Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
2051 MAIN STREET (3)
3 os1 met..► v-I 3-1.. Q 6 p 3 . *. .., n F I. 0 ,. .. u - �. - , a / / ,ii7,._:' ''ilPfli,„4-"e#: -, :', l''''''''''''6-'''4, .-' '' ' ' 26914-7.!rj--1- . "C.'',--':' -',':- . ''..f - : - :'-,___. 4:-\''..-,'. ' ' ,,,, i,9 ,,,/.41,.: ,e--,00-r-e'f' -' '. ,, -Z- 9 tdeit eyo- , . . . . , / . ''' ' ' 2- -'-' ' ' ''' '''' ` 9 � „ Z 7- . ' '''' ' ' ' -'-. ''''' " j� tom} t ,.,..-7--,,—.r,,..:,,...C., ,t,.4-.:,. . AR'llj/'j��,�.}: q '., #.::,:,.,-,:.1-,,,:,--0 4'-e:.:.,:.,;:,}..',:.l'.,,:-C : :. c .,.a,'$,.::1,,;i,,.q.',,:.:,:'-:,''.,.:, , -', ',., •-- -. .: :...t„ '-',:,i . : . ,. ,,,,,ei. '4, -..,,,,, ,c..,..c.c, t-i— vp.e 44 ) -.:7)", k,:c.17., ',-*'[.L.,,:-., ri., SCR` G r ( > ,4-� .', e.c c:_ i-✓ c f . t x 'o , $ -� ,r 1 - 5ep;--15�,`98, `01 23P t r k "„. '' _,,,_" '508-881 -4768 P",01' , dX' r i • 4 ti ,-0 t a,,3 p.' i � �.7 . y,} --.., :,,., 4 . . . ,, ,,. ,,. . , 1,:, .. i, i.a - . - MGL Chapter. 90 Dillator. Vehicle& ` , <ri Seetion=1.. of Chapter 90 es_amended in-1996i defines "Farmer" as a person i• '4ubstantialfji 'eh' gaged in•the o6cupation Ofr--farming:Which shall 'include:::the raising , .. °, E ` of livestock, including'horses.'," nd;.the-keeping of horses as a commercial - - ., 14. E et,terpritt..- ', Thus to ralify#for farm plates'.-or for'purposes of othermotor`vehicle • '' -_ laws;a hcii-se operation.rnllst be substantially engaged in breeding, or be a r , f - substantial't oartfing"business,'1arm'Plates are,the subject of repeal efforts ever ,, y+sa ii tr leegisfa'ture- end F'at f urestr fighte for their survival! _, {- ', '° � • 1-of e , _ „ .- r- NMI:. Chapter f11 PubdnCHaltf `/ , hhat • ofAgiultueto include bt "te -'section ,tfhapt Chapter ,tMne$ fl `. ` ",e aisirr c f�ii•testoc tnp€ rcfin horses" and 'the keeping of horses: as a pommerc ai g J. f 1 �'" a A fa. t Cr. enterprise _.Sectii h I2 A provides that odor frmrri.nr rmal maintenance of•livestock � ` , or spreading of ivi tr►ure 'Upon agrictiltur l and horticutture1�iand, .or noise from," - xa, IIve; ackICr farm puIpr ant u ed•sfi'-normal 4gederal,ly�;accepted'farming procedures 4`= ' - cannot be'deemed,a nuisance by bo"aids of tie lth* 4 / °r. These fa-'~rora.tieichan es eam about af't r several years'of Ferro Bureas. .tob y C+g°efforts. - ;' , u ,1 t- IGT ,``b ear 1Z8 ,ARgi••iculture - -^'# t' - m a ' S ctien t A'cohtairis'the definition of 'Agriculture or'Farming" most often referred i _ , I k_. 'to #,officials; absent a-differing defirttiun`in a•spec tic'statute or bylaw:'That • _ . ,:def nit,on is, .s follows; _ • �; ` - :Forrrtuog'" or 'Agriculture" shell include.fauming in ell-of ifs branches and,the d `A �Y, cut' tr aitr�tt £ ar 1-virage" f the•soil, dairying:the,proclvction, cultivation, gro+ving acid 7 'ha vesnng of any:agricultural..aiivactt tura!, floricultural'or tlorncuiti,tial commodities, The• `, . ,' Y "f{r 'iii 3,snd tirr+v t€rig,pf t�1,e t produ�s upon foiest land, the raising of livestock ' : s. 'sr`ici dirwig•he rset,, = ' , ttt "llsepjngg of liotees.as s r rar e,(cciat enterprise, the keeping and ,'. raising of uitry -: swine, cattle and other domesticated anirnals'used for food F a a x purposes, tees f <-k�ea in ,ar'm'mils find enyforeswi or lumbering operations, - > - i,,, ,, x� ., perf on d y a f n'a „ r o'i hhreb':#efttfre,as one engaged in agriculture tic .TM ferrri ng'a +ere►n defined .or on a farm ',as_ an-incident t3 or in'conjunction with Such • fafirriiitg operations ,ancltidirig preparstions ,.for riwrket, delivt ry to storage or'-to market` "} '0i•t carriers for transpDrt do to market. , S ctiops 2A and 2£3 raiets to°fteensi requirements for horse. riding"instructors --, a fools or stables(' action 2b ides the limitatio s of liability' -and n�lrrxg s C3rovr n Y' :. '. `:Z' r .ections or horse`operations and. activity spbrtsars, , , .. ., ` IS very javprablo'B'efmrtition'opens new doors far:the horse industry, it, and 'the '7 mi.tS,ti01$ f tiabiltty la war :;bt th poi•ant`victories for Farm Bureau members, `` I , m ''' ' ' '4 ,.i`•, t t 'Ohs ter 1: , Fire Prr N+istion, $ ` , 1. ,:,°Y., .r i. • , Se 'tion• 6G`ot Chapter 148 contains anexemption from fire sprinkler . rect firer e its fo, .buildings ui d for:a r€cr, tt irai purposes", The statute.refers;to the, ;,: 's ' 1, 8,1A'd'finrtir:± `,to:de ine #"r+cyiture: T ►t exemption was accomplished through y .. , iegt fativesaffo.rts-of F. rrt'i Btjreau in. 1994E ' ' y We the undersigned neighbors of the property at 2051 Main Street, Barnstable; owned by.Victor Cillis and Brenda Tri,`request the Town of Barnstable to enforce the Zoning regulations stipulating NO COMERCIAL USE OF HORSES in this,area. '' :'' Such commercial business as Horseback riding lessons, leasing of horses,boarding of horses, Summer Horse Camp, horse birthday parties, and trail riding on 6A and neighbors' properties, has resulted in an on- going NUISANCE and DANGER to this neighborhood. Issues of complaint include 1) The large volume of traffic vehicles accessing and parking along a right-of- way emptying onto 6A on a dangerous curve. This right-of way is shared by 3 neighbors, including small children. 2).Excessive noise: human, animal and vehicular. 3) Improper management of animals resulting in roaming of animals on both 6A and neighbors' properties, and subsequent damage to neighborhood property: 4) improper management of business clients resulting in trespassing of clients onto neighbors' properties, both on foot and on horseback. 5) Improper management of animal waste including disposal of a large volume of excrement in the woods, resulting in Unacceptable odors and unbearable horseflies. 6) Improper management of human waste i.e. clients denied usage of bathrooms- defecating in woods, thereby creating a serious health hazard. 7) Verbal abuse by business owners of neighborhood children, parents and workmen, whose normal activities are viewed by owners as disruptive to on-going horseback riding instruction. Our neighborhood is an historic residential area. We request that it remain so. Please enforce our protective Zoning laws. Print Name Si nature Address NArbi i}nn e Fenny...__ _ai,-,_.7-- l fl a 64,14,s -A__ qa.me-ia.T do-i-mah ��n,.-f a/ /71a tit Si, y6ez4./.4S 6 1 A✓► b 1 4.1aftrwkrn C --5--_, .1 YY)A_n ,�-t' 2a r n.s+abbe, f1 t c ie EA-lama ti triNc e.e U.f n a cyg 5 Mail)qj"kcox1.0 k, ;6'ti---&(, ��� f=7o)"xrye,e ILL. 6:.€0 y'Q ,pciy ;n( .Sr, v';v� bl-t /y i L•i F? -J v i ; P 7 �a7-d /40i��sr: .6AfAst/I. - C'h ax(eS C 1zysdc i'eV OHO /VaariV S'6 www. 13arA, k >r. ��.f� 1. . Zc�sclCg.c\cs ZI J'a Cc4,-t r. `3T Cs �"�jc�Ca��. {L{ C' �ikJ..,c` C' ' ..210.3 m4i,. 5 - W. gAILA Lc C Wt.ZS rqk Si p.1 .S. l!v\---.. ZOOS' r^A•d yr. —v)•')A M Crr►a to L! c` .J,J,JI `"`'S o,-1 �_ � — We the undersigned neighbors of the property at 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, owned by Victor Cillis and Brenda Tri, request the Town of Barnstable to enforce the Zoning regulations stipulating NO COMERCIAL USE OF HORSES in this area. Such commercial business as Horseback riding lessons, leasing of horses, boarding of horses, Summer Horse Camp, horse birthday parties, and trail riding on 6A and neighbors' properties, has resulted in an on- going NUISANCE and DANGER to this neighborhood. Issues of complaint include 1) The large volume of traffic vehicles accessing and parking along a right-of- way emptying onto 6A on a dangerous curve. This right-of way is shared by 3 neighbors, including small children. 2) Excessive noise: human, animal and vehicular. 3) Improper management of animals resulting in roaming of animals on both 6A and neighbors' properties, and subsequent damage to neighborhood property. 4) Improper management of business clients resulting in trespassing of clients onto neighbors' properties, both on foot and on horseback. 5) Improper management of animal waste including disposal of a large volume of excrement in the woods, resulting in unacceptable odors and unbearable horseflies. 6) Improper management of human waste i.e. clients denied usage of bathrooms- defecating in woods, thereby creating a serious health hazard. 7) Verbal abuse by business owners of neighborhood children, parents and workmen, whose normal activities are viewed by owners as disruptive to on-going horseback riding instruction. Our neighborhood is an historic residential area. We request that it remain so. Please enforce our protective Zoning laws. Print Name Signature Address Lth . C4 ifAU Alt 3Qt Aut,u 3WCA.QtaAl-U evo "fi_rxr e EL 16iL .2,4) Yr?it- (-/di 5 6„4") 01,01--e• 4)-7‘,d, AJ. ,04-$/s7-ddiet,#),, (-10 fL .t CItid q 0 cid "kr w. . • OFZHE ,ads,, �� The Town ®f �: l� • ���s�� le • BARNSTABLE • , 039. Department of Health Safety and Environmental Services to " Building Division 367 Main Street,Hyannis MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Ralph Crossen Fax: 508-790-6230 Building Commissioner January 28, 19 8 Mrs.Brenda Cillis 2051 Main Street West Barnstable,MA 02668 Brenda: I am following up our meetings on January 19th and 21st,regarding the commercial venture on your property at 2051 Main Street. As I stated on those occasions,your property is in a residential zone(RF)and the operation of a business would require relief from the Zoning Board of Appeals. If this office can be of any assistance in the ZBA process,please do not hesitate to contact us. It was my pleasure to have met you. Thank you in advance. Sincerely, Richard Stevens Building Inspector RS:lb q990128a Town of Barnstable Legal Department 367 Main Street, Hyannis, MA 02601 508-862-4620 Fax 508-862-4724 ROUTING SLIP DATE: .A�2/ 94° ( TO: / �'J � Y «mil r� Coensue', �(1,,00 fiu r.�/ off" A5 G972-AJ3 v7 c c FROM: t� RUTH J. WEIL, Town Attorney 1 ; T. DAVID HOUGHTON, 1st Assistant Town Attorney CHARLES S. McLAUGHLIN, Jr., Assistant Town Attorney V//J CLAIRE GRIFFEN, Legal Assistant PAM GORDON, Legal Clerk C.ri RE: ar C-zw S Co/A-) OUR FILE REF NO: (. lD Wl4/1 f - ,4 4i) ao5-1 `-f/ -v/g/® , , a /// ,7 �� = [Q:\WPFILES\OFFICE\ROUTING-astoform.DOC] g-6/o —06/ z/ STANTON & DAVIS ATTORNEYS AT LAW A Sole Proprietorship 1000 PLAIN STREET MARSHFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS 02050 (781) 834-9181 FAX: (781) 837-8253 JON S. DAVIS MICHAEL E. ERUST E-MAIL: JONSUAVISSTANTONDAVIS.COM E-MAIL: MBRUSTOSTANTONDAVIS.COM ALSO A MEMBER OF THE MAINE BAR • AMY LEE LIPMAN-WHITE January 19,2010 E-MAIL.: ALIPMANWHITE(..STANTONDAVt.S.COM CERTIFIED MAIL#7160 3901 9848 5999 8262 RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED and LAURA J. ADAMS E-MAIL: LADAMS('STANTONDAVIS.COM Planning Board Town of Barnstable 367 Main Street Barnstable, MA 02601 • • RE: JPMorgan Chase Bank, National Association,Successor in interest from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, as Receiver for Washington Mutual Bank fik/a Washington Mutual Bank F.A. vs. • Brenda M.Tri a/k/a Brenda M. Cillis 2051 Main Street,Barnstable,Barnstable County,MA 02668 • Stanton &Davis File No. 2139-2880-509F Acres Classified: 7.36 acres Map/Parcel: 206-075.002 216-075.B00 216-075.W00 Dear Ladies& Gentlemen: Please accept this letter as formal written notice required under M.G.L. Chapter G1A, Section 14, that a foreclosure sale has been scheduled on the mortgaged premises at 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, Massachusetts on April 20, 2010 at 11:00AM. A copy of the Chapter 61A Notice by the Board of Assessors dated March 9, 2004,recorded in the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds In Book 18368, Page 189, is enclosed herewith. The purpose of this sale is to enforce rights under a mortgage granted by its owner. Due to privacy laws we are unable to provide you with the amount of sums owed to the mortgage lender. e t y • u; • J . Da4s' for STANTON&DAVIS .1SD:bmm -Enclosures cc: JPMorgan Chase Bank, National Association • i . Bk 1336F-, P 1B9 02223 03-26--2004. 0 03 s ii 7sa (,? TlitS INSTRumENT Kw BE DULY pE=FOR RECORD OR.RFGi3T'R.ATION State Tax Form AJH 2 BARNSTABLE Nam of City or Town OFFICE OF T! E BOARD OF ASSESSORS AGRICULTURAL OR IIORTICULT7JRAL LAND TAX LIEN The Board of Assessors of the Town of Barnstable hereby state that it has accepted and moved the application of Victor C Ulfls s Brenda QM of 2031 Main Street.West Barnstable.MA 02668 owner or owners of the bergafter described land for valuation,assessment and taxation of such and wider the provisions of General Laws,Chapter 6I A for the fiscal year ending June 30,2004. ,For Me see Book 9499.Page . LOCUS: 2051 Main St I. Barnstable, Ka 02668 DESCRIPTION OF LAND LOT 2B on a plan of land entitled"Plan of Land in W.Barnstable,Mass.prepared for B.W.C.Ellis,dated September 24,1905",which said plain is duly recorded in the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds la Plan Book 406,Page 7 as described ha Deed Book 9499.Pane 341 and Lagj on a plan of land entitled"Plan of Land la Barnstable(West),for Brace bills,dated Aprll 20,1 9",which plan is duly recorded in the Barnstable County Registry of Deeds in Plan Book 302,Page 87 as'described In P l 9419.Pew 308 containing approximately 736 acres more or leas.Said parcels are also depicted as Town of Barnstable Assessor's Map#216,Parcel #075.002,Map#216,Parcel#076.B00 and Map#216,Parcel t 076.W00 as drawn for Fiscal Year 2003. Statement nude this 2.! _ day of March ,2004. SLI4V.C4eCW".4rZ-e--.`'- V-jAm'r'l< BOARD OF ASS COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSas a dS UMW f. c . i FORM VOA,HOBBS&'WARREN.INC.,BOSTON,MASS.REVISED 1974 THIS FORM APPROVED BY COMMISSIONER OF REV?IUE 1)442 26Azongsh sesmiWb Dxsaftssiltagar t • • 11414- GliC/11412,-44 clid- a edIL C /II /1/4ç6,4/I ke- 4a f e deed 0*THE To� Town of !: arnstablle ' 104�,. ��` Office of Community and Economic Development BARNST B E, = 230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601 (508) 862-4683 Fax(508) 862-4725 i'lEp and A Kevin J.Shea Director December 20, 2004 Ms. Brenda Tri Mr. Victor Cill is 2051 Main Street West Barnstable, MA 02668 Re: Property at 2051 Main Street, Barnstable Dear Ms. Tri it has come to my attention that you are interested in re-applying for the town of Barnstable's Accessory Affordable Housing Program for the property at 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable. Please sign and date the enclosed application for site eligibility and return it to me with a check for the $100 fee payable to the Town of Barnstable at your earliest convenience. Your application will then be reviewed for project eligibility by the town. Also enclosed for your convenience is a program brochure so that you will have the opportunity to review the terms of the Accessory Apartment Program. Please feel free to contact me at (508) 862-4683 with any questions. Sincerely, (-Elizabeth zabeth Dillen Special Projects Coordinator cc: Lois Barry Linda Edson Edson, Linda From: Dillen, Elizabeth Sent: Friday, December 10, 2004 10:18 AM To: Edson, Linda Cc: Barry, Lois Subject: Cillis I E Linda- I double-checked with Ruth on Cillis as to whether they can reapply for the program, and she has determined that they can re-apply,but the town will simply deny them a site eligibility letter based on their past history of non- compliance with the program. I will send Brenda Cillis the necessary info to apply and send you guys a copy of the denial when it goes out. 'Round and 'round we go... E lizabeth Dillen Special Pmjaas Coordinator Tozer of Barnstable Of Community& E conomicDereloprrrnt 508.862.4683 1 Cape Cod Times 1 Midday News Update Page 1 of 3 �et mastiff attacks owner, co-worker WEST BARNSTABI Two women were taken to Cape Cod Hospital with severe injuries after they were attacked by a dog this morning, according to Barnstable police. Police responded to 2-051=Main_Street at 8 a.m/to find the women already being treated by rescue personnel and the dog, a bull mastiff, locked in a garage on the property. The animal's owner, Brenda Tri, 43, of Hyannis, was bitten on her arm and her side, according to Police Officer Kevin Scott. Margarida Correia, 59, who works for Tri, received a severe bite to her head. After the women were taken to the hospital, an animal control officer removed the dog from the garage, Scott said. The dog was reportedly calm when it was taken away. Police said Tri was already expected at a hearing in Barnstable District . Court today at 2 p.m. for having an unlicensed, unvaccinated dog. Hospital officials did not immediately respond to phone calls regarding the women's conditions. -By Patrick Cassidy Wampanoag get ready for tomorrow's decision MASHPEE - The wait is over. The dirt and gravel parking lot has been regraded at the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribal Council . offices. �� , 1 The yard has been raked. A . tent and stage has been set up . on the pow wow grounds. Food ,, ; d ' has been cooked. The y' .,, Wampanoag flag has been t .. . , 0 Wampanoag tribe member Germaine Peters raised. runs a yard rake in front of the Wampanoag Tribal Council in Mashpee as the tribe gets ready for Friday's announcement about their tribal Inside the tribal council offices, recognition status. historical records, artifacts and (Staff photo by Steve Heaslip) geneaological charts have been put out for display. Three decades after starting to seek federal recognition, tribal leaders tomorrow are expecting to get a phone call about the BIA's Office of Federal Acknowledgement's preliminary decision on the Mashpee petition. Tribe members see federal recognition as their last, best hope at ensuring their economic and cultural survival on the land their http://www.capecodonline.com/cctimes/update/index.htm 3/30/2006 p� j To _ Date Ti .-• MILE Vrr. J WE RE-OUT of /.F ' W: Phone f 76' 6 -J �K L Area Code Number Extension TELEPHONED LEASE CALL CALLED TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU URGENT 1 RETURNED YOUR CALL Message /` ''. rCOtsd / /v` St max.. GtV yes . cl o .ei. 0.., >ffa , tom, 44-irtr.,/,:awt..)-,ateld ii-loAdt est-e --)1,0 ti-t--C-- ei-letalliZz. ,;(t CZAMPAD 23-021-200 SETS EFFICIENCY. 23-421.400SETS CARBONLESS et i e(t vc.t) .1A 61 - cM ) 1 0 �7 ,� �,.,Vic, �.. v I t ;lc fe r 7 , / G 9r)- g° 6(e (>P -6vg, I . r 0, , ,�Z U� 0 1 -- ^7 °A 'or3.9-- v ..0.-e. c', 6 r/vielL 30 ._e_Av EL4224, I \r\r/vLe.:(..A._ mac, II • 1 j 1 1 I f II � I I, t1 I p to .„ Town of Barnstable ,,0*1HE TOi„ c Regulatory Services ,14 Thomas F. Geiler,Director • BARNSTABLE, 1.4. MA Building Division 1639. ♦� 41)MPS A Tom Perry,Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 August 24, 2009 Jesse Green, Inspection Supervisor Housing assistance Corp 460 West Main Street Hyannis, Ma 02601 Dear Mr. Green First and foremost I would like to thank you as an agent of HAC for your recent efforts to develop and foster a professional and continuing working relationship with us. At the end of the day, I believe we all have the same''objective—safe housing for those in need. With this in mind and in light of the fatalities in the Quincy fire last winter, I want to assure you that this department is available as a resource to you at any time. To that end, you should be aware that our files contain information that would serve you well in your capacity as an inspector and our staff is most knowledgeable and helpful. During our last conversation we discussed the issue of"grandfathering". It has been my experience that property owners typically throw this word around with the belief that citing this magic word exempts the subject property from the same rules and regulations applied to everyone else. Be assured that the rights associated with a nonconforming status are based on one very crucial factor- the structure or use had to have been legally created. This means in most cases there will be a building permit on file documenting and supporting the claim of"grandfathering". This office religiously reviews our land use records in order to identify and preserve property rights. When the available information is deficient, the definitive determination is made by the Building Commissioner and duly noted. As a follow up to our recent joint inspection on Thornton Drive, I want you to know that I explained to the tenant that it was likely the landlord would not be able to renew the lease which expires in December and the tenant may Want to begin to explore other options now. We are all too aware that finding appropriate affordable housing is often time consuming. Do know that we do not displace any tenant unless there is an immediate and eminent danger.We do, however direct the landlord to take all necessary safety precautions in the meantime (such as in this case fire separation between the bedroom and mechanical room) in order to mitigate or hopefully eliminate those obvious safety risks. iw i y. I also want to point out in response to HAC's concerns regarding tenant confidentiality that we need not know nor do we care about any personal information regarding the perspective tenant or the subject lease. I assure you that our main concern is to ensure the safety and welfare of all tenants. We check dwellings for legal status as this is one way to definitively know that the imperative code inspections successfully occurred and the safety issues were addressed. Our goals mirror those of HAC's. We deal primarily with representatives of whatever agency is involved or contact is made directly with the landlord. We are always mindful that personal information is not to be shared and as a result we are most respectful of our citizen's privacy. I look forward to working with you again as I firmly believe our missions dove tail. I am available to discuss any of your concerns or otherwise facilitate a meeting with my supervisor to increase you:agency's confidence in our ability to partner and work well together. Please feel free to contact me any time. Thank you, again. Sincerely, C914-1dA'A Robin C. Anderson Zoning Enforcement Officer t oFTHE ra,,do Town of Barnstable ' ' •I1 s Regulatory Services • g Y * snRivsTnace. 11\ � Thomas F.Geiler,Director i639 .0� '°rEn,��A Building Division Peter F.DiMatteo,Building Commissioner 200 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 December 12, 2001 Dr. And Mrs. Victor Cillis 2051 Main Street—Route 6A W Barnstable, Ma 02668 Re: Dec. 6th Meeting- Zoning, Building Code, OKH &,CC Commission Violations Also in attendance: Gloria Urenas, ZEO, Tom Perry, Inspector, Robin Giangregorio, SPR Coordinator& Sharon Rooney, Cape Cod Commission Dear Dr. &Mrs. Cillis: It was a pleasure to meet with you last week and I thank you for taking the time to come in. I must inform you that I was greatly encouraged at the conclusion of our meeting. I remain confident that a fair resolution can be accomplished with the maintenance of our mutual efforts and the open dialogue established last week. After reviewing the violations together as outlined in my letter of November 21st, you agreed that there shall be no additional alterations or improvements of any kind on your property. You were subsequently advised by Sharon Rooney to file an official letter of withdrawal with the Cape Cod Commission and Old King's Highway. It was duly noted that the Planning Dept./Old King's Highway were in the process of relocating to 200 Main Street and therefore would not be available to accept or acknowledge said document until Dec. 11 at the earliest. Corresponding copies are expected to be distributed upon receipt. Ultimately our discussion involved the apartment over the garage. Previously, you have been required to completely remove the kitchen. During this meeting you were informed that should you desire to maintain the apartment you must obtain the necessary zoning relief or successfully participate in the town's affordable housing program. An informational pamphlet regarding this program and a reference to Paulette McAuliffe was offered for your consideration. Finally, all parties agreed that in the event that you decide to pursue any alteration or improvement in the future, you shall first consult with this Division for approval of the proposed project or portion there of. Any proposal requiring a referral will be referred accordingly and you shall be informed of this as soon as the determination is made. It is my understanding that Robin Giangregorio has agreed to a site visit this week at your request. She will be available to assist you in your endeavor and answer any questions you may have. While I appreciate your candor and your recent expression of cooperation be assured that I intend to quell the complaints and maintain the rights of all involved. I am sure with your support and understanding that this burden will be lighter. Sinc el Peter F. DiMatteo Building Commissioner cc:Tom Geiler,Director Bob Smith,Town Attorney John Klimm,Town Manager Pat Anderson,Historic Preservation Enc: State building code, SPR procedures, and definitions FEB-17-2004 11:20A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:1/11 Anthony Alva Attorney at Law 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 362-8342 phone 6 362-7770 fax To: Attorney David Houghton - ph# 508-862-4620 fax. # 508 862-4724 fax From: Anthony Alva Date: February 17, 2004 Total Pages (Including this cover Sheet) : 0- Client/Matter No. : Letters - Motion, Complaint w/signed affidavit by B. Tri Comments: Dear Atty. Houghton • See the attached with we discuss this�I ornirig. / e�/� J ve Sincerely, , . A.A. STATEMENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY The documents included with this facsimile transmittal sheet contain information from the Law Office of Anthony Alva, which is confidential and/or privileged. This information is intended to be for the use of the addressee named on this transmittal sheet. If you are not the addressee, note that any disclosure, photocopying, distribution or use of the contents of this faxec information is prohibited. If you have received this facsimile in error, please notify us by telephone listed in the heading above immediately so that we can arrange for the retrieval of the original documents at no cost to you. Thank you. tatigirlariA 'FEB EN, BLE FEB-17-2004 11:20A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:2/11 Anthony Alva Attorney at Law 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 Phone (508) 362-8342, Fax (5033) 362-7770 February 17 , 2004 BARN.WABLE SUPERIOR COURT ATTN: Clerk of Courts, Mr. Scott Nickerson P.O. Box 425 Barnstable, MA : 02630 . Re: Docking of Complaint and Motion for Stay of Enforcement of Board-of Health Order/ Preliminary Injunction/- Hearing under G.L.c.39, § 23B Tri v. Town of Barnstable Board of Health; -Building Inspector, Et.A.. Dear Mr. Nickerson: Kindly docket the attached complaint and summons and docket the attached ex-parte motion for stay of enforcement and/or preliminary injunction for ext available civil session today. Si Yv : 4ncere1Y ttach c. Atty. Frank DiLuna . . Town Counsel, Town of Barnstable • 18-17-2004 11:20A FROM: TO 15088624724 P:3'11 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Barnstable, SS Barnstable Superior Court Civil Docket BACV 2004- BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) VICTOR CILLIS ) LEIGH-ANNE SOUZA ) PLAINTIFFS ) v. ) Complaint Under ) G.L.c 231A, ) G.L.c.111, §§ 125A,155, ) 157, G.L.c.40A, S 3, BOARD-- OF ..HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) G.L.c..39,_ BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY § 23B, ITS MEMBERS, ) & WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN ) - - For Stay of Enforcement SUMNER KAUFFMAN ) or Preliminary Injunction ) SUSAN G. RASK � ) Demand for Jury BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) Trian all Issues BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) soo Triable ) DEFENDANTS Statement of the Case This is a complaint for relief from a "Notice of Revocation of Stable License" dated January 30, 2003, by the Barnstable Board of Health, that requires Ms. Brenda M. Tri to remove all horses from the "Diamond Edge Farm," her place of business. Diamond Edge Farm is a horse boarding facility and riding school which Ms. Tri has operated at her seven-point-one acre farm in West Barnstable since 1998. Diamond Edge Farm conducts agricultural activity exempt from unreasonable regulation, and -in this action Ms. Tri will show that the Board of Health's regulations are unlawful and unreasonable, and that the- Board of Health has acted in a;.wanton and capricious manue , Ms. Tri is seeking a Declaratory Judgment that the Board of Health's revocation of her town stable license, and its demand that she remove all horses from her property, are unlawful because both exceed the statutory and regulatory authority granted to the Board of Health under G.L.c.40A, § 3, G.L.c.iii S§ 155, 155, and 1 - FEB-17-2004 11:20A FROM: T0:15088624724 P:4/11 157. She is seeking other such relief as may be granted by law. This is also an action for a stay of enforcement or preliminary injunction to prevent the Board of Health from removing all of the horses stabled at the plaintiff's business, which would put her out of business, and, in the alternative, if the court adjudges the board had authority to. act, to require that it reopen its public hearing under G.L.c.39, § 23B, so that the plaintiff and others may have an opportunity to be present and to submit evidence before the board during a lawfully convened meeting. On the same grounds, in this action, the plaintiff also seeks declax.atory judgment that the Town of Barnstable by :its Building Department and Commissioner exceeded its statutory authority in issuing non criminal citations for the placement of light poles on the plaintiff's property, an alleged violation of building code. Plaintiffs, Dr. Victor Cillis, and Leigh-Anne Souza are taxpayers of the town of Barnstable, who, along with Ms. Tri, challenge the Board of Health's compliance with the Open Meeting Law, G.L.c. 39, § 23B. __ . ..,.The -Parties: 1. The. plaintiff,.- Ms. Brenda M. -Tri, resides at 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable, Massachusetts 02668. She does business as. Diamond Edge Farm, where. at the 7.1 acre site, she boards and/or stables at any one time about fourteen horses, and where she conducts horse. riding lessons, primarily for children. - - .. 2. The plaintiff, Dr. Victor Cillis , re3ides at. 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable, Massachusetts 02668, and is the spouse of plaintiff. Brenda M. Tr .. 3. - ' he plaintiffs, Leigh Anne: Souza, resides of 3715 Falmouth Road, Marstons Mills, MA 02648. 4. The defendan ts are the Barnstable Board of Health, 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601, and its members, chairman Wayne Miller 2231 meetinghouse, way, west Barnstable, MA, and members Sumner Kaufmann,- Old Post' Road, Cotuit, MA, and Susan G. Rask, unlisted address. 5- The defendant Building Commissioner Thomas Perr y, oversees the Town of Barnstable's building department located at 200 Main Street, ayannis,MA, 02-601. Facts Complaint Against the Board of Health 2 FEB-17-2004 11:21A FROM:: TO:15088624724 P:5/11 6. Since 1998 , Ms. Tri has obtained a license to operate the Diamond Edge riding school/` stable (hereinafter "Diamond Edge") , formerly "Stepping Stone Riding School, " from the - 40ommonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Food and Agriculture Bureau of Animal Health. (Hereinafter the "state license". ) Diamond Edge is an equine farm, training facility, boarding and stabling facility. 7. The current operating license, number 1033, from the Commonwealth was issued on April 1, 2003, and expires on March 31, 2004. A copy of the license is attached to this complaint and marked as "Exhibit 1", and is incorporated herein and hereto in its entirety. Ms. Tri is also licensed by the commonwealth as an riding instructor, number 3924. 8. Such state licenses are granted conditioned on Diamond Edge's passage of inspection by agriculture department inspectors. _ ... Diamond Edge has regularly been inspected by the Commonwealth Department of Agriculture Bureau of Animal Health, and was last inspected on June 20, 2003, and July 24, 2003. 9. Diamond Edge passed each such inspection. See copies of the inspection reports= attached...to this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto in their entirety. The June 20, 2003 inspection' is. marked as "Exhibit 2". The July 24, - b2003 inspection is marked as "Exhibit 3". 10. On or about March 22, 2001, the Board of Health directed that Ms. Tri construct two compost bins for the composting of manure outside the stable at Diamond Edge. 11 On June 26, 2003, the Board of Health by an authorized health agent, issued a non-criminal citation to Brenda M. Tri, dba Diamond Edge Farm, alleging violation of "Part ,X, Stable Regulation," for "failure to properly cover manure" and which demanded payment of $40.00. :See. _the -"NOTICE OF VIOLATION OF TOWN ORDINANCE OR REGULATION," (hereinafter the "notice") number BAR 65339, marked as "Exhibit 4" . attached to this complaint and incorporated herein 'and hereto in its entirety. 12. The June 26, 2003, notice of violation cited as its authority an April 1, 1972, Town of ;Barnstable Board of Health regulation entitled "PART :X STABLE REGULATION", (hereinafter the "town regulation") which was revised on or about July 15, 1993. Today, the town regulation contains fifteen paragraphs purporting to govern`. stable. operations. See the town . regulation, marked as "Exhibit'5",� .the contents of which are *incorporated -herein and hereto in their entirety. 13. On July 1, 2003, the TownLof Barnstable, Board of Health, by its chairman, Susan G. Rask, issued Diamond Edge a stable 3 FEB-17-2004 i1!`21A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:6/11 license, which expires on June 30, 2004. (Hereinafter the "town license". See the town license, marked as "Exhibit 6" attached to this complaint and incorporate herein and hereto in its entirety. 14. This June 26, 2003, notice, was one of several issued by town health agents, that year, including citations numbered: (a) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a .$50.00 fine for purported violation of town regulation Part X, attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit 7; (b) BAR 66554, dated August 6, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine for purported violation of the town regulation, Part X(7) , attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit 8. (c) BAR 66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a $100.00 _ fine for purported violation of the town..regulation, Part' X(7) , attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit 9; (d) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine for purported= violation of the town regulation, Part X(7) , attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit_ 10 15. Citing Part X(7), of the regulation as authority, on July 29, 2003, Health Agent Thomas A. McKean issued a latter, an "ORDER TO L.CEASE AND DESIST", -to .Ms. Tri, focusing on accumulating horse manure, alleged spreading of sandstone and/or dust, stated that failure to comply with the "order" could result in a "* * * $100.00 non-criminal ticket citation," and with each day's "failure to comply" constituting a separate violation. See a copy of the July 29 letter, marked as Exhibit 11, attached to this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto by reference. 16. Pro se, Ms. ;Tri seasonably challenged and appealed each such citation issued by agents of the Barnstable Board of Health and the July 29, 2003 "ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST" by Mr. ..,McKean. 17. As a result of Ms. Trigs appeals, as they were issued, all of the above referenced Board of Health citations were filed by the Town- of Barnstable' Board .:of Health in-Barnstable's First District Court for a determination of probable cause, and/or for a finding 'of responsible at a-magistrates hearing, and on February 5, 2004, a hearing'on all alleged violations were continued by the magistrate pending resolution of this complaint in Superior Court. 18. On January 8, 2004, -the Board of Health conducted a hearing at which time its members took evidence from its health• 1. FEB-17-2004 11:21A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:7/11 inspector, members of the public, Ms. Tri and her counsel, referencing the above cited purported violations and complaints from the public. Despite documents showing that manure was being removed from Diamond Edge Farm on an almost weekly basis, on that date board members voted to accept proposed findings of fact submitted by the town health inspector, and expressed an intent to shut down the Diamond Edge Farm. (See the document marked as "Exhibit 12","Proposed Findings" attached to this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto in its entirety. ) 19. After discovering the January 8, 2004 meeting had not been posted or held in accordance with the open meeting law, the Board of Health notified Ms. Tri by letter on January 14, 2004, that another meeting would be convened on January 20, 2004 . That notice is attached to this complaint,- marked as "Exhibit 13", and incorporated herein and _hereto._ 20. Ms. Tri by her counsel requested in writing that the January 20, 2004 meeting be continued because on advice of her physician should could not be present. That letter is attached to this complaint, marked as "Exhibit 14", and incorporated -herein-and-hereto - 21. At the January 20, 2004, meeting, the applicant, Ms. Brenda M. Tri, on advice of her physician, in fact could not be present, and the board members were so advised at the. beginning=of. the meeting by Ms. Tri's counsel. 22.'r 'At: that meeting board members refused to continue the meeting so Ms. Tri could be present, refused to make; at least one site visit so they could view conditions first hand, did not accept additional testimony, reread the January 8, 2004, proposed findings of fact then voted to accept said findings. 23. Written notification,of ' the Board of Health revocation which included an additional finding and demand for removal of the horses no later than February 17, 2004, was made public in writing by board chairman Wayne Miller on or about January 30, 2004, when notice was given in accordance with 105 CMR. 400.400 to Ms. Tri on February 3, .2004. A copy of the notification marked as "Exhibit 15" is attached to this complaint, and is incorporated herein and hereto. COUNT X Stay of Enforcement and/or- Preliminary Injunction 24. The plaintiff restates and incorporates' by reference herein 5 F88-17-2004 11:22A FROM: T0:15088624724 P:8'11 and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 25. The riding school and boarding facilities at Diamond Edge Farm are the plaintiff's sole source of employment. Her self employment has also had a crucial therapeutic and emotional benefit to her as she has been struggling with ,an otherwise debilitating long term illness. 26. If the plaintiff is forced to remove the horses from Diamond Edge Farm, then she will immediately be put out of business and potentially placed in breach of contract with clients, potentially exposing her to an assortment of claims. 27. Throughout the course of the plaintiff's interactions with the defendant board of Health, it has refused to consider -,- reasonable alternatives to its current order to. completely ,. remove all horses. 28. Such wanton, capricious, and draconian measures by the board, " 'gwhich would immediately shut down the plaintiff's business, would constitute irreparable harm to the plaintiff. Tri-Nel Management, et.al: v. Board-- of Health of Barnstable, .433 Mass. 217 (2001) . 29. The plaintiff. should prGvail in her complaint because the facts and law support her position 30.• Public policy supports the plaintiff ' s position. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Issue a stay of enforcement prohibiting the Barnstable Board of Health from executing its January 30, 2004, Notice of Revocation of Stable License demanding removal of the horses at the ,Diamond_Edge Farm because even if the defendant suffers any harm as a result of the granting of a stay, the plaintiff will suffer far greater 'harm if the stay is not granted; (b) ., In accordance with M.R.C.P. 65, and Superior Court Rule 9A(c) (3) , schedule a hearing be held after issuance of a stay of enforcement on a Preliminary Injunction; (c) Waive any payment by-the plaintiff of any security or bond under M.R.C.P. 65(c) because, among other reasons, in this type of case the defendants cannot reasonably show any costs or damages that. may be incurred or. 6: FE8-17-2004 11:22A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:9/11 suffered by being enjoined or restrained; (d) In the alternative, if the courz declines to issue a stay of enforcement, in accordance with M.R.C.P. 65, and Superior Court Rule 9A(c) (3) , schedule a hearing be held for a Preliminary Injunction; (e) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT II Violation of Open Meeting Law Stay of Enforcement and/or Preliminary Injunction G.L.c. 39, 5 238 31. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above, listed . paragraphs. 32. On January 14, after notifying the plaintiff that she must request a continuance of the January 20, ,2004 Board of Health meeting no later than fifty two hours prior to the meeting (see Exhibit 13) the plaintiff did request a continuance in writing (see Exhibit 14) 33. The grounds for the request was the plaintiff's medical condition. She faced surgery and on her physician's advise she was urged to avoid stress that could worsen her condition. 34.- oaegardless of the requests, on January 20, 2004, the Board of Health convened on January 20, 2004, at about 7 p.m. , and after rejecting an additional request for continuance to give the plaintiff time-to recover and respond to any additional evidence or statements by members of the board, it proceeded to: a) refuse to accept any new testimony; b) incorporate all evidence taken at its January 8, 2004 meeting that was held. (by its own admission) not -in accordance with the open meeting law, and; c) re-entered into the record their previously approved "proposed" findings of- fact and voted to revoke the plaintiffs stable .license. 35. The actual decision of the board, . giving the plaintiff until February 17, 2004, to remove all horses from the farm and revoking her license, was made public by service to the plaintiff in accordance with 105 CMR 400.400 by deputy sheriff on February 3, 2004 . (See Exhibit 15. ) 36. At the January 20, 2004 meeting, Dr: Cillis and Ms. Barrett FE2-17-2004 11:22A FROM: T0:15088624724 P:10/11 — 'were not allowed to speak by members of the board of health. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Conduct a hearing on this issue within ten days in accordance with the statute, G.L.c. 39, S 23B, at which time the following prayers for relief may be addressed. (b) Find that the defendant Barnstable Board of Health's refusal to take any evidence on January 20, 2004 meeting, aside from a prepared statement by its own agents, constituted a violation of the open meeting law since the facts contained in the statements were not discussed during a lawfully convened public meeting of the Board of Health; - • (c) Find that the defendant Barnstable Board of Health's refusal to continue the January 20, 2004, meeting so the plaintiff could be present, constituted a violation of the open meeting law since the plaintiff was not given due process or a fair opportunity to be present or to provide, evidence or comment to the board on 'its proposed actions and findings during a lawfully convened public meeting of the Board of Health; (d) Find that the defendant Barnstable Board of Health's refusal to take any evidence on January 20, ,2004 meeting, from any source in support of the plaintiff constituted a violation of the open meeting law since the no such facts were, or have ever been,, presented during a lawfully convened public meeting of the Board of Health; (e) Find for each or any of the above stated reasons, the Board of Health's Notice of Revocation of Stable License is the result of an unlawful meeting, and that it therefore is unenforceable, or in the alternative: (i) If the court finds the Board has authority, order that such lawful meeting thereby be convened, and that the Board of Health members make _a site visit' to the farm, or, • (ii) If the court finds the Board has. authority, order that at all such future meetings the Board of Health may only take evidence and consider evidence • submitted during -a lawfully convened meeting,and that-the-Board of 'Health members make a site visit to the farm. . 8-17-2004 11:23A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:11/11 COUNT III 37. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 38. on its face, the Town of Barnstable "Part X: Stable Regulation" as adopted on April 1, 1972, Revised on July 15, 1993, states at X(15) : Under Massachusetts General Laws, chapter ili, Section 157 anyone who violates the provisions of these regulations shall be punished by a fine of five dollars for each day such violations continue. The Barnstable Board of Health also reserves the right to suspend or revoke licenses previously issued if continued _,. violations of these regulations occur. Id. 39. Each and every citation issued by the Barnstable Board of Health exceeds the five dollar per day maximum fine allowable under G.L.C. 111, S 157, with said fines ranging from forty dollars to one hundred dollars. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that each and every pending Notice of violation of Town Ordinance or Regulation brought by the Barnstable Board of Health that exceeds the five dollar maximum cited in G.L.c 111, § 157 is preempted by said statute, unlawful and thus unenforceable;; lb) Order the transfer from District Court and dismissal with prejudice of each and every iminal and its associated fine that have nbeen on rbroughtcomthelaint Barnstable Board of Health against the plaintiff; (c) And that said order include the following citation numbers and any others which exceed the statutory maximum: (i) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a $50.00 fine; (ii) BARe66554, dated August 6, 2003, citing a $100.00 fin (iii)BAR 66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; 9 -EB-17-2004 11:2600t FROM: TO:15088624724 P:1/11 (iv) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine (d) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT IV • 40., The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 41. G.L.c.111, §155, "Licensing df stables in cities and large towns; fees" states in relevant part: No person shall erect, occupy, or use for a stable any •= building in a city, or in a town, having more than five thousand inhabitants, unless such use is licensed by the board of health, and, in such case, only to the extent so licensed. * `* * [T)he board of health of such city or town may make such regulations or orders as, in its • �. judgment, the public health requires relative to drainage, ventilation size and character of stalls, bedding, number of animals and storage and handling of manure in any stable in its city or town. Id. (Emphasis. added. ) WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: , (a) Find that (in so- far-- as the Town of Barnstable Board of Health is relying on "Part X: Stable Regulation" in its non-criminal enforcement action against the plaintiff) each, or any, of -the f ifteen 'listed paragraphs of "Part X", violate G.L• .c. 111, 5155, going beyond the statute by regulating areas outside and not- related to the drainage, ventilation, size -and character of stalls, bedding, number of animals and storage and handling of - , manure in any stable in -the town (b) Order the transfer from District'Court and the dismissal with";prejudice: of each" and=every non criminal complaint and its associated fine that have_been brought the Barnstable Board'`of Health against the plaintiff which exceeds the statutory authority granted under G.L.c.11, §155, (c) Include in any order the following citation numbers and any others which' exceed the statutory maximum: 10 rE8=17-2004 11:29A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:10/11 49. G.L.c.111, §125A, states in relevant part: * * * the spreading of manure upon agricultural and horticultural or farming lands or noise from livestock or farm equipment used in normal, generally acceptable farming procedures * * * shall not be deemed to constitute a nuisance. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that Docket 0325CR 002331 and its underlying non- criminal complaint, fail to state with sufficiency a cause of action upon which relief may be granted; _(b)--- -Order the transfer from District Court and dismissal with prejudice of said complaint and associated fines that have been brought by the Barnstable Health Department against the plaintiff; and (c) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff thatthe court determines are mete and just. COUNT VI - 50. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 51. -,An income generating horse stable and riding school on a .parcel five acres in size and larger constitutes an "agricultural" use under G.L.c.40A, § 3. Steege v. Stow, 26 Mass .App.Ct. 970 (1988) . 52. G.L.c.40A, § 3, `-'Subjects which. zoning may not regulate; . exemptions; public hearings * * *", states in relevant part: No zoning ordinance or by-law s all regulate or restrict the use of materials, or methods of construction of structures regulated by the state building code, nor shall any such ordinance or by--law prohibit, unreasonably regulate or require a special permit for the use of land for the primary purpose of agriculture * * * nor prohibit, or unreasonably regulate, or require a special permit for the use, expansion, or reconstruction of existing structures thereon for the primary purpose of agriculture * * * Id. (Emphasis added-) 12 FE8-17-2004 11:29A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:11/11 53. G.L.c.40A, §lA, "Definitions" of "Zoning" states: "Zoning", ordinance and by-laws, adopted by cities and towns to 'regulate the use of land, buildings and structures to the full extent of the independent constitutional powers of cities and towns to protect the health, safety and general welfare of their present and future inhabitants. Id.. (Emphasis added. ) 54. "Part x: Stable Regulation" as adopted on April 1, 1972 , Revised on July 15, 1993, states in relevant part in paragraph one, that the Board's authority arises from, "Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 111, Section 155" and the "zoning By-Laws of the Town of Barnstable". WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that the plaintiff's operation`of -a stable and riding• school is an agricultural activity under G.L.c.40A, § 3 - (b) Find that the town's ability to regulate such activity is restricted by -both G.L.c. 111, § 155, and G.L.c.40A, S3i (c) Find that those paragraphs of "Part X: Stable Regulation" of Town of Barnstable which go -beyond- the scope of both G.L.c. 111, § 55, and G.L.c.40A, §3 constitute an unlawful effort by the town to restrain an agricultural activity; (d) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought the Barnstable Board of Health against the plaintiff because they in fact exceed the•town's regulatory and/ statutory authority; (e) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers:. (i) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a $50.00 fine; (ii) BAR 66544, dated August 6, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; (iii) BAR 66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a • 13 •FEB-17-2004 11:27A FROM. 15088624724 TO: P:3/11 $100. 