the structure to 1985 but this is an error because the deed into Robert and Silvia in January 1948 states"woodland"while the April 1948 deed into Robert(for 1903 Falmouth Road)states"with the buildings thereon". h 4 Motor Court) were rented on a year round basis. See Exhibit 8. I submit that the foregoing facts establish that the four(4) structures which are present today and the multifamily use of the property existed prior to the enactment of zoning. Between 1960 and 1987 the property was utilized in substantially the same multifamily fashion as Silvia and Robert established in 1949. See Exhibits 9-12. In 1966, Robert E. Immonen and Kaino M. Immonen("Immonen") petitioned the Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals ("ZBA") for a special permit to expand the non-conforming use of the property. See Exhibit 9. The uses as stated in the 1966 zoning petition indicate multifamily use rather than purely motel. See Exhibit 9. Although the ZBA issued the special permit in 1966, the proposed new building was never constructed. Compare Exhibit 5 and Exhibit 9. Between 1976 and 1980, Edward F. Simpson as Trustee of the Ranch Rail Realty Trust("Simpson") operated the property. See Exhibit 10 (noting that as of 1976 the name Ranch Rail still associated with the property). In J Simpson June 1980 Sim conveyed the remainder of Lot 12 (1927 Falmouth Road) to Charles P. Colbath and Barbara M. Colbath("Colbath") but retained Lots 1 and 2, along with access thereto for his own use as a single family residence. See Exhibit 11. However, the single family use of 1903 Falmouth Road terminated in September 1980 when Simpson conveyed Lots 1 and 2 to Charles P. Colbath, Barbara M. Colbath and Dennis J. Colbath. See Exhibit 12. In 1987 Colbath conveyed the property to David A. Sauro and Janice L. Sauro as Trustees ("Sauro"). See Exhibits 13 and 14. In 1988 Sauro petitioned the ZBA for a special permit to expand the pre-existing non-conforming use (motel/apartments)by razing the existing structure on Lot 1 (one apartment unit) and constructing a larger building to house four two-bedroom apartments. See Exhibit 15 (noting Lot 1 contained only 1 apartment unit because Immonen never constructed the authorized two unit building authorized under the 1966 special permit shown in Exhibit 9). The ZBA denied Sauro's petition for a special permit but the Decision issued by the ZBA contains numerous factual inconsistencies from what is contained in Michael Ford's memorandum and this letter. See Exhibit 15. Notwithstanding the factual inconsistencies, the ZBA denial of the special permit did not change the existing multifamily use at the property as of 1988 (eight efficiency and four single rooms) and the Building Commissioner of Town of Barnstable recognized the apartments at the property. See Exhibit 16. In July 1993 Richard P. Callahan as Trustee of Centerville Village Apartments Realty Trust ("CVA")purchased the property. See Exhibit 17. A short time after acquiring the property CVA was issued a building permit from the Town of Barnstable for the remodeling of the property, which included the installation of new kitchen efficiency units. See Exhibit 18 (noting that efficiency units already existed in 1988). The building permit application originally described the proposed use as "existing apartments" but it appears this was crossed out by the builder, Michael J. Gardner, and"motel units"was inserted. See Exhibit 18. The reason "existing apartments"was crossed out and"motel units" inserted in the building permit was at the direction of the Building Commissioner so that ZBA would not be required. See Exhibit 19. From 1993 to present the property has been utilized the same. I submit that the narrowing of use terminology at the property occurred in 1993 and it should not have due to the historical multifamily use of the property dating to 1949. Based on the foregoing facts, I suggest that the proper use designation for the property is multifamily, not limited to motel. Due to the documented, historic multifamily use of the property, I suggest that the use clarification can be made administratively. In the end,4Ry future -development at this property will require a-variety of Town approvals including Site-Plan ---- -- Review and ZBA due to its proximity to Route 28. After your review of the letter and exhibits, I look forward to meeting with you on May 7, 2013 at 10:00 a.m. I have copied Town Attorney.Ruth J. Weil on this correspondence and I hope that she can join us. Very truly yours, Ochaelhulz MFS/jfs Enclosures cc: Ruth J. Weil, Town Attorney r 1, Thomas Perry, agree with that the use designation at the property is clarified to multifamily. Thomas Perry - ; date 'J ... .. This deed is gluon in correction of deed from ::d^lund S:3oucher { rty husb=nd) to &ui fusetin Tobin df't,:d Cctnber 16.194:i r=nd recorded in B-rnstgble .Cr)unt7 -llegis-try of Deeds Bnok 6i2 PPge , Ill. 123 _ Sd-jund 5.3oucher husband of said grantor, '< xmi€at tenancy by the cattesy other iatesests therein. release to said grantee all rights of�yffi , d nn r hand S andl thi seas thig______Ld_d day of^2ec�•nber, j947 . 7 Pies - ,.. X 7 '. ally 4TV=n==U1t4 of fiEW IPMUS T1eCamh _--- ar L ra.; 19 47 j . �A1xLS+oti`1 o aS. , r. When personally appeared the above named r h a tart ` .J. ... ;�•.,1.�Q. '' hedged the.foregoing.instrument to 1w__ free act and deed,before me _ - .. her ` k�rt.• - 7Na Nobry Pablie—Jli x4r Cammlmlaa if fill I _ - ... .. COUNTY CLERK'S OFFICE .I,PAVL R.REXFORA,clerk Of the County aforesaid,and of the County •'�'" Court,in and for said County,the same being a Court of Record,and having a .'`� 1-•' ; tZ' seat do hereby certify that ___.8-3d...F,...Hamiltion.._'................._. Esq., whose 110 Name is subscribed to the Certificate..__.........or acknowledgment of the annexed in- strument and written thereon,was,at the time of taking such acknowledgment,a . 7 ^'+tip!'`•' '• Notary Public in and for the said County,dwelling therein.commission - ..ed,sworn, , ' :>K and duly authorized to take the same,to administer oaths, take depositions and .' the acknowledgment of deeds and other conveyances of real estate to be recorded - ' 1n this Sts And further, at I am well acquainted with the handwriting of !,. s ` te. br said Notary Public,end verily believe that the signature to the mid"Certifica _.... l or acknowledgment is genuine,and that the said instrument I believe is executed - �:, and aeknowIedged according to the laws of the state of Vermont .. ..r- < - L.. ..., > . i# 3n ZBrarimtmq 3114ereaf. I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of acid County Court, .. __ __ ... o is-.z211d...._ .at _. .... m said county,LtlF y ...............---._..................._.._ �Clerk. Barnstable, ss., Received January 29, 1948, and is recorded. } of_- Lr Cr:Y_ir PF'iile) 3:3rr! County,Massachusetts, - briny-zmmnrried,for consideration paid,grant to-ji.,`1t�=an0._tf^_ 3=i ._P �ce_1 ilv _. e T�.-�I� s ._- ---' __ _with rmuenkltt9 ' of �3.�5:_��iill.L..� �....� .—_ matra[Qg the land in_5.3� ar.s t41 e-(�:er.tel v i11e L---__---_•--._____._.- ___-----' v ,'.;7 _ . .., . . ..... _. r:=sue:".',:•,:.:.-r-y. ..., .'-.---.-...••.,... <,.-�..... 687 —_ rna.aivti..and mwmbrwuas,ff ear) a certain lot o woodland situn.te(' ?`• t;1C1 ?'J.11:t• f; nr certer,.il'•_e� J,OA Tom n.and counter of barr_at able, ..w s., ly in; on tare scut' $icie of t e new'state -road leacini; from Hyannis to Falnanutr and is bound- ed and described as follows: fie iruti� at a 1)oi::t in tie f::.<. :; side, ,I' an oI d rpn<:. rued and in tne�soutlierly lire of said nevr'st.te road; thfinf e rt:nni71 aorta t;3 i3'3U'I east 3 feat ^ore _ less nver ti:e sn tt,iftrl-� l-r'e of s.iiti state voud to lura of illice L. F:).1ler: t:er-ce 30" east 569.4G feet :'y linu of s_id dice .. Fuller to a s�ones i t u car:ler ^f 1>,);d of :lice ? ?alier; tttan4,n rt! 30•",gent -eat Sect to an o_d county I'rad leud.in.•- fro' i?1r^^t::b to Osterville: thence :c,esterly 1--y Said Old en',IPtY r^%iC' tC .T.: ci@ .cad (� road; t?ie,_ce norta•;:esterl 1.^r *ne .._Lst;e'r+ s__e oz' tae old :rr.od •ert 1 neG t or :lam .roan 36Dt;t feet to i.7i0 i. :�it ; in- road �� r,. urnat, 1.t' :>cr.s F t e e aid _o� cor. iir.in- '•- � .i. S 9S � „ ,o r.e av Hazel F. b �e.ecwZ sPs conveyed .r,• - .. , � 1947, to be recorded"herr:-rait't _ �a ,. + a, ror a core ,iarr_calur c:rz,r.t' �,tiRL _E:: i,,.t ._..,_t 'd _--1-- f �„ �a:r,n (• "ass be_..r.r._.., ..o Pl«n f :;ood _�^ct Ce_-., .�il_ c, , , _ Siiir-iey arson, S^xle 1 is nh : lc:: Hearse, Surveyor, Centerville, .,..:s. _ i I„6���t fc �!a J�yB faxes. .. :t ric_c :. --------------------`.x_.______..._— o;_r:�------------------•--.__.__._._.husband of said grantor, -wife- release to said grantee all rights of ewer and home tthe cu eed and other interests therein. and seals day - ----------- ---... _._..--......— "-------_-- s 134t 1A1><iMrittIITPB11# of awmar*rtb . bo fiat stable Then personally appeared the above named._____t_:,;�='t_tt_zo'.i ...I....... .--_•- ------_---._._. and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to be._iLePr .___free act and deed,before me V lvobv YaWia- coEt6 Peaee I - LrY cammiaefon e,�ixae_.'.L<'.�.•.�__��.:_.._._._.._.-_.._.fsLL Barnstable, ss., Received January 29, 1948, and is recorded. `—We— INDA covo .�.James.z,.__a ov_oz� ...... a_._._Gov_or�,_ana..._...__.......__ oE•+.,-aS•axldl.`713,-C11 B4rn,5. .Ub.1.Q. County,14* _...._........_ t, a.sachusetis, og i mi erwiv for consideration paid,grant to__.6HI�?& .9_._1�Q __�nd_ .j� _.-]�0- D,Q.a.._husband I V � �IIIT 2 i •�� �fJ JJ = G``� n po cr �.• ' '' if `"; / A �`� '�o, PL/IN A'/YOODLA/YO//Y CZh7LeY/LLE,BA.PiYSIX.9-1 1-14SS. 044446/N6 T� ' SCALE ///Yl/Y=/OOFT. OCTOBE:2 �R3.2. - . n /✓6LSLW.BEAFSL: SUPIrCTa1 CEHTERY/LLE/lAS3. ' ` "7.>7. E-Xl Ili-31T 3 ti .fJ:('S'y-,�`3•L.'.9�,:- 4'r'�T!•�-y,�i•}!•�Y:�:.. i�r��-:'R�-'.':Y r�'%.�: .�,-:. .�, :�. �q.•s`a'S;fer• .:e7ti�ses~?c:caitife:3*t'd-:�o;;izs;'bg'.ynn•':';;Etrtri�Tobin.and . 28,;'194{8 ,and-:recoi�'d,iid. in._. , a-: 32+ i F .. - }4i94a�!i r. e' f ._A o e_ er T if o'b. t: — Tlat _ ft P �.. •rZi'i�_. Si'T e—nf ,jpvPl,h Li r therein.d other interests ih f' an r to 'd atrtee all rights o .. el said gh ea5g � S ower'and home,lead d ei 'ith s and seal tha. —da of_12s..�]._ `•�ftiteaa _,pd� h d .� enfi Y 1 •' 'Thenpersonally appeared the above named— '' �• -� —b r rc_...J_os__c.a..ii Silvia _a - I and admowledged the foregoing instrument to be-11l_e. r__free ad and deed,before me i ..—__ Notary PuDtae - Dir Commicuav.spirt+ T,P f:_ �f) Ty`=� - Barnstable, ss., Received April 29, 1948, and is recorded. T, 'Pileiria rlir ay — _ — of ' � C Mass achusetts, Dn wTrid for consideration paid,grant toll_.r jie—"! Jrooert h`,—,?tar d anti +.�fr�, as iU die e;; ret` ^. c i fi s- rt �nven nts i of ..�arnstable �fy u-ai� '' -� i. P t- w'. f 'd•r:s the land in_Ilsr.Ls=.,`„z1. .L...L111� J.t.1).:_li1] 1A.2r r? —_ (� �—, ��� t h r o 1D.caiptlon and weumbr.vcnr if a yl BeGinnin at .a n6nunent on the southerly icie of the State liie,h•„ag ,a at land '�;conveyed' to: Joseph Silvia and' Rita_ita ,.. Silvia by deed of even data, thence southerly 45 feet;:r;ore or less to a ^o^u.^.:er_t^ r ,•: e'r� t s' ,o^u.•,erft t enne southerly 263 easterly6 feet• --_ore or 1 c _. h .v � more feet or less o r•:onirton_t t zence sout._er_ ?,5� �cet ..^_e or , ..t .-o t less to a.-loni;ner_t•, s'eutaeriy 4l feet :^ore or less to nonuner_t c; borderinu^ Fuller 1;oad, tlier_ce easterly 24 feet !:orc or less to mon 1 iimsntA riortherly.85 feet-nbre or less. to nonuner_t, runnin-rj westerly 56946 feetborderinC -land-of:Alice 1. Fuller to :aonumer_t'on' the ,.w.- r i r r• h + tae e_ ee•dr• ___ �'_ .s' lI3 f t.I southerly s e aid 's te' hi :�+a -ate_ ,a t 1__ r . id of s ,.a _out ] 3 � Y Y ,. ..:„, e s ,:tra point- 'f �e:�ir�i r.-. " __or or le .s Y,o �oin o � . 1 „ .bei'n:r..the easte'rl� art of t;,ie• or'emisea convey ed to me b the c, f � . s .. . ? Y �•�'s sad p.T.G no'bert' ar'd Jos`e_>>l 3i'?via arid others b*•� deed of ever.' ! ai A. ..o� nd . e rb "rhereijli ih: �(a;te to b co.ded ' • - rt a tfuees._ L]y n*d . and seal this t -t ig)_thy of__.•3i1SL_____.—.19 4E rr_. ' ?IIFIt fIIrtnnttnxuur� uf-.�isxsarflt»rft�- ___._---•.• . --_-__-• -. -- -- rnstable, <s. .: 'Thenpeisonallyappeaset7'fhe'atiove'named, M el 3 rsUyraz,�^-_.. and ackmowledged the foregoing instrument to ___free act and deed,before me xetnr,anw;c mg ' Mr Commission ex,ires 'iO f` i') r9 4'eJ I I Barnstable, ss., Received April 29, 1948, and is recorded. 4, - i3�a:F+.;.,:to _ Coca Massachusetts, of i;1t�dYll,e ('•iV =ltL�) "- _ ,_ t3;, s::.:d for wnsidcration paid,grant to_slQs e i SilyiarG Ritz ??.. 5ilvyaa - hi1. hid Fnr, ,=F fe. es tors;:;ts t;v tho•entiY ety ri�rr-e ver.ants t ofarstYble { 3Yi?Iis1 __wfth7�(#l�t?X`t the<9andins'irstubie erv:.11e ;.'itu tiic '_tu'ic r;:s titeren :orc articularl'a boarc''ed act—. _described as fo --- . [A.serlptloa and eaaamh—m tf-71 - at a in l'_Y? Fr nonument on the nOUtl:e Y'lyi -+1(le of tileJ trite Eyi:':guy. $e.bi t land'coriveyed' to ii'. Roland fiicbert and astulie r. ttobert by deed I' of even irate, tiler_ce southerly �g feet .c,r'e"or less to a �o-^-ur:crt; easterly c6 feet :core or less, to �-:.aonuler_t, 't'^enne so ;,crl;,•' :'.'�� i'eet:*core cr less to a t'i.enr.e souther ;•,- 250 feet:.r+ore or less' to'a r.-oniiraert,.'scatherly 41 i'eet ^ore or 1es to a nonument :borde`riiia Faller. itoad' thence :IF_sicrly 25 zest !lox.( or less to t:Ye o,1d:viand road; tt"".ante roY thwesterly by ald road -about c•25 1-eat to---__ - _--- _. - ----- the State iii�hway, thence bythe State .,i�nTcy 130 feet -^ore 'or less to`.the:po'jnt of:neginnir" . , d b.ein the westerly dart of tYie .;.revises conveyed to me :may t^e Y ". If st3 ,d A. l:olarct 'RoLiert and Jose h:.s is and others debd of even date -to.be..recorded' herewith. I _ --- --- --- --- '-#W 'KU r ei,,Zth thxerfa)Rr rand and'seal day 48 a ;w_ .y. ti✓i1'" EXIIIBIT 4 J k 4 692 §jttttens.._zy ha„d . and seat tl is r . :. �1�{p (IInmmtnttmoealSf] of S{�arlFitstl#u t r `'ihen personally appearedlhe aibOve'inme and ackmwtedged the foregoing instrument to'be_.119.r _--free act and deed,before me l/V , - Notm• P¢lil, i i j Barns tabl e as. Received April 29� 1948, and is recorded: ne o_f Rrax sr"". , _ts_e_�_r e Oir co ile_vnit-�i—+i,•aTe I —. Count�.Massachusetts, y ?itL Silvi s;;o;w„e. d,forconsiduationpaid gnt t lush iand � :� `4-pr-cov enants _with of�a-r'r+at able-�,;',�+ln*119 -- t;�crenn :ore ?;zrnst�i:j e 'e^i.erville itu tnc Lta_`c iri:•:s : the�landin - descri.�ed r�s fo�lov✓.-s:_,—__--_— -- C P a tic larl✓ bourd'ed a- d: �a ic,rrl [,a Ipttloa and mmm ran ge.,iTY in at z _onur=ent o ttie sc::ti:erl,,' side of tile. �tste ;iy deed et land'corive�ed' to t1'. tofusd C.cbert' and D%Ltulie F. .tebert br deed o even date, theT ce southerly 45 i'eet �,rc or less to a eastE;rly cti -feet' :.lore.or less' to -.:0nunent, 't?:ercc outhcrl t 5 Beet *ore or less to a 7.0l,u:e:Tt; ti;eriee soutilerl -:'-�U fee(-.riu e or a b�ii�eT't �cathcrl; 41 feet :"ore: or =ee to'a onuine[ t .1ess'-to ,' 25 feet 'Ior•e or less to the ' borderiria caller. :toed; thence ,vestcrl; o]d"aio.od roue; t::ence northwesterly by �a'-d,^oad abeT;t ;?.25 feet to I State ou ., a3 thence- jjv the State ::i---h% 1s0 feet *ore 'or less to.the:PoInt of:be.�innire. by te t of and b•einl`cthelar_dtyl?otisrtyand Josed r13;1�* a,iard otier edvftdec? of ever. I` s A. date -to.ba.recorded' herewith. a e", th 8 tlue8n ____Band and seal' this_tj& t.`�__—_dayof__ 19`1 i i .o-s. r:« e 1 Aarnstable, ss. __J.L;;r'U 28,__ 19LC .5 62 Then personally appeared the above named. Th.e.? and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to beL. .I.;r-_..,-free act and deed,before me ' M�eomm;cnion��.. T+e Barnstable, ss., Reooived April 29, 1948, and is recorded. 1(iwm aU nun b #ter p resrit# That the SANDWICH CO-OPERATIVE BANE, a banking corporation duly organized and estab i fished under the laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and having an usual place of business in Sandwich,Barnstable County,Massachusetts,the mortgagee named in and present holder of a certain -GORGE H KRkI��, pp.d.. HXS+�+ .. mortgage of real estate given by............................