00 fine; (f) Vacate and otherwise dismiss with prejudice the January 30, 2004, Notice of Revocation of the plaintiff's Stable -�. License and its attend order to remove all horses from the premises; (g) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. The Building Department COUNT V I I 55. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein ; .and hereto the averments contained in the ..above..listed paragraphs. 56. On or about June 26, 2003, the plaintiff applied for a permit to perform electrical work-with the :Barnstable Building Department for the installation of "Light to Gazebo and outdoor paddocks andarena for safety of riding and caring for/ safe keep of horses. " The application also stated one lighting outlet would be installed, ' four: lighting fixtur_es- and one receptacle outline and switch.".A copy of the .,,application is-attached -to-this complaint, :marked. as ."Exhibit 18" and incorporated by reference herein and hereto in its entirety. 57. The plaintiff paid a. thirty five dollar fee and a permit was issued, permit number 69795. 58. The plaintiff subsequently had lighting posts installed for the riding arena which is used by the horse riders for the purposes stated above. 59. Shortly thereafter, the Town of: Barnstable by its Building Department and authorized agents have been issuing non criminal citations against Ms. Tri, each stating: Lighting Pole Erected Without Old Kings Highway Approval, Chap. 470, Sec 6 Old Kings Highway, and each-purporting to levy a $100.00 fine -A sample copy-of the application for complaint for nine of the alleged violations is attached, and marked as "Exhibit 19 60. To date there are at least twenty seven such citations, all of which were duly appealed by Ms. Tri, and all of which have been filed in Barnstable,s District court for a magistrate's ' earing. 14 - FEB-17-2004 11:27A FROM: T0:15088624724 P:4/11 61. As with the Board of Health non-criminal citations, at this time the magistrate has stayed proceedings on all said Building Department non-criminal complaints pending resolution of this matter in this court. 62 s The statutory reference cited on each of the complaints is "Chap. 470, Sec 6 Old Kings Highway Regional Historic." 63. None of the documents cite the specific Act or Resolves from which Chapter 470, § 6 is derived. 64. Chapter 470, of the Acts and Resolves of 1983 refers to "AN ACT FURTHER REGULATING THE PROTECTION OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH", and its § 6 refers to the definition of a research laboratory. Chapter 470 of the Acts and Resolves of 1989 refers to "AN ACT REGULATING THE RIGHTS OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES TO RUN FOR ELECTIVE OFFICE", and its § 6 amends_chapter 150E _ . of the General Laws. Chapter 470 of the Acts and Resolves of "1993 refers to"AN ACT RELATIVE TO 'THE ERNESTINA COMMISSION" and contains nothing related to fines for the installation of light poles. A review of the Act and Resolves in other years presents a similar array-of assorted legislative actions. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that each and every non-crimdnal citation filed in the year 2003,',by the Barnstable Building Department, by its authorized agent, fails to state with sufficiency a cause of action upon which relief may be granted; (b) Order the transfer from. the- District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought by the Barnstable Building. Department against, the plaintiff; and (c) Include in- said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-Criminal citation numbers as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket:' , • .(i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each, citing_ a $100. 06 fine; - (iii) BAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine- ,(iv) BAR 67,6261 67636 to 67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; . _ (v) - BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; (d) Grant what ever other type of relief to the_ plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just15 , , , • • ' _ • • • FEB-17-2004 11:27A FROM: TO:15028624724 • P:5/11, _COUNT. VIII 65. The plaintiff restates and incorpora-es by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the alternative to Count v, states as follows. 66. The Old Kings Highway was establish" d 70 of" ,,4cts of 1973, as amended by Chapter 298b and y h845eofr 4the Acts of 1975; Chapter 273 of Acts of 1976; Chapter 38 and 503 of Acts of 1977; Chapter 436 of Acts of 1978; Chapter 631 of the Acts of 1979; Chapter 338 of Acts of 1982; and Chapter 90 of the Acts of 1994. (Hereinafter the "Old Kings Highway Act". ) 67. Section 6 of the Old Kings Highway Act, "Limitations", states in relevant part * * * no permit shall be issued by the building inspector for any building or structure to be erected within the district, unless the application for said permit shall be accompanied;'eitler by a certificate of appropriateness or a certificate of exemption which has been filed with the town clerk. 68. Section 3 =of the Old King''s Highway Act, -"Definitions", defines "Structure" as: * *. a combination- of materials other than a building, sign or billboard, but including stone walls, flagpoles, hedges, gates and fences. 69. %ection 3 of the Old King's Highway Act does not def light post and/or light pole. inea : 70. On information and belief, no person has been required to apply for a lighting post or pole ` in .area under the jurisdiction of the Old King's 'Highway'Act. 71. Upon application by Ms. Tri 'for her lighting installation the Town of Barnstable issued her -a -permit without it being ' accompanied either by`a certificate of a ppropriateness or a certificate of exemption having been filed with. the town clerk as required by. Section of the Old Kings Highway Act.,_:. 72• No such certificate of -appropriateness or a certificate,of exemption were required because none was needed for the work that Ms. Tri applied for and which was accomplished. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS LE • 16. FEB-17-2004 11:28A FROM: TO:15088624724 P:6/11 a) Find that each and every non-criminal citation filed in the year 2003, by the Barnstable Building Department, by its authorized agent, fails to state with sufficiency a cause of action upon which relief may be granted; (b) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought by the Barnstable Building Department against the -plaintiff;and (c) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers, as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket; (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 fine; -- (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100.OQ- fine,( ii) BAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR.- 67626, 67636' to 67650, each citing a $100.00 _ fine; - (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; " "'(d) Grant what ever other type of-relief to the plaintiff, - that- the court determines are meteand just. COUNT IX ` 73. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the `alternative to Count vI,, _states- as follows. 74. Nothing contained in the Old Kings Highway Act, other legislation, states'-that said _sct superseder s G any : e G.L.c.40A,. § 3, "Subjects which zoning may not regulate; exemptions; public hearings * * *", as defined in G.L.c.40A,"Definitions" of "zoning . �1A, WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that the plaintiff 's operation of a stable and . riding school is an agricultural activity under G.L.c.40A, § 3; (b) Find that the townsability to-regulate such activit is not granted under Old Kings Highway Act; y (c) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all,,non criminal complaints and 17 , • • FEB-17-2004 11:28A FROM: TO:15068624724 P:7/11 • associated fines that have been brought the Barnstable Building Department against the plaintiff because they in fact exceed the town's regulatory and/ or statutory authority; (d) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket: (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 fine; (ii). BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100. 00 fine; (iii) RAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 67626, 67636 to 67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; -��-- - ,le) ._._Grant what ever other type of relief _to the_ plaintiff _ that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT X 75., The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs , and in the alternative to Count VII, states as. follows. 76. section 12 of the Old Kings Highway act, "Enforcement", states in relevant part:, "An y provision of this Act shall"Any eperson- who violates. any -fined not less than One Hundred- Dollars ($100.00) nor($500.00) . Each day of violation�of . thre is Actn �shallrco constitute a separate violation.�� nstitute 77. The Town of Barnstable in this action is '• seeking finesy of one ,�iundred -dollars per day for -at least twenty seven days. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that the defendant Town of Barnstable by its Building Department and authorized agents is acting in a wanton and capricious ,manner, attempting to levy a fine far in excess of that allowed under any reasonable interpretation or the law; . _ (b) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss prejudice of each ' any, s with and associated fines hatrhave been non cb ought themplaints Barnstable Building-`Department against thet because-they in fact -exceed the towns regulatoryiff or statutory authority; and/ 18 • FEBs17-2004 11:28A FROM: T0:15088624724 .. .. P:8/11 (c) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket: (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 fine; (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iii) BAR, 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 67626, 67636 to 67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; (d) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT XI The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the alternative to Count -VI-I, states as follows. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT grant what ever other relief to- the plaintiff that the -court determines are mete and just. An affidavit by plaintiff Brenda M. Tri is attached in support of this complant. THE PLAINTIFF D A TRIAL BY JURY ON ALL ISSUES SO TRIABLE. - RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED PLAINTIFF BY HRHATTORNEY Ant 633858 • torney at Law- 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 - Barnstable, MA 02630 (508)- 362-8342 Date 1 19 FE8.-17-2004 11.r9A FROM: T0:15088624724 P:9/11 COMMONWEALTH OF MASS10EUSETTS Barnstable, SS Barnstable Superior Court Civil Docket BACV 2004- BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) • PLAINTIFF ) v. ) BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) AFFIDAVIT AND ) VYRIFICATIFN OF COMPLAINT BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY ITS MEMBERS, ) BY PLAINTIFF WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN ) ) _ SUMNER.RAUFFMAN ) SUSAN G. RA.SK BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) ) BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) DEFENDANTS ) 1. My name is Brenda M. Tri, I am an adult above the age of 18 years, I am the named plaintiff in this action. 2. I have read the complaint being filed on my behalf by my attorney, and thoroughly familiar with those facts, and the facts as related in the complaint are correct. 3. In addition, my farming activities at Diamond Edgge Fa been economically harmed by the Town of Barnstable's attempt to impose unreasonable restrictions. I have suffered physically. emotionally and .. . ,. . . . . 4. I reviewed all documents. attached to the complaint and ,, As exhibits, and provided those documents to m markedA are documents which i have maintained in the routetc course of my business at Diamond Edge Farm, ar true and accurate copies of documents Ihha emarsodmaintained exhibits are ALL OF THE ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST -OF MY INFO ON, AND BELIEF. SIGNED •UNDER THE PAINS AND PENALTIES OFIPERJURY THIS DAY, FEBRUARY 17, 2004. • a Mom. Tri : . COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BARNSTABLE, ss: BARNSTABLE DISTRICT COURT No. 03 25 CR 002331 No. 04 25 CR 001769 No. 04 25 CR 001771 No. 04 25 CR 001772 No. 04 25 CR 001773 COMMONWEALTH COMMONWEALTH'S AND DEFENDANT'S v. STIPULATION TO CONTINUE TRIAL UPON PROBATIONARY BRENDA M. TRI CONDITIONS AND DISMISSAL UPON SATISFACTION Now comes the Commonwealth and the Defendant and stipulate as follows. 1. The trial of the above complaints scheduled to begin on September 15, 2005 is agreed to be continued to a date assigned by the Court in February, 2006. 2. The cases are to be assigned for pretrial status conference on a date in January, 2006 to be assigned by the Court. 3. As a condition of the continuance, the Defendant is to complete probationary terms without supervision consisting of (a) construction of animal waste composting bins promised in her compost registration application dated December 1, 2003 in October, November and December; (b) composting animal waste in the bins as they are completed in accordance with her application; and (c) submitting a stable license application and animal waste management plan to 20030213 stipl 1 the Barnstable Board of Health by the end of September, 2005 accounting for all animal waste including composted and non-composted if any. 4. If the Defendant completes the probationary terms established as a condition of the trial continuance, the Commonwealth shall dismiss the complaints and waive the imposition of any fines at the next status conference. 5. If the Defendant fails to complete the probationary terms established as a condition of the trial continuance, the Commonwealth and Defendant shall agree on a date for filing of any motions to be heard prior to trial. 6. The terms of this stipulation and dismissal shall not operate as an agreed statement of facts upon which a finding of guilty could be made, nor a waiver of claims or defenses based on the authority or lack of authority to regulate public health or agriculture. Dated: , 2005. BRENDA M. TRI COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, DEFENDANT By: By Her Attorney: ANTHONY ALVA T. DAVID HOUGHTON, Assistant Town Attorney [B.B.O. No. 633858] For the Town of Barnstable, on Motion of the 3291 Main Street District Attorney for Barnstable, Dukes and P. O. Box 730 Nantucket Counties Barnstable, MA 02630 [B.B.O. No. 241160] (508) 362-8342 367 Main Street, New Town Hall (508) 362-7770 (fax) Hyannis, Ma. 02601-3907 (508) 862-4620; (508) 862-4724 Fax 20030213 stipl 2 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BARNSTABLE, ss: BARNSTABLE DISTRICT COURT No. 04 25 CR 001766 No. 04 25 CR 001767 No. 04 25 CR 001768 No. 04 25 CR 001770 COMMONWEALTH COMMONWEALTH'S AND DEFENDANT'S v. STIPULATION TO CONTINUE TRIAL UPON PROBATIONARY BRENDA M. TRI CONDITIONS AND DISMISSAL UPON SATISFACTION Now comes the Commonwealth and the Defendant and stipulate as follows. 1. The trial of the above complaints scheduled to begin on September 15, 2005 is agreed to be continued to a date assigned by the Court in February, 2006. 2. The cases are to be assigned for pretrial status conference on a date in January, 2006 to be assigned by the Court. 3. As a condition of the continuance, the Defendant is to complete probationary terms without supervision consisting of immediate cessation of use of the three poles and floodlights illuminating the riding arena on her property and remove the poles and lights by the end of December, 2005. 4. If the Defendant completes the probationary terms established as a condition of the trial continuance, the Commonwealth shall dismiss the complaints and waive the imposition of any fines at the next status conference. 20030213 stip2 1 5. If the Defendant fails to complete the probationary terms established as a condition of the trial continuance, the Commonwealth and Defendant shall agree on a date for filing cf any motions to be heard prior to trial. 6. The terms of this stipulation and dismissal shall not operate as an agreed statement of facts upon which a finding of guilty could be made. Dated: , 2005. BRENDA M. TRI COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, DEFENDANT By: By Her Attorney: ANTHONY ALVA T. DAVID HOUGHTON, Assistant Town Attorney [B.B.O. No. 633858] For the Town of Barnstable, on Motion of the 3291 Main Street District Attorney for Barnstable, Dukes and P. O. Box 730 Nantucket Counties Barnstable, MA 02630 [B.B.O. No. 241160] (508) 362-8342 367 Main Street, New Town Hall (508) 362-7770 (fax) Hyannis, Ma. 02601-3907 (508) 862-4620; (508) 862-4724 Fax 20030213 stip2 2 2.051mohSr4 (CI 1ts), ., v0 c_ q 'r v 1, , ..., 0 i 0 Q. d Tv Q v o , r o 7. ' p L Y ` N a 0 NAME OF OFFENDER VI c,�-ts r O y \ 6�n j ck (I 11�i s B A R a 9 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFEN OS I M 1 t` .1f [� BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE i}Gxrvs.t G \1 1 t 4c, a O 2.103C1 /&SHE► MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER / �. OFFENSE op - 1�1 G( / sect-i Y\ OW t�•�.(ftS t1 )Q�j ' coo 1,AR ai .:bell .�, A..t,4i+ sib 1:,.Y C 4 'r c`ts,tt ly "t• 'O%A t + 0- i4,. CD k`S Or t C 'Di SAr•1CA A C* -- 1 ‘C 1n Ly5S f 45tt1Md�iy Qppov6 1 LU TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION t-*+.-)j LOCATION OF VIOLATION" Z NOTICE OF `-'1':t,k,> (A.M./M ON )0-11/ ,is c,LcS/ /►'Iola Si L) ar ns a1.71e SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. W. VIOLATION w, .e., c4`__--- bldy N> OF TOWN tI 1)0 J o I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE 8 Unable to obtain signature of„offender, dss 1--- _1Q /O_z a-0 3 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ IL)U OR Date mailed YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w cn REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, u before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or b mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDEQ i r 0 b`e (L ADDRESS OF OFFENDERc •1\'., - BAR 52924 DE TOWN OF2OSl d 0.. t> S* . 4' BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP �C,O3 . ,g € S 0t \e ! ,f�J��«,G 02(0,30 .,4 FfilkIHE� NUMBERBARNSTA `� 1 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER �0, • • OFFENSE L,. \�ASSp $ �up �17� Sec�'tOv� , (�Id f`�nc�5 }�'� h,. .y K, , Ft,n41 , La 6yq. A0 {i 1 p G cLA's ` arrS erec•k }'�,'<woo- u+� e _.'to ► $5 f)C V1:51 f 1 C.} I\CA - IC""t S f li 4 k Loo•v Q(gyp(Uv4 1 > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION C ui+.,$ LOCATION OF VIOLATION Z NOTICE OF - O (A.M. P M)ON JCf -IS -1s' .do I tylc,,„ s t.).), 30 c I ''\a Ok "1 J SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. - W VIOLATION " vim-.-- t. 1 .r w TOWN a L J I— OF I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE li Unable to obtain signature of offender. A �' Cb_!0-0 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS Si U, Date mailed w w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL rZ DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. .Li, REGULATION N (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation fore hearing. • (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint maybe issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature • • BAR 52925 NAME OF OFFENDER } C.A 4.,,C ) r C.T"U t.C s��t� 'K� YN 4 1' t<a TOWN OF ADDRESS'OF OFFENDER 12D 1 \G,ti s`r BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,zlPwwc�O�)q)-E,J bat sl „,10 fit '(A cA ' 62(3 b t ��pit1E row "� \ 1 t MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER +� op OFFENSE `y, t�(�ry}t(� A (^, } j�`yl r.t{w {t. �/('�p (` r� IIA MASSPIJ:.q htt0 1 f0 Seck% " V'�: I.`tkCS ` tCfi1WU� ti\GIO CIA Lij MASS. ! t rED MAr E,O { i t ti/ei POle)4 ettc4(- WAr'i"T ptol.�,+ 0 N OJ 1$ot 1 C ?;5,ArtC A.t* — }c I( S }�ttkLodt, Aap(J4 i > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION ._- , i Z fa rjj LOCATION OF VIOLATION J / ' Z NOTICE OF 3 1 o U (A.M./ P,M:NON /O"1 ' ,19 ,205} 1116t n 5+ 1.-J. BCAmS t SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. W '1 VIOLATION Q� .P t51 �C.4' v' OF TOWN 1, o I HEREBY�ACKNO LEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a • ORDINANCE CI Unable to obtain signature of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $I 00 Q° ~ Date mailed 20 — w w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. t ; ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER in 1 11 1s BAR 6'7 626 \/1 G�r an dre.vt�G, • TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDE)i 46.51 M ft9t BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE.ZIP CODE ¢ W . gc�rn5' .w�\e C 'a•• 0,2�3o P`0*TE I' ' , MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER '11 • ...! OFFENSE �+. / /, {� { 9Q� „639• `m� t .Ik1Q 147O ,l�° ti Yl\ fea Old k,1✓1cs T•1;41 t.zel.Ku Reo 1 ov'al 1 o ,elfD me./ �J T y .,j,, �.i i Jpek Vert 4 d ,Tnou.T 6I4 w kiI S`!D1'! C I)1s46C A 1 '" �c;Ncc 1•lic. i.,aat, ex ra�rrava 1 > *' TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION LOCATION OF VIOL�IATnIO�N� ' 1 W NOTICE.OF `3:(1v (A.M./€M;)ON 18-1? ,;2a2003 .�A3•! rat',Q UA S 1- ice)• C rr ret\ \t a SIGNATUREOF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. w VIOLATION; '119 r B i o OF TOWN ► HEREBYC1KNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE II Unable to obtain signature of offender. OQ Date mailed /t�"��'0 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ N O, w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w • REGULATION a to You may elect to pay the above tine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, LU before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose;a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. V.• a D.I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature • NAME OF OFFENDER V r Q.tnl te_\CA C';11 ;S BAR 67.636 . c� TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER t 020S) M tv.:,c� BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE Ltd, '6o,t-nc\A\3\<4 Ma. 02(0'30 THE r MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER '-g\o. OFFENSE RARNSIARI.E. ' )' t� ` � vvss. (�lrn `770 Sec�',oY. ( 00 K;ntg t•�iuNN,. Ay 'E {'cttann©.\ \-'rsiocic. o _ti6}q �0 -P t �{. !1 et � 1y \FD MO ),5 6�.. ! Ac "' 1 �o1�..S `te(44 IA.)% '\t)k Q� VQ t • �i TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION at t LOCATION OF VIOLATION t t W NOTICE OF 3:bta (A.M.• P. ,)ON / 20,2063 • .2651 Mco:,, , SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PE SON ENFORCI G DEP. BADGE NO. N VIOLATION e j ...,f 6 141 OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X ORDINANCE El Unable to obtain signature of offender. °6 1- �0—2�_ 63 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ �QO, Date mailed Lii w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL cl- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION Q (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER V tc r o rtn�� ;fl BAR ` •TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER i`�t� �,i BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE LA). bar vNs\'a'a`e.. ra . 021036 �II*r� - MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P1�ti �, O OFFEN,SSEry` (�r� ! j `4 \ t , BARNSTABLE,q C.Y6Q G► "I /O SEC. 10V1 (o OKI. k,l14"S 41c .)wo y Pt"GiIOV O j A'ks `t O Ld 'HATS. 1 \j 3 FD Mpi 11 nn i t -J t T 1� rtCC 1�C 1���� on�cS �('�C �d Wa�,naw +aa radar > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION Q w LOCATION OF VIOLATION 1 W NOTICE OF . 3!00 (A.M./ P.M))ON f 0-2l ,20 OJ . .6 SJ /Y�a;.l S'I' , eCkt ns lb Ile SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCI G EP BADGE NO. N VIOLATION (}� / 1Si ` ,G� l f i 0 OF TOWN (,i bi) / v I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE Ig Unable to obtain signature of offender. A A ° 1— Date mailed / i—o3 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $/LW, w LU OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above tine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE, MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Sinnatura - .. NAME OF OFFENDER V t CNQ,,c Q'N \l•�S' ,/1l Y'eJA XCh. a;\1 y C BAR 67638 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER p ,2o$) Ma,riSAC. BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE _ ' GEC A4S4\0..\% Vet MO. \I�h O., 0 ZOO k 0*tNE row • MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER , ti b:J OFFENSE /'� e 0Q 1ASS r a llA p I19d Sec eb& � O kt ASS N ►o wo y R q oa�c\ S ri '0 630. <0 s.r r o MPS 1 \ 15 r;el Ac. — ii Lt ocs\eS ere c' e.1 wt"tVo+,z a0oc1:s)a.\ > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION si T LOCATION OF VIOLATION y 1 Q w NOTICE OF 3%co (A.M./ -,A)ON 101-22 ,2009 „20Si rAet%A S'c Gt.), &srA� 1l . SIGNATU,RE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO, LLU ;,VIOLATION , /al ' �31J5 0 OF TOWN I HE EBY�ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE ® Unable to obtain signature of offender. [30 I- 2_ THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ ( w Date mailed / w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, J before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ . . • Signature NAME OF OFFENDER I I t c*o- Q V^ A` c; ,, ; BAR - ' 3 s TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER GSl : 4 BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE U.) eo.r nsXAAt.', Mo. 02,SC) //��NE ro,- MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER //Pam. _� • G OFFENSE IIAR\IARIE. : 7 NASS �. ('_l,G f3-LI70 Sec4 i a,n �9 0 W tc c 14 iS��lay ReG t 0A A%S t t c o • fD MPN� �isr\4� A�� - \�4� rx�les � ec�e w‘ 400tn►1a\ > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION •J , LOCATION OF VIOLATION i I tt w NOTICE OF 3`Cot3 (A.M./ ON 1c 27 ,200a .1�1 rig',,. Si i,J• Qa,rnS�'ab\-t a SIGNATURE OF ORCING PERSON -i: ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. < . VIOLATION 1, yt'J /�+--• 8/.1) OF TOWN I H RE Y1ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION XLu ORDINANCE II Unable to obtain signature of offender. QQ 1- THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ 00, _..1Date mailed r0`27` 03 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a .DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ • ' Signature _— _ • NAME OF OFFENDER r� f Q.� �reti` ;�\�5 BAR 67S40 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENSE cam}�5 1 M�f O. C'S1 , ld BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE 1.�3• arr�slv a�ole. o . p2b3© pf♦HE►p MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P� O OFFENSE ry 1 /� _{ ty �] l+ MASS. �'IQ ��( 4DY1 It1CrS \t< WQ� ui 639. �0 .,. 1 O p'E' "' iDiS4kik /ICY — \\�1\� pales er>•A"-C� w\�\nofk ' a, n/uVCA 1 >-J TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION t LOCATION OF VIOLATION/y'j V V 1�� w NOTICE OF 3 4£L3 (A.M.,a)ON /p—ZY ,20 a) ) 51 1!)C.,I 5+ LA), &(0541. )I SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. w VIOLATION +�J cn o OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE E Unable to obtain signature of fffender. a4 ,_ Date mailed ���z�_ �j THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS S f�}(�. w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL °- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, LIJ 'before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND, MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER_; ck 1 {31~.(A C 11\;s BAR 67 46. TOWN OF ADDRESS. OF OFFENDER . iY1 o.,,11`V t{yJs* {4r + BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP COADE]^ , Sat a0.y ‘e 'Mc,. Oa�3O `e1HE!\ 1L".7 ` MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P 64 9 OFFENSE / I} .ba 70 Se». _tQ PoACS, �ckAIG 4Iv►a ooas9 r *^ J I,kk ere.t""t 1.43i1 1.a1, Old t'►�cliS Htght y QOIx1JVk) > • TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION 1 LOCATION OF VIOLATION J rf f Y w NOTICE OF w:AU (A.M. P. >)ON /0)77 ,20a3 .20s) /nem St Q VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING, , 1ff✓✓dd PE SON ENFORCING DEE.� 1 BADGE NO. LU I1 , OF TOWN Ci LO I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X ORDINANCE E Unable to obtain signs ure of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS s/41 , w Date mailed I 1 II/o. LU OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL rL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)It you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. • (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. • 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature _______ _ NAME OF OFFENDER V { { el,twf f} i is BAR ' 764 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER +�Nm�.l•» !A'i? ON,rkM if••`~"' .20S I fiNa\k S BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP GODS, ; pv r sk + e r ist ,. 02 +] 0 ;1HE f� y V {(�wr"��,J MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER - 'o• OFFENSE n jj,'jI (+.j{. /r. J/., J{ y�e[_ ` /�}4 r'/�l�q .^ }t +}.y3 ti t ,,,s{,• NAizisf, :. ('.!M?� "(` A e4{;N V1>J i'�•»yS t`4lnwav 3'ec;�'lal !7E roV�c, Q S)"'Pi - -' MASS. f C 059. .elEO MPS a`e ��u}}� • }} } k �•1 f 1 4 t 1 ( uj C..T ne I IgkA- Fo1e e.cec A 0)�'`1�(5t T Q krrtcS ;�1r hugs y' Ci9.0("DYCt1 > NOTICE OF TIME AND DATE:0 OF 0LA(A.M./(fl )ON /0/2 et ,20 03 )05)OFION LOCATION frIcA: 54- LAI 'ace t nS I.0 SIGNjRE.fO•f``��F ENFORCING PER$QN ENFORCING DaP>� BADGE NO. cow VIOLATION sri K/ di.- rif.'. R1J OF TOWN1 hi)/ w I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE 2 Unable to obtain signature of offender. °4 I—. t f�3�03 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $MO,Date mailed w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION rn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 4 ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature. ,s NAME OF OFFENDER Vie ctAd tBrevlccb. j {�ry 1)j BAR 67648 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFEND „ tr . BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE, "VAI t, n , x' O Z GS0 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER 44f1 , Faso. 1 o Mak� D ILhaPf'14 , €'etIN► t o c;1 A'1,44., oy Pe'G;60,a ti% rt y4r►(. c v ` i GK* . \ ..� ; C..c eci tAiA*Ne�, Jit) k 'Ilkc y)4141A �,/ +l,a,1( }t�Q.! > NOTICE OF. TIME AND D ;OCil (ANM./EP M:)ON )O12 I 200 LOCATION OFVIdLATION t S V Y W ,� �tl3 1 Ma t n SIGNATURE OF.ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING D PT.) BADGE N0. VIOLATION U . .,,.•, �/�'' f . 0 OF TOWN I HE EBYACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE E Unable to obtain signature of offender. °'° ►—. �� /6 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS s d�. W Date mailed W OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1) cn You may elect to pay the above line,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, LQu before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, EJ. Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND, MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE, MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this ,.' citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing 3 to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature - - q • NAME OF OFFENDER i j'+} .f� # BAR 6-7649 4 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER r `1<, tw Taw• f�►✓F {� !! BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE` Rai- i-A Ky ` ke P�a. O ��tME\ -.1 *1• 1d,•J " t3 i11 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER - . OFFENSE BARNSTABLE. . } LJ.. „:55.� loan 470 Se(-4 ,0A Cal k;6c,c 14:cf,hurl.� t'Qtovnc � l\isAt ;c. 'yi5 r.4. C 1 G Do es et 2^ t LftC+,n. OW ,KC, >^ {kF14+1001 a l '1"DYQ + ill TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION " LOCATION OF VIOLAT ON .X "gyp 1 Si w NOTICE OF' 2160 (A.M.KEW)ON /4�30,2007 2.oS`! tar, $'+ Li; 4rMs- I SIGNATURE Q,F ENFORCING ENFORCING DEPT;r BADGE NO. N VIOLATION ..i/f( /V7 a'! o OF TOWN f� I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE E Unable to obtain signature of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ Ida"6° Date mailed hi7/07 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL ,L DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION a (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, iy before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, d Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Sinnatura _ _.. NAME OF OFFENDER i i 1 ("y ; `; BAR 7 6.5 0 t< C C�+A ta^ 4Se TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER A651 1r16..°r A BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE , Rat N S 7 i y t 'Ma. q}�^ , °Z O pP 1ME t� i V+ MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P`' O OFFENSE 4 ";,7S ii. e/7O S 0A i Dad. k';nG AlR\, Pe t t9Y1QA x rtc.... o prED MP'�9.h, bi.+i-t":t AG.4 I14!I* Ak c`recl"t''Ci 1-t44144 .4 oicy ke;ito Nit,'AWx.I apor,'wi1z TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION „Y t LOCATION OF VIOLATION. / 1, Iy NOTICE'OF 2 bC) (A.M.(r M„�.)ON /0/71 ,2Ofr Zo '! III o.,n .54'' AI. tafyts ,1r SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING FEBSON' ENFORCING EP. BADGE NO. LI VIOLATION j ./,;,LJSc OF TOWN f // LU I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE El Unable to obtain sig pure of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ 0 , c).t)Date mailed t, LU OR Lu YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION Cl) (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature ' .gym. NAME OF OFFENDER ,.. \ BAR TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER . a5t mr. 7� BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE.ZIP CODE r t.b). (.f r.;r-.C]\e . `\cL. O (Q 3 o `colHE Its, MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P OFFENSE?• , t t t t ,(� tLli \e .,Ass.p �A A 416 S C.4t rt3h 6.. 01J k 1 ri 4 S ri l q it t.',..1 O.V { eC t O nCA 11 15 {41,C prFD mot' 1);S*r,C* I\CA f?,�1 I;LJNA e Er C'eeVto Li11-1fi4A,k 61 tl 1t i/lc C, (411cr[11041/ 4 i);O!`etk,, + > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION �J "+ LOCATION OF VIOLATION .J {, NOTICE OF .Gta (A.M./e 1.)ON ))/t)3 ,206 2LS! P'co,01 Si U, tsar n�+4.14 It SIGNA,URE OFENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING D,EPT. . BADGE NO. (a VIOLATION kl 4.4 cif ; ' ! ICtiG o it. i v I— OF TOWN: I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X 0_ ORDINANCE .2 Unable to obtain signature of offender. o� THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ p Date mailed I t/17k-3 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL .- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. • ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ • Signature NAME OFOFFENDEDt © l BAR 67652 TOWN.OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER ' ,3.oS 1 di SA BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE • Elacv,Sk l a Ma . nZ(03© �}1 E r''q i GI/ MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER i`-.3. " OFF SE • ;,, ,s9. me N. tpC hc� {ti1ne�, �1 +n S rr fvf l Jrrt►an ��}( jj,=�- arc i���i' ED MPS 'N".i '� 7:74.i1:75:611 R.S � [ id J4 ' {�'�f'/f t J lt�l bu, r A� It tNfk11 �,>�f9�itV�t > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION I p LOCATION OF VIOLATION 1 V f Z NOTICE OF.. , ;00 (A.M./CP.N..)ON j /q ,2003 ',I'S.) u,ra Sri', IA). YIS a SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. • BADGE NO. LU VIOLATION �� „ � J 04 at o OF TOWN ~ I HEREBACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE ® Unable to obtain signatu a of offender. Q t— Date mailed MI �► THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $i1 O W LU OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION 1 You mayelect to pay the above fine,either byappearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monda throw h Frida legal holidays excepted, Lu Q before:The Barnstabl Clerk,230 South Street, yannniis,MA 0201,or by mailing a check,money order or postal noteto Barnstable lerk,P.O.Box 430, ELJ Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature • NAME OF OFFENOER�`� � Qom\ F�*�� BAR 7 TOWN OF ADDRESS. OF OFFENDER i. C\1 r2tS) inatre BARNSTABLECITY,STATE,ZIP VI co,SE� MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER C. OFFENSE �L;"'6;S. g akap 1470• Se io a� kings kta +t a , I M + ' ` .lr ` 4 ,�A55. ' t e 1 r Ew �s �q /� G►1A ra.� `� r t! ;S PI�. a fD MP�� ... .�„r, t 84k1 ru les el e[. to 1,3,F ife il C.)ilk'uovs, F i Co, w Q or o 1 > • TIME AND DATE OF,1IOLATION, - LOCATION OF VIOLATION y/' / i U w NOTICE OF 2:00 (A.M.i P.>ON // C ,20 al MIS i Ma,_ ►+ i.1, • Cid Cry v441,1 0, a SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON r ENFORCING DEPT, BADGE NO. Cl)W VIOLATION [Lb', „e' _.N al du OF TOWN t1 lip ' LI I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE E Unable to obtain sign ture of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ , b,°4 1- Date mailed 410ii>/�7 W OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. W REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a ' Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER 1c` / k /' 1 f..4 ^A R 6 E 6 5 4 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER .AV' ('�, ,2©51 (na`11. 1 , - BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE E • flHE \ MV•OPERATOR LICENSE NUMBER MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER OFFENSE ItAH\IANI.i:, t L ram. ( • t � a,q. `0S 1� �' �1 N�'t'; t��� f'E/! 5 ,G Alt url>� �1"G,[�Mlk1 I S ! 1� i s"tf"t o FD MP�� �. 1 !{ "'r + ✓ J Act''-.ly�� ,le�.'! Pr`ec' IA/1++'�ltW �;t ki/KS />a�itvav a .a.flr-,ici I > TIME AND DATE of VIOLATION LOCATION'OF VIOLATION '° / w NOTICE OF 2 'ClO (A.M./050ON /L ,20 03 aoSi (11a•, 54 Cd. ISAr:ne el)kkc a VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON A ENFORCING.PT�/. BADGE NO. N OF TOWN') I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X .12 ORDINANCE 2 Unable to obtain signature of offender. ( 1�� �� THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ ,� }. J -\ Date mailed w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL °- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. LL.I •REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, Lu before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a • Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND, MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE, MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. , (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. • ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature `y J j :: t`yf . NAME OF OFFENDER V t one' QY\I:t Breve G. C 1 13�& BAR ', i ... TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER iJ • f,265) maIA S+ BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE . (Ai. ? rrrs'1to: t. • `0ftHE ipw MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER �P Wi 1 OFFENSE • IA EO k9 M9Pa,`0'43t W / G Jr $ leh%1) II/0 5eC.4; A 0IJt4ilj t / e ; t 54D ; . 1 rC O AO***] ` )1c0' pr IC3 eter4Cfj t 4 h#4.4 Oki' t' d 114twati Q,Oo/ddG I z TIME AND DATE OF:VIOLATIO'h f LOCATION OF VIOLATION' 1/ Fli Z NOTICE OF 2 . (A.M./P.M',)ON JJ12 ,20 t 3 'roe) ; ,, St t 3. eat T4 4 a SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. VIOLATION i),::.l',,, :; :.- %4,<, . , ,4-3 6'lac rW 0 Li OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a' ORDINANCE I Unable to obtain signature of offender. O) F- THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ . Date mailed w OR . YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION Q (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)It you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature -- • NAME OF OFFENDER ; Y ;E f OvCI Nitre \a. 2 `1.IS , BAR 67 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER /�.r { t5'1 . iri%a'+A BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE i /R � � ` \f ' in&. o263o �1HE r194, •6J,f_�. �„L1�,3 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P�� OFFENSE 1 ,rAss , 4/ 1170 1,S 'C-4'Art 6 Old Kul s 141G,�il.00lt( iti.eGrd,wtJ /11$ 6'ric ►,TtS ls. " 0 ED modji 14',A4A03- 6 tCt. k 44 11 LA QI rimy' - TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION LOCATION OF,,VIOLATION ,A F w NOTICE''O .tF 34'OU (A.M../ ON /1 10 ,2063 2.o$'t '„. S+ tJ. me tIolt SIGNATURE`OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCINGJT. BADGE NO. N VIOLATION A�.. {{ffJ��1 y, o OF TOWN I HEREBY�A'CKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X ORDINANCE CI Unable to obtain signature of offender. sIQ 1- THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ 1 Date mailed 20163 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE, MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature • NAME OF OFFENDER k c,. or a ^rev & I�.'S BAR $7662 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDE .,2051 t la i t~ ' BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE , , Q)ar rss\t e.. /�a. 0211'0 CME \! MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER ti 90 �? OFFEN(/SE j`�,, 1,,fcQ7p J,J! s(_" '�ij .f.�q� ''�('`'� BARNSTABLE,39B• ?!ha�I /170 .."ec 0� k! !fit �i i` I R i I 1I i hr;c b} {) i O 1 w j( ��n}},, ���p t`� r �n�a/�is��, h ti�A/v( �l FG�7aj'na(/ r0. s fir,/ i `JO MP. p, AC+.' 1 c 17+ f�{7 er> c+eJ (,{.f F' (Ok.N Oki- i 4 S S /f� it t4 .f rO arat(aJ TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION 4 LOCATION OF VIOLATION/ t V . Z NOTIC 'E,OF " 'f. (A.M./ ON lib_ ,2003 .,20 .'i 41rh 5¢ i earn +0..1Ik LU SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DE T. BADGE NO. W VIOLATION ( � jl,j , (-' , rl `LD D OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE Q Unable to obtain signature 2f offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ Q4 r ac1 MI mailed J 1 2041 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. LL.I REGULATION a (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, J before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND, MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. . ❑.1 HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFE•NDER y j� I� a y /'��" .YA E\\r) Q A R �*'9 * TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFEND ER 65) Md.\ t�,l r LJ/�7 „7 t w+ BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP COD WI IdikrA511&,%611C, Ma . 02.6)3o ji IHE t� MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER P�4 • BARNSTABLE.. OFFENSE.,d+ { .A ok ]k' fP /);A e li Lc+�AD t ) (f ` )' + W ,'4�\��v .8� t��...;. G� �"t6 @�"t",4E1 /`xn 3 f t�.ar�1.V rand ry rfc. Jtf]1S r"1G',_ a ED MPS pLu P,." f i 1q 4°lel ere ci Lot teal...- ' Void �; s At.. t, Ci,,)i✓a 1 w F TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION ° j� LOCATION OF VIOL�A`TION { /� � Z NOTICE OF " i(�3 (A.M./ P.M; ON fJ ,2061 20SI 1#1 u r S+. t{ f�. 1 .r.s a • SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. �W VIOLATION 44 � 1 o OF TOWN (` �ffil I HEREBY A'CRNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE El Unable to obtain sigfnaturefof offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $, 4Q.°� Date mailed 1 f 12.Q/();" w w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL °- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION rn (1)You may elect to pay the above tine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER Li, a 1l)iiS • BAR 67664 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER V65 1 M tx,t A \/. • BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE.+,] rtk`,.1 e fri 6; O 2 A /tHE ro,_ liU•j , lJ MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER �� OFFENSE n IfANMASS. f'�1 a", ,7 G9 O P f fC2O Q[1 /A - riC, D1 s tt 4 a +ay �e 4r�r 7 1Q � fOY1 INi4� w`y G(�tAlfi�/ o a• fit[ 1+ h� l�tl "S f'r2c�f~�1 ►.t, o� ++M14S rG t,JL1N Gt.11prDVal > TIME AND DATE OF.V OLATION i LOCATION OF VIOLATION f W NOTICE OF 3 f ( (A.M./ P NJ� ON i1/14 ,20 O 2051 l , y+' ,0, 60.CM 5 \)c VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF•ENFORCING PERSON !', ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. N W.ai6..Ea,.4- ,( l 14 0 OF TOWN E f f,, w I H EB AC NOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE E Unable to obtain signature of offender. 00 I- THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ /f W Date mailed )1 7-•/V03 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL eL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. Lu REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE, MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ • Signature 1F �'* 4� F 4.k1. ! NAME OF OFFENDER Vic t� ate} ,ell l�fs BAR V TOWN°OF , ADDRESS OF OFFENDER#VG IFU. a_t4�1 BreINAck r BARNSTABLE'A CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE�91 r A c e , i • 671,36 36 4 t >� • !t 11 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER OFFENSE,*} I,AXMASS E. •, f( �tr�1 , }'�7 4F Jd , !r f Rt 0,('t 3,S� 1:7 • ! . O ,,,55 g � "�'!Q @t ,o� trawl t4 f.sldu ♦1c t ii plED P'� /,� j�, �, 11{�"t / DC .�. � IhT 11.A1 ,/ i�.t YS iS 4tAm1/ QJ,tInIQ 1. Lu TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION f f LOCATION OF VIOLATION •,J s I r w NOTICE OF 2!04 (A.M.t?M))ON ;J E/J7 ,2003 .2oc1 Ma,. LA.)• &Arn544k Q • SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCIN`c,DEP BADGE NO. w VIOLATION t}..,1i e:_ut..tJJ. 1`, ,f tr•rA..— 1 C co OF TOWN I '1'1) RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE ® Unable to obtain signature of offender. p° r— Date mailed Y 112t//t33 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $) O w Lu OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION Q (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, LU before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER t .j ' c• 8 •r cL . 0' - BAR 67666 • TOWN OF • ADDRESS OF OFFEND RO2 1 rf }1 14'11t rk BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE i{• W gar r, a.. lea , to :t,3 q 1..1ME.ro = MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER " 4 On a 14ft. 'PCs. OFFENSEEin i ; prEDMP�p`0g 1. .h., 476 e+:�` �;Mn, e, o#a K`' as 4i51 wrty Reo toraI I 1 S Tic... o MSS A 1 . - Q� r > _Ae. - I' ct oc ks er�cce t,Ait ()LA- tetcs ,� goy a rvvaI z TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION , } LOCATION OF VIOLATION ,r ' NOTICE OF 2 �`O o (A.M./ CON f I/)8 ,20 03 2oS i__ t' it , sr c r s + SIGNATURE OF,-ENFORCING PERSON-, ENFORCING C EPT. BADGE NO... w VIOLATION /,A14, �s�,w, rr ) o OF TOWN I HEREBYDACKNO LEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X k 0_ ORDINANCE I I Unable to obtain signature of offender. .°b I- Date mailed / �� THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $JOO. w OR w YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION a 1 (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, n. Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. i ' ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER + lItc r .���1` ~<c+:Aa e'il\is BAR 67667 TOWN OF ADDRESS OFOFFENJR _ y + BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE ��r3#; 7 tHE ti MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER OFFENSE BARNSTABLE. • ( C� t j,,, W ' .� .�,ASS i (1kC(!.) 7O ,SeC.T.thA L O l kietcS 4 'uo..V fiFGtoYLo.\ 1"r+s xC3 C IS4r1f. a .0Op\'639. \0 + ki .,,y1;Aj +1�4 r .11 !t_ C *' t c Dc\ a f c t t.f+ bu f n S is WE+t, 4norDVA.1 > • TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION H LOCATION OF VIOLATION ✓ J. �' Z NOTICE OF ` ,Go (A.M./(P.M)ON /)?I/7 ,20 03 2 S 1 / 1a+Y, S'4 LL+ ega.r.rjrki'r&b & SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ,T ENFORCING O,EPT. BADGE NO. N VIOLATION 1tg.� _, ' ,, 1d� o OF TOWN ~ I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE 0 Unable to obtain signature of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $I0+ y W Date mailed //2Y1(1 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, n:. Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. r ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ • Signature ir•� 11 Qe pQ��/jp(��68 NAME OF OFFENDER i f ao,,. i-e v'� +J. 1, ,I )1 l BAR. {,�! i r► ' TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFEND 1 BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE 'GYP pf IHE�� MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER 9 sf OFFENSE ' HA FINS AIMS: ' inn y�/^� '9�7 may(.. y 11 `},, ��.q{ (,r .1}�� 1 +td39• �0$ ¢J,��i CA" "]1n SP .:11��.A C 0)c.! k‘Ac S. W 1\ ....j..\ E[J�t'o.1;aA4A i', .13 tL Lts-�iJtc O \ Mn+O / •t..7 ,"r w r4�'%�" �` .,lO�A.' 'te ,.. 4r,J' `S(� t,.t! 1C f' I CI ,I L.c)t9l!/ {,�G�B V`tt.f TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION ' .w-�. LOCATION OF VIOLATION ✓ f ( w NOTICE OF 1 O /O (A.M. P.M, )ON i1)2.a ,2063 ,20S) t"r';iv, 5 I.J.. fv,si17 t#t SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON, ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. w VIOLATION L. i.,PA, ../'-',4 + 61(4c . o OF TOWN t..' PI: I I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE El Unable to obtain signature of offender. /Ai} bQ �- Date mailed #��*�`l�� THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $itk , w w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION a (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, d Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal.proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE, MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you tail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER V,'C6r .V'C\ fL e 111 tS BAR 676'6 R TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER�`j }} �� c4'O, 7 V T/i eX I h S 4T. . BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE &krTO � , Q , /t 20 6 ..co ° MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER JI`�h� f Y,. OFFENSE p � ` 1 J `1, t, ri ',,ASq0 ( ka0 N7t cc toy% 01A irxds IIVe kiJa.k/ pc,iae1a c ., t5c(k, o_ f°mid ' T kinC "" I141,A- 1-)61e. e tAt.A o,IlkW DJ t iS 111Pl WfAy 0+4)005ga I > . TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION 1 p LOCATION OF VIOLATION " i l: �t ` Z NOTICE OF 3:00 (A.M./(P M,)ON I lit) .2063 .ZU'S I ( '\O,v, t III I A,rttc-t#b it. SIGNATURE,OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. - BADGE NO. LU VIOLATION ilv {t,G ' .,�, (3)44,1 o OF TOWN i I H REBY�ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X le ORDINANCE ID'Unable to obtain signature of offender. { ) CC 1¢-- ���ijl THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $iOU• Date mailed w OR w YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL CL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (t)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET, BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. A ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Sianature _—._ NVOaiN)DER at,„& 6,vAa. ► 11.1 s BAR 52.907 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER m 5+ BARNSTABLE CITY,``TTA✓TEE,,ZI.P,CODE f,S aotk e 1 m 0 s . of 1ME iq. MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER (/A $p OFFENSE HANNSTANI.E �t r�/� / G� t y 69. be C 61 Ail SeCtsOA 4, Oid is ;n4s (.L1�\/ Rt'Ca1on�� w a q O QED MO►` ` ir—.5 r vioc r s t!YC c i'MA`W t*Ift p'l.4 a++f 1L„ J, W` S1'ar=t, L bjts -rick Act- - lctrir..,s 1-Itel}.ws.y wPtp Ai w TIME ANDE,DATE OF VIOLATION G(J v3 LOCATION OF VIOLATION Z NOTICE OF .V1:00 (A.M./C)ON 9"22 ,if ,ILL. / (Y cu Si', LA). batA 't'cx 1e VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF E U U RCIN RSOu +rr ENFORCING�DEP BADGE NO. w of �ihlJr r�Cilii OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X ‘,.; Lu ORDINANCE ® Unable to obtain sa'ture of offender. ' Date mailed �0 0 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ /OOe w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a REGULATION DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. C (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, •w before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER D A 1e„)reY\�!