�.............. husband..aua...9� fl..... �....t.fluaziGs..by....the....sxati7raty.:..klath............................... of Barns• . y .............table....("Pest.)..,...Barnsteble..�..Count r...........--am .�............... to the said Sandwich Co-operative Bank,dated....-.................nctpber,••16.,...............,,:.......A.D,19.h5s andrecorded in the Registry of Deeds for.............:......Barn at.able...............County in Book.- Page.._4.4Q...,,.,.hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of the same. -- IN WITNESS WHEREOF the said SANDWICH CO-OPERATIVE BANK has caused its. eor- porate seal to be hereto affixed and these presents to be signed>in its name and behalf by •F Camille•„A;....';9„il�, amsa,-.•,,--its$snmdm�-Treasurer,hereto duly authorized;this '+ T ......... . 27..th.........................................day of April.......................: ..A.D.19.48. ... :.•'' Ln Witn SANDWICH CO-OPERATIVE BANII_��'. + By Y.......... _ Treasurer JIl+ems. �J nuncnn+�` (�nmmnn>,urtt1#� of •fl��l��tu[�t,+3e#� Sandwich,Mass., .AP.??i]:..2 th......................194.9 Barnstable,ss. ... . Cam ....a.....�... ! . .... Then personally appeared the above named................................��-d,. � . .......................... ZZ%%XMZTreasurer, as aforesaid, and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to be the free act and deed of the said SANDWICH CO-OPERATIVE BANS, . �.__�T.-. — - - - -- - -- a EXIIIBIT 5 -r . � a -': _.,,..a�•».'2*<,�. "-.,4_-�x-..lvl". 1 .`f'`s sts}- Yy� 3 f s, r 'a: i 1, `-' x.,r. 1 I:r _ ,3, .r-� --i i - l- � w.. - A: rar.�N :=y z.... _S.ta:..ayi.. •!''1 .sl. t r'1y f.1. .,,r r -�'. .r> ,.s;`t ''"J^`-t` .,s .t++ a 'v '!' � ll S.£ ��33 T r_ ¢r: �. y r I+t f fm p''i` .. F asf F' v tr!-^'f *' ihi �3f t,u...fi}c 5)i 1 . s ! .7>. ter` ,.r`•-. r�"S.."2 ? i�` r r" ^mac• .,G. 3 Y ry- w. A,•_,' t Y.�s :i' :7 Y ":.^±'y. '�ie,.. 1 v:";, f-. -F° i as1" p 1 '.. �.' - I�a,P,a'"�€. fi erS 1,. -+:i"�,r, s� ..r T r 1 k,a:;. S ,` "_ �'' w., a -_ t,!,- v+ r 2 � g; Lev<� y f a, - , � /,y-_ _ c�;...; t: y - :f + - - •+ ,Z- -€.5'i .z:J - �.�r_ '3v R -. 'It n_ ��:.l 5' ,, ' i•. .s3. re`.'4 v ,». ✓ �• ..t?.i a: lll d �;�:• sfr' t - f< i s' 4Y'�,„f n.s fi 7` 41 "'-,'i ' '` f. s r 8 y- r _�. .. ,.:_ r +4�., `T�' `v% , r :,. ,b;=`F c :)f. " . .,- " ^k ,.: •� 1 -3; �1 -i:sr z:`°L -';."',i '>i' .� _ „w-� �, fy� ri`. t ``"� i C..�:u iyy..f .,� f..��, �i _fgj�.. Ali^ +°�"5 y^C,7-:''a ", i ,. r: !' ^- r +" x s "s 1r {fi'r a .. " F- �. .#% T •'�+'. v� ;h .'+�' n" l-;.r -' .:� .r,.<-y ti j6 r ,,'. S. hw' <, } -.k• ! 1 �" ;�. ! .h. y 1 _ .i:. - ���.. '.. .t 1; «-+z- .. �' 2.. ,z 5 F 'c r. f".'. t a d 4;: "+5'-Xh : r',: ,Y r na7tt ''t"� Y r ,:5:,:.>*-'� ," +�;.r•` J, : -� .;;. - s 'f .y f„ :'f "r 5, vr�t r L:.- �.;-"'rL -i' •:�a.n r^^-a .t`F..•'YI. .• _ ",,'.aYi r .bt v"f_ .:s !K -t J T. ..Z, .3 t... 1' + &1, •'<1-'.C.�v'nY ''i_`c `' .- r;isa •_ !r. iia� rz' -rS�Ps - ? �'.:_", r-1 •U. �x ti: tP - - c v-�' .i., �: 'a-jgtrr�.. rr;Fm4 a ?: '1 h •f �� s ` {- E a, Y ri r r .1 I _a , .. ;.�.� Ca... :r :'r _.,tv P ' .;:,x y a, x t t s b',: . ..3 r L ,e } �� . ,.4, -? - �4�. `E m_ i:...'s ,r Fitt _ r A, ��,t, a,�e. ,,:rfs� �n1�s, ?;;. S` :s4.`^ 'i",:•'", :.',1' -T ji" s �,s _`,F t� •s,:_ i l '' t :..a ,x-y }- `''„: 'C ` ` •: .,;;,• ps } '' .•,".., �: t)n_.A"' ,, ...::• ,,.- �1.45. > - r .a,. 1.ih 'r rri'�F 4 2 r r "4a- - 'xs,.,""'u- 3'..... - K,- °' •< , < _: ^"-'. .; - S::'.,:- :cr^s.,,, .. 'r''."r£: 1. k'� tS ,7, ,!vp's f : :4:,...s '` 'it Qrt3 t'. s,t',: e . a....� :,,a. aF�_ :; '. s z '• ;>.'`r ti 'i :- `- -' a f. r+ x '. :'r - i,�7'� '�r mod'-zr •r+' .h5 r "" ?`..s kx. S.r. y .!? - a C 4 �,.: `x' ,Y ��Ji ..5r -n•s�t Ar'. -' ?r `?^ =f" ✓ .°.,- ..;,' .... :.,.?. .^ :>. .,e r�',' a :.ri.,a,r f 7 .`y i.ir,, `.,1. Yi- , uvk6.'1. "f._ :A `e .- '- ',c er `y:�' .. g -t- r 5 `; Y; a,F"i G r "I.c j}..k-= r;T e,�"'� a i'_ 'C --'.a:. �::�+ a1, .."r r :,�.,:.wT ?:,.t•' �..;k `i 3_r.. t{ — } f tx S•j. 17f..Y. '*� Pe.•jam,. x'S�V, !`: .: _ rt .. ^.-,c' +' ' -x. :b. nn rµ,. rr, '' ?+ t",.x :.:.. ..a �LnMn ,_ j 1: 'N. n_ _:iyr'r :-' .r RAI �E'� Lx 3 rS.<:Q, sl.�_ t 1i- I f :fi @ .e rr.. ., +f .ra,.� 3f f Y,::b F_ t , l a 't-, j�''° •rr`'" Pr, ,'� t.r"f?..ti,-,.. '� c a" 1 :r=, - A e > - i :fi r: .(».' •-�lr. :'� 'Tr`; i:k...-u"it i.` y .t ., R � t .'v # "ta �- .. ..hf.F1 •fk w sw`-kf;e`" _ 4f .,.s .,:z�I,. J r, -_.' '" �=i-...,tq '- :•r'. ,Y'.. t� �. :a Y;. s,. R r�.c. t"�,r £z..a,..,. ^r"h v.�'`Si ,e,a-_' gr"-#'. 'U' w:- . ;_ ,,�.ftt.Y'4�. "'»6e..ati '_ c: R �, dt's"rz' .1 .U-., ,F f.- rC7 '�` }' ,j r.: 'K. ...t }t � 'i rc 1 n tii - <;3t §':ia 'i'r �e; a p� � t„%> :.'' ! F-It':r�- -r'" J�.1 '� � y }� ` A. r ":t ' t, i .y r� ,�1 4, ! It "'•t'wta :` r r, .._ .._.....+f:.:: ... ;sr s :_"" .,' :.t^ _ : r•:, LL '�'1 ..,,s i a. :,5 fi' •!v#.a , ry y ..:em:` t-4. E,. ?,"i t• �_ . .�f;• i...H c a of "r._y S 2 .+:: .n r• s.:. r R. _ .1 -, '.r: .:{.. - 'G -t. 1 -h A°°'y 4_ 't 3;�.F;f• �x,.f?, .. ,.M " .."' i,. .:,. > u,... .34 r�L.,�x F( .i, - t ,.:.:.., w, .w: :;:.'' ,E 't>rs,- ' ,n f. �,rr ;"�'.,., ,._: `ri:�>..<, �. �x ::... n,..wr : ,seu a'.., `t ..,, ' :JuL�. 1 .-. *.•.J, -".y ",r 'r .?i,Ci+' is I f.:. 7x' 1,, ?,-.z ,:; fJ, :}-:'.�' .Y,yi'�t>�..�"4r . _ .b ,:... ..{` `}s, 'Yh,L'{.t 9i.•:. .."_:� 1�'." .";' F,IC-, jt- P:: -.e'y� 'j �.i c t .::_, ..ar :v .aY., r:�-_ x tE!'�. -� Cw... y.�,•_ `, s z: i ...'�`.a. rs .. v 1 .K' '^.°: +. .. ,n0.yb.Mri+?,..... t. <r+. .. >. :.: -.t. -. i '_r:,:r� ,-..u• t„..:,......; x:._ a;�;'n }, cx';'y_ - .3Y`'' .�,1,-{ .i, uf ''tft... �-� - 'c��,Ys' t..i ,v., .w. e., w 3 .,4 !. -:fiv-le' i' .•d. �f;q _ c:�,aid< rf.iip,<�.-..r .;��, f ¢._ .f C_ F: r C`-.'-k c ::r!._ ,.. .:. a; svr.� ";n -:+u -.3-�' /..''4Y5 p, ssl. e•..k't rt ,,.:".,„._:. y... y.. ...:a. .ac .5.� _i' ,*.r. :..t!: Ln 1 .3. •AL 2 { :l 'i`ti: ". ,.il-tb. .x;N. .- tf- 54r _t.:r'�'.fl. �,<, :6 r -i... .4,. ..F::.: :...h r!', .. ....�.v 5. r.-e. l.:t.:- J - 4 d 7'. 1 R.t::'�, .aE .f :ri., •.'1> •S::a I .i4...i'. d 'L [.__. -rs c. - ._._M _ .. .- .,,�„ Y S� ,} .s r �. L+f;•(c.. :n i 'vr` f .�uta ' »iy. .';3`s•.,:. ..,z,. ,,,-a.k� ",. N.. ,:.. wY.,/ : 'rtth.. 1.t:I - z.,: ........ -f7 ! t."F: -.y_.t 7/' y+1 { {i r...,. ,.t y..:}. .�, .. .,K 6,, :e. ,. c-: .•v'.tt �rP {-?:�{' �fG �f ,} .f LV" A6.fu.. C1 t:. `"'nti li'r d"' .%'=Xi.Jr<' ..�.. 4 1 . ... ui,i ,..b., ':�.r,.s 1• is It :..,{I r, .{�<�_�:..t 1 ;.V A {f S c Y d +�.--r i s .,� ,.z�a ,.;,..G• ," '. % I, q ,..:,� "3.:, 5r• 7,'. t '},f u - '-1 x ',._ :�: "a to!cr- .93•.;`i1""w' -ra 7� '`" ...�'• t,, m. as ..U.s .'�s" n ..,. t. .::a3?t � "9r ,k, 1- v "Y" r h','}�. u{; v.-,>?:� -4 :.Y - 'rr :+5.x,"' ,,,{ .•,•Su,� .► 'r{c^`... S ii. ,. =f :f< a 'ys+t 3.... ,i w. SY..?v,.,.t .1 v t , -.> - .,t,..6 'q,1 - .t } -47r l.r'.::?r.,. �'?b3q A _.y... '.-.,r. i' r r a ,=.:l: z { f., r ;. ? Y sa,4 • .::..t _,._ , �r -„ a x ^3`�n4 , a k 3rt �4,..,;...,'_:< „&, '..,n:'ia. .r::� ,,y � -e^..,:°v5. ::e, i x. ,i.t.-r.<�s�:, - i .'•` if •.f x <:i.?f` aitrl.,.'k -Nj=vA sas: _,. - a*,1 7... \!-io.. ",.di-- .,.r t y.-,}f1.,r,x f-,'� fk �. _Iit-li,,v i., .;5 s".t U' S' t •.,ISn - '4•_,G'1 rlv,.. t:".:: >^ rz :3 t-.. i r : .,., ._ .?,.. F.. {tt tY, .s s ..-`<i'.+-.n ..t< ;,,r ;,,;:, 2 i3 ... t t �r..'s ., w., .S•ae, -`'<"S .>R. ?_ .... -4r 9 '.r.= :.er s., :4.,r n•: 1 if.t '�� +'' v 7� i 5: s t�rQ'sh'ry' f !`; ��... ,.�, 'A .,v`h,. .5 �.7,: .: .F.,1. t fi :N ! 4 K.a „ril{• y-:,u, k ,�.�' a c � ,A r.:q 2•t V,.1.j, 'qnA .7, _zu>< ,. ..\.. .yu'� :,: ,L•:_"� _S :r5.,- {;:.:' n„ .5 3 §Y,i r �+� �i= v.rr Pa b .t^, $-...ir, x Ft�.- x-.t.".:. 5 f : P.:. ;, .- .t ,r... '-'� ;.:. .42:"v a .3.ns ;t. Y `L t.+tt-. - 1,-v� s' -4 : �w1•. �v •f. '�+ v...,r.,F f-t .,?:�:. :'x .'- -.,f.. ,..;,:n :" 5e- .- .1.-r, "'is �, -....<..< ,,": .:,�.. ::.;:a• ,.:n,.,-• 3...,.._ .x :r.r,,~.G,--. •r.,r��rw.v•'.>F .,.- Wr+.'. �.t .-. '',_ y.._a'.!.. -� .t;-- :,.». ,?>! _r: >± taa' iFr -,i. , •+ 'v,. a,. >.u... -Kr .".:Y.,., 5t' r t'�:�. _.. 'f ..R1h: d+:ni,� r. .,.. c-b,r:w K;3 :...._ , .:!-. ':a n '1 t l C. c,.,. "aF b,. f?', `"4"•...v� -+ ek`?,x:,a yrr lt,.....y.,e: M. .:,.'._ - _. ,5+. ,.,.tl; ..;, �F r. -:.. .a +.n,. ";S ,r", ...rt -:.,., +' .yC, 'b .,.F, •, �' civ,x - Y-'rt. 1 I, •'i ,fir•15rT. ,t u ! t :a A i E. .yt. ,e, :�a -, s.. y,"&, �.4 ,..f`n )WlrT' -r r a , f ! kT q, �s. F T <. ?i> ,•t.J .. :,tl ,. i MI:t 4 ,. k' xi i. ,'1' ,'C' :f �K} :6`4 3 :.. '.� Y S: ;,t m ,'4W:�.. --+`c-r,.:7.� ,r.r-'� •,. r + !'-�C ,i •f'. is:.r. c ,y {itK.,� .: "i a ve+�L2 Ye�er: �. "; '. y r•_.i 3 .}. :..' ' .:.4c.az iu J7. 'i,t v,,s�°�:. w,. v`t' l �.. ,s;: ht`: :A f, s'r• s - — TiN a s i _ 't' r x' rkf" u :a ti:.t r P , yr.fir 3: , 1 2 -Mr r.+, ,, ,a✓,.{ t. ..�1`.,cf' J, i '' ux' i :!"'•J.i`a 4rn'^° :' v k t:f2^ t 9_. _r u' :_, ..?-- ✓ilt;r,r� ;xu,'. c Y,;. _ r. - _ S- '%,.^ 'f -':rr 'dZ. x .'. '�F E !vx' k .':rI 4s i„ ::V 41. •` y a st- �'. >'' 5:; f4" f (t �i v's '°m'-- , "�` -ir, r: f1. -x 'xf''.� r. p t-, t :"ka >s k - 'J _ -i...i r r•. xf A + ✓1 j. y i C A m 5 i.+.Ih i -. ry., t -i,3' Y •�' ? 1 "'�Y o f h p ., uFx �:a r { s r�-- 1 � a..:'s••.0 t S -.r— - i+' .w•,r,.h .:-.5�.. rt t.. 1 ,,.,! f? x �, x"y i11 ` % ,c d ,rw+ : , e x :� i f a� (rt}i iM, �4 .>t 5 ":i n '*a{1'- :a` 5 ♦ r .,li 4' 1 + }h ;i 's '� , �"-.' t i-•F• }.� :_ t Y . .-ti•! b, l dq 1p !I y hE!'3 1 ••II r h a j - '. .,».aA„""". ,.'a'i�'�.•cn'°+ ra .s'"+,c.•..s _" s g a i to 7.: { f�... i + i o- .1 �: ,,.:d•,�.:.. r .'t ,k tkyar - r3.-`' � v r v r::�l.' d :a,i DT's .�JG.P. r t x F ,� k1 rr a ,sf'bk, t't e 1 �' :f vl -t:'P R . _ N :c±±-��!bN, r a l:":' 1t ., _ _ R r n:.�. _ £'a. i 3 sr•Ts�� a° a v i:: ti%[' IC s t_j, t .Ai k. A lB .1.' l i k { i .�i J f .-1 hTJ 3F r;. i• _ ,t�h,W1E{;,� 4r,` h 7 it ±:Y - s'h 5• 4,?t, r a 'P` .vlP d::- a•k 7 1 r. r� 3.. y:. ".py � w,.' '* _. "�-.a •a`'z.5� '- ',. ..__'r.U^",� ,.3x 'tt` "ss o IP.�p"`q * r1u'�;a'1�+' - r ^ i..�.: '�','94. ..:.}''�R' m :;' t -: ,. '_""..,.tF '� ":'i'a's ':.',a'ti x f �y`4 s�!. .r. t.♦,. � , � r• .1 r / t't�',.x.5}��{,� .W"i -� V3:+�� a S yR .:{ >A-...'Y ^T-Y _ K �- •:f. „,"Y ="uq - -.T.,:F"•6 2:' .. f_. z:ii:,! r'�:;ay ,,:ri, --: ,:::, F ;..fir-ds .•y. ..+�c .: +,t: ,� r- a`,, ^& a. .a "- : al a '�•a -rrin -,, s' .�?i�.F.S:_ +- .... .!s` r, :}.>v, t#: - it �`a &,F f C- e.rn"' ti -:}•;1.' -IR ':4:7- :011. '3 r `tl 3, - ,zm` :^-E: r,Z:"&%zi 'g 2 y .. {F.i <t r :ix .-h f •_.f h i 'M ;.,'r�',k. F ..-.a���tT - 1 1'�i. riX.�?Y. h, .. 1@ 's. `mot S, Y - {1 J 4'j _ 1::r'iQ1.- - .1..L R - ,Tw�''�"�'_: Af--' _ F -" r ;• 'Tll+ 't `F 1L4" ,,,a•°1`�..-rI' `Y' a ye: .( S ^ a-,. -. ,alp M:-sue r,L `<5 ,xa•.'',.;. ..:'.-, _.•nTEBx.r- ,` :...q`. '� i e ,. v. .. @#y tt:=if's"� r ��-�';LJ ' ¢ s `�•:' '�-e,,: ' ,i,eit* q,tt'-. a e :.i:: a,.• t,-� :r -r ` .,,�.g T o. _..:,- s t .>r.F �:;;� ,, v,r y>`r =u"� 4 i- - .: • . _. .e. .ce E' _ ..J.. .i. ?tr n'rt� 7 i{? •,�Pi ,4, G`,r. -,,... ) .:r .. :5• pl_,_. .I _ l .•'.- y .:11 1/ �.r-� :Y l 1 J'1�^� _Y y9 • i ,5 it �' S;%1 i s. .. t: `` ::r - c. 6: �.Cv .;,r ,*. ,ut.lN -`i _' � ;;Y'� y �•+° {i r :. "�i'..Ir 1" - `q� �.,t>; . -q ,] ef.:n 's,, ii'< :,`q' ''+�,•v ?e s..✓-a ,fir=$ >-''4�.,;.j ¢`-E`"4, i- • r.r , _ a� w t,cn• ... ,2 :.- Kj., -'of .t a f',r�+[ ,,,? h 'i— atn t,i" s: : � ... �. Y ¢ .,x it t ty,ti_,;:/'O Z 4y F _ r� t r i.ra-5"-�;ip - �. - .r.�-_ 'k. ,',... Y� r' '..:.: x. -:Y. ...f t: v fh.'P i'2 s, _, f..3 _ f Y�= t....tFrf i.°°ij.S {" t .v r .- a...:.. -r-..�.: :t r tt�� ,,f i;�"S C +'w -'� : ,-:;wr t yir ;, '»c a,:si'A i7,ar ta. 1 .1< _ -` --�.y`'ndi «:1-;t t:':� -'>ti.,%=h' �.k.' �:. afg ;. x; Y �, y, 5 sk.. tee Fri kar t #1k�, br ,sf ,YC'1 ::ter,»f•.,{.K - s x a.. ?"< y. 'S'.'f ,s-b n n +a"t`':1' .i- t'" - .C.: % :}p8 + ,�. -t Cf T '•1 I! h,L - tine a-N7 ; .P' Pty ,ic'�'Gch -. „ . ...,4.. ',.,_,f -`:ts ;. 1,.. ,.;1 :'vs• .. *t /'. f ev�r� -"-�•' .. �r'1j-a , ice -=•a r` �S y?.. k+.':u '- u f _ e y tP 1i``4 Jt U-Ar \ " n.` ,><L ) ++'S' "`" Eh �r wtw su. ..,r' •• 11 :+fir- t>r - Y -`-�'� f "• 5 ^+ k � f _;� 'w, ✓ n . x„ 4`1,iit �,,,- !.. .v �tt•.:: ,.: ,, y.y;-7: ) �11-�.'t r �1 ,?: '+�a° ...�€, � �. 'p"-. `ha 'i z� �- t ': _ ' � 3. +t `• i r:, �r44 ��`" - c s.''� -_,. E ".: -f� .'3�! '.y -'r h 7 - 't Y c; M, 7r 1',s ,,:, . _: .K�+.-, a._.,..,.:< r _ , .+'T Eat,:i ,: "- Rym • • • .m.. I wo �.16 ,,I.,__ — • m - •NAINUOUTTOD I EXHIBIT 6.A 7erty Location: 1927 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28 MAP ID:189/067/// Bldg Name: State Use:1120 Account# Bldg#: 1 of 3 Sec#: 1 of 1 Card 1 of 3 Print Date 02/23/2012 13 35 ,on ID:12989 CONSTRUCTION.DETAIL CONSTRUCTION DETAIL' CONTINUED Element Cd. Ch. escription Elem=IDescriptionamily Conver. 8 lel 1 esidential oundatiole verage 12 ies 1 ath Spli 14 AIL ED.'USE WDK 44 12 WDK :rior Wall 1 14 ood Shingle Code escri tion Percenta a 26 44 :rior Wall 2 1120 ver 8 Uni MDL,01 100 5 44 �f Structure 3 Gable/Hip BAS 4 ,f Cover 3 sph/F GIs/Cmp BAS 1 rior Wall 1 5 rywall 14 rior Wall 2 COST/M>4R1LET.VALUATION - g 19 44 rior Flr 1 14 Carpet d� Base Rate: 15.48 54 :rior Flr 2 OP 59 R Fuel 3 Gas Replace Cost 86,154 34 A Type 4 of Air 'YB 949 Type 1 one yB 996 Units#6-8 al Bedrooms 5 Bedrooms ep Code al Bthrms emodel Rating Units#9-10 al Half Baths ear Remodeled :al Xtra Fixtrs ep% 5 :al Rooms 7 unctional Obslnc xternal Obslnc th Style ost Trend Factor :then Style ondition /o Complete erall%Cond 5 e pprais Val 58,200 ep%Ovr F ep Ovr Comment isc Imp Ovr ^ isc Imp Ovr Comment ost to Cure Ovr ,cesso Apt t Cure Ovr Comment to D' ost OB:-OUTBUILDING:& YARD ITEMS /XF-BUILDING EXTRA.FEATURESM ,;.: e ode escri tion ub ub Descri t B Units Unit Price Yr de Rt nd %Cnd r Value �' �• s ! DCK ood decking 1 48 15.30 1996 100 1,600 65 0.50 1996 �P pen Porcb-ro� 100 ,900 j BUILDING SUB-AREA SUMMARYSECTION Code escri lion Livin Area Gross Area E .Area Unit Cost Unde rec. Value 1,612 1,612 1,612 AS first Floor ' OP pen Porch 0 365 0 ✓DK ood Deck 0 448 0 1,612 2,4251 1,6121 •operty+Location: 1927 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28 MAP ID:189/067/// Bldg Name: State Use:1120 ision ID:12989 Account# Bldg#: 2 of 3 Sec#: 1 of 1 Card 2 of 3 Print Date:02/23/2012 13:35 CONSTRUGTIONDETAIL(' CONSTRUCTIONDETAIL CONTIlYUED `` Element Cd. Ch. escription Element Cd. Ch. Description yle - 11 Family Conver. ode] 01 Residential Foundation 01 Poured Cone. 10 21 :ade C Average WDK 5 ories ath Split 0 Full UST ''lIfIXED:USE 10 derior Wall 1 14 Wood Shingle Code [Description Percentage 6 32 4 16 cterior Wall 2 1120 Over 8 Uni MDL-01 100 )of Structure 03 Gable/Hip 11 BAS oof Cover 03 sph/F GIs/Cmp terior Wall 1 5 Drywall BAS 17 2 COST/MARSET:VALUATION BAS FUS terior Wall 2 L6' 4 BMT 2 terior Flr 1 14 Carpet Adj.Base Rate: 02.35 tenor Flr 2 eat Fuel 3 as Replace Cost 39,192 16 eat Type 4 of Air yB 1949 C Type 1 one YB 996 32 Unit#2 Aal Bedrooms 4 4 Bedrooms bep Code Dtal Bthrms Remodel Rating Units#3-5 otal Half Baths Year Remodeled otal Xtra Fixtrs 3 ep% 5 otal Rooms 3 unctional Obslnc ath Style External Obslnc itchen Style Cost Trend Factor, Condition /o Complete _ - Overall%Cond 5 - Pprais Val 103,300 ep%Ovr ep Ovr Comment t - isc Imp Ovr isc Imp Ovr Comment i Cost to Cure Ovr .ccessory Apt ost to Cure Ovr Comment 4` OB-OUTBUILDING'&.YARD ITEMS(L),/XF-B UILD_ ING EXTRA 17 TURES(B) 'Ode [Description Sub ub Descri t VBIUnits Unit Price lYr 1Gde Vp Rt nd %Cnd WDr Value =' VDCK Wood decking 0 15.30 1996 C, 2 100 1,800 IST Utility Storage- B 25 19.00 1996 C 1 100 600 ;MTBasement-Unfit B 768 23.00 1996 1 100 16,700 BUILDING SUB-AREA SUMMARY SECTION Code Description Livin Area Gross Area E .Area Unit Cost Unde rec. Value IAS First Floor 1,569 1,569 1,569 IMT Basement Area 0 768 0 'US Upper Story 768 768 768 JST Utility Enclosure 0 25 0 VDK Wood Deck 0 80 0 j� �►� >_ �°i� �. "sa+ M T11. Goss LiB�Eease Area, 2,3371 3,210 2,3371 •operty Location: 1927 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28 MAP ID:189/067/// Bldg Name: State Use:1120 Won ID:12989 Account# Bldg#: 3 of 3 Sec#: 1 of 1 Card 3 of 3 Print Date:02/23/201213:35 CONSTR UCTIONDETAIL` CON STR UCTIONDETAIL CONTINUED Element FCTCh. escription Element Cd. Ch.[Description yle 36 Cottage odel 01 Residential Foundation 00 Typical ade C Average pries 1 1 Story Bath Split 10 1 Full 22 ::;MIXED.USE ;terior Wall 1 14 Wood Shingle Code IDescription Percentage } -- aerior Wall 2 1120 Over 8 Uni 1VIDL-01 100 )of Structure 03 Gable/Hip )of Cover 03 sph/F GIs/Cmp terior Wall 1 05 rywall terior Wall 2 COST/MARSET VALUATION terior Flr 1 14 arpet Adj.Base Rate: 40.47 2 BAS 2 terior Fir 2 eat Fuel 03 Gas Replace Cost 67,987 eat Type 9 Typical AYB 1949 C Type 1 None EYB 1990 otal Bedrooms 1 1 Bedroom Dep Code otal Bthrms 1 Remodel Rating otal Half Baths D Year Remodeled otal Xtra Fixtrs ep% zi otal Rooms 4 4 Rooms unctional Obslnc 22 ath Style xtemal Obslnc ost Trend Factor itchen Style ondition Yo Complete - Overall%Cond 79 pprais Val 53,700 ep%Ovr ep Ovr Comment isc Imp Ovr isc Imp Ovr Comment i Cost to Cure Ovr ,ccessory Apt ost to Cure Ovr Comment OB=OUTBUILDING°& YARD ITEMS(L)IXF-BUILDING:EXTR4 FEATURES(B) 'ode escri tion Sub ub Des cri t B IUnits JUnit Price Yr 9de Dig Rt rnd %Cnd 4pr Value �. I � r✓ �I BUILDINGSUB=AREASUMMARYSECTION '_ Code Description Livin Area Gross Area E .Area Unit Cost Unde rec. Value OAS first Floor 484 484 484 T11, Cross / E •G tl 484 484 4841 1 a , J , y ?erty Location: 1903 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28 MAP ID:189/129/// Bldg Name: State Use:1010 'on ID:13054 Account# Bldg#: 1 of 1 Sec#: 1 of 1 Card 1 of 1 Print Date 02/23/2012 13 37 �. _ CONSTRUCTIONDETAIL:`= CONSTRUGTIONDETAIL' CONTINUED Element Cd. Ch. escription Element Cd. Ch. escription 1 anch el 1 esidential Foundation 01 Poured Conc. 10 le verage WDK ies 1 1 Story ath Splrt 10 1 Full MIXED USE 10 rior Wall 1 14 ood Shingle Code escri'tion Percenta a 24 :rior Wall 2 1010 Ingle Fam MDL-01 100 f Structure 3 Gable/Hip f Cover 3 sph/F GIs/Crop for Wall 1 5 rywali riot Wall COST/MARSET:YAI UATION '' riot Flr 1 14 Carpet dj Base Rate: 4.11 riot Flr 2 11 Ceram Clay Til t Fuel 2 0 eplace Cost 1,311 6 BAS 3 t Type 2 Ioor Furnace yB 985 Type 1 one yB 999 al Bedrooms 2 Bedrooms ep Code 31 Bthrms 1 emodel Rating _ .. al Half Baths ear Remodeled al Xtra Fixtrs ep% 2 al Rooms Rooms unctional Obslnc xtemal Obslnc ost Trend Factor 24 h Style cben Style ondition /o Complete verall%Cond 8 PPrais Val 1,600 ep%Ovr ep Ovr Comments .: is c ImP Ovr isc Imp Ovr Comment ost to Cure Ovr z - cessory Apt ost to Cure Ovr Comment /XF-BUIL.DING EXTRA:FEATURES OB-OUTBUILDING& YARD LTEMS(L) . B) ,. I de escri tion ub ub Descri i LIB Units Unit Price Yr de Rt nd %Cnd r Value _ DCK ood decking, 0 5.30 1999 C 100 ,000 BUILDING SUB AREA SUMMARY SECTION Y Code escri tion Livin -Area Gross Area E .Area Unit Cost Unde rec. Value kS First Floor 864 864 864 DK Wood Deck 0 80 0TtL Gross LivlLaa-i' no 864 9441 864 EXHIBIT 6C. Property Location:IV41 14ALMUU lri KUAll/KIh 28 YLAY 11J:15VI 1JU/// ntvg Name: Mate use:I11U Vision ID:13055 Account# Bldg#: 1 of 1 Sec#: 1 of 1 Card 1 of 1 Print Date:02/23/2012 13:36 ALLAHAN,RICHARD P TR Description Code Appraised Value Assessed Value ES LAND 1320 11,000 11,000 801 70A MAIN ST ✓2012 BARNSTABLE,A STERVILLE,MA 02655 SUPPLEMENTAL DATA Additional Owners: Other ID: Plan Ref. Split Zoning RD-1;RC Land Ct# Per.ProesExpp. #SR VISION esExpt Qual Life Estate DL 1 LOT 2 Notes: DL 2 GIS ID: 13055 ASSOC PID# Totall 11,0001 11,000 RECORD'OF.OWNERSHIP'.. ' ;' BK--VOL/PAGE SALE DATE %u: 01 SALE PRICE VC PREVIOUSASSESSMENTYWISTOR ALLAHAN,RICHARD P TR 8688/234 07/15/1993 U V 115,006 N Yr. Code I Assessed Value Yr. Code Assessed Value Yr. Code Assessed Value BX REAL ESTATE CORP 8614/143 06/15/1993 U V 122,000 N 2011 1320 11,000 2010 1320 10,700 2009 1320 8,300 AURO,DAVID TRS 5590/003 03/15/1987 U V 70,000 N OLBATH,CHARLES P 3149/101 Q 0 Total: 11 000 Total: 10 700 Total: 8,300 EXEMPTIONS ""OTHER ASSESSMENTS ! This signature acknowledges a visit by a Data Collector or Assessor Year T e escri tion Amount Code escri tion Number Amount I Comm.In. APPRAISED.:VAL UE.S UMMAR Y. Total- Appraised Bldg.Value(Card) 0 ASSESSEVG.AEIGHBORHOOD ,-, Appraised XF(B)Value(Bldg) 0 NBHD/SUB NBHD NAME STREET INDEX NAME I TRACING I BATCH Appraised OB(L)Value(Bldg) 0 0107/A CenVil Appraised Land Value(Bldg) 11,000 NOTES. S pecial Land Value 0 Total Appraised Parcel Value 11,000 Valuation Method: C Adjustment: 0 �et Total Appraised Parcel Value 11,000 B UILDING PERMIT RECORD+ VISIT/CHANGE HISTORY Permit ID Issue Date Type Description Amount Insp.Date %Comp. Date Comp. Comments Date Type IS ID Cd Purpose/Result ''LANDLINE>VALUATIONSECTION =`l B Use Use Unit I. Acre C. ST. # Code Description Zone D Frontage De th Units Price Factor S.A. Disc Factor Idx Ad'. Notes-Adi Spec I Pricin d'. Unit Price Land Value 1 1320 Undevable MDLr00 PLI1 3 0.24 AC 8,680.00 3.41 U 1.0000 1.00 0107 1.55 11,000 Total Card Land Units: 0.24 AC Parcel Total Land Area: .24 AC Total Land Value: 11,000 _ 1 We, A: ROLAND ROBERT and NATALIE F'. ROBERT, husband and wife, as tenants by the entirety, both of $�4; Barnstable (Hyannis),;Barnstable County,Massachusetts, �+�for consideration paid,grantto .TOSEpg SILVIA and RITA K. SILVIA, $ husband and rife, as tenants by the entirety, both of Barnstable (Hyannis), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, I` _ _.. with 4nttrlattu raustn mto the land in Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable Coun with the buildings thereon, more particularly bounded and sdescribed�as. follows!— (Ikscriation and encumbrances,if any) Beginning at a monument on the Southerly'side .of. the State Highway �.`. at land conveyed to Joseph Silvia and Rita M. Silvia April 28, 1948; by deed dated i thence Southerly forty-five (45) feet more or less to a monument,., ' Easterly ,sixty-six (66) feet more or less to a monument; thence Southerly two hundred sixty-three (263) feet, more or less, to a monument; thence Southerly two hundred fifty (250) feet, more or less; to a monument; thence Southerly forty-one (41) feet more Or. less to a monument bordering Fuller Road; , thence .Easterly twenty-four (24) feet more or less to a monument, i. Northerly,eighty-five (85) feet more or less to a monument, running Westerly five hundred sixty-nine and.46/100 (569.46) feet, bordering land of Alice L. Fuller to a monument on the Southerly side of 'said State I Highway, and running i. Westerly one hundred thirteen (113) feet more o r l t less o the point.of beginning. �. Being the same remises conveyed to us by Thelma Murray' by deed dated April 28 19 �•. P , , 'reoorded with Barnstable Co•••'••••unty, RgR1stry,ot.Deedy,,.,. in Book 692, Page 60. , • S ' t S i . ��i� ��-'�F9L��FlCShCX}JP283tiC r . tlmas_.:.9ur _hand s and seals this 13th day of June Ig 52 0 i. Barnstable, ss.• June 13, '19 52. Then personally appeared the above namedA.Roland Robert and.Natalie F: Robert L,aand adasowledged the forepnin .in; ,tv be theii` free act and deed,before me My Commission Expires March 17,1Q B'6r stable 'ss a;ne=:Y6 -.:1 3 able ..s8eie red:, _ 95..,.';and;da.recorded` r aa SME- .7, I r _j �k AFFIDAVIT I, FLOYD J. SILVIA, on oath depose and states the following: 1. I am s�L;years of age and have resided in the Town of Barnstable my entire life. 2. I have personal knowledge of the statements made herein. 3. I am familiar with the premises located at 1927 Falmouth Road, (Route 28), Centerville, presently known as Oak Tree Village Apartments. It has also been known as the Ranch Rail Motel. 4. The premises, which contain about 2/3 of an acre,was purchased by my parents, Joseph and Rita Silvia,in 1948, when I was a young child. 5. I,my parents, and my brother,Ronald, lived at the premises until my parents sold it to Robert Immonen in 1960. 6. During the 1950's,the premises was used as both a motel and apartments. Although the main use was that of a motel, my family lived in a portion of the residential dwelling on the premises and at least one of the other units were occupied on a year round basis. 7. I believe that the multi-family use of the premises continued after my parents sold the premises. Signed under the pains and penalties of penury this / day of July 2002. Fl yd is •ten-71 4dl1IPT, . � 9 I `I I y�F THE i 31ABa5TABLE,i YAea �0 YRY a. TOWN OF BARNSTABLE VARIANCE PETITION FOR SPECIAL PERMIT UNDER THE ZONING BY-LAW To the Board of Appeals, Hyannis,Mass. Date _ _ ____ 19 l� The undersigned petitions the Board of Appeals to vary, in th manner and or the reasons of the provisions of the zoning by-law to the following described hereinafter set ffo�r'th-, the^application premises. �J Applicant: — — (Winter Addre (Fall Name) Owner: -=ter Address' (Full Name) Tenant (if any): (Full Name) (Winter Address) r1 eC 1. Location of Prem)ses�_'�� '�-_j_.._.._.._........_..________..�-.-_...•.---__-______..._...�_..-..__ (Name of Street) (What section of Town) ZI 2. Dimensions of lot .- _°�1 _ _ _ Area __ _G �S -- (Frontage) -_----- ^� (Depth) (Square Feet) 3. Zoning district,in which premises are - 4. How long has owner had title to the above premises? ���--?- -----•----•--•-- 5. How many buildings are now on the lot? _ n . . . _ � - ---•-- - 6. Give size of existing buildings:_ AQ xr� -•----•---- Proposed buildings -- 7_State present use of premises 8.-State proposed use of premises l!t1 /22.Z •° ygQ= W7UhZ., 9. Give extent of proposed construction or alterations:J.l ✓ --d !JG ���'���- _- 99__�.__...._r.!.�li`_•o..._.��� .__. l��cf��t//i4.t.�urp't„�li.eG�L.-��1.��� �`�' �`��c.Li�„ _.d1r4•th"i:.�4f1.�...C.t�C :q;_.�.tr,_ �z�.T1(tltsf.l:,.•fSTGR..�%s2L�c'u:�!�P.�..�t - &.�. ____.._._. 10. Number of living units for which building is to be arranged_ ._.—_�_--_.-..-..-•------••-- 11. Have you submitted plans for above to the Building Inspector? ••-•-•-•----••----•-- 12. Has he refused a permit?___���____._ .- _-____• _•�%-_-_•-_••-•---•---- ---•- 13. What section of zoning by-law do you ask to be varied? 14. State reasons for variance or special permit: _..___.____...___-_._�_.__.__.:__.____.--- ---�__--• _.�71..fr._Yvl,:4.1.G..(:'.�.'.G_✓.�..(.�'.::?�:4..r[G_:�C!(.��� P:.C::(.�r: - , _-e:L_.<.C.e�ct�l:�:___;t.�_���.�t.�_.L��x'�t..t'.s::_ � aLih/ �/^ ✓ _...__.._.._....__._......................._..__. _ Respectfully submitted, (Signature) A/ -. ___.._---- Petition received by _..... p}Address 'h _ ._�v� ?.x'.�! ....._.� d�ir�2R('<4 _ 1�u� flea ring date set for _._._- _-____-_ ___ 19+.�.__. • Filing fee of $15.00 required with this petition. * This form may also be used for Appeals. (Over) f . Please type or print only. The following are the names and mailing addresses of the abutting owners of property end the _name and address of the owner across the street,according to the records in the Assessor's Office -- at the date of/this application: •,.{ JOSlr� ���r1ifr.$ , ���'rM.dt� Rv. R1+e .2i' [Astor-✓YFII-e //l'�sls. Robs{- CLt�ot, Cld ST✓ai./J�e,rt-r l�.l� Rl. J-fra�+„s '. - Joh,t f SII1a1ds Ii.l ��57 i3a� fjd. QsJe,��,)le '0a.5.9. yei 1 ` 4m4s of 7hrr4 AV. o.s-fes vI/te �YlasS. f Verified by Amessor'a Office Assessor Thme must be submitted,with the witbin application at the time of filing a plan of the land,in duplicate, (or two prints) showing: 1. The dimensions of the land 2. The location of existing buildings on the land. S. The exact location of the improvements sought to be placed on the land. l r Applications filed without such plane will be retnrned without action by the Hoard of Appeals. t � E t �.� jam'• t J\ it�� ,� 4 . � f v 1{iJ. c'th 411 a :�' ~tad .g4 �Qzr: 00�' CP O XV ti o b o m • � �� � 'tint �� •.2y�' �' o° f k � _ 13 ! /P`� &oa.✓5�z�Z1 ✓ohm Ar 06: Sh%e Jp I of a C E:m-rr-RviLLF-. ,5ARNSTABLE, MASS. V�L0�1CirNd TO $C-AL>= tr�eH=�O Fr DEc A..195G. F1�tSor� YJa�u�v¢-,�R�GU Ascv Lr,w, SU2V EY�R�• i .4-0 3r r TOWN OF BARNSTABLE Board of Appeals Petitioner Appeal No. FACTS and DECISION Petitioner ` filed petition on -- , .. 1966 requesting a variance-permit for premises at e, _ , , . ,,,,,_____„•._. xq4�0 in the village or adjoining premises of_ .._.. Yam"M 'AS�nm,iu L+;.i W:: _,� ., , ., •4rw'.A7+' _ ..m•c ':p....1?. .__ :E r .. _. ? ._..__........_..........._ ._.. ..... _� :....._. _........_............_........._....... _.__._ for the purpose of _. ��; _ -u• _.. n �: _ ,,....� �... �, �... yC'� _ . ....r •.R..•�-.�,1�ti.Y� ..+dhJ.V{ly�A.. ........._............ Locus is presently zoned in . _ .._..._ ri s `___._...., ........................................_..._..__......_.._..._................ _.._.... I Notice of this hearing was given by mail, postage prepaid, to all persons deemed affected and by publishing in Cape Cod Standard Times, a daily newspaper published in Town of Barnstable a copy of which is attached to the record of these proceedings filed with Town Clerk. A public hearing by the Board of Appeals of the Town .of Barnstable was held at the Town Office Building, Hyais, Mass., at ..34 ........__ P.M. * � � * _....__.__.__.... ,19 6 upon said petition under zoning by-laws. Present at the hearing were the following members: i'1 ................._ s Ciairman Mel—^n,•u_ �.�» .. ," io` ... . ...A� "3.,. 't� At the conclusion of the hearing, the Board took said petition under advisement. A view of the locus was had by the Board. On the Board of Appeals fiound E "Ibe. tit<ioww.' tatad that deSIZOO tO eml an S' be 14 g F�.yyna, �p��cth' reox t��'[ uma .ppr,e'se1g�t ,}how C q e� �y �5� �q �e��g '�•'�.:Mi& .i; .avil"..' ' rk �` -1 7 ala-'LGcr�� 4+��{-. Wr iE�i:�P c+WW As b$�'� `ula=r Wits- 06.c be z e s .w . ;be PZt1tio-nar the additiola Of- WO 0 lee knits o e wwald not b detrimmteL to e Swea, It e- -A then:tU= ;of +,.:--e Board� � - � gig#. e s inguse t r eat f rom. t �� the, �_'-` .MIX. . e, �� � �� � 1��� he v�y� r_{ , 4f X F�i> „rear a., a -jai � .�t �£, �? " : ten tjie- Stme': nr V C a ld- f�3 9 irx .,- : .� Y..7 .5,s== conr�inPB•.'%ct+'. Y a Y:S l' `f 1— o 'w 1.. �W!'.kl+(51.a'��L��, i..3i.��W i vi... razat Restrictions imposed: Distribution: Board of Appeals Town Clerk Town of Barnstable Applicant Persons interested Building Inspector Public Information By �—�_ ..��%C z�: '��_ ....... Board of Appeals Chairman "IVO�MrL"E'.OF �] SI RiNG ONDER ZdNING BY�LgyY$ PPeal No;:.1466 3 January 26 1956.I Jo.,eph„Brerdns,,RcUert Elliot;Jchn F.: hields,;Ne1l'F. q'mes:'• _ Being`;,all y rsons;deemed mie�ested Nected by ane Board:of Appeals s•Ctinn Corn Chwp 4oA of Geneva, Laws: TOWN" OF BARNSTABLE 4,the Cammonwealih;ot Ma;sachusetts ad ali amertdmenta iherrto you are: areby nctlfied that .ROBERT Ag' A,NONEN-li s appea3ed to the• Board:,� BOARD OF APPEALS Appeals From a decls�on of the 8uilc' a. Ihspector and patftions for...,Is e on c vary; tha oning byy law,:ta per a NOTICE- /� PUBLIC ^� p7�7!'� ii eaten io0 of an•,;>ex�siing,lion con-. - NO ICE- OF P BLIC HEARING e as per afba summer mafelup[emises - - 'n,Pr oq :F.atmouth Itcad tR,pute 2s,,: UNDER ZONING BY-LAWS •n Qryllie,,In a Residence t area 4 Public'hearing•will be given',:on.1his InTown Offlce.`9ullging';onFeb•s ary 17 1964 at a.30.p m Ynu are.Invtled to be-,present � l(� ! By ordcr.'b� the Board of Appeals _ » _ Jama:�_26 » I96 ROLAND T FIHL;.3c Ing Ch al,manj '»» _ », R. RAO 11 RNE CHARLES.YJ4cGRATH ?&2,4 f 66 y Joseph Bmalos,�,kbert Elliot, /John F. a,_ields, Ail F. AMSs Being all persons deemed interested or afFect'ad by the Board of Appeals, under See. 15 of Chap. 40A of General-Laws of the Co;imonwealth of Massachusetts and aU amendments thereto, you are hereby notified that _ _ »»_ROBMT ELIAS !O'''LX has appealed to the Board of.Appeals from a decision of the Building Inspector wand petitions for permission to vary the zoning by-law to permit extension of an existing non.. conforming use by ad�ig one building for use as part of a sw=er motel; premises looted on Ral=uth Road (Route 28),, Centerville, in a Residence C area. A public hearing will be given on this petition, in _ __»TOUR Offic®.Buildla-z._ on »»»_» __ .. 1`ebrizas'ylZ, 1966 at You are invited to be present. By order of the Board of Appeals, (15 proofs please) Roland T. Pihl Abting Chairman. January 28 and February 4 R. Ralph 'Horde Charles YaGrath p 1 i r t J. 14.653 _ - .�0:2361 ;.':: 158 We, JCRN D. SCANNELL and THELMA H. SCANNELL, husband and wife, as Tenants by the Entirety, both of Route 28, Centerville, Barnstable County.Massachusetts, in consideration of NINTY-FIVE THOUSAND AND 001100 (395,000,00) --- DOLLARS, grant to EDWARD F. SIMPSON, as Trustee of the Ranch Rail Realty Trust under a written Declaration of Trust dated 'We x9 ,1974 and being recorded at the Barnstable County Registr of Deeds in Book p)'jlr( , Page /)'5- , /-/C-Ktt,i'it c, 1 I t1'P'i i' S`7` •�.