� �1 ' s - BAR 52908 TOWN OF ADD 2E$Q OjFENDE CI � e .. BARNSTABLE CITY A STATE, I CODE THE toss, MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER C A . 9. OFFEN/SE�. ,,^^ p� �/�a lbo MASSPI.EA L. `/�a Seci+IclA LD. O kt k;nos H ighwav Rec1o)7c\ 111 679• `0CC oMAy� �? cT• 1G 1 l`1\C ,19h s u 1rS CCKc'+:`Ctk W.'-,,ha.r.`i O CL Lij TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION j"*'.J LOCATION OF VIOLATION Z NOTICE OF ) do (A.M./ ON 9/021 ,is a05) Plc) Sc , rr5�q\)k(M Lu VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSONE �/, ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NOIcic . N OF TOWN ✓ (_L-• " w 1- ,I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE I Unable to obtain s'gflature of offender. 'z' 1- Date mailed ypg16 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ � W OR W YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. W REGULATION a(1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or b mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND, MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or ifyou fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF9. N C*C. r OP BreIN C t { Its - BAR 52909 TOWN OF AD,;21) OF 35 OFFENDER 4 �� BARNSTABLE CITY,ss STATE,Zp CO Oki' .',)+ e , �c , 0„( � ctHe Tq,_ ! 1/ •,i• MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER OFFENSEf/{1 jj ��ry/(/�� p f/� j/�/jM lj jK,,. /!(` ��+)I +'; A }y XAX IASS. E. } 1"' R ! I 0 S4ci f or\ t i/i�,.` /' , `.7 J ! 1 C•1V 15�r�.iavi g n NAlS g. i�r„ AAA,li.J I♦� ( R om{ t t�n CL iI Ttc r�nvn+.. cylf Cyf"t C 1 S e 1 e�1.yr. f,la a e$ c c`4 Id t,tC wA fJ lrt{ o t t{"5 C f`c. !`err, ("��� 4.Wax�/ QQQfr�/a,' > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION wr 20 v' LOCATION OF VIOLATION Z :aa 9— Lf 1s' Si. g �� w NOTICE OF (A.M.KM)ON ,2gSt roo, ar 0 *.ci. t VIOLATION SIGNATUREOFn ,P-ERSOGN9�**w-M ENFRCItiEPT. BADGE NO. ti OF TOWN I E EBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X ii yLu ORDINANCE 13 Unable to obtain signature of offender. AA 00 1- Date mailed 94 19/0 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS S /VV. OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATIONcn 1 You mayelect to a the above fine,either b appearinginperson between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q () eC Y 9P w before:The Bamstable lerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21 D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NDER NAMEQIOCF.F.E � Qh C1IR' ' C t 9 BAR � TOWN OF ADDRESS05 OFFENDER aA A • BARNSTABLE CITY,STTATE,ClQ 'n' cA }\�. . f�j"E Q µ �36 `e INE/N. � � tt MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER f' OFFENSE �j {^ \ 1d �/y• �' (�"� ' KZIt•BLE,e. �i0 7 t� .w/ CrV rT• tI.fJf'�f�1 �,, ' {e4.(I V�GI\ dN. 639. •0 hu,i oren+' t C l.•f�N"� QQUr3 rtc,'c�.d w.wlne..t .1C)1`r o R1 rt t t'1 � Ac k,', eS Wit, wu,) oPPCoJat j TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION 2004 LOCATION OF'VIOLATION Z NOTICE OF .2:G (A.M.AR)ON }-„ni g LLI .20 l /Y)ui n Jlt. L }. B r15 c�1e SIGNATUREi OF,ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. N � VIOLATION U.r c�, ..,,/` , • 8 i �� OF TOWN �f I HEREB AC r KNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE El Unable to obtain signature of offender. qp • ►Q- Date mailed / �t/D3 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ /(}0, w. OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w' REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main.Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)11 you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. • (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you tail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME If,OFFENDER a�nc\. bf�.h ck. C Id���s BAR 52911 . TOWN OF AD 1iD ESS& OOF//Victor��ENDE ^at ww ,A S* • BARNSTABLE CITY,4STG ATE.ZIP�CODErJJrrntts. `1,+;\, 1 fil` 6.24s0 pf MET 1v . MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER "(Sae% OFFENSE \.,A6 0 C"1, � Ll"�a SC 6 d k►nqS iq)ci.�/ I�Ersi©tnp, a ,IAlS. w 1679• �0 ��qpo O -J `°M°y +SA r1C.. �1S4 1CA. ! 4c K,„t,S Nc414..44.,N appr►Jar > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION j LOCATION,OF VIOy�ION W NOTICE OF 2:�U (A.M.i4P.M?)ON ?-2-6 ,°ts- 010 1 !flaIr S* LJ• ��f,fh$ CAUk VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. w OF TOWN 1 �'V ` o I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE 0 Unable to obtain signature of offender. y+;,�/.(} THE NON •CRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ I�� Date mailed w w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL d DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, IQ before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)It you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ • Signature NAME OF FENDER {f22 y , r l,C. ,r ck. 1Jre1+ G 1 4,(s BAR 5291,3 TOWN OF ADDRESS Oct �ENDE in '� Y • „ • r BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE ZIP CODE tDATE W &.A r iNSka\CI,C. . Q 2 E'3(3 �HE►qk, MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER 44, +G OFFENSE , '}`� [+ R (� BAN\STABI e" oo Li !0 M1C4:-V1 1 W Old chvUSAA/ Re GtL0Lij MASS. I T l Y� 1�. 1 .639• . r ►} /� j — L. ir-t�De�lt s �frr(+et) \�cutof 'to rAr•+' t S r* C 1/'5k r 1 A >'1 C l "C I J k1..c s {'),t j.�I. a y A ,)Jt'Ft✓ls I u' TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION 7OU.3 LOCATION OF VIOLATION t 1 ➢• Z NOTICE OF )1 (A,M./ P.M.)ON :29 is- ,105) y`i)C4;A `',* Lc) 111611 aci\S-kuN0f SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DPT. BADGE NO. w VIOLATION ,, ,,�" bIrjcf . C" •OF TOWN `` ~ I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE .I Unable to obtain signature of offender. c THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ I0t'�+ Date mailed /I)i7/63 I- OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION < (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,ether by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citafion for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature 1. 14.\.,,11., NA c w a� revs\a .'1. .;s BAR 9 .4 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF A )a t N. ✓j BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,)S ATE,ZIP CODE tom) VI",r t,s f�`e AY'1ct, © -�3� n f IKE T4. MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER Ck • • p OFFENSE) 1`n (� //.{�'�•(y /1/� (J�} �+ (q []/� n • •fa�! 1 / ec.. ��I'� V V« I>� .i r IG� 1/4 i+,11,) A 4.G;o c, d sr j}�� ` ' N , 1 c, \ J ` O rtoru*r• tyi Fairy Cre<t•�# wt�4t%ut 1 S r t< t� (....1 1� C 1 t( K;'n o s /•1 WC. G pvr`, I > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION; Z.G1b.S LOCATION OF VIOLATION' ./ ,* W NOTICE OF ' 11 ((M')/ P.M.)ON %-30 ,19 OS I Illa;„ S* LU baens4a1bl t SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON T ENFORCING� _ BADGE NO. uJ VIOLATIONt Cr2J d OF TOWN J (,:1I V - v �o HE I REBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X — a a ORDINANCE '❑ Unable to obtain signature of offender. Date mailed !U�'7/�3 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS 506' W OR W YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL rL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. W REGULATION You mayelect to a the above fine,either byappearing inperson between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday legal holidays excepted, Q (1) eC PP 9 9 Y 9 P.O. W before:The Bamstable Jerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk, .Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature lei R NAME OF OFfENDER i . ro V,,;.�ru. o r' Q ce In c\a C. i 11 i s BAR 52915 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER, a'.„ BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE C n��0-1)\ . • frla, 4.20,0 elm rDl MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER OFFENSE I7 M}� �+\'1 (f,., }1 4 • BARNSTABLE. k;, Id ha H70 VeA 1 -)jt W Oki 1'fl1Ts 1 Irj 1,I4tV Ie \MASS. $ / V 1 Y��` ,/ 4 �{�1�1I M. DMPy s�O // 1� i L`'t 1,4� Poi4*)"�u rr.e`CfeGy (Ad,"f`�lot,1 O st tor. )f�, C1�� AC fi/ct /rt,`n4x f,`y t,r4.y c, r(SthvA� w TIME AND DATE OF >VIOLATI N_. "�'tT V,$ LOCATION OF VIOLATION tl W NOTICE OF !I A.M'./ P.M.)ON lOh ,1'9` o.€OSF t'7a;,� ' (,L3. Dar rohA(a e C.C. SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON „/ ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. 8 VIOLATION : ,,,,.. .-_ b kiti C ) r " sw o OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X w ORDINANCE LI Unable to obtain'sig�ature of offender. �� /V 116.1 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $1 Li), Date mailed w w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature I NAME OF.OFFENOR), * Ac 1 I j_ t S D(�D 5 2 9 1 ..� i(Tr y r f D„n TOWN OF ADDRESS OF QF I.y)DE, !,4A. S4 • I, . BARNSTABLE CITY,Say,(ZIP(',O�DCEE C� As3\e. mQ. 024 so yF}HE►\ (p MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER O� OFFENSE") 1(,,, M/j�'y(J//�.� �'\l j/�, t((`} �.1} try,., +�'�{ ` `/� r �1 RAR ASARl I. •k ItL{11 . 7 `-i 1,/e�.- 'tc,h 6 ViV ' "I„4, J 't4 WV�t� 4. {V„Q. w MASS p, I'r a_ 16;q. �G i p � }k 1 i.1 t1�' J�c.if s "Ilf CG. rri WI'I+Y}0�+:X ff OJ P`t t S f t C. i c 1 CA E 1 - CIO )ci.' ,.$ 4,i w ci y A pp r b'a 1 LU TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION G V"'S LOCATION OF VIOLATION Z NOTICE OF I1 (A.M!/ P.M.)ON I " 5-t L J. fa rrs c.Mt SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT. - BADGE NO. w VIOLATION ...�t1 oc' - D t d v 0L, " ~OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE ID Unable to obtain signature of offender. II btu Fa 1 / 7/ THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ /ili' J Date mailed w OR w YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL °- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION co (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, IQ before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or b mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATyyE OF THIS NOTICE. FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal STREET,BARNSTABLE,Mou may do so A 02630,Attn:21 written D Noncruest iminal Hearings ari gss aCT nd enclose T ra copy of this citation.for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFENDER Vi r }, B A R 21 TOWN OF: ADDRESS OF 2 C OFFENDER 05 11 Id.t 1. c Ty ic) I R8 • BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CODE r C`` \t. Pi) A 2(r 6 ba,IKE roo_O L� 1 1 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER \'�� OFFENSE I �) /L„. /^ /Li /1� j((n/tQ` r, I3AN\ti'l'ABIJ:.p // {f^�q . jH� ° /\'7 '(�` 5 1, tJ)(I ` ` yag) ' f ,/I1 /� / `L-4t W rt I.A e it ASS. /O k...,.I ha f .,J 7 {�'� n r/I fl.J WV�� 1 .erFD /.�" pp , , `..i(,t .fea.lts ✓ore e#t et iar+t,m..a,1"t' of J)is r1C fS�lic y ' 0.14:1 kin4f P1a14L.16., 0%91.011% i Lu TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION. 1 t./.:3 LOCATION OF VIOLATION. r 1 Z NOTICE OF !i C(A.M./ P.M.)ON lob ,1 20 / Pi.t. i S+ tJ, 8c rr sk-41okk SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON / ENFORCING DEPT.. BADGE NO. w VIOLATION 1�,j.. '.1., ,f/ - b1, co OF TOWN I HE'EBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X JLii ORDINANCE tEl Unable to obtain signature of offender. //�, 6° IQ— Date mailed Jt?� /� THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $/Ur�1 -J w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. LU co REGULATION (1)You mayelect to a the above fine,either byappearing inperson between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q eC PP 9 99 O P w before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature NAME OF OFFAD �1�€!/)C.,V£ Q :1>'1 o.. f I �.:i - BAR 52918 TOWN OF ADDRESS OFLFo5 T; ma;VS S i 11 4 BARNSTABLE CITY,STATEE,ZIP CODE `0*ME►qM, MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER if� $ OFFENSE j, 1 ( f } NAN\:TARi.i:. eat) '"Q ,cn t9 Oki 1� Yt l�a 14 c11 a7CCv R ;CSY1'Q I f 1 f S4Qr j c a • MASS. V ion 1 6}q. �0 ,Eo • _`` �:yl,s pc�1r� t7{ r"sr W, M1�psr1't)dcf J�rirl+ �r,cfi2 x1) o b 1 Sfi iC C J C;AChetsVL>.i > TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION t 2.443LOCATION OF VIOLATION !/ W NOTICE OF (A.M.(V )ON oia""0- ,d9' .20S1 Mo,n 51 (A) ea(ya #j 41, • -I SIGNATUR€OF,ENFORCINGPERSON ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. VIOLATION JL;,, ,,, ,.,, ' id* cp OF TOWN I EREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X VLu ORDINANCE <EI Unable to obtain signature of offender. A13 1- Date mailed U/1 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS Spiv. LU OR Li,YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, w before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. • ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature DER NAME OFQFFI .r°tlr Q,.f4 $cg61), �,1.11;s BAR 52919 TOWN OF ADDRESS s;icy )OFFENDER rt,,, S e !i BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIP CQDE 10 FAME tr: , MVIMB REGISTRATION NUMBER • OFFENSE1 IIARNSTAel k:, • tt n 1 !! 1 r 1 tttt .�F,IA55. g, C.-hw,a 4110 „err{,,an ta ` l''nyi 14iGhwcxu I QC;onAl 14f�540rr+�. -IS r,rc'1 F� L,:i 6}q �0 ,,,ty } J�.yj [ � D MP+� (, N pole E 1 eft d 4-60-4 Old k f1afs 1 e ,f'h With Q pprzva 1 IF1!' cl� " tt 1 I J w TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION , OOJ LOCATION OF VIOLATION �' W NOTICE OF of, (A.M.i )ON ,4)-7 ,rrs' 420V C/rr% . rnsidige Q VIOLATION SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING,D BADGE NO. Cl)W tit trls"Jill-� G+"I v cm OF TOWN V n . THEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE El Unable to obtain signature of offender.' 1- d/l ���3 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS. $ /1 -J Date mailed w OR w YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION You mayelect to paythe above fine,either byappearing inperson between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q (1) eCPP 9 9C LU before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.P. .Box 2430, Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST ARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature' (� NAME OF O if, to aprN Bfc,r\Ar:A 1..I. 1 i5 BAR 292€ TOWN OF ADDRESS OFFENDER,0 ,10 10 SAC+ 1 BARNSTABLE CITY tSTATE,ZIP-CODE � \e. iyy 172k1.:C4 f THE O- 0A130 11 MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER ti OFF IISE ry / j i�!! ( A PIIAN\STAB..:' • ha r A{70 A;.) 4 Olci Inds ri•chway f'Segi4Aak I ns -errc 1.145.. (" . t- uw MASS. t6yq �� ✓ FD med- ..tt~ r p,Ie,s ere cie 0.3;441 10-4 Oki fri►t r94way apPrOVa I TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION ;,.kid„F LOCATION OF VIOLATION t i Z NOTICE OF a - (A.M.I„PM ON fo r ,T9 .S' OMrA $+ tL,J, safnb4tAdt, a SIGNATURE OF ENFORCING PERSON ENFORCING,DEPT, BADGE NO. w VIOLATION J., .,.,, t fcry, co o OF'TOWN V GV , ~ I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE In Unable to obtain signature o offender. rk� !/ THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ } }, _, Date mailed r w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a. DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w cn REGULATION 1 You may elect to pay the above fine,either bHyannis,appearing in person b or etween g8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q Hyannis,before: MA 02601,he ble I WITHIN TWENTY TW 367 Main ENTY-ONE(21)DAYS F THE DOATE OF THIS NOTICE. money order or postal ote to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a. B2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST ARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:2ID Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature FFENDER NAME 0i 0c+br �.'(N rCY'.A4. l l �'1 BAR 52V TOWN OF ADDRESS►RE OF OFFENDER ,,OS/ ty!..,, SA, BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE,ZIPS t`s\AA.1 oM 021,0 THE Ipk MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER , �tg& 9' OFFENSE �}�{p ^yj t /Gj�. NAN\�lABlk:.p j ryp, .yyn t§ �,,,. p f a..iQ l� ffG t 1 p 1_ i r f c MAb4� M /iJ Vfz'f'(t 1Ly r Ater I,'!'4.J rf. Y✓ f,1' t11�Lt f"f,,5'T !rC l f.rr' a- %Midi' j ( ty • + (.. !j g 1,a.,tk" 41 beat .S er$c.te l\ [ijt4 101,ii• tole M1t 111f,5 1"t!5Fi1 A dv Q PIpfolo l w •NOTICE OF TIME AND DATE OF'VIOL(A.M.1Y M)ON fp-5j "1ION 9°0�` LOCATION OF 4 SA* . orn�4sbk a SIGNATURE70F/!EN/!'r''FCS .,,,,,, , ENFORCINGpEPTr 1 BADGE NO. v) VIOLATION .f.4iit•1,-`A.�(�t e,�'` -- tfdFlit�g OF TOWN V '0 `" I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE IZI,Unable to obtain signature of offender. dC? I-- Date mailed /p/151D THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $/00 OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION 1 You mayelect topaythe above fine,either appearinginperson between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q () by 99 y P w before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430,• a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature 2 NAME OF OfF��r QN [,�C# rtf. c., Ci )11�. BAR 2' 2 TOWN OF ADDRESS OF OFFENDER . 2oS1 Mc:,A BARNSTABLE CITY,STATE.ZIP CODE r r&.k e' lilts, 024,Sb of rok, MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER ilk % OFFENSE • HAN\TAPI.f:. • Ft 1 i i{ A, w ;b39 mot CkNO r, IOC) s"'eC+;c.r. 4 Oki IC1444.5 I c titaar eQGfanal fits :'i4 r.JrS r;c� A 4 a q t pia ( o fForAn+` i4ro- 00ks r(4.4trA wA1plL-4- Old icbotcl 1't14,1tJcitt 42OP rev ai w NOTICE.OE TIME AND D 17,..E ,VIOLATION /0.4I1 "19. L2AoON1VIOri t� 9f /A. r04 ( it W C9 C? #i7 SIGNATURE OF EN 'ENFORCING PERSON �y ENFORCING DEPT. BADGE NO. cn VIOLATION _Liz,. OF TOWN fib f *+ o I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X ii ORDINANCE la Unable to obtain signature of offender. 443 1- cc tally/t1 THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS sld , -J Date mailed / w OR w YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, W before:The Bamstable Clerk,367 Main Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or b mailing a check,money order or postal note to Bamstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ Signature ,.- - r• /Y r--« - '/ + , ` i iNirt4 1 �+ 051 Main St. • , Bar h \,, •,,ili , _ * ,-,., ., - -:, ..‘ '''' 1 •lit •••,.• . , * —..-.. 3 4 :. . .. ., ,..i.„ ,...... _,....„„. •.., .,,.„ ... . , ... L• as rr ' iIf 1 .` / ' ... I , E", .,"-._ _., t . 174.- ii.,, • . ..... .4. ...,4• t. ,... . -, . ja . :1' .A 4 • ,„,,,,,-. , ,: , . ;:.. It \.% 1 ,r 1 _ _. , .. `� .y' • ` ---7 y� • ,. a +..�•� s:. ; s s�. � �_ r 'V� yi>' wf tJ.--i rs :� 04 "'.1,4:: i` nr!'l �' r.". h� i -,i'. a J i• � V. ♦ i. o r � /� -m la kw..yyi,..�.1• T 1'4'4;,*..• T. i ' - lig i. fali('' •c.v.., Tif%ar I �� remG . d I�► -i i ci- Town of Barnstable 0,114EToii Regulatory Services saxrrsrnst ey 1 i Thomas F.Geiler,Director N 1ArED6 9 Building Division ' Tom Perry,Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 July 16,2003 Re:2051 Main Street,W.Barnstable On June 26,2003 David Mattos and myself met with Victor and Brenda Cillis at their property. We had a long conversation in regard to the issues I brought up in a letter dated June 17,2003. The Cillis's were civil and agreed to comply with my requests. I found that they did not at that time have a illegal apartment and they expressed no desire to rent to anyone. They told us that they would remove the light poles and repair the stone wall. I also have received a copy of a Massachusetts Dept.of Food and Agriculture license to operate a riding school/stable under the name of Diamonds Edge. Brenda Tri also has a license to provide horse riding instructions. She showed us a informal farm plan. I requested a formal copy for our records. The Massachusetts Bureau of Animal health performed a stable inspection at my request and the findings are acceptable. As of today's date I have had no additional contact with the Cillis's . Copies of the licenses and the inspection report are attached. Sincerely,(*(4. 0 I on Silva Town of Barnstable Building Inspector Regulatory Services 200 Main Street Hyannis MA 02061 Phone:508 862-4025 Fax:508 790-6230 Y *_= The Commonwealth of Massachusetts =_ 1 -= BUREAU OF ANIMAL HEALTH =`=4i= 251 CAUSEWAY STREET, SUITE 500 _.-=_�``- BOSTON, MA 02114 .'o^M�Sye y`e,� STABLE INSPECTION REPORT Stable Name & Address r o,t, C IJ(;e Owner Name& Address 0.5 / f7 .)/ A .j / Veterinarian Name&Address , ` - /4 / „ YES NO Ex'lain a"no"answer under commen .. aim Are Buildingsand cl n- premises ean,sanitary and safe? Are Licenses and Liability information prominently posted? nom �m Is manure-rubbish properly handled; Is manure storage inaccessible to animals? _� Is a pest control program in effect? Are barn-paddock areas free of insects and rodents? - Is adequate shelter available? not/ Are stalls clean and adequate size? s Are water troughs-buckets and feed pails clean? IMP111111 Are floors,gutters and alleyways clean and free of litter? / 1111 Are paddocks free of glass, wire or debris which could cause injuries?/ Are paddocks graded to drain away from shelters; no pooled water or wastes? Min� Are turn-outs kept in compatible groups and not overcrowded? — Do animals confined to paddocks have adequate water and � shade. � Is water being offered as per rules and regulations? � Is fresh feed being offered each animal twice a day? Are horses feet properly shod/trimmed,cared for? Are horses properly groomed and without equipment sores? I- Is equipment clean and safe? MN Are horses in good condition and sound? IIM- Are records maintained for working horses in compliance with tth section 6? Number of horses on the premises: COMMENTS: r. Inspector's Signature Date of Inspection/ Approved Not Approved ' ! Reinspect / , : % ,,, Office Copy/White Barn Copy/Yellow Inspector's Copy/Pink • ---� r THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE *ni BUREAU OF ANIMAL HEALTH ,°` 251 CAUSEWAY ST., SUITE 500, BOSTON,MA 02114 LICENSE TO OPERATE A RIDING SCHOOL / STABLE Name DIAMONDS EDGE Date 4/1/2003 Address 2051 Main Street W. Barnstable, MA License No. 1033 Having paid a fee of Fifty Dollars ($50.00), and having agreed to comply with the rules and regulations, is hereby licensed in accordance with the General Laws, Chapter 128, Section 2B, to engage in the business of operating a Riding School and/or Stable where horses are kept for hire. THIS LICENSE EXPIRES ON MARCH 31, 2004 CHIEF-BUREAU OF ANIMAL HEALTH THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Department of Food and Agriculture Bureau of Animal Health Y. 251 Causeway Street, Suite 500 Boston, MA 02114-2151 Date: 4/1/2003 License No.: 3924 This is to certify the named bearer of this license has been qualified as a Horse Riding instructor, under Chapter 128, Section 2A. Brenda Tri Barnstable, MA Signature THIS LICENSE EXPIRES ON MARCH 31, 2004 Or unless sooner revo CHIEF,B REAU OF ANIMA) 41=eI Tu °FTHE Tpa Town of Barnstable ti9' :.. Regulatory r i Services ces BARNSTABLE, 1639. MAss. g, Thomas F.Geiler,Director �'',bbn o�A�� Building Division Tom Perry, Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 February 5, 2004 Jeffrey Lauzon Building Inspector Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services Building Division 200 Main St Hyannis,Ma 02061 Re: 2051 Main St,West Barnstable To Whom It May Concern: The following shall represent an overview of the events and circumstances resulting in the fines assessed to Victor and Brenda Cillis,2051 Main St,West Barnstable. 11-7-2001 Complaint received from concerned neighbor that light poles were being erected 11-21-2001 Letter written advising Victor and Brends Cillis of zoning violations concerning light poles 06-17-2003 Letter written again advising Victor and Brenda Cillis to obtain the proper permit for the light poles or dismantle them immediately 06-27-03 Wiring permit obtained for an unapproved gazebo 07-16-03 Memo written describing a meeting had between Victor and Brenda Cillis and David Mattos and Jason Silva.Memo explains how the Cillis's were civil and agreed to remove the light poles 07-29-03 Letter written giving Victor and Brenda Cillis until August 8,2003 to resolve violations or be subject to daily fines in the amount of$100.00 for each day of non-compliance 9-22-03 Daily inspections of site begin.Light poles are still up 10-17-03 Light poles have remained and additionally a gazebo has been constructed also without approval 11-14-04 Light poles still up as is gazebo(still no permits for either). Daily inspections conducted until this date and fines assessed. 02-05-04 As of today issue is still unresolved. Light poles and gazebo still erected. Sincerely: f f•-y . Lauzon Building Inspector c104 r Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services A ,° Thomas F.Geiler,Director its Building Division M 6 Tom Perry,Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 July 29,2003 Dr.&Mrs.Victor Cillis 2051 Main St. W.Barnstable,MA 02668 Dear Dr. &Mrs.Cillis: This is a follow-up to the letter sent to you from this office dated June 17,2003. In that letter you were asked to remove the light poles and rebuild the stone wall at the rear of your property. To date this office has seen no activity in regards to rectifying these matters. Action must be taken by August 8,2003 to resolve these issues. If no action has been taken by this time we will commence with daily fines in the amount of$100.00. Each issue shall be subject to individual fines and each day will be a separate offense. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation. Sincerely, 2eig4 -- Tom Perry Building Commissioner TP/AW CERTIFIED MAIL 7002 1000 0005 0781 8027 AHEN Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services • BARNSrABLE MeEV Thomas F. Geiler,Director s69�iOrED 200 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 www.town.barnstable.ma.us Telephone: 508-862-4672 Fax: 508-778-2412 FAX TRANSMITTAL DATE: January 19, 2005 TIME: 4:15 PM TO: David Houghton FAX#: 508-862-4770 FROM: Lois Lomba @ 508-862-4672 Number of pages (including cover sheet): 4 COMMENTS: Re: Brenda & Victor Tri-Cillis q/consumer/lois/caforms/fax l.doc Court Dates : 01-20-2005 Thru 01-20-2005 01-19-2005 Date Docket No Offender Bar# Offense Issued By Disposition VioDisp 01-20-05 9:00 AM C 0325 CR 002331 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 66279 Failure to properly cover or Mckean,Thomas Pretrial hearing Cleared dispose of manure;many flies 9:00 AM C 0424 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67650 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 66533 Observed accumulating Stanton,David Pretrial hearing Cleared manure/waste matter 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52917 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52916 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52915 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52914 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52913 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52923 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52921 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67637 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67638 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67639 Light poles erected without on,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52924 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52925 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67636 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52922 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52920 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52919 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval Page 1 of 3 Court Dates : 01-20-2005 Thru 01-20-2005 01-19-2005 Date Docket No Offender Bar# Offense Issued By Disposition VioDisp 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52918 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67626 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67647 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67648 Light poles erected with Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval. 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67649 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King Highway approval. 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67640 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67646 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon ffrey_ Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001769 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 65339 Failure to properly cover manure Stanton,David Pretrial hearing Cleared 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67668 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52907 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52909 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52908 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52910 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52911 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67665 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey PTH Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67667 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67669 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67661 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,J�� Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67662 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67663 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval Page 2 of 3 Court Dates : 01=20-2005 Thru 01-20-2005 01-19-2005 Date Docket No Offender Bar# Offense Issued By Disposition VioDisp 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67664 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67652 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Kings Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67653 Light poles erected without OldLaugs292j.effrty Pretrial hearing Cleared Kings Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67654 Light poles erected without Old Lat,521Lidirgx Pretrial hearing Cleared Kings Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67655 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Kings Highway approval �- 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67666 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001771 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 66554 Non-composted manure on slope Miorandi,Donna Pretrial hearing Cleared of bank 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001772 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 66537 Accumulation of manure/waste Stanton,David Pretrial hearing Cleared / matter 9:0 'M C 0425 CR 00 La ue Paul 682����ire on Sandy c ORV Beach Pai at tne_o e ban 00 A C 0425 CR 00404 Miranda Mika 50955 i-noise _ _�'` Twome m /C1 ed i Page 3 of 3 i Court Dates : 01-20-2005 Thru 01-20-2005 01-19-2005 Date Docket No Offender Bar# Offense Issued By Disposition VioDisp 01-20-05 9:00 AM C 0325 CR 002331 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 66279 Failure to properly cover or Mckean,Thomas Pretrial hearing Cleared dispose of manure;many flies 9:00 AM C 0424 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67650 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM 0425 CR 001767 ri Cillis Brenda&Victor 66533 Observed accumulating Stanton,David Pretrial hearing Cleared manure/waste matter 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52917 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52916 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52915 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52914 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52913 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001767 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52923 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52921 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67637 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67638 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67639 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52924 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52925 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67636 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52922 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52920 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52919 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval Page 1 of 3 Court Dates : 01-20-2005 Thru 01-20-2005 01-19-2005 Date Docket No Offender Bar# Offense Issued By Disposition VioDisp 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52918 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67626 Light poles erected w/o Old King's Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67647 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67648 Light poles erected with Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval. 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67649 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King Highway approval. 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67640 Light poles erected without Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001768 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67646 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval - 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001769 Cillis Brenda&Victor 65339 Failure to properly cover manure Stanton,David Pretrial hearing Cleared 9:00 AM C 0425 CR Of 0 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67668 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52907 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52909 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52908 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52910 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 52911 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67665 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey PTH Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67667 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67669 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67661 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67662 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval :r 9:00 AM C 0425 CR 001770 Tri Cillis Brenda&Victor 67663 Light poles erected without Old Lauzon,Jeffrey Pretrial hearing Cleared King's Highway approval Page 2 of 3 co THE T Town of Barnstable �\O Regulatory Services a'\MAASSS. • Thomas F.Geiler,Director o;p/10� Building Division Peter F DiMatteo, Building Commissioner 367 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 Notice of Building code Violation and Order to Cease, Desist and Abate: Mr./Ms CILLIS and name full address all persons having notice of this order. As owner/occupant of the premises/structure located at 2051 MAIN STREET,WEST BARNSTABLE Assessor's Map 216 Parcel 076 BOO WOO, you are hereby notified that you are in violation of the Massachusetts State building code 780 CMR Article(s) 110 ,Section(s) 110.1 ,and are ORDERED this date to: 1. CEASE AND DESIST IMMEDIATELY,all functions connected with this violation on or at the above mentioned premises. SUMMARY OF VIOLATION: 780 CMR Article 110 Section 110.1 BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED (type in text of this section) 2. COMMENCE immediately,action to abate this violation. SUMMARY OF ACTION TO ABATE: STOP IMMEDIATELY—RECEIVE OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL ZONING BOARD detail action to be taken APPROVAL FOR STRUCTURES OVER 30' BUILDING PERMIT REQUIRED FOR POLES And,if aggrieved by this notice and order,to show cause as to why you should not be required to do so,by filing an appeal with the State Building Code Appeals Board(as specified in Article 1,Section 122 of 780 CMR State Building Code)within forty-five(45)days after the service of this notice. By order, cL—r,(2„,„_ Local Inspector enclosures(enclose copies of sections of code cited,permit application, etc.) Certified Mail# R.R.R. • Q/FORMS/violatel Commonwealth of Massachusetts County of Barnstable The Superior Court CIVIL DOCKET# BACV2004-00084 Brenda M. Tri, Victor Cillis MD, Leigh-Anne Souza vs. Barnstable Board of Health, Town of Barnstable Building Commissioner A TRUE COPY ATTEST heod SUMMONS AND ORDER OF NOTICE?r To the above-named: DEPUTY SHERIFF You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon Anthony Alva, Esquire, plaintiffs attorney, whose address is 3291 Main Street PO Box 730Barnstable, MA 02630 , an answer to the complaint which is herewith served upon you. This must be done within 20 days after service of this summons upon you, exclusive of the day of service. If you fail to do so, Judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in the complaint. You are also required to file your answer to the complaint in the office of the Clerk of this Court at Barnstable either before service upon plaintiffs attorney or within a reasonable time thereafter. Unless otherwise provided by Rule 13(a), your answer must state as a counterclaim any claim which you may have against the plaintiff which arises out of the transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the plaintiffs claim or you will thereafter be barred from making such claim in any other action. WE ALSO NOTIFY YOU that application has been made in said action, as appears in the complaint, for a preliminary injunction and that a hearing upon such application will be held at the court house at said Barnstable County Superior Court, in. Barnstable on 02/24/2004, at 2:00 PM, at which time you may appear and show cause why such application should not be granted. Witness, Suzanne V. DelVecchio, Esquire, Chief Justice he Superior Court, at Barnstable, Massachusetts this 17th day of Fe uary, 2004. e(/,/ Clerk-Magistrate (AFFIX RETURN OF SERVICE ON BACK OF SUMMONS) cvcsumornot_2.wpd 27201 hrgord kellmary Anthony Alva: . Attorney at Law 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 Phone (508) 362-8342, Fax (508) 362-7770 February 17, 2004 BARNSTABLE SUPERIOR COURT ATTN: Clerk of Courts, Mr. Scott Nickerson P.O. Box 425 Barnstable, MA 02630 Re: Docketing of Complaint and ex-parte MOTION FOR A SHORT ORDER OF NOTICE - Tri v. Town of Barnstable Board of Health, Building Inspector, Et.Al. Dear Mr. Nickerson: Kindly docket the attached complaint and docket the attached ex- parte motion for a short order of notice for the next available civil session today. I have contacted Barnstable's Town Counsel, David Houghton, Esq. , to notify him of this filing, and faxed him a copy of the complaint and motion. He has notified me that he cannot be present to appear for the town today and that he is not waiving the town's right to appear. Sincerely, ` • Al -f Attac -nt cc: Atty. Frank DiLuna, Murtha Cullina LLP David Houghton, Esq. , Town Counsel, Town of Barnstable COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS' . Barnstable, SS Barnstable. Superior Court Civil Docket BACV -2004- . BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) VICTOR CILLIS ) LEIGH-ANNE SOUZA ) PLAINTIFFS ) v. ) . BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY ) ITS MEMBERS, ) WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN ) i SUMNER KAUFFMAN ) SUSAN G. RASK ) BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) DEFENDANTS ) EX-PARTE MOTION FOR SHORT ORDER OF NOTICE ON PLAINTIFFS' COMPLAINT FOR STAY AND/ OR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AND FOR HEARING UNDER G.L.c.39, § 23B NOW COME THE PLAINTIFFS AND MOVE THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT ISSUE A SHORT ORDER OF NOTICE FOR A HEARING ON THE FOLLOWING: 1. On Count I - Only on the issue of a stay of enforcement/ preliminary injunction to prevent the Barnstable Board of Health from forcing removal of the horses now stabled at plaintiff Brenda M. Tri's business, the Diamond Edge Farm, before either a full hearing or trial on the merits can A occur. The relevant Board of Health Order is. dated January 30, 2004 . 2. On Count II - In accordance with G.L.c. 39, § 23B, the Open Meeting Law, that on this date the Court issue a summons to . conduct a hearing within ten days, on the Board of Health's failure to comply with the Open Meeting Law'; and 'The relevant portion of G.L.c.39, § 23.B, reads: "Upon proof of failure by any governmental body or by any member or officer thereof to carry out any of the provision for public notice or meetings, for holding open meetings, or for maintaining public records thereof, any justice of the supreme judicial court or the superior court * * * shall issue an appropriate order requiring 1 3. On Counts III to X of the complaint - In accordance with G.L.c. 223, § 2 (b) , on the issue of transferring currently pending non-criminal matters and one criminal matter from Barnstable's First District Court to this Court. Proceedings on all such complaints have been stayed in the District Court to February 26, 2004, pending this Superior Court Action. At full hearing, plaintiffs will argue this court should retain jurisdiction of those matters [ under G.L.c. 231A ] because each of the pending non-criminal matters and single criminal matter concern the same casual factual nexus as this underlying complaint. AN AFFIDAVIT BY THE PLAINTIFF, BRENDA M. TRI, IS ATTACHED TO THE COMPLAINT AND INCORPORATED HEREIN AND HERETO IN ITS ENTIRETY IN SUPPORT OF THIS MOTION. RESPECT„EULLY-SUBMUTED PLAINNTIFF BY HER ATTORNEY ony A 3858 Attorney a law. 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 (508) 362-8342 Date: Qj LPG I such governmental body * * * to carry out such provisions at future meetings. Such order may be sought by complaint of three or more registered voters in which the city or town is located. The order of notice on the complaint shall be returnable no later than ten days after the. filing thereof and the complaint shall be heard and determined on the return day or on such day thereafter as the court shall fix, having regard to the speediest possible determination of the cause consistent with the rights of the parties; * * *- 2 , t - COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS - Barnstable, SS Barnstable Superior. Court Civil Docket BACV 2004- BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) VICTOR CILLIS ) LEIGH-ANNE SOUZA ) PLAINTIFFS ) v. ) BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY ) ITS MEMBERS, ) 1 WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN ) SUMNER KAUFFMAN ). 1 SUSAN G. RASK ) BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) . BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) DEFENDANTS ) 1 MOTION TO TRANSFER MATTERS FROM DISTRICT COURT DOCKET NOW COME THE PLAINTIFFS AND MOVE THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: 3 i Transfer all currently pending non-criminal matters and one criminal matter from Barnstable's First District Court to this Court as outlined on Counts III to X of the complaint, in accordance with G.L.c. 223, § 2(b) . Proceedings on all such a Distarict Court complaints have been stayed in the District Court to February 26, 2004, pending this Superior Court Action. Such complaints, by docket/file/ reference number are listed in detail in each of Counts III through Xof this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto by reference in their entirety into this motion. This court should retain jurisdiction of those matters [ under G.L.c. 231A and in accordance with G.L.c. 223, § 2(b) ] because each of the pending non-criminal matters and single criminal 1 matter concern the same casual factual nexus as this underlying complaint. A proposed order is attached. AN AFFIDAVIT BY THE PLAINTIFF, BRENDA M. TRI, IS ATTACHED TO THE COMPLAINT AND INCORPORATED HEREIN AND HERETO IN ITS ENTIRETY IN SUPPORT OF THIS MOTION. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED PLAIN BER ATTORNEY Anthon A 633858 torney at Law 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 (508) 362-8342 Date: g/t -V fer } { 2. a. COMMONWEALTH OF- MASSACHUSETTS - Barnstable, SS Barnstable Superior Court Civil Docket BACV 2004- BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) VICTOR CILLIS ) LEIGH-ANNE SOUZA ) PLAINTIFFS ) v. ) BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY ) ITS MEMBERS, ) WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN ) SUMNER KAUFFMAN V ) . SUSAN G. RASK ) ) BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) DEFENDANTS ) S ORDER In accordance with G.L.c. 223 , § 2(b) , the following non-criminal citations by the Town of Barnstable Board of Health and/or Town of Barnstable Building Department vs . Ms. Brenda M. Tri, their related docket entries, and the below listed criminal docket, are all ordered transferred from Barnstable's First District Court for hearing, deposition and trial in this Court: 1) BAR 52913 to 52917 Docket 03 25 AC 005322 2) BAR 52918 to 52925, BAR 67626, and BAR 67636 to 67650 - Docket 03 25 AC 005513 3) BAR 66279 - Docket 0325 CR 002331 4) BAR 66533 - Docket 03 25 AC 005315 5) BAR 66537 - Docket 0325 AC 005719 6) BAR 65339 - Docket 0325 AC 00357.4 7) BAR 66554 - Docket 0325 AC 004268 8) BAR 67661 to 67669 - Docket 03 25 AC 006147 9) BAR 67651 to 67655 - Docket 03 25 AC 005718 SO ORDERED: JUSTICE ., DATE: . C11/ILACTIO,N`%„ DOCKET'NO:(S) 'Trial=Cou.rt of Massachusetts �. Superior Court Department C'OVER'.SHEE:T. _,. County:Rarnstahl PLAINTIFF(S) DEFENDANT(S) Brenda M. Tri. Victor Cillis,Leigh— Barnstable, Town. of, Board of Health n�Srsuza and R 1i 1ding Commi ssioner, et.al. ATTORNEY,FIRM NAME,ADDRESS AND TELEPHONE ATTORNEY (if known) Anthony Alva, Esq. ,Box 730 , Robert Smith, Esq. Barnstable, MA 02630 Board of Bar Overseers number: -412 S R Origin code and track designation Place an x in one box only: ❑ 4. F04 District Court Appeal c.231, s. 97 &104 (After 1. F01 Original Complaint trial) (X) 2. F02 Removal to Sup.Ct. C.231,s.104 ❑ 5. F05 Reactivated after rescript; relief from (Before trial) (F) judgment/Order (Mass.R.Civ.P. 60) (X) ❑ 3. F03 Retransfer to Sup.Ct. C.231,s.102C (X) ❑ 6. E10 Summary Process Appeal (X) TYPE OF ACTION AND TRACK DESIGNATION (See reverse side) CODE NO. TYPE OF ACTION(specify) TRACK IS THIS A JURY CASE? D13 Declaratory Judgment X) (X )Yes ( ) No The following is a full, itemized and detailed statement of the facts on which plaintiff relies to determine money damages. For this form, disregard double or treble damage claims; indicate single damages only; TORT CLAIMS (Attach additional sheets as necessary) A. Documented medical expenses to date: 1. Total hospital expenses $ 2. Total Doctor expenses $ 3. Total chiropractic expenses $ 4. Total physical therapy expenses $ 5. Total other expenses (describe) $ Subtotal $ B. Documented lost wages and compensation to date $ C. Documented property damages to date . $ D. Reasonably anticipated future medical and hospital expenses . . . .. E. Reasonably anticipated lost wages $ . . F. Other documented items of damages (describe) . $ G. Brief description of plaintiff's injury, including nature and extent of injury (describe) The Board of Health' s wrongful effort to force the plaintiff to remove all of the horses from her boarding facility riding school, and stabling facility, all agricultural $ activity under the law. TOTAL $ • CONTRACT CLAIMS (Attach additional sheets as necessary) Provide a detailed description of claim(s): TOTAL $. PLEASE IDENTIFY, BY CASE NUMBER, NAME AND COUNTY, ANY RELATED ACTION PENDING IN THE SUPERIOR COURT DEPARTMENT "I hereby certify that I have complied with the rrements of Rule 5 Supreme Judicial Court Uniform Rules on Dispute Resolution (SJC Rule 1:18) req ' mg that I provide my cli s t information about court-connected dispute resolution services and discuss 'tis them the advantages an is n ges of the various methods." • Signature of Attorney of Reco DATE: ej (7-( AOTC-6 mtc005-11/99 A.O.S.C.1-2000 Commonwealth of Massachusetts County of Barnstable The Superior Court CIVIL DOCKET# BACV2004-00084-A RE: Tri et al v Barnstable Board of Health et al TO:Anthony Alva, Esquire 3291 Main Street PO Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 TRACKING ORDER -A TRACK You are hereby notified that this case is on the average (A) track as per Superior Court Standing Order 1-88. The order requires that the various stages of litigation described below must be completed not later than the deadlines indicated. STAGES OF LITIGATION DEADLINE Service of process made and return filed with the Court 05/17/2004 Response to the complaint filed (also see MRCP 12) 07/16/2004 All motions under MRCP 12, 19, and 20 filed 07/16/2004 All motions under MRCP 15 filed 05/12/2005 All discovery requests and depositions completed 04/07/2006 All motions under MRCP 56 served and heard 06/06/2006 Final pre-trial conference held and firm trial date set 10/04/2006 Case disposed 02/16/2007 The final pre-trial deadline is not the scheduled date of the conference. You will be notified of that date at a later time. Counsel for plaintiff must serve this tracking order on defendant before the deadline for filing return of service. This case is assigned to session A sitting in Civil A, Barnstable Superior Court. Dated: 02/17/2004 Scott W. Nickerson Clerk of the Courts BY: Nancy N. Weir Location: Civil A Assistant Clerk Telephone: (508) 375-6684 Disabled individuals who need handicap accommodations should contact the Administrative Office of the Superior Court at(617)788-8130 Check website for status of case: http://ma-trialcourts.org/tcic cvdtraca_2.wpd 373980 inidoc0l kellmary (TO PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY: PLEASE CIRCLE TYPE OF ACTION INVOLVED: CONTRACT TORT MOTOR VEHICLE TORT EQUITABLE RELIEF OTHER) fl nitutuntftrtait # -;1; azicaritustifiv BARNSTABLE,ss. SUPERIOR COURT No. Brenda M. Tri ,dba Diamond Edge Farm Victor Ciing, Leigh—Anne Souza Plaintiffs VS. Board of Health of the Town of Barnstable, by its members, Wayne Miller Sumner Kauffman Susan G. Rask Defendants and Building Commissioner of the Town of Barnstable Thomas Perry, Defendant- 4.1 SUMMONS To the above-named defendant : You are hereby summoned and required to serve upon.Anthony plaintiff's attorney, whose address is 3.2.9.1.....Main....St....., P...O......Hax....7.3.0..,.....Harnstable..,.MA 0.2.6..30 , an answer to the complaint which is herewith served upon you, within 20 days after service of this summons upon you, exclusive of the day of service. If you fail to do so,judgment by default will be taken against you for the relief demanded in the complaint. You are also required to file your answer to the complaint in the office of the Clerk of this court at Barnstable either before service upon plaintiff's attorney or within a reasonable time thereafter. Unless otherwise provided by Rule 13(a), your answer must state as a counterclaim any claim which you may have against the plaintiff which arises out of the transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the plaintiff's claim or you will thereafter be barred from making such claim in any other action. Witness, SUZANNE V.DEL VECCHIO Esquire, at Barnstable,the 17th day of February ,in the year of our Lord two thousand and f our . hii44 Clerk NOTE: When more than one defendant is involved,the names of all defendants shall appear in the caption.If a separate summons is issued for each defendant,each should be addressed to the particular defendant. NOTICE TO DEFENDANT You need not appear personally in:court to answer..the complaint but if you claim to have a-defense, either you or your attorney must serve a copy of your written answer within 20 days as specified herein and also file the original in the Clerk's office. COMMONWEALTH -OF MASSACHUSETTS` _ Barnstable, SS _ Barnstable Superior Court Civil Docket BACV 2004- BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) VICTOR CILLIS ) LEIGH-ANNE SOUZA ) PLAINTIFFS ) ) Complaint Under v. ) G.L.c 231A,G.L.c.128A,§1A G.L.c.111,§§ 125A,155, 157, G.L.c.40A, § 3, BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) G.L.c.39, § 23B, BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY ) & ITS MEMBERS, ) For Stay of Enforcement WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN .) or Preliminary Injunction SUMNER KAUFFMAN ) & SUSAN G. RASK ) Demand for Jury ) Trial on all Issues BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) so Triable BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) DEFENDANTS ) Statement of the Case This is a complaint for relief from a "Notice of Revocation of Stable License" dated January 30, 2004, by the Barnstable Board of Health, that requires Ms. Brenda M. Tri to remove all horses from the "Diamond Edge Farm," her place of business. Diamond Edge Farm is a horse boarding facility and riding school which Ms. Tri has operated at her seven-point-one acre working farm in West Barnstable since 1998. Diamond Edge Farm conducts agricultural activity exempt from unreasonable regulation, and in this action Ms. Tri will show that the Board of Health's regulations are unlawful and unreasonable, and that the Board of Health has acted in a wanton and capricious manner. Ms. Tri is seeking a Declaratory Judgment that the Board of Health's revocation of her town stablelicense, and its demand that she remove all horses from her property, are unlawfulbecause both exceed the statutory and regulatory authority granted to the . Board of Health under G.L.c.40A §' 3, G.L.c.128A §lA, G.L.c.111 §§ 1 155, 155, and 157 , and other such. relief -atlaw.., - This is also an action for -a stay of enforcement or preliminary .. . injunction to prevent the Board of. Health from removing all_of the horses stabled at the plaintiff's business, which would put her out of business, and, in the alternative, if the court adjudges the board had authority to act, to require that it reopen its public hearing under G.L.c.39, § 23B, so that the plaintiff and others may have an opportunity to be present and to submit evidence before the board during a lawfully convened meeting. On the same grounds, in this action, the plaintiff also seeks declaratory judgment that the Town of Barnstable by its Building Department and Commissioner exceeded its statutory authority in issuing non criminal citations for the placement of light poles on the plaintiff's property, an alleged violation of building code. Plaintiffs, Dr. Victor Cillis, and Leigh-Anne Souza are taxpayers of the town of Barnstable, who, along with Ms. Tri, challenge the Board of Health's compliance with. the Open Meeting Law, G.L.c. 39, § 23B. The Parties 1. The plaintiff, Ms . Brenda M. Tri, a registered voter, resides at 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable, Massachusetts 02668. She does business as Diamond Edge Farm, where at the .7.1 acre site, she boards and/or stables at any one time about fourteen horses, employs stable hands, and where she conducts horse riding lessons, primarily for children. - 2. The plaintiff, Dr. Victor Cillis, a registered voter, _resides at 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable, Massachusetts 02668, and is the spouse of plaintiff Brenda M. Tri. 3. The plaintiff, Leigh-Anne Souza, a registered voter, resides of 3715 Falmouth Road, Marstons Mills, MA 02648. k 4. The defendants are the Barnstable Board of Health, 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601, and its members, chairman Wayne Miller 2231 Meetinghouse Way, West Barnstable, MA, and members Sumner Kaufmann, Old Post Road, Cotuit, MA, and Susan G. Rask, unlisted address. 5. The defendant Building Commissioner, Thomas Perry, oversees the Town of Barnstable's building department located at 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601. Facts Complaint Against the Board of Health 2 6. Since- 1998°,- Ms. Tri has obtained a license to operate the Diamond Edge riding school/ stable (hereinafter "Diamond Edge") , formerly "Stepping Stone Riding School," from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Food and Agriculture Bureau of Animal Health. (Hereinafter the "state license". ) Diamond Edge is an equine farm, training facility,. boarding and stabling facility. 7. The current operating license, number 1033, from the Commonwealth was issued on April 1, 2003, and expires on March 31, 2004. A copy of the license is attached to this complaint and marked as "Exhibit 1", and is incorporated herein and hereto in its entirety. Ms. Tri is also licensed by the commonwealth as an riding instructor, number 3924. 8. Such state licenses are granted conditioned on Diamond Edge's • passage of inspection by agriculture department inspectors. Diamond Edge has regularly been inspected by the Commonwealth Department of Agriculture Bureau of Animal Health, and was last inspected on June 20, 2003, and July 24, 2003. 9. Diamond Edge passed each such inspection. See copies of the inspection reports attached to this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto in their entirety. The June 20, 2003 inspection is marked as "Exhibit 2". The July 24, 2003 inspection is marked as "Exhibit 3". 10. On or about March 22, 2001, the Board of Health directed that Ms. Tri construct two compost bins for the composting of manure outside the stable at Diamond Edge. 11 On June 26, 2003, the Board of Health by an authorized health agent, issued a non-criminal citation to Brenda M. Tri, dba Diamond Edge Farm, alleging violation of "Part X, Stable Regulation," for "failure to properly cover manure" and which demanded payment of- $40.00. See the "NOTICE OF VIOLATION OF TOWN ORDINANCE OR REGULATION, " (hereinafter the "notice") number BAR 65339, marked as "Exhibit 4" attached to this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto in its entirety. 12. The June 26, 2003, notice of violation cited as its authority an April 1, 1972, Town of Barnstable Board of Health regulation entitled "PART X: STABLE REGULATION", (hereinafter the "town regulation") which was revised on or about July 15, 1993. Today, the town regulation contains fifteen paragraphs purporting to govern stable operations. See the town regulation, marked as "Exhibit 5", the contents of which are incorporated herein and hereto in their entirety. 13. On July 1, 2003, the Town of Barnstable, Board of Health, by its chairman, Susan G. Rask, issued Diamond Edge a stable 3 license, which expires .on June 30, 2004-.. (Hereinafter the: . . "town license". See the town license, marked as "Exhibit 6". attached to this. complaint and incorporate herein_ andhereto _ . in its entirety. • 14. This June 26, 2003, notice, was one of several issued by town health agents, that year, including citations numbered: • (a) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a $50.00 fine for purported violation of town regulation Part X, attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit 7; (b) BAR 66554, dated August 6, 2003, citing- a .$100.00 fine for purported violation of the town regulation, Part X(7) , attached to this -complaint and marked as Exhibit - 8. (c) BAR 66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine for purported violation of the town regulation, Part X(7) , attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit 9; (d) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a $100.00 • fine for purported violation of the town regulation, Part X(7) , attached to this complaint and marked as Exhibit 10; 15. Citing Part X(7) of the regulation as authority, on July 29, 2003, Health Agent Thomas A. McKean issued a letter, an "ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST"., to Ms. Tri, focusing on • accumulating horse manure, alleged spreading of sandstone and/or dust, stated that failure to comply with the "order" could result in a "* * * $100.00 non-criminal ticket citation," and with each- day's "failure to comply" constituting a separate violation. See a copy of the July 29 letter, marked as Exhibit 11,• attached to this complaint and- incorporated herein and hereto by reference. 16. Pro se, Ms. Tri seasonably challenged and appealed each such citation issued by agents of the Barnstable Board of Health and the July 29, 2003 "ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST" by Mr. McKean. 17 . As a result of Ms. Tri's appeals, as they were issued, all of the above referenced Board of Health citations were filed by the Town of Barnstable Board of Health in Barnstable's First • District Court for a determination of probable cause, and/or for a finding of responsible at a magistrates hearing,- and on February 5, 2004, a hearing on all alleged violations were continued by the magistrate pending resolution of this complaint in Superior Court. 18. On January 8, 2004, the Board of Health conducted a hearing • at which time its members- took evidence from its health • • inspector, members of the public, Ms . Tri and her counsel, referencing the above cited purported violations and complaints from the public. Despite documents showing that manure was being removed from Diamond Edge Farm on an almost weekly basis, on that date board members voted to accept proposed findings of fact submitted by the town health inspector, and expressed an intent to shut down the Diamond Edge Farm. (See the document marked as "Exhibit 12","Proposed Findings" attached to this complaint and incorporated herein and hereto in its entirety. ) . 19. After discovering the January 8, 2004 meeting had not been posted or held in accordance with the open meeting law, the Board of Health notified Ms. Tri by letter on January 14, 2004, that another meeting would be convened on January 20, 2004 . That notice is attached to this complaint, marked as "Exhibit 13", and incorporated herein and hereto. 20. Ms. Tri by her counsel requested in writing that the January 20, 2004 meeting be continued because on advice of her physician should could not be present. That letter is attached to this complaint, marked as "Exhibit 14", and incorporated herein and hereto. . 21. At the January 20, 2004, meeting, the applicant, Ms. Brenda M. Tri, on advice of her physician, in fact could not be present, and the board members were so advised at the beginning of the meeting by Ms. Tri's counsel. 22. At that meeting board members refused to continue the meeting so Ms. Tri could be present, refused to make at least one site visit so they could view conditions first hand, did not accept additional testimony, reread the January 8, 2004, proposed findings of fact, then voted to accept said findings. 23. Written notification of the Board of Health revocation which included an additional finding and demand for removal of the 3 horses no later than February 17, 2004, was made public in writing by board chairman Wayne Miller on or about January 30, 2004, when notice was given in accordance with 105 CMR 400.400 to Ms. Tri on February 3, 2004. A copy of the notification marked as "Exhibit 15" is attached to this complaint, and is incorporated herein and hereto. COUNT I Stay of Enforcement and/or Preliminary Injunction . 24. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein 5 f and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 25. The riding school and boarding facilities at Diamond Edge Farm are the plaintiff's sole source of employment. Her self employment has also had a crucial therapeutic and emotional benefit to her as she has been struggling with an otherwise debilitating long term illness. 26. If the plaintiff is forced to remove the horses from Diamond Edge Farm, then she will immediately be put out of business and potentially placed in breach of contract with clients, potentially exposing her to an assortment of claims. 27. Throughout the course of the plaintiff's interactions with the defendant Board of Health, it has refused to consider reasonable alternatives to its current order to completely remove all horses. 28. Such wanton, capricious, and draconian measures by the board, which would immediately shut down the plaintiff's business, would constitute irreparable harm to the plaintiff. Tri-Nel Management, et.al. v. Board of Health of Barnstable, 433 Mass.. 217 (2001) . 29. The plaintiff should prevail in her complaint because the facts and law support her position 30. Public policy supports the plaintiff 's position. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Issue a stay of enforcement prohibiting the Barnstable Board of Health from executing its January 30, 2004, Notice of Revocation of Stable License demanding removal of the horses at the Diamond Edge Farm because even if- the defendant suffers any harm as a result of the granting of a stay, the plaintiff will suffer far greater harm if the stay is not granted; (b) In accordance with M.R.C.P. 65, and Superior Court Rule 9A(c) (3) , schedule a hearing be held after issuance of a stay of enforcement on a Preliminary Injunction; (c) Waive any payment_ by the plaintiff of any security or bond under M.R.C.P. 65(c) because, among other reasons, in this type of case the defendants cannot reasonably show any costs or damages that may incurred or 6 suffered by being: enjoined or restrained; (d) In the alternative, if the court declines to issue a stay of enforcement, in accordance with M.R.C.P. 65, and Superior Court Rule 9A(c) (3) , schedule a hearing be held for a Preliminary Injunction; (e) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT II Violation of Open Meeting Law Stay of Enforcement and/or Preliminary Injunction G.L.c.. 39, § 23B 31. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs.. 32. On January 14, after notifying the plaintiff that she must request a continuance of the January 20, 2004' Board of Health meeting no later than fifty two hours prior to the meeting . (see Exhibit 13) the plaintiff did request a continuance in writing (see Exhibit 14) . 33. The grounds for the request was the plaintiff's medical condition. She faced surgery and on her physician's advise she was urged to avoid stress that could worsen her condition. 34. Regardless of the requests, on January 20, 2004, the Board of Health convened on January 20, 2004, at about 7 p.m. , and after rejecting an additional request for a continuance to give the plaintiff time to recover and respond to any additional evidence or statements by members of the board, it proceeded to: a) refuse to accept any new testimony; b) incorporate all evidence taken at its January 8, 2004 meeting that was held (by its own admission) not in accordance with the open meeting law, and; c) re-entered into the record their previously approved "proposed" findings of fact and voted to revoke the plaintiffs stable license. 35. The actual decision of the board, giving the plaintiff until February 17, 2004, to remove all horses from the farm and . revoking her license., was made public by service to the plaintiff in accordance with 105 CMR 400.400 by deputy sheriff on February 3, 2004. (See Exhibit 15. ) 36. At the January 20, 2004 meeting, Dr. Cillis and Ms. Barrett 7- were not allowed to speak by members of the board of health. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Conduct a hearing on this issue within ten days in accordance with the statute, G.L.c. 39, 5 23B, at which time the following prayers for relief may be addressed. (b) Find that the defendant Barnstable Board of Health's refusal to take any evidence on January 20, 2004 meeting, aside from a prepared statement by its own agents, constituted a violation of the open meeting law since the facts contained in the statements were not discussed during a lawfully convened publicmeeting of the Board of Health;. (c) Find that the defendant Barnstable Board of Health's refusal to continue the January 20, 2004, meeting so the plaintiff could be present, constituted a violation of the open meeting law since the plaintiff was not given due process or a fair opportunity to be present or to provide evidence or comment to the board on its proposed actions and findings during a lawfully convened public . meeting of the Board of Health; (d) Find that the defendant Barnstable Board of Health's refusal to take any evidence on January 20, 2004 meeting, from any source in support of the plaintiff constituted a violation of the open meeting law since the no such facts were, or have ever been, presented during a lawfully convened public meeting of the Board of Health; (e) Find for each or any of the above stated reasons, the Board of Health's Notice of Revocation of Stable License is the result of an unlawful meeting, and that it therefore is unenforceable, or in the alternative: 't (i) If the court finds the Board has authority, order that such lawful meeting thereby be convened, and that the Board of Health members make a site visit to the farm, or, (ii) If the court finds the Board has authority, order that at all such future meetings the Board of Health may only take evidence and consider evidence submitted during -a lawfully convened meeting,and that the Board of Health members make a site visit to the farm. • COUNT III 37. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 38. On its face, the Town of Barnstable "Part X: Stable Regulation" as adopted on April 1, 1972, Revised on July 15, 1993, states at X(15) : Under Massachusetts General Laws, chapter 111, Section 157 anyone who violates the provisions of these regulations shall be punished by a fine of five dollars ti for each day such violations continue. The Barnstable Board .of Health also. reserves the right to suspend or revoke licenses previously issued if continued violations of these regulations occur. Id. 39. Each and every citation issued by the Barnstable Board of Health exceeds the five dollar per day maximum fine allowable under G.L.c. 111, § 157, with said fines ranging from forty dollars to one hundred dollars. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that each and every pending Notice of Violation of Town Ordinance or Regulation brought by the Barnstable Board of Health that exceeds the five dollar maximum cited in G.L.c 111, § 157 is preempted by said statute, • unlawful and thus unenforceable; (b) Order .the transfer from District Court and dismissal with prejudice of each and every non criminal complaint and its associated fine that have been brought the Barnstable Board of Health against the plaintiff; (c) _ And that said order include the following citation numbers and any others which exceed the statutory . maximum: - (i) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a $50.00 fine; (ii) BAR 66554, dated August 6, 2003, citing a $100.00 .fine; (iii) BAR.66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a • . $100.00 fine; 9 (iv) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a - $100.00 fine (d.) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT IV 40. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed . paragraphs. 41. G.L.c.111, §155, "Licensing of stables in cities and large towns; fees" states in relevant part: No person shall erect, occupy, or use for a stable any building in a city, or in a town, having more than five thousand inhabitants, unless such use is licensed by the. board of health, and, in such case, only to the extent so licensed. * * * [T]he board of health of suchcity or town may make such regulations or orders as, in its judgment, the public health requires relative to drainage, ventilation, size and character of stalls, bedding, number of animals and storage and handling of manure in any stable in its city or town. Id. (Emphasis added. ) WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that (in so far as the Town of Barnstable Board of Health is relying on "Part X: Stable Regulation" in its non-criminal enforcement action against the plaintiff) each, or any, of the fifteen listed paragraphs of "Part X", violate G.L.c.111, §155, going beyond the statute by regulating areas outside and notrelated to the . drainage, ventilation, size and character of stalls, bedding, number of animals and storage and handling. of manure in any stable in the town; (b) Order the transfer from District Court and the dismissal with prejudice of each and every non criminal complaint and its associated fine that have been brought the Barnstable Board of Health against the plaintiff which exceeds the statutory authority granted under G.L.c.11, §155; (c) Include in any order the following citation numbers and any others which exceed the. statutory maximum: 10 (i) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a $50.00 fine; (ii) BAR 66544, dated August 6, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; (iii)BAR 66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine (d) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT V 42. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 43. On or about April 14, 2003, the Board of Health by its authorized agent issued a Notice of Violation of Town Ordinance or Regulation number BAR 66279, which stated on its face as the alleged offense: "Failure to properly cover or dispose of manure, many flies. See the citation, attached to this complaint, marked as "Exhibit 16", the contents of which are incorporated herein and hereto by reference. 44. On or about July 22, 2003, the citation and non criminal complaint on BAR 66279 was filed at Barnstable's First District Court, probable cause was found by the magistrate and the matter was docketed as 0325 CR 002331. See the criminal complaint, attached to this pleading, marked as "Exhibit 17", the contents of which are incorporated herein and hereto by reference. 45. On its face, Docket 0325 CR 002331 cites a "MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION", and goes on to read "on [sic] April 14, 2003 did FAIL TO PROPERLY COVER OR DISPOSE OF MANURE, in violation of NUISANCE CONTROL REGULATION #1, § PART X: STABLE REGULATION. " . 46. The complaint cites a fifty dollar fine. 47. On February 5, 2004, proceedings on District Court Docket 0325 CR 002331, and deposition of all other non-complaints of a similar nature, were stayed until February 26, 2004, pending deposition of this complaint in Superior Court. 48. At all relevant time periods, Ms. Tri and her employees have disposed and handled manure in accordance with customary farming procedures. 11 49. G.L.c.111, §125A, states in relevant part: * * * the spreading of manure upon agricultural and horticultural or farming lands or noise from livestock or farm equipment used in normal, generally acceptable farming procedures * * * shall not be deemed to constitute a nuisance. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that Docket 0325CR 002331 and its underlying non- criminal complaint, fail to state with sufficiency a cause of action upon which relief may be granted;. (b) Order the transfer from District Court and dismissal with prejudice of said complaint and associated fines that have been brought by the Barnstable Health Department against the plaintiff; and (c) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT VI 50. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 51. An income generating horse stable and riding school on a parcel five acres in size and larger constitutes an "agricultural" use under G.L.c.40A, § 3,G.L.c.128A,S LA. Steege v. Stow, 26 Mass.App.Ct. 970 (1988) . 52 . G.L.c.40A, § 3, "Subjects which zoning may not regulate; exemptions; public hearings * * *",. states in relevant part: No zoning ordinance or by-law shall regulate or restrict the use of materials, or methods of construction of structures regulated by the state building code, nor shall any such ordinance or by-law prohibit, unreasonably regulate or require a special permit for the use of land for the primary purpose of agriculture * * * nor prohibit, or unreasonably regulate, or require a special permit for the use, expansion, or reconstruction of existing structures thereon for the primary purpose of agriculture * * * Id. (Emphasis added. ) 12 53. G.L.c.40A, §1A, "Definitions" of "Zoning" states: "Zoning", ordinance and by-laws, adopted by cities and towns to regulate the use of land, buildings and structures to the full extent of the independent constitutional powers of cities and towns to protect the health, safety and general welfare of their present and future inhabitants. - Id. (Emphasis added. ) 54. "Part X: Stable Regulation" as adopted on April 1, 1972 , Revised on Duly 15,. 1993, states in relevant part in paragraph one, that the Board's authority arises from, "Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 111, Section 155" and the "zoning By-Laws of the Town of Barnstable". WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that the plaintiff 's operation of a stable and riding school is an agricultural activity under G.L.c.40A, § 3, G.L.c.128A,S 1A; (b) Find that the town's ability to regulate such activity is restricted by both G.L.c. 111, S 155, and G.L.c.40A, §3; (c) Find that those paragraphs of "Part X: Stable Regulation" of Town of Barnstable which go beyond the scope of both G.L.c. 111, § 55, and G.L.c.40A, §3 constitute an unlawful effort by the town to restrain an agricultural activity; (d) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought the Barnstable Board of Health against the plaintiff because they in fact exceed the town's regulatory and/ or statutory authority; (e) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers: (i) BAR 66279, dated April 14, 2003, citing a $50.00 fine; (ii) BAR 66544, dated August 6, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; (iii) BAR 66533, dated September 29, 2003, citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 66537, dated November 10, 2003, citing a 13 $100.00 fine; (f) Vacate and otherwise dismiss with prejudice the January -� - 30, 2004, Notice of Revocation of the plaintiff's Stable License and its attend order to remove all horses from the premises; (g) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. The Building Department COUNT VII 55. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein -- and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs. 56. On or about June 26, 2003, the plaintiff applied for a permit to perform electrical work with the Barnstable Building Department for the installation of "Light to Gazebo and outdoor paddocks and arena for safety of riding and caring .: ._ for/ safe keep of horses." The application also stated one - lighting outlet would be installed, four lighting fixtures and one receptacle outline and switch." A copy of the application is attached to this complaint, marked as "Exhibit 18" and incorporated by reference herein and hereto in its entirety. 57. The plaintiff paid a thirty five dollar fee and a permit was issued, permit number 69795. 58. - The plaintiff subsequently had lighting posts installed for the riding arena which is used by the horse riders for the purposes stated above. _ 59. Shortly thereafter, the Town of Barnstable by its Building Department and authorized agents have been issuing non criminal citations against Ms. Tri, each stating: Lighting . Pole Erected Without Old Kings Highway Approval, Chap. 470, . ,; Sec 6 Old Kings Highway, and each purporting to levy a $100.00 fine. A sample copy of the application for complaint --- for nine of the alleged violations is attached, and marked as - "Exhibit 19". _ 60. To date there are at least twenty seven such citations, all of which were duly appealed by Ms. Tri, and all of which have_:-_✓:- _been filed in. Barnstable's District Court for a magistrate's- hearing. 14 61. As with the Board of Health non-criminal citations, at this time the magistrate has stayed proceedings on all said Building Department non-criminal complaints pending resolution of this matter in this court. 62 The statutory reference cited on each of the complaints is "Chap. 470, Sec 6 Old Kings Highway Regional Historic." 63. None of the documents cite the specific Act or Resolves from which Chapter 470, § 6 is derived. 64. Chapter 470, of the Acts and Resolves of 1983 refers to "AN ACT FURTHER REGULATING THE PROTECTION OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH", and its § 6 refers to the definition of a research laboratory. Chapter 470 of the Acts and Resolves of 1989 refers to "AN ACT REGULATING THE RIGHTS OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES TO RUN FOR ELECTIVE OFFICE", and its § 6 amends chapter 150E of the General Laws. Chapter 470 of the Acts and Resolves of 1993 refers to"AN ACT RELATIVE TO THE ERNESTINA COMMISSION" and contains nothing related to fines for the installation of light poles. A review of the Act and Resolves in other years presents a similar array of assorted legislative actions. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that each and every non-criminal citation filed in the year 2003, by the Barnstable Building Department, by its authorized agent, fails to state with sufficiency a cause of action upon which relief may be granted; (b) Order the transfer from the District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought by the Barnstable Building Department against the plaintiff; and (c) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket: (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 fine; (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iii) BAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 67626, 67636 to 67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; (d) Grant what ever other. type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. 15 COUNT VIII - 65. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the alternative to Count V, states as follows. 66. The Old King's Highway was established by Chapter 470 of" the Acts of 1973, as amended by Chapter 298 and 845 of the Acts of 1975; Chapter 273 of Acts of 1976; Chapter 38 and 503 of Acts of 1977; Chapter 436 of Acts of 1978; Chapter 631 of the • Acts of 1979; Chapter 338 of Acts of 1982; and Chapter 90 of the Acts of 1994. (Hereinafter the "Old Kings Highway Act". ) 67 . Section 6 of the Old Kings Highway Act, "Limitations", states in relevant part • * * * no permit shall be issued by the building inspector for any building or structure to be erected within the district, unless the application for said permit shall be accompanied either by a certificate of - appropriateness or a ,certificate of exemption which has been filed with the town clerk. Id. 68. Section 3 of the Old King's Highway Act, "Definitions", defines "Structure" as: * * * a combination of materials • other than a building, sign or billboard, but including stone walls, flagpoles, hedges, 'gates and fences." 69. Section 3 of the Old King's Highway Act does not define a light post and/or light pole. 70. On information and- belief, no person has been required to apply for a lighting post or pole in area under the jurisdiction of the Old King's Highway Act. 71. Upon application by Ms. Tri for her lighting installation, the Town of Barnstable issued her a permit without it being accompanied either by a certificate of appropriateness or a certificate of exemption having been filed with the town clerk as required by Section of the Old Kings Highway Act. • 72. No such certificate of appropriateness or a certificate of exemption were required because none was needed for the work that Ms. Tri applied. for and which was accomplished. - WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: • • 16 (a) Find that each and every non-criminal citation filed in the year 2003, by the Barnstable Building Department, by its authorized agent, fails to state with sufficiency a cause of action upon which relief may be granted; (b) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought by the Barnstable Building Department against the plaintiff; and (c) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket: (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 fine; (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iii) BAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 67626, 67636 to .67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; (d) Grant what ever other *type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT IX 73. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the alternative to Count VI, states as follows. 74. Nothing contained in the Old Kings Highway Act, or in any other legislation, states that said act supersedes G.L.c.40A, § 3, "Subjects which zoning may not regulate; exemptions; ' public hearings * * *", as defined in G.L.c.40A, §lA, "Definitions" of "Zoning". WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE • COURT: (a) Find that the plaintiff's operation of a stable and riding school is an agricultural activity under G.L.c.40A, § 3, G.L.C.128A,S1A; (b) Find that the town's ability to regulate such activity is not granted under Old Kings Highway Act; (c) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice each, any, or all non criminal complaints and 17 associated fines that have been brought the Barnstable Building Department against the plaintiff because they. in fact exceed the town's regulatory and/ or statutory authority; (d) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers as listed. in the Barnstable District Court Docket: (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100.00 fine; (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iii)BAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 67626, 67636 to 67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; (e) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT X 75. The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the alternative to Count VII, states as follows. 76. Section 12 of the Old Kings Highway act, "Enforcement", states in relevant part: "Any person who violates any provision of this Act shall be * * * fined not less than One Hundred Dollars ($100.00) nor more than Five Hundred Dollars- ($500.00) . Each day of violation of this Act shall constitute a separate violation." 77. The Town of Barnstable in this action is seeking fines of one hundred dollars per day for at least twenty seven days. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT: (a) Find that the defendant Town of Barnstable by its Building Department and authorized agents is acting in a wanton and capricious manner, attempting to levy a fine far in excess of that allowed under any reasonable interpretation of the law; (b) Order the transfer from District Court and dismiss with prejudice of each, any, or all non criminal complaints and associated fines that have been brought the Barnstable Building Department against the plaintiff because they in fact exceed the towns regulatory and/ or statutory authority; 18 (c) Include in said order dismissal with prejudice of the following non-criminal citation numbers as listed in the Barnstable District Court Docket: (i) BAR 67661 to 67669, each citing a $100 .00 fine; (ii) BAR 67651 to 67655, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iii) BAR 52913 to 52925, each citing a $100.00 fine; (iv) BAR 67626, 67636 to 67650, each citing a $100.00 fine; (v) BAR 52913 to 52917, each citing a $100.00 fine; (d) Grant what ever other type of relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. COUNT XI • The plaintiff restates and incorporates by reference herein and hereto the averments contained in the above listed paragraphs, and in the alternative to Count VII, states as follows. WHEREFORE, THE PLAINTIFF RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THAT THIS HONORABLE COURT grant what ever other relief to the plaintiff that the court determines are mete and just. An affidavit by plaintiff Brenda M. Tri is attached in support of this complant. THE PLAINTIFF DEMANDS A TRIAL BY JURY ON ALL ISSUES SO TRIABLE. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED PLAINTIFF BY HER ATTORNEY Ant 633858 torney at Law 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 (508) 362-8342 Date: 9W1-001 19 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Barnstable, SS Barnstable Superior Court Civil Docket BACV 2004- BRENDA M. TRI, ) dba DIAMOND EDGE FARM ) PLAINTIFF ) v. ) AFFIDAVIT AND BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE TOWN OF ) VERIFICATION OF COMPLAINT BARNSTABLE, AS CONSTITUTED BY ) BY PLAINTIFF ITS MEMBERS, ) WAYNE MILLER, CHAIRMAN ) SUMNER KAUFFMAN ) SUSAN G. RASR ) BUILDING COMMISSIONER, TOWN OF ) BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY ) DEFENDANTS ) 1. My name is Brenda M. Tri, I am an adult above the age of 18 years, I am the named plaintiff in this action. 2. I have read the complaint being filed on my behalf by my attorney, and thoroughly familiar with those facts, and the facts as related in the complaint are correct. 3. In addition, my farming activities at Diamond Edge Farm I been economically harmed by the Town of Barnstable's attempt to impose unreasonable restrictions. I have suffered emotionally and physically. 4. I reviewed all documents attached to the complaint and marked as exhibits, and provided those documents to my attorney. All are documents which I have maintained in the route course of my business at Diamond Edge Farm, and the marked exhibits are true and accurate copies of documents I have so maintained. ALL OF THE ABOVE 'IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY INFORMATION, KNOWLEDGE, AND BELIEF. SIGNED UNDER THE PAINS AND PENALTIES OF PERJURY THIS DAY, FEBRUARY 17, 2004. a M. Tri COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BARNSTABLE, SS DATE Q//i 1"/J ` I On this date the above named Brenda M. Tri appeared before me and stated that she egedu this affidavit by her free act and deed. / /7_ Nota-r-y-P My Commission Expires: ` Antbeny Alva, Notary Public Commonv.:ealth of Massachusetts My Comrrission Expires 3/5/2004 • • �f� • THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS DEPARTMENT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE W BUREAU OF-ANIMAL HEALTH 251 CAUSEWAY ST., SUITE 500, BOSTON,MA 02114 LICENSE TO OPERATE A RIDING SCHOOL / STABLE Name DIAMONDS EDGE Date 4/1/2003 Address 2051 Main Street • W. Barnstable, MA • License No. 1033 Having paid a fee of Fifty Dollars ($50.00), and having agreed to comply with the rules and regulations, is hereby licensed in accordance with the General Laws, Chapter 128, Section 2B, to engage in the business of operating a Riding School and/or Stable where horses are kept for hire. THIS LICENSE EXPIRES ON MARCH 31, 2004 • CHIEF—BUREAU OF ANIMAL HEALTH • THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS = Department of Food and Agriculture F p y Bureau of Animal Health '•, � r 251 Causeway Street,Suite 500 Boston, MA 02114-2151 Date: 4/1/2003 • License No.: 3924 This is to certify the named bearer of this license has been qualified as a Horse Riding instructor, under Chapter 128, Section 2A. . Brenda Tri Barnstable, MA •- n Signature THIS LICENSE EXPIRES ON MARCH 31, 2004 Or unless sooner revo . CHiB.ET- I Pg.a I --- - • The Commonwealth of Massachusetts- =*= /, - BUREAU OF ANIMAL HEALTH: 7- 251,CAUSEWAY STREET,.SUITE 500 E BOSTON, MA 02114 STABLE INSPECTION REPORT Stable Name&Address 1%!l ''d?✓i0 CC.' - e Owner Name&Address ?O >• / r A,-' .� / f, Veterinarian Name&Address G•-„. . /f=1 /j i YES NO Explain a"no"answer under comments t i.00- Are Buildings and premises clean,sanitary and safe? Are Licenses and Liability information prominently posted? `x Is manure-rubbish properly handled;Is manure storage inaccessible to animals?. , Is a pest control program in effect? Are barn-paddock areas free of insects and rodents? ' Is adequate shelter available? , Are stalls clean and adequate size? . '-''�- Are water troughs-buckets and feed pails clean? • `-� Are floors,gutters and alley ways clean and free of litter? Are paddocks free of glass,wire or debris which could cause injuries? • . �""� Are paddocks graded to drain away from shelters;no pooled water or wastes? =�! Are turn-outs kept in compatible groups and not overcrowded? y Do animals confined to paddocks have adequate water and shade? isl/'' Is water being offered as per rules and regulations? 4..---! • Is fresh feed being offered each animal twice a day? "'""r Are horses feet properly shod/trimmed,cared for? 4 _ Are horses properly groomed and without equipment sores? L..f - Is equipment clean and safe? . r Are horses in good condition and sound? - Are records maintained for working horses in compliance with section 6? Number of horses on the premises: COMMENTS: vO/- /- J f'' S?4 /i c A :�L° .7- P, ii,•ef ;L't'�- °} 1"—, -o/ ff / J �7 j L .- ) !•r G/� 7. ,` ,,,„'n Y ! j i/ -_ f: J I Inspector's Signature Date of Inspection' • Approved Not Approved Reinspect w0 L.r"/'t sr''r Office Copy/White Barn Copy/Yellow Inspector's-Copy/Pink. ,. l i+ A ee-� EXHIBIT- 2- . Pg.- 1 . ' ; ,--a r . ,-2, .. ,I ) 7 .e,.--- ,.... .... / -....,'T c,, ft_-1-• c,41 ,44 fi4. t.../ •1 ? "1 ; , . i •—•" ! t ‘....,?I . I —." ki.ij‘—" • c 's\ ./rp.,,v . . s. i -: Af_,. . • Cy 0,:" 4.: /X(/A• -f- 6 ' .3" C;4,4;-, The Conzmonwealth.of-Masrachusetts '''' BUREAU OF-ANINIAL IfEALTH 251 CAUSEWAY STREET, SUITE500 BOSTON,MA 02114 -'441NEP 54 • STABLE INSPECTION REPORT t ,. Stable Name&Address „r1_—/4.° 1 1 04,r * ' 04. CZ_- 27e ai-/ /7-,:7 i.4.- ,),/ ----)t, c,..„ /1-_-- 1,,--,/..,,• , Owner Name&Address - : ... Veterinarian Name&Address - ...,4.-.. YES NO Explain a"no"answer under comments -- ,-.. . _,,--,.....,--- - ...... - fr# Are Buildings and premises clean,sanitary and safe? v , 1,....< k Are Licenses and Liability information prominently posted? ,,,,......... Is manure rubbish properly handled Is manure storage inaccessible to animals? . - •y., ; ' i . • . - • Isaiest control program in effect? Are barn-paddock areas free of insects and rodents? .... Is adequate shelter available? 1S----L- Are stalls clean and adequate size? - ' / .4 . .. ,. Are water troughs-buckets and feed pails clean? - ) Are floors,gutters and alleyways clean and free of litter? -- .. Are paddocks free of glass,wire-o-illibris which could cause injuries? , . ' - , . • - t, Are paddocks graded to drain away from shelters;no pooled water;or wastes7 i f i . ' . Are turn-outs kept in compatible groups and not overcroy,"ided? . . I . . Do animals confined to paddocks have adequate water and shade?-- t-'. • Is water being offered as per rules and regulations? • . . Is fresh feed being offered each animal twice a day? • i.....---- . Are horses feet properly shod/trimmed,cared for? ‘,..."- ,_ • Are horses properly groomed and without equipment sore ? . . a.....,"" • Is equipment clean and safe? -: Are horses in good condition and sound? t./ Are records maintained for working horses in compliance with section 6? . . . ._ ' • „f_Le Number of horses on the premises: f 7 5 ' 4 Z4.... .", j ' ......- / COMMENTS LC ICA 1 -L e hit.A --5 4-, ( ,1-.-- / A"'---...; V /6 4.'4'''''.'-. 6/ i<7 /7- . 0 14/ '-•/ i i qCi' /f q 9 glaz., ,- .(,(P/ -_-"Ig4: c;•76),-.)3 ,97-e ./-- )1., --,f,.--, / - / A ii,._ 0 ..r-,._,.d! ...s Z,/Ci e--,-, F...,''..27 g Li :74/tr-- ,57,1 7-c-- /4. <- zz7 ,5..:1 ...,.: tif e- ./.2),4.-7. -.. c /1 -------) -,-%-------. /1/4-1-":47 I iV ...,- -1 r i - .....' '....= .. . 1 z ..111 11 1.... C—,--11: Y 0*. , t: 1::":"1— 41 I Inpector's Signature,: • . ,.. Date of Inspection . -4 -... . Approved Not Approved ' - 1 Reinspect V : -• Office Copy/White Barn Copy/Yellow Inspectdr's Copy/Pink - , 4 ..s. IJJJ 0 / , ,"--1 t". ---", g.,-- .41 1.-) il /7 ni- n //...": c;- ,, if ;5-I -6 ---- -' I "T..... ..../ - . . , -1,,pg it i / il i C. I 11, /.../ tit'''''' Li '1/4—/ ‘I ' i. f)(1-11B IT-3 Pit -, -, , - --7 ...... , .:..., „ :„.„ ,, ,,, . , ", , ./......, - ._? .... . i 1 , •.- :...... it-7. e --." —....e 4...." /.... • IVIyASSA �[iU: T T S.:DE4P R--q N ?�_�::O 'M�eND-"AmR-lCI II TURF _: B l i 2EAU, O.P AN I' IAL.:H EA'L. • `.--- - �' f=f=�= Page r- of - .Jame: In 1 /; C",f0 X' e_ Date And Time Of Inspection '1 ✓ 3r I ; r . /f COMMENTS: -► _ 3 S, ±.H#9 r L7 R,7i2 � ,� ;L.-- j/! a'2 / �'Q.. I r> 6'6 1: /•!'�e-.r� wa A . Z i, . / - /9/e a ? 2 fir' /:..5 0 %/fe: P6 oP % v :A it, f•C1i 13✓,e,5 4 1 I -1 :S 00� G 6 i -v'.., (-)-- 11, e- s i 3/9 010- 0e .A1 - I rk c c /I A-.‘ V ',i) iv/44.g/0.74- I PA- rd C_1 . AI j P�� le(/ �e . . 1 A ' , hi C --L. , , �4#0 c> ir/ :2 ;'=e'. 0e '•7DLill �? Si 7.e.e; e0, ai" k 44 !•/•, f, ' A IA , r- ' / d 1976 f,4, . , sue. J e fe- '= . . �,( lei, lic P ,�� 3 �' AReport Received By �' „`� ee /; S /U �`\i' Signature Of Recipien •�. r j/I e lm J 3"7 �.., 4 A.if- a' ='y,c,�k. ,' inspector's Name: =, 1 f r ,.3p;ss, Inspector's Signature:_. -=r�r-' FORM#77A r1 White Copy -Office / Yellow Copy,-Inspector / Pink'Copy�-•Owner • EXHIB IT- . Pg; NAME OF OFFENDER -. •.; . ;,,a — • r..,, 1.. B'AR..6.5.33 - , _ ✓fir•,•( I r-. ,,: - TOWN OF- ADDRESS OF OFFENDED i` ,1 BARNSTABLE CITY.STATE.JF�D- ., •1 t,. ff . .▪ ;- /� l 'pry /� / L�.f r15 61Gr !+ I a?.4be • Iw,- : , �P`pf 1HE►q,_ / MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER - 1 OFFEN�S]�. ,,,rrr��� ▪ �' : \au�S� J (Niel 01 a4'f) (AP1.if !Ice, (iv, K Cl,i j(./tr6'0, •x C r • 0- 1 - c j la,a �� I .4l f f l•� c �G. c. , MKk q c•.1•,�l cr�Oil .T ;1,!r e 17 rA c r/ w c. : _:_>. l �t:� r �c1rF =r. NOTICE OF nMEAND D�oFw°VIOLATION Jti!f 2,6,2003 �Lo�AO5olvli1o^ f /$,I� f� z :;e, =-. 3 G,l I.V. ff 1 / Iy ;w Q r-- r. SIGNA OF ENFOpCING PERSON E RCING D�T. ! BADGE NO• LL1 , VIOLATION w,cl ' ''- ��,::' � e1,•Iofatril %:r,• 1,� o •^: OF TOWN • / ~ ' ljEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a ORDINANCE Unable to•obtai signature of offender. ,�p • • _ .�„ , THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ J ,•, X,• Date mailed a r W • OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER_EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL a ',,;;± REGULATION DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w . - ;.. (1)You mayelect topaythe above fine,either byappearing inperson between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Mondaythrough Friday,legal holidays excepted, Q ••" `k4"'' PP 9 9 9 P Lyj< •• s �r before:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or b mailinga check,moneyorder orpostal note to.Barnstable Clerk,P.O. ox 2430, —1 ', O " `0' y 0 ,w ,,,^..' Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21) OF THE DATE OF THIS NTICE. o• (2 If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST ••" •▪ ,- BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this C" ,,!.; citation fora hearing. • „• ,. ., • • (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or it you fall to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the hearing 'r-1' lobe due,criminal complaint may be Issued against you. , n, 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of$ T Signature • I•' • '• • • • • • S'{ • • • L ' EXHIBIT I Pg - 4- PART X: STABLE REGULATION ADOPTED 4/1/72, REVISED 7/15/93 OFe•ray vase. �ArFa MAC k�� Town of Barnstable • . Board of Health • STABLE REGULATION 1. Under the authority of Massachusetts General Laws,Chapter 111, Section 155, no person . shall erect,occupy or use for a stable any building or land for the housing of horses and/or ponies in the Town of Barnstable,unless such use is authorized and licensed by the Board of Health and is in compliance with the zoning By Laws of the Town of Barnstable. 2. The license fee for each horse and/or pony shall be established by the Board of Health and said license shall be effective July 1 of each calendar year and shall expire on June 30 of the succeeding calendar year. 3. No stable may be constructed within the Town of Barnstable unless a stable license is first obtained from the Board of Health. The construction of stables shall be in conformity with the Barnstable Building Code. • 4. Stables shall conform to the following: (a) There shall be at least two(2)windows in every stable.' (b) There shall be adequate ventilation in every stable. • (c) Each stall shall be of adequate size so that any horse and/or pony shall have room to • comfortably lie down or stand up. (d) There snail be adequate drainage either natural or artificial. (e) All flooring in any stable shall be acceptable to the Board of Health. • 5. Land on which horses or ponies are pastured shall be fenced in such a manner as to prevent any damage to abutting property,trees or shrubbery. • • 6. No person, company or corporation shall erect,occupy or use a building for a livery or horse or pony stable for the keeping of horses or ponies unless such a stable or building is more than 200 feet from a church or school building and is more than fifty(50) feet from a building that is used as a dwelling or home. • • 7. Owners of stables housing horses or ponies must clean the manure from the stable at least once each day. Waste matter shall be disposed of in a sanitary manner and shall not be accumulated on the property. • 91 • • EXHIBIT - 5 Pg.- • • 8. No horse or pony shall be allowed to be pastured on any land unless said area is fifty(50)feet from a home or dwelling. 9. No person company, or corporation shall allow a horse or pony to be pastured on any land - unless said area is fifty(50)feet away from a private water supply well. A fence shall be erected to keep horses and ponies at least fifty(50)feet away from any private water supply well. 10. No person, company, or corporation shall erect, occupy or use a building, for a livery or horse or.pony stable for the keeping of horses or ponies Zmless such stable or building is more than fifty(50)feet from a private water supply well. • 11. No person shall store,dispose,or stockpile manure within 100 feet of a private water will. 12. Any owner or keeper of a horse or pony must provide stabling facilities for same. No horse or pony shall be allowed to remain out of doors at all tiros without having access to proper • shelter. . 