� /��5. I�� a �:I K Ct � tia�t S.S with quitrlahn ruueuants the land in Barnstable (Centerville), County of Barnstable, Common- wealth of Massachusetts, together with the buildings thereon, bounded and described as follows: BEGINNING at a point in the Easterly line of an old wood road and in the Southerly line of the New State Highway as shown on a plan hereinafter referred to; THENCE running North 690 43' 20" East Two Hundred Ninty- Three (293) feet, more or less, over the Southerly line of said State Highway to land of Alice L. Fuller; THENCE South 640 311 30" East, Five Iiuridred Sixty-Nine and 46/100 (569.46) feet by land of said Alice L. Fuller to a stake and stones at a corner of land of Alice L. Fuller; THENCE South 130 02' 30" West, Eightji-h'ive and 56/100 (85,56) feet to an old County road leading from Barnstable to Osterville; THENCE Westerly by said old County road to an old wood road; and THENCE Northwesterly along the Easterly side of old wood road about Eight Hundred .Twenty-Five (825) feet to the first mentioned bound or place of beginning. rAdf 4"CS.91 Said promises contain about 1.8 acres, and are: shown as Lot #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, MAss. Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson Boarse Surveyor, Centerville, Mass." which :said plan is duly recorded in the Barnstable County i Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48, Page 49. There is excepted and excluded from the above described premises Lot #3 as shown on a plan of land belonging to Joseph J. Silvia i recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Bock 139, Page 155, which I I 1 "' CC:P.1'!•iil1�[LTt� or MASSACHUSfTTS r ' I w 3ov,2361 rA.,i 1�9 :alcl prnmicu:: wurr. cwnvuyud to Adolph Uglkis cat ux by deed dated Aupust 1, 19VU, and duly rucurded In said HugIstry of Deeds in Book I No, P&AU h•61.. Mour!,rai; and tntondWn to convey and hereby conveying all and the uumn praml.so:c curivoynd to us by duud of uald dead being rocordud at the Barnstable County Jim{,I:;try of Wds In Book 1506, Page 684, to which deed ru1'uronce muy be made for title. This cunvuyanav in made subject to a mortgage running In favor of and pr"uonhly hold by the Milton Wings Banit, said mortgage Wing In the original amount of $59,000.00 and with its present hulanco King $4j,$ue.Q-Rj the grantee hereby warrants and guarantees L'tuat ha ::hull make and shall moat all the obligations of the said morLgaHu and of the Promissory Note secured thereby. 5ooh2361 tact 160 Fxecuted se a sealed instrument this n 7 day of << t' 19 76 JL THELMA H. SCANNI;LL �1lelllammanwe�lUzof a.rhuslett� f BARN STABLE, Its. Thmi personally itppenrod the abovo named .JOHN D. SCANNELL and THELMA H. SCANNELL and acknowledged the foregoing instrumont to bo their free act/aid daoA, B4/bre 4m9, - Notary Public.—AmRiF#4ha PRa I= My conuiriesion ospirai 111 7 RECORDED JUNE 29, 1976 EXHIBIT III i o I • BOOK$107PAU 266 r I I DEED !I T, EDWARD F. SIMPSON, Trustee of Ranch Rail Realty Trust, jlunder a. Declaration of Trust dated June_29, 1976, recorded in i the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 2361, Page 155, of 279 Ridge Street, Millis, Norfolk County, Massachusetts, for j ; consideration paid, and in full consideration of, ONE HUNDRED ;FIVE THOUSAND AND N0/100 ($105,000.00) DOLLARS, grant to Itt ;: CHARLES P. COLBATH and BARBARA M. COLBATH, husband and wife as j I joint tenants, both of 3 Wentworth Road, Natick, Middlesex ;: County, Massachusetts, with QUITCLAIM COVENANTS The land with the buildings thereon, situate in Barnstable I (Centerville), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, bounded and jdescribed as follows: BEGINNING at a point in the Easterly line of an old wood road and in the Southerly line of the New State Highway : as shown on a plan hereinafter referred to; THENCE running North 691 43, 20" East, two hundred ninety-three (293) feet, more or less, over the Southerly line of said State Highway to land now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; j THENCE South 64° 31' 30" East, five hundred sixty-nine and 46/100 (569.46) feet by land now or formerly f of said Alice L. Fuller to a stake and stones at a corner of land now or formerly of Alice L. f I Fuller; i ! eightyfive and 56/100 THENCE South 13° 02' 30" West, - i (85.56) feet to an old County Road leading from I i Barnstable to Osterville; I �I THENCE Westerly by said old County Road to an old wood road, and k 1 THENCE Northwesterly along the Easterly side of old woo road about eight hundred twenty-five (825) feet to the first mentioned bound or place of beginning. 1�.C:i•1::J�• ..' EY AT LAV 4:T 1'FR::4•' dA -I PAGE 1 of 3 PAGES t tt II i R it aoox3107('a�f 267 - 2 Said premises contain about 1.8 acres, and are shown° as !ILOT #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Center- 1 r . '!ville, Barnstable, Mass. Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale •` 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson`Bearse Surveyor, Centerville, Mass.", which said plan is duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48, Page 49. There is excepted and excluded from the above-described premises Lot #3 as shown on a plan of land belonging to Joseph . J. Silvia recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book.139, : Page 155, which said premises were conveyed to Adolph.Deikis et ux by deed dated August 1, 1970, and duly recorded in said.Registry Of Deeds in Book 1980, Page 461; there is also excepted and excluded from the above-described premises Lots 1 and. 2 as shown on said plan. ' Meaning and intending to convey and hereby conveying all of f the premises conveyed to the grantor by deed'of John D. Scannell et ux dated June 29, 1976, recorded in Book 2361, Page 158, !lat the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds with the exception of Lots 1 and 2 hereinbefore referred to. i Said real estate is conveyed subject to a right of way, ten (10) feet wide, across the granted premises running parallel`)9/Y("7 by c,9�vv ��< �.J r�Vi /I(�y ar 1GlHN �•sn'i1-got to the �T o easterly boundary for the purposes of egress and ingr s I ` for pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and from a single-family dwelling located on Lot 1 as shown on a plan of land recorded in jthe Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 139, Page 155, to the State Highway; Route 28. Said right of way shall be PAGE 2 of 3 PAGES i i i � I000KR07eaut 2W i 3 -/ i I)restricted for use only by the owner,4tenant5or guests of such • I dwelling located on said Lot 1. _'z� I%'0�v��17 �cO�Y�Yc2c e7 vx :I For Grantor's title, see I,DA"lc.n )D/Vcr x9r�Y7k rj'rzo�� r n u•ri Srsi�� �'�c�rS Tr.'y �ry WITNESS my hand and seal this `� day•of ciE_ , 1980. CiMUIESTH OF MA55ACHIUSET�T�S 1 a ' y Edward F. S p , stee o 4 JtlM' 2.3y9. 40= Ranch Rail a lty Trust MIMI- I COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS 11>47j ly ST(I/SL� SS- Then C:N��- 'j , 1980 Then personally appeared the aforementioned EDWARD F. SIMPSON, i:Trustee as aforesaid, and acknowledged the foregoing instrument i • fto be his free act and deed, before me. No y Public My Commission Expires: fi i II t I1 I PAGE 3 Og� 3 PAGES r• ..:,.iri;: JUN 9 So i i I ! I I EXIIIBIT . 11 2 M1 500KKO U 101 DEED 20818 III I I, EDWARD F. SIMPSON, Trustee of Ranch•Rail Realty Trust, under a Declaration of Trust dated June 29, 1976, recorded in the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 2361, Page 155, of Count Massachusetts for 279 Ridge Street, Millis, Norfolky, , ( consideration paid, and in full consideration of, TWENTY-FIVE :THOUSAND AND N0/100 ($25,000.00) DOLLARS, grant to CHARLES P. : COLBATH, BARBARA M. COLBATH and DENNIS J. COLBATH, as joint I 711V1VtV►a tenants, all of 3 Wentworth Road, Natick, Middlesex County, IRS Y Massachusetts, with QUITCLAIM COVENANTS es CD The land with the buildings thereon, situate in Barnstable I■1 r M (Centerville), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, bounded and 'K llf described as follows: _ BEGINNING at a point in the Easterly line of an old wood road and in the Southerly line of the New State i Highway as shown on a 'plan hereinafter referred Il to; t THENCE running North 690 43' 20" East, two hundred F ninety-three (293) feet, more or less, over the l Southerly line of said State Highway to land 9 ( now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; THENCE South 64" 31' 30" East, five hundred sixty-nine and 46/100 (569.46) feet by land now or formerly ; of said Alice L. Fuller to a stake and stones at i �x a corner of land now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; ^J� i THENCE South IP 02' 30" West, eighty-five and 56/100 (85.56) feet to an old County Road leading from } Barnstable to Osterville; i THENCE Westerly by said old County Road to an old wood road; and A:u:.>•IY Al LAW THENCE Northwesterly along the Easterly side of old wood .s. I road about eight hundred twenty-five (825) feet to the first mentioned bound or place of beginning. Page 1 of 3 Pages i i a BOOKU49 P.',GE 102 Said premises contain about 1.8 acres, and are shown as LOT #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass. Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson Hearse Surveyor, Centerville, Mass.", which said Plan is duly recorded in said h Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48,,Page 49. There is excepted and excluded from the above-described i 1ipremises Lot #3 as shown on a plan' of land belonging to Joseph J. Silvia recorded in said- Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 139, Page �i i155, which said premises were conveyed to Adolph Deikis et ux by i deed dated August 1, 1970, and duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Book 1480, Page 461; there is also excepted and excluded f from the above-described premises Lot # as shown on said plan, which said premises were conveyed to Charles P. Colbath et ux' by I - deed dated June 9, 1980, and recorded in said Registry in Book 3107, Page 269. Meaning and intending to convey and hereby conveying Lots 1 and 2 as shown on plan recorded'in said Registry in Plan Book 139, r Page 155. Meaning and intending to convey any and all of the remaining portion of the premises conveyed to the Grantor by deed of John D. Scannell et ux dated June 29,. 1976, recorded in•said Registry in Book 2361, Page 158. It is the intent of the Grantor by this Deed to convey all RuSERT H.CLAYTGX of that portion of the premises conveyed by the Scannells ATTOA.':EY AT W.9 WC Y—OUT". Ol6T. - n Page 2 of 3 Pages i i • i I 1 • I _ 1 BOOKX49 103 i. i remaining with me after the Deed to Charles P. Colbath et ux so that by this deed I will have conveyed all of the premises conveyed to me by the aforementioned deed of John D. Scannell, et ux. WITNESS my hand and seal this >`- day of SCr� 1980. i .I I E war F, S p n Trustee o 1 Ranch Rail Realty Trust I ! COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Barnstable, ss. SE f S , 1980 ,I Then personally appeared the above-named Edward F. Simpson, f� 1' (Trustee as aforesaid, and acknowledged the foregoing instrument Ito be his free act and deed, before me i Notary Public ;f My Commission Expires:,jc, I II 1 i {I HOD:n1'd.CLTi iUN! f! AITIF],Y AT LAW •11 Fll'1 i.AO 1 wf At IAe N•l•TN.NA C!A)A • Page 3 of 3 Pages i;���;,�[�SEP 580 (1 it ' f i j I 4 I I BJ�,A,S F.;Gf 00i ' 1363.3 1 WE, CHARLES P. COLBATH and BARBARA M. COLBATH of 1927 Falmouth Road, j Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, for consideration paid of TWO HUNDRED TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND AND 00/100 ($225,000.00) DOLLARS, grant to DAVID A. SAURO and JANICE L. SAURO, Trustees of DAVID RENTAL TRUST, under written Declaration of Trust dated January 18, 1983 and recorded with the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 3656, Page 245, as amended by an instrument recorded in said Deeds in Book 4388, Page 211, with a mailing I W�ti��-�'•��� address of Post Office Box 426, Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable County, m Massachusetts 02632, with QUITCLAIM COVENANTS, the land with buildings thereon situate in Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, bounded ti and described as follows: mill: BEGINNING at a point in the Easterly line of an old wood road and in the e. I Southerly line of the New State Highway as shown on a plan uj hereinafter referred to; ZIT Y THENCE running North 690 43' 20" East, two hundred ninety-three (293) n, feet, more or less, over the Southerly line of said State Highway to land now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; 19 1 THENCE South 640 31' 30" East, five hundred sixty-nine and 46/100 (569.46) feet by land now or formerly of said Alice L. Fuller 5 U,a to a stake and stones at a corner of land now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; h CTHENCE South 130 02' 30" West, eighty-five and 56/100 (85.56) feet to an old County Road leading from Centerville to Osterville; THENCE Westerly by said old County Road to an old wood road; and THENCE Northwesterly along the Easterly side of old wood road about eight hundred twenty-five (825) feet to the first mentioned bound or place of beginning. Said premises contain about 1.8 acres, and are shown as LOT #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass. page one of two BOOKV,.,oOi;GE 002 , Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson Bearse, Surveyor, Centerville, Mass.", which said plan is duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48, Page 49. There is excepted and excluded from the above-described premises LOT #3 as shown on a plan entitled "Plan of Land in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass., Belonging to Joseph J. Silvia, scale 1 inch = 60 Ft., Dec. 4, 1956, Nelson Bearse, & Richard Law, Surveyors, Centerville, Mass. recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Pian Book 139, Page 155,• which said premises were conveyed to Adolph Deikis et ux )y deed dated August 1, 1970, and duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Book 1480, Page 461; therefis also excepted_ and excluded from the above-described premises Lots 1 and 2-as shown on said plan. Meaning and intending to convey and hereby conveying all of the premises conveyed by deed of John D. Scannell et ux dated June 29, 1976, recorded in e Book 2361, Page 158, at the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds with the (% exception of Lots 1 and 2 hereinbefore referred to. Said real estate is conveyed subject to a right of way, €444e" (143) feet wide, across the granted premises running parallel and adjacent to the Northeasterly boundary by land now or formerly of John F. Shields for the purposes of egress and ingress for pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and from Lot 1 as shown on a plan of land recorded in the Barnstable County Registry, of Deeds in Book 139, Page 155, to the State Highway, Route 28. Said right of way shall be restricted for use only by the owner, his successors, assigns and tenants or guests of said Lot 1. For Grantors' title, see deed from Edward F. Simpson, Trustee 'of Ranch Rail Realty Trust dated June 9, 1980, recorded with the Barnstable County ,ie' Registry of Deeds in Book 3107, Page 266. WITNESS OUR HANDS AND SEALS this yP day of F�ebraary�-1987. //��►► Charles P./Colbath Barbara M. Col at COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS y y� ' Barnstable, ss. ary- 1987 then personally appeared the above-named CHARLES P 0 ATH and BARBARA M. COLBATH and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to t i actnd fr a deed, before me, M n expire ] R60[-,uHU` MAR `587 page two of two t i 1 EXHIBIT 14 Boon5590 P.