13. Any person company, or corporation engaged in or desiring to engage in the business of slaughtering horses for the purpose of rendering them shall apply to the Board of Health for a license as required by the Massachusetts General Laws,Chapter 111,Section 154. 1.4. The Barnstable Board of Health reserves the right to make any decision of situations or problems that arise in regard to health or housing conditions that are not covered by this set of regulations. 15. Under Massachusetts General Laws, chapter 111, Section 157 anyone who violates the provisions of these regulations shall be punished by a fine of five dollars for each day such violations continue. The Barnstable Board of Health also reserves the right to suspend or revoke licenses previously issued if continued violations of these regulations occur. • • • • • Brian R.Grady,R.S.,Chairman • • Susan G.Rask,R.S. • Joseph C.Snow,M.D. • • 92 EXHIBIT- 5 Pg.- 2 • • 61 THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Fee • Town of Barnstable $35.00 Board of Health This is to Certify that BRENDA TRI tto �� • 2051 MAIN STREET, W. BARNSTABLE,MA a- y Is Hereby Granted a License FORA STABLE c0 THIS LICENSE IS GRANTED IN CONFORMITY WITH THE STATUTES AND ORDINANCES RELATING THERETO, AND EXPIRES JUNE 30,2004 UNLESS SOONER SUSPENDED OR REVOKED. • • SUSAN G. RASK, R.S., CHAIRMAN July 1,2003 WAYNE MILLER, M.D. SUMNER KAUFMAN, M.S.P.H. • THOMAS A. MCKEAN, R.S., CHO, AGENT . • • • • . . • _ . - . • _ . ----- — • NAME OF OFFENDER c-,. .. _ . _ ..... . . . pr./341(5(i , ' . r, TOWN OF _ ADDRESS OF OFFENDER 2.0 5 i Ma vi .....)rre I' , BARNSTABL E cm,STATE,ZIP CODE t . , irOVS 1 2 -ii-fl 1-P-7 bit,i flein -) 1 e)(.45 foir_liv 4.411.1E to,s,9. 'MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER • OFFENSE....--• . . • • t 1..mixst ABLE. : . ( tyl.;:;a•sie ,;• -gfii .),11 .1., .. i . .. . . > • TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION 4,..0...,.1 LOCATION OF VIOLATION Z . • NOTICE OF -;,•.). ". 0...) (A.M./(P.W.)ON /61),• / )1,20 02, -D-C• '6./ /1•1 ft at: :`,..:-...-fa....:-.. -' •i (.,:.;1:77 pi........... UJ -...I - • • .c" . SIGNATURCOt ENFORCING PERSON . - ENFORCING DEPT/. BADGE NO. I...J ... VIOLATION ' r-. i. 11,0.*:.1/771;,74---- ../bb t eek 1.PI cn CD ------ I— e OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X 0_ ORDINANCE ID Unable to obtain signature of offender. THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ P`S-0, • Date mailed • w OR 11.1 YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL DISPOSITION WITH WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. REGULATION cn (1)You may elect to pay the above tine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,leg. nolioays excepted, before:The Barnstable Clerk,236 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, —I - Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. • r (2)II you desire to contest this rr atter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST 1 BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT.COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this /4 citation for a hearing. (3)If you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any fine determined at the head; i : . lobe due,criminal complaint maybe issued against you. .. - • 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of S . HitHwl.ut. -.% , ... . • . . • _ . - • . • - , . . • • -• . • • . . . • - • ,t1 t't . , .. . • --<.•-••'' EXH1B 17 - 7 pg - i • I- 1:-.:-..g.:.,-,7-1. 7-,,,i.,..`!1--:-..7.;--,:,-i-•, -D:,,..,"':'..ii.-,3'..:---..-'1."I'er: :;-. .krvit-',i-.-L.-7- ,-;•..4-----..,•.-..,'T.,--:...--.•.,..---.•;.. ...;•,,-.---.-:..-- -'-i.r.--.-.:,-H- i:bARZEIS.-5 ..''' TOWN OF, AREUD -Et ' BARtvJTABLI COY s xf(�(t�e fi s \tea ly1��1 �� c O _ � = _ rR .L tl _ 4 r ?Fohoz�� :fir t rrf 1� >� Bey ,HIME.AM3-flAT. e VIOE'A3� , : �-- e Y af". � _Li [ ND�10E QF ', -� toe toN o orc � '- �5ra ) /�T� 7,.tea e'F e/ G.r � � ���;�p � � = �` - V.IOt,KI f:OV i .9i, s -:� £.rr�dltr '-T .PI o T Bi1D E � , '� , .DF �O�f N <,)_# Ere AbRIN,V�, € EeE at F en.ATION IE,_ __▪ i I QJipf NAME 1 TJnabtt to o6taltl stgnaureof Qttender Y_ Datemailed F THE NOmFCRrM1t AE FINE FOR-THISQ,EFEAISE 4,S ,$ l OR Y011Jilk1/E.iHEtO k'clAr 6lALtiERNA.TfEES•WIibREGARF7T(LDtSPOStT• trJ DFTHISMA7EEREITHER0P710N()0[t-DPT101 (2}W1LLOPERATEA5AEINAL ' - 37ISPOS$IOtt'KrtTFiNO RES),l..0GGRIM1Ng-li ORD FREGU-t... ON fK - t1t}You maj eledlapaq the Shove:[me etthefhy,zappeaRo}inpetsomhieheeen$30-A.FrtaodAOUFM,-Monday_througftFfl y legalf'ioilda s'exce ted- ' Q before-TfieBarnstable,-Cleri2St SDuthM1'Street;:Xyannls-KJA'02601 or..by rnathnga:eheck money order_or.postal note to Barr♦stabte"Clerk,P p los-2p930- =- i- Flyanfis b tYZ60T NAIHft fiv¢ ta'k-0NEt21kD#YS4 ;TtgDTEOFTy.$1OT(G� _a 1211E youdeslre lo->oetest lhts lrta(tee a 4-noricnrp ai proceeding yQtr,rnaytla so-b;^making written request'.fp DISTAB.T _F1tURT DEPARTINpfFr'E113s - -' ' -.BARN'NSTABt;E D1VIS(ON COURT CQMPOUNIJ MA1Fl,STREET BAT3NSTABLE MA A2630u'Atth 21D Nhocnnmial.Elesongs a(id'endose d;copyol this,I ` -citation fq�aheanng ;,. �,. _ -13)ftyou faiLtapey the above or oflense_ to regyeAla heangy withln7l days of if you fad to appeatlor fhehearing or topay`anyfine determinedat'fhe beanno to be-dne,cnmmatconiplaint maybe-tsstfedagainstyoth -u 0 I HEREO ELECT the 11rs1 option above confess,fo the offense charged,and_enclose payment in the amount of S F� • I EXHIBIT - Pg 1 - NAME OF OFFENDER _ -- - < (1� I 6Te v N OF. AUi1=ESS OF OFFENDER- 2 G•S/ /Y) ,` sly-e BARNSTABLE CITY.STATE.ZIP COO _ F � - / MV/MB GISTRAT(ON NUMBER .• . 3 I:I •�1� OFFENSE.T IIAN\rl'ANI.F.�• )/ ))^^ , /^��1 }/I I }/�� Jjf j p / (J/. /r p 1�9,, MASS. . /01AM GI- ��Tl r iisi,ble JL4-•tr.T t� Het,I fL 4��v) i Ltns S+G, L k La d_ JCpy✓IN I/`clal, PA„--1- �' (7 't'l cPve yeC�lw�iat7'ny />)�thV!hell/re ,>7at. PI/' z -. TIME D DATE OF VIOLATION - L CATION OF VIOLATIQ$ ff w NOTICE OF ;30 (A.M.I';.J.)ON 7 y .2003 05 I /vf,,s4 St w. grzrb(-11illaSIGN TU OF EN CING PERSON ENFORCING DEPT.. BADGE NO. w VIOLATION • ...v., �;11. � — —�'y�'�G � / ���+ o • OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X nu'- . ORDINANCE 1Z Unable to obtain si ature of offender. .00 r- THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $//i� J Date mailed IU� 13 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOW] G/////ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION Q (1)You may elect to-pay the above fine,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M,and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, :C before:The Barnstable Clerk.230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601,or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430, a Hyannis• ,MA 02601.WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. ;a • (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST • • BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. • (3)If you tail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any line determined at the hearing to be due,criminal comolaint may be issued against You. - ❑ I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged.and enclose payment in the amount e-r ii T'-,, •�I,•j(r7'N, J•!H ''a Signature • . . .. eS EXHIBIT - g . Pg.- 1 NAME OF OFFENDER ��/e�e"ll))�y q • (� ;►�� ,�y^� / .S1l�•1 tie -Tr tJ A Ds,a.M,B411<Ed• e'�.- �rven B'Ah V�5••��. 1 TOWN OF' ADDRESS OF OFFENDER �� . . a D Sl yV ;'/i 5•f't _ej- • BARNSTABLE _CITY.STATE.ZIP CODE . �`p��c MV/MB R GISTHA ON.NUMBER.' - iM 0�1, • f:l d~' OFF NSE 0 b' MASS. ' :W1 Cc &L '1. � geii.� t1 MT AII:6 �441L c E110 AC jA 7718A fW b ` 4 / .. �i'A14 X {/7/1 GAS Ned cctald�(libi/yriq ►lia4V-z.iwq_sle M<,J{e� z _ - TIME ANO DATE OFFVIOWTIOM' ' .Jr°CATION OF VIOLATION W NOTICE OF 1,LIS 1 P.M.)ON l/ JO 0 03 accl Mw., Si I/Li. 6 As b1? -J SI E OF E RCINt.p�R N ENFORCING OFPT BADGE NO. LLI • VIOLATION ` iiti- RS (�•e ;;kz.:�x fot1� cn o • OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X a • ORDINANCE Q Unable to obtain ignat're of offender. (��� C" I-_, a r THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS $ / �. Date mailed ,I/In/2 w OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLO NG AL ERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(1)OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL °- DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. w REGULATION (1)You may elect to pay the above line,either by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M.,Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, ly • - • before:The Bamstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601.or by mailing a check,money order or postal note to Barnstable Clerk.P.O.Box 2430, - I Hyannis,MA 02601.WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. r (2)If you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making written request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT,FIRST - BARNSTABLE DIVISION,COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET,BARNSTABLE,MA 02630,Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this '' citation for a hearing. rlt (3)It you fail to pay the above offense or to request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearlppE]r1p pazan finapletgxnined at the hearing . lobe due.criminal comolaint may be issued against you. Bg91�L5 UU i 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above,confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount of S .• Signature • . • • • • • • • • • EXHIBIT It; p E I . PAGE I OF 3 �T44E ray - Town of Bar.:nstable: 'f"� °\ Regulatory Services it spaxsras ,-/� • • Thomas F. Geller,Director `Nhips. / . i839 0i TED AiA� Public Health Division Thomas McKean,Director 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA"02601 • Office: '5OS-S624644 Fax: 503-790-630+ July 29,2003 Mrs.Brenda Tri . 2051 Main Street West Barnstable,MA 02668 ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST THE PLACEMENT OF NON-COMPOSTED `' MANURE ONTO THE TOP OF THE GROUND.ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST COMPOSTING MANI'RE.AND ORDER TO REMOVE ALL FUTURE MANURE FROM THE PROPERTY ON A REGULAR BASIS On July 28, 2003,Health Inspector Donna Miorandi,R.S.and Health Agent Thomas McKean,R.S., conducted an inspection of your horse stable facilities located at 2051 3 Main Street West Barnstable, due to complaints received. Fourteen horses were observed on your property on that date. The following violations of the Town of Barnstable Board • of Health Stable Regulation,Part X,were observed: PART X(7): Piles of non-composted manure observed on top of ground scattered along . the top of a bank,slope of the bank,and at the foot of the bank which is . located at the south-west corner of the property. Evidence of soil and debris run-off from the steep embankment of manure piles onto the lower elevated land,between stone walls and onto neighboring property. PART X(7): Both compost bins containing manure were partially uncovered. Also on July 7, 2003,Health Inspectors David Stanton,R.S. and Donna Miorandi,R.S., observed dust materials rising into the air from an area where blue colored angular sand/stone dust materials were recently spread onto the top of the ground at your °', property. This dusty material was observed blowing onto neighboring properties. This was a violation of 310 CMR 7.09 and you were issued a written warning notice to cease and desist spreading sand/stone dust onto your land. During yesterday's inspection, large . piles of the same blue colored angular sand/stone dust materials were observed on you± property. :t was suggested to you that the piles should be lowered to reduce dust. You are ordered tb immediately cease and desist the disposal of any manure onto the top of the ground. Thenon-composted manure dumped onto the bank located at the south-west corner of the property shall be removed and disposed of properly. You are also ordered to immediately cease and desist the composting of any manure at your property in the future. EXHIBIT- I I Pge- PAGE2OF3 In addition,you are ordered to remove all manure from your property on a regular basis (e.g.weekly) and to dispose of the manure properly. • These orders take effect immediately upon your receipt of this notice. You are reminded that manure shall not be allowed to accumulate on the property. All owners of stables housing horses must clean the stables at least once each day and waste matter shall be disposed of in a sanitary manner on a regular.basis. • Since August 28, 1998,the Health Division Office received twenty-six(26) complaints regarding the horse stable at this property. Twenty(20) complaints were received in regards to improper disposal of manure. • Your original request for a variance to spread horse manure on the ground was not granted,as indicated in the letter to you from the Board of Health dated March 22,2001. At that time, Board did grant you permission to construct enclosed compost bins, with . covers, and to place all manure within.the compost bins. However,it is apparent that the two compost bins which you constructed are severely insufficient for the number of horses on your property and the amount of manure which is generated on a daily basis, . coupled with your failure to keep them properly covered. • According to Jessica page, WSU Cooperative Extension, Whatcom County,Washington, (at website: uw-w.whatcom.wsu.edu)two compost bins would be adequate for only one to five horses. However a total of fourteen horses were observed at your property. • Also,your compost bins were not covered on multiple occasions including during yesterday's inspection on July 28,2003,and during inspections on June 26, 2003,April 14,2003,October 15,2002,October 18,2002, and September 19,2002. On September 23, 2002, a letter was mailed to you via certified mail which read"you are reminded that the compost bins shall be kept covered all times whenever there is any manure kept within them." Also an order letter was mailed to you by certified mail on October 18,2002 regarding piles of non-composted manure observed on top of the compost bins and regarding an uncovered compost bin containing manure. Within that order letter,you were ordered to correct the violations within 24 hours. However, after •, •that date,due to recurring violations of uncovered manure within the compost bins and • • due your failure to properly dispose of manure;you were issued non-criminal ticket citations on April 14,2003 and on June 26,2003. You may request a hearing before the Board of Health if written petition requesting same • is received by the Board within ten(10)days. However,the violations shall be corrected immediately regardless of any request for a hearing. The option to appeal to the Board of Health does not over-ride the immediate public health threat imposed due to the improper disposal of manure. The manure disposal violations must be corrected immediate) by • regularly removing manure from the property(e.g.weekly). Your request for a hearing shall include a written proposal of how you intend to properly dispose of manure from fourteen(14)horses each day. • EXHIBIT- it s,- 2, PAGE 3OF3 Failure to comply with this order may result in the issuance of a S100 non-criminal ticket citation. Each day's failure to comply With an order shall constitute as a separate violation. Thomas A.McKean,RSTfO Director of Public Health • • • EXHIBIT- 11 ' '; • • BRENDA TM STABLE LICENSE SUSPENSION/REVOCATION Proposed Findings of Fact January 20,2004: 1. Brenda Tri was granted a license pursuant to section 155 of chapter 111 of the General • Laws of Massachusetts to operate a stable for one year from July 1,2003 to June 30,2004 on premises having a street address of 2051 Main Street,Barnstable,Massachusetts; a copy of which is attached. 2. All stables licensed by the Barnstable Board of Health are subject to regulations adopted by the Board for the conduct of stables, a copy of which is attached. 3. The licensed premises are shown on Town of Barnstable Assessor's Map 216 as 0 parcels 076-BOO,076-WOO and 075-002(hereinafter"the property"). A copy of Town of Barnstable Geographic Information Systems aerial photograph dated April 28,2001 • showing the property and its immediate surroundings with Assessors parcel lilies arid numbers superimposed is attached. • 4. On July 24,2003,complaints were received at the Regulatory Services Department Office from several neighbors regarding manure, odors, and fencing at the property. • 5. On July 28,2003,Town of Barnstable Health Inspector Donna Miorandi,R.S. and Public Health Division Director Thomas McKean, C.H.O.,investigated the complaints and observed a pile of non-composted manure at the southeast corner of the property further shown on photographs taken by Donna Miorandi on July 28, copies of which are attached. .. . 6. A written order to cease and desist the placement of non-composted manure onto the top of the ground,to cease and desist composting manure,and to remove all future manure from the property on a regular basis Were issued to Brenda Tri via certified mail • dated July 29 and received July 30,.2003,copies of which axe attached(hereinafter"the • order"). 7. Director of Public Health Thomas McKean received a letter dated August 6,2003 from Attorney Francis A.DiLuna bearing the letterhead of Murtha Cullina LLP stating that the firm represented Diamond's Edge Farm and petitioning for a hearing.by the Board of Health on the order. The letter further stated that manure would be removed • from the property on a weekly basis in compliance with the order. A copy of the letter is attached hereto. 8. The Board of Health scheduled a hearing on the order as requested by Attorney DiLuna to be held on September 2,2003. However,on September 2,2003,Attorney DiLuna requested that the hearing be continued to the next available meeting date, a copy of which is attqached. The Board of Health granted the continuance request,rescheduled the hearing for September 18,and extended the order up to the rescheduled hearing date. 1 • EXHIBIT- 2. 0'1:4 • • BRENDA TM STABLE LICENSE SUSPENSION/REVOCATION Proposed Findings of Fact January 20,2004: 9. On September 18,an individual who identified himself as Dr. Victor Cillis appeared before the Board at the time of the hearing and requested on behalf of the licensee that the hearing be postponed. The Board of Health granted the postponement,rescheduled the hearing for October 30,2003, and extended the order up to the rescheduled hearing.date. 10. The Town of Barnstable Public Health Division received a complaint on September 26,2003 regarding manure at the property. Health Inspector David Stanton,R.S. investigated the complaint on September 29,2003 and observed a pile of non-composted manure on the ground at the southwest corner of the property shown in the photographs taken by David Stanton on September 29, copies of which are attached. 11. On October 30, 2003,a document was received by telecopier at the Office of the Town Attorney reciting that it was transmitted by the licensee and requesting.that the hearing be postponed. The Board of Health granted the postponement,rescheduled the hearing for December 16,and extended the order up to the rescheduled hearing date. • 12. On November 5,2003,the Public Health Division received a complaint about manure odors emanating from the property. Health Inspector David Stanton,R.S., and Director of Public Health Thomas McKean, C.H.O.,investigated the complaint. During the investigation,they observed that compost bin covers were left open and overfilled with uncomposted manure,and further that additional quantities of uncomposted manure had been accumulated at the same location in the southwest corner of the property where accumulation was first observed on September 29,as shown in the photographs taken by David Stanton on November 10, copies of which are attached. 13. The accumulation of raw,uncomposted manure has continued on the property since issuance of the cease and desist order dated July 29,2003. 14. A reminder letter was mailed to the licensee regarding proper disposal of manure procedures on November 11,2003,a copy of which is attached. t 15. The property is bounded on the north by single family residences supplied by individual private water supply wells located on each residential lot, and on the south by the campus of Cape Cod Community College. The groundwater direction flow is towards the north. 16. Notice of the December 16,2003 hearing was forwarded to the licensee as follows: (a)by certified mail,return receipt requested,addressed to the licensee at the property on-November 13,2003,but was returned to the Public Health Division Offices on December 1 bearing the notation"unclaimed," copies of which are attached; - 2 . EXHIBIT- 12 P ..e. 2 • BRENDA TRI STABLE LICENSE SUSPENSION!REVOCATION Proposed Findings of Fact January 20,2004: • (b)by first class mail addressed to the licensee at the property on November 13,2003 • and not returned; (c)by delivery to the property by Thomas McKean and David Stanton and Ieft in the custody of a laborer in the absence of the licensee or a representative on November 20,2003; (d)by delivery on December 1,2,3 and 4 by Health Inspector David Stanton to the property but without deposit on the property in the absence of the licensee or a representative;and (e)by delivery by Public Health Division Director Thomas McKean to the property on December 5 at 5:30 p.m.and deposited at a side entrance door of the dwelling on the property. 0 17. At the conclusion of the hearing,the Board voted to close the hearing and hold a special meeting on January 8,2004 for the purpose of considering the adoption of findings of fact and taking action on the license. 18. The Board met on January 3,2004 and granted the licensee's request,made by her Attorney Francis A.DiLuna,to reopen the hearing closed on December 16,and afforded the licensee the opportunity to present statements and materials to the Board. 19. Part of the materials submitted to the Board by the licensee through her Attorney during the reopened hearing consisted of receipts for manure removal and photographs of the licensed premises,copies of which are attached. 20. During the reopened hearing,Health Inspector David Stanton,R.S.,presented photographs taken by him during an inspection of the licensed premises on December 17, 2003 showing the manure accumulation in the southwest corner of the licensed premises .partially submerged in water standing on the licensed premises that extended onto an adjacent portion of the campus of Cape.Cod Community College. • • • EXHIBIT- IZ Pg.-; • • PAGE 1 OF 2 RECEIVED BY: of1HE v ru nnpTo DATE: • y�PftiO# Town of Barnstable TIME: t I' Regulatory Services 1�0en �g 'i Thomas F. Geiler,Director Public Health Division ' . Thomas McKean,Directs 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4644 Fax: 508-790-6304 January 14,2004 Mrs. Brenda Tri _ _ Diamond Edge Farm • • 2051 Main Street West Barnstable,MA 02668 • NOTICE TO FURTHER CONSIDER STABLE LICENSE SUSPENSION OR '` REVOCATION On January 8,2004,the Board of Health, acting at your request,re-opened the hearing it had closed on December 16,2003, and at which neither you or a representative appeared, 1 for the purpose of holding a hearing to consider whether your stable license should be suspended or revoked(the original cease and desist order datetl'July 29, 2003 remaining ineffect). You were present along with your attorney and presented evidence to the • Board on the 8th. At the conclusion of the hearing,the Board voted unanimously to revoke your stable license for continuing violation of Board of Health regulations effective as of January 22, 2004. It was subsequently discovered that the meeting of the 8th had not been posted,therefore the revocation of your license is not valid. As a result, the Board must consider again whether to extend the order and take action with regard to your license. I apologize for the inconvenience this may cause to both you and the Board. The Board of Health will consider again at 7:00 p.m. on Tuesday, January 20, 2004 in the Conference Room on the second floor of Town Hall, 367 Main Street,Hyannis during its regular meeting(which has been posted)whether to extend the order and take any action with respect to your license,which could include suspension or revocation. The Board • will afford you the opportunity at that time to either repeat the evidence you presented on the 8th, or simply carry forward and incorporate the record of the 8th (minutes,audio and video tapes, documents)into the record of the 20th, or even to present additional material if you wish. The cease and desist order remains in effect. Again, I apologize for the resulting inconveniences. Any request to continue the hearings must be by a signed,written request stating the reason(s) for the request delivered and received at the Board of Health offices at 200 Main Street,Hyannis at least fifty-two (52) hours prior to the start of the hearings except in the most extreme of emergencies. I would remind you that the Board's offices are closed on Monday, January 19,2004 in observance of Martin Luther King Day as well as-Saturday and;Sunday the 17th and 18th, Triletter5 •• EXHIBIT- 13 Pg.,- i PAGE 2 OF 2 RECEIVED BY: DATE: • TIME: respectively. The Board has discretion to grant or deny a request for a continuance, and if denied or if no request is timely and properly made to conduct the hearing as scheduled and thereafter take any actions within its discretion with respect to the subject matters of the hearing if you fail to appear. Thomas A. McKean,RS, CHO • Cc: Dr.Victor Cillis Francis Diluna, Esq. • • Triletter5 EXHIBIT- i 3 Pg. 2 Anthony Alva ` Attorney at Law 3291 Main Street, P.O. Box 730 Barnstable,-MA 0263.0: - Phone (508) 362-8342, Fax (508) 362-7770 Delivered in Hand January 15, 2004 Town of Barnstable Public Health Division ATTN: Thomas McKean, Director 200 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02601 Re: Stable License, 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable, MA 02668 - a) Notice of Representation and b) Request for Continuance of Hearing Dear Mr. McKean: This office has been retained to represent Ms. Brenda Tri, in regards to her stable license at 2051 Main Street, West Barnstable, MA. Yesterday you put her on notice by delivery in hand at her home of the Board of Health's rescheduled hearing set for Tuesday, January 20, 2004, at 7 p.m. This letter is to put you on notice that tomorrow Ms. Tri is undergoing required important medical treatment off Cape that will most likely preclude her presence at next Tuesday's rescheduled Board of Health hearing. Therefore, kindly accept this letter as a request that the Board continue its rescheduled hearing for at least two weeks to give Ms. Tri an opportunity to recover and thus be present when the Board of Health next convenes to deliberate and decide the fate of her license. 1 C*SIB IT-- I = .� • As additional grounds for a continuance, this office has been notified that the members of the Board of Health have expressed an interest in a walk-through of the property. In the interim, from now to a continuance date, a mutually agreeable date might be arranged for the walk-through. Thank you for your consideration and feel free to contact this office at anytime. Sincerely,/ ! s th ny va cc: �f Zri Fr . CI a, Esq. 1 • oti roy A TRUE COPY ATTEST I - Town of Barnstable • � 3:�c y �ie , `_el. y�� Regulatory Services y, sysrasrE.l��` T. �~ MASS. a i - Thomas F. Geiler,Director o pu-nr St ER)FF ?0 1639.A�w�;. �.�► . Public Health Division Thomas McKean;Director • 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 • Office: 508-862-4644 fax: 508-790-63 04 January 30,2004 Mrs.Brenda Tri Diamond Edge Farm 2051 Main Street • Barnstable,MA 02668 NOTICE OF REVOCATION OF STABLE LICENSE You are hereby officially notified that during the public meeting held on January 20, 2004,the Board of Health voted unanimously to revoke your stable license. The Board . voted:o place the revocation into effect fourteen(14) days after the date of that public. meeting, on February 3,2004. A copy of the Board's findings,minus exhibits,is attached for your reference. In view of the delay in transmitting this notice,the Board of Health will delay enforcement action if necessary until on or after February 17,2004. All horses shall be • safely removed from your property no later than February 17,2004.- Failure to comply with this order could result in legal action. • PER RDE d E BOARD OF HEALTH / . Way Miller,M.D. BAORD OF HEALTH TOWNOF BARiNSTA.BLE • Cc: Dr.Victor Cillis • Frank Diluna,Esq. Anthony Alva,Esq. • 1:TriRevocation • EXHIBIT— ! 5 Pg.- 1 . ., .:-. • • •• •• , r ,' • • • .,, . . . .• . ..- . • ,• ••...- . . . .. .... . •• • .'.• ... •.. ,. ' . . „. • , .. . .:., . • • •• • • „ . . . • ' . .• • • - ' • • . - • ,....-• INAMEOFOFFENOER BAR porenci a_ 1 ri • TOWN OF . - ADDRESS OF OFFENDER . •aosi ivial -.- ty-ee,-1-. . il ' BARNSTABLE CITY STATE.71P CODE i , •-.1 .. KVS 1 al Zi bit, MV/MB REGISTRATION NUMBER .•';CP-----9.!Ti.`::, •, OFFENSE,......,.., . ...$4 ra i lure -16 pr Trnii ( over- c tz a s pose ;F_ 0 ,639......." . ..-,•,,,,,, . f,e1.72_ , /v.., 5......_6 < : R EC,L(c.ii--7/00 • -1 L1.1 > . , TIME AND DATE OF VIOLATION - LOCATION OF VIOLATION NOTICE OF —31 00 (AM. Ar .M.. P. .)ON .-17 /"i.20C2: --a0=31 mictuv sril -r Le, < ORCING PERSON, ENFTING DEPT/, BADGE NO. VIOLATION tvlo_KE.4 11( ro 1_,./,c, 14 e el 1 to) cr) a 1— - -- OF TOWN I HEREBY ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF CITATION X • EL' ORDINANCE 0 Unable to obtain'signature of offender: THE NONCRIMINAL FINE FOR THIS OFFENSE IS I S SO "1/1 I _1;Lr • . Date mailed e L.11_, u..) • .OR YOU HAVE THE FOLLOWING ALTERNATIVES WITH REGARD TO DISPOSITION OF THIS MATTER.EITHER OPTION(11 OR OPTION(2)WILL OPERATE AS A FINAL °- . . • DISPOSITION WITH NO RESULTING CRIMINAL RECORD. REGULATION C0 (1)You may elect to pay the above fine,ei:her by appearing in person between 8:30 A.M.and 4:00 P.M..Monday through Friday,legal holidays excepted, belore:The Barnstable Clerk,230 South Street,Hyannis,MA 02601.or by mailing a check.money order or postal note lo Barnstable Clerk,P.O.Box 2430. --I o_ Hyannis,MA 02601,WITHIN TWENTY-ONE(21)DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE. (2)II you desire to contest this matter in a noncriminal proceeding,you may do so by making writlen request to DISTRICT COURT DEPARTMENT.FIRST BARNSTABLE DIVISION.COURT COMPOUND,MAIN STREET.BARNSTABLE.MA 02630.Attn:21D Noncriminal Hearings and enclose a copy of this citation for a hearing. (3)II you lail to pay the above offense or lo request a hearing within 21 days,or if you fail to appear for the hearing or to pay any line determined al the hearing . to be due,criminal complaint may be issued against you. 14/44-1-2-2717 0 I HEREBY ELECT the first option above.confess to the offense charged,and enclose payment in the amount at S Signature ..4 • . .. , I. . . . - - - . • ,.• . ,, .... ., „ - , . . ... • . . . . • •••.t • . . • • • . .• . • • . , • • . : . ' -• . • . . . . . . . . . ,• • • ...,. . . . • I . • EX,1-1113 11 - Pg.- DOCKET NO. CRIMINAL COMPLAINT 0325 CR 0023;31'a. Trial Court-of'Massachusetts ° District-C"butt Department DEFENDANT NAME COURT NAME&ADDRESS BRENDA TRI BARNSTABLE DISTRICT COURT DATE OF COMPLAINT 'DATE OF OFFENSE NO.OF COUNTS - ROUTE 6A, P.0. BOX 427 7/22/03 4/14/03 1 BARNSTABLE MA 02630-0427 OFFENSE LOCATION POLICE DEPT.OF OFFENSE (508) 375-6600 BARNSTABLE BARNSTABLE POLICE DEPT. POLICE INCIDENT NO. ARREST DATE WARRANT ON COMPLAINT DATE ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED FOR 8/22/03 The undersigned complainant,on behalf of the Commonwealth, on oath complains that on the date(s) indicated the defendant committed the offense(s) listed below and on any attached pages. . 1. 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION on APRIL 14, 2003 did FAIL TO PROPERLY COVER OR DISPOSE OF MANURE, in violation of NUISANCE CONTROL REGULATION #1, § PART X: STABLE REGULATION. • SIGNATURE OF COMP ANT SWORN TO BEFORE ME • DET CTIVE R HARD S. MORSE ( CLERK-MAGISTRATE/ASST.CLERK/DEPUTY ASST.CLERK ZCI 722/03 3:14 PM EXHIBIT- \ 7 : ) - . Commonwealth of Massachusetts Off c?al'Use,only gi— =0 Department of Fire Services Permit No: Z/f/7Y.....3� BOARD OF FIRE PREVENTION REGULATIONS Occupancy and Fee Checked \w* ''11.i; [Rev. 111991 (leave blank) APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO PERFORM ELECTRICAL WORK Al work to be performed in accordance with the Massachusetts Electrical Code(MEC),527 CMR 12.00 (PLEASE PRINT IN INK OR TYPE ALL INFORMATION) Date: City or Town of: Barnstable To the Inspector of Wires: By this application the undersigned gives notice of his or her intention to perform the electrical work described below. 74 Location(Street&Number) „,C SI el,-„ Sr Map ‘,74 Parcel G pdec6 6 • Owner or Tenant i ,' C,'// $ Telephone No.5o p--36,2-/Sdf..2_ Owner's Address ,06.s / yl'Jb S?" it .,2 „j 144 4L /I/19. 62.b , Is this permit in conjunction with a building permit? Yes ❑ No I31 (Check Appropriate Box) Purpose of Building Utility Authorization No. j Existing Service �l Amps ' / //o Volts Overhead Undgrd® No.of Meters JGe-,S,Zr,/t New Service Amps / Volts Overhead❑ Undgrd 0 No.of Meters Number of Feeders and Ampacity Location and Nature of Proposed Electrical Work: L t f,(f -{-c 6,0 7.4 Ao dz....f �,..,d,�,, ,^art' ..etc ,.n....it a -e i+.:.- 1e," 5-1. LA % r.'41%n e # t C 4.,-;,--? i /t 5'a /C.-t'J%c4 f/6,?e� (Completion of the fallowing table maybe waived/by the Inspector of Wires. o.of Total No.of Recessed Fixtures No.of CeiL-Susp.(Paddle)Fans Transformers KVA No.of Lighting Outlets I No.of Hot Tubs ,Generators KVA Above In- (No.of Emergency Lighting i No.of Lighting Fixtures 4 Swimming Pool gt'nd. ❑ brad. ``IBatter�Units No.of Receptacle Outlets ) No.of Oil Burners 1 FIRE ALARMS No.of Zones 11 No.of Detection and No.of Switches I No.of Gas Burners Initiating Devices No.of Air Coact. Total No.of Alerting Devices No.of Ranges No. Heat Pump Number I Tons__ 1 KW No.'of Self-Contained No.of Waste Disposers Totals: i f " Detection/Alerting Devices M No.of Dishwashers Space/Area Heating KW Local 0 Counicipalnnection ❑ Other Heating Appliances KW Security vstems: No.of Dryers No.of bevices or Equivalent , No.of Water 'No.of No.of Data Wiring: Heaters KW Signs Ballasts No.of Devices or Equivalent Telecommunications Wiring: No.Hydromassage Bathtubs No.of Motors Total HP No.of Devices or Equivalent - OTHER: ,i Attach additional detail if desired,or as required by the Inspector of Wires. INSURANCE COVERAGE: Unless waived by the owner,no permit for the performance of electrical work may issue unless the licensee provides proof of liability insurance including"completed operation"coverage or its substantial equivalent. The undersigned certifies that such coverage is in force,and has exhibited proof of same to the permit issuing office. CHECK ONE: INSURANCE 0 BOND 0 OTHER ❑ (Specify;) /t/ Act (Expiration Date)Estimated Value of Electrical Work: 6 CJ 0 `- (When required by municipal policy.): Work to Start: (0-..2.5-•a? Inspections to be requested in accordance with MEC Rule 10,and upon completion. I certify,under the pains and penalties of perjuty,that the information on this application is true and cotnplete.. FIRM NAME: ---- --b.:"....,,,...-4, r n• LTC.NO.: Licensee: Signature 7` f.-z,,c_• /fir•' LIC.NO.: (if applicable.enter'exempt"in the license number line.) Bus.Tel.No.: Sew Yoe-e••: - Address: _ Alt.Tel.No.: OWNER'S INSURANCE Vv 4JVER: I am aware:hat the Licensee-does not have the:liability insurance coverage normally required by law. By my signature below;I hereby waive this requirement. I am the(check one),®'ow•ner, ❑owner's agent. Owner/Agent-- ' ---r-- .. • ,,,..., ,. . . ,-. c•.... ..... , I pF.R,VIIT FF.F.r ,T FX°HIBIT- 1 Bg, , • APPLICATIOWNO O325f. AC 0 a6147- Tnal Court of Massachusetts 1°4ra District Court.Departrhent The cemplainant named below requests that NEXT SCHEDULED EVENT CODE AND DATE COURT NAME ' a ctmplaint issue-against the defendant for - - the offense(s)listed below. CH 2/05/2004 BARNSTABLE DISTRICT COURT NO.COUNTS POLICE DEPT POLICE INCIDENT NO. OFFENSE DATE OFFENSE LOCATION ARREST DATE CITATION NO. 9 BAR 99/99/99 BAR BAR67661 DEFENDANT IDENTIFICATION. . LAST NAME FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME CILLIS BRENDA ALIAS NAME(LAST,FIRST,MI) STREET ADDRESS 2051 MAIN STREET CITY STATE ZIP HOME PHONE W BARNSTABLE MA 02668 CITY OF BIRTH STATE OF BIRTH SID NO. PCF NO. LICENSE STATE .7 MARITAL STATUS SEX ETHNICITY HEIGHT WEIGHT COMPLEXION 'HAIR EYES P•5''f:'agV,k"*.5Ria'NV4r!If5R:AS:*VNI'gi?.MaiVRA::WOFEENsEiNFORKATtOkeAgRagtWaKatVRM-ZgnngtEPM CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 1 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 10, 2003 LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 2 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 12, 2003 LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 3 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 13 , 2003 . LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 4 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 14, 2003 , - LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC JAIL? IF NOT IN CUSTODY,BAILED TO COMPLAINANT FIRST CODEFENDANT NAME,IF ANY N DETECTIVE RICHARD S. MORSE FIRST FOUR WITNESS NAME(S) NAME(S)OF EMPLOYER(S)OF DEFENDANT FROM TO MOTHER'S MAIDEN NAME(LAST,FIRST,MI) FATHER'S NAME(LAST,FIRST,MI) EMPLOYER PHONE DEFENDANT WORK PHONE OCCUPATION. REMARKS AC 2/04/04 1:35 PM' - , - . - - EXHIBIT- Lg. Pg.-. ARPEIZA- 'G LAI (APPLICATION NO DEFENDANT LAST NAME Q3�2.5 AC;: 006147 CILLIS CHAP/SEC/CUB, DESCRIPTION - OFFENSE DATE 5 9.99.999 N11S.CEL;LA TEO.US' STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 17, 2003 LIGHTS POLES': ERECTED`' WT.T.-HO:UT` OLD` KINGS: HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470- SEC- 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 6 999999 MISCELLANEOUS. STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 18, 2003 • LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 7 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 19, 2003 LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 8 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 20, 2003 LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 9 999999 MISCELLANEOUS STATUTORY VIOLATION NOVEMBER 21, 2003 rt LIGHT POLES ERECTED WITHOUT OLD KINGS HIGHWAY APPROVAL CHAP 470 SEC . 6 OLD KINGS HIGHWAY REGIONAL HISTORIC CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE It CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE 1,1 CHAP/SEC/SUB • DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE • CHAP/SEC/SUB DESCRIPTION OFFENSE DATE AC2 2104/04 1:35PM EXHIBIT- ,R Pg.-2 oiTHE Town of Barnstable ' 's�� Regulatoryr i Services ces anxxjTABLy Thomas F.Geiler,Director Building Division Tom Perry, Building Commissioner 200 Main Street, Hyannis,MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4038 Fax: 508-790-6230 November 17,2003 Jeffrey Lauzon Building Inspector Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services Building Division 200 Main St Hyannis,Ma 02061 Re: 2051 Main St,West Barnstable To Whom It May Concern: The following shall represent an overview of the events and circumstances resulting in the fines assessed to Victor and Brenda Cillis,2051 Main St,West Barnstable. 11-7-2001 Complaint received from concerned neighbor that light poles were being erected 11-21-2001 Letter written advising Victor and Brends Cillis of zoning violations concerning light poles 06-17-2003 Letter written again advising Victor and Brenda Cillis to obtain the proper permit for the light poles or dismantle them immediately 06-27-03 Wiring permit obtained for an unapproved gazebo 07-16-03 Memo written describing a meeting had between Victor and Brenda Cillis and David Mattos and Jason Silva.Memo explains how the Cillis's were civil and agreed to remove the light poles 07-29-03 Letter written giving Victor and Brenda Cillis until August 8,2003 to resolve violations or be subject to daily fines in the amount of$100.00 for each day of non-compliance 9-22-03 Daily inspections of site begin.Light poles are still up 10-17-03 As of this date the light poles have remained and additionally a gazebo has been constructed also without approval ‘.c4:2: '414. TOWN OF BARNSTABLE • SARNSTAeLZ. • OFFICE OF TOWN ATTORNEY NthMA99. t6,9. 367 MAIN STREET rEo HYANNIS, MASSACHUSETTS 02601-3907 ROBERT D.SMITH, Town Attorney TEL.(508)862-4620 RUTH J.WEIL, 1st Assistant Town Attorney FAX#(508)862-4724 T.DAVID HOUGHTON,Assistant Town Attorney March 5, 2004 CLAIRE R.GRIFFEN, Legal Assistant CLAUDETTE BOOKBINDER, Legal Clerk Scott W. Nickerson, Esq., Clerk Barnstable Superior Court, Civil County Court Complex, Main Street P.O. Box 425 Barnstable, MA 02630 Re: C.A. No. BACV 2004-0084 Tri, et al v. Miller et al, Town of Barnstable Board of Health and Perry, Building Commissioner Our File Ref: #2003-0213 Dear Mr. Nickerson: Enclosed please find the Defendants-Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim's Answer to Plaintiffs' Verified Complaint in the above matter together with Certificate of Service which we would appreciate your filing with the Court. Thank you. Very truly yours, 77. Cxti:(.:() TDH:cg T. David.Houghton, Assistant Town Attorney Encs. Town of Barnstable cc: Anthony Alva, Esq. cc: Thomas McKean, Director, Barnstable Board of Health `.cc: Thomas Perry, Building Commissioner, Town of Barnstable [2003-0213\nickltr2] COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS BARNSTABLE, ss: SUPERIOR COURT C.A. No. BACV 2004-00084-A BRENDA M. TRI, d/b/a ANSWER TO PLAINTIFFS' DIAMOND EDGE FARM, VERIFIED COMPLAINT VICTOR CILLIS, [and] WITH COUNTERCLAIM. LEIGH-ANNE SOUZA, Plaintiffs, v. BOARD OF HEALTH of the TOWN OF ) ) BARNSTABLE, as constituted by its ) Members, WAYNE MILLER, Chairman, SUMNER KAUFFMAN, SUSAN G. RASK, ) [and] BUILDING COMMISSION, TOWN ) OF BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY, ) Defendants. ) BOARD OF HEALTH of the TOWN OF ) ) BARNSTABLE, as constituted by its ) Members, WAYNE MILLER, Chairman, SUMNER KAUFFMAN, SUSAN G. RASK, ) [and] BUILDING COMMISSION, TOWN ) OF BARNSTABLE, THOMAS PERRY, ) and ) John C. Klimm, as he is the Town ) Manager of the Town of Barnstable, ) Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim, ) ) v. ) BRENDA M. TRI, d/b/a DIAMOND EDGE ) FARM, Defendant-in-Counterclaim. ) ) As to STATEMENT OF CASE: 1) The introductory paragraphs of Plaintiffs' Complaint are unnumbered and will be referred to as the "first", "second", "third", "fourth", "fifth" and "sixth" introductory [2003-0213\answertrij 1 paragraph under "Statement of Case" of the Plaintiffs' Complaint in Defendants' Answer to said complaint as follows: As to the "first" paragraph: ADMIT the averments set forth in the "first" introductory paragraph under Statement of the Case of Plaintiffs' Complaint. As to the "second" paragraph: Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in the "second" introductory paragraph under Statement of the Case of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to their truth or falsity. As to the "third" paragraph: - The averments contained in the "third" introductory paragraph under Statement of the Case of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. As to the "fourth" paragraph: The averments contained in the "fourth" introductory paragraph under Statement of the Case.of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer, is necessary. As to the "fifth" paragraph: DENY the averments contained in the "fifth" introductory paragraph under Statement of the Case of Plaintiffs' Complaint. As to the "sixth" paragraph: [2003-0213\answertr] 2 The averments contained in the "sixth" introductory paragraph under Statement of the Case of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. - In further answering, DENY all averments contained in,the unnumbered averments under Statement of the Case of Plaintiffs' Complaint not hereinbefore admitted. As to THE PARTIES: 2) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "1" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to its truth or falsity. 3) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "2" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to its truth or falsity. 4) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "3" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to its truth=or falsity. 5) ADMIT the averments set forth in paragraph "4" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 6) ADMIT the averments set forth in paragraph "5" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. As to FACTS (Complaint Against the Board of Health): 7) Neither admit nor deny the averments as set forth in paragraph "6" of Plaintiffs' Complaint but state that copy of the license annexed to Plaintiffs' Complaint as Exhibit "1" speaks for itself and specifically DENY each and every allegation not specifically admitted herein. (2003-0213\answertri] 3 8) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "7" of Plaintiffs' Complaint but state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 1" speaks for itself, and specifically DENY each and every allegation not specifically admitted herein. 9) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "8" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments therein. 10) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "9" of Plaintiffs' Complaint but state that the documents referred to therein as "Exhibit 2" and "Exhibit 3" speaklor themselves, and specifically DENY each and every allegation not specifically admitted herein. 11) ADMIT the averments set forth in paragraph "10" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 4" speaks for itself. 12) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "11" of Plaintiffs' Complaint but state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 4" speaks for itself, and specifically-DENY each and every allegation not specifically admitted herein. 13) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "12" of Plaintiffs' Complaint but state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 5" speaks for itself. [2003-0213\answertri] 4 14) ADMIT the averments set forth in paragraph "13" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 6" speaks for itself. 15) ADMIT the general averments contained in paragraph numbered "14" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; but in further answering each of the sub-paragraphs marked "(a)", "(b)", "(c)" and "(d)" state as follows: (a) ADMIT the averments set forth in sub-paragraph (a) of paragraph "14" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 7" speaks for itself. (b) ... ADMIT the averments set forth in sub-paragraph (b) of paragraph "14" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 8" speaks for itself. (c) ADMIT the averments set forth in sub-paragraph (c) of paragraph "14" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 9" speaks for itself. (d) ADMIT the avermentsset forth in sub-paragraph (d) of paragraph "14" of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 10" speaks for itself. 16) ADMIT the averments set froth in paragraph "15" of Plaintiffs' Complaint and in further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 11" speaks for itself. 17) ADMIT the averments set forth in paragraph "16" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 18) ADMIT the averments set forth in paragraph "17" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. (2003-0213\answertri] 5 19) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "18" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 20) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "19" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 21) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph in paragraph "20" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments therein. 22) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "21" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments therein. 23) ADMIT only so much of the averments set forth in paragraph "22" of Plaintiffs' Complaint wherein Plaintiff alleges that the board members refused to continue the hearing, but specifically DENY the remaining averments therein contained. 24) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "23" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, but state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 15" - speaks for itself, and specifically DENY the remaining averments therein. 25) DENY all other averments contained in the general numbered averments of Plaintiffs' Complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted. AS TO COUNT I (Stay of Enforcement and/or Preliminary Injunction) 26) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments as set forth in paragraphs "1" through "23" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "24" of COUNT I of Plaintiffs' Complaint in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. [2003.0213\answertril 6 27) Neither admit nor deny the averments set forth in paragraph "25" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendant has insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments therein. 28) Neither admit nor deny the averments the averments set forth in paragraph "26" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendant has insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments therein. 29) DENY the averments set forth in paragraph "27" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 30) DENY the averments set forth in paragraph "28" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 31) DENY the averments set forth in paragraph "29" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 32) DENY the averments set forth in paragraph "30" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 33) DENY each and every other averment in said COUNT I of Plaintiffs' Complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted. COUNT II (Violation of Open Meeting Law, Stay of Enforcement, and/or Preliminary Injunction (G.L. c. 39, §23B) 34) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "30" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "31" of COUNT II of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 35) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "32" of Plaintiffs' Complaint and in further answering, state that the documents referred to therein as "Exhibit 13" and "Exhibit 14" speak for themselves. 36) Neither admits nor denies the averments set forth in paragraph "33" of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendants have insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained therein. [2003-0213\answertri] 7 37) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "34" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, except that Defendants are without sufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averment that Plaintiff Brenda M. Tri was in the process of recovering from illness or injury at the time of the January 20, 2004 hearing. 38) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "35" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 39) DENY the averments as set forth in paragraph "36" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 40) DENY each and every other averment in said COUNT II of Plaintiffs' Complaint not hereinbefore admitted. COUNT III 41) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "36" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "37" of COUNT III of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 42) The averments contained in paragraph "38" of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answeris necessary; and further answering, Defendants state that the fines for violations of the'stable regulation have been amended and increased to one hundred dollars pursuant to section 2 of Chapter IV of the General Ordinances of the Town of Barnstable. 43) The averments contained in paragraph "39" of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary and further answering, Defendants state that the fines for violations of the stable regulation have been [2003-0213\answertril 8 amended and increased to one hundred dollars pursuant to section 2 of Chapter IV of the General Ordinances of the Town of Barnstable. 44) DENY each and every other averment in said COUNT III contained in Plaintiffs' Complaint not hereinbefore admitted. COUNT IV 45) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "39" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "40" of COUNT IV of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 46) The averments contained in paragraph "41" of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 47) The averments contained in paragraph "41" of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. COUNT V 48) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "41" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "42" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set-forth herein. 49) ADMIT only so much of the averments contained in paragraph "43" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint wherein it is alleged "On or about April 14, 2003, the Board of Health by its authorized agent issued a Notice of Violation" and in further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 16" speaks for itself. 50) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "44" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint. [2003-0213\answertri] 9 51) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "45" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 52) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "46" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 53) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "47" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 54) DENY the averments contained in paragraph "48" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 55) The averments contained in paragraph "49" of COUNT V of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 56) DENY each and every other averment contained in said COUNT IV of Plaintiffs' Complaint not hereinbefore admitted. COUNT VI 57) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "49" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "50" of COUNT VI of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in'the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 58) The averments contained in paragraph "51" of COUNT VI of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a,conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 59) The averments contained in paragraph "52" of COUNT VI of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 60) The averments contained in paragraph "53" of COUNT VI of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. [2003-0213\answertri] 10 61) The averments contained in paragraph "54" of COUNT VI of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 62) DENY each and every averment not specifically admitted herein. COUNT VII (The Building Department) 63) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "54" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "55" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 64) Neither admit nor deny the averments as set forth in paragraph "56" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, but state that the document annexed to Plaintiffs' Complaint and marked Exhibit "18" speaks for itself. 65) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "57" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 66) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "58" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 67) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "59" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint, and in further answering, state that the document referred to therein as "Exhibit 18" speaks for itself.. 68) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "60" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 69) ADMIT the averments as set forth in paragraph "61" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 70) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "62" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint. [2003-0213\answertr] 11 71) DENY the averments contained in paragraph "63" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 72) The averments contained in paragraph "64" of COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for a conclusion of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 73) DENY each and every averment not specifically admitted in COUNT VII of Plaintiffs' Complaint herein. COUNT VIII 74) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "64" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "65" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 75) DENY the averments contained in paragraph "66" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint; and further answering, state that the Old King's Highway Regional Historic District was established by the Acts set forth in paragraph "66" of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 76) The averments contained in paragraph "67" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' -Complaint call for conclusions of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 77) The averments contained in paragraph "68" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for conclusions of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 78) The averments contained in paragraph "69" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for conclusions of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 79) Neither admits nor denies the averments set forth in paragraph "70" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint by reason that said Defendant has insufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the averments therein. [2003-0213\answertrij 12 • 80) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "71" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint, and furthering answering state that work undertaken pursuant to the electrical permit issued to Plaintiff Brenda M. Tri is not within the jurisdiction of the Old King's Highway Regional Historic District Act. 81) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "72" of COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint, and further answering state that copy of the application annexed to Plaintiffs' Complaint and marked Exhibit "18" did not contain any statement that any lighting fixtures would be placed on anything other than existing structures. 82) DENY each and every averment not specifically admitted in COUNT VIII of Plaintiffs' Complaint herein. COUNT IX 83) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "72" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "73" of COUNT IX of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. 84) The averments contained in paragraph "74" of COUNT IX of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for conclusions of law and, therefore, no answer is-necessary. 85) DENY each and every averment not specifically admitted in COUNT IX of Plaintiffs' Complaint herein. COUNT X 86) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "74" of Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in paragraph "75" of COUNT X of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein. [2003-0213\answertri] 13 87) The averments contained in paragraph "76" of COUNT X of Plaintiffs' Complaint call for conclusions of law and, therefore, no answer is necessary. 88) ADMIT the averments contained in paragraph "77" of COUNT X of Plaintiffs' Complaint. 89) DENY each and every averment not specifically admitted in COUNT X of Plaintiffs' Complaint herein. COUNT XI 90) Defendants repeat and reallege those answers to the averments set forth in paragraphs "1" through "77" of all counts in Plaintiffs' Complaint, as realleged in the unnumbered paragraph of COUNT XI of Plaintiffs' Complaint, in the same manner as though fully set forth herein; and in further answering, state that no subsequent paragraphs are contained in Count XI of Plaintiffs' Complaint to explain Plaintiffs' realleging all prior paragraphs as an alternative to "COUNT VII" of its Complaint, nor are any other averments made to support the additional count numbered "COUNT Xl" to Plaintiffs' Complaint. 91) DENY each and every other averment contained in the general averments and all counts of Plaintiffs' Complaint herein contained, not hereinbefore'specifically admitted herein. FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: The Plaintiffs are barred from recovery under their Complaint because said Plaintiffs did not commence this action within the time specified under the applicable statutory limitations and, therefore, Plaintiffs' Complaint should be dismissed. [2003-0213\answertri] 14 SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: The Plaintiffs' claims fail to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, and, therefore, Plaintiffs' Complaint should be dismissed. THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE: This Court lacks jurisdiction over the subject matter of Plaintiffs' Complaint. WHEREFORE, the Defendants respectfully pray for judgment against the Plaintiffs as follows: (1) That a decree be entered dismissing Plaintiffs' Complaint herein on all counts in all respects; (2) That judgment be entered in Defendants' favor under all counts of. Plaintiffs' Complaint; (3) That Defendants be granted their costs, disbursements, and attorneys' fees in the defense of this action; and, (4) That Defendants be granted such other and further relief as to this Court it deems just and appropriate. COUNTERCLAIM 1) Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim, Wayne Miller, M.D., Susan G. Rask, R.S. and Sumner Kaufman, M.S.P.H., as they are the members of the Town of Barnstable Board of Health, are the officers responsible for enforcing the General Laws of the Commonwealth and the Town of Barnstable health regulations as they relate to the operation of stables. [2003-0213\answertri] 15 2) Plaintiff-in-Counterclaim, John C. Klimm, as he is the Town Manager of the Town of Barnstable, is the chief executive officer of the said town under its charter and is generally charged with the enforcement of all laws within the Town of Barnstable. 3) Plaintiff-in-Counterclaim, Town of Barnstable, is a municipal corporation with a principal office at New Town Hall, 367 Main Street, Hyannis, Barnstable County, Massachusetts, 02601-3907. 4) Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, is an individual operating a stable under the firm name and style of Diamond's Edge Farm, having a usual place of business at 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts, 02630. 5) Pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155, the Board of Health of a city or town having a population greater than five thousand inhabitants, is authorized to adopt such regulations or orders as in its judgment the public health requires for the number of animals and storage and handling of manure in a stable. 6) Pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155, no person shall erect, occupy or use for a stable any building in a city, or in a town having a population greater than five thousand inhabitants, unless such use is licensed by the board of health. { 7) The Town of Barnstable is organized under a city form of government pursuant to a charter adopted in April, 1989 pursuant to Mass. Const. Amend. Art. 89 § 3. 8) A true copy of Part X, Stable Regulation, adopted by the Town of Barnstable Board of Health pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155, is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and made a part hereof. [2003-02131answertrij 16 9) Section 7 of the stable regulation prohibits the accumulation of waste matter on premises operated or used as a stable. 10) On or about June 26, 2003, Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, was granted stable license number 61 pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155 for the conduct of a stable for up to fourteen (14) horses "in conformity with the statutes and ordinances relating thereto" on the premises having a street address of 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts (hereinafter "the property") for a period of one year from July 1, 2003 to June 30, 2004. A true copy of the license is attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and made a part hereof. 11) The property is shown on Town of Barnstable Assessor's Map 216 as parcels 076-BOO, 076-WOO and 075-002 (hereinafter "the property"). A copy of Town of Barnstable Geographic Information Systems aerial photograph dated April 28, 2001 showing the property and its immediate surroundings with Assessors parcel lines and numbers superimposed is attached as Exhibit "C" and made a part hereof. 12) The property is bounded on the north by single-family residences supplied by individual private water supply wells located on each residential lot, and on the south by the campus of Cape Cod Community College. The groundwater direction flow is towards the north. 13) The stable license granted to Defendant-in-Counterclaim Brenda M. Tri was one of sixty-three stable licenses granted by Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members for the same period and was for the third highest number of horses. [2003-02131answertri] 17 14) On July 24, 2003, complaints were received at the Town of Barnstable Regulatory Services Department office from several neighbors regarding manure, odors, and fencing at the property. 15) On July 28, 2003, Town of Barnstable Health Inspector Donna Z. Miorandi, R.S. and Public Health Division Director Thomas A. McKean, C.H.O., investigated the complaints and observed an accumulation of non-composted manure at the southeast corner of the property further shown on photographs taken by Donna Z. Miorandi on July 28, true copies of which are attached hereto as Exhibit "D1-3" and made a part hereof. 16) A written order to cease and desist the placement of non-composted manure onto the top of the ground, to cease and desist composting manure, and to remove all future manure from the property on a weekly basis (hereinafter "the order") was issued to Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, by certified mail dated July 29 and received July 30, 2003, a true copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "E" and made a part hereof. 17) Town of Barnstable Director of Public Health, Thomas A. McKean, received a letter dated August 6, 2003 from Attorney Francis A. DiLuna bearing the letterhead of Murtha Cullina; LLP stating that the firm represented Diamond's Edge Farm and petitioning for a hearing by the Board of Health on the order. The letter further stated that manure would be removed from the property on a weekly basis in compliance with the order. A true copy of the letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "F" and made a part hereof. [2003-02131answerrij 18 18) The Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members scheduled a hearing on the order as requested by Attorney DiLuna to be held on September 2, 2003. However, on September 2, 2003, Attorney DiLuna requested that the hearing be continued to the next available meeting date, a true copy of which request is attached hereto as Exhibit "G" and made a part hereof. Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members granted the continuance request, rescheduled the hearing for September 18, 2003, and extended the order up to the rescheduled hearing date. 19) On September 18, 2003, an individual who identified himself as Dr. Victor Cillis appeared before Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members at the time of the hearing on behalf of the Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, and requested that the hearing be postponed. Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members granted a postponement, rescheduled the hearing on the order and scheduled a hearing on the suspension or revocation of Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri's stable license number 61 for October 30, 2003, and extended the order up to the rescheduled hearing date. 20), Notice was sent.by first class mail on October 6, 2003 to Defendant-in- Counterclaim Brenda M. Tri of the rescheduled hearing on the cease and desist order and hearing on revocation orsuspension of her stable license to be held on October 30, 2003, a true copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "H" and made a part hereof. 21) The Town of Barnstable Public Health Division received a complaint on September 26, 2003 regarding manure at the property. Health Inspector David Stanton, R.S., investigated the complaint on September 29, 2003 and observed an accumulation of non-composted manure on the ground at the southwest corner of the property shown [2003-02131answertri] 19 in the photographs taken by David Stanton on September 29, copies of which are attached as Exhibit "11-3" and made a part hereof. 22) On October 30, 2003, a document was received by telecopier at the Office of the Town Attorney reciting that it was transmitted by Defendant-in-Counterclaim Brenda M. Tri requesting that the hearing be postponed, a true copy of which is attached as Exhibit "J" and made a part hereof. Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim granted the postponement, rescheduled the hearings for December 16, 2003, and extended the order up to the rescheduled hearing date. 23) On November 5, 2003, the Public Health Division received a complaint about manure odors emanating from the property. Health Inspector David Stanton, R.S., and Director of Public Health Thomas McKean, C.H.O., investigated the complaint. During the investigation, they observed that additional quantities of non- composted manure had been accumulated at the same location in the southwest corner of the property where accumulation was first observed on September 29, 2003 as shown in the photographs taken by David Stanton on November 10, true copies of ¢which are attached as Exhibit "K1-3" and made a part hereof. 24) Notice dated November 20, 2003 of the December 16 hearings was forwarded to the Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, by certified mail, return receipt requested, addressed to the Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, at the property on November 13, 2003, but was returned to the Public Health Division Offices on December 1st, 2003 bearing the notation "unclaimed": Thereafter, Director of Public Health, Thomas McKean, and Health Inspector, David Stanton, personally delivered copies of the notice of hearing to the property on December 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th, [2003-02131answertril 20 2003. A true copy of the notice of hearing is attached hereto as Exhibit "L" and made a part hereof. 25) No request for continuance of the December 16, 2003 hearing date was communicated to the Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim, and neither Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, nor any representative appeared on her behalf at the hearing. At the conclusion of the hearing, Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members voted to close the hearing'and hold a special meeting on January 8, 2004 for the purpose of considering the adoption of findings of fact and taking action on the license. 26) Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members met on January 8, 2004 and granted Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri's request, which had been made by her Attorney, Francis A. DiLuna, to reopen the hearing closed on December 16, 2003 and afforded Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, the opportunity to present statements and materials to the Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim, concerning her conduct of the stable under her license numbered 61. 27) Part of the materials submitted to Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members by Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, through her Attorney during the reopened hearing on January 8th, 2004 consisted of receipts for manure removal, true copies of which are attached as Exhibits "M1-14" and made a part hereof. 28) During the reopened hearing on January 8, 2004, Health Inspector David Stanton, R.S., presented photographs taken by him during an inspection of the property on December 17, 2003 showing compost bin covers were left open and overfilled with non-composted manure, that the manure accumulation in the southwest corner of the property partially submerged in water standing on the property that extended onto an [2003-02131answertrij 21 adjacent portion of the campus of Cape Cod Community College, and erosion of the accumulation in the southeast portion of the property, true copies of which are attached hereto as Exhibit "N" and made a part hereof. 29) On January 20, 2004, Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members voted unanimously to revoke Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri's stable license numbered 61 effective February 3, 2004 based on findings of fact. A true copy of the findings adopted at the January 20th, 2004 meeting of Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim Board of Health members, without attached Exhibits, which are separately attached hereto as Exhibits "A" to "L," and "N1-5" is attached as Exhibit "0" and made a part hereof. 30) On February 3, 2004, notice of Plaintiffs-in Counterclaim Board of Health members revocation of Defendant-in-Counterclaim's stable license numbered 61 extending the time for compliance to February 17, 2004 was served on Defendant-in- Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, by a deputy sheriff. A true copy of the notice of revocation with return is attached as Exhibit "P" and made a part hereof. 31) Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, continues to operate a stable on the property without a license as of the date of the verified complaint in this action. 32) The actions of Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, in refusing to comply with the applicable provisions of the Town of Barnstable Health regulations applicable to the accumulation of animal waste on the property formerly licensed under license number 61 will continue to cause extreme prejudice to the public interest. 33) The actions of Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, in refusing to comply with the applicable provisions of the Town of Barnstable Health regulations [2003-0213\answertril 22 applicable to the accumulation of animal waste on the property formerly licensed under license number 61 will continue to cause irreparable harm to the public interest. 34) The actions of Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, in operating a stable without a license issued pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155 will continue to cause extreme prejudice to the public interest. 35) The actions of Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, in operating a stable without a license issued pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155 will continue to cause irreparable harm to the public interest. 36) The Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, cannot use the premises having a street address of 2051 Main Street, Barnstable for a stable without possession of a license issued pursuant to G.L. c. 111, §155. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim respectfully pray as to this counterclaim that this Court: (1) Enter a preliminary injunction and a permanent injunction against the Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, prohibiting her from maintaining animal waste accumulations for more than seven (7) days on the premises having a street address of 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts shown on Town of Barnstable; (2) Enter a preliminary injunction and a permanent injunction against the Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, prohibiting her from occupying, conducting, using or operating a stable on the premises having a street address of 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, Barnstable County, [2003=02131answertri] 23 Massachusetts unless and until such time as she has obtained a license therefor pursuant to the provisions of G.L. c. 111, §155; (3) Enter a judgment declaring that the Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, is prohibited from operating a stable on the premises having a street address of 2051 Main Street, Barnstable, Barnstable County, Massachusetts without a license so to do issued under the provisions of G.L. c. 111, §155; and, (4) Any other relief this Court deems is just and equitable. Dated: March 5, 2004. BOARD OF HEALTH, etc., et al, Town Manager, BUILDING COMMISSIONER, and TOWN OF BARNSTABLE, Defendants, and also JOHN C. KLIMM, as Plaintiffs-in-Counterclaim, By their Attorneys, jti:i.j ROBERT D. SMITH, Town At orney [B.B.O. No. 469980] RUTH J. WEIL, 1st Assistant Town Attorney [B.B.O. No. 519285] T. DAVID HOUGHTON, Assistant Town Attorney [B.B.O. No. 241160] 367 Main Street, New Town Hall Hyannis, Ma. 02601-3907 (508) 862-4620; (508) 862-4724 Fax TO: ANTHONY ALVA, ESQ. Attorney for Plaintiffs & Defendant in Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri 3291 Main Street P.O. Box 730 Barnstable, MA 02630 (508) 362-8342 [2003-0213\answertri] 24 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Barnstable, ss: March 5, 2004. I hereby certify under the pains and penalties of perjury, that I caused to be mailed by first-class mailing, postage prepaid, copies of the above document and the attached Affidavits of Thomas A. McKean, Donna Z. Miorandi and David W. Stanton to the attorney for the Plaintiffs & Defendant-in-Counterclaim, Brenda M. Tri, on the date first written above. Claire - riffen, Le a As ant Town of Barnstab 367 Main Street, ew Town Hall Hyannis, Ma 02601-3907 (508) 862-4620; (508) 862-4724 Fax [2003.0213\answertrij 25 LIST OF EXHIBITS for DEFEDANTS/PLAINTIFFS-IN-COUNTERCLAIM (Re: Tri, et al v. Miller, et al, Bd. of Health, Perry, Bldg. Cmsr.) Exh. Brief Description of Exhibit A Part X: Stable Regulation, Board of Health, Town of Barnstable B Stable License for 7/1/03 through 6/13/04 C GIS Aerial Photo, dated. 4/28/01 D-1 through D-3: Photos of non-composted manure, SE Corner of Subject Property, 7/28/03 E Cease & Desist Order 7/29/03 F Attorney DiLuna Letter to Bd. of Health, 8/6/03 G Request for Hearing from Attorney DiLuna before Bd. of Health, 9/2/03 H Notice of Hearing on Cease/Desist Order on Revocation, 10/6/03 I-1 through 1-3: Photos of non-composted manure, SW Corner, 9/29/03 J Request 10/30/03 by fax from B. Tri for postponement of upcoming Hearing & for extension of Hearing scheduled 12/16/03 K-1 through K-3: Photos of non-composted manue at SW Corner, 11/10/03 L 11/20/03 Certified Mail to Plaintiff, Tri, re Notice of Hearing on 12/16/03 returned to TOB marked "unclaimed" & subsequently hand-delivered personally by BOH M-1 through M-14: Receipts for Manure Removal from subject property N-1 through N-15: Photos of erosion of SE portion of property; portion of CC Community College 0 Findings (w/o exhibits) P Notice of Revocation cf Stable License [2003-0213\exhslist] • EXHIBIT A Susan G. Rask,R.S. Sumner Kaufman,M.S.P.H. Ralph A.Murphy,M.D. PART X: STABLE REGULATION ADOPTED 4/1/72, REVISED 7/15/93 of s roh, , ti BARYSTABLE. MS. es vbAS i639. .,4,c�f° d. Town of Barnstable Board of Health STABLE REGULATION 1. Under the authority of Massachusetts General Laws,Chapter 111,Section 155,no person shall erect, occupy or use for a stable any building or land for the housing of horses and/or ponies in t the Town of Barnstable, unless such use is authorized and licensed by the Board of Health and is in compliance with the zoning By-Laws of the Town of Barnstable. 2. The license fee for each horse and/or pony shall be established by the Board of Health and said license shall be effective July 1 of each calendar year and shall expire on June 30 of the succeeding calendar year. 3. No stable may be constructed within the Town of Barnstable unless a stable license is first obtained from the Board of Health. The construction of stables shall be in conformity with the Barnstable Building Code. 4. Stables shall conform to the following: 96 (a) There shall be at least two(2)windows in every stable. (b) There shall be adequate ventilation in every stable. (c) Each stall shall be of adequate size so that any horse and/or pony shall have room to comfortably lie down or stand up. (d) There shall be adequate drainage either natural or artificial. (e) All flooring in any stable shall be acceptable to the Board of Health. 5. Land on which horses or ponies are pastured shall be fenced in such a manner as to prevent any damage to abutting property,trees or shrubbery. 6. No person; company or corporation shall erect, occupy or use a building for a livery or horse or pony stable for the keeping of horses or ponies unless such a stable or building is more than 200 feet from a church or school building and is more than fifty (50) feet from a building that is used as a dwelling or home. 7. Owners of stables housing horses or ponies must clean the manure from the stable at least once each day. Waste matter shall be disposed of in a sanitary manner and shall not be accumulated on the property. 8. No horse or pony shall be allowed to be pastured on any land unless said area is fifty (50)feet from a home or dwelling. 9. No person, company, or corporation shall allow a horse or pony to be pastured on any land unless said area is fifty(50) feet away from a private water supply well. A fence shall be erected to keep horses and ponies at least fifty(50)feet away from any private water supply well. 10. No person, company, or corporation shall erect, occupy or use a building, for a livery or horse or pony stable for the keeping of horses or ponies unless such stable or building is more than fifty (50)feet from a private water supply well. 11. No person shall store,dispose,or stockpile manure within 100 feet of a private water well. 12. Any owner or keeper of a horse or pony must provide stabling facilities for same. No horse or pony shall be allowed to remain out of doors at all times without having access to proper shelter. 13. Any person company, or corporation engaged in or desiring to engage in the business of slaughtering horses for the purpose of rendering them shall apply to the Board of Health for a license as required by the Massachusetts General Laws,Chapter 111,Section 154. 14. The Barnstable Board of Health reserves the right to make any decision of situations or problems that arise in regard to health or housing conditions that are not covered by this set of regulations. 15. Under Massachusetts General Laws, chapter 111, Section 157 anyone who violates the provisions of these regulations shall be punished by a fine for each day such violations continue. 97 The Barnstable Board of Health also reserves the right to suspend or revoke licenses previously issued if continued violations of these regulations occur. Brian R.Grady,R.S.,Chairman Susan G. Rask,R.S. Joseph C. Snow,M.D. PART XI: TOXIC AND HAZARDOUS MATERIAL REGULATIONS SECTION 1.00 FLOOR DRAIN REGULATION ADOPTED 9/28/99, EFFECTIVE DATE 10/8/99 &IKE Tot, BARNSI'ABLE.p,` "WOtrU'4 Town of Barnstable Board of Health FLOOR DRAIN REGULATION Section 1. PURPOSE OF REGULATION Whereas: • floor drains in industrial and commercial facilities are often tied to a system leading to a leaching structure(e.g. dry well, cesspool,leach field)or a septic system;and • poor management practices and accidental and/or intentional discharges may lead petroleum and other toxic or hazardous materials into these drainage systems in facilities managing these products;and 98 „ . \\\. ' . , . - , • , Pghp Fee t • MMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS $Fee 61 THE`CO Town of Barnstable _` Board of Health BRENDA TRI This is to Certify that W. BARNSTABLE, MA • 2051 MAIN STREET, Is Hereby Granted a License FORA STABLE m x 2 ANTED IN CONFORMITY WITH THE STATUTES THIS LICENSE IS GRANTED AND EXPIRES JUNE 30,2004 CA AND ORDINANCES RELATING TOR REOOKED. • UNLESS SOONER SUSPENDED SUSAN G. RASK, R,S., CHAIRMAN . \VV WAYNE MILLER, M.D. Jul 1,2003 SUMNER KAUFMAN, M•S•P'H' y AGENT THOMAS A. MCKEAN, R.S., CHO, x MAP 216 PARCELS 076-WOO, 076-BOO, & 075-002 1,1,.. ,;,. . -,,,-1,--•.,-;!'ill,...;;':_;:*.A.......1. t!,.-.:1-,,:" ?.,,•,.. :.- ---:: s,r,,-,-,,..:3...::1.15s. fi,atief...! , ,,,,;,,„!..:i.7:-,?::,..2.: , _• _. ..- •..,,, ..:•.,.?..4:..:;-,t. .... .. - . ------- -_, ' ---,,".,- .. Pr- '(;--..;?.., •..., • 17 - ' --1:r''..1.c. i'f.".r.• e::, i -...!-',', . .1-:'-'.., - --. ,-.... .- i,..5': .-.4.---. • .,L______.---- - ,I:- • : sag .4- i.. ..'.4..! •. ".; ' ,....%-•4' 1 ''•'! '‘,.......,:,:'......• ;'..•.7:;?.-„`":,''''' . '-.-----'' .....:4----- . . so.?.;,...r, ,', .-,•• :,...r- . ir'? 'e, lie, . .. , ..„1.,..1› —, ...,. -c..... ' ' `i-V-' '.. . • ., - ''''6'- ',1 41/2'.. :.11'.;/0a -, • ' :.;.:111:;:;./111P...:L.417 '.'-•_-'-'=•••-:-.;•.,;•-:X....--"";VV''..1:.•::::! ••••".. 4111/44.6,,i ,ar',V,I. ' ' ''.(..... . .''.. %-ill -''' :-.1A-b'.,-:# .' .. '.'. - -.' •,_,.,,— -Ar.,1.:5,',---•.:t . ,f.. ..... .L.L. ...,,,.. ..,,...„..-------77, ;, - — , ._..,------14.,--..v. -.•.. :t7 . . - ._..-. - .;:, ' :.,lefr.,.f.. ,•,r Y. ` Wlir 4.-N-f:: 1,-. ''11.''' • . i„,, ' -- •- 't:..--- ''---:-.---. r7- .:::'-"- ,, . ", C ---! -4i.-"-T:t4:41-Po.' ..i.:' ; '' -!...,„4' '; .-. '.,.: '..-1.4..i.:' :!,- !- .fr-,:&,,. .'-'? — \ .\' '_• : ' '''';',..i,'. 4 .- ' $' . ' ,Y,--i4,.,1",..:'..','• .,:i. • • ..• ' ' '''r ',.' .. .. 4... .• ....„.r..,lift.'.', . VW/0 n.: • k.'. , ''',..-c45:k., , -. ., , - 1.-._,0.- .,:—.)-)iii*:. *—.— . - • . 41.t/ii.:',.. ;t4k*‘..', -•f ''. "...:''' • ';'''..,s,;3:" ''4 i. .. •''' ' • . •' IP :- -'7.16\*- ''' ‘ . ' '''',4,4t,•••---:--ri. . ....... . .:--4-''4.) . T-7 ' A .. ..„,e;-tt , :i',10.1.,A '':.'•,'..-- . ..- .- ''4/ 4 -- ,''.!.. :'s<-14: , ;;',.....i- . ",.:• ..7,i-NA '.:'. . . ',...1r,c•it, • Ar7,7 .•'4,,r.'.14/ '• / . s: ... .!4, -. 17 ,.'-, ,{i".1,..7;.:;...:,.'.. 1-., .—. ,- .;?"-- • , - --',7-...• ,:, . .2. r ., .• o'..;:-.. o- , . 4 f 'lti.'-... ... 1,-' ": .--.•.1',. ;,;;.- , •..,-4-'....• , . '..,''.ft i' ' 0-&-,iri.!, ..t.C.. . ..,.5-:-.,..,.,'...,k-..,...1' ---%.:....,',-.'". ! tr•-..,'; . .. . - , .,-.... --•--- .--. -......,,v-• -..... '• . -......-2-- --,.--2,-, :',7 '.. ., ,.,;ia '..... .ti'‘..si'.•': .; . ., .' 4 1.1. f.'1171'17.11. .• i fii ' ',1:i1./. ..•, .i: 11111r!T.;•.1 .-,7t-,:. i1 ..x.--4.V‘ - t',' ' • •--• • ''' • {,-4, .1 .0.- cip, .. „„ iffit•R i 1. 1.1 1,• .1 " .• i-i 4 i ft•1 • 144 -1 :ii 1 - • ; 1, •: • •111';, .T•'1T• . ' iiT 'i;-.1 ..- — • ' .,-r)... ''.'.1-1'.;•It ,A'C ' 4.,,,ri 1, .r. .c, . • ,k,.-7' .• 4..20..A,4 ,. ,.• • r ','. -:,t .;.44;,. -.....6 .` * ' A, g. ii."4"L'ir-, .' .ir,..,,'4.- . i: .,." .A!i:• V '.....,• r,..,_ri v . -.. 44400,te, ., 4...,... •-: . .. . -.... .4,../.2. ::, / ,. .:: ..,...,....,:. .....i... .::„i, • .... .::.,. .... , ,..,;;, Y`• :-... ,,,,I ,itLOT,,. .4*., ,., -...--4,,,i. ,..',,T.,... . ?<go . • : •-• '..,,,...- -.: AlS1,-.:i1 T • 1•ii, ••-i1N f.'..,: t,. . :-.,. . • .... " ': . . ',./.4 .V.A t"'"4, :.. • -'":•:.hy •;,-At 'J.c.471)-'1;:f 44•Vibill,:ki .c .: '-• . . R ' 4' ‘1.* ,'!.?4,.„...-.. , '' ,: '.• . ' . '", r,7-' :....1 ,,W,:,,,. 4,61',:- :::".• .....-. . Of' , .,,,,g, -.. -, '...1.,.:,',-,,,,,-ti :;•.,'''....; •,.•1' ''.4't .. ;OS..1,..f, ..5i-E, ,,I,,,,E..,/ •-•!..,,ici,i -4. .,,, , AIN ..r.b.•L,.. R. 1 y,,-, • -• •4. ;-,' -,-4. . '...•' -I., , .7%,,, 4'. w.,;:- . ..•;:;..,..,,-:r (i.v,-. 1 '.', . Nr- .. - -,:.,.4;,47::,,,,,,.... 0- 7)„, ,-:Al., •'-'446. 0.411:00.:30,1*;f..'!"10,t..1.14ri '.'r. ,_,.t ..,_ 1, .' --. ...':''''' ,... .‘ • ...,r •...,,,.'4, '.,0!IA. 4..`..,':...r:.:,-'. 7,-, .e. •, ',''..; , , - .:_. ;-,.::-..i.:i:;,:... • •..„1''.1.; . ".,..- 1„„. te; i,-.I-,,....44 fif-ot.,...el,e.t.• .- ' ‘..: .;:,,..7,40.,.,%. , , -.4.„,,4,.. . ''''''. ''1.• .-i.t1,,W.,Y,' :..4.4..p.,,,..1..'1:7'.3•1;,,•;..4. .. , i.•;...,;.‘. ..,k•r? r :. .; 'f.'.. ''`'...11'.i •. ;' ..... -‘,',--,..„il._',, ,...*fr---", "•••••• 4:4 V,‘, ....4 ii.' ,r ,-.,,4 .. ;CI+ ••),:!1 '4.411..y.sMi4.1 CA f i-.'.1. ; •Y "r1•• Ix 4...TT. ' 1 I ....Fe'. .i.....-.::.1"''..'•. i , •1 •-11 '""...--• ••`",.4.• i 1 s'•14i 4r,:;,t . • , .. ).•yjeA -..11)?.S.'.. ... :,..N.,; ..; ..::.,-;44,.,4',.: .. • -, ;; .'%'.. ,-'0... .,' , •--;,:‘,., .., ' .' . • .. .. •., : ,.----; ; ,_ -;......:,., III 1::1.':- t 7ir.1-A,?.1',,' •1P.. ..wi,... ". • .--..,:11 sgit, :4f,•. 'evir,-A-• - •.,:% •-iNt- _If; :--4._t,-•... 1%, ,• ,.-, ,.!-„.. ,,,,.. • _ „,. ,,..,... ,./.. . .,_ : /„.,.,_ ..,. :4,„.. ..,t' • -, newt. - ,, --- - 4 i .11F 1.11 T ,:i.11'i -• 1 41'.1.-1, k 4.r'i4.1)"i" k.' '' ,4.1: /-.t,.;:::41!'•••., ,:. - i(, : 41 4.•,.' ' ...7 t'...:.!e.,.r!;" .' '• ' '? ' •.ii•Itii '''', 1-' •0:4- , • ..*. '••?:. ''.•-...,-.-.11.:•-',, .. A,..i.s1- -- 'i et. .t-,in .- -..,74 .,,,_it. 2, ......- -,.' " '.'i.6`''; * '''''' ''... 1 ' 57 -.'!.'.....i., ..e -'9:' • ... ..... • t, tA. ..r•'- ' 't.".". . • '.:'' ' ''i.',..-W•-;":- I i '- ':".• ,., ; -, tii.7. .Atiiolf.#4"( 7 b,e,'' ':•:0;. , •• .‘ , 'v $‘,;.••: -0...,•••. .. A ''.'y•: ••,•-:-."-....4.''-:- 1 ..:.:i:4'.I-.,, ; 1:',•••t:i '!.. i •• ./.A „ -. , -"I p, ' '..,- , . s ,',:.;-,f,i44:41,,,,z,..y.•.. 1::.,..:.::,.. *;.,,i, *.1;:•.:' .1'g• ':14'0 ';' kl*/ ..:.i •;::, -; . .,?i; ',V I.';•;-;:',?.',.:;,.. ...,. • . ; •I':;-,...CI ,.....-T. , ,', : . ..,',*'. .....tepi.i.:„..;,,,,i.-•••‘:,-%;.!. ,.. ..,:f.- sv•p•..:.-4.! ,. .2.... , '.-..1.-4,,.../.. -,.,,,•f- :7.. ii., ,.f• .70 . 4 ' 4? -.,,,a •,'k`.....' . ' .f, -.2..,,,,:....- ,,, ,.1.1 ., ,, 1,41!1;:711ii./. .. • .. '. ,..1. 7,'" ; ---4 ' .. i„.1.• 1 1 ‘i 1', 1.e• ty'L'. iT....1s: . 4)1" C•4Y'.1 • -'.'i. .1 , i.. - .rdi'.• i',..i'1'. '•1i.'•:1 • '-,ii Af,i• ; ,:i. i 4 • .1'. i•i; 4'.,,,,,.„... .. .,/...,A, .. a • • 4 • - -T, 14 A' *. 4i.• s'i''••''' -4!‘f •: .'"w !.*:.4., ''''. ;', .1. -, : ,-..to - F ..t.r ' '.,• :'.- ...--.4'• '' .‘ . '1,;, -+4,1.: •"•4/ 'f't.'e• al' 4 'I, .. ,..',.‘i/011'.::51, IC ' ', I:-,b%‘ I •rif . C,. , ,I* .1i',1314414.4;:, keV.f..':•r:7. ..,.,...-7..,; -.,- . sil 't.1,...1.4'1,',._ •, ,rr., .P.-..; fr. , . `'' _ .. . :4•,;;'?", „ t.. If': i - .44e 'e,,/ . '••4"' • .. i VA,". If .14$.,/',„1.., ''. .0 ' .. -'' ""''' - 1-- .. -.4 or ' Vii;e . f- ,.. .. .e 0.. ...4. 'Nip , ,.'s , . - '.4e. 4.;`)..--f ',....7‘':4... .111V! .. . .,-..; -..-• • ,t,..- li',"..,...k•.. ,....: i -- - -.. .' 4e.7.71.,., '.:,,d .. . ,-,, '> ..t.: T, ki..,1 A •,,,,it,- .. :•'.% • • : .-p, .;%.,e - ." --: — '. ' ' '''lic''' - - .- . -' ••-•". - •=1,'.. •.1 '.....-...,•: '54, .: .44 f-„ $..j4 ...-.; 74-, .,-, -• ,.41 -...).- '00 r !'. '‘ • , "; . '•‘44-,-13",,_tp..,,,,,•4 CO- '-,-..s . e -'-' -.." .1`,."--...- • •-..o, , "'N-.43-.--,-. ..?.'• v IA;..V. , jr.HO'''. •',' 11, 1' r. • ....,.,,,....,..,..,.) ,t,.-,..4.,, ,.., . .,..-',.. 4,... .1,tv-..; ';16 '3' c'e". '''..i• '-' -- ' --''' " -,......---1',- -•,;:',, . -- ' ' .0' '' '7,'• ir. ,4.4 7, '.114.-v-li , . # ,•'. 4,,, . /ht. !.'",:::0 s;cit....!.e. .:,...- .-- .- TOWN OF BARNSTABLE G.I.S.UNIT r.r‘ .1"...' .....• ---*'' ,..C."''''.-.. -;- •“.• - ' •' .,:• '.-'; - .. i'' '74'ls-'1F‘,. .AT . .;%41 '' .1 il2g;''''14.i i•••4 i' -'7-.-''' ' !' '' ;'Ai':'r. n':' ••••• : •. -'''' PHOTOGRAPHS:APRIL 28,2001 III ' ''''''t'?;. - .. ' '''''t:111.4St:'''..',-;14...'•!.Z.97,; -' ' ''''.. ' :'', .-...'.,'''. . .1.1'1.'1 ; ;". ' . ' ''-'- .'''.. ''i6,.!ti:,dr- • - itirfkiliVitil‘ '.•:.ir.,,;:;'‘'..-,i A .,,•;s0.,4‘,1 ',,;,, ', .._::.i.., •• X . s..;.- -,• _. ..-...."-. „.1.-- ,-.4.• ,..s,;", :hi.,-...''.-:;'•:!,•s,t,'.. .. .L. 0- '., , '•.!;:4' ,- tvie:, V:= .f0‘..,Viffr 1:' ''ll?'itriTi'.'-•,,, •• '•,./..1 ;:,iii•ife'•47•;1,31416... ?.'"... 1160(11(WtOP N " -21t,' im.4; ' Vort,4•,40, - k ...,, .6'4,- .:f.3 N 4: tf ii.' --T— '-.17=.,,'- Til..., •,-,,----. •-:7•..04.: -;.#-",,,y.: 44,,.if, 7-44:,• , ..4 s'-'.' •-4.i.,-,.,....,,:y,t. 1-.......,, ., . ,-.. , , , ,,, .i, ": ‘r, • ' ', ''9" itie I ''..'•' '' ,.,,,,,,,. ' 7 ,(24(., ..,, ,.,...,-,-,•:,...',,, ,...'4...e-: •--..,•.,- tt.',.,.14.e-...",I4. ;kr) it..'...„. 1,.,;;;;;,..t...',....,e., .• _ t.41 .4 ,.., Of .,:. .i , „.„,.• ...-1-,' • ..., of.,ot,it 4„.%,-.*IT, ., .:v I -...-,!.,,t4 .,,.._..v.... of . ,• ,.. .... ......„ .....„..,„ .: . ...:,,,,,,,..• ,-.3,.:x.,,.... .-... ..,...„ •.. v..a.e.1\ ' "..V.1,1r.' ;-.0'''.1._ - ../10,` ? ..' 1'1 '4''''••i.4',of.71-' 'i . "i...;:leil."- . 4.'.‘.4„tr it; al .P4 ' ,:.•-.., .-'s .." •I • de,kice;-.• -4./.--i...".. . •'d•' •, 1 -01i* '..,*" 4.• . r II! ''.'A - disg_ill. ,r, .i.).`.. ?,,W 5.,iti it, i.W., .;.,,tfiffjoki. ,in."';-•.-; VIA" '''''-';',:%‘: . ,,),. ...7. .. .:, ,;,,..--i NO..:j!...n't7..,•::•,.."%,&.$11!1-,,,•.t.,„'..,4:*:-..ir:, s'- '?. •.1tj ,n- ,- ' . 4„,....e!'!"•:- -,.'. .1F1,77. 71-. ' '.....1',..-•...,`-' c ,i, 1i',..k 41, lit•4 4,..77 C..7,7,4 o.t.... S !'... .':.1''. ">n,...-1.',',;t... ' .' ''71e2,-..'it''',-;'''','-`,...7:',4:: '... .4et- • ,.t:-.;_,.....:.-:,,,,„!= 7:r.s.tt,';n: -. - /-.:'.;.; .. ; -:. •. ., C.1-. - •,,e,,, ... 4.7. 17:4,14;.:O•t. ....7"...• . 7:7,;-- •,' ' '' ..4:f —1 ,•,, .'. . . .-,41T.-.. :. . .16.., 44%::,,,,,..,„ ' a 7,..•7..-'1:4'.. .-S ''' •..T5C-1";1",i7,:let:/:;,41firt r..:?40. . ,....,. :.,' . .., : -.• .,....c„,:- .„.....-..r..ok.v.:. PUNTED VALE lit HU 14'. IT:‘i 1.1''?"''' 117:/..4`.t.'. t4.4.!4.:"....N.4."' i...., • ,4 ii.:,;fre* :4-.....:,V., ij,:.. ,'. ''.. :;',,',"_ ..,' '-i,- 4.,4!!'),41t...4:;,.. .#4.4;41T,s4 .,4 # ;I',:'"•i i•••:!C kir.:-:41;;:,! ,..; EMRIMitEii ; • ': eft,.- .--•'-?tlti 14:,-.1.,•;.;Z;..,1It ,I,I*. -•• • • . 'fi' 0 ii'it:M/4• s,,,nfili•-; • - ' . 't- -..';',„',.-'-t.,.'-, ' '-*-•'"4,4:1;10.•'. -• l'ir• 't`r7-' 1 ' ,.. s Itlf 1 '1".-4,,, 0 i, ;50 ,, i ' - •,. 7::i' •Ske-•.:4,1.„ 1",..,,, 14 fo. r.'; A • '44.;i T# 'T 1.1.i.1:; 4 1 ".'ii,,i 1 i ty - ic: , 'if' :4 l ••• .. ';1 i.:..'gr .1,::: Illteit il '' • , .;1:.::t....' c ::. ;INN=;So FEET C.' • •11:, 1 '',-..i,- .•. i Altilta:.`Tii lie 1'417 2.„%'•'',i.......4*.' ... ..t...,..t-;.;:l.Ster,44:."1.-.! •• ' ....A.,iiiiiii:.e.''''il:1'1' ', . • '.:'!',i41,.':;„":.......t,':',..i ..'f.':4;:.;ii I- .`1 : el.' '. .4' 4 't';' -,14ir it,110,$::i4c4te,-;:4,i II;er, ::.,,? 6./Ir.-..,.,'',,•:i.. '.r 1 of propel boundones.they are nol true Woos,and do dot jitrris7....,:' .e.,-,4,,,;,1!,.;,,,,;--U,A.: -..,....4... .tt.5.!..e...ii,..44,.._. . .......,; •.4...-;,:;,:f1);;:f,....„,4:17:4::,::;$:::'.. ,;...•.:,.e. :44R..l. off:ii...e.t.. .-1:!.f!!..r:,...411,11.4,:t.,..i.litri4:J.i...;.„! irpii..„.ti!. -.4.11...P...:;-.ii''.:.;.,..„....,ri,.:,i'rio.2...47'7' "rj.:14.4,„,,.,,, .f?..i.".0..,'.il..1 1;4;......„,;--1,`....,, ..........i. represent actoal relationships to phricol gjeds on the map. :4>1...A .*:`,...',..-''-'i •••'4.(c....A4'•itir':'1.' >- .;. • -4 . .'...4*4,4.70').,, ,-,,t;-,,,. .,.0%,..v..„t.(i,i,,,:?,i't i_-.. ,4•,' _ . ,,, ..,. ,,.., , ,,,„, ,, • ,), , • •-..,.. 1 5 j 4 z Aik •Ar 1 ' trk- ' •'.• DAIA SOURCES:Planimetrics(man-rnade Incomes) -r-..;.(r"- .-I'. .,'-- •.n. f..44.Z' ':1").:4-r•'..‘,„Ni I ..f.,..:, ,:'.4rffit. ..f...-.. .. '• , ,r!,,?- ,. -4i,-,• '...., iiA :, --. 100,90%,„,„,e„r:-..z'. .. . , .. , .. .. .. ..,, .„ . ,,,y, ....... -+-4. e• . ... ,;•,. ',,..‘.-- .'"... 4:"...i',',',.1 T._ -4tii ...r"‘:..i,-•A; 0:41.44'".4',(•,. ' . .'...4'",...4'4.:. ''.* ;01e.-.' .. ,... , ,, • ,••64',IA-1 ,e..3'„s:4 0• . • -' wee interpreted ham 1995 aenal photogropho by The . ''-'7 '-''-',`-•1..(-•.: f; '..'..J;i,.•;•. ':-., . 1. lames Vi Sewall Company Topography and vegetarian ,- •%*C.,(1, i,.,, - ..-.i'.• ' . .---/.- 4-11... ";;4:;; v--4./"...., '.•;',-;;-•,:4.,(- ...4, -:I.,•• .„..01.,.,,-;:.•-?..; '' • , . . , ,,,.g.,, ,, ;• ;‘,',,,,4 it n•;,‘.' .. .. ., ." .1 • `'''',:4T, .::: 1 Az '..s.,` .1. , .,•-••• . .....- .44r , - ^• • . • . ,\,.., . ,;.....401i, • r., .f . were intetarded from 1989 aerial photographs by 6800 '.... ..s. • ;. .. -• .-:. . .- ..1,' 1 i.. ,;,‘' 7'; 5i,P--i;,s:'-' *" .., '.- -- - • -- }-- ji*.-, ;As. ../•„ ,• ii„,-,,ii„;;;• 4 . •i 1';. ' i whoa Planimetim,topography and vegetation • 1"6 --4 e .. ..,• ..- - -A. vii ,' 414,t. r - .,. . , ..., . ..,. .,fe. ..-.. i ,.,.., ,• . '''' , ..' ' - 11: • • . •aloftp:,r; .. -- , .' •:. .ii,'44 '. .': . . '.. - .,:".11‘.'4 A. .,, 4,,,. -11,7;*i.1.,. ..,.,,- _ -- ' .w.. -.;-e-. A.,. - - . -- ''..1,'..4 ',...i-',' -,;:-:'-''.:*1.. .i..f. :•7' - - A Ni',--(,:f.,, ..,-- ..,. --: ..---.•'•_%,...,,,„*.t.4:4 . ve.,.:... - :ii „'..4.....i.:.--.:;:.‘„,4, .4).. ."rob ..,,.... . -,..„-:-....t."1....,, ./7112,: ...f.i.44%,' :s4:11,:c. ..I'vel .: i, werryota2esctoorlo3lePTPedoownlIto--:100:itiN.aP:earleisollitsPwerA,scajrieurdiiitizoledntorrith - . .i . lo'!.. " , • tf.k0,... ': -2 .,• .•-. .....2.4".,-1:..., ' • •. i`2.' I-,4,-..'••••.: v• - •• • °'1 .. -,, 1, • -.. ..,_ .„ .•:...,— , ,,,•..q..•.... ,„.. •..t.- .4 . 1 ., m216p76ph8x11.dgn JAB 01082004 l .1.;'....:'..-e, =`'..• V,. i4,',.'444•,d,.e ati,.. ,..;,,,istir -1t..,.,,...:'4 L,' ..•=4" -, -...„,-.;.A. .. ''',,:.'':'''....' ',A,',. ,.. ..,t,;;;;:71V ' ' . i.AO. '. / . ._ . .. " k4.f.s. •,•-.,"*.'. .2/ 4,/, ..,. ..,,i.. , .., ,., . ..., . :* :to::.... ...1.....A.. AL...net.. . . .•t -,- ..4 •t • • , Exhibit • .. .,---,-, -- counterclaim Mi!19r ..-' 1l-R•1?eaittv--: 1111i.!..,71:: ;4et. 7-..f-1-,',.,'1;'..7..1',7;;:-9 2004-0084 . Sup. Ct. BACV.10t,'3:71,i' .: ::1`...471,:4',,,;'::•!...1;k7::',•:•.0::'''',,71'.i.:":4::."°•'''''C''''',L:1`.-,4;A:''''''',,,,,.!4::'.1; D-1 to •. •• •-•,•- ......1','' ',.. .'ik.,,:*T...' ''',',''. ' .,.,:,- •',Z.''''It',:',',.'::::,,,,'X".',•.'$W,';.t” ', Ay.:.10'"..1,i' • ' .. '-,.',11,1.iiii..r!k„ -A. . . ' ---•,....„, __,-,?”1,.'.-... '• .. ...r",:Xff•) or '117`,,, .,--,; ,....:',,y,,....",;::: i...".4V3,71,',, .,' ,'*''.'.,:i U.t!'::.''..f.;',7.ti''.',*.k4,,'41:,,.:'''l'.,r1-it. ,'. -r. • '14Nii3O,' .. '' ..,,i,,..„',......„..,.,;;,—, ,,,....,, .,. . , _....,,:..,,.. „,,.. A '. •.. k 4'.,,::....1!.. ' „ 1,,t,.,. ' :....,..'...4,..'''''' ..• .1,-;•, .4'.. • . ,• .. 1.'.. •,1.., .:::,,:::15r:''''. :':,''''''i71...:fliq,11: + 'rl.;.4A.:..t.:4:11Nt i.'' '4i..'• ..i.' :,{,11.1,.'..4'..:'44...,.'''':.' 'V k‘,0" 1,,,'.'::..;.''ci, . , '4-. 1.'-A."'."'\.!'..!‘ ';‘!".:.WIFS.It'illt:i.„„" ,:p:;,V•4:,44,a,41.0; . ',.1-,,,f44.'.' ....,:or '1? '. . ,,4.''''' „gr.'•.),1:.,.....1.,,tholtr,,,,..nii r','"'7,.';.',''''':::,'";,.&.'''i \i•:,':'''' :' '''' -.J1,Ij'Z•1420kINA-!`"41, ' .04N,,414s •49."n4.4"eil,.,: r.:-/"4.'c':' ,.,4' ".`; ,.'"''.7;,:,,,,".0.,!-:;''',';`,4'',.„.'...J',. - i',‘..-.e"', ., (,,,,',,i;',', ' 31c,'-4--t.,1*.• 4cf firr'", ,.,'-.1!t:.....e0 'i.'"v.•-,,,f v..-.t.,.'..,;.,, ,i4;,,,•.?„';',', .,',,,,,.':,.,:4,,e .. `..,i‘•:.'f.:,',a--• ...,0.,,,a.','N.".;••v.o.'.',i.!.':•'.'k •.. ..",...4-',1-0,•4.440.'''''..''1.0._ine„.''..- . F5.in:,'.‘'.,i::', •-A..•'Viii0;•..",..':-.,;--4-.v••..q, - :',,.',1..le•'•••;,, :'.i.'.;'1 "....',.....',...iik...-...-. :A:':'''.--,.';?:T.',..114.!.'...-•_-_,,,•44,,is,rke. .,','...,.„e,--1.,-P, Ji],..,:, ,'•r, -,,,`":•'.,-.„'!..r..",.:'V?,,i,..?..„.,,,,..f_'..,,,:'.,',-4,7-,-,,I.Viog-,.;.,)i...,, " .%..t...,..-1,i,',;.',I.:%$4;5,1,:+t,if:;. 1.'.'','.,.`ii.,It113:.,!•('N!,,.C.,-,,i_,,"...."-'-.".;';',,•• •,'-'•• jl:1444‘''''...;:.•01.`"s, 4"i7:••••.7:',-;:-....0,'!"1•••<1:;;;;:>'..7T' ,,,,,H•' •,,''..7,••• ''.!',V,f,'.';':•.-.A.-•••i'•`'C'!'•'.. .."'''-•:-•,,.•;',A,4''''''.1tf:14,'"-7: •,-„,.f.It:eAs.-„,,,,...4rm„,!ii...:,,::::,,7:-.-7.-..::-......",,'......,,,,A ki,,,s.,,,..,,,,,,,,:c„,i,,, ,...‘ ':..- „a•-•:-.,..,-..i.1,ii,,: k.i.:-„.:,:-.4?%.,-.-..;,......,c.:;-:...1:7:7,w „... ,..„.,.' ps.,;".',I.::A_,,,,.;:-. ,-3,41.''. -'\:"..',...; -•.-:.r.,;•,,iq.,..7 ,,;Ifici‘!.:-4- -'-'1':,;:,..;:,114::_;-::.;,..'...,_, ..1..;',:-g., ,%.,-••... ,..,--.;.,:,---•:-.. .,,•...:"Ik-i,•;:-. ::--....,::..:;,..',....._.'.,.',-;•:',. t,,iit...‘,.,5•:.•'.,''.'.;*'.N.'•.k,,,)' .i:7'1',i'•':',1'.';e1*':,,',`"..-,•:12:!.'`•'''''''''-t',20'It' .4'o,i -.'-,. ..•,:.:::,":'''. ..,:,[,,:,:::-", ..';'''.:..'11;.:•.,'::::::: ..::,;:''';':.:;'k,..!':ii,''.,.:,, r:::i'illfit4i14,'.,;?,:er,',..V.::.•'..AP4,#''::::**1',....:::`,.; ....„.•1, '''4!,,,,S ...,.i,....1.... . i ,111111ratri,i..:,...,:,,,,,,&t. ',.,'4'77:„-,.;,..,...-:.,1:.:,,:,.:....-.:..,... .,V,.',•;:.,$, ..,_,'.•.::.::::,4,p.,.:::...;)7,r.,./,',:.i;:.:.'%?,:;;1•:,:;7-1:-4`..4:4-:.. :!...:..,.,.6:.:,:).:'1,tijc:. 441, ',': ,4..,:4,,,:,s;'.,..i.,,:,.. '. itel,(::.,.:! 1:!!'...',. .",,,. 4milft..:7:.r,Itik-, ,..,.'.,...‘,..,...:..,,,y:l.",.:„'....:v.'.'..._',.:;-.:',-f-P;.,.,,',..:'.';....-.. ,T:,--:::.'.. ' -;.-,,,::•;.4..,,,::,.:'41..i•,:;..isl. 6,-;.,.i.:, -' :.,•;te., . tri", 1,',"''...,.. / i. '.:'•.'\-.-',..r,.;.-::'...,4, ....„'-',A..,,,,,,,,,v ..:,0,4-.,:..,3/4.--.!.:.:-. ....4 ,.;-....,...y..,i....-.",„,.:'....,,..:.;:i...4,z,f,:,4-,,,:-.-.:,,:.-;,,,q..2.:..,..i.i.,..: .'..-.,,, ",,-17' 'F''.1'.:':'•'''',4-t'TiT•'.:''t: '• ..L----,:, 4141;;',3;:'1" tt co',:-..A,14:.4:...,-:'4_,..-‘4,;V:,,,,,4-,:...,;.:.y.',,-.-7.,...-4,..v.' .. v?.:.,,,1.'kJ,.f,;,..4....ai,!...4,... ...' ,...,.*-.,.. i ..•;4, 1,,,,,....i ..,-,... 114:...it.„44,„57,0,4,,,,,,,A... ..-...,„: :,,-..-...,..,..:„.4.,,,....141.N-'",t0::.;'-'7-.VA :;';•eri,'-,:;L: -' • ly.';-, ,i_' ..,r.:,.:,,,',..i).- {:,4''','"::::;:,!?4,:':;..;L',.:,..VS,A\...14.‘!,,.....4'.... .„,C..Z.:,• ,..'.,:';':., ;',. :',1'i....r1.,!!..;7::'.:;,:'...",j:,64:,4 ''..''...r11 ,11i,/'''1'..;:.... ....'' :-,'-'''\''''i;;:t.N, .L-,...-.,:.,.....:.-- e, :,... . :,..,-''-,.. -,...\-0......,,r,4,vt,.- :'-.,'':-,,,....,',,..:-.-...i....0.,...,,..-, -4j.kN'''',' ‘t.i..:,:wq4'1,4.-1,,...N.,::,:::.'''' ".Z,,,'"•..,,,‘'''1.''.:.- 4.y.','. , ...,0.. ...,-'.1.,„......!.....,-,---.....,..........-...'!.i. ... ..,... ..44,. ...-.......,-4.. ,,;.. .. ,,.t. ':-. ...,:‘'.','"*3",..,:".;...',.;.ii,,, :• i,i.'',......0‘I''' ''s';.:1'.'1-"? .-'.,;(.1,,,.-4,..., f...,,.', et. .-q.,:.•,,,,e,,P,..!",;"'..,f:',,'''7.-4,:,.':.;' .