-GE 003 13614 WE, CHARLES P. COLBATH, BARBARA M. COLBATH and DENIS J. COLBATH a/k/a DENNIS J. COLBATH, all of 1927 Falmouth Road, Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, for consideration paid of SEVENTY THOUSAND AND 00/100 ($70,000.00) DOLLARS grant to DAVID J. SAURO, Trustee of DAVID BUILDING TRUST , under written.Declaration of Trust dated February 12, 1972 and recorded with the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 3442, Page 292, as amended by an instrumenx.recorded` in said Deeds in Book 3656, Page 257, with a mailing address of Post Office Box 426, Barnstable (Centerville), } Barnstable County, Massachusetts 02632, with QUITCLAIM COVENANTS, the land with buildings thereon, situate in Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable County,, Massachusetts, bounded and described as follows: LOTS #1 and #2 as shown on a plan of land entitled "Plan of Land In Centerville, Barnstable, Mass., Belonging to Joseph J. Silvia, scale. I inch = 60 Ft., Dec. 4, 1956, Nelson Bearse, & Richard Law, Surveyors, Centerville, Mass." recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 139, Page 155. ere i xcep ted an cluded from the ve-described pre s Lot #3 as show on sai lan, which premises were c ye to Adolph De et p ux by dee dated A st 11, 1g� duly recorded in 1d Registry of Dee i L1 Book 1480, age 461. �C��Vr•� Said real estate is conveyed together with a right of way, fifteen feet wide, across the Grantors former premises, shown as LOT #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass. Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson Bearse Surveyor, Centerville, Mass.". which said plan is duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48, Page 49, running parallel and adjacent to the Northeasterly boundary by land'now or formerly of John F. Shields for the purposes of egress and ingress for pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and from Lot 1 as shown on a plan of land recorded in the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 139, Page 155, to the State highway, Route 28. Said right of way shall be restricted for use only by the owner, his successors, assigns and . tenants or guests of said Lot 1. It is the intent of the Grantors by this Deed to convey all of that remaining portion of the premises conveyed by the Scannell sto Edward F. Simpson, Trustee by the deed recorded in Book 2361, Page 158 less-that-Wh-0wis=excePt*d page one of two l BOOKWO P.-GE 004 abeMe-and that which is convey?d to David A. Sauro and Janice L. Sauro, Trustees, by a deed recorded prior hereto. For our title reference; see deed recorded in Book 3149, Page 101. WITNESS OUR HANDS AND SEALS this '"`-day of Feb.av,1, 1987. Charles P. C61bath Barbara M. Colbati � C•lti--� .' t�Y is J. Colbat a a Dennis J. Colba h COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS l� Barnstable, ss. Fghruar� , 1987 . Then personally appeared the above-named CHARLES P OLBATH. BARBARA M. COLBATH and DENIS J. COLBATH a/k/a DENNIS J. COLBATH, d cknowledge the foregoing instrument to be their free act and. deed, be or m No ry Pub My c missio expires C.cfAKAO cJ, tr p ven set Jj )_� 15 9. 6 Q ar page two of two " MAR 587 i f s ' e i . f - A L I CLERK ASS. - BARNS I .� •g� DEC 21 Rio 32 TowN of BARNST,ABLE PETITION FOR gpp(-TAT PgRMTT UNDER TEE ZONING BYLAW To the Board of Appeals. Town Hall,H annis.MA 02601 aae Ort- 1g 87 The undersigned petitions the Board of Appeals Lo vary,in the manner and for the reasons hereinafter set forth,the application of the provisions pf the zoning by!aw to the following described premises. Applicant: . David A. Sauro and Janice L. Sauro, Trustees of David Rental Trust lru .�amel 1 1I14 'Trust (Telephone Kumlr_r) Address: Box 426, Centerville, MA. 02632 Owner: -_same,-as above I Full X.-el same as above Pr;ur Cl--:ner of record- -Charles P. Colbath Teazm lif;:nyl: ----.__..-_---Centerville Motel__._— -----.--_----_--_ - -.- .- -Full N h-•e) - ._ !; ..:n: [•':cr :....,. Q•.n;�c, Of�, i•�cr)- :.'.r ra ..._ O,,n &rt•ct ]. .:. .. _ aad lot nu r,ber.____. _`.L$�. - ,. Lots 67, 129 and 130 2. 1927 _ 1..:•:::::,:: o;f:•::;:ises -• .------•--- -------`--Mp�:"� _ 1<GGIi� \'i;l Se ` 2.,_^,•J� � Ili 301.28 on Route 8` 60-150'-- — (\t•''�.I:vn 4r a:-TI - 3. D'.;1Er: Emsoflolalsoon--undefined-ancient-way --- ----Lot 67_(_64) Lot 129 _ 130 (.31) . 4. &uninc disiricl in which premises are located RC_-.- --•-- ---- ---------------- J. lieu h:.^.g hss c-•cr:er had title to the abr%e premises? .__..6 months --—- --- - - 6. Ho v Inane•buildings are now on the lot? --1_on Lot 129 and 3 on Lot 67 7. Give size of existing buildings Frc•p:osed buildings see plans attached _ — s. S:zte present use of premises 9 F-_a;e pr:pcs-d use of premises4_two-bedroom_apartments.,two-of-which-are.,to be rented in �ccordan- with the-Barnstable[Hoeusin,%Au�horoitytRe pal Certificate prograttl. )U. ':e ex:enl o. ion Demolition of existing one-story wooden frame structure and construction of new 4 unit apaz-ment structure with eight_(8)_ bedrooms. ]]. tiu:e`er uf:iE'Ing units for NEhlch builair.s- is to be arre::yc7d fQur.__!A)_--. ..... _ 12. .:z:e- . -_`_mi':ed pans fur=`:o:e to :ne 1_3—j ing In ;rc:ur? -- No - )2, ras he ref_=r'z permit?---N/A --...---._.....- -... .4. \',;.at sectiun of.Eming byla:: do%nu ask to F.e :a:ird? A70 Variance- is, sought, Petitioner-is seeking a Special Permit_undex.Section G, Non-conforming Uses, and Section P, .paragraohs 4-and 6, ,f_or change, extension or alteration of pre-existing non-conforming use and structure. fury}50Sl3DX sfler:c; Fey it: _.Prc;perty_is loF3tQd.in zQsidixntial _2on;ng district, therefore, pre-existing nnn-conforming..use as a motel/.anarttrents requires a special oermi The /`ur41 under Sections cited above.- /Petitioner in seeking..a.permit.for construction of the yenta nits-orolaoses..to submit two (2) units to the Barnstable Housinq Authoritv Rental Certificate program-_ ----...... .. . .. ..._. _. _. . i he fo'.ln'.'ir.f are:hc--nes crd n:.l i addresses o rti e a,'u uing,o. Hers orpro1 v and:n[-,nes d and adresses -cr:.,. :•v:nrrs c r_rc;.=rt zbc::inr:hE abul:inp n: ner>prr rc;a r:y a-c thr Hanes and addrrs c a:ie Owner-,across:}:e ::reel eli i:h:heir corresponding map and lot r,t mLrrs a[curdl,•ie to thr recurds in tnr.=._...s.or's Ufr)C.e al thc'date or this application: 5 Please type or print only. A7ap Lot 7 Tame Address Zip Code SEFr > CfD LIST J I hereby certify the names and address on the attached sheets as required Linder Sec ll, Chap 40A of the Massachusetts General Laws area as they appear on the most recent tax.list to within 300 ft or the abutters to the abutters within the 300 ft. , l Dec 23, 1987 Andrew Machado Assistant Assessor Use additional separate skeet and so note if neces,ary t with tie a- lication at the time of filing, a P'an of the'.tr,ri,IF:,e i5)Cctirsl c oh'i 1. la c..- n:ions of the land. 2. :r e 107:.:icn or r,:,ting l;•uildin s c•n t`.e'.:.nd. Michael D. Ford, Esquire, Agent for Box 960 Fetiti-or „' '•e tivaru�is, M�. 02601 P: e.. ._.. ... ..n. 771-5070 LouTfl 2$ ' c� N aj i ip ' UCw GVRO �.JT .p 7•�TZ:h'i?��o 9�Pwc'i M£rJT\i ^"D� ag. .srNla Vlmv'>'+•+nE �Tu1cT`]cG I _ . .\WJ^•sESP'i/,:.0 fr\ NBC -,� 'Tb'F7E�p6MOiJ6N@� T . v,-> 00, �z 1.?c�v�cD�.,...�I•JS, Lori. � vm .P�' \ l ` b`'�--�� . S.k,—,I.oT Cwr-"6E J6,6goti R'aa Oda 14 Ya "4s � L-ev ,A "FCz e9 �con c-%A,•L fir: GievaC. i" .LNO. IZC U:-Z��l•'41�-I - _ � -�..)i.. TnuK BFNGUN Ci�r,b �7�.,Ass' Id w T:.�a9'at'.' <o-r•=r;r _,�' -- ' ,:4b...eJC J.e-.•\�S..a.«. J`j-:w-.. - :6Z•�s-,1..: =YSG. w3 C i .. AZEA Sspu L I rJnWsara S'T, �aa�.d..a rt,b�' Aoo Pewrn _-� � L_or 1 �h�*•'la�n'H..RCAD ��'+T Z0� •"�2V F1,r r`"`.of sv� tt I�f='7 t�'P��KwNT: ��Y11.77IN6 1 Qu6'T' •� �.•mAo� �i ♦ Jwu11�\9�9 T r VPGI.TE h4,IIA n � !Z..-�,n� •c�4K�'EC�I�E�r,lt i 1 •i,. 1 -aA TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BOARD OF APPEALS MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF PETITION OF DAVID A. SAURO AND JANICG L . SAURO, TRUSTEES OF DAVID RENTAL TRUST AND DAVID A. SAURO, TRUSTEE OF DAVID BUILDING TRUST FOR SPECIAL PERMIT FOP, PROPERTY LOCATED AT: F 1927 Famouth Road, Centerville, MA . Submitted by: i Michael D . Ford, Esq. Mycock, Kilroy, Green & McLaughlin, P .C. Box ' 960 Hyannis, fMA . 0.2601 771-5070 ` i , I FACTS The locus which is the subject of this petition. consists of three adjacent lots located off_ of Route 28, ( 1927 Falmouth Road) , in the Village of Centerville in a residential zoning district. The parcel has 300 feet of frontage on Route 28 . The total area of ' the three lots combined is 1 . 34 acres. The total area of the two lots which are the subject of the proposed project is 27 , 248 sq. ft . At present the Petitioners operate the property as a pre-exist ing. nonconf orming use consisting of twelve ( 12 ) rental units, eight ( 8 ) of which are efficiency units and four (4 ) of which are single rooms. Three of the units are presently rented to the Housing Assistance Corporation and the Barnstable Housing Authority under their respective rental assistance programs . The property has the benefit of a special permit under Appeal No, 1966-3 (a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A) which allowed the construction of the building, presently proposed for demolition, and its use as two ( 2 ) apartment units. The use of the property for rental units commenced around 1.950 and was operated as the Ranch Rail motor Court . It is a pre-existing nonconforming use in that this area has been zoned. Residential and the previous Board in the 1_966 Special Permit Petition found that said use was indeed a pre-existing nonconforming use. Subsequent to the issuance of the 1966 permit, the one-story wooden frame dwelling that is sought to be demolished. and replaced with. the proposed structure was constructed. There is presently one ( 1) apartment unit located in said structure. -1- The Petitioners ,propose upon demolition of the - -- -- --_--a f or e-m ent-io n-e d--st r-u c t ur e---to c-o n s-tr-u c t-a---t w o-=s t o r b u i l d i n y-- g---w i t h-- -- --- four (4) apartment units located in same with a total of eight (8 ) bedrooms . The Petitioners further propose, and would welcome a restriction, that at least two (2) . of the proposed four ( 4 ) units be offered on a' long .term basis to the Barnstable Housing Authority for ,use in their rental assistance program. ( See letter from :Michael Toner, Director of the Barnstable Housing Authority attached hereto as Exhibit B. ) There are six ( 6 ) parking spaces proposed to service the four units. The new building, although slightly larger , will be built in approximately the same location as the existing building, setback from Route 28 by over 100 feet . 1 � The new building as proposed would meet all of the requirements for four ( 4 ) new apartments ,�or multi-family dwelling , as provided for in Section 3-2 .1 Subsection J except the required perimeter green space of 20 feet along one side of the lot serviced by the 'proposed driveway and parking . ARGUMENT The Petitioners are seeking a special permit under the provisions of old Section G, ParagraphB and old Section P, Paragraphs 4 and 6 to extend, change or alter a pre-existing nonconforming use The applicable sections under the recodif.ied By-law are Sections 4-4 .2 , Subparagraphs 2 and 3 . The test before the Board of Appeals is the same as it was under the previous By-law. i .e. , whether or not the proposed -2- extension or . alteration of the pre-existing nonconforming structure and use is more objectionable and substantially detrimental to the neighborhood then the existing nonconforming structure and use. The nonconforming use of the site, i .e. as multiple rental efficiency units, pre-dates the adoption of zoning in 1954 , the initial units having been constructed in 1950 . The use has been recognized as a nonconforming use by the Board of Appeals in Special Permit No. 1966-3 which authorized the construction of the two (2) additional efficiency apartment units. Therefore, the Petitioners ' standing to apply for special permit relief as a nonconforming use falls under the provisions of Section 4-4 .2 . The Board must now determine whether or not the issuance of the permit as requested would result in a use which is substantially more detrimental or more objectionable to the neighborhood then the existing nonconforming use. The neighborhood is primarily residential in nature consisting of vacant residential land and numerous single-family dwellings . The proposed use would be in conformity with the underlying zoning being residential in nature. Indeed, the uses as proposed would only be an increase of three (3) units over what is presently on the site and two ( 2 ) units over what was authorized as an addition by the 1966 Special Permit. As such, the additional three ( 3 ) units would not result in any substantial increase in traffic or congestion. The benefit to the neighborhood and .the Town as a whole is that such needed housing will be made available to those in great need of one. -3- Y Since purchasing. the .property in March of 1987 the Petitioners have made numerous changes to the existing property including a 'complete face-Lift and renovation of all existing buildings other than the one proposed for demolition, the . elimination of the swimming pool that-existed in the front yard on Route 28 and interior remodeling and cleaning of all units presently under rental contract .' The Petitioners' have submitted elevations to show the style and construction of the building and all traffic would ingress and egress out onto Route 28 at the existing curb cut. The site plan, together with ' the proposed elevations clearly show that the project aesthetically will be an improvement over the existing wooden frame. structure which it will replace on the back portion of the lot . CONCLUSION The Petitioners feel that the permit as prayed for will result in an extension of the existing use, residential in character , in keeping with the, under_lying residential zoning- and one which would greatly benefit the neighborhood in terms of providing much needed housing. Therefore, the Petitioners would suggest that to grant the permit as prayed for , with restrictions, would not be more objectionable or substantially detrimental to the neighborhood then the existing nonconforming rental operation. 3792d , At the conclusion of the hearing, the Board took said petition under advisement. A view of the locus was had by the Board. 3V� on 19,.E the Board of Appeals found T118 ve tftioner stated that he desire a to eunlargo an existing non-corXorminC use 'by adding a 36 by 16 Soot b-ftildinZo to ba placed in the rear of the are wont motor e='*t prarrsi ca s on Fouto 28 in Centerville. . The new buildir % ill ecntcin two efficiency unit F .each with a bedroc-r.., bath and Litchonetto. �`he -petitioner 'r:.as vwno6 the Ranch Rail Motor Court since 1c'60. the opinion of the petitionor the addition oftao of ficioncy units to the exiatinC use would not be dot-mental to tho az ea. It. was the -opinion of tae Loam that the addition of two e"fi.cisncy ape.„t=`ents was a reasonable extension of tho OF.iB-pins non-conform-inr use. --he neti4ionor DIms to locate the building at n din-.i nce of anmrc+xi toll-.-17 f ee- f'rmi the _ rear of tho existinY. bui l din--. In thin location., the bui2din,f. could not be see:: Lror tha rt.:roet eLd-k.culd not be detr3 ont al �o s o.inc?in�; resic:ent3al n��operty. The :�ourci vat©o w�^ni. oucly to grant a special vor-nit subject i;o the re:friction that- the Aroposed buildin^; conform to the 8t;;lc of the exis tin;- Wild mme Restrictions imposed: ; Distribution: Board of Appeals ' Town Clerk Applicant Town of Barnstable Persons interested Building Inspector Public Information By Board of Appeals Chairman Barnstable • 9A MAWL ie, • L Telephone (617) 771-7222 =6 HOUsing- AUt6 r.lty--_.-- --146 South Street • H'yannis,Massachusetts 02601- - ?°70• �4�._. 4' January '14, 1988 Mr. Ron S. Jansson, Chairman Town of Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals ' Town Hall Hyannis, MA 02601 Re: 'Petition of 'David A. Sauro Dear Chairman Jansson: The Barnstable Housing Authority. has negotiated with Mr.. Sauro for exclusive use of two (2-BR) units within his property located at 1927 Falmouth Road, Centerville. Mr. Sauro has agreed to provide these units to the Barnstable Housing Authority within } our fair market rent limitation for the benefit of our low and moderate income clients. The t.erm of this commitment is 15 years, to be structured in 'such a manner that the BHA does not exceed current financing agreements with the State or Federal government . It should be `noted that the "countable" units under 40B is a matter of "interpretation"regarding this particular development: We believe that Mr . Sauro' s proposal is consistent with the Town ' s efforts to provide affordable housing for its citizens. If you require additional information please contact me. Sincerely, C . Michael Toner Executive Director cc : Attorney Michael Ford 1 TOWN OF BARNSTABLEO � . BAR .. H t.fia. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS APR 14_ _P 4_23_ -- - - DECISION AND NOTICE SPECIAL PERMIT PETITION NO: 1988-0.3 PETITIONER: David A. Sauro and Janice L. Sauz Trustees of David Rental Trust - David A. Sauro, .Trustee of David -Building Trust . At a regularly scheduled hearing, held on January 1.4 , 1988, notice of which was duly published in the Barnstable Patriot, and notice of which was forwarded to all interested parties pursuant to Chapter 4.0A of the General Laws of Massachusetts, the Petitioner, through attorney Michael D. Ford., Esquire, requested a Special Permit of section 4-4 .2 of the Town of Barns.table 's Zoning Bylaws for the property located at 1927 Falmouth. Road., Centerville. (Map 189, Lots 67, 129 and 130 ) . In support of this petition, the petitioner presented evidence: The petitioners own a separately deeded lot , which is 16 , 840 square feet in all and contains a single-family residential structure. The. petitioner presented plans to, show the .removal of the single-family structure and the construction of a four-unit apartment building with a total of eight bedrooms. The petitioner requires a Special Permit on the basis that this is an extension. of the existing, non- conforming use on an adjoining, separately deeded lot. Based on the evidence submitted, the .Zoning Board of Appeals made the. following findings: Lot 1 is- occupied by a single-family residential structure and, there- fore, is: in compliance with the existing zoning bylaw classification of this area as single-family residential uses only. The. petitioner, therefore, has no standing to request a special permit to extend a non-conforming use. -2- To replace a conforming, single-family structure with a use that is not permitted in the zoning district requires a variance which was not requested nor .advertised', and which is not permitted within 300 feet of Route 28. A special permit issued under Appeal No. 1966-03 allowed for the construction of two units on Parcel 1. Only one unit was constructed and the special permit granted 22 years ago has long. since expired. Based on the consideration of the land area involved as either .one entire parcel consisting of ,three adjoining lots, or as one separate lot #1, the addition of four dwelling units and eight bedrooms on this small property is an over-intensification of use and would be substantially more detrimental to the neighbor affected. At a public hearing held on March .31, 1988 , the Zoning Board of Appeals. vot.ed by a unanimous vote to deny the Special Permit sought . The following members voted on the petition:- Paul Brown, Dexter Bliss, Richard L. Boy, Gail Nightingale and Ron S. Jansson. h I I N l - i Any person aggrieved by this dects on may appeal to the -- Barn-stab-i.e--Super-i.or_.Court; or-Land-_Court__of_ the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, as prescribed in section 17 of Chapter 40A of the General La ws of Massachusetts by filing a Complaint in said Courts) as well as a notice of action with the Barnstable Town Clerk, within twenty (20) days of the filing of this decision with the Barnstable Town Clerk's Office. All ,. Chairman Clerk I, Irene E. Job_ „ . „ . . _ _._,�».., Clerk of the Town of 13ariist:tole, 13ari'sstable. County, Massachusetts, l:iereby certify. that twenty (20) days have elapsed since the Board of Appeals. rendered its.deci9ion in the above untitled petition and Witt no appeal of. said. dccisi4m ling been filed. in the office of the Town Clerk. Ma fy88 w. under the paius anti. Signed and Sealed this .5th�.»-�.. cla;• of �..:�....�..-�,.�. .�.».�»...• penalties of perjury. bistribution °'r �' Property owner '"""" Town .Clerk Asst.TOM Clerk, Applicant Persons interested Building Inspector Public information Board of Appeals PARTIES IN. INTEREST 1988-03 - DAVID A. & JANICE L. SAURO -------_- - - -MEETI-N_G_QF_ ,IANUA_RY_14, 1988 -.- --- osarlaeRaspan eo 65 Millstone Way, Centerville 02632 Frank J. Donovan P.O. Box 87., E. Wakefield,N.H. 03830 Burns, Sheila F. 36 Allan Rd. , W. Barnstable 02668 Brandos, Joseph 1934 Falmouth Rd. , Centerville: Fairbanks, J. Richard Irma N. Fairbanks 39 Birchill Rd. ,. Centerville Forman, Saul .S. & Dolores 28 Wilshire Drive, Sharon. 02067 Jucenas, Brone 195 Fuller Rd. , Centerville Morrill, Pamela 85 Brandywine Ln., Suffield, CT 0.60 Parissi, Anthony J. Patricia. A. Parissi . 190 Fuller Rd. , Centerville Wiinikainen, Olavi V. Gladys L. Wiinikainen 164 Fuller Rd. , Centerville Dupuis, Herbert. L. Natalie L. Dupuis 156 Fuller Rd. , 'Centerville Berry, John F. 1641., Rte. 28, Centerville Lebel, Douglas W. Sollows, Jeffrey A.. Trs. 131 Old Rte. 132 , Barnstable 02630 Carr, Kenyon A. Greene, P. A. & Drew W. L. Trs. Fraternal Lodge AF &' AM Box 654, Hyannis 02601 Urbanik, Dale F. 15.3 Hickory Hill Circle, Osterville 02655 ~ TOWN OF BARNSTASLIr ' ZONING BOARD OF.AITEALS NO'IICE OF PUBLIC HEARING UNDER ZONING BY-LAWS ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS MEETING OF JANUARY 14,1988 To all persons deemed interested or affected by the.Board of Appeals,under ec.S it of.Chap.:40A of General Ima of.the,Commonwealth.of Massachusetts and all amendments thereto,you are hereby notified that: Appeal No..19W-01,`7:30 p.m.:Jaogcea N.Me&&b[uG&DL*Wn have appealed to the Zoning Board of.Appeals.and petition for a Modification of a Use Variance at Map 310,Lot M 300 Bearse's Way,.Hyannis,mt an RB zoning . district. - t A public hearing.will.be held on this petition-at.7:30 p.m. A. Appeal No.1987.9ti,.7AS p.m.:Robert M.WMhuns&Lnum A.Widla®a have appealed a. decision of.,the Building Inspector and petition'for a Variance/Special Permit to build an office:building to house a bank and other office space at Map 294,Lot 10 and.Map 311;Lot 92;at Corner of Airport Road and Route 132,Hyannis,in a Highway Business,Business and Industrial zoning di$WIC'. A public bearing will be,heid.owthis petition at 7.45.p.m. ` Appeat:No.1988A2,8:00 p.m.s Santa Dawaan•Eft.has appealed a decision of the Building Inspector and petitions for a Variance to.ovmert etisting barn into two one bedroom apartments at Map 157,Lot 1,located on Route 6A,West Barnstable;in a:RF°zoning.district. A public hearing wM be held on this petition at.8:00 P.M. Appeal No.198&031:15 p m.:Davld-A...Swm&Janice L Sam,Trustees e of.David Ranfal.Trmt;Dadd A.Sauro,Tmotee of David BuildingTrast have appealed to the Zoning Board of Appeals and:petition.for a Spww.Permk at Map 189,Lots 67,129 and:130,:1927 Falmouth Road,Centerville,for demoli. tion of existing structure and construction of new four•unit apartment structure with eight bedrooms in a RC zoning disbicL A public hearing will be held on this petition at 8:1S p.m. Appeal NO.1%8-04,8a30 p.rna RobertJoseph Mayo has appealed to the Zon. ing Board of.Appeals and petitions for a.Special Permit at Map.140,Lot 061, Blanid.Road,Ostcrville,to finish off esiSting shed dormer for use as.a:family apartment in.a RC Zoning district: A public bearing will be on this.petition at;8:30 p:m, These hearings will be held in the second floor hearing room,New Town Hall, 367 Main Street,Hyannis,on Thursday evening,January 14,1988. You are.invited to be present. By order of the Zoning Board of Appeals Barnstable Patriot December 23,.1987 and January.7,1988 Ron S.Janson,Chairman Zoning Board of Appeals December 24,1987 and January 7,1988 ••4r IM• Je"" •4 .: T aWN.�4 ERM t5s .Bj DEC 21 R10 .32 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE PETITION FOR 'sPF'('TAT. PF.RMTT UNDER THE ZONING BYLAW To the Board of Appeals. Tcru•n Nall, Hti•a,nnis, 1w1A 02601 • D:1to Oct - .87 � The undersigned petitions the Board of Appeals to vary,in the manner and for the reasons hereinafter set fort~:,the application of the m��sians of the zoning b•:aw to'the folioV. ng described premises. David A. Savro and Janice L. Sauro, Trustees of David„Rental Trust Applicant: ld l 1nQ ruS r ttu . a•me> _ tTeicphone":umt+er) ry , ille MA. 02632 Add,es.s Box 426, Cente same as above — ---- --- IFull Narnel same as above f ric,r Q•-nor of record. _ Charles _P COlbath ;--- :r Cete nrville Motel - Ij-vii i' _ ...if :t.:n t�-,t...e: of r.-i•�.CJiy - _ ` L � Lots 67, 129 and 1.30 ac ini ..^.utr,:�er -- — -- 1 ]. , 301.28 on Route ` 60-150' Lot 67 t_.64)_ Lot .129 (._39.) _ 3 �:,�f :�.�.;_: of;otalso ors -undefined ancient-way.._ �__ -..__ ..._ . etaot 130 (.31) I .. . r 4. Z�ain.g disrri'ct in which premises are located -- 6 months •'cv. is h z. c,•::er had .title to t.hc- shore Free'::ees? 3�•w 1-.m hui;dina. are,nox• an the lni? ']_ _on Lot 129 and _3 on Lot 67 _ 7 Cis F :izi?of existing buildings -vians—a_ttach_e_d--. Prrpas�d.bU�toins see plans 'attached _____..-- •- ----.. _ $. C:=_•.'e j,reFt?nt use Of PfEl7ricgc motelLapartmen.tsf- `C of Frt nises4_two-bedroom apartments,._-tiao_`Of.tahich .are to }fie reritecl In �Ccord�ulC l with the, }3arnst e Hou in(7_,Au{�] rity, Rei;ital Certificate program• _. "`.mot-'__, .,. ., .7 .i_2:nr V"T'e or r.-,t n 3 n--5 th t nnr.ne�-aj--a6d,J—% o-':ht wwners-a:ress. C., :-C.tr! the .4l.h rr.,-,-,2-kd im atvurdmg to the re-cords m--�v AIL.�r-o.'3;Of7it-e-at tr.(-d;i-0' this application. hi ap Lot V Name AddressZip Code SEF,��-APIPL LIST I hereby certify the names and address on the attached sheets as required under Sec 11, Chap 40A of the Massachusetts General Laws are as they appear on the most recent tax.list to within 300 ft or the abutters to the abutters within the 300 ft. Dec 23, 1987 Andrew Machado Assistant Assessor 211� Use additional kepa.ate$I-leet and so note if r1tc.-Fcary - .A time.or Ming.F. Oi an or f e!L; •, 'he'land. 2. T t of fyift;ng bui!A'l-Igs t..n the ,Michael D. F6rd, F�Nire, Acent fOr BOX 960 02601 771-5070 i DAVID SAUW, TRUSTEE OF DAv1D BUILDING-.'TRUST MAP LOT OWNER and ADDRESS 189 2-1 Stage Development c./o Fraternal Lodge AF & AM Box 654 Hyannis, MA -02601 189 2-2 Stage Development c/o Dunning and Dunning RouteL28. Ma.shpee, MA 02649 189 2-3 Stage Development , c/o Dunning and Dunning Route 2B Mashpee, MA 02649 189 2-4 Stage Develpment -c/o Dunning and Dunning Route 28 Mashpee, MA 02649 189 3 Berry,- John F. 1641 Route `28 Centerville, MA 02632 189 6-4 Small, Alan E. Dorothy Small P..O.. Box 536 Centerville,, MA 02632 189 5.8 Raspante, Luciano., Rosaria Raspante 65 Millstone Way, Centerville, MA 02632 . 189 59 Donovan, Frank J. P.O., Box 87, Fast Wakefield, N.H. 03830 189 60 Burns, Sheila F. 36 Allen Road, West Barns.tab]:e,. MA 02668 189 66 Brandos, Joseph 1934 Falmouth Rd. , , Centerville, MA 02632 189 67 Colbath, Charles P. , Colbath, B.M. c/o Dennis Colbath 1927 1. Falmouth Rd. , Centerville, 14A. 02.632 189 129 _ Co.l:bath, Charles P. , c/o Dennis Colbath --- 192.7 Falmouth Rd. , Centerville, MA .02632 189 130 'Colbath, Charles P. c/o Dennis Colbath 192.7: Falmou:th .Rd. , Centerville, MA 0.2632 189 131 Morrill., Pamela , 85 Brandywine Lane, Suffield, CT 06078 January 7, 1988 TO; Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals F M.z Jacqueline EtstenLMohiammad Tarig RE.- APPEAL #1988-03 (DAVID AND JANICE SA.URO) Location: The premises is a 16,8.40 square foot parcel (Map� 18.9, Lot 129) of land, located at the south side of Route 28 in Centervil 'le. The premises is located within the RC single family residential district. Applicant's Pro2:Qsal .- The applicant proposes to raze the exist!-ng single-family structure which was constructed ire 1985, and build -a multi-family structure with four apartments. The applicant has applied for a special permit under Section 4-4.2 (non-conforming uses) presumably to expand a non-conforming use which exists on an adjacent lot ( lot 0) . Recommendation: It is recommended that this petition be denied. The applicant is, attempting to creat a separate. new use on a lot which does not conform to zoning. A use variance Js required but not permitted along Route 28. THE Department of Planning and Development MAS& STAFF R-EPORT EXHIBIT 16 JOr :PH D. DALUZ — A=189-067 TELHPHONEt 775-1120 Bu ding Commissioner EXT. 107 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR TOWN OFFICE BUILDING HYANNIS, MASS. 02601 June 9, 1989 Mr. David A. Sauro, Trustee David Rental Trust P. 0. Box 426 Centerville, MA 02632 RE: A=189-067 Route 28, Centerville Dear Mr. Sauro• This letter will confirm our telphone conversation of June 7, 1989. Upon inspection at the above locato �t was determined that a stairway with rails and platform wouldrbe required1to�provide a second-means of - egress from the second floor apartment unit. In addition, a. three foot (3') wide walkway with railings on each side.lis required to safely reach stairway. _......_.. Work to be done within the next seven. (7) days and this office to be notified upon completion for required inspection. Very truly yours, A 55��W1 _ �k Richard R. Bearse Building Inspector RRB/gr cc: C-0-M.M. Fire Department f, f' � 4� h e l ,Lt' /vV% �' c3�•�f'�,�?d fi""�rG �YT ��� v ekl��Ise t� S. .- IV I b r - 1 t 5 w - I ' a Boor 8688 PAu 234 MASSACHUSETTS QUITCLAIM OEM BY CORPORATION (LONG FORM) 795 4,F,301 BBX Real Estate. Corporation a corporation duly established under the laws of Massachusetts —— —and having its usual place of"4usirie§s 7 New England Executive Park, Burlington, Middlesex County,Massachusetts for consideration paid,and in full consideration of ONE HUNDRED FIFTEEN THOUSAND AND NO/100 ($115,000.00) giant to Richard P. Callahan, Trustee of Centerville Village Apartments Realty Trust u/d/t dated July 8, 1993 Of 770A Main Street, Osterville, Massachusetts with quitclaim rournttrits � Sbe�d3e ( 10 PARCEL ONE the land with buildings thereon situate in Barnstable (Centerville) , Barnstable county, Massachusetts, bounded and described as follows: BEGINNING at a point in the Easterly line of an old wood road and in the Southerly line of the New State Highway as shown on a plan hereinafter referred to; THENCE running North 69° 43' 20" East, two hundred ninety-three (293 feet, more or less, over the Southerly line of said State Highway to land.now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; THENCE South 64° 31' 30" East, five hundred sixty-nine and 46/100 (569.46) feet by land now or formerly of said Alice L. Fuller to a stake and stones at a corner of land now or formerly of Alice L. Fuller; THENCE South 130 02' 30" West, eighty-five and 56/100 (85.56) feet to an, old 0ounty Road leading from Centerville to Osterville; , THF3QCE Westerly by said old County Road to an old wood road; and THENCE Northwesterly along the Easterly side of old wood road about eight hundred twenty-five (825) feet to the first mentioned bound or place of beginning. Said premises oontain about 1.8 acres, and are shown as IM #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass. Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson Bearse, Surveyor, Centerville, Mass.", which said plan is duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Bock 48, Page 49. There is excepted and excluded from the above-described premises LOT 3.as shown on a plan entitled "Plan of Land in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass., Belonging to Joseph J. Silvia, scale 1 inch = 60 Ft., Dec. 4, 1956, Nelson Bearse, & Richard Law, Surveyors, Centerville, Mass." recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 139, Page 155, which said premises were conveyed to Adolph Deikis et ux by deed dated August 1, 1970, and duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Book 1480, Page 461; there is also excepted and excluded from the above-described premises Lots 1 and 2 as shown on said plan. Said real estate is conveyed subject to a right of way, ten (10) feet wide, across the granted premises running parallel and adjacent to the Northeasterly boundary by land now or formerly of John F. Shields for the purposes of egress and ingress for pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and from Lot 1 as shown on a plan of land recorded in the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 139, Page 155, to the State Highway, Route 28. Said right.of way shall be restricted for use only by the owner, his successors, assigns and tenants or guests of said Lot 1. PARCEL TWO The land with the buildings thereon, situate in Barnstable (Centerville), Barnstable County, Massachusetts, bounded and described as follows: BOOK.8688 mr 235 LOPS #1 and #2 as shown on a plan of land entitled "Plan of Land In Centerville, Barnstable, Mass., Belonging to Joseph J. Silvia, scale 1 inch = 60 Ft., Dec. 4, 1956, Nelson Bears, & Richard Law, Surveyors, Centerville, Mass." recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 139, Page 155. Said real estate is conveyed together with a right of way ten (10) feet wide, across the former premises of Charles P. Colbath, Barbara M. Colbath and Denis J. Colbath alias, shown as LOT #12 on a plan entitled: "Plan #2, Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass. Belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch = 100 ft. October 1932, Nelson Bearse Surveyor, Centerville, Mass.", which said plan is duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48, Page 49, running parallel and adjacent to the Northeasterly boundary by land now or. formerly of John F. Shields for the purposes of egress and ingress for pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and from Lot 1 as shown on a plan of land recorded in Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Book 139, Page 155, to the State Highway, Route 28. Said right of way shall be restricted for use only by the owner, his successors, assigns and tenants or guests of said Lot 1. For title see deed from David A. Sauro and Janice Sauro, Trustees of David Rental Trust to BBX Real Estate Corporation dated May 12, 1993 and recorded with Barnstable County Registry of Deeds on June 7, 1993 as instrumentV32046. See also confirmatory deed from David A. Sauro and Janice L. Sauro, Trustees of David . Rental Trust and David A. Sauro, Trustee of David Building Trust to BBX Real Estate Corporation dated June 29, 1993 and recorded with Barnstable County Registry of Deeds on July 12, 1993 as instrument #40011 I :T {tj 'DEEDS REG bi'; ,. .�. ,.,. �- , ARNSTABLE 21. ro _ .IUL[1'53.�5\`; ��.._ 21/93 n lbw lei\ e CKC •3�3�39 ` TAX':•• . ``` 'spy Y'r•k t'' y -. .. II•• ,'1', .13 E r ; - 0874QRQd 'YAX23 . i l._.._._........ . er (CISE cl I Bw 868 8 �Au 236 flit witurso w4errof, the said BBX Real 'Estate Corporation has caused its corporate seal to be hereto affixed and these presents to be signed, acknowledged and delivered in its name and behalf by Kevin J. Hughes its Vice President hereto duly authorized, this 14th day of July in.the year one thousand nine hundred and ninety—three Signed and sealed in presence of BBX REAL ESTATE CORPORATION ........ _ by ��n . j'C .......... _ .....,.,,. ...._.__......._Hu Ace.l.Mside t............................. m_.__........_.._...........,. ._... t(04r (20utnlaltuiraltil lit id agaitrlluintla Middlesex, SS. July 1.9 93 Then personally appeared the above named Kevin J. Hughes and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to be the free act and deed of the BBX Real Estate Corporation before me 1. • V r Ce..r k J Not ublic , sw 0.14, N. My commission expires V. 5 CHAPTER 183 SEC.6 AS AMENDED BY CHAPTER 497 OF 1969 Every deed presented for record shell contain of have endorsed upon it the full name,residence and post office address of the grantee and a recital of the amount of the full consideration thereof in dollars or the nature of the other consideration therefor, if not delivered for a specific monetary sum. The full consideration shall mean the total price for the conveyance without deduction for any liens or encumbrances assumed by the grantee or retraining thereon, All such endorsements and recitals shall be recorded as part of the deed.Failure to comply with this section shall not affect the validity of any dad.No register of deeds shall accept a deed for recording unless It is in compliance with the requirements of this section, iILLUI&! U JUL Ll y.j aoox 8688 FAu 243 0 QUITCLAIM DEED '4��c,.. 1 ' I, Richard P. Callahan, Trustee of Centerville Village Apartments Realty Trust u/d/t/ dated July 8, 1993 recorded herewith for consideration paid and in .full consideration of one hundred dollars grants to Cynthia H. Callahan, Trustee of Centerville Village Realty Trust u/d/t dated July 8, 1993 with an address at 770A Main Street, Osterville, MA 02655 with Quitclaim Covenants the land with the buildings thereon described as follows on Exhibit A attached hereto and made a part hereof. WITNESS my hand and seal as of this 8th day of July 1993. Richard P. Callahan Trustee COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BARNSTABLE, S.S. SS"� Then personally appeared the above named loard P. Callahan, Trustee, and acknowledge the foregoing instrument to be his free,,,, ,, , • act and deed, before me, N t ry Public ``.,•« Hoy*`� s Ib BOOK 8688 FacE 244 EXHIBIT A i ROTS #1 as shown on a plan of land entitled "Plan of Land In Centerville, Barnstab Mass., Belonging to Joseph J. Silvia, scale 1 inch = 60 Ft., Dec. 4, 1956, Nelson Bears, & Richard Law, Surveyors, Centerville, Mass." recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book ,139, Page 155. Said real estate is conveyed together with a right of way ten (1100) feet wide, across the former premises of Charles P. Colbath, Barbara Me and Denis. J. Oolbath alias, shown as LOT #1.2 on a plan entitled: "Plan #21 Plan of Woodland in Centerville, Barnstable, Mass. belonging to Shirley Marston Scale 1 inch • 100 ft. October 1932. Nelson Bearse Surveyor,, Centerville, Mass.", which said plan is duly recorded in said Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 48, Page 49, running parallel and adjacent to the Northeasterly boundary, by land now or formerly of John F. Shields for the Purposes of egress and ingress for pedestrian and vehicular traffic to and fran Lot 1 as shown on a plan of- land recorded in Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in book 139, Page 1551 to the State Highway, Route 28. Said right of way shall be restricted for use only by the owner, his successors, assigns and tenants or guests of said Lot 1. For title see deed fran David A. -Sauro and Janice Sauro, Trustees of David Rental Trust to BBX Real Estate Corporation dated May 121, 1993 and recorded See with Barnstable County Registry of Deeds on June 7, 1993 ate nt#3320of.David also confirmatory deed Fran David A. Sauro and Janice L. Trusting Rental Trust and David A. Sauro, Trustee Doff Davi Builded with Barnstable County Estate Corporation dated June 29, 1993 Registry of Deeds on July 12, 1993 as instrument #40011 r" rf Being,4,:he same premises conveyed to me as Trustee by deed of BBX Real Estate Corporation which deed is recorded herewith. 4 GE:i,ili�ULU JUL 4193 EXHIBIT 18 r, Assessor's office(1st Floor): I Assessors map and lot number `oF TN To` Conservation(4th Floor): SE PTIC S`6j EM IV111ST B �� 0 Board of Health(3rd floor): J lili.�TALLED IN COMPLIAN tas»TAXIC 2 Sewage Permit number WITH TITLE 5 ■ 39 Engineering Department(3rd floor): J .' ENVIRONMENTAL CODE �i°to House number 19r �r l� TOWN REGULATIONS o�►r►. Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board 19 --APPLICATIONS-PROCESSED 8:30-9:30 A.M.and 1.00-2:00 P.M.only TOWN OF B ARN S TAB L E -- -------- -- BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO YY�rI �9 /•7C r i�r r Jf Ili 1 l n�2 i IJ TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION r�fQ!rl P! 1711 193_ TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: Location Proposed Use Zoning District Fire District q /J � Name of �Owner �/' `.� U r �.. � I I� Address D-?(.. Name of Builder ° ddress Name of Architect Address �j J Number of Rooms_ r � Foundation' Exterior 1�. ' Roofing Floors �ct�✓rOfi �j5�i�✓OCI")rKiQ Interior >I�� +f•OC'L Heating� � u0 '\�t J `' 'I ' ' r Plumbing Fireplace /U 0 Approximate Cost )oo Area Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee Sn ICCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS ereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of"nstable regarding the above construction. Name ✓�l C�j (iniL {fl Construction Si — pervisors License ! jq ._,rILLE VILLAGE APT. REALTY TR. j No - Permit For REMODEL' BLDG. MotellUnits Location 1927 Falmouth Road, Rte 28 Centerville Owner Centerville Village Apt. R. Tr. _ Type of Construction Frame ~ " lot Lot Permit Granted I Sept. 22 , 19 93 Date of Inspection: Frame. 19 Insulation 1 Fireplace 19 i' Date Completed 44TY, 19 10in ' �4 r L�a a QUERY INSPECTION HISTORY: PREVIOUS FIRST LAST END DISPLAY NEXT RECORD IN QUERY PENTAMATION----------------------------------------------------------- 01/05/99 PARCEL ID I?q' 06 7 --PERMIT—NUMBER— INSPECTION REQUESTED DATE REQUIRED DATE REQUESTED DATE SCHEDULED INSPECTOR ASSIGNED DATE INSPECTED RESULT COMMENTS 1 f "8 ZOWN OF BARNSTABLE, MASSACHUSETTS- llILDING PERMIT w '1 j^. f 19 93 R SIT NO. N -�-6 APPLICANT i'1ichi[i.t3.;. l7ardiic'2. ADDRESS - Uj}.1-.�,9Z (NO.) (STREET) ^-- CONTR'S LICENSE) Remodel PERMIT ��Qt'C: �./u�ai-L:S NUMBER OF PERMIT TO 1 (_) STORY DWELLING UNITS (TYPE OF IMPROVEMENT) NO. (PROPOSED USE) _ AT (LOCATION) 13� Falmouth Road, Rta 28, �.t^.T1l.L.X.��$l.11c - ZONING CT RIC .(NOA ,.(STREET) 1 BETWEEN AND _ (CROSS STREET) (CROSS STREET) LOT SUBDIVISION LOT BLOCK SIZE BUILDING IS TO BE FT. WIDE BY FT. LONG BY FT. IN HEIGHT AND SHALL CONFORM IN CONSTRUCTION TO TYPE USE GROUP BASEMENT WALLS OR FOUNDATION _ (TYPE) Sce-wage 3r93-4U�. REMARKS: AREA OR No iire 1. ChaacjC � 10, u�EU: UU PERMIT . 100.00 VOLUME ESTIMATED COST FEE (CUBIC/SQUARE FEET) OWNER Cc!n :.e i/.'�.Lle village jipt. 1`al. ,l'1". - ? �. i - BUILDING DEPT. ADDRESS 7 !U A i`A6'1in S re 4� 0stfa lli BY s THIS PERMIT CONVEYS NO RIGHT TO OCCUPY ANY STREET, ALLEY OR SIDEWALK OR ANY PART THEREOF,(EITHER TEMPORARILY OR PERMANENTLY. ENCROACHMENTS ON PUBLIC PROPERTY, NOT SPECIFICALLY PERMITTED UNDER THE BUILDING CODE, MUST BE AP- PROVED BY THE JURISDICTION. STREET OR ALLEY GRADES AS WELL AS DEPTH AND LOCATION OF PUBLIC SEWERS MAY BE OBTAINED FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS. THE ISSUANCE OF THIS PERMIT DOES NOT RELEASE THE APPLICANT FROM THE CONDITIONS OF ANY APPLICABLE SUBDIVISION RESTRICTIONS. ` MINIMUM OF THREE CALL APPROVED PLANS MUST BE RETAINED ON JOB AND THIS WHERE APPLICABLE SEPARATE INSPECTIONS REQUIRED FOR CARD KEPT POSTED UNTIL FINAL INSPECTION HAS BEEN PERMITS ARE REQUIRED FOR ALL CONSTRUCTION WORK: ELECTRICAL, .PLUMBING AND I. FOUNDATIONS OR FOOTINGS. MADE. WHERE A CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY_ IS RE- MECHANICAL INSTALLATIONS. 2. PRIOR TO COVERING STRUCTURAL QUIRED,SUCH BUILDING.SHALL NOT BE OCCUPIED UNTIL MEMBERS(READY TO LATH). FINAL INSPECTION HAS BEEN MADE. 3. FINAL INSPECTION BEFORE OCCUPANCY. POST THIS CARD SO IT IS VISIBLE FROM STREET BUILDING INSPECTION APPROVALS PLUMBING INSPECTION APPROVALS ELECTRICAL INSPECTION APPROVALS 2 2 2 3 HEATING INSPECTION APPROVALS ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT , 1 2 BOARD OF HEALTH . OTHER SITE PLAN REVIEW APPROVAL ✓CORK SHALL NOT PROCEED UNTIL THE INSPEC- PERMIT WILL BECOME NULL AND VOID IF CONSTRUCTION INSPECTIONS INDICATED ON THIS CARD CAN BE TOR HAS APPROVED THE VARIODUS STAGES OF WORK 15 NOT STARTED WITHIN SIX MONTHS OF DATE THE ARRANGED FOR BY TELEPHONE OR WRITTEN CONSTRUCTION. I PERMIT IS ISSUED AS NOTED ABOVE. NOTIFICATION. EXIIIBIT 19 f MICHAEL J. GARDNER c& ASSOC. Building &Remodeling P.O.-8oz 334-- , Osterville, MA 02655 October 4, 1993 Joseph Daluz, Building Inspector Daniel Hostetter, Owner/T'rustee Town of Barnstable Centerville Village Apt. Town Hall 770A Main St. . Hyannis, MA 02601 Osterville, MA 02655 RE: -Permit#36186 - Existing-12 Motel Units at 1927 Falmouth Rd/Rte. 28, Centerville Dear Mr, Daluz, I would like to recap and confirm our discussion on 9/28/93 regarding the l installation of kitchen efficiencies in the above-mentioned apartments. Because the wording on the proposal has been changed to read 12 motel units, we are now allowed to proceed with installing the new ' kitchen efficiencies and are not required to file with The Zoning Board of Appeals. Please feel free to contact me if you should have any questions or concerns. Sincerely, Michael Gardner I i . s MICHAEL J. GARDNER & ASSOC. l� Building& Remodeling ---- --Box P.O. Box 334 _ (S08)428=4422— Osterville, MA 02655 November 25, 1993 Joseph Daluz,, Building. Inspector Daniel Hostetter, Owner/Trustee Town of Barnstable Centerville Village Apt. Town..Hall 770A Main St. Hyannis, MA 02601 0sterville, MA 02655' RE: Permit#3918..6 -:.Existing 12Uotet Units at-.1.927 Falmouth BdT/Rtp. 28,Q6nterviitig Dear Mr. Dalua, I would:like to inform you that after "pulling" the above mentioned..Building Permit , Mr. Hostetter has decided to have one of his.people in his employment.complete the.finish carpentry at the above mentioned address. This work will consist of. Constructing the guard rails for the second floor lofts; fabricating the moveable stairs to each loft, installing all baseboard and Casing, installing the new kitchen efficiencies, and the small oddities.that will no less be needed to complete the job. I informed Mr. Hostetter. and Mr. Bearse that I wished my name to be removed from the Permit in regard's to all of the above mentioned work.. Sincerely, Ot (A/i) Michael Gardner R ' MICHAEL J. GARDNER & ASSOC. Building& Remodeling P.O. Box 334 (508) 428-4422 Osterville, MA 02655 November 25, 1993 Joseph Daluz, Building Inspector Daniel Hostetter, Owner/Trustee Town of Barnstable Centerville Village Apt. Town.Hall 770A Main St. Hyannis, MA 02601 Ostervill% MA 02655 RE: Permit#36186 - Existing i 2-Motel Units at 1927 Falmouth Rd/Rte. 28, Centervi(le Gentlemen: This is.to advise and.confirm previous warning that the remodeling project at the above location has lofts with cathedral ceilings installed at the request of Daniel Hostetter but those lofts were solely for light weight storage only, with the understanding they will not support-use of heavy furniture storage and/or persons and the weight bearing is not adequate for living quarters use and will not pass building.code as diving space or habitable space if attempted to be.used in-that manner. Although there are guard fails'and a ladder for adult access for light weight storage only, if anyone goes up there and falls down or if structure cannot support the weight, the responsibility is.that of the owner and his agents and the.subsequent tenants and occupants who should be warned by the owners and owners agents not to be up there. This letter is being sent to confirm and clarify the limited purpose and use only with all other use prohibited. Very truly ur$, " t Michael Gardner i i I For Sale • , , - , • - L r kp. � , � � ^.,� tfLve' 6� � `� }S �'fit ;�'�� ^�C< =� �✓ If n r'�.1 t t •* �.. an%p'G�., '�� ;?4n5.,n.'��a$ w �� - T . *� � a , �'T a #.' r "'� t ffi.�J'.�.♦ ^' t_ Yr�'r r� �Sa c._ • 1: •1 :•11 1: •1 :°•: THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN GIVEN TO US BY THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY OR OTHER SOURCES WE DEEM RELIABLE.WE HAVE, [E(ELIA fAREY[OMMER(IAL.[OM 508-790.8900 NO REASON TO DOUBT ITS ACCURACY BUT WE DO NOT GUARANTEE IT.ALL INFORMATION SHOULD BE VERIFIED PRIOR TO PURCHASE OR LEASE. r i 1927 Falmouth Road. Centerville (Oak Tree Village) Unit Bdrms. Rent Lease Terms Subsidy Last mo. Sec.Dep. Collected Collected 1 2 $900* TAW N/A Yes No 2 1 $600 TAW BHA No No 3 1+ $900 6/1/11-5/31/12 N/A Yes No 4 2 $950 6/1/11-5/31/12 N/A Yes No 5 1 r$600 4/1/11-3/31/12 HAC Yes Yes(2006) $600 6 S $500* TAW N/A Yes Yes(2000) $485 7 S $500 TAW N/A Yes No 8 S $500* 7/15/11-7/14/12 N/A Yes No 9 S $495* TAW N/A Yes Yes(2003) $495 t 10 1 $850* 7/15/11-4/14/12 N/A Yes No 11 S $500* TAW N/A Yes No 12 2 $1000* 4/1/11-3/31/12 BHA Yes Yes(2005) $1000 r. e *Plus gas and electric Town of Barnstable Geographic Information System September 22,2011 189021 189026 189031CO3 #94 #60 #39 189031002 +� 199064 1 0 0�� ® #27 188031017 884624 #85 189028 t�` #10 #18 189031001 189063 189027 189029 fill *89066 #65 #36 #12 #101 ' 189030 _ 189006002 18906 #1884 #45 #5122 189057 cy #81851 189091. 189Uby �� - 189006003 #39r #35 oft189000 a 1891Ya5 #31 #1815 1 99 00601 5 189066 #24 #1934 189151 189 03004 �Y9� •(1� � #9076 058 #21 199006005 4` 190067 189006006 #�1927 #23 189129 18 1 9 50„. ^� 189130 #195 9194E 189003 #1949 F l 189131 90020. • ._ - _ 18 04 #177 #163 _ PLO 189100 09 189002003 189101 a #149 `7f19 189002001 . a 189114 ' 189005002 #164 t 3: #2009 .. - -190002002 - 2. 