-.....,':..:44...,-;,.... ..,4,, . !,..,,(_, . . .....; L... .. ....;.,..,...,,,,Ikt;.. ....,.., '..'.... .-'.--- .:'. .i._:',..-:-..:,-,::.•-. .i...,-,,,',.:,- .4'....',,i4:.--,...,..••'--7,-,-,---, :. -4'!:,!.:4::t...- 'i.,...•A,!,,..'.*. 40+-$.,-•.•-' ,oi*,-.4., •••• -..'i. ,Nr .,.*"?‘..',,,::::.`.:,...4§,:k,'!:', .s..,:re.,,',‘' -.'.• Oi;.,'... '..- •••• - .4-01.);:...,., .-:.,,,,i4.,..-:.,,,,.. ,,,,., ''':',.k;r14.':',:::',. .i''."V-.:'''''C'^,,',:.''..Z'?.#: ''''''''.:'''',''..' . ", .•.-,,,A... , ..,- ,,,,,,.;.--,..-,,,,,,,..' ..,..,..,4.2.,,,o.i.v..:......—...; ....,.. ,, ,'..91t,..,„t-,..- ..,_-' •'6•A 'i-,r:-. .;.. _.zi,..i...• ...---q...,!v. ,,•-•.-. ' -,. 4,1i. ,o,'';01, --,..,L: . ...-f--...,-.,',..-4111:",!,:-..6,n.''';',•••:,.':' .-t.'4..-:',=.;1.."';...'4.1c.'..•''ZIt%i'.!,.''''''''7•',0'444'44 4- .14%)4,:'' ,•. .,‘T.''.', ''''%4.''' '''''4'-'''. ..44j'' ''''.:;'44!*:4''''',.k1.:"....'''.;:0:;::*4,1'''''''''''''' ';"4:::r...'C'''''-'''C'' ''' '4';.,-%N;.,,;;.'.'^i• ''''7.' ''.V.;,i.V....;',.;.',..1.-;.N .'''':':;:t''.;.....;:::::.',. :10.t),N .'1,1;,...••••-•-'.4''':''1'S..;:ktIt'-'-''''‘ s,,'i_,.',,I,16'2iA,p, etth4? RTh '."...,tt, '''''kk€,..:.,.., ' .',44.-',...- . ,,„.. ... '. .:,„.: , ,. ..1M..N.,:4.;<;;;;':,-,:.'-',., , "'•.. .`,'-4,1;.,e'',',',...,,."''',' '''''',"''I'''.:10,NV'r'.k.."'4.-N...",i;t1"4,..-;,,•,' . . ..,,,..0,.+:7`74,;,..;'...r4, •••-- '.."..',-,L'.'.,r,'" ... . .f' ''.'*;•...,.• ,:f.,..-- . -.''''`r. . .;-,-......,-.-,'?V,••0 irV'.,;',.... -, ..ae.....: •';,..„.;(1,-,;•,,',7.'''...,','...::;;v-,..Ti-, .";','`....,:-:'.' 'ft,"',..-iiirik:Killai!ill,:.:;ii,;•,+.;;4.I 0;,..,,,,,,,,,,.:4.,:•%, ' - ''"?:i.4 ,.,,,,,,Si,,,, ..., '', N.-er,:,-..404';',,Y,,, 7.:',":-z,--..ttf..".."... ,,,i,.,•.k.„ '..,4jg.1,,.:2:t.;,..:,,,.,•;.„ '•':.:'..."'`.t...1,-.4.t..k•f•'--`4).4'''.`;.‘4.!°". t • !-•-' ...- -';';'''',4 1-1? ..'. -';'''''.':'' '' ''.i .r, '''1'k •C.'''• S'Ilii-. ,` ....i.'.•t . .....7.••'''''':4';'+'.4. t•''4•!'t, •'':;';':.',„`.:;,t.i...",":•• .,' ''..'."....,-.' .tpe,,'''.1t.!;:•'0!,...-...'"?..,....q.',...q..41.. .. ...i-,,;., . 44A1•.; ..,,F,..-: ,:..-..:,--•";,•.. ,itt,......,. .';'..;1. .• •..'.....',.'."fic,';',,71i., -••tr.44,4;01. • •'-',1 :‘,..••',.1.4-,w,,,,,,,„-,„itett,A..,....,....4.-.. :.,,,::,-.,-,z,' ....% •Yttt,-,,f,..;.:,..i,.,i,•,,L.:..,,.:-.,.. . -,,..:„0.,;,77,k1--: e,diNt ,'.• ,'!,;,;-.:,;„:, _ .,,,:..!- '-,*:.,„:141 ,P..,' ,..,.J..... ,‘„,' ‘,4,:ii441.,.:.. ''''"''.',.fli;-.i.:PA,,‘'rt'1;--;i:',..',,b.:y"•- ,;-,J,:',.4i. :,,',.;:,,'.:,..-',/,.-.3..,.,51'4,,,..t.e..,„ .I. ;$.,tt".•(,:iy,t, 44v.,1/._ % ., .4:. - ''.%!.'....:, - ,...,-,..,_ .,_1',.•;....'---..''..•Itv,1•.:;•.,''..'.-_',44.i.'..14! '.:1-..!,,W1,_,I:i,•:'...- ,-.'- -',.- • .•'.i::67:.;,'-.:,,,,...:'--.41,1*-.--'1-.„,,, ...i.‘. t'Jr40'",'4.4t.4k,,i`.4".;:,-t.-.. 150 zoo tgHqii?!..-'-'?.°'''!'----'•-•:-.Z-s•!,;t.. •;.''.•4'-=:-.I.. .... ""t ''''I',.,r-4-.-44:4,',7,4 :::.:'... ,'.7-.-.. ' •;:r.; , ,-Ai:AT,.....74,"1.-.,i. .••••:-.L1 (;:::,.:. . •-:,:i-Y,;,.'''...- ' ...--k,:::*.• . .---,..4:1,f....,.t-,..;-...:t,-;iye,,,,,.4....1,,.,,,,_ --.:-...1,?7,......., ...ji,•.i.;.,,,et.f.?",,,:::.1..4,- t..:-7,4,,pe.,r,„?... .-....,..,:.--.,,:.1.,:i!:;..%,.. ..111- ,.,..' '''..' '-!.-.t-..0•r4;. '''• ..i•;,,j'3.,,' .•.'.',.:-..s.c,1'`..-1:4\4:.."r,..,:•,,.,_!7i:-..,- 2,.,..-.40..(1..... .:„--.1.c.: vhf,iit7.,,:.'.7.,.;;iit..,„;:,:;,2''..-1.ZZIW'f.',. .;.':••'.. _..?..i4:2...,4•41. .i.. .g.,4.i,,....): ,, ,,,,----,,,-. .i't.".: _-;•:,;,,,, ,,1 _,„-:, ... .,,,,,.,4„,,,,,,...w.,:e.,,,,,,,.:„. .„-.,, "''' ' Istdif4t.' . ": -.;,'-';.'..*--;iit:,,,:,.‘...2-.?,,,,,:lk.„,,: ,,-.:--,. .,N•- •:,.tizi''',.,.,...,,..-.-'.. ‘,1.-n. .,,,, . - :(..,... ;: N‘..,....,4.....064;,,...,•.•-• •‘'..:'--imiltri:•,.. --..;,•,;'•..t.r..;,,ki:-*>,,,,,..,-,.w.:.:;--,,:-.-;--,.,,...-...n.N.,:q-,•-•,,„v:.,80.,c.‘'--.„,,:„.- .. •....,w.--...,,,,,,,,,-•,...F.,44:7.,°,744,,-.a,k;;.31.,...,.,,.•,,.•T.:',:,,:....,,, ,...•...:-'.',',....%'...qi,4...i-Jr.t.,....--,,,,.,k,:-.,,.-/ ' 7.:,_ ,.,..i..,.,-......!....;.„,,,i:14,,,,,:‘,7-7,_-. ...i,.,..: ........,:,...i,, .,....!,,....- -",:_ • z1,...,.;...:-4,..z.;-=.,.4.x7i.A;... .,-. .,..: t. ',:,:g.:. -,v ::.;-.-.'..:".-.'..-...,.1s% ,.:.,,:::.:-. ''..,7:';f,,,.--';.,... ..i.,..4.,.;;:t.;iv,-., -.: — .— . •,1 2:' ' ,,,,-.e4...,..:,;:„. ...4.,„.?,,vt...,,,,,:7:.„.*,.-.,,::14...i...,7:4.:.I.,. ..,:. t .,,,,,4:?.?4,,,,it.:.,..•.;...,,,:..v.,...:.:,.....;.:, ., .. ...:::,.:...;,::;,,y7:"....(!.Z.i.,!. .,...r .N.„,-.7 '...-:-/::::-.;..;,-..::".:: ',4:tp‘cf,., ' ..•lt,...d--.!.-.: ..:',.;t04,t.„1','.-,,'W..7)t.1.1,-41'."4-1t.:'.;,;44,...." ...*.y.•;'-.-•-!...,,.. .,,r,,,,,,..,,.,.,,.,,,,..,.,2,- ,41,•qiilt.„ ./ .,.•:. : . -'::.-,. ., ''''''..;-,-''',,:'-'....',..,`....P.,-.1/4':*';'4411".:--It„..` .•;:'''". '•,:,.......,;..;'•-•.!-,,..:.•,..:••'--,,••„,..,.. .,-,•,,, , ,-.C.;;,,,,.,,,,,, - ,'••-•',•?7,11r.e•.r.a..,,,,' --'0,--, ,;-''' "." ,41.1,444 ...,..:„,,,.. ....... ,,A,..,-,..tii:::.,,;:-.-1.„4„..,-,.r.;t ..': ' .1"AeN• ; r: '-•". • ./' ./Or'-''''•':.4- ',,.,,,I'4'?..!:-4,:+,:':+••;,.!•:-k,:.'.,,' •'.','•'3,,.....r.'; ,',,''''.:,+.+..:,..:.:0;',.,,--'.P.z...,,....rt1++,,,+441,41 a i:-,!,,L,LiL.!:-.,,Adin,g, ,t,,.:.:...,...ti,.-f,.....at.....!..---;:;,y,,,,,7:1 Fli,*: /itt.';' -•'.-::::.. '''''- "7:",f1.`„:;','s.'•/-'...:,:: ::,:,':::;.•.::; ,-.41-,-Y,',Y:-.7...A'.,•*:t...-.:•,•Z:,',.,.,..,....;:".:!.. ..,-,'''..T'q"..S*";:t°,'-.-N, . :;;;it„,.'•!.'ttk'::;?'"'=•11.WS'''''.•' .-;..*:.4!47,i74.:12,:-1:.`-:!:.9' ,,,:,:,,;?':A...,,..-,c!,:,......„,.: ,..:-..... ,;...,r,:..il,...v,,,,, ,,.‘,....;,.: .,.,,. .:,..,:,:,,,o'i.;.::;:•,.::',4. 1'k"'--;46ii;. -.4-•:..; :.k.:[''7, -...:•::.1.-.2;:4:::::?'?,•,40'": • . ! •Sir.4.:,. '. ..:,-iji;-:•.4',,:l';`x.‘:‘,,: Vii.'4•,' ",'•••±:C.,1!:•:.`,-,:,.'1::: :;..."',:ti•'"/. '','77!:--''...--,.......:'-1,:;?"•'-;i*"1;;-::;;I:'''--1,; : " .-* 2:;4"1.ir,;-- -,•:"-j,tal:•'-'1'''''''&•;*Zih....,;:.:,,ti'•:1:::i.;"1"i. V;:7.....:,'4"0;e_ri'l",,' ;.,'::.'--.ril!_zi:foori.;:-.„.,,R,,...::::,.,r.:"1.,:itip,,.,.....4%,:vt;-,..-1,:,:‘,„;,,.....,:,,I.._-;..--......,,,.,4,,.. "..,,,,....!_to.: :-_-: ,, ,, .::'. ...,... .,..-.,,,%,.,-....-..---n., ..,-...,,:,.......,,:i.".,..-::::;„,i.f-, .-,..- •,.0..,,. -,..-',....i.. iy.',,..:.,..-c,:i:;'..%-.4.'..':.:............,,,'• .,-' ,...-,z-,„.- ., e•-•:1;,V,,..!•%44; :.,, ,'4,i I'- '''''';,111‘ ;!',....tA '..,''''.4:!i.',Ci"3''...''..-,r '1.''''erf.6',..?". r r-;!-....:./. •:',,.‘:.*AS-.'‘.0.1;9.'.•":1."':-..- ',,,'.'S.''..'l - .''.. •tr-'.' -,'"-k'e-V.::''''-'qnirtiO''''' ''' . :,.....'t, ',. .":' 4i?_;''',:',‘.'.";,„,'''',.W.',,' - ' 6 ' '''''',11•• '7'.'4:7'::'''-i..2;'..:"'.--.:'''-"'%."..:•:.,,,k1t'.•.4,.6';;.;.'",-;:',.!`;'....;!4, -':•,..,-it.,....','17i,"".4.1..'ci...".-..;:-)'' '.,....-.. ...!vi'''„:::::- ""', ..,:-.4,....? ' ., ';'itk".."..-'. ''''' i•Z.4 ie•-:•;„.:-....1....".1.c.:,.%7.,..„'",,,. - '.•-•.'•::',":,..,....t.....A -....:.. ,..74 .. . -,..-,....,..-r:',...•.:"!.:5;',',...,i...,, ';'.1--',.',::-,:.::,r,7, ',-..f.; "....4,-'.1,,•:,!•,'-4 0 • -!',AA-^. ''4,'.''' i 7,...;,V-04 . ' '. ,','• ''''4-...--,,... .,.F,-*.q,V:;:;;;•11-/.f...''s''''tf:.,;',":.'i?:',',..e..IZQR:!i,-',.'.,?':Ai :-,-;.-,,c,,•:,.iik.-.4:„.v..;,,-,:,t.:,,..10,,,,,,,,„....:•:;;;.., ,,,,••:„„,.r..,e-r,,,,,,,,:ii•,drel.•,,p,... .ti,:%.., ..7, 4.... '.....,.,..,..14.',4..,i . ,.,, •c, :+••• „,,,,,,,:4..L.,.. ,..,, ,4,.,,,„,„,.„,-,...,•.2:;.-,1,1q11".4.•'-4,•t.'rn':".'e:f:'''.`•=.-+ ,1c,•1 itltw,....• . 1;•' •,,,,, .•,...-'N.' k..41.4+.1.4.,,,,•1 „,,,/,,,„:,+.‘,.,...,,_%,,_--•.,•••••,,,,,,,F'.:1 ,,'?,,,A• ,,,' :. '+*.';',.1,,,.;,•rfat,',.',48++. i,..:,...-,..4.,,,„,;•+...,.•1:. ,4,,,, ,!?,-,,,•,4:.,•••.,,/, 4. .-, •''•i.,:,,,-..,..."....,',......; '1'....'T,•,, , - ,+-,4)...0i..i •..-",,,,... .....it'-,;:;,.4.,-,s-4.--,..),,,.--r-0.-e..1. !!...v.,..!_e.,•.,.'- -.4.•::.`l',',".;,•:',4,'•••-:-:i,.-‘,...,.. eri., -f..,';,..1,..-••?"'.F....‘.,,. 6:,'',..'; - ',.--.i'....,V-..74 -..'..-:;:.?:.f!..;i:".'-‘1 ' 4, b:,-,:,,, •'.:is:-.1,4--4-1.-..,04;';1_,J,41:-„ . ..,,. -„A.,iN,..., , ;,-,u,,,:iz.,,,,,.„. , - , a :.--;. ' . '"-7,14.;t.,-,.....-.iL,...,',.,;:r.r.,',:,;-y.‘;'1':..;:-.ii,...:..,....,,,.,.1;?•,;,,,i-.,i,..,,.:.,-,,f,-4.....r...., ,,',,•. .-.7.;. , •-...,_.•:•.•",,•4:::;,..rt;t:.•,V:2._'.00-'••• AT,. - • .., , ..:,..,, „.,,L0;.50.. ,•-, , .i;:, ....,,,,,K,,,...",1."!.7i,:',„;:-.-..,;,'•‘•;:i.'„,".•At•'.1$.,::.'1:'.,:i;:":!...01.:..-.• -' ,L,00.J.•Y0'.-';'''''''''''''- - ''.... -`1' ".•-•-•'-• ••••"".--•"."-•..", 410'.. V/- ' t",,,. 1-1,..,..!,(f,,;`,.:....,..„',..-,/,:.:J.:,,:,z''.',).-.`,.-it-,••/.',1:•-••'''',v---•''' ' ' -, ,...... ..;.' . ,. ,. Exhibit D-2 counterclaim Miller et al TRI et al v. MILLER et al Barn. Sup Ct. BACV 2004 0084 a ; ppt ��..a {v.-...inn zp�•1,.`!^.r= t / •dt ' ,_-0,) ,, �r -ki , ' • 1 ni a m 7 �y S• ^ ` ^' rr `ro l 1 �'� a -tea t v F '� • r o x �' a_ `s' •-- ' . t G'A '��1 -• , r Q v t ! 'F'4 •'.;"'",- . . ,- , "1 ? a }e' 71 i . ' i"' a }'t�t "" t r ^b r' F'.4<' — Ty .� + 7 *1 tt < -x T. "� ! -1 � � T ' r I f' , �� .rsr fi y`�,t�`'r4 ati, 2-�v a, 1 J I� 7. i �k','\!' r !s � a J ,' • o- sv f' }L�.�„�+�1 f� v�nr ss ,fR o- Y-�:_ ,a�i-Ft 1t.!^7 d is `r� M a,.n.''���+ � '' 1 � , •* 4.' ' _r hrr T. '�-. c� a` ° ,f`x, '�.' 4f•-J�' • N ( 8 {.. >✓t",if r ''''• f X`r a te% ' Y yr `'t 4,, 4 Kt •mot• Or .KY ' 1' t e}. ;iv att�'y � y�' ' J �4�'k r#c . i+9" ,j T.: r"�.F 4 a.�'�"Fye � ..r Q�.y�r. :.j r• r k 4 'r5 �. s .. t- 'Y y T 1 . � .Jv r K, 1, i etr' v.i.1, ,,,,1R+f1+� , *" ,. .,. ..., ,{.�•":!§{� r ' r s _ af' r rtv1 Y'w- -,, 'Tr 'V ..,,�,(� j62' I i p �-,vbra 4 ',. , fit/ ,! : 4+-.. zy 4.70.. • . '{/ f syY e• •.A+4 f>;L �*�t. �� hn :r + � * L i ( ' �'`s"4,t" !<h r N ✓/ r�{� '�i +- t .F"".,-..- .+t.R1 M .�+�:.*.Q-` -�( �.� h mot, 4 a • ' L t r E I�€ �'��� , • 4., K 7,t r s"ti rJ r V... ►`47,.. - 'i.'. r §P rt' s rw� .} it 1• till,' '' ' 7' 4..5 .a • ''' "+a y r`it r 3t \ �i �t,5..,�.•T'r\ •r v ;'. �i'� t • !.k< ' o 3 .,,d,3 y o ,,i a •r rani F.'of•swstc - '^'1-{'Y �J'� t. d�y�=}r.{ �, 1.,, 5�i:t; �. t-i;, ,�".x a t it T. 1 c p 4� y J -.;r .fig' 1r`S° i +F rd `,4 �, _. - �i"R' ?1 ! i t'f • >7 r _ \.I� ( t ; _ 7 t V .t ,��.r'., � y\.rtt • S;�•y +� \�! T� s .+r. R 4'+/� � � B��� r ^y-\` ;, r-;..,, r'j�+ t . �' ,,x ' 'r-,.te, x.,. \ �,'i-ram�•*� o"Q` `4'r ,+yN"�'Yr:,,�3 Rac ..Ri ✓ 7a--.� a •K7' `k r•a w k 7 ., P 1 • +�'r' r $�j0 t o- 3 , • yw-? i.. r f , ,ya ti!+/ t -+., , ( i Th* ' y r. -.4- t r ( Y.+ f �� L@`� s a�„ S+_.r r.S:cs '. '3 f,, • P• ••_. _".vi. • , r(t G w•" ' r� is?2 I. i - °,j r. �y ? t � r - S r• . 'mot! a..h� f o�r d�V'r ` L� T J Y i.'hi�?~ t -.. 1 a �r_ A9 •t �'i!� • � ! � \ 1 r• -': �a,,:i t tvJ- .r� ' 1r.:k- .3 %i•"}`. `�! t _.a 16�*��''.r, 7 : er -; j �1P3 �' t t. 2',,• 't V {1�' S i4• �y 14,Iv: : Y . r•�,• ""• .. ita �� ^ / 5. t- r 7t ,; `° Ala: yv^ 1 y�l'Y� ' R 417K....77 P. tS,,, "y J.r/,- � •a•7•, `M ,{ I �ii '� ! t Wr �,,. r��4yt- ^•v ,/, 1 � y +V h G 111�,,{k E. �t^� y ri ir ^�•.:' Fa y A 'yA:r1.,. y ,1!C-•4,I . J ,.!': Ls• • • �ro-LP� . :N • R. zltc:5, q`,� R��R��•••• � �� � it(k'.� �� Y y`� t•,�•y� ��t ) rS�R�rh'�1���� t i 1/ r'i�: rs �•'r Y /R\tw i ,f ,• ai3" '_! M P. p .. 31�� �;���rl.�y/ 31/►�.Rs�:..�'X•'�w��{,��'d-�(`� r '' �L_ .���-�Y� �'"� r�'r�, :X,�kY�,1„ +'h �i'�N � :' A 0.t h r J ,r' -,Fi• , Y•• , ,`• N t, I✓ 7 �,S>T' Y .d P{ •7 . s • - v rR ;:.• t p ..ate ,`, ,Kly !f m •s'a*� �m.e�Jv`�a�� ��'�iff'+�s.�,y. �' p, 9a '+ ..:_,•.--. � � 5sC""� • Hsi w x•`- R� T��'+ �{��,v lx'/ y w 4 r t S l �( +� y... ( ' ' ' n c!r t- •1.1";) t•", �N/ yyX�r f rf Ps W qp' 5_,,. iR - j , , f ,f . y,�,ILr ; ..C.i '�,,/yL�,r�}-,r� r.`w t j iy f..t a ��7*;7 4M .t. s� R eg. '.." y ~(•= aY.(.1 i . t.r y„ atfi v ." r qY- �,.-ilf' Ha'� Y / r� K,7� �'S t;.v .i T` F a•14• � r+'J y r ` .�( r .J` ter ''' ny:'nay /) ` i �^f .1 Y44 t A to • • ' p s.'" }� -y�, r •••� 5. ^?-- �.*.,•..,,.,,,,,..tier,....,. �Ll „ottke - rF' :Al ru' y r + •)`4 t • �S y' ` .,rt" `d"r v�J14 G ot,t'-1'...,•E"i ,T f 1 ;. Fj -Q < 7 EMi +1 T .'T^ ...._Yam- " gr 1,,,�it:t• yp+• 'r / �' ..r Idles_ .. 2 s-. V.' 1�'' � �+' "/ �Y�`r f � ��p„ � 'f R`t�'� � . A. � ci �� V 4 � 'F/ '.���'�,4. .:. r^r�_, `v' (�bA t�i/�(��1:� �r�: ^_ i,.•,J " 4,.. •a8- ,f -•r.; . ) .• 5M • ,r�,/ =! �P+1 " nt '''-* n _ '.'.,7. wei o 'r.71 T �Y j ". � "r ►�-.. f' �" 1 1E-( '4. �,l, ,i. , ` ,, .,ti .3...+a er" ., �� e '- x c{ ,,.r i.'n nF ' - U }t •,,t • 1 �:- ••,t.,. ,�,,-r r �i�s cue..• Ar +' (� . , 'r r' tkk' rt,,w r.' vr wjr` a r'ywk ,rd` ^, R�+, ads. 9 �q �aY.;r�'��t k , { - - .. jr.�. . ,�.'- f•r - �LW� a_�'a�a,ayd a' i.fi � �!.Y.. � _ � 1 N ... Exhibit D-3 to counterclaim pfMill..!!:,t!,..„1, T,R.01 et1v,..17. 11,1,,.!..:1!.w.!Leti.,,,_,,,I*Ir[,737r....p:,.:; r„..,..,.u4.7..,..„ct.,B!,,frA4C„4.446..V.2.,i..,,,L0.,0,:;-:,9,1,O....8,.,,,,:,.. ..L17:71,, ,. . .,:: -,--,_ ‘,..,. ...i.sx, .-4.--_-4*, ..-,„,,..,;.4 -. - .''''. 1,..- 7' '!'.. 4:7' -*--7'0,7--'4:4$_....,--'91-1<13tW.f;-- - d ,:1"•- - .'. '?.4.fk114, .!-,' .• i 5-•":, ,, ,,),-.100,• ',VA'44',;•--,,,•s".,- ,:4",,,,:"4"..P!''''.7.-" ", :t::,, •-,44-7; 1%-:241.7::,,sksti4;., :c • %.- ,.::•1...---7 -'''',1,';!~1.144..i1..•--L,,:21-e-4':•,17.. .44k..t.",-,:.,*--,%640,4-firk-74,,,,,,,,,,,z..,. , ' -„,;:leit;,,, ,.,.1.,.‘-..,- ...-- ' -,---3,,iewv;-- 5.!... .;4,:.,;N:,r-.;:orP:,-,:-. 41/4,N:,,,,,,;...,,,'......,747.4/0:N.-.--,-4, ,,,,,,;,;;,..4,,c -'..:( - .,,,-i,04 ,...,.::-*„..,;:;;;. ;:i.....•.• .''`e'-''',--.,'..'°.---i,411 • . .,, ..-4-..A2,,V4. 7.*.i-,•?.tT-4 ,::-.;,-,. .y- •,•;:k:, -,-.....:,-,-. :-....,.-4-,,,-,c AsIt.,..".-zz.141.;”,.,.*:-.A,!....4-•;'.7.•).::7-1:-17--..,-.4- .4.•:- .1. '.. •-.- . .7..':''" s.,:.44,47.,, ,i,...-- .0,, .. .; ......i. . •.,..16,.:,,...7,.........4„-,,,-;;....,:,...,;•,,,-,,,97r,,,,le-, .7,2„.„.,...,..,-4,•.:-. (4,S,'-' .'-..11:4•4"---.4t.'. :,‘,.'..':1,-;':'&,Z`'%...:*".- - sL .--- kr2...... -•• . .,,, ,--,...-.... -, pi..- .--pi, - < T5'"4---.-.- . , ,,,,..--,,,-,...':;-, -....-..,7-,:,-.,•-;.;. .ti., -.: - -"'',-Sk :--..'. .,-ill''' ''':•'-,,,',..,,, ..'-'. -:..-4'-'4:-;',!,,,- •,, . ,c, '.•...... 4,. "... .,i. '- •-',7,4: .---,:i. ,--.,-,.. 0 '.,-,. ... .: :ic:.%:'',A,i,gralZ6',7)1..k.''' '.'''''''',' 4. ''''.4-t,...;.,k4";''.4""lie"4'0,'T f.''.1.%',:r."1!;,-.111 ..6V .,-.;'1,..,11. . , ...:.''';:?,,... .." -'‘,.. At.,i,-, -. '„ ''',„;,.:•:-... , ''::: .‘' '.'!' ' ''...iSt !',,q:'',/,,IlfiLti.j.';';',.. 2:•::;r4;,,,,'-:*7..'-)%7,..;Avv.: ---ij..,,,,-;.:.,77 ,-,4*.i...--";i- , ,..:,tc,Y,'•-•.„,-..,:.,..,,,-.-*•':. ,...',..V.,. :7:5;:.... -,...,.,r,N . ::!-- :11.• .;se..si,,V,."4..:,-‘-,4•5, -Aft.-_,',:,,,/- --A:c,,..'..--',••••\k-'1',...Nef.'47,- -T'.'''..;.••.-,.:‘-k.!,4,11, •: .• 4 .,:-.4.,. -.:10ii-..-i.,, . k. ,-.,-„ ' ., ' • ,'•-. Ai...-,:-' • •,'''41,..„- ,r.-." ."", 4&,3rt':.,'i-4..'.'".: .---,,,,,i,,,q-,,,,'S.0-4•:'..\--.. ,•,;Z:,, '. *'''•' - .'- '4'' - •C43•N kt,'TA--.,-;',,-',,: .+--%-2. 'A- ik.t9.4 4 4 i V r s,f-, 4 '*:.; -...,:':. :•,riii4:4‘, '..::40.1,3 .•-•••AV.'"4r11 ,,•1/4"V*•:::".7':::0,$A.,j;."‘L .4.4-4 .1 t kk:.:1,40-',,t-A-.4:4?::.-bp .i.A,j,1*,",ii:' ,-,..•%etle:-it Z.,„...•, le,.,...47c-_-416- 1.-, '..%r,,. . ' 'TIINp.,,V,::,-, t-kllikW' A .,„.. ..,,..,...,..,..„-., _ . , ..„,„„, ....,,,...,,..,..„......,:.,,,......0,.„:,,,...., ,..,, r, ....,_ ------..-..,.-yo. , • rt. .<44,... .,:::„.....1! , iNi4,104%!4'k:.",.:•-,,,,,,...y.'!4,',„',.4...,'1;0011140,,,, ,,.•..is!,,„,,,,.,..,;..,!-',,,..! ,,,'.1..1' ,"'1. Vetisi,7,tr'- 4,01cie....1".,,,. --3C.:17 ..,t' ,',,7...:.r,.Arg'. ,•,:.1!!:4e.,`.;' . ic,:,..,);.'117;:.!;.'7;7:Z.::),..,"'.,,,..! :k:i'<;:f7.,,R-t:-77t.; ' .. .1".,.` -,:1'.- , t,""; ,-3%.:7e,..,''': .:- 1:,.*-0. ....''',7 ,....!' 7,'.'1 ,:: .?,..7. S2,A:1' .'77:744, :, ;x- ..,i .,. '_,..„,.,4,,..,,20.,.. ..: -.2.,, .1.:., r.,,v.,..;.,;\...,,:i7,1tAt.,-,00e: 57•-,.1--,: •-.--7.!.'4-•--- .,. .,‘ :-1:,,kV- .P..!. -0-.;.; ;Z:ez;,.7:''ll:''-.4.-e4;-k•••,:=,-;.1/4',',- .....-'°74•..i.:,.--17;.,-,-;..,:. 0116, -•.. '4,Arr,77; -.,:lie.. ... ''.'4.,."a, -•,"' '.-....7,*14,'"X-7',,,:'.:.?."-::'. ..,10,51,zv..'Ll'o.r .i, ,,,,kt,K,,,,d.i4. .4.1,141,,-„,,,i, .,..1.4•27,:...*4-•••4,,,,e - .,..--• .:..,..1,?,,,,F4,,,,...,Anw,,,t ii,..-.-ii....,".,44,''.--.:::,• ....,„,-.'-•-•.•_,.--;,...-.4.:...;4:•:•-•,..7z,,,,,:-,-.:e!...--„,,,,:;•44,,,, ::,....,-...1.0,,..-. ..A1,4,...•, ::.„..7.Wr ;:,,,*::,:1,',4-.M:'''..t.4,,,..'',;;*-• '.,.....:4'4, ..-:••=;=1::f.',..4,1,:-;;,,,r'..:"•1:45g.ft'.A, ,'.:;.'-*.:',',.. ... .:1:11?*:r.i:;:i.l'r<1,,,1" --T9,7.:- -y: _ - . . • .1'''7'i --; ..-'-,;." c--... ..--,.•---.. ...;''yl,. 7;i.,..27?". 1,1.t.ti7i3V,.. .:..yli-,:"-PS:i%taikne"•—*:Y,7, 1,', srit-_ ;:ti-74'; i1W471'4•:-.'''''''''''''.7'3!:•-•"---.?•:•";i::•;:-: • - •'' '04t.`:‘,,!,"•11-4e*,'-''.::,,r);"--; .'=;,:,•-p..-1.t.'•:c-''''"•-: r, lrez -•(-'''''*.i.;; 6_,. '''!.4'iliITA'41° .,„, ,„3. -41,.1.4 ..,''''`7:-Nki'.;-'-..47--'..--,W-;4';-.:•:41.-';''':::!''':4114e:. - - ts ...(4irl' +'''. .'''''.'11.A7i:',07-•1? '..e,'''':-•.'.•'•:;-:4!....':'•"4:•-.- '';';,-, .....1':'.4,•••-77;.,,, ,t...-.•,,,,*%,•*'•'.4.::•!-..t•,,s;7?-7;.:',,Z:-•:;5jrX:;,,,..,...._;3,::•4-140?. ." :•---Z 'l•-•'•440 ?•;-;'-:;:-.'4'4 '.07::-:-•'•-,:or-,••-•:.L...›Ityb.6."'••':''.-- It--.. •i,:---''.. •:?;144.41.4iiii;ije.-..t,1-,1---4':`:`,17i'l 11,4,.'7. :`' ,4-ij_.,,-'•••C•':-..,-;;;--.-,r1.. "-=:••:,•5;a: -.;.':... .4.;•4,i7,'_.-7-1...;:a .r."1.?1N.;re;,.!?i,.:.:;.:,,,:ley417., .2.--.---;% .,:;.. ,tiv,t;'',.. ..",..',... ••.•.!.-',":;•-i-,0:.•-'• f:...i-i... .......!t.,--- •••'"-.:"'..-4.-, '77-.4-4 ,-.:4,..k.:.•,1;,;,:,,,,,,141.11,3;„ (4."!...,....„.-15,,,•:Azz:".•::. -+•7:',..T10.‹:-.,:7". ',1,-,01,4;..,....'.,••,,,.::,--..,?-..i, ...-,. .,,..„.-.." --::,:,i,E...f.1,..• w*°"4. ' ,•-'•'„,-, --•-•' :y N\•,..,- 'sfi.-1*-4,.-:;Z‘MO.;:t•t,.:'-...S;-:- .:,•••,-.1.t:,,.....,.:0 ,-,•3.1.1-,....N P.. .:,i-:::...,-,:,-. ., if:1 ; 41.‘7,',Ail..!--:--.-.• ...... :7,74,,,...--41 ..••-4--,. ... - --1?''...-T:'';'•, -';q:':..-A--, ,:-..,, \T',:1:;,,=44.,,,,xY:.i.•-•.•••T'.4?•,",-..,--4-77,5. -- ,,........,..„,....,:; :., .-.1.:v..,._....f.,. .•„.pg.)?F,,,,,,.:., -,,:r.;, .--,,,,,-1.-.,,,,-,:, ..,.....-,... .. ,...,,,,:---0-.-..)N.,...;,.., ,,..,,,._-,..!,„:i...-.-.,,„..„,:-..;:...4-..,/,...„. ,:....k,..,,,,,...:-..,-. .?":;.„..,-;,-,-.,e,-,-•.,.., r.,-.-.„..:•,,,,..---.....,',..- --;-.:.•1.4-,..„.„,,•—• -'. . -,, -...,..„..40,..,, .. 3:.-.,,,,,:..., ;.,...--N..,....,,,,.,.......7-„ , -.,z;:-;... ..._.;„:...12`P,:,:.?....1:?-19r . l•'-'.jt.0'-'''';', ..1.!.40114;;;•-`;':;A: "• •4•-:,;-:•-':'---2.2 ,,qr-'''';'i7i*j;iijili:Ten-'7XC,-.4,4,!.'••"-",..-;',N::"A-:;%•:,,'•.''' • 41':',. '.1 ,:'''';?,-,.--'40;:•,;:tr: ,'••4.,;•,•••,,- : '''S--' -•..--,,,,11- -.If....r,V.,},-'7.4'1-;-A411,15".••.-' :,...:•':''-; ..--•`.: '!-''t '4"t .," .:',-,7`,,,,,-,. '.-44:4111V 1_,!.%.,;-,;•..•:,:-, 'v4.''.:•.'s ''''. ,:, :,',.:00:.:ik,re'Pt,--:,r4,,-'''..;.: lie "..C".',n, '.1.-Ak, L11111,:v.,-.•.1./1,•.--.... -,-... --A-.--;.,,A.. -„-i,..-.- ..--,--•...-: A-..,,,,:‘,.-.-. :1.,:::,,,-.v:0," --- '..:...-!‘.• - ..... -c-,.--,,...--••• ....1 4 4 III''''''' .:T lit,'''-'••-• 10 '711&',V"..,,,10...f..- 'C'..0`.....,'4.•.. .!`"ft.,:':7 0 7.,,'.;4 0'''','`.,',,'!''' "N.':-.':,.'.:•''P',C.'=?°-0'::7-,r,..',411';':i".47.'.4' .i ' ,''..--...,W..-' 1 ,1, ,.t. , .`„.1 t.:.,'r"..,. .,i:?.',4.7;., a,.- -—-.'''---.44%.. •-•:.--'4:'.-%,,--..:.6-1110'% ,•;"1 i,•.:!•';";‘,.':-T •i--;'-"fis.61-4?N.'.;•:.•' _,,..' ''''R'-",e.,.*::•%;.t.-' i';'4'',-,-.''!':,", .•''.0'-•:'••r,ae',.`,4i.',4, ''.'1•Y(!'fi....,,,,,,','4..;'----';','%,1.-?-,;, :k:s •nVlifr- c;:!„',,4:-.'-'-' ,-'2:'': '.''' r,.'$::. ,„z..',,.,,,,-%.0.0„,',2••':'7":. '',..+4":,-,-t,s, --.1t-.7 -1-4„,,--',•-..,••-‘‘Z.,=',i'',..-•A',.„'.',;;.,,..,,,..., -,:•,,,,,,, ,,, - ..,,,,,•;,:::,,,,,'.•'--,,,'.;-.;:fk*f:.'n.e.:1,,.:13;t4Z1±:::X;Ift,, .„1.. ...).,, .::'.,..,„„f,;‘,,ja,tlitj:i„,: ".•:,,,i2';`, ,A :IS,:,:r,"3''''re.:'•;-:'..,.,;.:: ;.,t':'.-'''7-'....'''' : , '.P:,!;':i!f-f2:.. ...f'''''':*.VT:)". '71.:,..,.:r..4 .,.: .,,,iilitg•.,e, -...._,....,014.r.:„1 -.47.;,:,".C.:,-- ,:171.,:iii,:':.,,,e,l'i.:-. '..Wr.. . 11.1. ,7,-,-,,:ia. rif* ,- -". ."."\-.,. .',-,;,,;f.. --,._-,,!;t,,-,,.i.:::,.f:!:.,,F--.-,W ,:-'7i-.;;,Ak"(?:..:',7i;. 41.. .:_ii.%:::,,,-,,:.•,,,,,:N,`,.‘,44,.,:,:,,,,. ii _,,,,......- ,.•,:p.,;.- ,,j,...:....,,:::...,,--.:,--.,.i.-,.4,...- '. .,-, , =;,:!... ,• "'..v, ' '..,_.-.' '`,4sr4'..'.•-..,., , ,'"- .,;',-,.:-• _ ,..f.,-...:44., ,; ...,,7 !..XS' .-• ',i-,- . '.77,:!*Irr',09'..:, -•'''''7.1.-A,",.'1A-'-.."-:':?,''..:::1-,;;^.-.. -,4,„-_,....;,...- ,,;.;,- A:10;,._ .*::. .4'..,,,s.--,...),'"7_,. ..,-.*1-.....‘,.: '.,. ,...'71' i,...i.,.'.,t,gr..,--4..4;40.7..,,,,,,,,,..::-. ,.:;-,,.:77:„.1.:1•11....migio,/,, ,.,..„ ., _,,._,....,j...L. .,;,,, .014.w...z.,,,r. _,t....,,,.,: ..,..... . i.t.-:,..,,,g::-...,F.;,;,;:.V: ,?. 4--!-: •.,.:;,..A7:H-..':--:_,.1, •-,40_,--..,..7.;,..-.:... ,,„4,-,,y!....b.,..v,.:--t.::;f7,74:,,?.... -,,:.,400% ,..,.--."-, ,.:.) ..,... -:--Nticl,:.-„,...;,:...,,g,.,,, ...!-- ,IL*NW::''.7:,'AV'.',;4."‘.,:-:!..';'_,-*.'7':.k4',1'-'-f:':.0°..'..,' ,., .'''.:44':::::):..,,'V..-,. '1441,71-..'.!,.‘W,,e,iiz.71:;...„1.7::01. 5.4Z:,;:: ;',„-.:.,•:::,',' ,.!..:*:17,';'1tr't.:,Aki,':::.1' ''''Z:i:'::.;2 '.1-',14,••t,:?,;.,e.;;;P:‘,,...7•':,•%,:,,.5-',, ..,- '..;,zr•-_, ••:',-.);i•-:'.4,, •';-,47,1...';2,:-...;•,:•7'.(400P,1-'-.•-,,, rn'''-''';..!.•'-',:r•-••%,,''.;.'.- "Z'f,,8*,,f17.,•;:',.'W;;•,?'.,4,,,,(5-.0-,-;s7i• ;"..,"•?'",: ,?..,..4,''.4,,,r-'-'.:-#,1701',''','''.•,•.•.,, ••L';,:.,:•4in,,..0''';41471;':"'----•,t‘''''.''' '..,"•1-; --,...!,...••,,,;>‘,' ''„:„.ii,'!',,,12-,,,zyliTh,,- 0.114-r•.',1'-..,,,, .,•e!h?,.;-...2..,fillr-,4,4,4,:.•,,,A -,.-.4.:,..--',7n.;--,..,,e-..z. ,.:,,,-.7.4-,,, ,..,..-.•:,,,..-.,-.0,,,,,, ...,.; •:ir.;. ,,,...,%-..,rill.:•,,:•/...,:1:.,,,,,. . . . i •:-i;.•' •.t?.'...f-,...,4-, .— ii-i....----A ' : .•:•,,,. ., 1,..,.. .42,,..44t,,, ,,,,,:•:.. . ,..-,.;?-'4, ,...,,,,,..'.--•.,---,i'....",ifiz,. _AI, ..,...,...,,,-,k,,, , -,'N 4,,,,r41611-4.4'.'''- .1:"'• () .4.-''''•'-:)4:4*Rrl 4,:'' • • f.•'• 1.":7-:•'-:•';''':;itt.p.:Ir'''''''' 7.•7rA.,-;,S'.-N,Z.,-''..,,,;•'-4,1'''jg:14:''' -...':'"--,;,ftie,'W"'' -44,-.re.A.%•? '''. ,-•'' 'ilii•-•2'.‘,4' •-•''':ii '.''...'`W ,.;,..`r, ,•-,..,i. ; ,.•--,.:.--4p,,,,,,-,- ., ;,,..--.. 47' ..- ,ItilSi-,..,y, ''21••'' c, -,' ,1,,-''''• '''.•-•‘'-. :r.•Iii•ek;.,1 . "--.- •'•• • " -' • ''' '''ii• ---‘ 1 a *-..., ---) ...„,.. ... .,:,,,,,.., .,.(..„.., .„-‘. ....... .„41!....1 .,.-.''0;-<-.1-* '',;,,,,,'Zi7.-• . ,;,,t... * - - ,:-Te.2.1..':',,,'" '.' :':".,', -. L ..--,- -''=-7:-! 2let . ._ . .. .... .,.,-.k ....., .. 4,..,....,': - • ...,: ,,-,,..-).''.-C.V.•'!, -;..g. . .. • :, '-''• ' ' • •'• ' '- le .', ' -.:/$44.;'•11•,• 'et'il0 Av -r •.1'"1-,"'''-'': ''.,...ik •• -,..,1`•- A, •.i. k7 r.•''• ..'' •• •• 4. ".7. ,-,..."4''.4.-',' , • • '`.. •.--- V '.. -'' --',. ' • ., No•• ',::4=k/re-•?1''....:•:•'''''';',"411. '''1---.•••sk /.4VIC itV-1 Wai•P--,;:' +•6 „. . %II--1.;•e--.41,. •r ,4','e ,.-.-- "',:;17.;.'i.• '-4 -0. ''.,'.,',.. -..." .:.,';‘,.,. -'; - ,4,..:r.:Aqt,.;;:•,.',,,,":.y.f.',.=K4g.,-.', 4 - ''' •-•"'" 04.1 .4sijj.;",e '' -.',--1 ,.;,A4.6- ._, li,,' - ,.. •-;..1.:- 1- • '=- ' ' a,..-, . - ., . _. ',... .4.;...-1:4. %.,.; '• tc,,,:..."-%.44625-61,' :-•-•"rgt. ie... '-,,,,•_.:tj.', -.0,-2!40,- .. -,;,...'.,c,-. .leiv.":' ., • ..44%;.2z,Ai#4 '' ''' W , . • • • • • PAGE 1 OF 3 • Ps°FZHE Tpk� Town of Barnstable • y ' s',. °�' Regulatory Services• • BARNSTABLE. • EXHIBIT MASS. i Thomas F. Geiler,Director X B �A ,639. A,o 'FD�AA� Public Health Division Thomas McKean, Director 200 Main Street, Hyannis, MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4644 Fax: 508-790-6304 July 29,2003 Mrs. Brenda Tri 2051 Main Street West Barnstable, MA 02668 ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST THE PLACEMENT OF NON-COMPOSTED MANURE ONTO THE TOP OF THE GROUND, ORDER TO CEASE AND DESIST COMPOSTING MANURE, AND ORDER TO REMOVE ALL FUTURE MANURE FROM THE PROPERTY ON A REGULAR BASIS On July 28, 2003, Health Inspector Donna Miorandi, R.S. and Health Agent Thomas McKean, R.S., conducted an inspection of your horse stable facilities located at 2051 Main Street West Barnstable, due to complaints received. Fourteen horses were observed on your property on that date. The following violations of the Town of Barnstable Board of Health Stable Regulation, Part X, were observed: PART X (7): Piles of non-composted manure observed on top of ground scattered along the top of a bank, slope of the bank, and at the foot of the bank which is located at the south-west corner of the property. Evidence of soil and debris run-off from the steep embankment of manure piles onto the lower elevated land, between stone walls and onto neighboring property. PART X (7): Both compost bins containing manure were partially uncovered. Also on July 7, 2003, Health Inspectors David Stanton, R.S. and Donna Miorandi, R.S., observed dust materials rising into the air from an area where blue colored angular sand/stone dust materials were recently spread onto the top of the ground at your property. This dusty material was observed blowing onto neighboring properties. This was a violation of 310 CMR 7.09 and you were issued a written warning notice to cease and desist spreading sand/stone dust onto your land. During yesterday's inspection, large piles of the same blue colored angular sand/ stone dust materials were observed on your property. It was suggested to you that the piles should be lowered to reduce dust. You are ordered to immediately cease and desist the disposal of any manure onto the top of the ground. The non-composted manure dumped onto the bank located at the south-west corner of the property shall be removed and disposed of properly. You are also ordered to immediately cease and desist the composting of any manure at your property in the future. • PAGE2OF3 In addition,you are ordered to remove all manure from your property on a regular basis (e.g.weekly) and to dispose of the manure properly. These orders take effect immediately upon your receipt of this notice. You are reminded that manure shall not be allowed to accumulate on the property. All owners of stables housing horses must clean the stables at least once each day and waste matter shall be disposed of in a sanitary manner on a regular basis. Since August 28, 1998, the Health Division Office received twenty-six (26) complaints regarding the horse stable at this property. Twenty(20) complaints were received in regards to improper disposal of manure. Your original request for a variance to spread horse manure on the ground was not granted, as indicated in the letter to you from the Board of Health dated March 22, 2001. At that time, Board did grant you permission to construct enclosed compost bins, with covers, and to place all manure within the compost bins. However, it is apparent that the two compost bins which you constructed are severely insufficient for the number of horses on your property and the amount of manure which is generated on a daily basis, coupled with your failure to keep them properly covered. According to Jessica Page, WSU Cooperative Extension, Whatcom County, Washington, (at website: www.whatcom.wsu.edu)two compost bins would be adequate for only one to five horses. However a total of fourteen horses were observed at your property. Also, your compost bins were not covered on multiple occasions including.during yesterday's inspection on July 28, 2003, and during inspections on June 26, 2003, April 14, 2003, October 15,2002, October 18, 2002, and September 19,2002. On September 23, 2002, a letter was mailed to you via certified mail which read"you are reminded that the compost bins shall be kept covered all times whenever there is any Manure kept within them." Also an order letter was mailed to you by certified mail on October 18, 2002 regarding piles of non-composted manure observed on top of the compost bins and regarding an uncovered compost bin containing manure. Within that order letter, you were ordered to correct the violations within 24 hours. However, after that date, due to recurring violations of uncovered manure within the compost bins and due your failure to properly dispose of manure; you were issued non-criminal ticket citations on April 14, 2003 and on June 26, 2003. You may request a hearing before the Board of Health if written petition requesting same is received by the Board within ten (10) days. However, the violations shall be corrected immediately regardless of any request for a hearing. The option to appeal to the Board of Health does not over-ride the immediate public health threat imposed due to the improper disposal of manure. The manure disposal violations-must be corrected immediately by regularly removing manure from the property.(e.g. weekly). Your request for a hearing shall include a written proposal of how you intend to properly dispose of manure from fourteen (14) horses each day. PAGE 3 OF 3 Failure to comply with this order may result in the issuance of a$100 non-criminal ticket citation. Each day's failure to comply with an order shall constitute as a separate violation. Thomas A. McKean, RS, CHO Director of Public Health • • - THE FOLLOWING IS/ARE THE BEST IMAGES FROM POOR QUALITY ORIGINALS) " AGE DATA • UNITED'STATES POSTAL,SERVIC ' -rat;clo YVl . ' ' ,• QO• P1q • ..E4Stage& es aid 001 1940 0004 9042 1501• 1 �K; • p M _----- f.--permitNo". 70 • - 13I1 z1.11 m o m in • c or:Jut /; hg1 ° - $ 3 o ,' Sender Please p�ii�'�you rr��, address andd ZIP+4in this box = e of g A* o eii�d _ No ? I I- a m 11 !°r. ( Town Of Barnstable r-r t-+CD D n t „_ Public Health Division b ' ' b - - 200 Main Street N • - Q a° m � Hyannis, MA. 02601 5 c r - - SENDER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION -'= COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY t d.Complete itam's7 2 and 3`Also complete b1. Si re d.5. x F +.'- � Iii item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired" `. - ., C ent ©'Print your namend address on the reverse •_�"•.• '� - -..,❑Addressee / r so that.we can return the card to you g R. (prrnte Name) C D t of Deliver. I ® Attacfi:this card:to the track of the mailpiece ccpp -. or on ttie front if space permits. ✓ :,C.� ��r". ..: 3 "' - D Is delivery address different from item 1? Ye , 1.. Article Addressed to - / a If YES enter"delivery address below o 1 i x 1I Mrs. Brenda Tri s _ FI 112051 Maiii�Street 4; z. j I West Barnstable, MA. 02668 ! 3 S_eeType ' 1 [ Certified Mail I ess Mail -'El.Registered '- Return'Receipt for Merchandise I ❑ Insured Mail ❑C.O.D. . I .. ..._...-... __.._...___, __...,.....- 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) ❑Yes 2. Article •Number ., ;._:,,;,,_ .` 7 0 01 19 4 0 ''0 0 0 4 9 0 4 2 1501 i . (T}ansfe fiiirrisenrice:lalie7 iT I PS orm;:381 August 2001 'Domesfjie Return Receipt .tozss- r.t oz- =isac 0 1 I li i It II 'III I I It t►1 I e • v 5:D 1 V IURTHA CULLINA LLP 600 UNICORN PARK DRIVE WOBURN,MASSACHUSETTS 01801-3343 TELEPHONE(781)933-5505 ATTORNEYS A T L A W FACSIMILE(781)933-1530 www.murthalaw.cortt EXHIBIT E August 6, 2003 RECEIVED BY FIRST CLASS MAIL AND CERTIFIED MAIL AUG 12003 RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED ARTICLE NO. 7001 0360 0001 9961 1756 -ro'NN OF u"'p-t a�E HEALTH DE PT. Thomas A. McKean Director of Public Health Town of Barnstable. 200 Main Street Hyannis, MA 02610 RE: Public Document Request Please be advised that Murtha Cullina LLP represents Diamond's Edge Farm regarding the Cease and Desist Order issued on July 29, 2003. Pursuant thereto, I am Petitioning for a hearing before the Board of Health concerning said Order. In compliance with said Order, manure will be removed from the Farm on a weekly basis. Also pursuant to G. L. c.66, §10, please provide to me, within ten (10) days from receipt of this request a complete copy of the entire file maintained by the Department concerning the Farm located at 2051 Main Street,Barnstable,MA. It is my understanding that none of the public documents requested above are exempt pursuant to the provisions of G. L. c. 4, §7 clause 26. I further, pursuant to the provisions of 950 CMR 32.05 (6), elect my entitlement to receive all such documents by mail. Please forward to me an invoice for any costs and I will forward you aheck for the same. Thank you. Sincexel , \ i arffilW9r- • FAD/mj f cc: Brenda Tri BOSTON HARTFORD NEW HAVEN WOBURN 600 UNICORN PARK DRIVE MURTHA C7LLINA LLP 6ODURC.MASSACHUSErES 01801-3343 TELEPHONE(781)933-5503 A T T O R N E Y S A T L A W FACSIMILE(761)933-1530 wyrAniurataLiw.corn EXHIBIT_- September 2, 2003 BY FIRST CLASS MAIL AND FACSIMILE: (508) 790-6304 Thomas A. McKean Director of Public Health Town of Barnstable 200 Main Street Hyannis,MA 02610 RE: Diamond's Edge Farm Enclosed please find a check in the amount of Eleven Dollars and 30/00 (S11..30)to cover the cost of postage for the mailing of the public documents requested by letter dated August 6, 2003 and received by you via Certified Mail on August 11, 2003. On August 20, 2003, Ms.Rita Connors contacted this office to inform me that the copy cost of the documents would be S150.00. On August 21, 2003 I caused to be forwarded to you a cbeck in the amount of S150.00. Whereas I have not as of this dated received the documents related to tonight's . -aring, please continue the matter to the next available date after the documents have been m-' -d to me. I thank you in advance for your kind cooperation concerning -_s-, •• - $iricerely, l ima.-ww,0" FAD/mj f cc: Brenda Tri Victor J. Collis BOSTON • HARTFORD NEW HAVEN WOBURN • PAGE 1 OF 2 �Op1HE Tp� Town of Barnstable " Regulatory Services • swRNscnsLE. • • SS. Thomas F. Geiler,Director tor9• ♦0 '64D mgs Public Health Division Thomas McKean,Director 200 Main Street, -Hyannis, MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4644 EXHIBIT�_ Fax: 508-790-6304 October 6,2003 Mrs. Brenda Tri Diamond Edge Farm 2051 Main Street • West Barnstable, MA 02668 • --- - - - OF-CON-T-IN-UANC-E-OF-CEASE AND DESIS;I` E-ARING---- - - - - NOTICE OF HEARING ON STABLE LICENSE SANCTIONS NOTICE OF ADDITIONAL COMPLAINT On September 18, 2003,tie Board of Health members voted unanimously, at the request and with the occurrence of Dr. Victor Cillis acting on your behalf,to continue the hearing you originally requested on the cease and desist order entered on July 29, 2002 against the activities described therein, until Thursday October 30, 2003 at 5:00 p.m.. The hearing will be held at the Town Hall, second floor Hearing Room, 367 Main Street Hyannis. You are reminded that the following cease and desist orders remain in effect pending the hearing: • You are ordered to immediately cease and desist the disposal of any manure onto the top of the ground. The non-composted manure dumped onto the bank located at the south-west corner of the property shall be removed and disposed of properly. • You are also ordered to immediately cease and desist the composting. of any manure at your property in the future. • You are ordered to remove all manure from your property on a regular basis (e.g. weekly) and to dispose of the manure properly. During the public meeting on the 18th, Dr. Cillis agreed on your behalf to submit copies of receipts from the man-are disposal site to the Board of Health. Copies of the receipts from the manure disposal facility shall be submitted to the Public Health Division Office , 200 Main Street,Hyannis on a weekly basis. Failure to comply with these orders may result in the issuance of a$100 non-criminal ticket citation. Each day's failure to comply with an order shall constitute a separate violation. In addition to considering whether to extend the cease and desist order, the Board will also consider on October 30 whether to place the order and any extensions in your license file. The Building Commissioner has informed Health Department Staff that the fence around the stable has nct been properly permitted, and Health Department staff also 20030213 letter2 PAGE 2 OF 2 received a complaint of a new manure accumulation in the southwest corner of your property,which they investigated on October 2, and which, if not properly disposed of, could constitute a violation of the cease and desist order. As the holder of a stable license issued by the Board you are required to comply with all of the Board's regulations, particularly those contained in Part X, Stable Regulation, of the Town of Barnstable Health Regulations. Failure to fully comply with any applicable regulation(s) could, among other consequences,result in suspension, revocation or non-renewal of the stable license issued by the Board. Thomas A. McKean,RS, CHO - - - - - - - Cc:- - Dr.Vrctor£-illis- . .. . . .. --- - - - - - - - .. - ... _ . - - - - - - -- -- Frank Diluna,Esq. • 20030213 letter2 • d s 11 ,. i i I-1 to counterclaim of Miller et al Tri et al v. Miller et al. Barn. Su.. C. A. No. 2004-0084 r 4 t )n y 4 •X l Yr ab �. 'tt.Jpyf+�r r - <�t. G rT , :-.I} y- 1t 4..,Sk1 ..a �R J'i q EXHIBIT Ir: ..7 j a•r '. 1 ar „yt,• - € 'i 1 1 r Y : e.Ac .fX ' ; ,LS` -'$ ,�,� ^a r i+ v '1 a n^ 1 7 6 7a .( .r. ,. a+. i <7 r i .;,- ) x �a Y# ',a '` „e ...„ .. e 7t :>,. �r W ,-F A;'..-{ Js t' f t•^4�',1 y'_ �t , •, s 4 r •,,,c s+i it '. ab. .' x r v. t " . i- ,: e. pt � t i ► b �+r r'�� a .� 7+ , -. s / . r+ F A 'r ., ra 3..;, ','i� 7 4 r u a , t �' a .1 t ". r tiR it r..„ j�.,1+�, • ,. -"Ott , • ., f • 3t I•t M�Jai: {a ' -n � .•`t 3, 6!' , ++ ,,,If'w � ,r t i.-•- s ': .i t ' A.},k'�. i -� % 7 .•J„ * 'e4+ St. t'-n - . k s �; a�i. �' j>t""'v c T c S ti` d l ':-� ++w, � \• yes, `P I ,�y � F � !,� r!: •a R- ",� fii�- fir. ". e _ r i'+t � � t N -�*•,� � yp.. 1 {s� R �S ! t 4 � � _^ }-- J 1 1 . ty�,7A'j. a,�, i s i .. 4 �, Y I .J!1 i t , ?�,, b`�;.t' f 7 y , ,i k , _,',-,, t G [ f['' ~ fi^)j t'b .: ',y,.2 e� r-A �g� x�$6 f , ,-,,,-' y 7. r":,:;.. ,�(,7Cr ... J ,,i1 v, :7, r;'/ t7 v 1"F ;'. y �0 t.6; Y: ��[ r"Mw yZlcj•s,y 4 !t"Y ,1r ^�•h 12' It � y-� t}bt _�iJ[L tcf ) l �. 1� ;.-,y ��if r < r ::-e a '� � 1- t r s. IJI.� Y o t' a 7 ;.: ' '2t. ,•1e N I .x J 1 •e i 1 :'� a '�. f., ,R{ � _ �Fyn �"5� 32F`�h�A.' ,� .r S� E ,s •� >.ih,�! ,)II y�r`"F„} -1 4 �� s rapt+'1 , tl..... • •,� �„' + ��r z z e r `, ,, r i( rx� r i '4,� ,F `x ' h ' �}. r ,1 sue'! j,u s E ak5• �t 'c1 4 :'rY6 � fd � i r tt ` .i.: yv .. '� w .:j.i„;i[ :..�- •i:0.t+ '• � 1�.�. ''1,. .1t)ri }rx •.l�r' '- - r s 3 - ,[ ti ty-" tY"' zr [.i ,r r, � `,a�' 3 .t,� gg�' :,, ;• a� ' [a ; k x �. ., .s +l 'K_ }3 V G) • rrr� [ r� !F J r 7 i s ��: �{'�/�. i ' [.•• + .' n.+". H iw+ may. q •f .. ... c r y& •L s 4. Y ii` iT t�__yfri ..s4•�aa, 4. .'�"' r flit%E. ]` r sf it7 • r Z e. MS�► .. ` �,. S!.!Fro✓ T1i --1 4 ....:•„:.,...:, _ ,...., . ... • .. ..... ..... .. _ , _ . . . .. . •:.....,........7.,..,..„ ... ..,,,,,,.., .-.. . ..., .,........__1„._ _.:„, ,... .. .. ..,...„_, . • . . _. . .. . .„..,..:..1.,_.-. ...• . , ,,,.. -;...,;,,, ..,:,,:-....- , ,...„...„..:-.7„,r-- • e � 2 YLt. c v '.• �l 1 t . ' .i. 1F ` .r ° t .e �"� � i �F w aF' EXHIBIT 1-2 to counterclaim of Miller et al, TRI et al v. MILLER et al. Barn. Su.. C A No 2004 0084 ra..� ., �:`f, -nt� r x 'fie k' z, ',- , • -/ ,( y`o f at f y-'FDt t� •M !• - "G' . ar. h' � ' ' � �'4t ? A r3 ti. S f9 ' j prxr= f_ r� o terr � b h, 4c rt i� HM a � ..?,,.-;),;.;,-.:,...:,--•-..:-.-:,.',n , .',' i s1 4�:!1,03 ,4o ,:t ' rm f F: F j ; 3 n�}� Ja � "`'+ � ��r i Zf a, s3 J w t _km-. .i 4,4 " u •C Ax +P yY i.s ' ,': I.r ' ° h�k„ yn , SL ! : rw k a 1 .. -4 � ' � ,,`z t; 0iii t " a A" r 3r Y� ' _i t ' 'g -" * rJp - ;t. � ti ¢ ' am '� s!V 6 L y � r" ; RAl Fa C y ,+t 4•'r it A '�! ?b V'4 t ,f r ? . 1 . a r 1 �J3S rs - .t t ! v s ati' y s 7'� • k. % . "`.4 �i .r ^ s S r > t,n Q> ! -' r t Z �7 f. tj t i /:. u ;: yy s r a ,tYb. p M ,} . r ' , -5 a• • k s �f , {u.4-fi; E 4,rX SS .✓ i• ..a fit? ,+ ' ` r� w - �'` .."' ,-R�,kis a h• l r y5 _ ! ,+tom .. ,r • ,...,4;,.� } 1 y...4 ,4,, tf} . • _ 9 �,�-,E• (( _r rl u , l'4An u i 4-, j.;>+a y"�S t€.,.. ,.-y' ,q {r^ .*-- - �1 •J i / '' ro t ,• ,q , ,gam; z •,'�,,v W • i r Iti:,4f ';9' a ` • t!r 4 �Yr r y j, l-: • . ..,, 7 "7+ `,,, R4 �,y., +� -q? Yt• v `v!,W" 1�,D,.ct-'4{'4' ��; {!'� W`i r�J 't 1 t "1`•�� +f• O • f '... x �,.`.*{'�': .... !fi '„�cX,'r' Y ,,: :".,`t'' F4Ts' r 7- S �}t'',Y��,,,..,'` , ,,,, r /" r%� ,1 t!� �. ti6' 'j a �,. .t. '"5t. -�" rS . 'l 1' r"fs- 74,,,_ i tj�k /-ry c A : -,- r \ \'• � y'e x„ :AA'.7 / tr•y r:•� •= "`' nl / i ,i41 �� � i /r 4i p• F .! ti , _ x .F • c• m r a�. 61 ri f ! ✓ -..w _ J m v \ t•'• d ,yam ,„ 5r+� c S. a s 4" «' �: r '+.�. d^~ 1. r t �'" d=atik 4/ a�yrn tl-'.;;ti's. • `�\ + ti -. n AA,.� 1,yik fv ° �jy','<'- ,/ ri' 3 a,`, - k W w.y ._:��„ 0.4. •W.,a/ C el�aa'1;. k r' n Pr•li ,% r. •F � '� 6� 'i(� . L n `..4,.. `�} �' - ..• t:r ' S �' f A f >� -ems` ram, '' s u� TY;?,f r ` ' :r /'r it � l l,; f t•-. -:.••• �-• r t `�,y .,s i-"'0 .+ T r 0.s y+:t' -a• , �•tt �. P. ` u• 7P55•5 +•_ i '' :.•- ~ .f Xµ" 2 � " 'eT�. s1\cr wC. '3'`r. ��_ f +r .„4.3:1_�� t! W` �. 1 x t•• it f -�( y f riy'�'^ +v/ r ti ,,r,.S �. ' v* j. ,A% ,,,tiz titer r r k� '�` "' ` • ' •�'".. 'cY q+: --�- �" " ¢e.. • 7 a .*Af•4\�� 'k ,s' "_ l!'','' ty`3.at x'`"',,�t v�da i`,Y r "y,..... T1 .I' "7e.., 1•... CO �, r fi ,�;, /�5, 4-, ,3-,. �,•.. t ,/•e� x�Z..Sr�r y�.� K',7 , :?. / .,." s ; a�,,,5�� a a �r / _ e.i „ 'Y r f,r- a_ , + ,a "i.. 'uj.' s`� v L rV r 1 V[ - .s• , ��... -� � Il�. �� �i �` �"'�c , a�e r„q� `�is t'..+'in 4�f Zr�� K,s P y .; , G y. .j,. 1'^ r ". ,"..*y.' 4 .::1; �'^'tip', J `t', s yt i • � `� . r{ .a r� + +>i V. _ 4' S r i f•;J /"3 .i�Ail.:‘:.:'.. y7�TrZ s -,`:rot f4C '�.. „£1Ft..f.k � , }a,,Wt' Zf, d40t 11 r •: t -u,r --.3 '••• ,'- •"..-n..� S r r 7,,,.l'eJi. .n., f r tM-;-,: 1`, 1, .. _ .• .. ,ice 1 Ct. BACV et al Barn. Sup. x.„,.. .. ......29?,4-?.?84. ,:., MILLER ,,.:-..,.- 1 TRI et al v. -„-: ; , ,-,"-,:-.....;.;./ii :: , .-„..!:.','4;•.- f 1. . of Miller et a , !..i'.,5 :-- 4".t, - . ;11,..'.1.t..4counterclaim ,,..'..-f',.•4-Ci*** -•'-4.04,....,,,?,.;);..... ,,''...,,..--.;',,.,.• '... . ri-f.,-7i.,..,.....,„ . Exhi tit 1-3 to __ _ ,-.....c ,.. ,,,.,,....,,,-.. _,,,, .„4..4..,,),........ .:1.-..,,•?..:L,1---,;5•,;‘,?-2,.. ',- 1,,,,•, - I/- 'int ii-,:!-4k-•i'•%.e.-:;;;;-‘7,," :Itr.t.:,-;;•I.-,,:‘•.":j.-14,'.':' .,..1.'- `••-:-,....•• - ', „_ •,.' . .- 44" ,•?4 ' . ',1,4Pt',‘"J‘;.--5 *, ,• * ! '' -)...;fi-;;• *''''.)'. 0,-:'-'..,,4',,,,••••.**'*/-•'n'I.c,..4,.'•:::',,P•":%,.PP,'"'n'V:.-n• t ;*•:":::'..'"‘•-'n.',' ' " 's i,""V-'n'•'.•••:'•nn' '''7':".*'.--"'.e.7-., ..!"Ie.....'-;,- . .-4„--A;i---:..,.,•,,:,,,,'-.4:',4 ,:a1.7•••,1•V•,-,•% . In••i - , - ......• ''..- '''-L.':4-',;.-- ••••,.`--",:,•1%7.4'. ''-,..!• .,''' . ,,, .'.,:,'•;,„.- „'" ,...,,.; ,-;-_,;= !1.";,,;.',.: .---..„'••-.'..- li:.-,--Y- ,......" „,,,Ji,..t.....o-d,,-.3--. 1e;;;;;,;144.0 ••,-“; • ..Iti- .1 • :. 1 . ,,,. -..Cet` ,-,-i',.:?., ' , -1 fr'll:' f.n. .... .--.%.5.;1;;7:-- ,,,,,,,,*..-S..-,'':',.t-,,,,,...• ,,. -...1.. ,_:.,,. , . - .„-,,-; '',-.`;- .1:•t-7 .';';?I'-..."nnaAn- --•••-7•••',"-'*- ' '‘'..:17'9: 4:';','` ,1-7";'"J)',1-•,;.r.c,-.„ -5,f.,e!''', .••••*,'nn'n. n.fi,`- - -''' - * •:;„2,i. ' ,.-.."'''-..",r•", ,,•'1. ...,"`;',TYg‘• ',,,"; ,•nt'.'ff-"---" gl,„,-z ."=-:•-• •`,. . „.•. --,t ;‘,-4..---,---- .-., ,-4...„.:....1%.: , - -- ._ '.-'',•I'S n',7' ,,n,,,,i;n:,, .•:S.'. ).,.:-.,.,7`, '1,017* •,-;N ,,t•..Wdz.Z.-0,r4.•,.....3-;`-;"'...--•',, ...2-,..1,,":,;,,,,,:f..*••••" '4"':' 'n '1,--0..-...----•,,,:-:=r....17,-.4'..'-.3..; :;,-. .'`,,-.'''. ' . •,.,....-'' -,,.\''..,,,, ....t7: 7 : :-\..._tl'.$1:.c."-;:k& .1'' 'C''. '.'-';..‘7.....:.'-'7,'' .,- .400.V.,;''''.1;' -:..,.!' ' , - ''. '-/-../, .' :,•,. 2 _,..z.c„, . ..,0-,!••,••,:4',-r•.4,;., ',..,.- ';''',' -- - •':.. '-'1,-.--„,:a..1r.).--ca.,'i.•-•...,::::M-, ....'i.--;:','--' *-j''•-',' ..„,i-• - ' '' '-' '''.' -'' ..S.7',.'',.:. ..:•;,,,..;'.,Q.,, .,..,-.f.-r,,.'''',..',,,.*:..,'.7%,,,,,,, 41-7.Te',...,iet. ..-^` i.''',.'" 0.: „:" ..... .,r.,''-," ' „sr.::: ''Z'"... '1.'...&/•"%fiW,, ...-,'". ...r. ..%;17.,:„,.._.7?"..,,, • ,'''''.''-- ''-'':'' ''' ••rivi'`.'ill!. 1 '4:-•-• f.',.t''',...,, ,,,,,--7:,' ...-11Ft. .. .;:, oi'' " ...,-a:i-.r--...>'s-.;i-'. .. ,-',--''' f ''''-',..--. n• n'•‘......'-"--'N n' '•,1;,,,,;.•,,: ..,k-": ,•:"....Ayr ' ill;.--4W-,...„1-4•47-;•ffi4.5, .-44.4- "-,.. ,,ttl, V .;,--rxtt.-.)•. -?-1 -, .7:„..2.....3-1,-,,,,..-.,.•_,•-,_.,.. •_.- - . . -. „„, ,,,,,,,,., -''''4--•-;---,115,-,,':. s ,--•-,,,,,_, , ',.:-',/.!1....., 11... .-,.. :---:::!4„-. ,•'-4..'.....?,,,,. '';• ••,,".•;:•0',Ahr•..t."• --.14fr, „,.--- -"•c!..-7,4:;•'/X:. ,A, f-•''''-'-'.'''17-:;"..'''•''''•••.' ' - • 5- I.•:" :, •' 1 --,-- •-•---. It- :I' ••-4..., -v-.„..1-e-w......;.... .tvl.,.._-:-...,,.741., ...,11......piriS-..,,,....",....:4, .i;,....„7 1v7'..•... ‘,......,?' ,..r.:4,,.' ,,,:e .. ,s. .• -,- '4'. ."-: ,', .!_e... -:•,"'.4',7'7%.1,-4-7...Skl. 4$'..f!'..%,*—, ...r‹...1.':''.,'i:P'. , ..Y."..1.,'W r-4', '%. ',:,.7-• ,.'-..•.', ,..(A:-'-'/',-,;,';',, -::4:-',.-,,i.;•• ‘,..'-,..t1,-',•-• -.....1.::, - '*-- :.-=:, '',.-•. 4-y--.-'---=-.e.-'::-1 --__,--1.- .,,•••' 4..r:'''l'-‘4.1g•t%r5-ti-4.1-2d4-4.17'stf•T5-'.'•-i:A;..44--.4.44:;•"'" ..P4,-;,:;•- •,.;''rr rA-SA1 it- ' -.'7:04,4 ;7;4,4i;f;-•-16g:;!...",`1;:%•fa•- •.;,'11 '';'.:. •,:v.-.A, :'.,:-.1 ':_ .6. ••=i,-3;,---;,,,,„..*:!-,*;_, ,,;4:::::,. ,...„..,..:. -,$-'-‘t..-4,-,i_..„<-..v... -..,1-it. _ ,: ./...,i4 -' - 4 .-.,.:.. .,,,;-......,...',4-,,?..t.,:-.1.-i.a „.,;g.t.f-r4' ','... , ,,,.. ,7::' : -.,1Ra ., 'A,% Vi'Ls-.1- 1....`7:c,-..4.' .,. Tg4-'eirs,i.„t-.7- -:; -..,P:i-,'. -.1: 44-K' I,. 1-. 41 ' .--..------,....` ` -*.f.:por.. ,,4- .1.,.,.,r-,...,-3.....1;..-.4...: , .."....,...1„...:.;,,;..„. --;.„,,,.;,..-=.;. --e..1:.% -.......;_•tql,:-.--.. .wis,„,t...,:., , ,,,,::,,.,-..,(0.•;Ame.,1. -../,..... .-. ...-A- ------,‘ i ,„..-.‘ ,..i-,- ...r.,.-41?-t:-,.--,,-Ab--,zt, i.. ..,.-.•,.,t.--:,, '77*. , , - '..''' 7,'•_, '.. * ,,:',?'„.. .!:!;•!:"V,‘...-.:*,:n .."41Zkl:17,7.A 1110000% n"•-'-''''"'-ryOrnlig.V'1' 't;-,l', '`‘' ir '" --.4.....,`:,, -n' '''- .*:;01;•. '...I,.e•,,i..--.'"rn•''`,,,,n21-,..C.-,•-n.''..;`•,:„, ,. 4.,-,1.* -1..-...,...1, .,. •Ttifx•••,,, - 1 • ,‘, e.,1"•..,-...1•4„ ,t, 1 P.1,ft,,-..,,J.,•.4. ..:•,. •.1.,..;•;,A,-;`E:••,••.-e iti,..,YME - ,,,f,. .bF,,..•••...'..n.,i..,4*-1...".,,t:.,:,,,,,vt,--_1•-•.•,,.1.,,•-,C:•,,,,,,.,.! . •,,,,. , . . ••-.' _-.. -..:.•\ •,,,,,tyr4j :.. -' -,,, ,74.: ,if. ',""sr4, Npl,..•.1. "-•"'4''.1,1;f".54'1".•41,'i'11.1.1'•1"..,,,,t,'•-'-'.7, - '.g..,4.4.T,,ii--'^.'-t.,,,-,,...••..o.';•". :,"-•-l"i, '',. .1 •-'"-\' 1 ' :•1.- -7•-•"7.--S'.5..fr ' . : -t-.T.-4-.0-;aPpri-- -,12.1.,....... : ,,,, ..,...,,,,,..,-. .,-....., --.--..-- - , ,...4,- - , - ea,--„;'4‘..:'.1.-•-1:0":;":::::fr41' •-•-'-J.s4-'`- ••:?:.'--41:'-'5•••-n:y.FA" *'''''P.`,S•ft,'-'4. .' ". .....," -"S.,,..'•!"" -s•"..+T'if' - `•••.44/:!4. ..r ?-11,4„,,:,-; ,-• ' , - .""_.,,,--,,L. ,,,, .1,-......,..:::,,:,#5,6;iss::•-.4..,--4A-..,,i,q..A. •-•, -4.:,-,,- 4-,r. -...-.•"• •c•-"*...,;48,f,/,,J,, ,, . ,..,,,,...5.-..-....,0,;,-..,....d.;.....7• .....”......1, ..c. (..,-...,i,.,....,- , .-s., 2. ,- .......„. ..,,,s-_-. .. .„. . -.'t.,:l.fly„ii.:.:z:t..:..??.1..."41.,-4-..,.,..,-4--: Pt:r.",-•••-7 '-‘1.,.'"r".,'•,...'''': •r‘e- -4....r - ••'' "wly--., - '4.- -„,;icttit,.., ti,J.-.. ..,, ---,-,...,-,-- --..,'? .' ... _=.....v:-.T.7.. .."... ..";,..i. ..,,,,-.....,;c4of::-.„..1.,....-k.e.-.:1,4,. .f.!--,-,...-. ,..,..-.:f... .....i4±.,.f.,..., I. ..c -•.-:,L , td.0.-,•-•., . . ,,'.. - ,.-..----....„..,., •.,,.... ..if,. .;,--.•--' '..."..-,--.--..r. ' ..---,,,,,Q.,.....--• .,'.. ...----; ,,s. -.„; .-*_t-i-uo-.-...;''''''-,. :-- e ,,. -‘,-'':,, :'-';---•'''', e.:- .-.,_-''',`,7,,-;',"."—_,.....,:-.-•'_`"':',.; F4.-...:,'-'1 '7.„4:4 .4.3147 ,41W;-"ti 4.. ,.. -,-.7--, .,..r:.,-- ,,,. ...,ilr'+"..,-.14:'-A.,,,,14;....A.3..ft.,:., ,...fr,',I.(...,,..''-',!,--,,:.:,',....`,•,.''- .. :IT, 4.--,-*,.-,,i;' .-7.)..viet,tif.'mg....ez--..- 7,-7,,A.„::,,-..-•'.,,...:,,; ,,7-...,„.._-...-rt-, .1.1:4::: .,-::../..:,; --....,,..,::--7.y., :,_,,,,L.,-...-.5.,.. .-,...,?4-,4;s4..0,-,i--;.i..,..,:,:,::.--- -:;;-.--; ','fi-,=. 7,*..;,..,,_--',:*•.4.A.,;...;',e'.:*rifr.f-.4,--1,51.`5.i '- 7.'''...4--- "- v; :--...;.".:-.-,,- —.,..N1:-',. .,-..--,,,_.:,':c.-i''.-„ Plsr-,•,-.:..*:!:_o..\ fli ,kle,. .--•:i0)7$1,i,,,:-.1:-..-:‘- -:-..."-.:14'4,g,4,':kt-R: \''47,if,..';;e4,,-.. .,;-...,',,,-.U10„,...1,14',. - -:.Liz.-7.. ,,?;",',::''4'.*- -.i2: ..,,,' ,..4,, ,f,- .- .4 -.. .'4'..-- .',;'),',4,-,,,,,,44V•fko,,,I:'.iN,.--.'-4!-'' -- - '-4''-r'-'-. ' 2k:_,''' .'',..V.,.,..,-i'-'•-•?';'il•±T.-til4a''-',--.4:'4:c4,•-• 4 t-?..%.2 ; '''-'-'',,' -'``a:if:-.,--;-v<v,-.-ig.-•---- .7"., :-.... • .:7'.,7'- '-..;;S:i;;2::. X .';'9,r. :Tr.i;?F,t;Z:f4V ,'„''.:6•• '-, ,,;,A , 2.:•.4..i‘ •.'.1t,,t.arT!;!,1;;\ ...1r-•••,-..., ," :',,6 4.1/irAtz"- '-,4a,- -10•,. , -,s,',:-,•1‘7‘.,-fl.', ils•', .,?ei,,,', '..41 ,•;:-•- :,_; ,:ek. I. ,N,..\ ":7.M''tif.;• rA).', ": 'f,'",-,'4;,:li.''. ..-f:-17.,, ,.`,.'.,,,,:!'", ',-.. ,,,'•14,,-'.. i :,,, '2,.',L,,;i:';'; -4,N g,...,..- ,., .„,-4',..-'' 7-.:..-., , ,2,-,..,,,,_4 17,,,4,• ... „If f-?-7-..: ''.-'2,,*-..-,..1.:4-..--.,,,,,,-,s1--, ..,,,,,;:.. -‘4,,As ..,., '--',rtz.,/,--.,,e_- --,, .,7-'''---,,:-T•1.;-i',,;-= -,,.... '''-'i .,..'1'.:f;ifr'1" ''i, -''''''' .1 - ' '--•."°::- -'c'E'''''-4-.--).::, :xv-1,4141-VrAit' - '-. 47%;1-j'I'''''' ;*:,T:i'ir?rr'4f;:';'-'444i/..*,',,,4 ,i'V.--::* r4--':- 4,:'-',- --.:-''' .: 4-1.• (... --...`--,.. -*..-!-1`,";;;',-.0:'ft: ' . ', 4 _ n-'..."1,--7.-:::-:...,.. -7-;;;-:--L-„7•4i."1.;,-,-,1,,,444t44,-: 401, .-,?.'i.-=-- -,.;::-°!"-. 4,.-.* -, ..4'-../.,,i'..:,...:,":, ,,,i.':... w;F„,.-.-_-.;,,----.,-. --;;;.y.-i.:r,..- '---..: -.-.,,,/-,,-",s. ,c,," 1,2'' '.. ,4, -.. ---- .,---,r-e,-. ,-- ,--.-.), .,:e-, ..,:c.--..-c'- L'.;..---'..'' - - -4- ,11.1,i......-..;.,....V'. ..--1.:.,i;,:::%-....‘.y-.-Iv- ,,, .:-.-:.,-.. -.-- -‹%,--.4e.›,.....:...,--...--- I".'',• ,',-.- "' ' • '4 :-.41 et,,,,,, 4.,,. -,,,,,.•„-:,3,4*.-..., -4•4;,..,'-•:.•••1,_,.44,...,1 .le.iit-e,..2,•• ••• •r-•,.%,,'.'t;Jimr-',....14-j.‘",, ' 'Z'j :.F-...1:•• V.. ...t•'-'•-. ...,'IC-1•''snn .,•: .• -•„' n •7-1,n -;;4':`°51-.tin'..nm.ns';',- r'....;.•'''' ,''.;:;'?":',..4k4tr,e!...,-.''t`'.'s•V ' -41.-in•riefr:,:r'n, , . ..,. in.,,,,••••r",7,:li•:,!,"nt‘i"-',•,,,An:•'-'*7*- •--,.., It...j-.. -/;'.(•:"•;..:!..3 '..44:t•-,i. --......,• •:.......r \':',„2-'A ,;: i '''. ''""'''".'"*" - :. '' '-'"'7''ki•F-----c-- '''i,'-'''''''-‘-'--;'"4"11;11i---.i-::•-';'-',rj-e - . . 1-•.;-'' '.4-...77,-,-2,'";•.?/..,',/, -.:--<- 1",6,-2e.t.--..:.-•:,.,,.4,.,,,,, . ,,p,;1,14,(,.;?:, ; LvP-4.;.•f*:•• ,-- .kro---' 11(t-' 4N-'f4 7-:t›-S'...:-...-- ;;•• . r-1.:.::'•-,...5,4;41410 .., , ,,.. ,,...„,....,.._-....,4ri,,,,,:c.,,::,40!_t!,-.....,,,...„•,,.• ,.., ,t...01..,4,,,,,•,.;., .."AiAr-',„'..41;,.,•.N.444,1f,,"",....)::.•t,.:,',P"...,•,,,,;1 4,. -::,.c.,,;:';I ,. . ,f,,,,./ig :-.,,,i,),,,ft.,-, A';'Xi-7W"‘•;,,,;« '''',',',12'''' ' 'fri::;11•",;4'''.;5:;'-%`:f.•7;'.-4. '',',::....,,I.7•".-f:-!,'I.:.-. ..-.=•?"tis.."-',-.z-\:-;i4::i .,. .4.':;.:/.?,'.• '..,1',..?,..:4-,,. : ..X- .',-/.1'. ,.f / ,.4 ,.:: , "T„,_ 4.7:74a.:,.::•.k ',..,27,,- - „ ,,-",jo:,:-....-,,=-^ ,"'"--- • t,.,, _..t. . -,..q., ,...-.. ,, ..:1 ,,, ". .....• f I.,'..'.•'. '*,',f,tt ..7:. .' • ' -''''' ''''..•2741.' -':' . , .1-.,... :Ai. , .f,,. .7 -.•,?.-r..--:,;..,../,,•-,... ,..--..:‘,?-...- . . •0"..,.: 1- U4 w,.. 1 ,.. ...,:..,.. -r..,..- .,-- - -,40',.......- .,' ;'..!tt •...--,-- . :-eT-4-'.',--.-''.4•..7,:',....,.,.1.i.:-,..:...... -1-.-„+ .:.. ,:. I. '' ...-..' ,.rr..rn'.?...n 'n-n-.—',--. ''''''''):-1:.rular.-*''-n*I'''.\;1''' .* '`'- •-•; .' 4,--n'''X' 3;n'r;-4: ••'''''...::::::::::."7 n••'`,.;-Y;.. -....,.-<.,,,.,;i;..;:....t.e.. ;g1--..-E.':-- *--rot`..- ,k,'--'t,..?..',-i• ... &'N.-e-.:..'.:3....,t4..,-.-.....,-.,..- .4.- --.•.,--:-.(1-,...,?...-•;„,.,..;7,11.,,%7:.41,, .•_':•.V...,7;:il.,e,--•.IL-,„,-,,... ,•••• ''''' ,-- ' ''' "'•"',07yi. -'(c.••:". -4, ,-. "--.-;,-...,-br .,:-.,..--7.--.,..,-.4-,--,,t-..7,',.-,,...,.i.: 4-;"'•.;I''4,•••^'.-!-.•-•:,.../",44''-P ,--- ,:7-,•,^.-'.',-'-,-.---,=4;,,,,',4-- Agt.,.._"-""-',''', 1'4:..0."'1-0; '''.--4-.`• , ,...,..- ',:.:"., . , -u_-.5...ir.,. 4-4-'-,=-'-:' ...:::7.1t,-. -,'' J."- .„..:-4. --7- A--;•,:k4.,,i-e2*'" :,..../-:-.',-;•:!..:',--',',..-;,1„-;- .,.----•-,- „ik, ._,. _ ,..., ... . ... ---....`:,,-.: • r•.2- .--- — OCT-30-2003 16:35 FROM:CAPE COD AUTO MALL 5084327370 TO:15088624724 P:1/1 ;200/-- p 3-Cr. T EXHIBIT_____ /6 - 6`- 63 e.E....r" f /._.),97-n 3. ..-.< ge./..—?0,4 , „,./. (eiZZ )Q ... 1` /U.( e C 7 " / (.....4-- ¢ ic•r 0. 6,'n 7 J'i,ei-Pr n C.G € GSA- C'Cit/r- %i; R.) C) /VA.' /14 t C0 _cif/1;z.-7, �..,4 07,,,,, / e.'.��,./- 744.��J „hi_,..,_24'1- JZ - `z.v‹ /,.•f &44, 4.44 iz, A clef . .. sc i- e/ ; /I S S eA--z2-- =2i 2 _y r-. ` /f G J' / t. /l1 ce/c". X, 4 14,, IL Z.-- eL-t! , .61/ 41—Li ... i A - 1,4 r'• .'''ZI dll-rhs-g---74-x.s.X.47"--" ( S r aLG/� ,L- v'- -- G z.4,....,e /A-4_,(..._ , 7i) ,( A...c-/ ./x—e... / 5 6 k - s?‘. 2. - (i . -- /i N E. v E V \) y ti IpWN a B R^ . '4•,7 1 .., ,,,,,,--..! ,_ .--.,,,,,:-..t,-, -, • .1,, .-.T.,,. .... t-Itek- EXHIBIT K-1 to counterclaim of Miller et al, TRI et al v. MILLER et al. Barn. Sup. C. A. No. 2004-0084 -„, ,..,,-. ; , -.--4se;,---!:',-).7).-,--:"..4•,,,z,, .=!,^,i7:-...-r' ----.. -,-.-:-..„ .,3 .,-,- -.T.,,,...,,,„:„.„.,.-- . - t-,,--te-,-...•,% ,1 • '4: . .- • , , ..• t ,1„,....,..,':-..- -- , --., \ i. * :;,---i **1•?•'`6-'' - -,.? '--- .-‘0:!," -"•'-' - --AV-''fi t . ' M.' 4,1;.'!",-1.k9t,,e,• =..,,,- •kr,- 7-,=. .t.,../ i'-.,, -if4le. •I, - - •-• ,-- , . • . •., ..... • . .-......: ,,,7,.•,1. ..., .... '". -"ie.",• i ` 1„,,,r1- ',el") jet. ....1.1 t.t•i'voriV--,.. •4 '''Tii r., ' N'...• " - '- - ',-4. • ; 05,. 14,...44.c•;;:„".J. e•,- 4;.' . • • ' ',, . 1` ' . it?..rt,.r •v,v. , ile xl-;PA n,;2# - - - - ''•11.":-.--A- . .•,',,Wriii, ,4"- • , -*'. 1 , ,%-' . .. `k ,' Wr • 4, -...SC,:-.1% , - rn, "• -, !• •- t I',--.3r.,%t'Ait • .6.1 ; -4 .4 ' • . • 4..1 ' '• , '4 -' ''*."if•411 n-* .„- = • i . ---- 4; ,,,.44••0004 " ...4 .4., ..p". '' .?..0•0`,“41KV., ",- bt. ' •grt • '..'‘‘ • . *.', .- =, ; ,r ,.• - - IN .--0.7 - Pt • -.• ,..„.•:-• ft 1:- -...: ..4',7--• . ' '- - 4 '- .gige4,,rnt:: .,., ..,,;•., -„-,. -- .- .. ,,, - ' --4.....1,;,.... .--- 4 • k-'..-: .,.' 1 '...i.''". ' 9'04 ir'.7":.•'." '. ,•• i isc- <6-.+11 is, r. . 41.....• 1-.... /\.,,..t' et-. . . • •••• * r ', , '..-.•.. -•r•t". .4 ? 4tr,.. t 0 4 -,.-.4 4 i I = ,-;,„ -'Lf, ‘?•"'g,.,r A-•''.-':..--),!,-!•....,4'.,-.:-:,,„ -:.-/.-t.h-.-,!...' .:-":4-,, ' •', •katt' .., •,;1%;',.:•;4=-'1.,,,,,i•~r.,,i erri- Z,5,t i -r•-•.4" - ' , ' 4•- -:1:- , ....'N ' --0.,.: ,- , 1., 'k ', , -,. -"` ,;;• • ,,L,,,,,,, --i,, ,. '-'',•• • •,!, - r,, - '.. _- • -PX"•:-- ft•--4.-' - : . ,rr '","'- -;',i';'•4-i-''7.41.'„,..-'4;', ,V• 41;401;'-- :i 1 , 1;.' ,,,; : • , , , , `il ''-1, - -, 'T,',.•-, ---; ,*),..- ' ,- •-.`, -trio- • ••• ,,,,,, '. ...1111 '.,/,,,• 0• - fr ,..,V,' '21 .• ' r.,k ';,.1 i's,t,i‘41.•,,/..'",,e' , ,,-,,, ''.. ,,,,..'. _.', ,r4,t40.1:11•a.i.. ‘..,,-',.-'j r.','.."' .. .., , ,/, n!.. i*, ,,,, :tr.,..;r0,,,,..,:. •...,•,,1.r24.,l'. _,/;7.:',!'*' ,5; ..„, .._ ;- .•., ,..t.,-. _ ,..,. . ,,.. , .,.-.--3e-,:1,4,741,...ipccil ......,, ifiv .4:- -, ....pr,,,,... ,v, , *, ..,..,, ,,do., i,,,,r,,,,,,„y, ,,, .. . . „_., ..,, _ - , ; ,•r•-sr:^•' ty 1„,5,4z. ,i„.4.-. , ; - ,„ „,..,,117 _, i1,•.. ,, ,, , - ....,4 4 ,:,.... . . , ..e...,....,.,..w -,,, -., . .. rforzt'..,,7.0.",..":"P-For'n.T,',4'.(,...f•'' l,' 1 '7,!.4'' "V,:,-.. '' :t.,15. if,',?' .. "!'''''' T.'"•''' 1;., '' . - '..,--'''''''.7..:7 ? ' %,-' : - 4.<;. ., .. ' f'••••:, ,,IPJ,1 7P 1 ;;,,,,*Vi. ''',A• 0101:: irN4, Z.' ‘•,'Y'':',1 ,e' It •gl,' ',...":''''V.,.s,Ir.:,•:, ,,,il,..,;4.;:., „., ' ....,.;,!•,., ,,'" ..,„, "V%'' ,-., •,k,.;,,r; ,i f t K.,_.4 ira.4't ,_7,4 . 1 kt ' :,2,'‘-• -, ('--'!".;= „.... - t-,,• :-...=,-, - ,.., • A,...\_. -- ,,tr,‘,,:‘,'F'..,:i;*„. ' `" ''''''re..4 • ..... -...A ' -f.'s!' ,f,Spe. .-)-4,-re '•••;',ie,,,:,, , !,,:,,,,.t.•:.. "4- •. ," .,, - -,-_,..itT.'4•" 1 '.`, ,„:„_•,,,--, 0, ,t: ..L'eh,,,e, '•„),ic .T"r - :,:'0. .3,. , el '. •'' 44' ' ,IIA ''' el'.. . '' ''''7.' .- ' ' -'4.-'''..t,44.'if. r.'s.4%, / \ ,, .•-,,,,,•ti ,,-,-;._ r",..- ...,-14IF i- '!",:,1,-",, ,, •4,...*,- pi.,-- :.1.„. 4•0,4,„"7....,,441:*,. „. .,,..•..,....-!„',Z,e.:";;?,.'1,--1.:',....t.'.9........:. ‘,.:, '1(?*"'c''F'- ''''."4: (- :ie.' --',..- . • 1";-- • '414:1'414:4;' ..;ierejc..-.;5,.4 ori-... 1,,,5.1"....1:iij,,',..'•-,../•.`el.',,,•.-4,„?."-*,:.1. •.:,:',,;!' ' X, t/ 71,,,,-*2--7.'-i' •,-\NI Oto. ./. V, '..."..tit*'-''‘.,-,;••,1,i,'.4 - ,k'''.,.,'„• 4..., .,,,,,•%_, `'''' ' 44. ,,, ic., ,-.: -...,.....;.:„.. ,a,,,,,,e.:,.....,.. ..,,3, -,, ..; .,... , ,-, , , .. : ' -....-_,,,_........,_. ylic,--- ..„—, -N . ge6o, f490'5,' ' :,"_.• 4.,',“ 4 --,y4. ',.....r,, ,..2* ,,.., , , .. r. - .A ', t'V.)-.1., 9,,4'.., .r C:er, . , ..er'•/,'„i4 ' #11'' A 4- "y.'ac,t‘i' ',""if,,,•;-°` , •i,„•' ., ' i 4 „ ,:i'/-• L--.•"._, ',...,.,e, •1' • \. lr:14• 6. ..c.,,,;,.... ','.., ‘...- "r•A. , '• :,,,..:44 i ';a...,•'•4'^ :,-.' ro'r."\,t.T'I.,• .•'A 40. ' ee'"'''.."' )-' We., - 'e ..' ''e ..''''..e. . \ ; -11...T ..‘,Ei- -lit ''' 7`-'1f4i'•''''). ''.. '67 ',44."4,,,''"Li*?.:,47.1‘4.'V'kn''''Z''4,`'..•.'i%sin_l,,, 7Z C.''':'Ar,;-. fsk,d.'' ,,,'-' ‘,..: ,T.:r*'' -\' ..•i A .. : ,_1?if, -l'i.e.,.4...ir'vel, ;• + 4- ,„41,-• ,,:1, • i- > , 'i!..--t.'4%47 ',, ' '. ,:-.111- \'''r i',-,:. 1117•,' 1/-- •\c"' ' .'c" Z -'' 4,10,r- _ i• , - .oft.Y.-.411...i"'` •'",,,,•'' ..- ;',.!3,44 44 r:-,-,.* . ". t';'''-) - -,*-AS, -"•-•; .' -mil 0%4 ,..:, '. . , ,.. .-,i. 1, .410.- - ,,, j-4-. . •,.f.f . w. ----.4.1.. kiA0N. , .....t.,-,,,, , y1/4 •,4 ,4t...- ,,, ,- . ,—,-.'"; Ar . -i ' - i - 4-1p.4. -or: -' -„.„:„..• ..-t. •..i",' Ai,,,', •,.,r __.,.,:.'irt.:',14 ,',,--4,4re.,ter.;,,, t...,; -,y2,•_410%,- ,. ,„„...1... ,, _,,,,,, v-,r„......-€TIL-* p ',,,.- '.--..; ' "_,„,`''''`..,k___,,-i'''.f_,••A:. .„, - - 05.c.., ''_„-;.'„1,-.Tiotte ,,,,„,, ,,,If. yor;(314",'.;#44k0-4'..t:'-clri'cl.:! ,',.:A ''. ' 7 , 1.---•'`e.-7 ,'I,s4/Vti.;240ek: \r„of\r„... •-•,..-:,;?7„,,,,-.77.- ,:';,.-:-7-4;"•.r,;.--;*-‘-;'- _ Air:, '417 ,. N.„ . '''!1, '" 4 '- ''''` `-fri-r=7"s4 "''' f-, .•`,r,. . '4 p,ffil, of: ,..0,„,„......., 'zit, .;;;._-?,-;-4,....--...27,,,-i;.,., ,‘,„-„:447. .., ,,'',7,-..'..,'" •--..,-,. _ • .• •e„,t- • -,, 4„/„:,?e"..„ 2,',f,r,r.p.,-4..-• -.. %ott r.,8-_-:-Vi.--...TL•.- •.-t :T-4.-' * ,- 1•-•Vtz ••,''..:‘,=-li ',-;-.,,••-,,, '0- _•4,!,".:).„...;,, ; •'ic•-• ,1,. '-- .- .4 " o . ,,,,i,-,i(-,-4.- ,. ..,;,,-. : r,- -- ,.--& - -,-,,,.•,‘-.•-•:-:,.4. ;.,,..•:y.1 0 . -1,. • , , 4 „a• f-.,• •-4'.114 ',,,--;::-.4.'- Jitiore.. ";,-.:,:e,,,f 4 , 4;41,-;-• , -,,-:-.-:,, ..17r--.4e'' "7, ...4't.-ell% y vF47.1, ,VZ4e'-,'.•-; .. '... :4 1 .1:'''+ .14:1, ,-.4;.' .r-:): ' '. - ;,,,j!4,...,T,..;,': - "'"•,,-It,42r,g'S -1.4. ; 11.' ' e,.. ,• -3...11''' :.7 s'Ar. TieSk -5••.(,.;• t,/, '.1 , latt).7 itvie. I'"h.__4* •. 7,4"V vii.:“' 4:,‘;1 - i:',"4-v t124-'?"--'7,,-,.-" •Ke'$41:-,' rrsi, ;*--i',..;!,t,ati 4"A‘,;A „:,,', .;,;',‘' %- ,. ,:;* '--A -,-.. "-----i..'r or *.., .\ ._,--,.._,-„di .„„„p , ,,, , . r ..„, - . -, z ,N, 4:,.- , 4,,i,.-• . , k' ' 41,. „tfr.--4. .,':',4:,)7(1 ist,e0,i"11.. .:;1'%:%-'52,/ .' .1k..i. ...7' * 4' ..2 * ' -:‘• I ;'filtT' .1.:2.1.,:i.!1 Cr.'n -• ki:;;;174.^ ...k2 ""4.,...1-^i fligr'.-*IC .4*'f'i. .V,'-- ...I',li,''S,•;,q••4•'•,,:',./' '',`4+.;‘.1....',,,,.‘ :-. . . ,,,''10'1).. 7„...•.--*'‘,.•••••1..:Y'..41tr,...'",;. :.; 3 ..300A, ,r ,,,,i,,,. -., vA-,7„7,...:?-4--• A,...•,f .,1,.';',1,,,I.4'.,‘ ,1-*-.,,6, ,,-,;,,,y17,,,t,a, ,,,t,I:1,,,-. .;..' ,Ng" J.v.. - .,-,-,,,i5iiktk, .- ••'-''- -- .--.7-•44, '...i #. ,;,,,,....,. :„.4.,,,,,re---or,.., . •, -,,s,,.,:it.:,:-,',2,' 0-•r `1,,,!,,tt, ey.,` . „,••,,„„.,„,,,,,:,,,,,,.1 '4, *., , , ,,, i ,,,r ... .....,.. , .. „ .,... ,,,,,.._...... .,, , 1 -,44 f,.. ,,: ,'- ',,,. .,1,-.7.„.:,4,„ --Y's,.."-: -2,:-. .,,,,---..,,,,, f:-.0:#0:.•0,,iff^ , ,..r.4,...,)i,:v(;7...,eri, .,:t.,, ?,,,,a -.-i.-,..,,--. , l'' '''t4-;'e_, J_4 ‘..:efl 11,C,,leiro A-4,;-.14"--1 c /,-,-•-.!-)1;'''';',:,,N C• 71'''. • , f- 't,...-7', "r4.A'Ai,V,01'1, '^4.;',.'1,‘:‘L'ik'./--t'it%'i:''.---'1'. '.;•,"::, 4.,A•t: - -,,'li9r,j,!•14„7*,', ,`,-, • ',.1, - '.)-,: A,..- "--or , , ,,4-,- . ,,„, 4,,,• ,,.., , ,. 0,p,' .1.1.-; ,,,,,..', ..--,. - ',.;, , -.., _ 1. ,., .0. 4 lir--.av- ' ,, iiit,. 7.:, ',=. ; .J t.,1:rr 9'r','d/ i --•-'./..)--if-1 i,o 4.Y), -.11, ,...,.1p.e.-- •--...: - it,.,-; - AA- - '"'- 1,--,1.-r-z.-41,ffe,-14,0.., ,1%,,,i..,',,,, -,,,:,..-,,c,.. , ,,,,,-,,,,,;...4„-.! ,,%yn.„4 tt,f: il 1;,,,„''',14_,,,,4i-s•4'-','c';.,..1.,.°,,- '',.. ,,1/4,..plaftli,,,,i•1-,;,.,..'"!'ir".1",„:4'''','''' ''•.• f tr,'".:t 1''-'-,..1c-4.i..4,;'''',`,---1'-''.,'r; `‘:.--•, 1;tri,-. • t."7:.--,r.'"„;;',.',.- ./ ,"','-", ; ,i`--.,;',, ;-en- '-,-.ti';',:-'74-/::.%.t4_-, ,-.2';TY `4:.,•,',16,-,..,-/K:!%-, V.-A*.i.;2.,,,.:;.'--':'-‘,. ,'-'.. 'AU,!,7‘.1,..;'-'`-;..itt-v-.4-...1x,:$.1.1 V , 1 ,1.4 , '..: ,,,13'' ..C,,Jr. % 4.e„-4. , ,' e _ flt• . 7....S ' ''' A ''1 '4::. ,1,,i ' ; /-••' , ''1 `" 'elc,,,,.• .f1.4zp,'1 ' ..-.'":‘,Iiiir,. . Ai -'1' '..-- • :•'4y...'4.7 '4444.7`;:,•,7:1( .' , ii ,.,,i- . ,$),X,„:)' '.2•1',, ' -: .."1‘en''.".,- e• -- -'. , •'' f' ' s' •i'.. As c 0-.,•`-k-4-.." 1-> '.--1 EXHIBIT K-2 to counterclaim of Miller et al, TRI et al v. MILLER et al Barn. Sup. C. A. No. 2004-0084 tea,•r •iA,-^v,`.RY! 'i i .OM o =f.1'�I.+y,•""y3 f"•it�,.�d3y4 •fir - 'A';,-.'t Y' -; . 171 t ttsrt =1,- , , 'Et r•r , s'11 PO Fir• •r fy•. f ',f.. �fti: �y,+� t( � ° iriy' „.1- f.r�i i'1 �' S ' �a- ?t y `_ar �? ti",, 'f,'+ /� r d ,irk rs, W ,il 614i-rs', �' ri IA e i �.i ..r{ r.�.'` 'r - ,114 i�ry �� ,.4 „ Y !" ! ,� axe 1 1. �h �IY A l7 l? �'Ry-u s � , ,��•Z �7 �'`it. 4 t� y,�t, . \ y ..+ r„ q, y li;� I "� i�{YT_ 3Si!:$-7 ,Waa ' 'L b kl rt E�r �JM1 : i vl i -, .try"Y _ ..1 ,'' is �� i.,,"d •' ,- r e f s} l rr P u t zi4 ,P� y A• r' h .e iIt 7�r��� y`D� �Z( y '�i '�r'sf "�` }r1 ti✓l � _1� � rY �1 F 6 (�IIP nj " I. � �'w • • fh f, 7 s rJ t h '.1 7, t`;?''4 1 4' r-,"f-6t' {r• y ' G s , 1 { l,, +-, ''hr i ./ Z r- ,(4i` r 11 �,1r0t '� 1' 'J' 1Pr r�41+4 ,r^ J '''''V e. ri '-'.1) ..! i. •�,- y .,1 4e JI w<d Y ( 3�,,C t+F; 1 ,!,,' 4 i • f'Y i.,,ri „t,,, pyr f ih A. .'..r ".r.r11u ', CIA I �Pi` 1.' tvd.. 11' :- t t ... �•�, .1„'ryS-` f. _: F! 4 ,i'`tc � r\ { pt a<; a u .� 3? k ' T r}F7?' ^ 1� ,p '" y .• ► 1 ' �'" . s �./ 0' xL �r f.l}r a _ 1 + / ti o' it 4 t rr 1 .. k.--, 1 y/47. .s:' 4 r f • ., � ,�„ Jy .A'X1 , - 41t..,.z .::- ' ,, �t f.11 1 1 14- s f,--A-,,°Ti. 1�I1¢• v- f F- ib, f.t (� !u S'.. ii :4/' ''' t - , _� <H,y, {N `_ t• r. r yr'y� 13 �_ , �`'�'Gj •Cr ,7 4 r i,... Jet`.1!F r .. �1'1 Ap- 1' F 4:,,:t y+., tAAV.(' ,, k41' „f 7:rJ�Y ' • •r ✓ } c PI eti C ..erd9 ��S "R�'•,. b 3' d: g'ifi +1 q - `�' .� yr c a x Iu$s . r s y, f,t , 5v} w -.rr C r tr *y .1 .1 r.P � ..t,-- �r.+�,.y0."L'�1 'icy „ 1 '4{j 7f �1/�d . V.J'�'t ... "\ s. _ 1 r -.4 r6;r•'r ..+•:A• �My v }k' Lei R`', le• j f 1 ' . 0441,17' ' `y�'�. k /' �K f V �+'T Y '��•-•. -y ` J�,Fly _ ? ,+ fff �r, ti 1 rryl •� �, )� � 5 i,.'} •_ -4.*44 . C+.._Y� 7� t' 0.df d .vY {j!t* r rt -�yRi I err j1 , .. _."„�._ y� • rpM, y y i qr x�, �'s}' 3 r t r r ". ,1 {3 ' , 5.,; 1-' f e, ✓ ..,yam, r: rye.t N fi b`'7e„ "' 'PI ,'rS5 t' tlt t {{ d1?^I i _ ,��yy : .�,— ne,.. 'esF•+ .�. yl :( ,.� STIR r','l+ ,{r it � �a . r r�3. {� '". Y �.. ` as 74" Cis � "Jr. 't y ,t < / e _y�!1 { - mac. .) 7 , l•' .ham, ,,,' . r71., .7 -. ,, v.v. tl 1�rr� '4 lam' 1, 1 s f-' ,'+ y ""' r r` ,..A9, u► A .}.. . t .i '> 'k.(1'-'*y ',r y N lit tf, ,•n� a 1 :17- 1 1 v1'rr,,,, -.. s.` ' Vr ,��^ r ,, � 'd.t b,'°' �', c`'y'' i t • L 1 r1 u r'' �'^S fir - s y�.. ,;4. �. if tt- ^ ' rr / +/ y 'k % t •, • �r-..,, `ri •r 7 �4 1.a ,' ; ,�� „s ay ysr,'Y$� "k.. ✓ - r i ✓c .y'}..J yN 4 .! • - c , Y y r a..; 6 ..*:', i�,tf•,it,... Y _r, . �C 1.,,��y,. d �` �. ��ry. y, , „4g. :„. r) err 4 ;,\ Ve4ti, , -, /P4 j,,.y(�r ` . 11 • t fi+ r t ..,t r ,l i i 1 f t} rV s r¢ { -;� f y �" y�a,� rT . y •+ y ..,/hei 7.a41., '. n . r. 1 .t F a \r 9 Ill' 0,' y` '. itr �4\`, ...-• 9 ±�1{r ..r r .,,r. ., 9) 7 ,� .*^ - / y,• 1, t .,V 1.�Y ,-.7 J• • !2 .`,Y"�q. h� /\ r y aA r ' r t L:.:• S • i '. 1(r �!('r}• l • S rt' ..,r'+ + �. ... r a �e `:s ti Atr•'F f�\ r r'^',`,0.�hn '�+/ s.}t� d X y 7 r/AN die l ,r ,.t/y^ `k•y;r'�' • .�i e ; x "l ;h" � d` 4 . � a � , 'I.,t.. i t-;-.)-A . 1 •t— -'4, / .. - �'^. It FF' /� /!`$. Yx r"J IA r j� ✓� .i ..;-„ I (:.v r } `le�� . 4 4 R ` \ if *. , q i J w V+7R� �y J�I..y; - fi p,' 4�� 1.4�'° i e 1 t•1-' ,`riY t ' .� HAy r ps d� tb ,, , �K't :}d�, r:` . 1f •.. `' �t. ',: cr '* / tt 1 t ,.•r... .+2. �� �t i_ f K t / ' 1 J \' it ,, f j. r • �' M //a r ?_�r � ;- 1. �lr 4"'(,Fr.' .,,1; ) -b ?q .',� )`1� 1,i/ir,/y� 5 L '. { .c.-�b, ,' 1 -,.. ! �'�• - IW.1,'- ?ia:i t 4r. Y •.P i&,'�_, .. 1. ,.�1 , _ -Ii' ' ',. .."'a' f•' • 1 EXHIBIT K-3 to counterclaim of Miller et al, TRI et af.l v. MILDER et al. Barn Sup. C. A. No. 2004-0084 ' _ Ai + - '1f f. ):+ 1r. cj . • .. '� //� r ve , 'Y�" �!`�"a t� '� '` �F + >a..e�. � T.t: ..,.- � 'ors-a=- . • { li; `_' ` a r -. �y � ',7,,sY'F t l t� y , J s\ ;.. r... 9...:'�. � `�` }f� r �b' rti qt• t f ¢I v - '� -9'�l�w }r� ^+..`xY it i rah 1• �• �. ` s, r ft w l f u— �' �� ¢`f t �} ''d ` ^ ,� E;:.' ,� � stl ' ---: . , 7 ? • i,,errir I. i s y t Y, - � i' `4 'A,,.'- '111:p"f' ., q t-Y ;'- of�:. ' ...i . • �P P .r.�. � .3 S .:�'It°v e - /� x .�y� jk�3' .f'ti T'r - ,� it y �.�"E •y,•:_�•"`y ` . , ' �QQr�} s Y i L rya)' JJx ;-" t e•,�'1` yF "4 b t ' • l a 1 -"*s f h �• �. ✓� , ' � •,:� r�� � , .aTy�. '� � a t / � � ���z� y.��� 1 F � {�.w r Sys. { CFI . nf'' ` 6. r L t r d' 41� ..; '1�1. • 1 `+� +'!' �7'}-! y�.a ..,r,�sas� ?" /�F .r-�" ��'�> �� �+ b-t &p1. � i�'s � 't� � �1 �t�� ,1 .• ��;�1 ��,,., �i7J y,*.� w[K y.t'� �' a i 1 ;�y i� ;r 1 / .- , , fir,� 'a w 7. rry ii- '� r.. i.. ,/ t i „\"' 6 ,� T .1;� ✓ 1 a d".., 4,;*' .., 1 d® '-' o: 1,0 , ci : ::*; i e k-,�� ., P `' a� ;'�' �2� {�fPK;.t`�' ' �tr i.1 ty. ,e'11'_,,may .p�'t N '� �.F s F s �!! a, t':: l:�r' .4 .1 \ d r 1_ SS.,� 1 1 I:Y'� ' "�� ,tea ''N , Q . �/ ,, ^. - r•. q\ ''i iis:- :� _.. r � -� a,, � ..'J N ry a ', T r 'S ! ." /� .�^ f!y_ r, '"�ddd .7 y +r:K :1 } ,1 ' Y"�7.`�.r �t►ti{.- e , / -•, -, i ,r,Y "� ,:1' )Y3,_ �,'' ;; L. N `rgyp `,7 L', f YJ ! j`` y s `". ;• '" . X. fr ." ,��7 . .'i�''� � 7-�1�.��Y '� fr�� ,-"j ��i -.:: - : ,--- ..:_'..., ,',,,,Ii?',7---:-...-..,: 3--,..,:,7,:-...„..J ..,.4,_,-;,-4::,,„. ..',..,.,::..).-.:'7.„.. '...,:„:1 �p�yf.�"«t..tv, A....,,'-.. `�F � "JJ.. � �s ' �� �'��� ,2....',.'..7,4_1,13.4;..14 ;:_.,-7,14,:r;, ....-4-4:,R..'.f...'.F.::.,:,t,o'..,:,,...P,,,,...-. - , : <.',..:04. ;47-''.,..;,-.;..' ..,...-„,, tilt ; : A ! 2T L*,:� - �gyp.' r xl ,. . -p i t • r ,., t xl i sat r yp4��t inb+h -' :, 7 V"' y�► - +ems( ,.'�ff�- �.r ;./ i 3 �,r... 'c; -r�' Y t 7 � i e'_' '.' t �L, t ., y s-r t q 'rv,7 s r . r y ..\. {�� /�� �.t�t . f t +'`ts� "'Ni�`,, t y '.;;, a (�'/,y-.t tta ... 'Y i �a I'a� m 1h• t'f#b do ' i f Y 'u. 1 '' �- • S s i ( vial f� �`.� c,,';-,*�.1,rri 4� • !" !f''. *•�7�CRd �>L '. ,` II <s ' t g Y fi • �y l d7. 1.:',ill, ,-7.:,--,.:: 6,,_. - • awl 8 � � ` ./ . + r�r��I _. f /���t�3w�,y, f(BB6//�� �.�crw � F��yr^!*' .. -� .r .� .. .;_�'���� ....,scL1i-.� f� V4 I V EXHIB1T � � 3 '- Ue.-E D r. ftn Td: PAGE 1 OF 2 /� oP RECEIVED-D 1 el"'ip. .Y: ..trs FIsku •ry DATE: NO 2.n )God Z 0 14 ,\ 4, ,aif °� Town of Barnstable T 4E: :6'5 1°A , -I.) • aeRr scAste, • 90 ,erg Regulatory Services A'Fo a+A+. Thomas F. Geiler, Director Public Health Division Thomas McKean,Director 200 Main Street, Hyannis, MA 02601 Office: 508-862-4644 Fax: 508-790-6304 November 20,2003 Mrs. Brenda Tri Diamond Edge Farm 2051 Main Street West Bamstable, MA 02668 NOTICE OF CONTINUANCE OF CEASE AND DESIST HEARING NOTICE OF HEARING ON SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION OF STABLE LICENSE You are directed to appear before the Board of Health at their meeting on Tuesday December 16, 2003, at 7:00 p.m. to show cause why the cease and desist order originally entered on July 29,2003 should be modified or lifted and immediately thereafter to show cause why your stable license should not be suspended or revoked due to recurring violations of the Board of Health Stable Regulations,Part X. The hearings will be held in the Town Hall, second floor Hearing Room, 367 Main Street Hyannis. During tie. hearings,you will be given an opportunity to provide testimony,to present documentary evidence,photographs, and to present witnesses on your behalf. On September 18, 2003, the Board of Health members voted unanimously, at the request and with the concurrence of Dr.Victor Cillis acting on your behalf,to continue the hearing you originally requested on the cease and desist order entered on July 29, 2003 against the activities described therein, until Thursday October 30,2003 at 5:00 p.m.. Then, on October 30,2003, the Board of Health members voted unanimously, at the request of Brenda Tri,to continue the hearing again. You are reminded that the following cease and desist orders remain in effect pending the hearing: • You are ordered to immediately cease and desist the disposal of any manure onto the top of the ground. The non-composted manure dumped onto the bank located at the south-west corner of the property shall be removed and disposed of properly. • You are also ordered to immediately cease and desist the composting of any manure at your property in the future. e You are ordered to remove all manure from your property on a regular basis (e.g. weekly) and to dispose of the manure properly. Triletter5 PAGE 2 OF 2 RECEIVED..B1.- •, bATE:. .7 During the public meeting on the 18th,Dr. Cillis agreed on your behalf to submit copies of receipts from the manure disposal site to the Board.of:Health?'To date,i q receipts were received at this Office. Copies of the receipts from the m_agi to disposal facility shall be submitted to the Public Health Division •Office.;200 Main Street,Hyannis on a weekly basis. ` �� --•:-•---•- -"' Failure to comply with these orders may result in the issuance of a$100 non-criminal ticket citation. Each day's failure to comply with an order shall constitute a separate violation. Immediately after the hearing considering whether to modify or lift the cease and desist order, the Board will convene the hearing whether to suspend or revoke your stable permit. The Building Commissioner has informed Health Department Staff that the fence around the stable has not been properly permitted, and Health Department staff also received a complaint of a new manure accumulation in the southwest corner of your property, which they investigated on October 2nd and again on October 27th, and which, if not properly disposed of, constitutes a violation of the cease and desist order and a further violation of Part X, Stable Regulations, of the Town of Barnstable Health Regulations. As the holder of a stable license issued by the Board you are required to comply with all of the Board's regulations, particularly those contained in Part X. If the Board finds after the hearing that you failed to fully comply with any applicable regulation(s),particularly with regard to the existing cease and desist,the Board could, among other consequences,vote to suspend or revoke the stable license issued to you by the Board, and in the latter case direct that you cease operating a stable. Any request to continue the hearings must be by a signed,written request stating the reason(s) for the request delivered and received at the Board of Health offices at 200 Main Street,Hyannis at least fifty-two (52) hours prior to the start of the hearings except in the most extreme of emergencies. The Board has discretion to grant or deny a request for a continuance, and if denied or if no request is timely and properly made to conduct the hearings as scheduled thereafter take any actions within its discretion with respect to the subject matters of the hearings if you fail to. <-77F-2/44)‘. Thomas A. McKean, RS, CHO Cc: Dr.Victor Cillis Frank Diluna,Esq. • Trilctter5 • FARM No. JAY NOONE DAT , q 0 �R NO't:, za s'z �b .E rg i . NAME �q(c%t , t it y �'"t %�).�_•,'hys1 ,� r.t zx Coo st.+a hM M ✓r rya 'fr 4 a t' r+ ti S yi>nu �f y„ya'. ' ri . ..�.`r !t r .. :K?,..,,. , d„<J:.Fc. .Mi '., rg—r.;5 tC,7k. '�x.;w'": ADDRESS :4 a c ) yc fc a s V r sr i s ! l ),N.,rry�>.r'y i't i 4.;^YS -.yz. t > : a*1-Y i T i J*;: S.'S,� 't.:.• a, SOLD BY rf i j,r 0 CASH y 0 C O D _=,Q PAID OLir, r .7 Y, ;.1,n f t 3 i )r, F CHARGE f'A n MERCHANDISE RETURNED4,' ' �zyi t r. ,6+'- nn 1 r i 1 t.144. ..1 ,. ). .t . . .F v.. A,.:t. ,4.1., Y,.. .� 1, .d ( f4 QUANTITY DESCRIPTION, , .:PRICE:: AMOUNT • • IJ ... a, I / °C I :b. l. 1 X !y z s ,: .. .J: ,., .;«T>r.< > tzt r ,.? 7 (,': . .�` .�..>,.fgr�rr , •. ,ff:t C t' q i : ., ... .Hl >>ti /..; / t T 1: r' J :f a t ti 'L't.} f. i !. 1... `.i.: ). .,.j.7: :.:h.. .l.7 .Ft a..._;:)r .} f... .,y .t F,z.ar,C 1 ) t,'. ). i i r ) c: r r t . L� .. ._ J i 'T' t _.,a irI zk f S,l:: , z -:fg,: a. : S! ti z * !,i- i 1} a 1,' rein s.y.Y a' �,.7✓z r hc>.~t`ts �..4�.f!.c r r 2'i FS< tr ''t.,ly R- -7 AA } 4✓ttt > 'za'.�x,7 a'A' Z i q). 1 a .f° X et t" ¢f A. t a X x r ) it ..c . sm cf.w ? ,,+„ e ,,.,s -- 4.,. '? r,.'.c11!.;i�'.c._.z 5x z<A t1}t t.`r a adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE JAY NOON. FARM N�' DATE /, 1 +T I � 2228286 5-sawa.i:Th`c�,��'-1'•n�t�,7�"'',�.�C`^>,sa C� "'fi �l�""ikx r•A,s x lfy4 rY�s ttir i,�<�r�' lw3 twt i'�w�',fi_ • ADDRESS }l{ r� Ali t Y wy i r t l to y T¢ Zn�C M {[: • -t Atj t �'ti 4 t s rYi tW✓y , r� t4. y �r��� , SOLD BY t r t Q,CASH ` Q C O D t " Q'PAIb•OUT �' 'r xa J s a y'a QCHARGErn OMERCHANDISEtRETURNED pt�s r i ..7• : :: QUANTITY ..DESCRIPTION PRICE AMOUNT ;I/ ty �, r,_, �KY4n F3•n a r �a 1 S 4. t 1 Y hit t()vt D -trt '13�,�ai. t a adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE (� FARM N o. DA JAY NOONE ,„, Y '1o5 i}Y� 7'l ORDE vti t �. tk}R;NOat:',= .'1. .' ' ,, 'y+ Thar v'Y a ,y!'M p'' ,k,,, NAME //g . <<<< 5 ..K ♦i.•,' :t; 1 A� } z t,"t �' v{ f /�t,/ a� �1 s.y_ r ..�.k.[?f 1[, %_'z °'' � 1 �� . ADDRESS •,-,�ti z,i, ` 4 [s f S-,,,ff 7Fs•.41. a • SOLD BY t CASH ,❑COD 4 Q PAID OUT ,y �' i,y ,, < ' • t i CHARGE �MERCHANDISE RETURNED! .s�K.�yllt V. ° ri k, •QUANTITY DESCRIPTION PRICE • AMOUNT ;. 9 < f a a r L t s n I is .5'r i i k.t ,x f 1 i , t f t� , J." ' i.i i.,.ti�<, :'.j !•'' n. o c,: ! F< 5>yz a ,'x"' is adorns NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE JAY NOONE FARM • No . h(� W p 1`y Y�i.. . : Y s 1 xC E 6 .� R� 2228286 s oRD R tJo�f���t�" n�„rp�..� ,:S�r4 it ,1 } rtj toNAME , * { +' f,� �' ▪ t ,,., y. (:4 rot' .r.q "rr \.......i2) ADDRESS Krr { k f t 2 .. YSOLD B • CASH ❑COD: PAID OUT iy ,"s T '';i� t r y n t`x ❑CHARC'E' 0UERCH'INDISERETURNEDri. , ?�,s„il ,, �:...x. . ,: .h • , mil AMOUNT � ANTITY" ; DESCRIP710N PRICE., IIIMIIIII t A 4. ` c ti . . � , { itr ; 1 1 A } - 1. } ._ • :,,k ^S11"t<! r/� LTG t,T ▪ r } } t . R \. °L ,. 3 ktf y lJ G f f Xf< \ �a ?xk4 l t'' A��*rt� 1. r a �>?1ob▪ t� -ti yr} a ,1 S (�'s":i I'�ri1 t`y7tL�, }'a }„w1 ...“): yr` 1.gdams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE aE FARM No . JAY N00 � : DATE . XJ ,;;i6 : ` ftL 1 Mq t /9. k.. �e x a r f,?,, s`y T 1 V 2228286 ?. '+. ',."`:. ..h P �a },Cv i i .,,,:i .�2`t ,v4• eQRDER,NOj✓ :;y,ems' `1 i .' .. J r?,. S f, ..i 1. i} bh T NAME t r > F rf„t,K� , tk t /%{ 'r Y r i 5 ray r �l! i� JCI' '1( /x}', •1.V.F4 4',A 1A . j it�i,.f x \ ,t 1 / " a 4 Y T} ADDRESS x 1 l '' +t� . t s•7 say a' xs�4•r '' 4it 43v n?a S Y # s vta 3,i, 1 SOLD BY CASH ❑C O D r* ❑PAID OUT ri ?, rr -a r, �.; 3 I �CHARGE�'_r Q MERCHANDISE R TURNE4.r.„l,r, ?L v: ;.. as . . DESCRIPTION .PRICE AMOUNT DUANTITY : A rqa; Z G x t' ` T'i � to s Y Yt4t 1 i...t' t � t tt } t r a. 'ttS fAzG. '�+Se L LY:,,,, `{.q} ! tI SS� .F i p t - T� fir'f .a. ter r 1 4 }� . LJ ,lti t.474 1, J c i <., - t Y a r r :t._ t t t ifc. t r l e ,,.r .. .. B r a 'i',sr t ' ) s t i' 1 C x s x a .t 4 t o al ., t iIT S i�'. r`t:.` , 1 t '. � t ti.. 4 + r :'.� fr,x�...• A?i u xv'r' r S 7T: J t tl `` � ��t,ti �{ �� t t is t i,. �'Z i air`s t 5 v k f-t y )t .Yr ;x i 44- i i ,a.• .^ ':.t F rt5, .1 r TY it - rat t i' • 7S t ' t .tSffiS `u ',,4::e . 2 �i ftY' w,".ilf^ l . ,.tar t t r 4 ; f4 tk<sit r{y a s .t p'.i:7 t: i E::.adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE • °� FARM NO . JAY NO.ONE FA DATE E � , 413 6 el ,ORDER NO':,„, "x,,„.. 4" !+, f�s3� • NAME fY z, ! l �, rr r,, , 1 I� ' q .r'a" r R 'k � y 4 x + , � „ } . J 4 .„. ADDRSS ,, t § 4r,�„rY f , , ,, ,„ Z, y +t4 � sF1iz .„,!.,„,„,„.„,„:„.„,.„.,, `}r4 r ` � y ..,... ! . .... .. .:,. .., .. ...... .:,,,,,,:.,,,,.:„.:,..,„..,L.:. SOLD BY ,, 4 CASH 0 O O D 0 PAID OUT y ;1 . , a .,,,,„ {r ,...: �I s ` ,,h Q C 4ARGE_ ❑MERCNA RISE RETURNED' ,;� ,^ '� p a DESCRIPTION . . ;PRICE . -AMOUNT QUANTITY; .. � <= ~ W r } S. r1R J j4 .i 4 1 ..Y ✓' \VV1 ` r s i S '. 2 7 ik , s r .f t , 4 s } L , 4 tt h 4". .✓ S y s !'. �.. :A P r r 44.; ,;a.•., » v y''j R. 'i-J 4.F'"r' > .A ,.r s f et - } s .A } 1 fya[rx /n� ; ',1 iX ritryu' r.n`•.} tI,.a tsya.4.!!' {)'s}: l.'z7'fi.V'..tt t*.. IYf S5, .. ar.adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE O FARM NO, JAY DONE T u 1�i 't / y r Z�r L n` -g iii4g7� trt r,'r, 413 !a b 6 ;;ORDER NAst i r�' '�t' -+ t a ,. t iv p NAME r r: 1 t c rr .. Cj 4;,r in.�d a . � '° � - •^, i xrr V of �, s�iq ' � �+�Jt .5.i �1 Orr :y •f 4 .LC �� i Yi•b. r.. Sa 7+ . fr•{irt . n [ ‘ e V. 1 v r. k r, Yet. •/�DDRES51c , 1 \r:_ 4s i1.,3 . r S ;n �:4-".t� .xi OD'BY s.'r .r ` 1::!,__.:6Agi-fi":..';'6',:..fr.:-.1 C O.D PAID OUT ' fi i � C r[ r� xrI , ~\t. . CIiARGE . MERHNDIE REURED� . ...,'t . kflUANTITY DESCRIPTION PRICE•. AMOUNT l' ( ,ts s rc.�t}r S f. .t F .Y 5 .Y t .f.Y 1. ^^""i.i y + 1. _ ,L Zd?f .T i V4'u�r _V r k s k r •`q� 6 hf•ti > Xt'Fc 4 -"3 s cs r.i t .. ;( \ it3 at t,,ra V' , y - � } i� r ( f -'t i t* : t r1 L.. A : ' s .,: �ss. ..cti ,1 s. ,j..i -\.Z...r�.k`"rS, y M. 4 , + . 4 2t 't : t r &4 4 ; 7 S 1 . t . 1 '' 1 4.4 4:.r, ,t:. �Y S ) tf rf 'c F 1l Yr .St j�~.f:. ...f✓} F 2,r4Y 44'k.4' . 41 7(�!3 ',:: l 1: 1 w ti L <z x c Y i. Y r. ,O t e, r...,.\ Jy y�,t ..ti\t i 1,t\1,. �, .?.,. r.r .1. r \: :i: �i.. " adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE No . JAY NOONE FARM DATE � z rf t i + 413 2228286 .ORDe No;-§$t ,Q ,: ,. H . w`. t 13�,kn34j+ ih; - .,,.is `'] q�',Y`+g'� .. � .. NAME / �3 ript rw r t 1 f ) : t Y3 f 1 ! 1 1 S i\ Vh APT C''6ri ! t ADDRESS' t 1 ; rAa ` } K" 3 ", s.sv 1r•it LOLDBY CAH ` ❑C OD ' Q PAID OUT Yr; A�Fti,r t i it t lY s `` s,?, 0 CHARGE [ ❑MERCHANbISE RETURNED ".�s°ij+ ^ QUANTITY` • DESCRIPTION . r " PRICE% AMOUNT • r t , Y• 7 t co t P i .il L e v 7�S S.i,�. :'.....i.lj.:',—....:;::_s.1::::,::•, is t.. ` 4 ` L 5.vt• l a tT 'v t ! vN1 b ! Y A > 4 .Y 4t r 4y r' a 3 _ f r.., a '�rtilt a?f f^ 1 k i 5i i ,,.,.}5+t< n '.i ] !(+f`- "" C'. + t �:'1 i +- ] y r '` r. r ti 4i:,* S 'fT''. 6 t .,cla ] :� rc ! tt .1, c. , !, t:�.! �. 4 ] l., c .; f ]' a.;adorns NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE • No. JAY ii0ONE FARM 4:,.,i,,,,,,,,,,,,,,i1,,,,,,.,,,,,,:,,,,,,,,,;,;„...,,,,,,...,„.1,,t.,,,,,(?,:k.,4it,,,,,,iii.,:z,i,,,,,,, 413 2228286 ,...,,,,,-;:y..i.1,,,.;54..c.,,,!i,.:, „.,;,.:;,:7,,,,y,.4,,,,..-41..,„,,,,w4::4_46?..,•..,-,.7,, ::1,.w.1/41,A ...,,.,...,,=..,,,-...;:.. '. .:,.,,-.:,,,.,,,,,,,,..:,,„:,.,,:....,;,.,.:.=,::,i „:.,.....,:.,...... ,::-:...;,.._...;;,..-,.,•.:,,'„,',.,,,,.:.:,..,:,-,it;.:-.•-:,;,•,i,s,:.:'•,...,:7.;,-4:?...'.''::;:..,....*:: :..;i:a4i,, ,4,, .„ ,,:,:::,., ,,,.,,... ..,,,...:..-;,,,;.'..;c:i.,...!;,.. ',.,,:, ,,,:', ,,;,.•.,:.,? .:.;,. .:'''',,,.:...-:, .:.}.:....'•;...,i'..t1',. .... .:-,• :: 5Y:?,.!..,5'.,:- .; ,,t.;.:.,:'...,,,',..i.);:... . ;IT..:';':.::zif':.:WEget...!;v:AC.k4;:i7, -.3'. ..:1-'-'4'';::::'''''l.j.).??'..''''.g',''..;f6'. -';':i''':-.:1:',;;(g ::,',':-:',.,4•:;.1 .:,i1.,?:,..f.________•.(5,:::::',...: , g?.,:••;"f:,:::,1:1'.,,,-;.;!,34:.:..4.,.;;:tv,i-.-,:,,..,,,:.e.,,,p,-,..,,,,. .,.:,k.g.!...gkt::::?f!;',..-;44.i'A,'..*.4, •...ADDRESS., ....:.-1. .;'I.,...-+.4...:4-;-,'.7,-,g:,..::,..:.01,.....:.i:':'.4 ..:Z..;*.i::.'SA::?-;,'"--•44.-.:..'.':.:Y,,1, 72:-,;:::,..,k;'. ..i. g.,,YLt.,Z.sr.--..,141'.::^ 6,,'.i;,,.',;,),t:i..:f*,0:.;-,,s, A , ..".,'..,, .P.:,.''.':.:3i':4=1:CHARGE;.,'.:-,'.1..E3.1.,:lERCHANbIse.,REruRNov.-•-•;'kl,",..'s.',',ARit--,--,';'N,'-','...-:,''':`,',Y,:',1 ..7.1:itiAtolvt;::Y,-...7‘..:::::.::::-.-:..,-:..,:-..-,..,;::-.,:.::5:oEscRoN. .,:-,:,-,..,:,..., ,.•-...::::-,:',...:.,,,,:.'. . . , • . . , . . . . . . •... .. . . . . . . • 'H. .' :e) ' . M .:....,..:4,..,..::-.,Y.A.,:.;..:. ;.7;Zt'4;,;,, ,,,: :".,',:-.-:' .,7!..,;.i..:...'i,..,A-,:,:;,;.:-.;';:•.1•,,,,,',,„!•;:-.,..';-Z:..,.••.':•,, ::;,";,:,1.1...,;.,,::,...,;:.::.!,i,t,,:,:.;.,,, ,V;,,,:f.,:.".:, f.... .::4',.,7.L,:',,t, .,:;t:, ,,,5....'.:;:s1.'::::. .-eCi.:%-,-,A . ''' :',.:-:.-::,:':-7'..:':..;•i':'..f,.'f'.1:'...::\';-:.tZi...:',. .::.;.,.;.": 7(...';':.:.:;:.:-....:,,':::.:"•.',:'E'r';1(.:::-.,.:''.. .:::'.1.. : :....:;-...! .'.':;.;%:.':f:.!'.:; -.1,.'. ,:.':.:' ,''.;j: ::;.!..i...:','E.4';',.:;';'.':,;,.!•.':. .1'. .;',-.',%;!':f,' '1 ':',.....','.,'.':., ..,:-..'n', .'..1‘:.•...::.:i7.;:.::-..';il'::;',.i.:!',.•,;.',:.-,:,.',...,..r.:':-.:::....'::-:..''',.':',,',:--,:'...:;;:.,:i.':.'' ''':'.....--...f;E.:V,',:r•-••• •••••;;:::',.:,ji-i;i'.--.'"f•irt''. . ..,',1 ,.•:',',,,f1...4-,1 :::',:-.-,1!...:1-....„....;,::.. ....1.:,...:,:.:',';',:'.•:...:1:;..,‘.Ef:',..::: ::.:...,;:::.'. ..::1:-.."::::', . ::::;,g',;::::..:.:;.:.,:::',. .:.....,:',....-:.,:t'''. .:71::::::.'''.......:.;',:.'7';'''Y'!';:d.Y.: .-.."!;. :7•;;'..f:::4',:r.;':::'':'''''] !.:Zl'i:'.4!-, '..'''....','::7?-...'''''':::: ::•!';:.•-•!,.'.'.-:A•i,'•''.44::.':1:-:",•*";'.'.'... .':;:"..f.;:' ,....'j'..:.•.'„,!,. .',',!::.',....':1,'''...''..::''.;',.,;',.: ;.L'.:,':•!'s ..'i,':•.....':.'.",:i'-::',;,. ;-).,..cY.....;::,.:'ire,':.',,;:irl:•;rf•!k*.j,:-'-'::::?,'.`.'4 '.: f'.7,...,,,,••','•••.....,•,•."'!:,: :;c.:;,!7,•:••••,4i:',,, ...:,-,:•:•,..,:::',...'....,:••::.•:::;:::;.....'. ....1'•,•:,-.,-,:'•-,..:;."::•••`•:::,:,!:.•:,.....•;!:,,.,',',',.', .',:‘,i.i'...,,:,-::.!,3.: .:','..!:.:,•-,..;••.:.;.;::....-t.:••=. ..P.,... .-•!.;.:,?:t::,.. ,.•••i ..:,'1::.':-.,'•;.[:,.;,",:;.•••-,'''...••':•:;;'•":,,,:',C;;:,,:.--:','I:•'-'..!.....'....',:'.77:7:''''',,...: ',':',`.":::,,....":',77''"...'•!.. •••••,r•"' '••,"fi•t-71'''i"; !•*<:,‘•', ,..7:*‘. i-t.'4.4,•::'••;/:,..‘;',.'t,Y:, 4..';'•,. .i,--';','..1., h--Q ;..::.'•:..::::.:f:......*.':' '.'...,,..:::;•':.!:;•!::.;-.:;:•:-..v::....':'.':::iY:::.;:?:‘]:".:-..': :::::: ;::.:,, i,'.. 7::•'...':;,.:'•'/;inss'r,: ::: :.';•c.::.;*•:......''.::":.:::::;V :',:.•'....7. e?!!:,,,!".;:ki...,=,.!•:°::',F0, ,i. . . . . . , . _.• . . • ..• , .. . i,.,.!:.,...‘.„'.-.,,,-.1,..,•I ', .:T:,..,'...... ..::,.::;::-.:•g/,:'•:-.1•.'i; ',.''',...i:r7.• ;,•.:4-:',`:-':1'.'-'.':''f-.7..... ic-,.::..:;', .',.',.-::7.-.',.-,E;:.---:,F;;', .:1::;,:'.:i!,:N.11.;-•',..':;4 -;11:::1.1.:,1i. :',.-::-'...''' '.:..:1';::::,::;::::'i••••;.:1'A,l'.7:sf•'?::;', '...!:.-;1,....;••••••••;•.,:.::••,..,•!..,:".•.:„1.*::,-...',.:Z ;'.:,..',....::.!-..,;:::.:.y,,.•.:-. ...!...:"..:. :.... .,.••:.:.i;li.. .;:...:::::,•: -...;:i::;,i,T,. .'..•,.,'7.,.:`;••••'•::.,:.:::.'7.,...'...•:•••....::;3.•:.':::,i':..,=•';..'...,!:':z.;?..,.:::;:. ::'..,-..--..'..,:1'...:::.2.... .:. '‘)..:..5'-:i'!..K :'•i,i:i:•:,'..:'••'-'-:'..',,T.v,'-f:'.• . • : , • •• • - . •:.•••••-• ........ .".•- • .,.---• --- •-.. ''..'',.‘:.•:.'....I'l4:-,;:.•••:.•:::.:':;.::',:itf.-;•'...•;:.,:.-ii•. '-'7'..•:...;,....',.',...:•'.•;',',..''..;:.;•:'Y".,:,•:•':•••...,;:::::';','''''.'.•':.::', 1'.•':',.'...'',....1:, ,,:'...:''.•±,V.:,,,..?,...:i..•. .,7.:; .,:.',;:';',:;„:.:.,'-:-..V';',::;;,,, ,i,.,':::„'1...,....*•-;;.;,' ''.:f:.;;•,:',.::.. '-,',]•,if.,•'.....,..4.....,•,...i.•:;,:,-•'-::.?•';..,,,.Y.-....;'.:;,;..,;t., .;:••:• •••'.'.., ,, .•..,....•..;••;i :-.,...,,..."•.;.',.'...•,-..,:•;:::: .,...f.•?',1...7-. ''.>.•.::',.:.'. .,•'2'.,..',-, ...::1; 46'..,:•?.i...7,:;;.:Y:„I':;:.,, , ; ..';:".;''';';'''''..::',.: •'.. ..: Y;i:•:'.'A:'1•4:::t1'..'1:•.: :: ::•'''•',':'; '1...1:''';':::-!:..:::.:i'''i'V::-•;;.!: ' ' ' . .' s,': .i..'"i'',V!.''g.''4?'1:-‘,...?4<';'-'':"'..:Y.'10' . :`:1'..:::-:,:',...::.1 •17;...f....i..:::.:•:1.; .';'•-•‘.-!....C.:i.,:.;1•'!:•:::::-•.'•:;:'''[.:?.*: ::3:::::',.:',!,:'..:,..1';'.'...1..". -'.:‘;....,','',....7';.'; ',e.,...:f.,q.:`:!.‘,:•...f.:,f1,...,:-Y.:::72'..1.1.!1:,'..7.,‘,.:7:.:.......4 .--',.i''ti; '....:,i;'4'cf.?!.;%,V,!..V1';',7;-:i-r.i?;::',': •,:..•'''.;.''..`,.`,.".•2.•:.•(.;,!,:., '::',...., n,';,,,,..,.,•, ..,:',„...,,'" •,:,;••,;:,:,..,.',.;."•2,.,i'.•.."..7,..,.i.. :.7,...;...4:,s; .-,,,......;,::•i'S;: , ;,:•;:.,,••?:':,',4".Y;..?:...••••,,,...;f:•,,,l'f.:. i ,;,',„:,.;•:,5;•'....,..',7.1•.,1,:.i,W,.':'41..., . .... .-,..,•. -. .••••.....,..t•.... .,„ ••.... • ,.. ..,•..",,•-. •,•. . .,..,..•,.... •••, .... .......,.., ,...,.. ..,...... ......,..:., ,. . . , . ..',..!?.1;--4.,:',',i•;;.,. .,...::i•''.:,'' ,i;.. .. . .i:2,...':,':.;:,::-;:',;ii,i' !:: :)....,,;!: :;..'.:.. .:.,.. ii ', 1‘, .',. .:,;!..,'S..1.4i5.':: ..'"L'g,,•?::.'7!', :=.1::•:,:i'.' ...,%:',Zt.',:": :i.:?.. .:;,- ,Z •• ! ';.;''..'::.'.*.. 'ii;' .el:''.i:';'•i;*,;i;'.,i'i.q4'; . ..: . 4'. - arit'Warns NC2501 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE n , � No . JAY NONE FARM DAT 2 r rt s>t a f 1 }}t( '..,"t t : ,. .,,41,- `'r x{?;t°'c,t?x '}',ttt' T 1 222 tl ki.:r tK :,.. ,.Y+u1'',4 t:}"'‘ ri y} 4 ,:q,,.h°a aC ORDER NOfnp4*'i y?10,04 14.. ''Kiaf X C !'t L` ♦1 S. 0..�„1C. t NIta+4.,I tat. 1 NAME ..'; z. . ' t�, e � �, , ' � ,,.;i xi ;� 7`y i t.~S�+'sy r�� �r�t a t r t L.. S � x ; .,ti ♦fa r!e� Nt�S �}'r'i f,h. � C f t 0 tit.+� �',} ADDRESS1 ty f,�,,i t o- t r F, t c, r ret r°11 t&,i ; ti Y{- a a n J fit F t G t; SOLD BY ,, CASH ❑C 0 D to ]PAID OUT `f 7 '1-T t ' i?4'' ', 4„h. r ' DCHARGEQMERCHANDISERETURNED �ix ' � `4i . , _ ; ' , ;..'s: , ,a; . t_ QUANTITY- • DESCRIPTION .. PRICE AMOUNT. • t i t ± 4 1. :c . } 53T � t ,� tTL 1r -:.i kt 3' i,i,t' ) ' t t 5 '* t`tC t .11+y P% '1 :, I { t r tS f f 3� �ta a. P 1(`t i x k tt Iy !' ? t . t L, ;3r 1 s. 1. .,Sk ) t S t s <- F r r 1 f a t Z *T r 4 t 3 b .._ye r. )i -�iid �alF',n 1w v lt, 1..I d » xv s R -yt ,r. a> �s i rti z n :. tt/tt; }e r.Y Fn?tdo t• zr 7.x .,i< ,. .' V t ..:tih t xt t t 3 2 < f s t F t t-' f t*t f 1 �:Q.r t' ..i r aitk ` l y fi t�: '. r .r t t t, .IS 4C '\. f `' fdcs4:;', r`. .P1:5; , t! }r '...r 1 F r', t :s t ter. ,:i ,adams NC2581 SIGNATURE • ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL. GENERAL PURPOSE JAY NOONE FARM No. .::.P,1,T .<.,i,:4-..C:-..0•,;::::-4 i,;::::,:...A:,'.-Ar'';'•;,,,;;f4,,'To•.',.!-,.1.:i-'A',754'!:. 413 222 g 226 .„;0Flogr3N9.6gtoptroka*,v:vot.;'Sviklyill 7,•. '.::...,•,y.:'.,-.,..-7.....:".?:,::,,,.,,..",:..,!';‘,7`..;•,';',!;,, ,,,,;',..:,;:.,......,,-.,: ,,A," '..'.:' ' ''':.,,.;''.'.;,•••;.''',,',,?..;''';;,:"...;',!,,,: ',''., ;:':::..:,.1--!..,.,k4'%,'1.7.,i'iL4..,,,..4.. '''''''''.;:;.:Iti... .)5:. ...i..,. . .i.11 ::..:.•":;;;;40i,Tiligih.::?.:..;.....;.:i...:,:i:i;.;....?''.1-'''..:, ''.:;'.. I'.1:-U..;7,:''i‘Ca.;*1.',71;i;4'...;.:§"ittliitili4.:14.',-;:iik, tk)(511ESS ,1 . Y,./.4,..'.fi,ti.;;.4iSk..f.,,..:...,,XCi.,;,..,,,, , ,;,%...,114. . ..,0:.,;,,,a,',..:-:,..t. zrybk;f4id,...,,,;12,i4.5:.+.,,,,,;.,,,;,„,.'6, .... -.. •,.,.:::...e.?..i „...4.,.:,....,..,, ,,' ; i.11.,ti;,:,,:4•-.;"...::::,?,,..;:k.,"....t,,..ei.,,,...,:.;,,,I;,•:?..1'f.:,:V:1;'.,,f,•::,:.:,;:';:-:&••;•,,-,7••C- ,..„.„,nr,,Oil',t',12,V, .. •••••••'..,,..,,,, ,'-:,-,-.,:',,,,,:,,•.,;:,,,,.;?..,:-..,...", -,:' ,v.,.'.,-.....,',,...... ....,,..".'.,:t.',,,.7-.:',.•:,,',,,.:(..,".4,,,f.,%,...P..T.,..,;:').;‘.,.:!`.Y.,:.',,,,(,.tgir,1,,:.?,;.1.V"?...lit.. ,.•.,,,..-.'.';;.4.?.!•-•,'.?..•.,...-.1, ......;.;1:`,`...Y.":.(i.)'4‘..1::!•;1';',?;•.'.i.,. ...;.',;,,..:N:V.fq7.:.6*, :iI',.;i.. 91. .17!!..'.,W..,; 9:•4:)iP.'!.. .=.'s.‹....'; IF.!,..9.:;9Y.T:';' ,i,::::..t.,:r;;V:fe'll!.:7if:i:',.;',0,',:';iTg?. ?.r....,54..,j..".4.. ;;?-...!,,,.,:,/,`. .'",,,v,',..!;t:I.,5 ,..,,,..1:: ,..::::iy.71-;:'.!•:::,,....;.,.,'.;4,:-.v.:,......,..s', ' . ....,•.,f.,r..e..,,-,,,..,-...',,,,'....,1.,! ....,:i..,...',,,...,4,,,,.?...!4,!..4.4.'4...1e.„.',•!Zir;74)..;,:t,,,4' QUANTITY< ,..- ' : , ' DESCRIPTION- - . - • -"- ,PRICE' " AMOUNT • ! . . U • ,, . . . . . . " , • ., • Er.." I • , . . :;,',.. , :::. , :.',",..„.:,;-',,,;:,,,,,1,.... ..1 l,..:,..:...,.. .....:,', '..•:;;:.i....;::':..:',..•.':..,::;..":'!.:;:',,.-:,.',7.''.::'; '..':::'..Y,'..!'''....,ii::'...''.:':/,';'4:'‘.Z.........;';.-yiL:°;' ! X ''...,,-.,'...:,':,,:',,:0.-',.';';:..-?,..‘.',`.;*.;•':.;..J';'. .:'.Y:';,?,,,i-.,.'1,;.V,...?....':.;',::g,..". .:;t: :•,-,':'i'::::4i:%‘j,...;,',..':-,4...,'.-.... : PN....,:.,'...-Z:.'.,."-....--:,:..,..:.,,,,,,..f.,, ,.,,- 71,,,,%*';,,.:,(,y.,-,,,!,,i"?...-,•:7.;..,‘.:,,:;:., CO ....:,::„.,,,,‘,,-.:.. ,;;;;.:, ';.,-.j:: ',.;.; ...,,•;.:••:-,.. ,V.;::::... .':::•.':::; ;; : .::;:-'1'.'5, .. .'...';'.;:i... ?".-:;':..C..f.'. .:;:".1.'/'..;'-'.': 's.;Ckze,'!N4k;71,ii..'.1',4.'S.?':..'...171I-:': 1:i'l.P.;7:c.;':4C5' '. ". ::.„:.;i:;',::: ::::',:.;..''::: ::,.:::;$is,:...:::.;1j,;;;;;;:;,:'.:.•e3.44.7.',:P..:Z.':::.:','''.:'i.:'.'. ..f:,.1;...:11::!.', 2".;:: ;..!;.f!...:."%'...'-!;:.:i:,.:'':: :;,::.*:4:1:::;1',.4,4 ::,',..=!.P.',.PItt.;..4.il. Mii',7%.i,.-':::,'!:: :',',,; ;:5 1 ,.. ,,..„./.....-„,,::?;,:%y,....:,..,,,-:!..7.::::•,•,'„,:::-;,..h... •',,,,.•;-,.,K!'...f',-.;,-,..','.:,',?.;if.?,":;,f..v:i.,,,',€,';'•:•;;;, i7.,:%.•..',..','; ',',.;,...i,,,Y.,'e ,:i.k•::,4....-.qi''.:: ".',.A: . '..•;''''':''''''''''''.'''''''': '''',,''''..i•X!.',--..7 :,.... ...:';'?:*:.,:."..'.;.: ,,,,;;;;,',..•,'.. .•.1'..A'..'.;,7.,....:.. . ,•.:;',;.:',-:i.,..."....:.:.:4‘-;:i ::',.:V41,4f.,-:••.,e.:!'i....',..4.,.,;ii,....:',f200.,t,k4.,,'i.,,,v.tk,,,I,,,,,,y-.:,..,4....;,, .,::::-.,../:: :..::,i,.;,'......,-fi?'::::::f,.,/:,...!...!: :.:i-1-..•:,j,::,;:,2 .'"!2:::::5:::.;:,:. '.'4,;.•?.,.....;;;.'-... .,.......::,.:,:i.,,'..,;..,....:,. ..,.i.'.;:.:.•k.ip.:,..::.,..,::;;;,;::'.!.r., :•.;,]::.,';,:--:;:.:.:.:',......f .•.:(,,. .?,...7:1:;;6•7.; :;;,:-.._.T.,,-..'....-.,•:::::11i,i.,-..,•..-.. .i•-:;;:,,,,,,,c4,iii•Far... .7:.,.. ,,s4.,.4.,,,q-?.,:-,,,-,j....,..,;:,... 1,.. . -1''''.0'.:.-S:!;:1:':44.:;.;:','.'';;.•':;..;:'.: .:',.‘:.;;; .'.. 2:'•:i.:*'..',.,i flf.,',.i.':';'-.1i:i.;.;,:•':;" ...i.,!'0'.'.;:::i.•%!:'...>,(.,.:',N'e;,' 'z%-:.:':-1.;:,;?,.,';;:,,,-,,P,,,r,::y:4•1` .4. ',-- ,,k-,.:*:-::; :,:o.,;•!.;,',.:..54.;,...;::..t.i4.,t. .-i6i.',.'•19:7• -.21 ,'. i,::::;..:...,..,:.::,... ..•.; ,.i.c..4. ;. .. .:,:•:. ',....:',,g.Y,..;.*:!:-,..'..,';.,s.:..i',4;°1;:e.."..S-,-;.72::21..ii",..?,".?:,X;:., . . , . . .. - . ... .. , . . :,...:!:::.:'::'''.:.;:. :,;:.;:•.--;:-. :'.:..... .;.1.;.•..:'"'";.:-.!:.:.:'' ...".. 1'.;*:':-:;I :.'.''. ),'. ',..L'.,i'.:',",:'Y',"-e.k.1,t,g,.;':;;;;...::4:!,': ,:::, :r.,..:.......-.7..,.:...,:.;..;,,,,,i;....T.,:,....;.:4:;„:.;-,1r.i.„‘„, -,;.:*•;:.if,'...,-,.i'..f..:.. ..*:•;?,.. ...".....;A:,,...i.:•.A. ..:-;;...'i;,..;.:'i.: ".....4a;'.A.!,S:,..i.'''''-fi''.i.'.. •;'-'i:i;:.;..f'::':ifi:;!.(:.'.:::-'. ..4.:-''''' ':•‘`::';'' '':‘.,,•".::..',.:.-:-...r.':",:•:;;.'..:-;,.i'..'..:','A..,i'..i-:',;',4,1.4::-.....7,2.!:,:.,..,i,..7.;,,,;....;',.......:4..!:,,i,..;;;,..:,.,.k........ ;,=;.....!,..,N.,..'.',..5. ''''.:4. 2:.-...',..:-.-;•.'... .,.•.,...,Ni:,....'i x,,::;',.••••:,...,,,....,,...,..,!..n:...,./.7..,,' .'!.:',.!;.:..;:'.:-Z...',..,,Z;f..:'..4,;?4:..W.,-.'1:;.i.tti::1;',i.;;:•.SY":,:i:;. :,!'-.\-,..:'.'..'P-A,,-.;,,..'•••::.:;',P;;.‘,r.:fti•-:....'4.-.:,,,,,.....,h,....,,-..•ci.:.:,!;:7,-,,,...,.....,..?.::...: 4.,.;.,:,.r.:,..!-AIT;;-;o,!:(.....;.:!.....-:•:,..,:.:,.:...,,,,:-....,.v.. ot*f.ii..,N;,.t.. ,...,..v,,T..;,;,,,,.:„,,,,,;.,.7,4,,5:.,1-,.;„:, "..:,14:..i.::.;-;;: :;i:'::J'.:.:..'1,-1.`,.'.'..it....;'.i..0"-,z,.:,k.-.'-'..t.iF!''':..7.11*:.0'.-:":;ii',i,li,.i7. .i,:?‘",ze'•i•,::..,:2?.1i•;',:..'.'.4';'/:..'7,*-:•:i....lisf .71P..,..4',',:'ii?,''S:1.:4?,:51„:4;,-;..:A:;,-4,1,.',1...!.,.7;f,'.-4,,s(?:::-44,34,0: .;,. ;:g:',....:,11=5-:::.•,:-..,44.,:it.-.3.:4',',-;:?.-Ki.14 ,4i:...k. ,..-.•:...;:.:;;,,, 15.I.z,,.a:::..;;;;,:,..,•,.,.-%.,1 r:p::;r.t.,,,,,-.4.ie4z.,4.f.1c1....i,.-1; C.',%.!1,iN.Y...,..,::,": .,...,f4,c,':,t):".,,k'..'f,:4!"4?ig0,4',4.1.sf:.;i:YA.',...?l, Te :Vra-X7';', ;;.'it A':::11-....?k6,,t,1::1,--iiy,g.f.;,$;,..q::::i;.ift,..,:i: at,adams • NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL.CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE No . JAY NOONE FARM DATE ; z i,� ; 413 2228286 fiY,�f i w 1 *rfi, E tii .. yil1r?, OFIDER NO i., _ a, Yap 3i„sgv,. r - re it���� � NAME fi . :1:i 7 " foi 0. d 11 r ! y x b _ ""�! t.i t �♦ShT Yktt�t l "itr�f x r.� r J t a < r,€ • ip t•i s,'. t p i Sir t- ,:. :4 'si 1 Y,7„.4 ADDRESS t �. � e ,4s,t ,�t I }t � 3 v rF,A ,ts. `' � � d ' SOLD BY F 1 :' ' r AE .,- ❑ N :iki rt ' , r CSH QC OD PAD OUT i l $ ' ,, \#{ r4 ..k ac i CHAR( t 10AE rr 4r; t , MERCHNDIS +RETURNDi � ; , trZ.4.:. r n„ II DESCRIPTION PRICE AMOUNT QUANTITY ,,FR ...,_. , . ,. . f . ft.- . , {� - .. a f_ . d ti i t s .a, F ..'' k 'x.?'.. i t J, +• + v3$ i 4 itk ari Y ^:1 11 �� r!n 1�+. • .. $ .1 i'I ' i ! v Y s �, �} t 1 { .fi I J � t t 1 ..•a t r f v r t.+A . °ys' :�f° '� '4 b p • r r 1,t.. av ; r, + :sn T '^,dr tt 5 iY tr tk !- ri:: Yk S w{it ,-. �.4 i 71 i. { \ \ "t r ci - t 1 e { rj tl 'X ♦ itr ., tf a .)_ {a S4t. aa H xr rf is ts. i 3+ f 1 x •. 1Y.• •i ,' y,4fh , i t "5 rS. + i �faf 2 1 . �ky*t t y •:• ' "r 4t 4 ;4 � - 4 F nf -ti.) C+ izrisa 5 " i ' y ,N- ,A. r t7P i 4?Z tyrrv.K 4 i T . a 1 ;%3 aY c., t r ,i:�. - :,rz _} .:4'tx ;.'k�.,1.., te.4. . t .a1 . f .n' yewa 't adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE JAY NOONE FARM No. DAT sJo, y 41 Z22QZ8f �I; �;t414 aa► ,p`3.�Yy., r";° .2. 4s7g.'F.YyFr 4 �+s" lTr NAME S x"•" ..s 3 a i t. A$ ,s} i i'r i t fl ... 1. a � C..Ott r,'{ �n a"h. '�syxt- ADDRESSL h �! x 1 6 :a t a a<r v rly tt x itt�<3c�x {r } Z kW ! �, [.., 1 r .St, f ..tit l) :.t�:�� �q t,.avk ` ��:• 2 . SOLD BY rg xt L r s it•i CASH {{ C O t ! 0 PAIDOUlra t 3� ruk ri O CHARGE F j MERCHANDISE RETURNED- QUANTITY; DESCRIPTION PRICE AMOUNT i = 11 b<•e, r .r4. j5 sr. a r A a r _r Ir r • >.i ,: ...;.. tt u: y i. e 4 ... 5 '.. .1 r ti •} a „ ,} i:"#r!°T� ut 4 �I l.} tt ;', + e ?: .-. 'r'S ,t., tt•', c", _ y t 7 • iw 'r .f i -.Y•' tr t.: .. eAIj .�, r'.1 1 5:...;.� /�t.x� .'�E.,..�:.5.. ▪ I F�,j.rl r 7.e.�at �.?+.•:.w�< tp +. t c ' �' rr T�2l�C .}Eti{r .x a`.z ,r:.... 's '�.. .;�" ,! .<:<.`.r i;. .�3:,cat;t+' _.a"t er4a X�•rn ti4+. r tl "r .. �i 1��j.�{taf�T rr y .lr ri �Y � •�''- y Z; i�t ••-1' w �y{ > f Prta;irl. �,`.5.. ' rs1 -• �.1`: '< .t "-<.Ta°. r�.;..r,._ � ,}'?y'.rE nst4".; r a YJk r ~ r v,>;x•l f+ P.:}r 1 .7r.yi r r -.S!t.,4s r5'�r.�,�k i" t+�i�r•."`S ar 3 L�s��•+,.c-1 3-r+7 ' 141',°+^'?,��J7".�'raE.K..: � ..�f�tY.t 4i.;i.,�''.�i:e,r C �"a�e i�t"i�� ,�` it'd`.�f.ict'➢��.f#."�":Z"�r ra�.!r rYJ��'�i�tv.l��'c"•tiy(i°d$s;. �. adams NC2581 SIGNATURE ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE • .. • .. . JAY NOONE FARM No. . • :.,,,,,,,,,af.:,,Z,.,4:i3......,,Z;,,,y____,,Q,,,i44.-il,/,!;,, il,'' .,,,,;•,,,:.:5, ''°°g?5it141RARiViAlgOPhlk•'1A1 z • 413 2218286 ‘,..4,1,,,,:•:„„ ,„, „-. m, .,,:,,. ...t...,y....-....-.,. ::;:pRoRt3iNolt,vw...e.;:loi• akiaykAts .,14Eit4 :1 ,..e.„,,,,,,,q,,,,t,,,,,,,,,„0.4,....„,,,,,,i.,,-0 44:11:-.if...,:Ni--.47: 7,1;•.,..t:-:.:M ,.4•..,4',1,44-;.1.,..4,...,1, ,..r.-:,....z),:,..1.:.00;1,-..;,--,,,,,,...,A:L'7.4.,:,k'.?,:f,.-lt .1:.:,...A.L.,,,,,I.p.,-4,,,,v.:,;,,,i,,b,4ci..,v,,,,,,....t...t,,,,,A4wit,6 . ...,,i.,„.,,,,,..,,,,„ ,:_,.1.,.. ...„...,....,.... ...,,,,:. :.,,....„„...::-.1,-: .,---et:;:,r;.,-...-.1‘,:' Q.f.s::sz.-...y:'..-41-44,,,11-4.4:i:1,;••147:lic.....11re?.,;-`4Illi 4.AVDRESSAf::141P*,15(t-li,';W:iiifil.:Z.ti,r,„:4:;atT,Cf*t.,: ;4Mrii:?;;;;,V.,: ;:l:ff°,:ii.:0iiipgeVire:;z:MAi....,:k;',,O'ktkiArii*V.,;.; ?.'4,'"'''.....,,,F,:":;:r.A!,,..V4,-7,•L,,R.,,,,,,,,,•,‘`. ,11,..7:w..:74,..s.-3-‘4.1.1.;:•:',i,,n{44,.:Vi,t?.:,...vij.,,,,,,v..e...,.1.....4U.I.,;0.,it,-,„tooa.,,;., t,A ‘;,9 .,...?„0 -,-;•,,,P.,,,4,..,!-,,,,,ft.ci,,'.:,,,,i,,,,,.:,,„i„Afpf.o?,• ,..;,.,0,0.,..4.,,,',.t..,x...,..,,,,,,,,-.4::,e.,,,,,i,.;w:),,diF,:.,:..;,,,•e.:,,,,h2.-- .-..,-.3.A.,/,A,,,r, , %-:,,-,,,,,,,,,,.Z,''),.0'1't,4,-,,,tt,...AV,,,,:,•;,..4,..,.44 ,...),S.„...--)*,:;:::',:2!v'...,•,.Q.,•',;v...,.$1.,,i,,,...,..,..,-,:,‘...i•.,,....1.,•Gt.,,,,,,,r...,,,r.:2..1.5,,,,,,,;:t...,,,,e,..k,;, -, ni n By„:.,.,..,,,i,..-:_i;;.,:,,.„,t.,:..L..,,..:,,,ex,.-.:.,,,,i•-:•r,_• ,::.:::;.,...<:.7-7.,..,,,,_--,-,—...,,..,..:.!,,,t-v-,.-,,,,,,,,,,,i, .,..,....,:.•,, ,,,,,s....';-1:,...,4,1efiez,4:,',,,,,,r;,,,. ,,,. '',',.:,,s.""fA.:,..•.;=...".',.'At:V' t'tlf,,,,q."tinkt, ',,b.L.J!•:.'C,kSi-1.';'i''''''''.LIC 0 1:11V4,;•,');:141 PAID-0l117.'42,'";.:','''';e4,*•%°;.:4-'?.;44'''.'-'•''''': V:i''.i'r:A;.;, ' .. ,; 2,,,;;Al:411: ftl'",'!'i'''!. ;1_1`''' ',.. *:,.;, •'..0i4:7 ..- ,'.:.iic...:./.:. ...*:.:::.>.1:1rAg.;,',51‘.1T.otcli,',q4)%%;.ji.T.: . 4'44dOkOkVii::170.11'A E=1.t.1-1ARCiE-1.iFfMPR*64ANIDISEFIEtORSEVN il' *V.11,7ta,!‘'$':K.,':Z..A'' ...."-i,A,"+"*:',..,,F:0,i. ,...'.. .:5.6•::•,,7:,..i::..*.;,. ..tw..,A.i.", OUANTITY.; , . . • ':DESCRIPTION - , . ••., '-PRICE, ..- --AMOUNT ., , . . , ..,,, .... .,. ..,...., ..., : ...: ...,:: :1'.4:', .:E•,':':1'.,:.' :„1"1,,,!,!..•,•;.',';';',.:','1',- .'";:. :7:,',4';',..>;:,,]., :.='•? :';:::,..,:,.....,.-:::,--:':•.':,.''.':,,'" :'.-':::'..i:'''..?,,4.1.J..,:'1,;:: ';;,f2,:%;:','„':'.,;;;*il:: .':','',i''' ''.:;:21','',,:,4,. .,..:,,L:•':,..::'' X ::: :::,:,:i',:..7 :?z`'K':'':',.,,.:',;::';';',.'"A'. ',',::•',',:','",,;',„:'if':';'i: i,l';';..:';;1,7:1.;,.2...i,-::::1,%.*::,,...;(1..'';'..':' ',...,:::',#;;.'1;!;1:.;',,'' '.,;!ii';',:,' r.;:,:i:::,1',, ,V 4 4`...7'4, f,5,'''1,.,:. i ...... '', '.4.' .•':','•;F'''...';'.%%':....;,;,.,.. r:...'''.;:1,!4.::.4!:. ;;;;...: ,.;,'0*.4.:EA,'!,', ,;',:.:7:, ,... ..7;:l'i-i:',T4Z3F4,1'..;•..!1' .14:4,i4.S.ki.PkMf4;&:ij'V,i';',:.'4:%.:!4'',:,.eqi:..-We'::tiAt'. 7:.`i,', ...!;i10..?d'.;`;441,R:::' :-.1';."5-*.iI.;',i3$...1;•!;51.4+,1,;:itlir. ,rn':, `' .1 Z11Aa's?..::.:;.,4i'Z'S,AF,6!;,4..i..::;:'- '‘'";;Z :7.1,?':'':',1% .'",';',4:g-4•V'i.k•L,Aiil.'ii,i',:e`.5%fii,:,.. ,4 .t.,....if-: ,i'''''.4..,'''''`.4,-,''''1'3'r',''`,''''r.",,,,T"''''-'-'•&••'•..,1•''r''',--,'S.--X.4, '4'6.'",",,i'N''..."-4,-*J''t d l',$)1',''-, ,..4.:11,ii,4,„5,,e,..,.%Vt i....Iv:*•,...a.,r: -•-•7-;,.4:';',:il''.1 '''.17:','4**,i,,I1C',....,;i4.•.44',,,:l.,;:;:,!''.'-%::','-;••4:V.:=4:-`;',:j:4 V,N:,'.:1-'.:',':,';;?.;',.: ,-0,1,it':',',,-X.;•';i:•!''.',-,4194-aP'.,,,.:'.4±.•-•,;,,'-',4,,4,•:-... z o:, -:•-' ',A.:,.'",'";-,,t--,4,,..?,-4,4,-,'-,...•.',"-V4,1i,,::N't.1,.Y:,;'.",.;`.i.,,,:i,.;31,,;,:t. ,,,,7‘*-34....,,,,t;'...,,,,;.,,e::e,..:...J.i.;5,,,,,,,,r..',.......,..,:y...S41,4-,•4-,,,,i,,t,....zk-;:,..:,,r,..A.,,,,,t.:,,,F..:..!:.,..:! k.,«M li, ..,,ii:111'.45i.g....; :.W1:.'61'W.,it.i;:lti.ii:t".:. .rliX4gIlik'AIO-i .11:All'i.V.'!'it',`IgAtlf,tfAlkifjef4,1:h L...... 4Vs;'::.?::;:.;::: ..:•^Y.!: ;;=4,11,1;:''V. .'%:::;%''. .!,:t0...;;O:',.:iiO.A:4,,R;Z;',...';:,: f$4,..; :ki ;#iik41.14::4":44.i:g.:ki0;t1c$,A21 . 1:'''5!.:'.'71:,..'''''''.:!''-7,%":1.'';'.:TeX7.....i•Cik':a.....;‘'S?P41Yi.;.t;.:Z.,:W:'1';''i%!,..!-.:'7.?Ali.'hi.:.•;,t,...',1.17.•',1,14,13:-.:;k :.:?i,;(;1.4:. .,1:::,;'.`,,,,i,W1:,,.;;;.;?•:.t3,:k44..,yi.ikIZI,"...2tev ••••,., ,':?,,,-;';;W:f.:'':':;;; ,::':, ..„..a,i...1‘4,.:4;t11.11C,".7;i.:::','&..?;a7C-'3,!..!.4'.,;t\SP.`:'-i;'.'iYil•!'ri.'%q•'4',71,..e.440..!..ar l'il:Vi4 i friA4V::!-.Z;q:V. 'h,70,<,',AAM1:3!,t;Fit',::',0%&,ni'!':‘ell.''.7,3l,t1";..`!;1'ri.,c74.. !;'•.?;t:/;:t'ktif•Lit,5',VP9'.,.;,,i,i,...t.'.*:•ki,* .;1*".:',':;1*Vi'3WA''''r::!: :4";%,•'S:,",.., isr. i.j,ilfit. .,'kt.".,;,:.‘"4 ,0:4,i'lj5.:ik.,4;.:iiy,,fii;:,tki..4.'kir.i.;;454;,6...,1.1a4-4,i.:,,,j,ki',.,,,, ,:•4,,,,,,,:. ..;..' :'''?".-,', ''itt.,'... :''i''' . " .'',',....•,:!...WAr.p,;,,1-....',5,,i,-e.I.M1P..-.!qk t::,..f',:6:;,i ''''.'..A.,,,,:,:y.41....";•i.. 'f.,,,,,i,,44.1; .,..,:'. .,:',. :.,.: ..V:''''''''':,.',%,"''''"i%::' .:4!'n.•;.....‘,4;4:.,,'3',,, ,:'';.'...C.:.'!:i,V`'.':".,!1'1,!:'..V:ti-:,5:.?'4".'t,::,,,,,,'34:."....`Ce,4`..r.V:1?..,!..f t*."..1"?...,....r...7.-0.A. '.'"?;,''..t .1.1'''VO.,.1,:tr,,;.1,••',.7.:., -.: ,, . ,.::''''i:.';'''.:'‘1"..,...'i'.','''',.. ...,'.',n"..,:',,,,.,;•i, ,..',,:,.:,(1..%,;'...\'''',::•..;•C...1;1,•'Z'''.'•''''''c''..',"-tIV,..',...".4`,,,......1,4‘...r.,:::,,•4-,,,:•,,'.i.,,,,ol'••;;;"!;,;:r..••V:‘hriV.;41....,,A,.•:,..:71 1 i':•.,-7:7-J, ,j,;••,:!,•,-i':•:--:.,,,,;:p4,;;:.,:z gi i'-',i0'•'-,i• i:,44'.; ;:'..V':•%ili,rt`i'd,'q,,';'.,'-'1'.:',1!..4.S ••'45,..4 w ikz,e'f.tii,';;i1,'.4,,,Wi.,,iiE,',:a'....i..4.!..y..:•+:'• ,-....47f'..e',Y,';'i- ,,.Vt.t..,-.:.;;.,;v;i.fit!a-,. .r.;.-<;: ..tl:. ,.,,T.; ,,.etkgtTzT,:.::y1,..x.[:,-A vit... ,-,a, ei,',...-4,:t,.,..•.41;...,,. ,,•5'..i'(,4)::i11,41:',.:$,'4'4.ii:wf-,-0.:,7,-,.....,4.4,,..,i,•.7ii.‘1,..'4:1 ;A:1,..:4••,y,i.1::;,-,!.;,,,..i.4-„1„;•:i.,,i;,,..i,. ;•,c;.::,4,:•,;A-i,..,;.,,,.....;,,,t,,:,,, .y",.,,,,,?..,.4:1:4,,,,,,....,,F: q.,=,;:i,,,-lif,,,,..1*.:;,•64,,-4/:;„i,,A,t,e,.;:i.t,:,: ,.--•,,,,:•-•:;.,z,1;p?,,,,:;;,..,,;,,,„..1,-,T,i.w.,,,,:,./.„:.,1,.t&r:iik-f,,....,-A,,te:mt-; .7*-1',A'•''!,:'‘ -k912:1-::%•14i1,1:1-1.'j%:41,41'-'',1'7444':-fe'•!,45.''.L,':iiv'1;-r:',Wf',.,:,'il:C.tAIAKVAtr.*•gs',H4:V14:1;'-';:,,A`;',.:1:%"'/:taPz'v.''''A..R..-...5.21.—tt...,:f Z7'1:-V'..-4.1•74.* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''' '''''',:"4;i24'11-ti-%1V:7'...,i4i1<.ipit:i ',::?:••.:',4.:.i.,?.&i,..,:4,::...,z...9.-qiiii•ti,4i,-iA'..4,.::...‘ ,',.',..)i:iV.c,iktirfiVi.t.iirAI;;;11:::,...i?i ,,,:-::9?.i.61.:•,:11;,;-.4,. .,..,' .,..-,'.,..-Y .:Aa.',.--:..5:::,1:1,-.:; ;;FL4-..,,e,v...1,-..,AN...i...iir.,..,,,ii....f.,„,:i,:g..,.:::,:s.i..,,,,kivatAthri.o,„,;7;i:,..,. ..t.?•;14...',4, .W;,4,,,,,v,';',014),i,!:4i'!,11 ;;?.44,i;:t>i'r:.'"0-1..^.::?,.,,e.,...!.-q.t'.".,,.f,.: '.1r,;;;:v...7;•:,,...54“;,t,',44:11;-1',..;41..12.1'.....,`,ie•t.i.:--;.:ci'i.......lei4,::e.,, v:•••,7,:,,,,4.44,1.10,-",,,,, P,' ift4.6:04404;,15CA:ir,v-2,e;,R+:4'.4.ig2,9;.',I,Y.J:IR)1ii.lk:,,,i' -tet7LAP2. lk,VirleNelf.;:ei°Iti..0,6•MPiN,'Vt7pi..i.iPpliS1-$1•Y<FanYWV:j•-yrjlie.0"i0,,,.1''ZIYVAt"?0,i10-1"114k.VVirtl't-44.hinttf - Ert adamg NC2581 SIGNATURE • , ' ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY THIS BILL GENERAL PURPOSE .., , F":•?.:. • ;:;.