19991102 .-198089 #139 N 0139 #23 189142 #30 189115 # W #64 56 89140 189139 189126 132 w 1�891 9 . �8#56 1 t ,« 189113 U89143 #42 189138 189137 112001 27� #9 30s9 8 #20 --#119 * All 139 DISCLAIMERS:This map Is for planning purposes only. It Is not adequate for legal Map:189 'Parcel:129 EJ boundarydetermination or regulatory interpretation. Enlargements beyond a scale of' Owner:CALLAHAN,CYNTHIA H TRS Total Assessed Value:$253200 Selected Parcel 1"=100'may not meet established map accuracy standards.The parcel lines on this map �(�' :. are only graphic representations of Assessors tax parcels. They are not true property Co-Owner `, ,Acreage:0.39 acres • Abutters boundaries and do not represent accurate relationships to physical features on the map. Location:1903 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28 /fr' such as building locations. .Buffer Income Statement ' Cash Basis, From 1/1/2010 to 12/31/2010, By Year CVA - 1927 Falmouth Rd. Income Rent Income $79,806.46 $79,806.46 Total Income $79,806.46 $79,806.46 Expenses Cleaning and maintenance $430.00 $430.00 Fees-Bank $29.90 $29.90 Fire/Security $905.00 $905.00 Insurance-Property $7,374.33 $7,374.33 Interest $150.62 $150.62 Repairs $4,291.53 $4,291:53 Supplies $2,426.27 $2,426.27 Taxes-Real Estate $10,875.00 $10,875.00 Trash Removal $2,505.00 $2,505.00 Utilities-Electric $6,399.67 $6,399.67 Utilities-Gas $1,711.18 $1,711.18 Utilities-Water $1,378.30 $1,378.30 Total Expenses $36,936.77 $36,936.77 Net Operating Income $42,869.69 $42,869.69 Net Income $42,869.69 $42,869.691 Generated 8/15/2011 11:34 AM Page i of 2 Assessing Division Property Lookup Results 367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA.02601 «;sacK TO s"EARCH« kPrint,Fnendly Owner Information-Map/Block/Lot:189 1 129/-Use Code: 1010 Owner Owner Name CALLAHAN,CYNTHIA H TRS Co-Owner Name Property Address Owner Mailing Address 1903 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 26 770A MAIN ST OSTERVILLE,MA.02655 Map/Block/Lot 189/1291 Assessed Values 2011 -Map/Block/Lot:189/1291-Use Code:1010 2011 Appraised Value2011 Assessed Value Past Comparisons Building Value: $87,800 $87,800 Year Total Assessed Value i Extra Features: $0 $0 2010-$247,700 Outbuildings: $0 $.0 2009-$258,200 Land Value: $165,400 $165,400 2008-$288,500 2007-$288,500 2011 Totals $263,200 $263,200 2006-$199,500 Tax Information 2011 Map/Block/Lot:1 89 1 1 291-Use Code:1010 Taxes Fire District Rates Town Residential C.O.M.M.FD Tax(Residential) $336.76 Barn FD-All Classes $2.31 $8.05 Community Preservation Act Tax $61.15 C.O.M.M-All Classes $1.33 Town Commercial Town Tax(Residential) $2,038.26 Cotuit FD-All Classes $1.68 $7 28 $2,436.17 Hyannis-Residential $2.04 Hyannis-Commercial $3,24 VV Barnstable-Residential $2.65 . W Barnstable-Commercial $2.34 Sales History-Map/Block/Lot:189 1129/`-Use Code:1010 ; History: Owner: Sale Date Book/Page: Sale Price: CALLAHAN,CYNTHIA H TRS Jul 15 1993 12:OOAM 8688/243 $100 CALLAHAN,RICHARD P TRS Jul 15 1993 12:OOAM 8688/234 $100 BBX REAL ESTATE CORP Jun 15 1993 12:OOAM, 8614/143 $122,000. i SAURO,DAVID J TRS Mar 15 1987 12:OOAM 5590/003 $70,000 COLBATH,CHARLES P 3149/101 $0 Sketches-Map/Block/Lot:189,/1291-Use Code:1010 i B . r t } I AsBuilt Card NIA Constructions Details-Map/Block/Lot:1891129/ Use Code:1010 Building Details Land • t Building value $87,800 Bedrooms 2 Bedrooms USE CODE 1010 Total Improvements Value $96,490 Bathrooms 1 Full Lot Size(Acres) 0.39 Model Residential Total Rooms 4 Rooms Appraised Value $165,400 Style Ranch Heat Fuel Oil Assessed Value $,165,400 i S Grade Average Heat Type Floor Furnace Year Built 1985 AC Type None Effective depreciation 9 Interior Floors Carpet Stories 1 Story Interior Walls Drywall Living Area sq/ft 864 Exterior Walls Wood Shingle Gross Area sq/ft 944 Roof Structure Gable/Hip / Roof Cover Asph/F Gls/Cmp Outbuildings&Extra Features-Map/Block/Lot:189!129/-Use Code: 1010 There i are not any extra building features on record at this time. Sketch Legend Property Sketch Legend AOF Office,(Average) FTS Third Story Living Area(Finished) SFB Base;Semi-Finished BAS First Floor,Living Area FUS Second Story Living Area(Finished) TQS Three Quarters Story(Finished) BMT Basement Area(Unfinished) GAR Garage UAT Attic Area(Unfinished) CLP Loading Platform GRN Greenhouse UHS Half Story(Unfinished) CAN Canopy MZ1 Mezzanine,Unfinished UST Utility Area(Unfinished) FAT Attic Area(Finished) IVIZ2 Mezzanine,Semi-finished UTQ Three Quarters Story(Unfinished) FBM Finished Basement MZ3 Mezzanine,finished UUA Unfinished Utility Attic FCP Carport PAT Patio Outbuilding Listed UUS Full Upper 2nd Story(Unfinished) FEP Enclosed Porch PTO Patio WDKWood Deck FHS Half Story(Finished) REF Reference Only WKO Wood Deck Outbuilding Listed FOP Open or Screened in Porch SDA Store Display Area -- � Prrti',F;cen 401,930 views since 4.4.11 Contact Director of Assessing =x Assessing Division Property Lookup Results 4 367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA.02601 ' «,:i3kcK.TosEARCH'z< Priiit Friendly Owner Information-Map/Block/Lot:189 1 067/-Use Code:1120 Owner Owner Name CALLAHAN,CYNTHIA H TR Co-Owner. CENTERVILLE VILLAGE REALTY Name TRUST Property Address Owner Mailing Address 1927 FALMOUTH ROAD/RTE 28 770 S MAIN ST OSTERVILLE,MA.02655 Map/Block/Lot 189/067/ Assessed Values 2011 -Map/Block/Lot:189/.067/`-Use Code:1120 2011 Appraised Value2011 Assessed Value Past Comparisons Building Value: $453,200 $453,200 Year Total Assessed Value. Extra Features: $0, $0 2010-$957,700 Outbuildings: $5,300 $5,300 2009-$963,200 Land Value: $446,000 $446,000 2008-$938,500 - 2007-$938,500 2011 Totals $904,500 $904,500 ` 2006-$966,900 „ Tax Information 2011 -Map/Block/Lot: 189/0671 Use Code:1120 Taxes Fire District Rates Town Residential C.O.M.M.FD Tax(Residential) $1,202.99 Bam FD-All Classes $2.31 $8.05 Community Preservation Act Tax $218.44 C.O.M.M-All Classes $1.33 Town Commercial Town Tax(Residential) $7,281.23 Cotuit FD-All Classes $1.68 $7 28 $8,702.66 Hyannis-Residential $2.04 Hyannis-Commercial $3.24 W Barnstable-Residential $2.65 W Barnstable-Commercial $2.34 f r Sales History-Map/Block/Lot: 189 1 0671-Use Code:1120 History: Owner: Sale Date Book/Page: Sale Price: CALLAHAN,CYNTHIA H TR Jul 21 1993 12:00AM, 8688/243 $115,000 BBX REAL ESTATE CORP Jun 15 1993 12:OOAM 8614/143 $122,000 SAURO,DAVID A&JANICE L Mar 15 1987 12:OOAM 5590/001 $225,000 COLBATH,CHARLES P 3107/266 $0 Sketches-Map/Block/Lot:189/067/-Use Code:1.120 This property contains multiple sketches. Please use the navigation below the sketch to browse sketches. tlnffs'111r8 Unific#9=10 - Additional Sketches 1 1 213 Click Here for print version that displays all sketches at once AsBuilt Card N/A Constructions Details-Map/Block/Lot:189/0671.-Use Code:1120. F I Building Details Land Building value $453,200 Bedrooms USE CODE 1120 Total Improvements Value $214,83.0 Bathrooms 1 Full+1 H Lot Size(Acres) 0.64 Model Residential Total Rooms Appraised Value $446,000 Style Family Conver. Heat Fuel Gas Assessed Value $446,000 Grade Average Plus Heat Type Typical Year Built 1949 AC Type None Effective depreciation 15 Interior Floors Typical Stories Interior Walls Drywall Living Area sq/ft 1,612 Exterior Wails Wood Shingle Gross Area sq/ft 2,425 Roof Structure Gable/Hip Roof Cover Asph/F GIs/Cmp r Outbuildings&Extra Features-Map/Block/Lot:189/0671-Use Code:1120 Code Description Units/SQ It Appraised Value Assessed Value WDCK Wood decking 448 $4,000 $4,000 w/railings WDCK . Wood decking 80 $1,300 $1,300 w/railings Sketch Legend Property Sketch Legend AOF Office,(Average) FTS Third Story Living Area(Finished) SFB Base,Semi-Finished BAS First Floor,Living Area FUS Second Story Living Area(Finished) TQS Three Quarters Story(Finished) BMTBasement Area(Unfinished) GARGarage UAT Attic Area(Unfinished) CLP Loading Platform GRN Greenhouse UHS Half Story(Unfinished) CAN Canopy MZ1 Mezzanine,Unfinished UST Utility Area(Unfinished) FAT Attic Area(Finished) MZ2 Mezzanine,Semi-finished UTQ Three Quarters Story(Unfinished) FBM Finished Basement MZ3 Mezzanine,finished UUA Unfinished Utility Attic FCP Carport PAT Patio Outbuilding Listed UUS Full Upper 2nd Story(Unfinished) FEP Enclosed Porch PTO Patio WOK Wood Deck FHS Half Story(Finished) REF Reference Only WKO Wood Deck Outbuilding Listed FOP Open or Screened in Porch SDA Store Display Area .�.,Printc;F 401,932 views since 4.4.11 I Contact ". s,<Back Building Style Family Conver. Interior FloorsTypical Model Residential Interior Walls Drywall Grade Average Plus Heat Fuel Gas Stories Heat Type Typical Exterior Walls Wood Shingle AC Type None Roof Structure Gable/Hip Bedrooms Roof Cover Asph/F GIs/Cmp Bathrooms Full + Units#9=�'0 1H Replacement Cost $214830 living area 1612 Depreciation 15Year Built 1949 Total Rooms Building Style Family Conver. Interior FloorsTypical Model Residential Interior Walls Drywall Grade Average Plus Heat Fuel Typical Stories Heat Type Typical Exterior Walls Wood Shingle AC Type . None Roof Structure Gable/Hip Bedrooms 2 Unit#2 , Roof Cover Asph/F GIs/Cmp Bathrooms Full 2H Replacement Cost $306281 living area 2337 Depreciation 15Year Built 1949 Total Rooms ..Building Style Cottage Interior FloorsCarpet Model . Residential Interior Walls Drywall Grade Average Plus Heat Fuel Gas Stories 1 Story Heat Type Typical Exterior Walls Wood Shingle AC Type None Roof Structure Gable/Hip Bedrooms ' 1 Bedroom Roof Cover Asph/F GIs/Cmp Bathrooms 1 Full Replacement Cost $74398. living area 484 Depreciation 20Year Built 1949 Total Rooms Rooms T + I Assessor's map and'lot-number QUO%THE Sewage Permit number ............ .'-./�,Xa......_.....� .. �� �`� ♦� BARNSTADLE, i House number ............................................ ,. 9�O NAS& 9� D OR , TOWN OF BARNSTABLE Y BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO '..��l!� 1.`. ......... C1C X};��0,(1...................................................................... TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION ....(—A—.X°!r`...... .t .!M��....................................................................................... ................ � ................19 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to thee following information: Location ..... ya 7...V t M O�.1,�,`!\ � 1•........... C t1 C2.1�1...\�s�'..L......1/!', ` A... ..........................::........ . Proposed Use .....................i 1 t 1 �i ...... ?.........��.(!! ............ =•r (�C»J�....:. ��t c.1......... ;. f 1C: ....................... i. ........ Zoning District ` .. ...........................Fire District ?.!.\. ....2... `� f .........•••.• ...................... Name of Owner'' t--)r, n s ` f'+ \ �� ..............Address n `�71 .................... :`.V........................................... Name of Builder . 1Y1k F .. ..............Address ....` `:: ::. ......o-:,� Xa�:J :............................. Nameof Architect ..................................................................Address .................................................................................... Number of Rooms .........................................Foundation c;....\•ID.. ....................................� Exierior ... � .........Roofng t � h1 .... ............................................... r� ( ' Floors ........ ..Interior �' t1F S � r�c�c �'. I Heating ....G.-. . .......� , ~•' ` ),., :............................................r .................Plumbing ..... .......>.�..�......a....—..�.......a..C..�..�.J................................ Fireplace ....:1 ...................................................................Approximate Cost ........ ....................... ............Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board ________________________________19________. Area ... t?.. .. ............. Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions , Fee ...In !�- /.... ... .............................. `SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF BOARD OF HEALTH /f OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of Barnstable regarding the above construction. Name ..!A� ......... .... .�,t::.....�//'(............................ Construction Supervisor's License .. ..............................6t � ~ CLXLBYIH, DINIS J. A=189-129 27656 - , ---------- Location7Falmouth ~ ........................................... ' . ...................=~=^°,°.==Ile................ ...... Owner -I�P-lis..J�. ........ ......... Type of Construction ......�����-------- --------------------------' P|cd ............................ Lot ................................ ' ^ Permit Granted March 37Granted --------.�----]A 85 Date of Inspection ------------lg Date Completed ....... ' � . /�r`�� / / ~ ~ o � - � _ - f c� _ Assessor's map and lot (number .l...�r .�� ��� ` o TNe o� -_._. YSTE FIST BE Sewage Permit number ............ ..... IINYSTAIL ° a IAN WI TH TITLE 5 • � Z 339S33TdDLE, i House number .....:":�:"............:..................................................: ENVIRONMENTAL CODE !` 39. \0m TOWN Ri"��"�o Pao"A r -,1K 1 TOWN OF BARNSTABLE BUILDING INSPECTOR APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO .. .................. k � .......................::............................................ TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION ....(4!t; .A...... �CS'..)ftls.................................................. ' ................19 TO THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS: The undersigned hereby applies for a permit according to the following information: Location ......1./..'��. .....:.. 1.f11 .......PA................4 ..'.n \1a...1.1. .fi......V'::.!..:.,............................. • R ^ Proposed Use (n i n. . .........RvlL ............. ........ qa':1��C ....................... Zoning District ..............: ........................................................Fire District .�.�.I�....:.....�......:...................... ........................ Name of Owner � ....V.:.... 0.` 4 ..............Address ...... V:3 .... ...... Name of Builder ........ >........ ..............Address .... 1:..... ........:.......... ............................. Nameof Architect ..................................................................Address ....................................:............................................... Number of Rooms AFDC �� (Ccsrtt(2F ) ......�........................................................Foundation ............................ . .................. ................:........... ° St►� ` i + Exterior C:.... .P...............��`L s........................................Roofing .... s�.? . ` ........ ..n�`��.5 .......................... Floors ® .......Interior Heating :... f't ......(.riAg,!: k.... .......fit2).................Plumbing ......A.R.PN................................................................... Fireplace ....(�a.f� ..................................................................Approximate Cost .... .1. E sC� Definitive Plan Approved by Planning Board ________________________________19________. Area -�. . .... . ............ Diagram of Lot and Building with Dimensions Fee l .a�- S BJECT O APPROVAL OF BOARD OF HEALTH l� --------------------- OCCUPANCY PERMITS REQUIRED FOR NEW DWELLINGS I hereby agree to conform to all the Rules and Regulations of the Town of B rnstable regarding the above construction. Name ..... ... ................. Construction Supervisor's License L ... ............. ODLBATH, DENIS J. „may r 27656 •'� r ' No Permit for Build Additi '+. 4 ................ ........................QXI. 4 ti , Single Family Dwelling, .......... .. .. Location Falmouth Road ...:...............Centerville.................................. �;� � "� �f 3 _ � 't •+ ................................... Owner ......Denis..J-....Colbath..... .... = .. ..... Type of Construction R ....Fri.......................... F .w' l ✓ r - 11 +s..........y .................................................................... 1 ` �� , "y • - r '•, ''i�.•q. ^ - �ye Plot .I......... .............. Lot ................... t ......... � -.. _ Permit Granted ..........7l...........19. 85 Date of Inspection '- ` P /(_ Date Completed ^+.......1:9 or 1.4 n